Election of Vice-Chair for Council Year 2026-2027
Councillor Regisford proposed, and Councillor Thorniley seconded, the nomination of Councillor Fry as Vice-Chair. There were no further nominations.
Every time Oxford's minutes name Councillor Fry, as the council published it.
Councillor Regisford proposed, and Councillor Thorniley seconded, the nomination of Councillor Fry as Vice-Chair. There were no further nominations.
Councillor Fry was elected as Vice-Chair.
The Risk Management and Business Continuity Manager concluded by reminding the Committee that previous feedback from Councillor Fry had been considered, as detailed in appendix 5. The Chair invited questions from the Committee.
Councillor Fry thanked the Risk Management and Business Continuity Manager and queried whether a reference within the report to ‘failure to comply with governance requirements’ related to failures to comply with the constitution.
Councillor Fry also asked whether some of the service risks were generic and related to more than one service area. In response to the second question, the Risk Management and Business Continuity Manager recognised the presence of some specific service-wide pressures related to staffing and finance, however commented that these were also considered within the corporate risk register and the finance risk register.
The Risk Management and Business Continuity Manager reminded Councillor Fry that risk number 168 specifically focuses on the increase in the number of judicial reviews relating to planning and regulatory decisions.
Councillor Fry proposed, and Councillor Regisford seconded, the recommendation. The Audit and Governance Committee resolved to: Approve the updated Anti-Bribery, Fraud, and Corruption Policy, as attached at Appendix 1.
Councillor Fry praised the work of the Counter Fraud team and asked whether consistent achievement of targets could suggest that future aims should be more ambitious; a summary of targets and performance over recent years was requested.
Additionally, Councillor Fry requested an indication of the trading income from commercial activity, such as the annual conference, and queried why it would not be going ahead this year. The Counter Fraud Manager explained that targets are set to extend the delivery of the team, and these are evaluated annually to embrace new methods. In relation to trading income, the Committee heard that the team does provide external services on a commercial basis to around 35 organisations, mainly other local authorities and social housing providers, and this generates the team’s main income.
Councillor Fry, in relation to previously noted issues, asked whether the External Auditor felt that the Council could now satisfactorily act on the External Auditor’s recommendations and make the required changes. The External Auditor (AB) explained that meetings had been ongoing with relevant officers in relation to the valuation approach, and improvements have been considered and factored into the next audit. The Group Finance Director agreed and informed the Committee that the Council intends to complete a full asset valuation by this time next year.
Councillor Fry proposed, and Councillor Harley seconded, the first recommendation.
Councillor Fry requested some clarity on the status of audit areas listed in appendix 2 and asked for a view on how this Council compares to other local authorities. The Internal Auditor clarified that the workstreams in question are complete and that this would be noted in the next iteration of the report. In relation to comparison with other local authorities, the Committee was informed that this Council sits consistently in line with comparable examples in terms of outcomes produced; similar themes such as LGR are also being focused on widely.
Councillor Fry sought to clarify when the final report would be received, and in relation to client and commissioning, asked whether ODS relationships are being reviewed as part of the audit.
Councillor Fry moved, and Councillor Lancaster seconded, that Councillor Chewe Munkonge be elected Lord Mayor for the 2026/27 Council Year.
Councillor Fry left the meeting.
Councillor Fry presented the report. He thanked the officers and committee members for their work on the budget. He summarised the main recommendations from the Budget Review Group and noted those which were and were not accepted by Cabinet.
Councillor Jarvis also thanked Councillor Fry as the Chair of the budget review group, and the Group Finance Director. The Chair noted that the Committee’s earlier recommendation relating to noticeboards would be formally appended to this report.
Councillor Munkonge proposed, and Councillor Ottino seconded the nomination of Councillor Fry to be elected as Chair of the Committee for 2025/26. ? There were no further nominations.
The Audit and Governance Committee resolved that Councillor Fry be elected as the Chair for 2025/26.
Councillor Fry joined the meeting.
Councillor Qayyum proposed Councillor Fry; Councillor Jarvis seconded. No further nominations were received.
The Committee voted to appoint Councillor Fry as Chair. In regard ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Councillor Railton moved, and Councillor Fry seconded, that Councillor Louise Upton be elected Lord Mayor for the 2025/26 Council Year.
Councillor Fry, Chair of the Scrutiny Budget Review Group, advised that following detailed discussions at each of its meetings throughout January 2025, the Review Group made a total of 23 recommendations, of which 9 had been agreed fully, 7 had been partially agreed, and 7 had not been agreed. He thanked all the officers involved throughout the process, with particular thanks to Nigel Kennedy, Group Director Finance and to Celeste Reyeslao , as Scrutiny Officer in drafting this report.
Councillor James Fry, Chair of the Group, presented its report and summarised its twenty-three recommendations.
Councillor Fry highlighted the central points from the Budget Review Group report.
Councillor Fry noted that they had proposed setting aside an amount in the budget to prepare for the forthcoming reorganization of local government.
Councillor Fry said that The Group had also discussed optimism bias to some length as they reviewed the budget.
