Said5 Oct 2026Council
Constitution Updates
Councillor Muddiman said that they opposed the national scheme of delegation. She said that this was an attempt to centralise planning applications and take power away from local people. She argued that communities would have less influence over developers and that these changes would increase communities concerns over planning developments.
Named5 Oct 2026Council
Constitution Updates
He supported the request from Councillor Muddiman for Councillor Brown to write to government about their concerns.
Said3 Sep 2026Council
Additional Funding for Community Improvement Measures
Councillor Muddiman welcomed the new investment, noting that it had been secured following collaborative cross-party negotiations. Council heard that the investment in public toilets was much needed and she welcomed sight of a more consistent plan for future updates and maintenance.
Said3 Sep 2026Council
Additional Funding for Community Improvement Measures
Councillor Muddiman also noted support for the investment into noticeboards and for street scene enhancements, including overnight storage for commercial waste. The appointment of a new scrutiny officer was praised.
Seconded27 Jul 2026Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Ottino proposed, and Councillor Muddiman seconded, Councillor Taylor as Chair.
Named23 Jun 2026Planning - Oxford City Planning Committee
23/00988/FUL Bertie Place Recreation Ground And Land South West of Wytham Street, Oxford
Councillor Muddiman and Kaddy Beck spoke against the application.
Named27 May 2026General Purposes Licensing Committee
Election of Chair for Council Year 2026-2027
Councillor Ottino proposed, and Councillor Miles seconded the nomination of Councillor Muddiman to be elected as Chair of the Committee for 2026/27. There were no further nominations.
Named27 May 2026General Purposes Licensing Committee
Election of Chair for Council Year 2026-2027
The General Purposes Licensing Committee resolved that Councillor Muddiman be elected as the Chair for 2026/27.
Said23 Mar 2026Council
Petition submitted in accordance with Council procedure rules - Save Our Museum
Councillor Muddiman noted her personal commitment to securing a sign from the Botley Road bridge for display at the museum. She expressed her hope that residents will be able to visit the exhibition for free and emphasised her belief that free entry to national museums should be ensured, as initially introduced by the Government in 2001. The impacts of the cost-of-living crisis on people’s ability to access cultural activities was noted and the importance of the walk-in principle was emphasised.
Said23 Mar 2026Council
Petition submitted in accordance with Council procedure rules - Save Our Museum
Councillor Muddiman informed Council that in December 2025, the Hodge review of the Arts Council England recommended that charging should only be enforced for international tourists when visiting museums; it should remain free for all UK residents.
Named23 Mar 2026Council
Better use of Oxpens Bridge Funding (Proposed by Cllr Jupp, Seconded by Cllr Miles)
Councillor Muddiman formally withdrew her amendment.
Said23 Feb 2026Council
Miscellaneous Licensing Fees and Charges for the financial year 2026/2027
Councillor Muddiman presented the report. She outlined the charges for street traders and the law dictating how they set these fees and charges. She said that although this was an increase, officers had assured them that this was a fair and reasonable increase.
Said23 Feb 2026Council
Hackney Carriage and Private Hire, Road Closure Orders, Scrap Metal Dealers, Sex Establishments Street Parties and Commercial Events: Licence Fees and Charges for the 2026/27 financial year
Councillor Muddiman presented the report. She said that there were no increases to charges to many licenses this year and that the increases for road closures were minimal. She thanked the licensing officers for their work.
Said9 Feb 2026Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Review of the Cumulative Impact Assessment and Special Saturation Policy
Councillor Muddiman requested data which had been updated since September 2025. The Senior Licensing Compliance Officer (KT) noted that since September, 14 new premises licenses had been issued, 8 of which were within the SSP areas. The Committee also heard that 1 was determined by a Sub-Committee, 9 were granted with agreed conditions, and 4 were granted as applied for; no applications had been refused in the period from September.
Asked9 Feb 2026Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Review of the Cumulative Impact Assessment and Special Saturation Policy
Councillor Muddiman asked whether data was available to compare the number of applications with and without the SSP for a similar duration of time.
Said9 Feb 2026Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Review of the Cumulative Impact Assessment and Special Saturation Policy
The Senior Licensing Compliance Officer (KT) clarified that the only data available for comparison was that of when the SSP was in place for the previously 3 years before it expired, Councillor Muddiman requested the officers’ view on whether there been an increase in the number of applications since the SSP expired, to which the Senior Licensing Compliance Officer (KT) noted the numbers of new applications having been steady and only a smaller number of variations to licenses having been requested.
