Said5 Oct 2026Council
Housing Competence and Conduct Policy
Councillor Katherine Miles said that she supported the principles of the policy. She queried the budget allocated for the training and noted that it appeared high. She asked how many members of staff would be trained.
Said5 Oct 2026Council
Urgent Key Decisions Since July 2026
Councillor Katherine Miles said that wildfires are increasing and asked about emergency preparedness. She asked if they should be distributing emergency preparedness information to residents.
Said5 Oct 2026Council
Questions on Cabinet minutes
Councillor Katherine Miles welcomed the new Street Naming and Numbering Policy. She asked if there was a baseline number for how many streets are named after woman and men.
Said3 Sep 2026Council
Additional Funding for Community Improvement Measures
Councillor Miles welcomed the community investments listed in the report, noting connections with positive cross-party agreements.
Named3 Sep 2026Council
Additional Funding for Community Improvement Measures
Council heard that the report lacks some detail, and that Councillor Miles hoped implementation details could be discussed further over time.
Said3 Sep 2026Council
Additional Funding for Community Improvement Measures
In relation to public toilets, Councillor Miles also suggested that the inclusion of footstalls for children be considered to ensure Oxford is accessible and inclusive for children. Broad support for the report recommendation was noted.
Named3 Aug 2026General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair
Councillor Ottino proposed, and Councillor Yeatman seconded, Councillor Miles as Chair.
Named3 Aug 2026General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair
Councillor Miles was elected as Chair for the duration of the meeting.
Named20 Jul 2026General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair
Councillor Lygo proposed, and Councillor Dhall seconded, Councillor Miles as Chair.
Named20 Jul 2026General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair
Councillor Miles was elected as Chair for the duration of the meeting.
Said13 Jul 2026Council
Urgent Key Decisions Since January 2026
Councillor Miles welcomed the report but noted concern regarding the continued pattern of urgent key decisions; it was suggested that some processes may not be fit for purpose.
Said13 Jul 2026Council
Urgent Key Decisions Since January 2026
Councillor Miles suggested this could be reviewed as part of the transition period following LGR to ensure effective and sufficient democratic oversight continues and to ensure the Council responds and delivers quickly for residents.
Seconded13 Jul 2026Council
Motions on Notice July 2026
Use of Park and Rides to facilitate pupil transport services (Proposed by Cllr Gant, Seconded by Cllr Miles)? f.
Named27 May 2026Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Election of Chair for Council Year 2026-2027
Councillor Ottino proposed, and Councillor Bala seconded the nomination of Councillor Miles to be elected as Chair of the Committee for 2026/27. There were no further nominations.
Named27 May 2026Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Election of Chair for Council Year 2026-2027
The Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee resolved that Councillor Miles be elected as the Chair for 2026/27.
Seconded27 May 2026General Purposes Licensing Committee
Election of Chair for Council Year 2026-2027
Councillor Ottino proposed, and Councillor Miles seconded the nomination of Councillor Muddiman to be elected as Chair of the Committee for 2026/27. There were no further nominations.
Moved27 May 2026General Purposes Licensing Committee
Election of Vice-Chair for Council Year 2026-2027
Councillor Miles proposed, and Councillor Taylor seconded the nomination of Councillor Ottino to be elected as Vice-Chair of the Committee for 2026/27. There were no further nominations.
Seconded27 May 2026General Purposes Licensing Committee
Appointment of General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committees
On being proposed by the Vice-Chair and seconded by Councillor Miles, recommendations 2, 3 and 4 were put to a vote.
Said23 Mar 2026Council
Allocations Scheme Review
Councillor Miles requested clarification relating to the qualification of tenants who live in social housing outside of the city but need to relocate or commute in order to work in Oxford. It was suggested this could cause hardship.
Asked23 Mar 2026Council
Allocations Scheme Review
Secondly, Councillor Miles asked how far outside of the city people must live for the relevant clause to apply.
Asked23 Mar 2026Council
Outside organisation report - Partnership report on the Oxfordshire Children’s Trust Board, and the Council’s work for Children and Young People living in the city
Councillor Miles asked whether future updates could include information on the city centre playground proposals.
Said23 Mar 2026Council
Outside organisation report - The Oxford Strategic Partnership
Councillor Miles noted that a small budget is assigned this workstream and asked what the money is used for specifically.
Asked23 Mar 2026Council
Outside organisation report - The Oxford Strategic Partnership
Councillor Miles queried how many days work this equated to; Councillor Brown committed to offering a more detailed written response.
Said23 Mar 2026Council
Scrutiny Committee update report
Councillor Miles thanked Councillor Powell for chairing the Committee this municipal year and asked whether a summary of the urgent decisions taken would be provided, as promised last year.
Said23 Mar 2026Council
Petition submitted in accordance with Council procedure rules - Save Our Museum
Councillor Miles suggested that some of the paintings held in the Town Hall that do not support or align with the Council’s values be sold in order to fund the preservation of other aspects of the city's history that do align with the council’s values, such as the museum.
Said23 Mar 2026Council
Petition submitted in accordance with Council procedure rules - Save Our Museum
Councillor Miles explained that reinvestment of these assets could support income and shares could generate a better financial return to support the Council’s service delivery costs.
Seconded23 Mar 2026Council
Motions on notice March 2026
Motions agreed as set out below: 18b) Prisoners for Palestine hunger strikes (Proposed by Councillor Jarvis, Seconded by Councillor Mundy) 18c) Support for Mini Plant Oxford (Proposed by Councillor Linda Smith, Seconded by Councillor Ottino) Motions taken but lost: 18a) Better use of Oxpens Bridge Funding (Proposed by Councillor Jupp, Seconded by Councillor Miles) Motions not taken as the time allocated for debate had finished: 18d) Condemnation of Attempted Election Postponement (Proposed by Councillor Smowton, Seconded by Councillor Miles) 18e) Stop the War in Iran (Proposed by Councillor Powell, Seconded by Councillor Djafari-Marbini)
Moved23 Mar 2026Council
Better use of Oxpens Bridge Funding (Proposed by Cllr Jupp, Seconded by Cllr Miles)
Councillor Miles, seconded by Councillor Smowton, proposed the motion as set out in the briefing note. This was self-amended by the amendment set out in the briefing note, omitting one paragraph.
Said10 Mar 2026Scrutiny Committee
More Leisure Annual Service Plan (Year 3) and Update
Councillor Miles requested disaggregated data in relation to the participation rates of women, girls, and young people in sport via membership numbers.
Asked10 Mar 2026Scrutiny Committee
More Leisure Annual Service Plan (Year 3) and Update
Councillor Miles also asked how youth age groups are using the leisure centres in the evenings across different locations;
Named10 Mar 2026Scrutiny Committee
More Leisure Annual Service Plan (Year 3) and Update
In response to Councillor Miles, the Active Communities Manager acknowledged that different interventions are required in relation to the youth hub to specifically target involvement of women and girls; examples of recent successes were noted, including the recent relaunch of girls’ sessions at the East Oxford Community Centre. The Committee understood that feedback is sought from attendees to ensure plans are targeted and informed in the future. The Active Communities Manager committed to checking the data relating to women and girls' attendance at the East Oxford Community Centre sessions.
Said10 Mar 2026Scrutiny Committee
Nighttime Economy
Councillor Miles requested a definition of the nighttime economy and emphasised that it should consider a distinction between activities for adults, families, and children.
Asked10 Mar 2026Scrutiny Committee
Nighttime Economy
Secondly, Councillor Miles asked how the impacts of the nighttime economy on residents are being assessed, specifically environmental factors and noise. The City Centre Manager explained that whilst the audit had heavily focused on live music, it did also consider all forms of nighttime activity including events at libraries and museums; work going into the assessment of future opportunities for families and those under 18 at these venues was outlined. The Committee heard that analysis of existing licenses was not undertaken as licence conditions ... view the full minutes text for item 112.
Said10 Mar 2026Scrutiny Committee
Fly-tipping and Litter Management
Councillor Miles outlined a two-minute litter pick scheme which had been successful in Cutteslowe Park and suggested this be placed in additional settings.
Said23 Feb 2026Council
Licensing Act 2003 and Gambling Act 2005 Licence Fees and Charges for the 2026/27 financial year
Councillor Miles presented the report. She thanked the Licensing officers for their hard work in enforcement across the city. She discussed the statutory and legal responsibility they held as the Council to set these fees.
Asked9 Feb 2026General Purposes Licensing Committee
Miscellaneous Licensing Update Report
Councillor Miles queried what the process for a consultation on this topic would be, to which the Supervising Senior Licensing Officer explained that the internal consultation team would be engaged to identify stakeholders, would be licence holders, councillors, and the public.