Separately, Councillor Fry stated that The Group had discussed the projection of rents from commercial properties. The Group suggested that they should allow for 20% optimism bias in their projections of these rents.
Councillor Fry presented The Group’s discussions and recommendations regarding uplifts in fees in the budget.
Councillor Fry stated that The Group would like to explore the scope of this possibility.
Councillor Fry stated that the Group asked the Council to work with other councils to lobby central government to adapt the housing benefits system to remove the anomaly whereby 800,000 pounds of additional housing costs arise where registered providers are not used. The Group also asked for a business case to be prepared for enhanced links with registered providers as an invest and save initiative.
Councillor Fry presented The Group’s concerns with HRA Housing, where the tenants are on social rents, and where the properties are being invested into to lower energy costs. The Group suggested that the Council should work with a company, or establish such a company, to finance investments into sustainable energy installations on these properties. This would make the financial case for improved energy savings in council housing.
In light of the legacy of Brexit, Councillor Fry noted that he was surprised at the lack of support for funding for twinning, which helps to demonstrate the links between Oxford and the EU.
Councillor Turner thanked Councillor Fry and the Budget Review Group for their work on this process.
Councillor Fry reminded Panel members the budget papers were published as part of a supplementary agenda for the meeting.
Councillor Fry asked about the overspends in terms of evaluation fees and bank charges. The Head of Financial Services noted the increase in electronic payments, further audits and an increase in moving software to the cloud, which has a higher implementation fee.
Councillor Fry than asked about car park charges, with the Head of Financial Services that further details would be reviewed closer to Cabinet and Council in February 2025.
Councillor Fry asked if there were any financial implications in contractors pulling out over the next 12 months. The Head of Financial Services that contracts were still going ahead but would have to be retendered if contractors pulled out, but budgets could be slipped.
Councillor Fry commented on the percentage of allocation within the report, and if there would be a change of policy. The Head of Financial Services responded that the figures are inflated each year based on the previous year’s figures.
Councillor Fry asked about the different housing providers. The Housing Strategy and Needs Manager responded that further conversations had taken place and further details would be shared with the panel in due course.
Councillor James Fry was invited by the Chair to attend for this item in his capacity as ward councillor and his longstanding involvement in eco-moorings initiatives.
Councillor Fry noted the origins of the project, highlighting its 12 year history, the existing temporary moorings, and current air quality levels at the site. He also referenced a similar scheme in Islington, which has demonstrated reduced air quality complaints due to the adoption of direct electricity. The Principal Air Quality Officer confirmed the parallels with the Islington scheme, including the use of temporary moorings, direct electricity, and the same contractor to manage the online payment platform.
Councillor Fry noted that once committee approved the statements of accounts, they can proceed with signing them off, ensuring compliance with the December deadline.
Councillor Fry inquired about the practical implications of the disclaimed opinions for OCC and ODS, specifically questioning any potential impact on credit or risk ratings and whether the disclaimers might collectively pose a disadvantage.
Councillor Fry inquired about the timetable on page 411, specifically regarding substantive testing and whether it would meet the deadline. The External Auditor confirmed that substantive testing is currently underway and that timelines are actively being managed.
When Councillor Fry asked if everything would be ready by the January meeting, the Revenues Service Delivery Manager confirmed that this was his goal.
Councillor Fry further inquired if he was confident about implementing these changes and asked if they would be in place by the new year. The Head of Financial Services acknowledged a slight delay but aimed ... view the full minutes text for item 18.
Councillor Fry asked the Revenue Service Delivery Manager for clarification on whether this would be fully operational by January. The Revenue Service Delivery Manager responded that he expects to be in a position to continue monthly reconciliations starting in January.
Cllr Fry (Chair), Cllr Jarvis, Cllr Smowton and Cllr Yeatman. The proposed scope was similar to that agreed in previous years; as were the dates and timeline proposed. A key change to note was the provisions for substitutes in exceptional circumstances, noting that Review Group Members should make every effort to attend meetings where possible.
Councillor Railton nominated Councillor Fry.
This was seconded and Councillor Fry was elected as chair in a unanimous vote
Councillor Fry requested further information regarding the two new red risks, regarding quality of data and data management systems.
Councillor Fry asked if the new system would move at least two of the risks examined in the report from red, to a less significant risk category. The Corporate Asset Lead responded that the new management system would move the two new red category risks out of that high risk level.
Councillor Fry asked if, in practice, the risk regarding proper procedural practice occurred very frequently. Bill Lewis responded that although that risk is always present, it is not a regular occurrence. However, with the new legislation that is coming in, this could become more frequent and they are working to prepare for this eventuality.
Councillor Fry raised the point that for the 21/22 and 22/23 years, an external audit had not been completed.
This was raised in the previous Audit and Governance Committee meeting and Councillor Fry asked about the assurances that could be provided by having an audit disclaimer.
Councillor Fry asked when the deadline for the 23/24 audit is and Preeti Malik, an External Auditor with Ernst & Young, stated that she is managing the 23/24 audit and that they are looking to commence fieldwork for this in August and will be working on this through January 2025. The External Auditor stated that although there have been delays, they have a positive view for the 23/24 audit and the audit workshop they had earlier in the year, which educated on quality of audits and timely delivery, and which was well received.