Named5 Feb 2026Planning Review Committee
25/02702/FUL Unit 11 Kings Meadow
Coppe Van Urk, Councillor Muddiman and [name removed] spoke in favour of the application.
Seconded26 Jan 2026Council
Proposed Submission Draft Oxford Local Plan 2045
For the Green Group, Councillor Rawle, on being seconded by Councillor Muddiman, proposed an amendment as follows: amendment 3a, preventing the loss of playground space. In Policy G1, insert after “Planning permission will not be granted for development ... view the full minutes text for item 85.
Declared9 Dec 2025Planning - Oxford City Planning Committee
Declarations of interest
For 25/02702/FUL, Councillor Muddiman declared that she was pre-determined as she was speaking in favour of the application and would watch from the public gallery for this item.
Named11 Nov 2025Scrutiny Committee
Councillor addresses on any item for discussion on the Scrutiny agenda
Councillor Muddiman was not present at this stage to make her address.
Named11 Nov 2025Scrutiny Committee
Hackney Carriage Vehicle Emission Standards Amendment
Councillor Muddiman joined the meeting. The Chair clarified that the decision, on this occasion, is being taken to Cabinet due to time constraints, and that in the future, decisions on taxi licensing policy are expected to be ... view the full minutes text for item 66.
Asked3 Nov 2025General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Peripatetic Street Trading Application
Councillor Muddiman asked the Supervising Senior Licensing Officer if the applicant was expected to be on the street or pavement. The Supervising Senior Licensing Officer said that the applicant could either set up on the road or on the pavement unless restricted.
Asked3 Nov 2025General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Peripatetic Street Trading Application
Councillor Muddiman asked for clarification around employment. Lucy responded that it was Annabel’s business, and she was the registered sole trader with HMRC and that Lucy would only work with Annabel on a voluntary basis. Regarding Annabel’s 14-year-old sister, Lucy said would also work on a voluntary basis if permission was granted.
Asked22 Sep 2025Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Review of the Cumulative Impact Assessment and Special Saturation Policy
Councillor Muddiman sought to clarify how many applications had been refused within the SSP in the previous licensing period. The Supervising Senior Licensing Officer confirmed that 120 new or variation applications were received, of which 52 were located within the Special Saturation Policy (SSP) and 8 were referred to a Sub-Committee for determination. Of these 8, only one had been refused; therefore, 51 of the 52 applications received, which fell within the SSP area, had been granted.
Said9 Sep 2025Scrutiny Committee
Endorsement of Recommendations from Working Groups
Councillor Muddiman, who was also present at the meeting of the working group, outlined the public ownership of the infrastructure and the financial agreement which is being reached between the partners and contractor. It was emphasised that there is a desire to avoid the monopolisation of the project and its infrastructure.
Named5 Aug 2025Scrutiny Committee
Councillor addresses on any item for discussion on the Scrutiny agenda
The Committee heard one address from Councillor Muddiman.
Named5 Aug 2025Scrutiny Committee
Councillor addresses on any item for discussion on the Scrutiny agenda
The Chair invited Councillor Muddiman to address the Committee as follows: Dear Scrutiny Committee. The controversial Oxpens Bridge, which would be in my ward, is on your agenda today. I urge you to use all your powers of scrutiny on this item, when considering the upcoming Cabinet decision to allocate further funds to this project.
Named5 Aug 2025Scrutiny Committee
Councillor addresses on any item for discussion on the Scrutiny agenda
The Chair thanked Councillor Muddiman and invited questions from the Committee; there were none.
Named5 Aug 2025Scrutiny Committee
Councillor addresses on any item for discussion on the Scrutiny agenda
The Chair thanked Councillor Muddiman.
Named21 May 2025General Purposes Licensing Committee
Election of Chair for Council Year 2025-2026
Councillor Miles proposed, and Councillor Mundy seconded the nomination of Councillor Muddiman to be elected as Chair of the Committee for 2025/26.
Named21 May 2025General Purposes Licensing Committee
Election of Chair for Council Year 2025-2026
The two nominations were put to the vote and by 7 votes to 6, the General Purposes Licensing Committee resolved that Councillor Muddiman be elected as the Chair for 2025/26.
