Said5 Oct 2026Council
Declarations of interest
Councillor Ottino noted that he works for a company that partners with the Council in the Oxfordshire Homelessness and Rough Sleeping Strategy (2026-2028). Emma Jackman, Director of Law, Governance, and Strategy clarified that he did not need to declare an interest for this item due to this relationship.
Moved14 Sep 2026General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair
Councillor Ottino proposed, and Councillor Bala seconded, Councillor Lygo as Chair.
Named11 Aug 2026Scrutiny Committee
Chair's Announcements
The Chair thanked Councillor Ottino for chairing the last meeting in his absence and reminded members of the scheduled online Scrutiny training session on 22 September;
Said11 Aug 2026Scrutiny Committee
Cowley Branch Line infrastructure and public realm funding
Councillor Ottino suggested that the Committee be provided a map which outlined the 1.5km radius noted in the report and the rationale behind this measurement was queried.
Asked11 Aug 2026Scrutiny Committee
Cowley Branch Line infrastructure and public realm funding
Councillor Ottino also asked whether affected ward and parish councils, as well as South Oxfordshre District Council, had been contacted to make financial commitments towards the project given the benefits they would receive following its completion.
Named11 Aug 2026Scrutiny Committee
Cowley Branch Line infrastructure and public realm funding
In response to Councillor Ottino, t ... view the full minutes text for item 29.
Moved3 Aug 2026General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair
Councillor Ottino proposed, and Councillor Yeatman seconded, Councillor Miles as Chair.
Moved27 Jul 2026Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Ottino proposed, and Councillor Muddiman seconded, Councillor Taylor as Chair.
Declared14 Jul 2026Planning - Oxford City Planning Committee
Declarations of interest
For 25/01588/FUL, Councillor Ottino declared that he had attended a presentation relating to the site but had not taken part in any discussions
Seconded13 Jul 2026Council
Littlemore Neighbourhood Plan
On being proposed by Councillor Brown and seconded by Councillor Ottino, the recommendations were put to a vote. Council resolved to:
Named15 Jun 2026General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair
Councillor Lancaster proposed, and Councillor Yeatman seconded, Councillor Ottino as Chair.
Named15 Jun 2026General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair
Councillor Ottino was elected as Chair for the duration of the meeting.
Named9 Jun 2026Scrutiny Committee
Election of Chair for the Council Year 2026/27
Councillor Ottino nominated Councillor Powell for the position of Chair, and this was seconded by Councillor Jarvis.
Named9 Jun 2026Scrutiny Committee
Election of Vice-Chair for Council Year 2026/27
Councillor Jarvis nominated Councillor Ottino for the position of Vice-Chair, and this was seconded by Councillor Morris.
Named9 Jun 2026Scrutiny Committee
Election of Vice-Chair for Council Year 2026/27
Councillor Ottino was elected to the role of Vice-Chair.
Said9 Jun 2026Scrutiny Committee
Cabinet responses to Scrutiny recommendations
Councillor Ottino expressed disappointment in the Cabinet’s response to the flooding and watercourses issue that had raised. He asked how they could request a fuller response from Cabinet on this issue.
Moved27 May 2026Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Election of Chair for Council Year 2026-2027
Councillor Ottino proposed, and Councillor Bala seconded the nomination of Councillor Miles to be elected as Chair of the Committee for 2026/27. There were no further nominations.
Moved27 May 2026Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Election of Vice-Chair for Council Year 2026-2027
Councillor Ottino proposed, and Councillor Jupp seconded the nomination of Councillor Taylor to be elected as Vice-Chair of the Committee for 2026/27. There were no further nominations.
Named27 May 2026Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Declarations of interest
Councillor Ottino reminded the Committee and officers that the meeting had fallen on the date of Eid as reasoning for the apologies of some Members. It was suggested this be avoided in future.
Moved27 May 2026General Purposes Licensing Committee
Election of Chair for Council Year 2026-2027
Councillor Ottino proposed, and Councillor Miles seconded the nomination of Councillor Muddiman to be elected as Chair of the Committee for 2026/27. There were no further nominations.
Named27 May 2026General Purposes Licensing Committee
Election of Vice-Chair for Council Year 2026-2027
Councillor Miles proposed, and Councillor Taylor seconded the nomination of Councillor Ottino to be elected as Vice-Chair of the Committee for 2026/27. There were no further nominations.
Named27 May 2026General Purposes Licensing Committee
Election of Vice-Chair for Council Year 2026-2027
The General Purposes Licensing Committee resolved that Councillor Ottino be elected as the Vice-Chair for 2026/27. In the absence of the Chair, the Vice-Chair chaired the remainder of the meeting.
Seconded26 May 2026Planning - Oxford City Planning Committee
Election of Vice-Chair
Councillor Upton proposed Councillor Fouweather as Vice-Chair; Councillor Ottino seconded.
Named20 Apr 2026Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Lygo proposed and Councillor Yeatman seconded, Councillor Ottino as Chair.
Named20 Apr 2026Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Ottino was elected as Chair for the duration of the meeting.
Asked9 Apr 2026Audit and Governance Committee
Risk Management Update
Councillor Ottino queried why, in appendix 3, risk 00030 remains classified as a risk. The Insurance, Risk Management, and Business Continuity Officer explained that despite the mitigations listed on page 49 of the report having been completed, this example remains a risk due to the serious impact it would have should it occur. As the risk owner, the Financial Accounting Manager noted that the risk in question related to treasury management and explained that the controls in place are critical, but that it would not be preferable to remove it from the register given its importance.
Asked9 Apr 2026Audit and Governance Committee
Risk Management Update
Councillor Ottino queried whether the registers could be separated out to demonstrate clearly to the Committee the risks which remain on the register due to their severity if they occurred, and the ones which require additional work to manage. The Insurance, Risk Management, and Business Continuity Officer noted that this could be done and offered to present the risks in the manner the Committee finds most beneficial. The Chair noted other examples, such as climate change, for which little can be done however it is important for them to remain on the register to ensure the Council remains alert.
Said7 Apr 2026Scrutiny Committee
Watercourses and Ditches
Councillor Ottino requested maps outlining the rivers and streams that the Council is responsible for and noted concern relating to the lack of progress with flood action plans for specific areas of the city. The Major Works Project Manager committed to sharing a map in the future and, in relation to the flood action plans, explained that due to feasibility issues, alternative options are now being assessed by the environmental sustainability team on behalf of Oxfordshire County Council. The Committee understood that actions arising from this should be apparent in due course.
Asked7 Apr 2026Scrutiny Committee
Watercourses and Ditches
Councillor Ottino queried when the relevant reports would be received and emphasised the need for more urgency to ensure residents’ homes are not flooded.