Cllr Munkonge proposed, seconded by Cllr Jarvis, that Cllr James Fry be appointed Sheriff to the start of the Annual Council meeting in May 2025.
Council resolved to elect Cllr James Fry as Sheriff of Oxford for the Council year 2024/25.
Councillor Fry was elected Chair for the Council year 2023-24.
Councillor Fry declared that he was a member of both Cyclox and the Oxford Preservation Trust. However, he had taken no part in any discussions by those organisations regarding the application and was approaching it with an open mind.
Cllr James Fry, Chair of the Finance and Performance Panel advised that the Panel had met on 26 March 2024 and considered the Integrated Performance Report Q3 2023/24. The Panel made two recommendations which would be submitted to the Cabinet meeting in April 2024.
The Chair, Cllr Fry left the meeting and did not return.
Cllr Fry, Chair of the Scrutiny Budget Review Group, advised that following detailed discussions at each of its meetings throughout January 2024, the Review Group made a total of 9 recommendations, of which all but one had been agreed. He thanked all the officers involved throughout the process, with particular thanks to Nigel Kennedy, Head of Financial Services and to Alice Courtney, as Scrutiny Officer in drafting this report.
Councillor James Fry, Chair of the Group, presented its report and summarised its nine recommendations.
Councillor Fry highlighted that the Group had expressed some concern as to how the savings proposed in the Council Tax Reduction Scheme would be achieved. This had led to a recommendation that several alternative scenarios for achieving the savings should be modelled and included in the next public consultation.
Councillor Fry thanked officers for their work in supporting the Group, and the members of the Group for their time and deliberations. The Leader, and the Cabinet Member for Finance and Asset Management, both thanked the Group for its comprehensive review.
The Scrutiny Officer presented the report and recommendations of the Budget Review Group 2024/25 for approval for submission to Cabinet on behalf of Cllr James Fry, Chair of the Budget Review Group who had sent his apologies.
F inance and P erformance P anel (and B udget R eview G roup): Cllr James Fry (Chair); Cllr Tiago Corais ;
Cllr Chris Smowton; Cllr Chris Jarvis; Cllr Hosnieh Djafari-Marbini ; Cllr Amar Latif H ousing and H omelessness P anel: Cllr Lizzy Diggins (Chair); Cllr Mary Clarkson; Cllr Jo Sandelson; Cllr Rosie Rawle; Cllr Paula Dunne; Cllr Shaista Aziz C limate and E nvironment P anel: Cllr Alex Hollingsworth (Chair); Cllr James Fry; Cllr Katherine Miles; Cllr Emily Kerr; Cllr Paula Dunne; Cllr Shaista Aziz For the Companies Scrutiny Panel, the Oxford Socialist Independents Group did not wish to take up its allocation of a seat. It was therefore recommended that this Panel revert to a membership of 4 Members and the vacant seat be given over to the Independent Group, therefore the Panel would be comprised as follows:
The Panel was attended by Cllr Fry, Cllr Jarvis and Cllr Smowton; Cllr Fry thanked Cllr Turner and officers for their attendance to answer questions. At this meeting the Panel agreed their work plan, and considered the following three substantive reports; Integrated Performance Report Q1 2023/24, Treasury Management Annual Report 2022/23 and Scrutiny Performance Monitoring. The Panel was due to meet next on 06 December 2023 and it was expected to be a busy agenda, including initial consideration of the 2024/25 budget ahead of the Budget Review Group meetings which would commence in January.
· Scrutiny Committee – Councillor James Fry to replace Councillor Paula Dunne.
Councillor Fry declared that he also lived fairly close to the application site but had not been involved in or discussed the application and was approaching it with an open mind.
Councillor James Fry was elected Chair for the Council year 2023-24.
o Housing and Homelessness Panel: Cllr Lizzy Diggins (Chair), Cllr Dunne, Cllr Fouweather, Cllr Nala-Hartley, Cllr Rawle, Cllr Sandelson o Finance and Performance Panel: Cllr Fry (Chair), Cllr Djafari-Marbini, Cllr Jarvis, Cllr Smowton o Climate and Environment Panel: Cllr Hollingsworth (Chair), Cllr Dunne, Cllr Kerr, Cllr Miles o Companies Scrutiny Panel: Cllr Rowley (Chair), Cllr Miles, Cllr Morris, Cllr Walcott 7. Agree that the Chair of the Finance and Performance Panel will Chair the Budget Review Group.
Cllr Chapman proposed, seconded by Cllr Upton, that Cllr James Fry be appointed Deputy Lord Mayor to the start of the Annual Council meeting in May 2024.
Council were resolved to appoint Cllr James Fry as Deputy Lord Mayor of Oxford for the Council year 2023/24.
· Cllr Lubna Arshad – Lord Mayor · Cllr James Fry – Deputy Lord Mayor · Cllr Mark Lygo – Sheriff Cllr Dunne joined the meeting.
Cllr Fry, Chair of the Scrutiny Budget Review Group, advised that all but one of the recommendations had been agreed. He thanked all the officers involved in the budget scrutiny process.