Named21 May 2025General Purposes Licensing Committee
Appointment of the Sub-Committees
To establish Sub-Committees membership, the Committee and Member Services Manager referred to the report and explained that the Chair of Sub-Committees A and C would be Councillor Muddiman, and the Chair of Sub-Committees B and D would be Councillor Rehman. The Committee were then asked to nominate themselves to fill the remaining two places on each Sub-Committee. All Committee members nominated themselves which exceeded the number required for each Sub-Committee.
Named21 May 2025General Purposes Licensing Committee
Appointment of the Sub-Committees
Councillor Muddiman proposes an amendment to the recommendations to appoint three members and one reserve member to each sub-committee to allow for a pre-allocated substitute for each meeting to be available.
Named21 May 2025General Purposes Licensing Committee
Appointment of the Sub-Committees
Sub-Committee A 3 Members 1 Reserve Councillor Muddiman (Chair) Councillor Jupp Councillor Clarkson Councillor Yeatman Sub-Committee B 3 Members 1 Reserve Councillor Rehman (Chair) Councillor Lygo Councillor Waite Councillor Sandelson ... view the full minutes text for item 19.
Said20 May 2025Planning - Oxford City Planning Committee
24/02372/FUL - Units 2-5 Botley Retail Park
Councillor Muddiman spoke against the application.
Seconded4 Mar 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Ottino proposed Councillor Lygo as Chair for the meeting; Councillor Muddiman seconded.
Said4 Mar 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Declarations of Interest
Councillor Muddiman stated that the Uni Food and Wine shop is situated within her ward (Osney & St Thomas).
Named4 Mar 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Uni Food and Wine - Application to review a Premises Licence
Councillor Muddiman reminded the Sub-Committee that the premises in question lies within her ward but clarified that she had received no presentations regarding this, nor engaged in any communication regarding the application. The Senior Licensing Compliance Officer (ET) presented the report, notifying members that the Licensing Sub-Committee Hearing is convened to determine an application submitted by Oxfordshire County Council Trading Standards for a review of the Premises Licence in respect of Uni Food & Wine, 19 Park End Street, Oxford. The Sub-Committee understood that the review is required following enforcement actions being taken by Trading Standards Officers in relation to breaches and offences involving tobacco and vape sales, and with breaches of the premises licence issued under the Licensing Act 2003.
Named10 Feb 2025General Purposes Licensing Committee
Miscellaneous Licensing Fees & Charges
Councillor Muddiman and the Chair shared these concerns. The Business Regulation Team Manager confirmed that in the year 2021/22 there were no increases, but that in consecutive years they have be increases which have averaged to around 4.2% over the last five years. It was explained that the increase in this report is to ensure lower fees in previous years are made up for, and that a debt provision project team has been established to ensure that the current level of 0 debt is maintained.
Asked10 Feb 2025General Purposes Licensing Committee
Miscellaneous Licensing Fees & Charges
Councillor Muddiman sought further clarity on the 400% increase noted within the report to which the Business Regulation Team Manager explained was an anomaly as the fee is attached to a 2-year period for renewal meaning the cost of a licence is split across two years. In the past the renewal period was for 1 year (£100.00) whereas now it would be for 2-year period (£350.00) a modest increase of (£75.00 per year). New applications are charged at £500.00.
Named10 Feb 2025Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Cumulative Impact Assessment Update
Councillor Muddiman referred to page 26, section 5, and queried the increase in public order incidents in Jericho and Osney from 2018 to 2021, requesting any information on this. The Supervising Senior Licensing Officer explained that this information would have to be requested from the police directly.
Asked10 Feb 2025Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Cumulative Impact Assessment Update
Councillor Muddiman sought more ... view the full minutes text for item 14.
Named27 Jan 2025Council
Appointment to Committees
· Audit and Governance Committee – Councillor Alex Powell to replace Councillor Lois Muddiman.
Named27 Jan 2025Council
Appointment to Committees
· Planning Review Committee – Councillor Lois Muddiman to replace Councillor Alex Powell.
Said21 Jan 2025Planning - Oxford City Planning Committee
22/02954/OUT Land at Oxpens Road
Councillor Muddiman spoke against the application.
Asked20 Jan 2025Audit and Governance Committee
Setting of the Council Tax Base 2025-26
Councillor Muddiman sought clarification on how second homes are identified and noted that the number reported seemed small. The Local tax and Benefits Service Delivery Manager clarified that correspondence addresses and occupation cross references are utilised to check whether the new premium should apply, and processes exist to monitor numbers of second homes. Finally, the Chair asked whether the Council is charging at the maximum ... view the full minutes text for item 24.