Said7 Apr 2026Scrutiny Committee
Review of Ward Member Budget and Community Infrastructure Levy Councillor Applications
Councillor Ottino also welcomed the changes and requested clarity on when planning permission is required for ward member budget and CIL requests. The Committee and Member Services Manager explained that the relevant form has been updated to include questions relating to the need for planning permission and location; this will ensure necessary permissions are in place before CIL is spent. The Committee were minded that due to the number of stakeholders across the city, it is not possible to give a one-size-fits-all response.
Said7 Apr 2026Scrutiny Committee
Review of Ward Member Budget and Community Infrastructure Levy Councillor Applications
Councillor Ottino requested additional clarification of what would be classified as an ongoing spend. The Chair also welcomed the changes set out in the report. The Chair queried the response times for applications and requested a description of the background processes involved.
Named7 Apr 2026Scrutiny Committee
Review of Ward Member Budget and Community Infrastructure Levy Councillor Applications
In response to Councillor Ottino , the Committee and Member Services Manager outlined that anything not accounted for in an annual ongoing budget cannot be accepted, this included examples of waste bins with ongoing ... view the full minutes text for item 124.
Asked7 Apr 2026Scrutiny Committee
Urgent Key Decisions End of Year Update 2025-2026
Councillor Ottino asked the Chair if sufficient information and notice had been provided on each occasion. The Chair confirmed that sufficient information had been provided on each occasion, and whilst haste had often been required, this was due to factors out of the Councils' control, such as government action and pressures. The Chair also noted that the current process has improved in comparison to the previous year.
Said7 Apr 2026Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny Work Plan
Councillor Ottino suggested that a report on the state and use of disused garage sites be requested, as well as report on HRA land in relation to attraction of anti-social behaviour. The Scrutiny and Governance Advisor recorded the suggestions. The Committee noted the workplan.
Named23 Mar 2026Council
Declarations of interest
Councillor Ottino, Councillor Arshad and Councillor Rowley noted they were also members of the Unite Union.
Seconded23 Mar 2026Council
Motions on notice March 2026
Motions agreed as set out below: 18b) Prisoners for Palestine hunger strikes (Proposed by Councillor Jarvis, Seconded by Councillor Mundy) 18c) Support for Mini Plant Oxford (Proposed by Councillor Linda Smith, Seconded by Councillor Ottino) Motions taken but lost: 18a) Better use of Oxpens Bridge Funding (Proposed by Councillor Jupp, Seconded by Councillor Miles) Motions not taken as the time allocated for debate had finished: 18d) Condemnation of Attempted Election Postponement (Proposed by Councillor Smowton, Seconded by Councillor Miles) 18e) Stop the War in Iran (Proposed by Councillor Powell, Seconded by Councillor Djafari-Marbini)
Named23 Mar 2026Council
Prisoners for Palestine hunger strikes (Proposed by Cllr Jarvis, Seconded by Cllr Mundy)
Councillor Ottino formally withdrew his amendment.
Seconded23 Mar 2026Council
Support for Mini Plant Oxford (Proposed by Cllr Linda Smith, Seconded by Cllr Ottino)
Councillor Lindas Smith, seconded by Councillor Ottino, proposed the motion as set out in the briefing note, incorporating the two amendments set out in the briefing note. Following the debate and on being put to the vote, the motion carried. **** Council resolved to:
Moved16 Mar 2026General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair
Councillor Ottino proposed, and Councillor Yeatman seconded, Councillor Clarkson as Chair.
Asked10 Mar 2026Scrutiny Committee
More Leisure Annual Service Plan (Year 3) and Update
Noting the loss of space at Blackbird Leys Leisure Centre, Councillor Ottino asked if there is confidence that people have been able to find alternative venues for some sports, and whether new sports, such as padel, have been considered as part of a broader programme of activities.
Asked10 Mar 2026Scrutiny Committee
Nighttime Economy
Councillor Ottino questioned the geographical focus of the work so far, noting that it perhaps excluded locations which could offer beneficial opportunities for the nighttime economy, such as some industrial spaces.
Named10 Mar 2026Scrutiny Committee
Nighttime Economy
In response to Councillor Ottino, Councillor Hollingsworth welcomed the suggestion that a broader geographical area could be considered, however explained that the initial audit had been completed with limited resources and therefore, consideration was paid to what workload was feasible.
Asked10 Mar 2026Scrutiny Committee
Fly-tipping and Litter Management
Councillor Ottino queried how effective the signage around the city is, why there are not more, and why signs are not automatically placed in fly tipping hotspots. More data regarding fly tipping locations and hotspots was requested.
Asked10 Mar 2026Scrutiny Committee
Fly-tipping and Litter Management
Councillor Ottino also asked what is being done to encourage communities to not fly tip and to be more proactive in keeping their areas free of rubbish.
Seconded17 Feb 2026Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Clarkson proposed, and Councillor Ottino seconded Councillor Lygo as Chair.
Asked17 Feb 2026Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Application for a variation to a Premises Licence – Raouls Bar, 32 Walton Street, Oxford, OX2 6AA
Councillor Ottino sought to clarify the licence timings and how they would align with clear out times. The Supervising Senior Licensing Officer explained that the Licensing Authority cannot restrict the hours of a business, only its licensable activities;
Said17 Feb 2026Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Application for a variation to a Premises Licence – Raouls Bar, 32 Walton Street, Oxford, OX2 6AA
Councillor Ottino requested information on the opening and closing times of nearby premises. The Supervising Senior Licensing Officer noted that the Oxford Wine Cafe on the same road is currently licensed until midnight on Fridays and Saturdays, and 11pm on weeknights. Additionally, Love Jericho is licensed until 2am on Fridays and Saturdays, and 1am on other nights.
Asked17 Feb 2026Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Application for a variation to a Premises Licence – Raouls Bar, 32 Walton Street, Oxford, OX2 6AA
Councillor Ottino sought to clarify that there had been no representations from other responsible authorities in relation to noise from Raouls’; the Supervising Senior Licensing Officer confirmed that there had not. The Chair invited [name removed] and Mr.
Asked9 Feb 2026Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Review of the Cumulative Impact Assessment and Special Saturation Policy
Councillor Ottino queried whether the conditions attached to recent applications had been generally from police, and whether there had been a lot of resistance from applicants to these. The Senior Licensing Compliance Officer (KT) confirmed they were mostly TVP agreed conditions and noted that positive conversations between the police and applicants had taken place. The Chair asked whether the licenses applied for in SSP areas since its expiry has increased the density of licence holders, or whether the density remains similar as people reapply for previously licensed premises which may have stopped operating.