Councillor James Fry, Chair of the Budget Review Group, presented the report of the Group and summarised its recommendations, some of which had already been incorporated into the revised budget proposals. The Group’s recommendations had included that the Council should provide an up-to-date, confidential explanation for Members of the options available to achieve the savings that would arise from ODS depot consolidation.
Cllr James Fry, Chair of the Budget Review Group 2023/24 presented the report and outlined the recommendations. Discussions were held in private session and the Committee agreed the recommendations that should be made to Cabinet, and to delegate authority to the Scrutiny Officer to make minor editorial revisions as necessary.
In the absence of the Committee Chair and Vice-Chair, Councillor Fry was elected to chair the meeting.
The Committee resolved to elect Cllr James Fry as Chair for the 2022/23 Council year.
21/02581/FUL Councillor Fry stated that he had been a signatory to the call-in but was approaching the application with an open mind, would listen to all the arguments and weigh up all the relevant facts before coming to a decision.
Cllr Upton proposed, seconded by Cllr Clarkson, that Cllr Fry be elected Lord Mayor to the start of the Annual Council meeting in May 2023.
Council were resolved to elect Cllr Fry as Lord Mayor of Oxford for the Council year 2022/23.
· 05 April ( in-person ) In response to a request from Cllr Chapman, the Committee agreed that he could ask Cllr Fry to Chair the Companies Scrutiny Panel meeting scheduled for Thursday 24 March on his behalf.
· Cllr James Fry – Lord Mayor · Cllr Mark Lygo – Deputy Lord Mayor · Cllr Mike Rowley – Sheriff
Cllr Fry, Chair of the Budget Review Group, outlined the key findings and recommendations in the report and Cllr Turner outlined Cabinet’s responses.
Tom Hudson, Scrutiny Officer, presented the main findings and recommendations of the Budget Review Group on behalf of its Chair, Councillor Fry. It was noted that the financial climate remained very difficult: the impact of the pandemic had led to reserves being reduced to half of their former level. The challenges of budget setting were identified as not only the legal duty of needing to achieve a balanced budget, but also the ‘higher bar’ of delivering core and strategic priorities for the benefit of residents.
Councillor Fry had identified the Group’s key recommendations as being that the Council reverses its proposals to make £25k cuts to advice centre base budgets, as well as two recommendations relating to regeneration and investment which were contained in the Part II report. It was also important to ensure that savings arising from transformation were clearly delineated and not ‘double-counted’. The Budget Review Group had wished Cabinet well for delivery of the budget in the current challenging financial environment.
The Committee noted the following update from Cllr James Fry, Chair of the Finance and Performance Panel:
The motion was proposed by Cllr Dick Wolff, seconded by Cllr James Fry, and approved by all those present and eligible to vote.
The Chair of the Audit & Governance Committee Cllr Fry , introduced the r eport, proposed the recommendations and answered questions.
Councillor Fry stated that he had called the application in to committee but he had expressed no view on the application and had not made his mind up on the matter and approached it with an open mind.
Cllr Fry, as Chair of the Companies Scrutiny Panel, said it had considered a report on the structure of OxWed , a joint venture involving Nuffield College and the City Council. It had become apparent that the current arrangements, which had been in place for a few years, exposed both parties to a significant tax burden in the future. The report simply proposed an alternative arrangement for good commercial reasons, which did not compromise the Council’s interests while at the same time being more tax efficient.
Cllr Fry presented the recommendations from the Companies Scrutiny Panel meeting on 18 October 2021.
QL Implementation Cllr Fry, as Chair of the Finance & Performance Panel, was pleased with the positive response from Cabinet and its agreement to the Panel’s two recommendations. He was pleased, also, to note that an audit of QL’s implementation was to be held at some point.
Social Value in Procurement Cllr Fry said that while a formal response had yet to be received, all indications were that Cabinet was well disposed towards the two recommendations.
OL Implementation Cllr Fry, speaking as Chair of the Finance & Performance Panel, said the Panel had been keen to ensure that the lessons learned from OL implementation addressed both its direct and indirect consequences as well as those for Oxford Direct Services and not just the Council. The Panel was also keen to ensure that the significant additional workload for many colleagues caused by the delayed implementation was properly acknowledged.
Social Value in Procurement Cllr Fry said the Panel had benefitted from a very helpful report and contributions from the Procurement Manager. It had been good to see that the Council performed well compared with similar authorities and was keen that comparisons should be expanded to include a wider group of authorities.
Cllr Fry, as Chair of the Finance & Performance Panel, spoke briefly to the two reports before the Committee.
Cllr Fry was elected as Chair for the Council year 2021/22.
Cllr Fry drew the SJVG’s attention to key points from the discussions at the Companies Scrutiny Panel meeting on 20 July.
In the absence of the Chair, the Panel AGREED that Councillor James Fry should assume the role of Chair for the meeting.