Said9 Feb 2026General Purposes Licensing Committee
Miscellaneous Licensing Update Report
Councillor Miles emphasised that the Committee must consider the justifications for 100% smoke free pavement licenses, with recognition that it would not be an immediate change and consultation would be required.
Said9 Feb 2026General Purposes Licensing Committee
Miscellaneous Licensing Update Report
Councillor Miles emphasised that she would support this direction ... view the full minutes text for item 32.
Seconded9 Feb 2026General Purposes Licensing Committee
Miscellaneous Licensing Fees and Charges for the financial year 2026/2027
On being proposed by Councillor Upton and seconded by Councillor Miles, the recommendation was put to a vote. 12 Members voted in favour and 1 abstained;
Asked3 Feb 2026Scrutiny Committee
Debt Recovery Procedure
Councillor Miles asked what steps the Council takes to confirm the identity of a person believed to be residing at a given property when enacting debt recovery measures.
Named3 Feb 2026Scrutiny Committee
Debt Recovery Procedure
In response to Councillor Miles, the Revenues Service Delivery Manager explained the ... view the full minutes text for item 98.
Said3 Feb 2026Scrutiny Committee
Noticeboards Update
Councillor Miles noted her thanks for the report and expressed a preference for valuable work with noticeboards to be maintained within the city. On this basis, it was asked what the procurement procedure and funding sources would be, and whether this could be standardised.
Said3 Feb 2026Scrutiny Committee
Noticeboards Update
Councillor Miles suggested that the Committee could consider the allocation of free space on noticeboards to allow residents to post their own leaflets, without the control the relevant organising body. Finally, it was asked how new locations for more noticeboards could be identified.
Named3 Feb 2026Scrutiny Committee
Noticeboards Update
It was noted that this could provide consistency across the city, as suggested by Councillor Miles.
Said3 Feb 2026Scrutiny Committee
Noticeboards Update
Councillor Miles noted concern and her experience with planning permission disputes relating to noticeboards and requested that councillors be provided with some definitive guidance. The Deputy Chief Executive for City and Citizens suggested that the Committee may wish to make this as a recommendation, with consideration for the budget review group report later in the meeting. The Chair invited the Committee to consider possible recommendations.
Said3 Feb 2026Scrutiny Committee
AI Strategy Update
Councillor Miles suggested an open question focused on whether security and GDPR had been considered within the Council’s expansion of AI.
Named3 Feb 2026Scrutiny Committee
AI Strategy Update
The Director of Communities and Citizens' Services, in response to Councillor Miles, emphasised that the Council manages AI within a highly secure environment, and the current policy ensures employees use tools that are confined within the Microsoft environment. This ensures that all organisational data remains within a compliant boundary and risk is naturally minimised;
Said3 Feb 2026Scrutiny Committee
Budget Review Group Report
Councillor Miles noted her thanks and support for the recommendations but suggested that all those who had contributed the budget review group discussion be referenced within the report in the future.
Said3 Feb 2026Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny Work Plan
Councillor Miles suggested that the report be framed around commissioning and payment channels. The Scrutiny and Governance Advisor committed to taking away the suggestions and discussing the feasibility of the suggestions with relevant officers. The Chair emphasised the importance of the topic with consideration of Local Government Reorganisation and the potential responsibilities that a new unitary authority could take on for highways management.
Said26 Jan 2026Council
Urgent Key Decisions Since July 2025
Councillor Miles noted that at Scrutiny Committee meetings last year, members had recognised a growing trend towards urgent key decisions.
Declared19 Jan 2026General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Declarations of Interest
The Chair, Councillor Ottino, and Councillor Miles declared awareness of representations that had been submitted in relation to items 5 and 6, but confirmed that due to late submission, these would not be considered. All Sub-Committee members committed to proceeding with an open mind.
Named13 Jan 2026Scrutiny Committee
Declarations of interest
The Chair, Councillor Miles, Councillor Stares, and Councillor Rowley noted having received emails from those speaking at this meeting.
Named13 Jan 2026Scrutiny Committee
Workforce Report 2025
Councillor Miles firstly queried whether the positive progress against ethnic minorities targets meant that it could be increased to encourage further improvement, and secondly whether anything could be done to encourage men to opt for flexible working to promote more gender equality.
Asked13 Jan 2026Scrutiny Committee
Workforce Report 2025
Councillor Miles also asked whether action could be taken to ensure those who have the necessary skillsets, are not automatically locked onto lower pay brackets when recruited, specifically in reference to skills learned from informal employment.
Named13 Jan 2026Scrutiny Committee
Workforce Report 2025
Finally, Councillor Miles whether data is disaggregated according to those who live within Oxford, and outside of the city, and whether more data on youth employment could be presented.
Named13 Jan 2026Scrutiny Committee
Local Plan 2045
Councillor Miles firstly queried whether the Local Plan considers the density of hot food takeaways in district centres, specifically possible maximum limits; Manchester was referred to as an example.
Named13 Jan 2026Scrutiny Committee
Local Plan 2045
Specifically, Councillor Miles considered the proximity of these retail units to schools.
Asked13 Jan 2026Scrutiny Committee
Local Plan 2045
Secondly, Councillor Miles asked whether play for children has been considered within the plan, and finally, it was asked whether remerging subdivided dwellings (previously altered for caring reasons) will be considered in respect of the challenges posed to reconfiguring buildings at later points.
Named13 Jan 2026Scrutiny Committee
Local Plan 2045
The Planning Policy Team Leader (SH), in response to Councillor Miles, clarified that policy C1 does restrict hot food takeaways in line with the NPPF, which, whilst allowing different approaches to be used, requires they be justified with evidence. In the case of Oxford, the Committee heard that sufficient evidence had not been found to deviate from the NPPF. In reference to play for children, the Planning Policy Team Leader (ND) noted policies C2, G1 and G2, which generally seek to protect green spaces and open spaces which can be used for play.
Named12 Jan 2026Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Upton proposed Councillor Miles as Chair for the meeting;
Named12 Jan 2026Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Miles was elected as the Chair.?? ? ?
Asked2 Dec 2025Scrutiny Committee
Authority Monitoring Report and Infrastructure Funding Statement 2024/25
Councillor Miles queried the reference to a land supply of 2.8 years in the report and requested a simplified explanation of its meaning.
Said2 Dec 2025Scrutiny Committee
Authority Monitoring Report and Infrastructure Funding Statement 2024/25
Councillor Miles also requested expanded information on the complex set of reasons relating to why housing targets had not been met.
Named2 Dec 2025Scrutiny Committee
Authority Monitoring Report and Infrastructure Funding Statement 2024/25
In response to Councillor Miles, the Planning Policy and Place Manager explained that when compiling the data, it became evident that there had been a downturn in housing delivery. The Committee heard of a range of reasons that could be contributing, however were also informed that no singular reason could be entirely responsible; instead, the downturn is the result of a complex matrix of interlinked factors including market conditions, for example. The Planning Policy and Place Manager emphasised that officers are working to make sense of these factors in order to support housing delivery.
Asked2 Dec 2025Scrutiny Committee
Authority Monitoring Report and Infrastructure Funding Statement 2024/25
In reference to her previous question, Councillor Miles also asked whether some of the reasons for the downturn in housing completion may be within the Council’s control.
Named2 Dec 2025Scrutiny Committee
Authority Monitoring Report and Infrastructure Funding Statement 2024/25
In response to Councillor Miles, Councillor Hollingsworth noted issues relating to the block on development relating to the Environment Agency’s concerns about Thames Water’s infrastructure, which has now been resolved, and section 106 agreement delays due to third-party decisions and actions. It was also emphasised that these issues are not unique to Oxford and are largely out of the Council’s control. Other external influences including inflation in the cost of construction materials due to the Russian invasion of Ukraine were listed.
Asked2 Dec 2025Scrutiny Committee
Devolution
Councillor Miles queried why Swindon is included within the proposal for a Thames Valley Mayoral Strategic Authority, noting that its identity fits more neatly with west country regions.
Asked24 Nov 2025Council
HRA Policies
Councillor Miles asked whether data is available which demonstrates the proportion of housing stock, specifically flats, where bike parking is provided. If note, it was asked that this data gap be filled to ensure targeted provision of required facilities.
Said24 Nov 2025Council
Recommendation from the Standards Committee to censure Councillor Malik
Councillor Miles commented that as a woman in politics, she acknowledged Councillor Arshad’s comments. Upon being put to a vote, the recommendation was agreed. Council resolved to: Censure?