Said9 Feb 2026General Purposes Licensing Committee
Miscellaneous Licensing Update Report
Councillor Ottino commented that the report should have included feedback from organisations such as Turning Point in recognition of marginalised groups within Oxford who struggle with mental health challenges and addiction.
Said9 Feb 2026General Purposes Licensing Committee
Miscellaneous Licensing Update Report
Councillor Ottino emphasised his concern that a 100% smoking ban on pavements could further marginalise some groups by excluding them from social environments. The Supervising Senior Licensing Officer acknowledged the request for feedback from relevant organisations and outlined that control of smoking on pavements can only be extended as far as the legal boundary of a licence.
Said9 Feb 2026General Purposes Licensing Committee
Miscellaneous Licensing Fees and Charges for the financial year 2026/2027
Councillor Ottino noted that the 10% increase sits above the inflation rate and therefore questioned how the increase was deemed reasonable. The Business Regulation Manager outlined the increases in previous years and explained that the average is therefore only a 6% increase across the last 5 years.
Asked9 Feb 2026General Purposes Licensing Committee
Miscellaneous Licensing Fees and Charges for the financial year 2026/2027
Councillor Ottino queried whether the increases proposed reflect a large impact on the budget, to which the Business Regulation Manager could not comment on the budget process in its entirety. The Chair invited the Committee to debate the recommendation; there were no comments.
Asked3 Feb 2026Scrutiny Committee
Debt Recovery Procedure
Councillor Ottino queried what the Council does to support those on universal credit with council tax payments, and whether any reductions are offered. The Revenues Service Delivery Manager outlined the Council’s use of MARS software to assess council tax for those residents in receipt of universal credit. The Committee heard that this enables better understanding of the impact of payment timings in order to inform recovery action and it considers personal circumstances of vulnerable persons to ensure appropriate support can be offered.
Asked3 Feb 2026Scrutiny Committee
Debt Recovery Procedure
Councillor Ottino also queried how often the Council meets with relevant advice centres, to which Councillor Turner noted the Council’s openness and officer attendance at advice centre AGMs. The Committee heard of capacity issues within advice centres which has limited the frequency of these meetings. The Revenues Service Delivery Manager further explained that the Council used to hold quarterly meetings with advice centres, however capacity issues and volunteer availability has reduced these.
Asked3 Feb 2026Scrutiny Committee
Noticeboards Update
Councillor Ottino queried what permissions are needed to put up a new noticeboard and requested that relevant guidelines for councillors be made available.
Said3 Feb 2026Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny Work Plan
Based on existing issues within Oxford, Councillor Ottino suggested that a report on the City Council’s role in highways management be brought forward, with a focus on powers and lessons learned.
Asked28 Jan 2026Audit and Governance Committee
Housing Benefit Audit Report 2024/2025
Councillor Ottino asked what could be done to encourage landlords to become registered providers, noting the financial burden which can be placed on the council when this does not occur. The Local Tax & Benefit Service Delivery Manager explained that a financial burden presents when the council is required to pay the full subsidy allowance to charities, but the government does not provide 100% of this amount to the council. To encourage more landlords to become registered providers, the Committee heard that commissioning sites are actively encouraged, however the difficulties faced by housing associations when becoming landlords were also acknowledged.
Named28 Jan 2026Audit and Governance Committee
Setting of the Council Tax Base 2026-27
In response to queries from Councillor Ottino, it was also explained that the Local Tax and Benefit Service Delivery Team conduct the visits and the Committee learned that in August 2025, a review of all long-term empties and second home premiums was conducted to ensure that the council understood the status of each address and whether it complied with the necessary legislation for various council tax discounts. The Local Tax & Benefit Service Delivery Manager provided comprehensive detail on recent analysis conducted on the matter and noted issues with engagement of owners.
Said28 Jan 2026Audit and Governance Committee
Setting of the Council Tax Base 2026-27
Councillor Ottino requested that information regarding second homes and empty properties be shared with ward councillors, to which the Local Tax & Benefit Service Delivery Manager committed to circulating addresses, but not details of the owner. The Committee also heard of ongoing efforts, including leafleting, to encourage rental of empty properties in Oxford. The Chair queried the nature and number of council tax exemptions relating to charities and the universities in Oxford.
Asked28 Jan 2026Audit and Governance Committee
Risk Management Reporting at 31st December 2025
Councillor Ottino queried why the climate change red risk remains on the register when the council have little to no control over this.
Named19 Jan 2026General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Declarations of Interest
The Chair, Councillor Ottino, and Councillor Miles declared awareness of representations that had been submitted in relation to items 5 and 6, but confirmed that due to late submission, these would not be considered. All Sub-Committee members committed to proceeding with an open mind.
Asked13 Jan 2026Scrutiny Committee
Local Plan 2045
Councillor Ottino asked whether the the policy will address inequalities in the city, beyond just the consideration of additional social housing. Examples of boosting economic development and employment in a manner which most benefits the least advantaged were suggested.
Seconded12 Jan 2026Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Ottino seconded.
Declared9 Dec 2025Planning - Oxford City Planning Committee
Declarations of interest
For 25/02702/FUL, Councillor Ottino declared that he was pre-determined, as he had been part of the call-in for the application and that he would leave the meeting for this item.
Named9 Dec 2025Planning - Oxford City Planning Committee
25/02702/FUL Unit 11 Kings Meadow
Councillor Ottino , Railton and Muddiman left the meeting for this item.
Asked2 Dec 2025Scrutiny Committee
Devolution
Councillor Ottino queried how inclusion within a Thames Valley Mayoral Strategic Authority would be communicated to local residents as a beneficial arrangement, noting that he does not personally identify himself as being part of the Thames Valley region. Concern with how distant this identity could feel was noted.
Named2 Dec 2025Scrutiny Committee
Devolution
In response to Councillor Ottino, Councillor Brown confirmed that many conversations are ongoing between local authorities regarding the impacts of devolution and how to present it to the public. The Committee heard that a significant budget has been allocated by Government to give more powers to local areas; the potential benefits of which were highlighted. Comparable examples, such as Manchester, were also referenced.
Asked2 Dec 2025Scrutiny Committee
Cabinet responses to Scrutiny recommendations
Councillor Ottino queried whether the Scrutiny Committee could make recommendations to the licensing committees. The Committee and Member Services Manager explained that there is no formal mechanism for this, however comments could be taken to officers to make them aware of possible discussions relating to policy at the next Committee meeting. The Committee noted Cabinet’s responses to its recommendations.
Named11 Nov 2025Scrutiny Committee
Declarations of interest
Councillor Ottino and Councillor Miles noted their membership of the General Purposes Licensing Committee and their involvement in previous discussions relating to the report being considered at this meeting.
Named11 Nov 2025Scrutiny Committee
Declarations of interest
Councillor Ottino, Councillor Jarvis, and Councillor Powell noted that they had previously received correspondence from COLTA.