The Committee agreed to appoint the following as Chairs to the three Panels · Housing & Homelessness: Cllr Smith · Finance & Performance: Cllr Fry · Companies Scrutiny: Cllr Chapman The Scrutiny Officer set out the proposal for a more flexible approach to the Committee’s Work Plan which would enable a more responsive approach to variations in the Cabinet Forward Plan. At the heart of the proposal was the prioritisation of anticipated Cabinet reports for Scrutiny consideration.
Cllr Fry, Chair of the Budget Review Group, outlined the key findings and recommendations in the report and Cllr Turner outlined Cabinet’s responses.
Agreed that the Scrutiny Officer, in consultation with Cllr Fry as Chair of the Finance & Performance Panel, would decide how best to address this.
Cllr James Fry introduced the report by focussing on the main recommendations. In relation to Floyd’s row there were two recommendations in the light the inability to make full use of it because of the current Covid restrictions and some concerns about the future funding arrangements for it. It was suggested that the savings flowing from the proposal to move to one planning committee should be monitored and, if not achieved, the position should be reversed.
The Committee confirmed its agreement to the Review Group’s report and delegated finalisation of it to Cllr Fry and the Scrutiny Office.
Cllr Fry reported back on the last meeting of the Finance & Performance Panel which had reviewed the Cabinet report on the Capital Strategy. Among other things the Panel noted that there may well be value in scrutinising projects once complete to see whether or not they represented good value for money.
Cllr Fry fed back to the Committee about the most recent meeting of the Finance & Performance Panel. The Panel had considered 4 reports in relation to Treasury Management; Integrated Performance ;
Councillor Fry raised the fact that his company rented offices from Lothbury , who run a property fund in which the Council is invested.
Councillor James Fry was elected Chair for the Council year 2020-21.
Councillor Fry fedback on the most recent meetings of the Finance & Performance Panel and the Companies Panel.
The Committee elected Cllr Fry to be the Chair for the Council Year 2020/21.
Similarly, Councillor Fry, in his capacity as Chair of the Finance and Performance Panel, was pleased to support Cabinet’s support for the Panel’s recommendations in relation to the “April Budget Monitoring Report.”
Councillor Fry, in his capacity as Chair of the Companies Scrutiny Panel , drew attention to some of the key issues arising from its recent meeting. In relation to Oxford Direct Services (ODS) there had been discussion about its trading performance and the steps being taken to address a high sickness rate, the latter was partly but not wholly attributable to Covid-19. A recommendation from this discussion was the desirability of ensuring that the social value of capital projects was taken into account when commissioned from ODS by the Council.
Councillor James Fry, Chair of the Finance and Performance Panel, reported back on the previous day’s meeting of the Panel. The Panel’s discussion had focussed on consideration of the Council’s deficits projected in the Medium Term Financial Plan and ways of tackling them with a particular focus on the current financial year. The Panel recognised that it would have the opportunity for a more detailed exploration of these matters later in the year when the same members would meet to look at budget proposals for 2021/22.
Appoint Cllr Fry as Chair of both the Finance & Performance Panel and Companies Panel and Cllr Aziz as Vice-Chair of Housing & Homelessness Panel;
Councillor James Fry had commented on the report and his comments, together with the Scrutiny Officer’s response to them had been published with the Committee’s papers. The committee accepted the recommendations given in the later paper.
Helen Bishop, Head of Business Improvement, had met Councillor Fry to discuss the Committee’s role in relation to performance monitoring as a result of which there would be a review of the way in which these indicators were presented.
Councillor Fry, Chair of the Budget Review Group, drew attention to the key findings in the report including the very small percentage of business rates retained by the council (8%); that the council had to fund 100% of any discretionary rate relief; and the very large amount spent on homelessness prevention despite the lack of stable central funding.
Councillor Fry stated that he was Chair of the Company Scrutiny Panel but that he had no prior knowledge of application 19/02841/VAR and was approaching it with an open mind.
At the last meeting of the Committee it had been agreed that detailed consideration of the Quarter 2 Performance Monitoring report should be delegated to Cllr Fry.
Cllr Fry had provided the Committee with a commentary following discussion with the Head of Business Improvement.
Cllr Fry had also provided commentary on the responses made by officers to the Committee’s recommendations in relation to Quarter 1.
The Committee’s response to the Q1 recommendations and responses was as follows: Rec 1:Target OCC spend in relation to local business Response accepted and Cllr Fry recommendation agreed Rec 2:Change in wording re measures to reduce carbon footprint Response accepted.Noted however that while the revised wording now provides an accurate description of the indicator it does beg the question as to whether this is the most appropriate indicator.
Rec 3: Indicators re use of Council leisure facilities Response accepted and Cllr Fry recommendation agreed.
Noted however that there should be no reason not to ask for revenue data as part of a new contract when the time comes for renewal Rec 4: Measures re effective delivery of capital programme Response accepted and Cllr Fry recommendation agreed Rec 5:Revised target for number of people moved into work by the Welfare Reform Programme Response accepted.
It was agreed to defer substantive discussion of this item until the following meeting, having asked Councillor Fry to pick up the issues raised by the Q2 report in the meantime and report back to the Committee.