Asked24 Nov 2025Council
Questions on Cabinet minutes
Minutes of the Cabinet meeting held on 22 October 2025 Councillor Miles asked how Cabinet is reconciling the inconsistencies within the draft of the Air Quality Action Plan which is framed around transport initiatives of the County Council that it publicly does not support.
Said24 Nov 2025Council
Questions on Cabinet minutes
Councillor Miles also requested clarification on the level of compliance under the existing regime of HMO licensing and what is being done to manage noncompliance.
Seconded24 Nov 2025Council
Motions on notice November 2025
Better use of Oxpens Bridge Funding (proposed by Cllr Jupp, seconded by Cllr Miles) 18e. A World-Class Multi-Modal Transport Hub for Oxford Station (Proposed by Cllr. Lois Muddiman, Seconded by Cllr.
Said11 Nov 2025Scrutiny Committee
Declarations of interest
Councillor Ottino and Councillor Miles noted their membership of the General Purposes Licensing Committee and their involvement in previous discussions relating to the report being considered at this meeting.
Asked11 Nov 2025Scrutiny Committee
Hackney Carriage Vehicle Emission Standards Amendment
Councillor Miles queried how the responsibilities of the General Purposes Licensing Committee may be impacted by these changes and asked whether these would apply to all licensing functions, or only taxi licensing.
Said11 Nov 2025Scrutiny Committee
Hackney Carriage Vehicle Emission Standards Amendment
Councillor Miles expressed concern regarding the process of the decision taken at the last meeting of the General Purposes Licensing Committee. The Monitoring Officer clarified that each area of licensing has its own legislation, and the matters discussed during this meeting would apply only to taxi licensing.
Said14 Oct 2025Scrutiny Committee
Project Approval and Delegations for Westlands Drive and Halliday Hill affordable housing scheme
Councillor Miles requested clarification between the distinction of ‘low car development’ and ‘car free development’ referenced in the report. The Affordable Housing Supply Corporate Lead noted that only a small number of parking spaces had been designed into the scheme and committed to providing relevant data following the meeting.
Asked14 Oct 2025Scrutiny Committee
Project Approval and Delegations for Westlands Drive and Halliday Hill affordable housing scheme
Councillor Miles also asked what provision there would be for resident bike parking, recommending that this be considered from the start of the scheme, rather than built in at a later date . The Affordable Housing Supply Corporate Lead noted confidence that bike spaces had been included within the plans and committed to providing this information following the meeting.
Asked14 Oct 2025Scrutiny Committee
Annual Safeguarding Report
Councillor Miles queried the data relating to heat alerts and emergency accommodation to ask whether some data could be made available to enable comparisons of this over time. She also queried whether this could be linked to the budget that the Council makes available. Secondly, it was asked whether any ward specific data was available in relation to youth ambition interventions to demonstrate where these are occurring.
Said14 Oct 2025Scrutiny Committee
Annual Safeguarding Report
Finaly, Councillor Miles noted concern with issues being passed between County and City Council and therefore asked whether officers are aware of any feedback loops.
Said14 Oct 2025Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny Work Plan
Councillor Miles noted that the General Purposes Licensing Committee had considered these issues recently, and therefore recommended that a briefing, as opposed to formal report, may be more useful.
Named14 Oct 2025Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny Work Plan
The Chair, Councillor Miles, Councillor Altaf-Khan , and Councillor Ottino debated this matter.
Named13 Oct 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Rehman proposed Councillor Miles as Chair; Councillor Ottino seconded.
Named13 Oct 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Miles was elected as chair for the duration of this hearing.
Seconded6 Oct 2025Council
Motions on Notice October 2025
c) Bring Thames Water into public ownership (Proposed by Councillor Mundy, Seconded by Councillor Djafari-Marbini ) d) Keep Oxford Open (Proposed by Councillor Goddard, Seconded by Councillor Smowton) e) Better use of Oxpens Bridge Funding (Proposed by Councillor Jupp, Seconded by Councillor Miles)
Moved29 Sep 2025General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Election of a Chair
Councillor Miles proposed Councillor Jupp as Chair; Councillor Ottino seconded.
Named29 Sep 2025General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Declarations of Interest
Councillor Miles and Councillor Jupp declared that they are councillors for Summertown, the ward area in which the applicant regularly trades.
Said22 Sep 2025General Purposes Licensing Committee
Declarations of interest
Councillor Miles noted that she had spoken with members of COLTA socially at an Oxford City Council Christmas event but noted that they had not discussed the policy being considered at this meeting.
Said22 Sep 2025General Purposes Licensing Committee
Declarations of interest
Councillor Miles also confirmed that she would be attending this meeting with a with a fair and open mind.
Asked22 Sep 2025General Purposes Licensing Committee
Hackney Carriage Vehicle Emission Standards Amendment
Councillor Miles sought to clarify whether urban and rural variations have led to the difference in vehicle types available, or whether other root causes were responsible. The Licensing Team Manger explained that different policies exist between different authorities as variable devolution of powers to councils over many years has created discrepancies, alongside the requirements for councils to respond to varying local needs. In the case of Oxford specifically, the Committee heard that the Licensing Authority has been ahead of the rising national standards required and has therefore had to make fewer changes that other authorities.
Said22 Sep 2025General Purposes Licensing Committee
Hackney Carriage Vehicle Emission Standards Amendment
Councillor Miles noted a reference within COLTA’s submission included in the report to attempts to de-regulate the Hackney trade and commented on the cap to the number of Hackney Carriages which Oxford facilitates.
Said22 Sep 2025General Purposes Licensing Committee
Hackney Carriage Vehicle Emission Standards Amendment
Councillor Miles expressed the view that Hackney Carriages are preferable for the easy wheelchair accessibility they provide and asked therefore, what the time frame for this proposed de-regulation is. The Licensing Team Manager confirmed that the report was withdrawn due to the need for more consultation to inform the recommendations it made. Since this took place, the state of the trade has changed significantly, including an increase in the private hire trade, and therefore the report will likely be brought forward again once more information is available following this period of change.
Said9 Sep 2025Scrutiny Committee
Citizen and Community Engagement Policy 2025
Councillor Miles noted that the Scrutiny Committee had previously provided feedback on ensuring inclusive engagement by considering different languages, and therefore asked how resource allocation is determined for this provision.
Said9 Sep 2025Scrutiny Committee
Budget Review Group Scope
Councillor Miles emphasised the issue of the Council’s Environmental Health receiving decreasing budget, despites increasing pressures and recognising the Council’s statutory responsibilities. It was proposed that this be highlighted as a specific focus area during the budget review. The Chair suggested this be inserted into the scope.
Named9 Sep 2025Scrutiny Committee
Budget Review Group Scope
Councillor Miles and Councillor Ottino discussed the requirement to mention statutory responsibilities within the scope.
Moved9 Sep 2025Scrutiny Committee
Budget Review Group Scope
Councillor Miles proposed the amendment; Councillor Ottino seconded. The Committee unanimously voted in favour.
Seconded9 Sep 2025Scrutiny Committee
Budget Review Group Scope
Approve the Terms of Reference for the Budget Review Group The Chair proposed, and Councillor Miles seconded this. The Committee unanimously voted in favour.
Said9 Sep 2025Scrutiny Committee
Endorsement of Recommendations from Working Groups
Councillor Miles presented the recommendations made by the Climate and Environment Working Group and noted the matters discussed, as set out in the report.
Named9 Sep 2025Scrutiny Committee
Endorsement of Recommendations from Working Groups
Councillor Miles detailed the partnership model that is taking shape to include the off-takers of the network in the city, including Oxford City Council.
Named9 Sep 2025Scrutiny Committee
Endorsement of Recommendations from Working Groups
Councillor Miles provided further details around the progress of securing funding partners for the project.
Said14 Jul 2025Council
Annual Scrutiny Report 2024-2025
Councillor Miles, Chair of the Scrutiny Committee 2024-2025, presented the report, noting that the Committee’s discussions took place across a challenging landscape in the last year which further emphasised the importance of the scrutiny function and its delicate balance.
Said14 Jul 2025Council
Annual Scrutiny Report 2024-2025
Councillor Miles noted that members of the Committee were encouraged that its views were embraced, and its role valued, and she noted her happiness that, despite political differences, members united and worked towards shared goals and values.
Said14 Jul 2025Council
Annual Scrutiny Report 2024-2025
Councillor Miles thanked officers and members and handed over to Councillor Powell as the new chair of the Scrutiny Committee. Council resolved to note the update report.