Asked5 Nov 2025Scrutiny Committee
Local Government Reorganisation
Councillor Ottino queried whether alternative boundary options were considered for the city unitary, and how or why they were ruled out. The Chair asked, in relation to the interaction between unitarisation and devolution, how the three-unitary proposal would fit into the development of a Mayoral Strategic Authority (MSA), noting concern about representation within decisions at the MSA level.
Said3 Nov 2025General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Peripatetic Street Trading Application
Councillor Ottino raised a concern regarding narrow pavements. Lucy responded that they would be careful not to obstruct pavements and would look for areas that were quiet and less narrow.
Asked3 Nov 2025General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Peripatetic Street Trading Application
Councillor Ottino asked the Supervising Senior Licensing Officer if Radley Square had the same conditions as Bonn Square, or any extra restrictions. The Supervising Senior Licensing Officer confirmed that Radley Square did not have the same restrictions as Bonn square.
Named3 Nov 2025General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Peripatetic Street Trading Application
Councillor Ottino mentioned that there was a legal minimum wage age and an employee would legally need to be paid. Lucy responded that her intention was to facilitate Annabel, but Annabel would pay her sister in due course. The Legal Adviser stated that the consent holder may employ any other person to assist and should provide the Council the name and address of that person.
Asked3 Nov 2025General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Peripatetic Street Trading Application
Councillor Ottino asked the Supervising Senior Licensing Officer if there was a way to restrict the license getting in the way of other events. The Supervising Senior Licensing Officer responded that they could prevent the use of the license during events in the area. The applicant agreed that they would be happy to have conditions added.
Asked3 Nov 2025General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Street Trading Application
Councillor Ottino asked the Business Regulation Compliance Officer to clarify that the application was for one person to work at and that any additional people would need to be added on. The Business Regulation Compliance Officer confirmed this was correct.
Asked3 Nov 2025General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Street Trading Application
Councillor Ottino asked the Supervising Senior Licensing Officer t o clarify that this application was for one person to work at and that any additional people would need to be added on. The Supervising Senior Licensing Officer confirmed that this was correct and added that if the applicant wished to register new employees it would be on a website which they would have to provide relevant documents for. The applicant would not need to come back to committee, and this would be an administrative procedure.
Asked3 Nov 2025General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Street Trading Application
Councillor Ottino asked the applicant how they would control litter. [name removed] responded that they had bins available and were aware of their responsibility to maintain cleanliness, adding that he would personally ensure the area was cleaned. The Chair asked if the applicant had experience with catering.
Asked21 Oct 2025Audit and Governance Committee
Purchase Cards Internal Audit Report - October 2025
Councillor Ottino queried whether the matter would translate into a performance management target for all officers who hold a card and asked what impacts the removal of a card has on council functions. The date of the next follow-up report was also requested.
Said21 Oct 2025Audit and Governance Committee
Purchase Cards Internal Audit Report - October 2025
Councillor Ottino requested clarification on the purchase limit noted in the report and asked how this impacts emergency situations. The Revenues and Service Delivery Manager clarified that payment limits do not restrict responses to emergencies as usually there is more than one card holder within a given service area. If a larger spend is required in an emergency situation, this can be authorised centrally.
Asked21 Oct 2025Audit and Governance Committee
Internal Audit Follow Up of Recommendations Report - October 2025
Councillor Ottino queried the problems with suppliers which were referred to, and the Rapid Rehousing Manager summarised complexities relating to terms and conditions, indemnities, and the size and scale of suppliers. The Chair thanked the Internal Auditors and officers and recommended that a meeting with the Monitoring Officer be scheduled soon after her return. The Committee reviewed and noted the report.
Said20 Oct 2025General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Declarations of Interest
Councillor Ottino noted that both applicants live within the ward he serves as a councillor, however confirmed that he had never met either, or possessed any previous awareness of them and therefore did not declare any interest.
Named14 Oct 2025Scrutiny Committee
Anti-Social Behaviour Policy
Councillor Ottino firstly asked how confident the Council is that Registered Providers uphold their responsibilities and perform to expectation in terms of tackling ASB. He also queried how strong the Council’s relationship is the registered providers. It was requested that relevant contact details for the housing associations be shared with councillors.
Asked14 Oct 2025Scrutiny Committee
Anti-Social Behaviour Policy
Secondly, Councillor Ottino asked what the Council is doing to coordinate actions against fly tipping with housing associations and ODS. And finally, it was observed that whilst the report focuses on responses to ASB, there needs to be more proactive action taken to decreasing ASB.
Asked14 Oct 2025Scrutiny Committee
Anti-Social Behaviour Policy
Therefore, Councillor Ottino asked what more could be done to this end, including considering how to design areas more considerately.
Named14 Oct 2025Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny Work Plan
The Chair, Councillor Miles, Councillor Altaf-Khan , and Councillor Ottino debated this matter.
Asked14 Oct 2025Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny Work Plan
The Chair recommended that a formal report on Uber not be requested, but that the Committee may be provided the same information on the matter that had already been presented to the General Purposes Licensing Committee Councillor Ottino queried why the content of the 5November meeting was not an all-member briefing instead, to which the Chair explained that the report would be going to Cabinet the following week and therefore the Scrutiny Committee was invited to consider it as part of the usual governance chain.
Seconded13 Oct 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Rehman proposed Councillor Miles as Chair; Councillor Ottino seconded.
Named7 Oct 2025General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair
Councillor Lygo proposed Councillor Ottino as Chair; Councillor Yeatman seconded.
Named7 Oct 2025General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair
Councillor Ottino was elected as Chair for the duration of the meeting.
Seconded29 Sep 2025General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Election of a Chair
Councillor Miles proposed Councillor Jupp as Chair; Councillor Ottino seconded.
Said29 Sep 2025General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Declarations of Interest
Councillor Ottino noted that he was present on the previous Sub-Committee that considered this applicant’s case; he noted that he would withdraw from the meeting should the applicant object to his presence.
Said22 Sep 2025Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Review of the Cumulative Impact Assessment and Special Saturation Policy
Councillor Ottino requested data on the impact of not having an SSP in place for the last five months, particularly relating to whether there were any changes to the numbers of applications received, granted, or refused. The Licensing Team Manager noted that only one application had been received just prior to the last Committee meeting at which time the policy was removed. The Committee heard that this application was approved and there had not since been any applications objected to on the grounds of the SSP, and no applications had been received since the SSP had not been in place.