Councillor Fry had, prior to the meeting, posed a number of detailed questions about the performance monitoring report and provided them to the Scrutiny Officer. The questions were tabled for the benefit of the Committee and the Scrutiny Officer was able to read out responses received from officers. Those questions and responses are attached as an appendix to these minutes.
Councillor Fry was elected as Chair of the Committee for the Council year 2019-2020.
Councillor Fry, Chair of the Companies Scrutiny Panel, was present to speak to the minutes of the meeting held on 16 July 2019 and which had been circulated to the Shareholder. The Chair commented on the challenge of providing effective scrutiny in the short timescale between agenda publication and meeting date. Although there were no formal recommendations from the Panel they did wish to make reference to some issues.
Elect Councillor Fry as Chair of the Companies Panel 3. Appoint Councillors Munkonge , Fry, Smith and Simmons to the Finance Panel 4. Appoint Councillors Muknonge , Fry Landell -Mills and Simmons to the Companies Panel 5.
Appoint Councillor Fry as Chair of the Finance Panel, and Councillor Bely-Summers as Chair of the Housing Panel.
Cllr Fry ,Chair of the Scrutiny Shareholder Group and Finance Panel presented the report. He said that he was pleased with the protections given to employees , but felt that the report didn’t sufficiently emphasise the benefits of the trading model for the Council. The Board approved the Scrutiny recommendation.
Cllr Fry, Chair of the Scrutiny Shareholder Group and Finance Panel presented the report. He noted that the benefits of the scheme were potentially greater for the County Council . He suggested that the scheme was of sufficient significance to warrant that the wider community be consulted about its introduction.
· Oxford Preservation Trust had agreed to reduce Council appointees to 2 and Councillor Fry was relinquishing his appointment.
Councillor Fry added that he was concerned that local hotels would indirectly end up bearing the bill of an additional levy, rather than visitors.
Councillor Fry gave apologies for being absent for part of the meeting.
Councillor Corais substituted for Councillor Fry.
The Chair drew attention to an observation from Cllr Fry that a breakdown of year-on-year figures for participation by centre and activity would be useful , though it was noted that this level of detail may be difficult to provide.
With the Committee’s agreement the Chair said he would pass on a number of detailed observations made by Councillor Fry in advance of the meeting.
In the absence of Councillor Fry, Councillor Munkonge was appointed as Chair for this meeting only.
Councillor Fry had submitted a number of questions in advance of the meeting. A summary of the responses is set out below.
Councillor Fry, Chair of the Budget Review Group, explained the Panels’ approach to scrutinising the budget and formulating their recommendations and drew attention to the key findings in the report.
Councillor Fry spoke to the report before the Committee, drawing attention to a few matters in particular. While the Council was powerless to challenge the proportion of business rates it retained, the regrettable fact that it would retain a mere 8.5% of them should be noted as should the fact that this small share was under threat from the “Fair Funding Review.” Maintenance of support for twinning arrangements was important in the present environment as was the desirability of being clear about environmental consequences of Council plans. The use of the Council’s homelessness reserves, touched upon in the previous item, was a matter of great concern and the recommendation to the City Executive Board about it should be expanded to request a contingency plan to deal with the consequences of its significant use.
Councillor Fry, Chair of the Finance Panel, left the meeting during this item.
In the absence of Councillor Fry (Chair of the Panel) Councillor Munkonge was appointed as Chair for this meeting.
The Chair, Councillor Fry, asked for more detail on the ‘programming difficulties identified in the report. It was explained that a pipeline of work associated with the Council’s wholly owned Housing Company had not yet come forward. Furthermore, there had been delays in the progress of the Seacourt park and ride development.
The Chair, Councillor Fry, summarised that the market for income generation was limited, and that the Alternative Business Model was not a favoured option. He also noted the constraints in relation to marketing and the difficulties in securing work through the Legal Hub as factors that limited income generation.
Councillor Fry asked for the reinstatement of the following performance measures included in the Quarter 4 report for 2017/18, or if these were annual targets or an explanation of the reasons for removing these:
Councillor Fry, being proposed and seconded, was elected Chair of the Committee for the 2018/19 Council year.
Councillor Fry, being proposed and seconded, was elected Chair of the Committee for the 2018/19 Council year.
Councillor Fry mentioned that that Lothbury Property Trust were the owners of his company’s business premises.
The Shareholder noted that Councillor Fry, Chair Scrutiny Companies Panel, had sent apologies and that Stefan Robinson (Scrutiny Officer) was in attendance to present the views of the Scrutiny Companies Panel which had met on 7 June 2018.
The Chair, Councillor Fry, welcomed new and returning members, and asked all attendees to introduce themselves. The Chair explained that the principle of setting up Oxford City Housing Limited (“The Company”), with two separate subsidiaries, as a wholly owned Council company was to gain greater borrowing freedoms and control over the housing supply. A separate wholly owned council company, Oxford Direct Services Limited, was also established to run frontline public and commercial services for the Council.
Appoint the following Panel Chairs: Finance, Cllr Fry; Housing, Cllr Henwood ; Companies Cllr Fry.
Cllr Fry, speaking to the recommendations at CEB, had argued that recommendation 5 (proposal to increase garden waste collection fees) could have funded recommendation 4 (proposal for additional resource for City Centre Management).