Moved14 Jul 2025Council
Motions on notice July 2025
b) Ban Smartphones in Oxford Schools (Proposed by Councillor Katherine Miles, Seconded by Councillor Andrew Gant) c) Protecting trans peoples’ access to services (Proposed by Councillor Alex Powell, Seconded by Councillor Chris Jarvis) d) Keep Oxfordshire’s street lights on (Proposed by Councillor Susan Brown, Seconded by Councillor Lubna Arshad) e) Environmental Protections in the Planning and Infrastructure Bill (Proposed by Councillor Andrew Gant, Seconded by Councillor Chris Smowton)
Named3 Jul 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Ottino proposed Councillor Miles as Chair for the meeting; Councillor Rawle seconded.
Named3 Jul 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Miles was elected as Chair for the duration of the meeting.
Named1 Jul 2025Scrutiny Committee
Work Plan and Forward Plan
Councillor Miles reflected on previous discussions at the Scrutiny Committee and suggested that members could focus on lessons learned to inform future projects. Upon a vote, the Committee voted in favour of adding the report to Scrutiny agenda for discussion at the meeting in August.
Said1 Jul 2025Scrutiny Committee
Work Plan and Forward Plan
Councillor Miles suggested that the Committee consider capacity constraints on the Council’s environmental health team following discussion within Licensing Committees. The Chair supported the suggestion. The Committee: Confirmed its agreement to the Work Plan, or agree any amendments as required.
Named30 Jun 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Ottino proposed Councillor Miles as Chair for the meeting; Councillor Rehman seconded.
Named30 Jun 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Miles was elected as Chair for the duration of the meeting.
Moved10 Jun 2025Scrutiny Committee
Election of Chair for the Council Year 2025/26
Councillor Miles proposed, and Councillor Jarvis seconded the nomination of Councillor Powell to be elected as Chair of the Committee for 2025/26.?? No further nominations were received.
Said10 Jun 2025Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny Operating Principles 2025/26
Councillor Miles noted feedback that the Housing and Homelessness working group often focuses on financial information and therefore asked whether some of the content could be reassigned within the scope of the Finance and Performance working group going forward to manage workload and ensure due attention is given to the matter of homelessness. The Chair committed to taking account of this when considering the terms of reference. The Chair proposed to consider the recommendations in the report.
Said10 Jun 2025Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny Operating Principles 2025/26
Councillor Miles noted her concern about the assignment of work to the Housing and Homelessness working group but did not propose a formal alteration to the recommendation. The Scrutiny and Governance Advisor clarified that the Committee has the power to delegate work to the working groups and to alter plans.
Asked10 Jun 2025Scrutiny Committee
Oxford Local Plan 2042 Regulation 18 Consultation Document
Councillor Miles asked several questions: In relation to categories noted within the report which have experienced no change since the last Local Plan, it was asked whether reflection has been made on the policy coherence of matters such as bike parking and demand for bike parking against other council policies. In regard self-build, whether the six-month period noted in the report could be extended to support people taking time to secure funding. In relation to specialist accommodation for elderly persons and those with dementia, for example, how is the appropriate size of rooms defined.
Named10 Jun 2025Scrutiny Committee
Oxford Local Plan 2042 Regulation 18 Consultation Document
Councillor Hollingsworth reminded Councillor Miles that the report only outlines the consultation stage proposals for the Local Plan. In regards self-build, that there can be difficulties around financing was acknowledged, but it was explained that the Council’s plan must respond to the housing shortage and must avoid leaving sites vacant for longer than necessary.
Named10 Jun 2025Scrutiny Committee
Oxford Local Plan 2042 Regulation 18 Consultation Document
In regards specialist accommodation, Councillor Miles understood that attempts to consider this within the last local plan were thrown out by the planning inspector.
Moved21 May 2025General Purposes Licensing Committee
Election of Chair for Council Year 2025-2026
Councillor Miles proposed, and Councillor Mundy seconded the nomination of Councillor Muddiman to be elected as Chair of the Committee for 2025/26.
Moved21 May 2025General Purposes Licensing Committee
Election of Vice-Chair for Council Year 2025-2026
Councillor Miles proposed, and Councillor Mundy seconded the nomination of Councillor Rehman to be elected as Vice-Chair of the Committee for 2025/26.
Named21 May 2025Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Election of Chair for Council Year 2025-2026
Councillor Sandelson proposed, and Councillor Jupp seconded the nomination of Councillor Miles to be elected as Chair of the Committee for 2025/26.
Named21 May 2025Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Election of Chair for Council Year 2025-2026
The two nominations were put to the vote and by 8 votes to 6, the Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee resolved that Councillor Miles be elected as the Chair for 2025/26.
Named19 May 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Ottino proposed Councillor Miles as Chair; Councillor Jupp seconded.
Named19 May 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Miles was elected as chair for the duration of this hearing.
Moved15 May 2025Council
Appointment of Sheriff for the Council Year 2025/2026
Councillor Miles moved, and Councillor Kerr seconded, that Councillor Andrew Gant be appointed Sheriff for the 2025/26 Council Year.
Said9 Apr 2025Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles presented the reports from Scrutiny Committee.
Said9 Apr 2025Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles presented the Scrutiny Committee’s discussions and recommendations relating to the the Anti-Social Behaviour Policy Update.
Said9 Apr 2025Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles presented the Scrutiny Committee’s discussions and recommendation regarding the Urgent Key Decisions End-of-Year Update.
Said9 Apr 2025Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles presented the Climate and Environment Panel’s discussions and recommendations regarding the Energy Efficiency Update, the Carbon Offsetting (Local Carbon Oxford) Update, and the Zero Carbon Industrial Decarbonisation Update.
Said9 Apr 2025Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles noted that the Panel had made no recommendations on the Zero Carbon Industrial Decarbonisation Update.
Asked27 Mar 2025Climate and Environment Panel (Panel of the Scrutiny Committee)
Energy Efficiency Update
Councillor Miles asked to what extent issues raised by the national press had affected insultation works in this programme. The Energy Efficiency Officer responded that they were not aware of how many problems occurred and reassured them that it was being managed. She also mentioned that there had been no issues in Oxford and they did not expect any.
Said27 Mar 2025Climate and Environment Panel (Panel of the Scrutiny Committee)
Energy Efficiency Update
Councillor Miles suggested it would be helpful for the demand exercise to explore the breakdown of types of entities and properties installing heat pumps, whether they were businesses or residential owners. She also asked for clarification on who needed to go through planning for air source heat pumps and who required approval to install them. The Energy Efficiency Officer clarified that most air source heat pumps could be installed under permitted development.
Said27 Mar 2025Climate and Environment Panel (Panel of the Scrutiny Committee)
Energy Efficiency Update
Councillor Miles then raised the issue of potential noise complaints and asked whether there was any work being done to assess how this might impact neighbourhoods and mitigate cumulative effects on residents. The Energy Efficiency Officer confirmed that this had been discussed, and the Environmental Sustainability Manager mentioned that a study by local government had been conducted, which she would circulate to Members.
Asked27 Mar 2025Climate and Environment Panel (Panel of the Scrutiny Committee)
Zero Carbon Industrial Decarbonisation Update
Councillor Miles then asked the diversity of attendees at the stakeholder workshops, specifically whether people from various age groups had participated and if there had been good engagement across different groups. The Net Zero Transition Project Manager said that overall there was a good level of engagement. A lot of effort had been made to reach out to different organisations to attend the workshops, but she wasn’t sure about the specific breakdown of which individuals the organisations had sent.
Asked24 Mar 2025Council
Draft Minutes of the Cabinet Meeting held on 12 March 2025
In relation to item 14 of the minutes, Councillor Miles asked whether the Council has conducted any analysis of savings and efficiency for the three unitary proposals in relation to devolution.
Named24 Mar 2025Council
Scrutiny Committee update report
Councillor Miles provided Council an update on the work of the Scrutiny Committee and its panels in the period from 29 January 2025 to 3 March 2025 during which the Scrutiny Committee had met twice, and each of the three panels had met once.
Said24 Mar 2025Council
Scrutiny Committee update report
Councillor Miles thanked all officers and councillors for their presentations, recommendations, and responses.
Said12 Mar 2025Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles presented the reports from Scrutiny Committee.
Said12 Mar 2025Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles presented the Scrutiny Committee’s discussions relating to the Oxford City Council Annual Business Plan 2025 – 2026.
Said12 Mar 2025Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles presented the Scrutiny Committee’s discussions regarding the update report on Adult Exploitation and Modern Slavery.