Named22 Sep 2025General Purposes Licensing Committee
Hackney Carriage Vehicle Emission Standards Amendment
Councillor Ottino firstly requested examples of other Councils that manage different taxi licensing regulations within different areas of their authority. Secondly, it was asked what differences there are between the regulations Oxford City Council applies to Hackney Carriage licences, in comparison to those applied by other councils, for example rules for disabled wheelchair access.
Said22 Sep 2025General Purposes Licensing Committee
Hackney Carriage Vehicle Emission Standards Amendment
Councillor Ottino expressed concern around how these differences are managed and the issues this may cause. The Licensing Team Manager noted Bath and North Somerset Council as an example of a unitary council that manages varying licensing regulations under one authority area and explained how the management of this could be approached if Oxford City Council were to be merged into a unitary council.
Said22 Sep 2025General Purposes Licensing Committee
Hackney Carriage Vehicle Emission Standards Amendment
Councillor Ottino stated his preference for the option to align the adoption of the policy with Local Government Reorganisation.
Named22 Sep 2025General Purposes Licensing Committee
Hackney Carriage Vehicle Emission Standards Amendment
Councillor Ottino formally proposed option C in the report. The Chair clarified the wording of the recommendation as being for the Committee to agree to align with Local Government Reorganisation to postpone the final phase until the establishment of the new unitary council in 2028, aligning the policy with wider structural changes and enabling consistent standards across the new licensing authority.
Said9 Sep 2025Scrutiny Committee
Budget Review Group Scope
Councillor Ottino raised concern that Councillor Miles’ suggestion exceeded the intended broad nature of the scope outlined in the report, to which the Chair noted that the additions could provide some specific remit alongside the broad scope.
Named9 Sep 2025Scrutiny Committee
Budget Review Group Scope
Councillor Miles and Councillor Ottino discussed the requirement to mention statutory responsibilities within the scope.
Seconded9 Sep 2025Scrutiny Committee
Budget Review Group Scope
Councillor Miles proposed the amendment; Councillor Ottino seconded. The Committee unanimously voted in favour.
Asked9 Sep 2025Scrutiny Committee
Endorsement of Recommendations from Working Groups
Councillor Ottino asked whether the Climate and Environment Working Group had considered the Council’s relationship with the heat network providers given that it will sit under roads, and highways are not a responsibility of the City Council. It was asked how Oxford City Council are expected to influence the project and its outcomes.
Asked9 Sep 2025Scrutiny Committee
Endorsement of Recommendations from Working Groups
Councillor Ottino asked how it could be ensured that the Council is listened to. It was recommended that the relevant information in response to these concerns was covered in the slide deck presented to the Working Group and endeavoured to share this with members of this Committee .
Moved6 Aug 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Ottino proposed Councillor Jupp as Chair for the meeting; Councillor Yeatman seconded.
Asked5 Aug 2025Scrutiny Committee
Oxpens River Bridge Update
Councillor Ottino queried why funds need to be transferred to cover deficits, and whether if further funding from external sources is not obtained, the project could go ahead.
Seconded23 Jul 2025Audit and Governance Committee
Election of Chair for Council Year 2025-2026
Councillor Munkonge proposed, and Councillor Ottino seconded the nomination of Councillor Fry to be elected as Chair of the Committee for 2025/26. ? There were no further nominations.
Moved23 Jul 2025Audit and Governance Committee
Election of Vice-Chair for Council Year 2025-2026
Councillor Ottino proposed, and Councillor Munkonge seconded the nomination of Councillor Smith to be elected as Vice-Chair of the Committee for 2025/26. There were no further nominations.
Asked23 Jul 2025Audit and Governance Committee
ODS: Annual Audit Opinion and Internal Control Environment 2024/25
Councillor Ottino asked how the business is affected by the unqualified audit opinion and requested further context on the matter. The Non-Executive Director (ODS) explained that ODS has not been significantly affected and were progressing with ongoing work successfully. It was emphasised that the matter would be held at the forefront of future plans to inform improvements going forwards.
Said23 Jul 2025Audit and Governance Committee
Risk Management Update
Councillor Ottino, in relation to page 192, noted that the Council have only limited ability to mitigate flooding and climate change risks, and therefore commented that there will always be high risks noted. It was asked whether it would be possible to view the data of only the risks which the Council can meaningfully address. The Insurance, Risk Management and Business Continuity Officer agreed that some risks noted within the register are outside the council’s control but explained that scoring risks involves consideration of probability and impact which can be managed differently.
Moved3 Jul 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Ottino proposed Councillor Miles as Chair for the meeting; Councillor Rawle seconded.
Said1 Jul 2025Scrutiny Committee
Domestic Abuse Policy for Service Users
Councillor Ottino requested some illustrative examples of how staff would be expected to respond.
Said1 Jul 2025Scrutiny Committee
Citizen Experience Strategy 2025-27
Councillor Ottino requested examples of how they are reaching people that may not usually respond to survey and in places without community buildings. It was also asked what is being done to ensure that residents believe that their views are relevant and mater to the Council. Additionally, in relation to young people, it was asked what is being done to ensure engagement in the democratic process.
Named1 Jul 2025Scrutiny Committee
Citizen Experience Strategy 2025-27
In response to Councillor Ottino, the Director of Communities and Citizens Services detailed examples of ongoing work to engage broadly within the local community. This included examples such as telephone contact centres, face to face services within the Westgate Library, and links with food larders across the city. The Committee heard that reviews are ongoing to assess the regularity of visits to food larders and possible new community locations to attend.
Said1 Jul 2025Scrutiny Committee
Work Plan and Forward Plan
Councillor Henwood and Councillor Ottino requested clarification on what this would involve and what the Scrutiny Committee would be considering. The Scrutiny and Governance Advisor informed members that Cabinet would be considering approval for power to be delegated and enter into necessary legal and funding agreements.
Asked1 Jul 2025Scrutiny Committee
Work Plan and Forward Plan
Councillor Ottino questioned whether there was value in Scrutiny engaging meaningfully with the item given the scope of the report. The Chair noted that the Committee may wish to scrutinise the delegations for the decision Cabinet will be taking and put forward recommendations given that the topic has been of great interest.
Named1 Jul 2025Scrutiny Committee
Work Plan and Forward Plan
The Chair thanked Councillor Ottino for the issues he raised and committed to considering and managing the remit of the discussion. The Scrutiny and Governance Advisor updated the Committee on the suggested topics added to the workplan, as detailed in the report, and explained how these topics were selected. The Committee were assured that further additions could be made and would be agreed with the Chair.
Named1 Jul 2025Scrutiny Committee
Work Plan and Forward Plan
In response to Councillor Ottino, the Scrutiny and Governance Advisor explained the TOPIC scoring system used to determine the addition of topics to the workplan.
Moved30 Jun 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Ottino proposed Councillor Miles as Chair for the meeting; Councillor Rehman seconded.