Cllr Fry had arranged to meet with the Business Development & Support Manager to discuss the list of indicators which it would be helpful for the Committee to engage with over the next year.
Cllr Chapman relayed a number of detailed observations on behalf of Cllr Fry all of which would be passed on to the Business Development & Support Manager.
He thanked panel members and the Chair, Councillor Fry, for their work.
Councillor Fry left the meeting at the start of this item and the Vice Chair, Councillor Munkonge, took the chair.
Cllr Fry mentioned that Lothbury were the owners of his company’s business premises.
The Panel resolved to elect Councillor James Fry as chair for the 2017/18 Council year.
The Committee appointed Cllr Fry as Chair for the Council year 2017-18
Councillor James Fry was elected chair for the 2017/18 Council year.
Councillor Fry was elected as Chair for the 2017/18 municipal year.
The Committee agreed that Cllr Fry would continue as lead member for performance monitoring and would select performance measures for Scrutiny to monitor in the year ahead.
Cllr Simmons offered to give his group’s seat to Cllr Fry to provide a link with Audit and Governance.
The Committee agreed the sub-committee’s membership to be Cllr Gant (Chair of Scrutiny Committee, Cllr Hayes* (Vice Chair of Scrutiny Committee), Cllr Henwood (Chair of Housing) and Cllr Fry.
Cllr Fry asked what the charge would be.
Cllr Fry asked if we could price variations by zones eg higher in city centre, than surrounds. [name removed] said it was worth considering, however businesses might move out of the city to surrounding areas to avoid the higher costs. This would mean the city could lose vitality.
Cllr Fry, Lead Member for Performance monitoring presented the report. He said he did get an officer response from the previous scrutiny comments. However there are still a lot of issues with the way that performance is monitored and presented in these reports.
Cllr Fry said that the user group he attends use to have a large number of maintenance complaints which has gone down significantly The Head of Community Services said that no centre has a maintenance backlog. The budget is available, but the challenge is finding the time to repair things as the centres are busier which leads to more wear and tear.
Cllr Fry asked about the user group figures in the report. Are they correct, because the figures suggest the focus should be on young people?
Cllr Fry, as Committee lead presented the report. He outlined his list of concerns with the way some of the indicators are measured, and the analysis of why some of the indicators had not met their target.
The Committee agreed that the Scrutiny Officer and Cllr Fry should write to the Assistant Chief Executive outlining their concerns. The response to be presented to the Scrutiny Committee.
Cllr Fry said that there were no smokeless fuel obligations or restrictions on boat emissions in the City Centre area, unlike at various residential mooring zones in the city. The Committee suggest that such measures are needed and, in addition, that the Council should lobby the statutory body to introduce appropriate measures more widely.
Cllr Fry asked if there had been implications on officer time due to the increased demand. The Revenues & Benefits Programme Manager said that additional funding had been secured from DWP for administration which would fund a full time post for 1 year. The team now consist of 4 members with a caseload of 30-40 people each.
Cllr Fry felt that the planning part of the council website was quite difficult to navigate and improving this should be a priority in the Action Plan. The Digital Development Manager said that the planning software was provided by a national provider and that it would be a challenge to make significant improvements until such a time as the contract was due for renewal.
Cllr Fry asked if the schools that dropped out of the programme regretted not participating.
The Chair explained that Cllr Fry had put himself forward to be the lead member for performance monitoring.
Other members could approach Cllr Fry directly if they had queries on the information.
The Committee Services Manager explained that Cllr Fry had suggested four additional performance measures:
Cllr Fry raised concerns about how quickly minor maintenance requests and IT failures were dealt with and questioned whether these issues were considered in performance assessments. The Head of Community Services said that Fusion used a variety of assessments including mystery visits and customer journey mapping. He could not excuse failures to fix minor maintenance issues but was not aware of any continuous problems, and such issues should be seen in the context of a vast increase in usage over recent years.
Cllr Fry asked what user involvement there was on the Leisure Partnership Board and commented that a user representative had been unable to attend recent meetings because they had taken place in the daytime on a week day. The Board meets quarterly and its minutes are published on the Council website. The membership included two elected members as well as customer representatives including older and younger people.
The Committee resolved to elect Cllr James Fry as Chair for the 2016/17 municipal year.
The Committee resolved to elect Cllr James Fry as Chair for the Council year 2016/17.
Councillor Fry, Chair of the Local Economy Review Group spoke on behalf of the Review Group and in discussion the Committee made the following observations:
The Committee elected Councillor Fry to be the Chair for the remainder of the Council Year 2015/16.
Recycling Panel Councillor Fry would adopt a “watching brief” on the implementation of the scrutiny recommendations.
The Committee elected Councillor James Fry as Chair for the Council year 2015/16.
Cllr Fry presented the report and recommendations of the Local Economy Panel which had been formed to examine the situation of small and medium enterprises in and near the city centre during a time of major developments which will affect the trading environment while construction occurs. The Panel considered how the City Council could make the city centre even more attractive to the public and to local businesses.