Said12 Mar 2025Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles presented t he Climate and Environment Panel’s discussions concerning the Net-Zero Masterplan. She congratulated the work that had been done already in this area.
Said12 Mar 2025Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles presented t he Climate and Environment Panel’s discussions concerning the Update and Overview of the Work of the Waste Review.
Said12 Mar 2025Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles presented t he Climate and Environment Panel’s discussions concerning the Heat Networks and Zoning.
Said12 Mar 2025Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles presented the Housing and Homelessness Panel discussions concerning the Selective Licensing Implementation Update – Year 2.
Said12 Mar 2025Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles presented the Housing and Homelessness Panel discussions concerning the Housing Ombudsman Complaint Handling ... view the full minutes text for item 135.
Asked26 Feb 2025Climate and Environment Panel (Panel of the Scrutiny Committee)
Net Zero Masterplan Update
Councillor Miles queried whether data on SMEs and those receiving training is gathered to ensure women owned businesses are accessing the support, and gender gaps are being addressed. The Environmental Sustainability Lead noted that she expected the data to be available and committed to reporting back. The Environmental Sustainability Lead also explained that there is a focus on surveying and strategising for decarbonisation of the housing stock and noted that the 5-year plan is in place.
Named26 Feb 2025Climate and Environment Panel (Panel of the Scrutiny Committee)
Net Zero Masterplan Update
Councillor Miles recognised the presence of the leaflets but asked whether uptake comes from a broad range of people, or whether there is a lack of interest from some ... view the full minutes text for item 36.
Named26 Feb 2025Climate and Environment Panel (Panel of the Scrutiny Committee)
Update and overview of work on the Waste Review
Councillor Miles focused on the evidence base and impacts, asking if students will be considered in the context of waste management issues and whether in terms of demand, there is consideration being taken for those who do not pay council tax. She noted the growing issues caused by densification. The Head of Corporate Strategy recognised the perennial issues with student’s actions around waste disposal, noting that the Council does engage with ODS and the universities on this matter.
Said5 Feb 2025Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles presented the ... view the full minutes text for item 115.
Asked27 Jan 2025Council
Minutes of the Cabinet Meeting held on 11 December 2024
Councillor Miles inquired why North Oxford was not part of the CPZ review.
Said27 Jan 2025Council
Outside Organisation Report: OxLEP and Skills Board
Councillor Miles pointed out the absence of disaggregated data, emphasising the importance of diversity when discussing the economic empowerment of different groups. She noted that the City Council values diversity, and as representatives of Scrutiny, they’ve raised concerns about the need for better collection and reporting of disaggregated data. She expressed hope that data on economic participation rates, apprenticeships and other relevant factors would be broken down based on key characteristics.
Said27 Jan 2025Council
Scrutiny Committee update report
Councillor Miles, The Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, introduced the report. She outlined that the reporting period was from 1 October 2024 to 14 January 2025. During this time, the Committee held five panel meetings and made 32 recommendations to Cabinet.
Named27 Jan 2025Council
Scrutiny Committee update report
Councillor Miles drew attention to two urgent recommendations. The first was that Cabinet supported the continued implementation and embedding of actions proposed to mitigate the increased number of urgent key decisions taken. The second was that officers ensured an end of year report was submitted to Scrutiny Committee, detailing the number of key decisions taken, including data to track trends and evaluate distinctions between capacity related issues.
Said22 Jan 2025Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles presented reports from the Scrutiny Committee.
Said22 Jan 2025Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles presented the measures and objectives that were discussed relating to the Council of Sanctuary Framework. She noted that the Scrutiny Committee and discussed queries around data protection. The Scrutiny Committee also discussed problems related to the learning of English and the anti-migrant violence which had emerged since the report was drafted.
Said22 Jan 2025Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles presented the following recommendations related to this report.
Said22 Jan 2025Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles presented the Scrutiny Committee consideration of the HRA Rent Setting Report 2025/26. She stated that the Committee had discussed the rationale behind the percentage increase in garages and concerns around the need for more dynamic pricing.
Said22 Jan 2025Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles said that the Scrutiny Committee had also debated whether they need to consider the impact of rental price changes in the private rental market when adjusting council housing rent prices.
Said22 Jan 2025Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles presented the Scrutiny Committee recommendations relating to this report.
Said11 Dec 2024Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles presented reports from the Scrutiny Committee.
Said11 Dec 2024Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles pointed to the recommendations in the pack and Councillor Brown confirmed that all had been agreed.
Named11 Dec 2024Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
On the second recommendation, she assured Councillor Miles that engagement with universities already takes place to encourage them to facilitate student ho u sing on their own land ; l ittle more c an be done. The Climate and Environment Panel convened on 20 November 2024 to discuss updates around the UK Moorings Project and the deliverability of solar opportunities in C ouncil car parks.
Named25 Nov 2024Council
Minutes of the Cabinet Meeting held on 16th October 2024
Councillor Miles mentioned the lessons that had been learnt with relation to Foxwell Drive. She said that they had had a Scrutiny meeting where this was discussed. Out of this, she mentioned that there is an opportunity for Cabinet to invite members from the opposition, who may be relevant for a particular decision, to come to the relevant Cabinet meeting.
Named25 Nov 2024Council
Minutes of the Cabinet Meeting held on 16th October 2024
She stated that she would be happy to discuss this further with Councillor Miles following the meeting.
Moved25 Nov 2024Council
Petition submitted in accordance with Council procedure rules - Establish a Children's Playground in Oxford City Centre
Councillor Miles proposed that the Council, agree in principle, that they develop a children’s play area in the city centre. She said that they are aware that children and residents want this to be introduced to the city. She stated that having a place for children to play would benefit the city and the families that visit the centre of Oxford.
Asked20 Nov 2024Climate and Environment Panel (Panel of the Scrutiny Committee)
Net Zero Masterplan
Councillor Miles asked whether challenges in ecologist resourcing were specific to Oxford or part of a broader issue. The Environmental Sustainability Lead acknowledged it was a wider challenge but noted that solutions were currently actively being explored. The Panel noted the report; there were no recommendations .
Asked20 Nov 2024Climate and Environment Panel (Panel of the Scrutiny Committee)
Eco-moorings Project Update [presentation]
Councillor Miles asked about communication plans for residents and the involvement of ward members in the project’s progression. The Principal Air Quality Officer shared that communication plans were being finalized, including the creation of a dedicated page on the Council’s website to provide comprehensive information about the eco-moorings project.
Said20 Nov 2024Climate and Environment Panel (Panel of the Scrutiny Committee)
Eco-moorings Project Update [presentation]
Councillor Miles emphasized the importance of engaging diverse segments of the boating community to understand their varied energy needs, suggesting the use of focus groups for this purpose.
Asked20 Nov 2024Climate and Environment Panel (Panel of the Scrutiny Committee)
High-level challenges and constraints impacting on the deliverability of solar opportunities at Council car parks
Councillor Miles asked for clarification on which car parks were owned or managed by the City Council and whether they met the scheme's criteria. It was noted that Redbridge and Seacourt Park and Ride were City Council-owned, while others, such as Peartree, was leased, and Oxford Parkway and Thornhill managed on behalf of the County Council. The Panel recommended updating the report to include a comprehensive list of City Council-owned car parks that meet the viability criteria for the scheme .
Named20 Nov 2024Climate and Environment Panel (Panel of the Scrutiny Committee)
High-level challenges and constraints impacting on the deliverability of solar opportunities at Council car parks
Councillor Miles also about the exploration of alternative uses for car parks. The Head of Corporate Strategy cited examples such as the EV charging hub at Redbridge and the redevelopment plans for Oxpens . The Panel supported progressing with feasibility assessments to identify alternative revenue-generating opportunities while ensuring alignment with the Council's sustainability goals.
Asked20 Nov 2024Climate and Environment Panel (Panel of the Scrutiny Committee)
Local Nature Recovery Strategy
Councillor Miles inquired about how geographies within Oxford were identified and whether this process would guide district councils. The Principal Flood Mitigation and Environmental Quality Team Leader explained that the work represented a high-level review and involved collaboration with stakeholders. The Project Manager added that a public consultation was underway to further inform the Strategy and pinpoint areas with biodiversity potential in Oxfordshire.
Said20 Nov 2024Climate and Environment Panel (Panel of the Scrutiny Committee)
Climate and Environment Panel Work Plan
Councillor Miles suggested that Climate Adaptation Plans, with a focus on mitigation, could be brought to the Panel for review. It was noted that this project, led by Oxfordshire County Council, would be added to the Panel’s Work Plan for discussion in February.