Moved10 Jun 2025Scrutiny Committee
Election of Vice-Chair for Council Year 2025/26
Councillor Ottino proposed, and Councillor Altaf-Khan seconded the nomination of Councillor Rowley to be elected as Vice-Chair of the Committee for 2025/26.?? No further nominations were received.
Seconded10 Jun 2025Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny Operating Principles 2025/26
The Chair proposed, and Councillor Ottino seconded for the Committee to agree the proposed operating principles for the 2025/26 municipal year, as set out in appendix 1. The Committee agreed.
Seconded10 Jun 2025Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny Operating Principles 2025/26
In regard the Finance and Performance working group, the Chair proposed to adopt the membership as set out in the report and Councillor Ottino seconded. Members voted unanimously in agreement. The Chair invited nominations for Chair.
Said10 Jun 2025Scrutiny Committee
Leisure Investment Programme Update and More Leisure Service Annual Plan
Councillor Ottino thanked officers for the provision of refugee and women only swimming sessions and noted his recognition of the difficulties that have existed around this.
Asked10 Jun 2025Scrutiny Committee
Leisure Investment Programme Update and More Leisure Service Annual Plan
Councillor Ottino asked the following questions: More information was requested on the ‘pool water features’ mentioned on page 48 of the report. Clarification was requested regarding the meaning of ‘3%’ on page 49 of the report, and whether this referred to an increase. More information was requested in reference to page 51 of the report focused access to, and use of, leisure services by multicultural communities.
Said10 Jun 2025Scrutiny Committee
Oxford Local Plan 2042 Regulation 18 Consultation Document
Councillor Ottino requested clarification around how empty student accommodation is monitored, and what happens when it is identified that a property is not in use. Secondly, he raised concern with the wording of the first bullet point on page 102, in relation to ‘the delivery of certain infrastructure’, noting it as contentious.
Named10 Jun 2025Scrutiny Committee
Oxford Local Plan 2042 Regulation 18 Consultation Document
In response to Councillor Ottino , the Team Leader for Planning ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
Asked10 Jun 2025Scrutiny Committee
Annual Complaint Performance & Service Improvement Report
Councillor Ottino queried whether information on similar performance metrics from the housing associations in Oxford is available to inform the Committee as to how the Council is performing comparably. More information on the tenancy involvement strategy was also requested. The Customer Care and Complaints Manager explained that benchmark comparison is not possible at present as no other comparable reports have been released yet by Housing Associations.
Named4 Jun 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Taylor proposed Councillor Ottino as Chair; Councillor Jupp seconded.
Named4 Jun 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Ottino was elected as chair for the duration of this hearing.
Seconded21 May 2025General Purposes Licensing Committee
Election of Chair for Council Year 2025-2026
Councillor Lygo proposed, and Councillor Ottino seconded the nomination of Councillor Clarkson to be elected as Chair of the Committee for 2025/26.
Moved19 May 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Ottino proposed Councillor Miles as Chair; Councillor Jupp seconded.
Said19 May 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Application for grant of a Premises Licence – Momo Station Oxford Ltd, 260 Cowley Road, Oxford, OX4 1UH
Councillor Ottino requested details on the opening hours of nearby premises selling alcohol to which the Senior Licensing Compliance Officer noted several examples licensed to sell alcohol until midnight, including Kazbar .
Seconded12 May 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Morris proposed Councillor Jupp as Chair for the meeting; Councillor Ottino seconded.
Named22 Apr 2025General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair
Councillor Sandelson proposed Councillor Ottino as Chair; Councillor Yeatman seconded.
Named22 Apr 2025General Purposes Licensing Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair
Councillor Ottino was elected as chair for the duration of the meeting.
Asked2 Apr 2025Audit and Governance Committee
Risk Management Update
Councillor Ottino asked several questions: Whether more information on the origins and history of the red risks noted on page 10 of the report could be provided to support the Committee’s understanding. Whether clarification could be provided around the definitions of the risk categories noted on page 32, and how officers determine these. Whether distinction could be made between ‘local’ and ‘regional’ media in the consideration of the adverse publicity risk on page 34.
Moved31 Mar 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Ottino proposed Councillor Jupp as Chair for the meeting; Councillor Sandelson seconded.
Said31 Mar 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Application to vary a premises licence: Oranges and Lemons
Councillor Ottino requested information regarding the opening hours of other licensed premises local to The Oranges and Lemons. The Senior Licensing Compliance Officer provided this information in ... view the full minutes text for item 41.
Named26 Mar 2025Scrutiny Committee
Anti-Social Behaviour Update
Councillor Ottino firstly requested that phrasing utilised within the report in reference to environmental crime be reassessed. Secondly, in regards obstructions of highways, it was asked whether the police often become involved, and more information was requested regarding where the responsibility for this matter lies and the parameters of the areas involved - for example, pavements and verges.
Asked26 Mar 2025Scrutiny Committee
Anti-Social Behaviour Update
Finally, Councillor Ottino queried what powers the Council holds to respond to matters relating to pests and residential gardens. The Community ... view the full minutes text for item 92.
Said26 Mar 2025Scrutiny Committee
Urgent Key Decisions End of Year Update
The Chair thanked the Committee and Member Services Manager and Councillor Ottino commented positively on the value of the report. The Chair asked whether the report could be produced annually to which the Committee and Member Services Manager explained that information on key decision is already reported to Council as a requirement of the constitution, but that this could be extended to the Scrutiny Committee.
Named26 Mar 2025Scrutiny Committee
Urgent Key Decisions End of Year Update
Councillor Ottino and the Chair discussed the process behind urgent key decisions and the Committee discussed whether they believed it valuable for a similar report to be brought to the Scrutiny Committee annually.
Declared24 Mar 2025Council
Declarations of interest
Councillor Ottino declared, in relation to item 16a, that he receives income from the Oxfordshire pension fund as his late partner was an employee of Oxfordshire County Council. He also noted that his current partner is employed by Oxfordshire County Council.
Named24 Mar 2025Council
Declarations of interest
Councillor Ottino would remain in the meeting for the duration of any debate relating to this item.
Moved4 Mar 2025Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Ottino proposed Councillor Lygo as Chair for the meeting; Councillor Muddiman seconded.
Declared3 Mar 2025Scrutiny Committee
Declarations of interest
Councillor Ottino declared an interest relating to item 8, the Allocation of Prevention of Homeless Budget 2025/26, noting his work at A2Dominion in the Housing first team.
Named3 Mar 2025Scrutiny Committee
Declarations of interest
The Scrutiny and Governance Advisor recommended that Councillor Ottino leave the meeting during the discussion of this item.