Asked20 Jan 2025Audit and Governance Committee
Risk Update
Councillor Muddiman, in reference to risks CRR7 and p age 5 6, queried why these risks remain red and how long they have been classified as such. The Insurance, Risk Management and Business Continuity Officer commi tted to checking and reporting back.
Asked20 Jan 2025Audit and Governance Committee
Risk Update
Councillor Muddiman then asked what is being done to downgrade these to amber, to which the Commi ttee learned that the risk register does not describe any new mitigations since the last report in 2024, but that comments can be made after these risks have been refreshed by the Senior Leadership Team in two weeks.
Asked20 Jan 2025Audit and Governance Committee
Statement of Accounts for the Year Ending 31st March 2024
Councillor Muddiman queried the potential consequences of devolution on the accounts to which the Financial Accounting Manager was unable to provide a definitive answer. He predicted that any accounts would be combined during the creation of the new organisation and noted that the trajectory would be delayed. The External Auditor noted the question required a hypothetical response but drew on the example of Buckinghamshire to explain what happened during the transition to a unitary authority, noting all assets and liabilities were subsumed into a new body .
Asked20 Jan 2025Audit and Governance Committee
Statement of Accounts for the Year Ending 31st March 2024
Councillor Muddiman sought clarification on whether it is still incumbent on the new body to carry on with retrospective work on the accounts for previous entities to which the External Auditor advised that this would not be the case. He did not speculate any further. The Chair questioned whether the disclaimer would affect the terms on which the council companies could obtain borrowings .
Seconded7 Oct 2024Council
Appointment to Committees
On being seconded by Councillor Lois Muddiman, the recommendations were put to the vote and agreed.
Named24 Jul 2024Audit and Governance Committee
Election of Vice Chair for 2024/25
Councillor Muddiman nominated Councillor Roz Smith.
Seconded20 May 2024Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Election of Chair for Council Year 2024-25
Councillor Miles proposed and Councillor Muddiman seconded the nomination of Councillor Mundy to be elected as Chair of the Committee for 2024/25.
Named20 May 2024General Purposes Licensing Committee
Appointment of Chair for the Council Year 2024-25
Following questions from Councillor Rehman and Councillor Muddiman, the Committee was referred to Section 14.2 of the Constitution and noted that deviation from the political proportionality requirement for its Sub-Committees could be considered in exceptional circumstances with reasons.
Moved20 May 2024General Purposes Licensing Committee
Appointment of Chair for the Council Year 2024-25
Councillor Muddiman proposed and Councillor Jupp seconded a motion to disapply the political proportionality requirement for its Sub-Committees. Having applied Section 17 of the Local Government and Housing Act 1989, the motion was put to the vote and with all members present voting in favour, the motion was agreed. There were no other nominations.
Moved20 May 2024General Purposes Licensing Committee
Appointment of Sub-Committees
Councillor Muddiman proposed that Sub-Committees A, B, C, and D each consist of three members from different political groups to enhance diverse representation. She also suggested that substitutes must come from a political group not already represented in each Sub-Committee. However, concerns were raised about the constraints this might place on selecting available substitutes, given the Committee had agreed to deviate from strict political balance requirements.
Named20 May 2024General Purposes Licensing Committee
Appointment of Sub-Committees
Sub-Committee A: Councillor Ed Mundy, Councillor Lois Muddiman, Councillor Simon Ottino Sub-Committee B: Councillor Mary Clarkson, Councillor Jo Sandelson, Councillor Ian Yeatman Sub-Committee C: Councillor Ed Mundy, Councillor Katherine Miles, Councillor Naomi Waite Sub-Committee D: Councillor Mary Clarkson, Councillor Max Morris, Councillor Theo Jupp Agree that substitution is permitted on each of the four Sub-Committees but that substitutes must be from the General Purposes Licensing Committee. S ubstitutes will be sought from the pool of members not appointed to any Sub-Committee before seeking substitutes from those already appointed, with a preference for ensuring diverse political group representation where possible.