Said18 Nov 2024Scrutiny Committee
Declarations of interest
Cllr Miles stated that she had supported the call-in of the Cabinet decision relating to the disposal of land at Foxwell Drive, and indicated she made the declaration for reasons of transparency.
Said13 Nov 2024Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles presented the reports from Scrutiny. She referred to two Scrutiny meetings, one on the 4 th of November which looked at an update on the city’s river charter, the Council’s engagement with Thames Water, and a leisure update.
Said13 Nov 2024Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles said that in the meeting, they discussed the responsibilities of different agencies, legislative gaps at a national level regarding environmental protection, and the impact of deregulation on water companies.
Said13 Nov 2024Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles said that they discussed the topic of domestic misconnections, as an area that falls under the Council’s responsibility. Issues were also raised about storm water run off and river pollution. Across all of these topics, was the need for meaningful engagement with stakeholders and work to ensure that residents’ concerns are adequately addressed.
Said13 Nov 2024Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles said that there were three recommendations from the first item. They were:
Said13 Nov 2024Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles then presented the leisure update report from Scrutiny. She said that committee had asked questions about the new contract’s progression and received reassurance regarding improvements made by the new leisure supplier. They also explored the topic of accountability for facility conditions, and how the new supplier is working to address inherited issues.
Said13 Nov 2024Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles said they received reassurances and were happy with the outcome of their meeting. From this report they recommended:
Said6 Nov 2024Shareholder and Joint Venture Group
Scrutiny comments and/or recommendations
Councillor Miles, on behalf of Scrutiny Committee, responded to questions from the SJVG.
Asked4 Nov 2024Scrutiny Committee
Update on the development of Oxford River Charter
Cllr Miles questioned the Council’s role in addressing domestic misconnections contributing to river pollution, particularly within Council-owned and housing association properties. The Head of Corporate Strategy responded that he was not aware of any Council enforcement responsibility.
Said4 Nov 2024Scrutiny Committee
Update on the development of Oxford River Charter
Cllr Miles suggested using Council influence to convene stakeholders on these impacts.
Asked4 Nov 2024Scrutiny Committee
Update on the development of Oxford River Charter
Cllr Miles asked about research or actions that could address domestic misconnections, seeking clarity on current or potential measures.
Said16 Oct 2024Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles presented the reports from Scrutiny. She said that they had discussed the LGA report and that the Scrutiny Committee would like to express gratitude for the work done on this. They asked questions on the LGA report regarding benchmarking in relation to ODS, clarification questions about the long term visions for the facilities in the town hall, and about how communities will be engaged in their regeneration plans.
Said16 Oct 2024Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles stated that on the Annual Air Quality report, Scrutiny had made the following recommendations:
Said16 Oct 2024Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles said that the Scrutiny Committee had been impressed with the work that had happened with air quality. In regard to the ZCOP Expansion Plans, Scrutiny Committee had made the following recommendation:
Said16 Oct 2024Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles noted that the Housing and Homelessness Panel had met on the 10 th of October, but not recommendations had resulted from this meeting.
Said16 Oct 2024Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Miles thanked the individuals who had attended the meeting.
Named16 Oct 2024Cabinet
Scrutiny Reports
Councillor Brown thanked Councillor Miles for the recommendations from Scrutiny Committee.
Asked8 Oct 2024Scrutiny Committee
Local Government Association Corporate Peer Review
Councillor Miles asked about the review of the Council-owned Companies.
Named8 Oct 2024Scrutiny Committee
Local Government Association Corporate Peer Review
Finally, Councillor Miles concluded with a review of the ongoing priorities for the Town Hall.
Said7 Oct 2024Council
Statement of Gambling Licensing Policy
Councillor Katherine Miles, Chair of the Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee, introduced the report and proposed the recommendation. She mentioned that the Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee had considered and agreed the revised Statement at its meeting on 23 September 2024. The revisions included updates to the Licensing Authority addresses, an amended map of Oxford reflecting new ward names and boundaries, and minor textual changes.
Said7 Oct 2024Council
Scrutiny Committee update report
Councillor Katherine Miles, Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, introduced the report updating the Council on the Committee's activities between 1 July 2024 and 30 September 2024. She thanked Alice Courtney for her work as Scrutiny Officer and welcomed Celeste Reyeslao as the new Scrutiny and Governance Advisor. She advised that the Scrutiny Committee and its Panels submitted 12 recommendations to Cabinet, of which 6 were accepted and 1 agreed in-part, and that the Budget Review Group and its scope for December 2024 to January 2025 had been agreed by the Committee.
Named30 Sep 2024Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Miles was elected Chair for this hearing.
Said15 Jul 2024Council
Annual Scrutiny Report 2023 - 24
Councillor Katherine Miles, Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, introduced the report updating the Council on the Committee's activities during the 2023/24 municipal year, and thanked Cllr Lucy Pegg for her contributions as Chair during that period. She advised that 142 recommendations had been submitted to Cabinet, of which 100 were agreed, 12 agreed in part, 17 not agreed, and 12 provided with commentary only. She conveyed the Committee's disappointment in some of the Cabinet responses that were not always aligned with the overall thrust of their recommendations.
Said15 Jul 2024Council
Scrutiny Committee update report
Councillor Katherine Miles, Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, introduced the report updating the Council on the activities of the Committee from 01 March 2024 to 30 June 2024. She highlighted work undertaken by the Committee, including the re-establishment of three standing panels, and the expanded remit of the Finance and Performance Panel, which replaced the previous Companies Scrutiny Panel. She welcomed the new Committee members and expressed her anticipation of working constructively with Cabinet Members, Councillors, and Officers.
Seconded15 Jul 2024Council
Motions on notice July 2024
a) Oxford United Stadium (proposed by Cllr Mark Clarkson, seconded by Cllr Ed Turner) b) Motion of No Confidence in Thames Water and development of an Oxford city river action plan (proposed by Cllr Jo Sandelson, seconded by Cllr Katherine Miles) [amendment proposed by Cllr Simon Ottino , seconded by Cllr Jarvis] Motions not taken as the time allocated for debate had finished:
Seconded15 Jul 2024Council
Motion of No Confidence in Thames Water and development of an Oxford city river action plan (proposed by Cllr Jo Sandelson, seconded by Cllr Katherine Miles) [amendment proposed by Cllr Simon Ottino, seconded by Cllr Jarvis]
Cllr Jo Sandelson, seconded by Cllr Katherine Miles, proposed the motion as set out in the briefing notes.
Named5 Jun 2024Scrutiny Committee
Election of Chair for the Council Year 2024/25
The Committee resolved to elect Councillor Katherine Miles as Chair for 2024/25.
Moved20 May 2024Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Election of Chair for Council Year 2024-25
Councillor Miles proposed and Councillor Muddiman seconded the nomination of Councillor Mundy to be elected as Chair of the Committee for 2024/25.
Named20 May 2024Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Election of Chair for Council Year 2024-25
Councillor Sandelson proposed and Councillor Mundy seconded the nomination of Councillor Miles to be elected as Chair of the Committee for 2024/25.
Named20 May 2024Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Election of Chair for Council Year 2024-25
The two nominations were put to the vote and by 7 votes to 6, the Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee resolved that Councillor Miles be elected as the Chair for 2024/25.
Moved20 May 2024General Purposes Licensing Committee
Appointment of Chair for the Council Year 2024-25
Councillor Miles proposed and Councillor Lygo seconded the nomination of Councillor Mundy to be elected as Chair of the Committee for 2024/25.
Named20 May 2024General Purposes Licensing Committee
Appointment of Sub-Committees
Sub-Committee A: Councillor Ed Mundy, Councillor Lois Muddiman, Councillor Simon Ottino Sub-Committee B: Councillor Mary Clarkson, Councillor Jo Sandelson, Councillor Ian Yeatman Sub-Committee C: Councillor Ed Mundy, Councillor Katherine Miles, Councillor Naomi Waite Sub-Committee D: Councillor Mary Clarkson, Councillor Max Morris, Councillor Theo Jupp Agree that substitution is permitted on each of the four Sub-Committees but that substitutes must be from the General Purposes Licensing Committee. S ubstitutes will be sought from the pool of members not appointed to any Sub-Committee before seeking substitutes from those already appointed, with a preference for ensuring diverse political group representation where possible.
Said27 Mar 2024Shareholder and Joint Venture Group
Scrutiny comments and/or recommendations
Cllr Katherine Miles, Companies Scrutiny Panel, advised the SJVG that a letter had been received from the Friends of Iffley Village relating to land at Meadow Lane, and as OX Place were not represented at this meeting, the letter had been forwarded to the Council’s Monitoring Officer.