Asked3 Mar 2025Scrutiny Committee
Work Plan and Forward Plan
Councillor Ottino queried whether the Committee has followed up on information regarding flooding action plans to ensure that plans regarding his ward be made available.
Asked3 Mar 2025Scrutiny Committee
Oxford City Council Annual Business Plan 2025 to 2026
Councillor Ottino queried whether the presence of the review into the approach to housing allocations is standard, or indicative of an issue. In reference to page 41, it was asked what the term ‘accommodation business improvement district’ meant, and finally, it was queried whether the risks mentioned had been updated since the previous year. The Chair also sought clarification on what steps are envisaged for facilitating conversations, the task group, and who will be involved.
Said3 Mar 2025Scrutiny Committee
Adult Exploitation and Modern Slavery
Councillor Ottino noted that the report does not reference prosecutions and queried firstly, whether these ... view the full minutes text for item 88.
Said10 Feb 2025General Purposes Licensing Committee
Miscellaneous Licensing Fees & Charges
Councillor Ottino expressed dissatisfaction with the larger increases in this report compared to those within the General Purposes Licensing report and queried whether inflation was the only driving factor behind this.
Named10 Feb 2025General Purposes Licensing Committee
Miscellaneous Licensing Fees & Charges
Councillor Ottino again queried why the fees in this report have a much higher percentage increase in comparison other reports, considering that the effects of Covid applied universally. The Business Regulation Team Manager assured the Committee that this is the cost of managing the whole process of the function and explained that it would cover the resources and time required to manage street trading.
Asked10 Feb 2025Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Fees & Charges
Councillor Ottino queried whether financial loss will be made if charges are not being raised to which the General Licensing Team Manager outlined that most fees are set in statute and therefore the Licensing Authority cannot increase them. In regards a loss, efforts will be made to reduce or amend discretionary activities in order to ensure costs do not significantly exceed the money available.
Named10 Feb 2025Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Cumulative Impact Assessment Update
In response to a query on timing, Councillor Ottino was assured by the Supervising Senior Licensing Officer that the results of the 8-week consultation would be returned to the committee via a report for decision.
Asked10 Feb 2025Licensing and Gambling Acts Committee
Cumulative Impact Assessment Update
Councillor Ottino sought clarity on whether the consultation would be based on the same geographical areas as previously included, noting the previous exclusion of the Westgate Centre. The Chair echoed this and asked to what extent other areas can be included. The Supervising Senior Licensing Officer noted that the assessment area can be altered and will be informed by data availability.
Said29 Jan 2025Scrutiny Committee
Declarations of interest
Councillor Ottino stated that he is a City Council representative for the Citizens’ Advice Bureau and attends the Agnes Smith Advice Centre meetings in his capacity as a Ward Councillor but receives no financial interest from these organisations.
Named29 Jan 2025Scrutiny Committee
Declarations of interest
The Chair confirmed that Councillor Ottino could remain and contribute to the meeting.
Moved27 Jan 2025Council
Visitor Parking Permits (Proposed by Cllr. Ajaz Rehman, Seconded by Cllr. Dr. Amar Latif) (Amendment proposed by Cllr Ottino, seconded by Cllr Linda Smith)
Councillor Ottino proposed an amendment to the motion, as set out in the briefing note and was seconded by Councillor Liz Smith. Following the debate and on being put to the vote, the amendment was agreed.
Said20 Jan 2025Audit and Governance Committee
Setting of the Council Tax Base 2025-26
Councillor Ottino expressed concern about the number of empty homes and the absence of a designated officer responsible for this; he asked who follows up on empty homes and if public reporting is relied upon to ensure council tax is paid. The Chair supported this question. The Technical Accountant explained that records are kept and t hat m onitoring empty homes is the responsibility of the Revenues team alongside support from Aspire and housing colleagues.
Asked20 Jan 2025Audit and Governance Committee
Setting of the Council Tax Base 2025-26
Councillor Ottino sought further clarification on who empty homes should be reported to and the Commi ttee heard that housing colleagues should be notified and will be supported by the revenues team. The Local tax and Benefits Service Delivery Manager added that long term empty homes and second homes are reported through online forms completed by inspector officers who walk the city. Fraud officers also i dentify p ossible properties that have been empty for l ong periods and work with housing colleagues to i dentify derelict properties.
Asked20 Jan 2025Audit and Governance Committee
Anti-Money Laundering Policy Update
Councillor Ottino queried whether the £5000 transaction threshold is outlined through legislation, and how often the Council encounters transactions above the threshold. The Counter Fraud Manager explained that this is a condition of legislation and that all transactions beyond the threshold must be reported to the National Crime Agency via the Suspicious Activity Report. H e noted a handful in the last year which required reporting.
Named20 Jan 2025Audit and Governance Committee
Anti-Money Laundering Policy Update
Councillor Ottino referred to business rentals and queried how checks to ensure payments are being taken from legitimate sources are carried out. The Counter Fraud Manager assured the Commi ttee that a suite of due diligence checks is utilised by the relevant team, and where concern exists, the finance team is ... view the full minutes text for item 25.
Asked20 Jan 2025Audit and Governance Committee
Internal Audit - Follow up of recommendations
Councillor Ottino asked the Internal Auditor why the actions listed relate more to recruitment than retention, to which she noted that there is one recommendation about retention policy but commi tted to checking and reporting back to the Commi ttee . The Chair queried what data exists to demonstrate the ... view the full minutes text for item 28.
Said14 Jan 2025Scrutiny Committee
Governance changes to address the increase in Urgent Key Decisions
Councillor Ottino noted his concern with the issue and highlighted the possible difficulty of training staff due to turnover rates. He also sought clarity on whether the e-learning is already set up and queried whether a two-year cycle for refresher training could be too long. The Head of ... view the full minutes text for item 61.
Asked14 Jan 2025Scrutiny Committee
Council of Sanctuary Framework
Councillor Ottino sought clarity on how many people the report refers to and stressed the importance of this for measuring success. He also expressed concern at how ambitious and broad the plans are, noting a fear that focus could be lost and suggested that more precise targets could be useful.
Asked14 Jan 2025Scrutiny Committee
HRA Rent Setting Report 2025/2026
Councillor Ottino sought clarification of how a garage within curtilage is defined and requested explanation of why garage rent is subject to higher increases when there are many empty garages across the city. It was queried whether alternative options of renting garages at lower rates could be considered. The Chair echoed this question and queried whether there are any restrictions on increasing garage rental charges.
Named14 Jan 2025Scrutiny Committee
HRA Rent Setting Report 2025/2026
In reference to curtilage, Councillor Ottino observed that the total rent on a property with an attached garage would increase more without the choice of the tenant. He queried whether tenants could opt out of having the garage as this would be an unfair imposition.