Councillor Clarkson - The Covered Market Councillor Sanders - Older Citizens Councillor Fry - Small Business Councillor Lygo - Events
Cllr Fry, Chair of the Recycling Panel said that the panel was meeting on 16 February at the Cowley Marsh Depot.
The Planning Review Committee elected Councillor Fry to be the Chair for the Council Year 2014/15.
Cllr Fry asked what the status of a consultation submission received after the deadline was? It’s the quality of the submission rather than it’s timeliness that is more important. However late submissions risk not being considered before a decision is made.
The Committee agreed to elect Councillor James Fry as Chair for the Council Year 2014/15.
Councillor James Fry presented the report to the Committee and provided some background and context to it.
Councillor Fry explained that there were recycling incentives in other parts of the country, but these were often used in conjunction with other incentives so that it was hard to identify their value. The Panel had noted that food waste recycling would be introduced in the Council’s flats in the next few years.
· Councillor Fry – Councillor Pressel substituted;
Councillor Fry – apologies, Councillor Humberstone substituted;
Councillor James Fry asked if further detail on the risks could be included in future reports.
Councillor Fry was elected Chair of the Committee for the Council Year 2013/14.
Councillor Pressel attended as a substitute for Councillor Fry.
Councillor Price seconded by Councillor Fry moved the following Motion:- “This Council declares its support for the introduction of a Financial Transactions Tax across the European Union and G12 economies as an important contribution by the banking and finance sector for the funding of public investment in education, housing, infrastructure and social security”.
Recycling Rates review - to continue, Councillor Fry as Lead Member, panel to be asked to tighten their focus; aim to complete by September.
Councillor Fry asked how the transition from the Audit Commission to Ernst and Young had affected the Council. In response Nigel Kennedy said that the approach of Ernst and Young was similar to that of the former Audit Commission and the staff were they same as they had transferred to Ernst and Young.
Councillor Fry asked how the risk based verification was conducted on new claimants. In response Paul Wilding said that the data was collected and compared against a central database and the likelihood of something going wrong (the risk). The Council would then receive a score back (high/medium/low) on each claim.
Councillor Fry said that some of the risks highlighted in red where not in the control of the Council. In response Jackie Yates said that despite the fact that these were external factors the Council still had to mitigate against them.
(a) That Councillor Pat Kennedy would replace Councillor James Fry on the Finance and Performance Panel;
OXRAD – appoint Councillor Fry;
Councillor Fry asked questions concerning the pension deficit. In response Jackie Yates said that the valuation was a point in time, and so would change. She added that the tri-annual valuation would look at the assets and liabilities of the fund and make recommendations for managing the deficit over the long term.
Councillor Fry made a general comment concerning the pie charts used in the report asking that rather than just the post code being show, population distribution would also help. He also asked if the Oxford Living Wage was paid to sub-contractors. He further commented that the maintenance procedures that Fusion ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Councillor Fry asked how underspends should be interpreted. In response Nigel Kennedy said that with the capital programme, these were divided into two categories, underspend and slippage. Underspends where a project came in under budget, slippage was when the cost of the project would be moved to, for example the next year, where the spend would take place.
Councillor Fry asked what was the Insurance Fund for, and did the Council have liabilities on the pension fund. In response Nigel Kennedy said that the Council self-insured and had to cover for hidden liabilities such as asbestos. Regarding the pension liabilities, he said that these had been factored into the Statement of Accounts, but while the fund had a deficit of £92m, there were no immediate liability issues.
Councillor Fry asked how would risk assessments be carried out regarding benefits and the proposed changes with direct payments. In response Jane Lubbock said that Officers were working hard to signup more people paying by direct debit and that the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) had agreed with Tim Sadler, Executive Director for City Services to underwrite the risk part of the direct payment pilot that the Council was part of.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Fry attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 Sep 2026 | Council | Housing Revenue Account (HRA) Budget 2026 - 2027 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 30 Jan 2023 | Council | Council to Vote on Motion | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 30 Jan 2023 | Council | Council to Vote on Motion | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Fry was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 2 of 6 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Fry declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 18 Apr 2024 | Planning Review Committee, item 13 | Councillor Fry declared that he was a member of both Cyclox and the Oxford Preservation Trust. However, he had taken no part in any discussions by those organisations regarding the application and was approaching it with an open mind. | |
| 15 Aug 2023 | Planning - Oxford City Planning Committee, item 22 | Councillor Fry declared that he also lived fairly close to the application site but had not been involved in or discussed the application and was approaching it with an open mind. |
Where Councillor Fry sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Jan 2023 | 3 | 23 Nov 2026 |
| Planning Review Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2026 | 2 | |
| Audit and Governance Committee | Vice-Chair | Jul 2026 | 2 | |
| Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2020 | 3 | |
| Cabinet | Guest | Sep 2021 | 1 | |
| Planning - Oxford City Planning Committee | Committee Member | Nov 2021 | 1 | |
| Finance and Performance Panel (Panel of the Scrutiny Committee) | Committee Member | Dec 2021 | 1 | |
| Shareholder and Joint Venture Group | Guest | Nov 2022 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.