Named25 Mar 2024General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the meeting
Councillor Katherine Miles was elected Chair for the meeting.
Seconded18 Mar 2024Council
Motions on notice 18 March 2024
b) Uniting to Tackle Oxford's Housing Crisis (proposed by Cllr Linda Smith, seconded by Cllr Nigel Chapman) c) In Support of Green Investment (proposed by Cllr Chris Smowton, seconded by Cllr Katherine Miles) d) Weight and emissions based parking charges (proposed by Cllr Chris Jarvis, seconded by Cllr Lois Muddiman) e) The Cost-of-living crisis and local government funding (proposed by Cllr Ed Turner, seconded by Cllr Nigel Chapman)
Moved21 Feb 2024Council
Medium Term Financial Strategy 2025/26 to 2026/27 and 2024/25 Budget
· An individual amendment proposed by Cllr Miles published with the briefing note.
Named21 Feb 2024Council
Individual amendments to the budget
Cllr Miles, seconded by Cllr Roz Smith moved their individual amendment.
Asked5 Feb 2024Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Licensing Act 2003 and Gambling Act 2005 Licensing and Gambling Acts Fees and Charges for the 2024/25 financial year
Councillor Katherine Miles queried whether there was scope for local authorities to write to central government to express concerns relating to certain fees set by legislation.
Named5 Feb 2024Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Licensing Act 2003 and Gambling Act 2005 Licensing and Gambling Acts Fees and Charges for the 2024/25 financial year
She thanked Councillor Miles for raising an important point.
Said5 Feb 2024General Purposes Licensing Committee
Commercial Events, Hackney Carriage and Private Hire, Road Closure Orders, Scrap Metal Dealers, Sex Establishments and Street Parties: Licence Fees and Charges for the 2024/25 financial year
Councillor Katherine Miles raised a question regarding school street closure for timed period. The Licensing Officer indicated that this matter was outside the remit of the authority as it fell under the responsibility and control of the County Council.
Moved5 Feb 2024General Purposes Licensing Committee
Miscellaneous Licensing: Fees and Charges for the 2023/24 financial year
Councillor Katherine Miles proposed an amendment to the pavement licence provision, suggesting the addition of a discretion to incentivise establishments committed to maintaining a smoke-free environment.
Named29 Jan 2024Council
Draft Minutes of the Cabinet Meeting held on 13 December 2023
Councillor Katherine Miles wished to put on record that this was the first Council meeting held where increased representations of women of significance to Oxford's political history were proudly displayed on the walls of the Council Chamber, reflective of the Council’s ethos. She congratulated the women represented in the photographs, as well as the Council on progressing its work equality, diversity and inclusion.
Said29 Jan 2024Council
Outside Organisation Report: Future Oxfordshire Partnership
Councillor Katherine Miles, Chair of the Future Oxfordshire Partnership Scrutiny Panel, spoke to expressed appreciation to Councillor Brown and FOP officers for their support in the work of the FOP Scrutiny Panel.
Named29 Jan 2024Council
Outside Organisation Report: Future Oxfordshire Partnership
Councillor Miles drew attention to some challenges of the panel, including delay in the availability of papers for adequate oversight, and an unclear expectation and scope of the panel’s responsibilities in relation to the partnership. It was clarified that these challenges had not stopped the collaborative work between the scrutiny panel and the partnership, however it was hoped they were improved moving into the next Council year.
Said29 Jan 2024Council
Outside Organisation Report: Future Oxfordshire Partnership
Councillor Brown acknowledged the concerns raised by Councillor Miles.
Seconded29 Jan 2024Council
Motions on notice 29 January 2024
The Cost of living crisis and local government funding (proposed by Cllr Ed Turner, seconded by Cllr Nigel Chapman). [Amendment proposed by Cllr Andrew Gant, seconded by Cllr Katherine MIles ] d.
Seconded29 Jan 2024Council
Motions on notice 29 January 2024
Scrap the two-child benefit cap (proposed by Cllr Christopher Smowton , seconded by Cllr Katherine Miles) e.
Named7 Dec 2023Shareholder and Joint Venture Group
Commentary on the ODS Shareholder Report [private]
Cllr Katherine Miles arrived at the meeting.
Said4 Dec 2023General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Any other business
Councillor Miles raised an item for consideration regarding the tests required for licence applicants and whether the assessments included material that highlight Road Safety in line with Vision Zero principles.
Named4 Dec 2023General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Any other business
Councillor Miles supported the inclusion of these principles in the current testing of applicants and licence holders which would mean focusing on their ability to share the road responsibly with other users such as cyclists, pedestrians and those utilising other sustainable commuting methods.
Named4 Dec 2023General Purposes Licensing Committee
Appointment of Sub-Committees
o Sub-Committee A: Cllr Lygo , Cllr Humberstone , Cllr Sandelson o Sub-Committee B: Cllr Clarkson, Cllr Hunt, Cllr Miles o Sub-Committee C: Cllr Lygo , Cllr Waite, Cllr Miles o Sub-Committee D: Cllr Clarkson, Cllr Hunt, and Cllr Smowton · Agree that substitution is permitted on each of the four sub-committees but that substitutes must be from the General Purposes Licensing Committee and must maintain political proportionality.
Named4 Dec 2023Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny Standing Panel and Review Group Arrangements
Cllr Chris Smowton; Cllr Chris Jarvis; Cllr Hosnieh Djafari-Marbini ; Cllr Amar Latif H ousing and H omelessness P anel: Cllr Lizzy Diggins (Chair); Cllr Mary Clarkson; Cllr Jo Sandelson; Cllr Rosie Rawle; Cllr Paula Dunne; Cllr Shaista Aziz C limate and E nvironment P anel: Cllr Alex Hollingsworth (Chair); Cllr James Fry; Cllr Katherine Miles; Cllr Emily Kerr; Cllr Paula Dunne; Cllr Shaista Aziz For the Companies Scrutiny Panel, the Oxford Socialist Independents Group did not wish to take up its allocation of a seat. It was therefore recommended that this Panel revert to a membership of 4 Members and the vacant seat be given over to the Independent Group, therefore the Panel would be comprised as follows:
Named4 Dec 2023Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny Standing Panel and Review Group Arrangements
· Cllr Mike Rowley (Chair), Cllr Katherine Miles, Cllr Alistair Morris and Cllr Ajaz Rehman The report proposed that the Scrutiny Operating Principles be updated to reflect the revised cross-party principle guide for appointments to Scrutiny Panels and Review Groups. The Scrutiny Officer proposed that the Operating Principles also be updated to provide clarity on membership in case a similar situation arose in the future where political groups might not want to take up their seat allocation on a particular Panel/Review group. The following wording was agreed, which the Committee requested that the Scrutiny Officer amend in the Operating Principles:
Named29 Nov 2023Climate and Environment Panel (Panel of the Scrutiny Committee)
Net Zero Masterplan
Cllr Katherine Miles left the meeting and did not return.
Moved27 Nov 2023Council
Motions on notice 27 November 2023
c) Back Oxford communities, Oxfam, and Oxford based medical workers, demanding immediate Gaza ceasefire (proposed by Shaista Aziz, seconded by Cllr Amar Latif) d) Peace in Israel and Palestine (proposed by Cllr Susan Brown, seconded by Cllr Anna Railton) e) Housing Management System problems and resultant accounts issues at Oxford City Council and ODS (proposed by Cllr Christopher Smowton, seconded by Cllr Laurence Fouweather ) [Amendment proposed by Cllr Nigel Chapman, seconded by Cllr Susan Brown] f) A Ban on Disposable Vapes (proposed by Cllr Lucy Pegg , seconded by Cllr Rosie Rawle) g) School Streets Initiative (proposed by Cllr Katherine Miles, seconded by Cllr Andrew Gant)
Named2 Oct 2023Council
Draft Minutes of the Cabinet meeting held on 13 September 2023
Minute 56 - Private Rented Sector Regulation Policies In response to a question from Councillor Katherine Miles, Councillor Linda Smith, Cabinet Member for Housing advised that additional legal advice was required to ascertain the feasibility of extending the assessment of the fit and proper criteria for holding an HMO or selective licence to encompass legal property ownership. A written response would be provided outside of the meeting.
Asked25 Sep 2023General Purposes Licensing Committee
Hackney Carriage Tariff Variation
Councillor Miles asked about carrying bicycles. [name removed] responded that these proposals ensured that drivers would continue to carry bicycles since the charge to carry a bicycle would encourage drivers to do so despite the inconvenience that is sometimes involved.