Asked14 Jan 2025Scrutiny Committee
HRA Rent Setting Report 2025/2026
Additionally, in reference to information in section 22, Councillor Ottino asked why rent charges on standing garages are increasing more than inflation. The Finance Business Partner (HRA) explained that garages within the boundary of a home are for the sole use of the tenant, and this is generally viewed positively. This would be a hard condition to remove ... view the full minutes text for item 63.
Asked2 Dec 2024Scrutiny Committee
Authority Monitoring Report and Infrastructure Funding Statement 2023/24
Cllr Ottino queried what understanding there is of how student accommodation is being used and when it is empty or unused, especially when in private buildings.
Asked2 Dec 2024Scrutiny Committee
Thriving Communities Strategy Update
Cllr Ottino queried the breadth of the measures included within the report and noted that only some are within the City Council’s which limits capacity for ... view the full minutes text for item 54.
Asked4 Nov 2024Scrutiny Committee
Update on the development of Oxford River Charter
Cllr Ottino queried clarity of responsibilities between the Council and the Environment Agency, particularly regarding maintenance gaps. The Head of Corporate Strategy clarified that some flowing water bodies like brooks fall under the Council’s responsibility rather than Thames Water’s, though the laws on repair and ownership are somewhat unclear. He added that, while the ODS maintained gutters and roadsides on behalf of the County Council to mitigate fluvial flooding risks, options were limited during heavy rainfall.
Asked4 Nov 2024Scrutiny Committee
Update on the development of Oxford River Charter
Cllr Ottino questioned whether landlords would be liable for costs or if the Council would bear them.
Asked4 Nov 2024Scrutiny Committee
Leisure Update
Cllr Ottino queried the improvements made to leisure centres since the supplier change. The Active Communities Manager explained that an improvement roadmap was in place, addressing legacy issues from the previous supplier that would take time to resolve. The Leisure and Active Wellbeing Manager added that an upgrade programme was planned over the next 18 months, focusing on ventilation improvements and retrofitting the changing rooms.
Said29 Oct 2024Audit and Governance Committee
Annual Audit Opinion ODS 23/24
Councillor Ottino raised a question about the governance questionnaire, specifically regarding areas of challenge, asking whether heads of services identified these challenges and if there was a plan to address them. The Non-Executive Director of ODS responded that service areas themselves had identified relevant issues and stated that the audit committees took follow-up action where necessary.
Asked29 Oct 2024Audit and Governance Committee
Annual Governance Statement
Councillor Ottino inquired about the action plan, noting that not all items had been marked for completion. He asked for an update on progress and requested that target dates be specified for each action. The Head of Law and Governance confirmed that an action plan is in place and an updated table with target deadlines will be provided.
Asked29 Oct 2024Audit and Governance Committee
Oxford City Council and Group Audit Planning Report
Councillor Ottino sought clarification on the IFRS 16 lease standard. The External Auditor explained that it is a new standard effective April 2024, involving a reclassification where leases will appear on the balance sheet.
Moved7 Oct 2024Council
Motions on notice October 2024
a) Winter Fuel Payments (Proposed by Cllr Chris Smowton , Seconded by Cllr Lawrence Fouweather ) [Amendment Proposed by Cllr David Henwood, Seconded by Cllr Ian Yeatman ] [Amendment Proposed by Cllr Simon Ottino , seconded by Cllr Anna Railton] b) Keep Campsfield Closed (Proposed by Cllr Alex Powell, Seconded by Cllr Dr Hosnieh Djarafi-Marbini ) Cllrs Pressel and L Smith left the meeting and did not return.
Moved7 Oct 2024Council
Winter Fuel Payments (Proposed by Cllr Chris Smowton, Seconded by Cllr Lawrence Fouweather) [Amendment Proposed by Cllr David Henwood, Seconded by Cllr Ian Yeatman] [Amendment Proposed by Cllr Simon Ottino, seconded by Cllr Anna Railton]
Councillor Simon Ottino proposed an amendment to the motion and was seconded by Councillor Anna Railton. Following debate and on being put to the vote, the amendment was lost.
Named24 Jul 2024Audit and Governance Committee
Investigation Team Annual Report 2024/25
In response to a question from Councillor Ottino, regarding the methods used to identify possibly fraudulent behaviour, it was explained how the team has implemented data from the National Fraud Initiative to identify housing applications with a risk of being fraudulent.
Said24 Jul 2024Audit and Governance Committee
Investigation Team Annual Report 2024/25
Councillor Ottino noted how the figures presented compared to previous years; stated that there has been a year-on-year rise, so the rise ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Asked24 Jul 2024Audit and Governance Committee
Annual Report and Statement of Assurance 2023/24
Councillor Ottino also asked why transactions are taking so long to review and approve. In response, the Internal Auditor stated that capacity issues were a central reason for this. Now that an invoice system has been implemented, this will help to address this issue and had recommended that sanctions be put in place, in the event that transactions are not being approved in a timely manner.
Asked24 Jul 2024Audit and Governance Committee
Risk Management Report as at 30 June 2024
Councillor Ottino asked about the procurement of a management system and if there is anyway for this to be done more quickly. In response, they could not develop their own system, because this would be too time consuming. However, there is a wide range of management system products available and they have employed a consultant to help them determine which system is the most suitable for their needs.
Moved15 Jul 2024Council
Motions on notice July 2024
a) Oxford United Stadium (proposed by Cllr Mark Clarkson, seconded by Cllr Ed Turner) b) Motion of No Confidence in Thames Water and development of an Oxford city river action plan (proposed by Cllr Jo Sandelson, seconded by Cllr Katherine Miles) [amendment proposed by Cllr Simon Ottino , seconded by Cllr Jarvis] Motions not taken as the time allocated for debate had finished:
Seconded15 Jul 2024Council
Oxford United Stadium (Proposed by Cllr Mary Clarkson, seconded by Cllr Ed Turner)
Cllr Mary Clarkson, seconded by Cllr Simon Ottino, proposed the motion as set out in the briefing notes and clarified the motion referred to parcel of land known as ‘The Triangle’, where the stadium is proposed to be built.
Moved15 Jul 2024Council
Motion of No Confidence in Thames Water and development of an Oxford city river action plan (proposed by Cllr Jo Sandelson, seconded by Cllr Katherine Miles) [amendment proposed by Cllr Simon Ottino, seconded by Cllr Jarvis]
Cllr Simon Ottino proposed a combined amendment to the motion and was seconded by Cllr Chris Jarvis. Council debated the amended motion. Following debate and on being put to the vote, the proposed amendment was agreed.
Named22 May 2024Licensing & Gambling Acts Casework Sub-Committee
Election of Chair for the hearings
Councillor Ottino was elected Chair for the hearing.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.