Seconded18 Mar 2024Council
Motions on notice 18 March 2024
b) Uniting to Tackle Oxford's Housing Crisis (proposed by Cllr Linda Smith, seconded by Cllr Nigel Chapman) c) In Support of Green Investment (proposed by Cllr Chris Smowton, seconded by Cllr Katherine Miles) d) Weight and emissions based parking charges (proposed by Cllr Chris Jarvis, seconded by Cllr Lois Muddiman) e) The Cost-of-living crisis and local government funding (proposed by Cllr Ed Turner, seconded by Cllr Nigel Chapman)
Seconded21 Feb 2024Council
Alternative budget proposals - Green Group amendments
Cllr Jarvis, seconded by Cllr Muddiman, moved the Green Group amendments.
Said5 Feb 2024General Purposes Licensing Committee
Miscellaneous Licensing: Fees and Charges for the 2023/24 financial year
Councillor Lois Muddiman expressed her support for the proposal and suggested extending the provision to include vape-free environments.
Moved7 Nov 2023Council
Proposed Submission Draft Oxford Local Plan 2040
Councillor Muddiman, on being seconded by Rawle, proposed an amendment to the 2040 Monitoring Framework to insert an additional line that would monitor the ratio between home spaces delivered and employments created.
Moved2 Oct 2023Council
Motions on notice 2 October 2023
b) Oxford Climate Emergency Centre (proposed by Cllr Lois Muddiman, seconded by Cllr Emily Kerr) c) Freedom from Fear for our Shop Workers (proposed by Cllr Edward Mundy, seconded by Cllr Shaista Aziz).
Moved2 Oct 2023Council
Oxford Climate Emergency Centre (proposed by Cllr Lois Muddiman, seconded by Cllr Emily Kerr)
Councillor Lois Muddiman, seconded by Councillor Emily Kerr, proposed the submitted motion as set out in the agenda and briefing note.
Seconded2 Oct 2023Council
Oxford Climate Emergency Centre (proposed by Cllr Lois Muddiman, seconded by Cllr Emily Kerr)
Councillor Anna Railton, seconded by Councillor Lois Muddiman, proposed the amendment as set out in the briefing note.
Named6 Feb 2023General Purposes Licensing Committee
Minutes of the previous meeting
Minute 11 - Sustainable Street Trading Motion referred to General Purposes Licensing Committee under Part 11.19(d) of the Constitution In response to a question from Cllr Muddiman, Cllr Upton, Cabinet Member for Health and Transport advised that she was expecting to meet with EV Team in the coming week and would provide a progress update in due course.
Seconded30 Jan 2023Council
Motions on notice 30 January 2023
a) Opposing Voter ID (proposed by Cllr Gant, seconded by Cllr Smowton ) b) Fixing Oxford’s Water (proposed by Cllr Jarvis, seconded by Cllr Muddiman) c) End Tory Cost of Living Crisis (proposed by Cllr Aziz, seconded by Cllr Upton) Motions not taken as the time allocated for debate had finished:
Seconded30 Jan 2023Council
Fixing Oxford's Water (proposed by Cllr Jarvis, seconded by Cllr Muddiman)
Cllr Jarvis, seconded by Cllr Muddiman, proposed the submitted motion as set out in the agenda and briefing note and immediately changed his motion without notice to reflect the amendment submitted as set out in the briefing note.
Seconded30 Jan 2023Council
Fixing Oxford's Water (proposed by Cllr Jarvis, seconded by Cllr Muddiman)
The change was seconded by Cllr Muddiman and agreed by Council, in accordance with Oxford City Council’s Constitution Part 11.20(h).
Seconded3 Oct 2022Council
Motions on notice 3 October 2022
c) Providing funding for ‘Warm Spaces’ in the winter (proposed by Cllr Sandelson, seconded by Cllr Goddard) [amendment proposed by Cllr Brown] d) Fixing Oxford’s water (proposed by Cllr Jarvis, seconded by Cllr Muddiman) e) To bring back water into public ownership (proposed by Cllr Hunt, seconded by Cllr Bely-Summers ) f) Campsfield House (proposed by Cllr Gant) g) Plant-based food and sustainable farming (proposed by Cllr Dunne, seconded by Cllr Hollingsworth)
Named18 Jul 2022Council
Motions on notice 18 July 2022
d) Sustainable Street Trading (proposer Cllr Miles, seconder Cllr Muddiman, moved without notice as per Constitution 11.19(d) proposed by Cllr Linda Smith, seconded by Cllr Hollingsworth) Motions not taken as the time allocated for debate had finished:
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.