Asked25 Sep 2023General Purposes Licensing Committee
Hackney Carriage Tariff Variation
Councillor Miles asked a follow-up question regarding bike-racks to be added to the outside of the cabs. [name removed] noted that this would not be feasible with older-style cabs.
Asked25 Sep 2023General Purposes Licensing Committee
Miscellaneous Licensing Update Report
Councillor Miles queried the potential for bulk purchasing sustainable packaging to offer to traders, with the aim to lower costs for individual traders. The Business Regulations Team Manager acknowledged the idea, noting potential challenges. He advised that a written response would be provided outside of the meeting.
Named17 Jul 2023Council
Motions on notice 17 July 2023
a) Support Oxford’s Sudanese community – create safe pathways for Sudanese families with ties to Britain and Oxford to be granted the right to join their love ones here (proposer Cllr Aziz, seconder Cllr Djfari-Marbini ) b) Use car parking sites for Solar Farms (proposer Cllr Fouweather , seconder Cllr Miles, amendment proposer Cllr Railton, amendment seconder Cllr Hollingsworth) c) Extending the Smoke Control Area (proposer Cllr Kerr, seconder Cllr Pegg , amendment proposer Cllr Railton, amendment seconder Cllr Upton) d) Supporting a Community Right to Grow (proposer Cllr Hollingsworth, seconder Cllr Lygo ) Motions not taken as the time allocated for debate had finished:
Seconded17 Jul 2023Council
Use car parking sites for Solar Farms (proposed by Cllr Laurence Fouweather, seconded by Cllr Katherine Miles)
Cllr Fouweather , seconded by Cllr Miles, proposed the submitted motion as set out in the agenda and briefing note.
Named7 Jun 2023Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny Operating Principles 2023/24
o Housing and Homelessness Panel: Cllr Lizzy Diggins (Chair), Cllr Dunne, Cllr Fouweather, Cllr Nala-Hartley, Cllr Rawle, Cllr Sandelson o Finance and Performance Panel: Cllr Fry (Chair), Cllr Djafari-Marbini, Cllr Jarvis, Cllr Smowton o Climate and Environment Panel: Cllr Hollingsworth (Chair), Cllr Dunne, Cllr Kerr, Cllr Miles o Companies Scrutiny Panel: Cllr Rowley (Chair), Cllr Miles, Cllr Morris, Cllr Walcott 7. Agree that the Chair of the Finance and Performance Panel will Chair the Budget Review Group.
Named18 May 2023General Purposes Licensing Committee
Appointment of Sub-Committees
o Sub-Committee A: Cllr Mundy, Cllr Lygo, Cllr Sandelson o Sub-Committee B: Cllr Clarkson, Cllr Coyne, Cllr Miles o Sub-Committee C: Cllr Mundy, Cllr Waite, Cllr Miles o Sub-Committee D: Cllr Clarkson, Cllr Hunt, and Cllr Gant · Agree that substitution is permitted on each of the four sub-committees but that substitutes must be from the General Purposes Licensing Committee and must maintain political proportionality.
Said18 May 2023General Purposes Licensing Committee
Any other business
Cllr Miles raised a question on bike taxis .
Named20 Mar 2023Council
Motions on notice 20 March 2023
c) Use Car Parking Site for Solar Farms (proposer Cllr Fouweather, seconder Cllr Miles) d) Consultation on the Sale of Council Art Works (proposer Cllr Miles, seconder Cllr Smowton)
Named1 Feb 2023Scrutiny Committee
Chair's Announcements
· Cllr Miles to replace Cllr Landell-Mills on the Companies Scrutiny Panel.
Seconded30 Jan 2023Council
Motions on notice 30 January 2023
d) Use Park and Ride Parking Sites for Solar Farms (proposed by Cllr Fouweather , seconded by Cllr Miles, amendment proposer Cllr Railton , seconder Cllr Hollingsworth) e) Plant-based Food and Sustainable Farming (proposed by Cllr Dunne, seconded by Cllr Hollingsworth)
Named7 Nov 2022Scrutiny Committee
Climate and Environmental Panel
In response to the third recommendation above, the Committee were in agreement with the following membership; Cllr Katherine Miles, Cllr Emily Kerr, Cllr Jemima Hunt and Cllr Paula Dunne.
Moved18 Jul 2022Council
Motions on notice 18 July 2022
d) Sustainable Street Trading (proposer Cllr Miles, seconder Cllr Muddiman, moved without notice as per Constitution 11.19(d) proposed by Cllr Linda Smith, seconded by Cllr Hollingsworth) Motions not taken as the time allocated for debate had finished:
Named19 May 2022General Purposes Licensing Committee
Appointment of Sub-Committees
· Sub-Committee A: Cllr Mundy, Cllr Coyne, Cllr Miles · Sub-Committee B: Cllr Clarkson, Cllr Upton, Cllr Sandelson · Sub-Committee C: Cllr Mundy, Cllr Humberstone, Cllr Miles · Sub-Committee D: Cllr Clarkson, Cllr Lygo, Cllr Sandelson · Agree that substitution is permitted on each of the four sub-committees but that substitutes must be from the General Purposes Licensing Committee and must maintain political proportionality.
Said18 May 2022Council
Selective Licensing fees
Cllr Miles spoke on behalf of her colleagues in support of the scheme which she hoped would improve housing conditions for those in private rented accommodation in the city and looked forward to being able to scrutinise the success of this scheme.
Seconded21 Mar 2022Council
Motions on notice 21 March 2022
a) End Fire and Rehire (proposed by Cllr Mundy, seconded by Cllr Dunne) b) Opposition to the privatisation of the Vaccination Manufacturing and Innovation Centre (proposed by Cllr Jarvis, seconded by Cllr Pegg ) c) A Sanctuary Strategy for Oxford (proposed by Cllr Gant, seconded by Cllr Miles) Motion not taken as withdrawn before the meeting:
Seconded21 Mar 2022Council
A Sanctuary Strategy for Oxford (proposed by Cllr Gant, seconded by Cllr Miles)
Cllr Gant, seconded by Cllr Miles, proposed the submitted motion as set out in the agenda and briefing note.
Named31 Jan 2022Council
Motions on notice 31 January 2022
d) Opposition to the privatisation of the Vaccine Manufacturing and Innovation Centre (proposer Cllr Jarvis, seconder Cllr Pegg) e) End Fire and Rehire (proposer Cllr Mundy, seconder Cllr Dunne) f) Setting up a Drug Consumption Room (proposer Cllr Wade, seconder Cllr Miles) [amendment, proposer Cllr L Smith, seconder Cllr Mundy] g) EU Nationals deserve to be treated with respect (proposer Cllr Corais, seconder Cllr Bely-Summers)
Named29 Nov 2021Council
Draft minutes of meeting on Wednesday 10 November 2021 of Cabinet
Minute 64: Anti-social Behaviour Policy Cllr Smowton, on behalf of Cllr Miles, asked how the new policy would assist to local residents in regard to the problems, resulting from the behaviour of Oxford Brookes students.
Named29 Nov 2021Council
Motions on notice 29 November 2021
c) Noise Nuisance from Licensed Premises (proposer Cllr Gant on behalf of Cllr Miles, seconder Cllr Landell Mills) Motions not taken as the time allocated for debate had finished:
Moved29 Nov 2021Council
Noise Nuisance from Licensed Premises (proposed by Cllr Miles, seconded by Cllr Landell Mills)
Cllr Gant on behalf of Cllr Miles, seconded by Cllr Landell Mills, proposed the submitted motion as set out in the agenda and briefing note.
Said11 Nov 2021Planning Review Committee
Declarations of Interest
Councillor Miles stated that she was a member of Cyclox , an organisation which had commented on the application but that she had taken no part in the organisation’s discussions or decision making regarding the application before the Committee. She said that she was approaching the application with an open mind, would listen to all the arguments and weigh up all the relevant facts before coming to a decision.
Named26 Jul 2021Council
Motions on notice 26 July 2021
· DSS Discrimination (Cross-party motion: proposer Cllr Thomas, seconder Cllr Jarvis) · Short term lets (proposer Cllr Diggins, seconder Cllr Hunt) · East Oxford Low Traffic Neighbourhood (proposer Cllr Wolff, seconder Cllr Miles) Motion not taken as withdrawn before the meeting:
Seconded26 Jul 2021Council
East Oxford Low Traffic Neighbourhood
Cllr Wolff, seconded by Cllr Miles, proposed the original motion as published in the agenda and briefing note.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.