Election of Deputy Chair for the 2026/27 Council Year
Cllr Overton was nominated by Cllr Hannaby and seconded by Cllr Snowdon.
Every time Oxfordshire's minutes name Councillor Hannaby, as the council published it.
Cllr Overton was nominated by Cllr Hannaby and seconded by Cllr Snowdon.
Councillor Levy moved and Councillor Hannaby seconded the recommendations and they were approved.
Cllr Leffman, Leader of the Council Cllr Fawcett, Deputy Leader of the Council and Cabinet member for Resources Cllr Bearder, Cabinet Member for Adults Cllr Gaul, Cabinet Member for Children and Young People Cllr Gregory, Cabinet Member for Public Health and Inequalities Cllr Hannaby, Cabinet Member for Community Wellbeing and Safety Cllr Levy, Cabinet Member for Finance, Property and Transformation Cllr Roberts, Cabinet Member for Place, Environment and Climate Change Martin Reeves, Chief Executive Lorna Baxter, Deputy Chief Executive and Section 151 Officer Ansaf Azhar, Director for Public Health and Communities Annette Perrington, Deputy Director of Education and Inclusion Delia Mann, Deputy Director of Children’s Social Care Ian Dyson, Director of Financial and Commercial Services Karen Fuller, Director of Adult Social Services Kathy Wilcox, Head of Corporate Finance Natalie Crawford, Capital Programme Manager Paul Fermer, Director of Environment and Highways Rob MacDougall, Chief Fire Officer and Director for Community Safety Robin Rogers, Director of Economy and Place Susannah Wintersgill, Director of Public Affairs and Policy Partnerships Vic Kurzeja, Director of Property and Assets All other Council Members were invited to attend as guests, those attending included:
Councillor Leffman moved, and Councillor Hannaby seconded the recommendation, and it was approved.
Councillor Roberts moved and Councillor Hannaby seconded the recommendations, and they were approved.
The Committee requested an update on the Fire and Rescue Improvement Programme, and invited Cllr Jenny Hannaby, Cabinet member for Community Safety, to present the report and Rob MacDougall, Chief Fire Officer and Director of Community Safety, to answer the Committee’s questions.
Councillor Fawcett proposed Councillor Leffman and Councillor Hannaby seconded the nomination.
Councillor Hannaby proposed Councillor Fawcett and Councillor Roberts seconded the nomination.
Councillor Roberts moved and Councillor Hannaby seconded the recommendations, and they were approved.
Councillor Lugova was nominated by Councillor Hannaby and seconded by Councillor Smith.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby, Deputy Chair of the Education and Young People Overview and Scrutiny Committee, presented the report on Local Area Partnership SEND Update .
Cllr Hannaby, the Deputy Chair, was also a current member of HOSC.
· Councillor Bob Johnston to be the substitute for Councillor Jenny Hannaby · Councillor Nick Leverton to be appointed as substitute for Councillor Ted Fenton · Every Member of the Audit and Governance Committee could attend the as observers, if not appointed to the AWG as formal Members Resolved that the Committee:
· Members for the AWG needed to also nominate substitutes · Members nominated to the AWG were, Cllr Ted Fenton, Cllr Roz Smith, Cllr Jenny Hannaby, Cllr Glynis Phillips and Co-optee Geoff Jones as the Chair.
Cllr Hannaby declared that she was involved with Wantage Community Hospital.
Cllr Smith proposed Cllr Hannaby and Cllr Bennett seconded the nomination.
With no other nominations and no objections, Cllr Hannaby was ELECTED Deputy Chair for 2024/25.
Councillor Johnston proposed Councillor Smith, and this was seconded by Councillor Hannaby.
The report was moved by Councillor Jane Hanna, Chair of the scrutiny committee and seconded by Councillor Jenny Hannaby.
Cllr Hanna was nominated by Cllr Lygo, and seconded by Cllr Hannaby for the role of Chair, with no other nominations.
Cllr Smith proposed Cllr Graham and this was seconded by Cllr Hannaby.
Councillor Hannaby and [name removed] were attending virtually to hear the debate.
Cllr Hannaby declared that she was Chair of the Wantage Town Council Health Committee.
The Chair proposed the nomination of Councillor Jenny Hannaby to replace Councillor Sally Povolotsky who wished to stand down.
Cllr Jenny Hannaby declared that she was Chair of the Wantage Town Council Health Committee.
Councillor Hannaby to replace Councillor Ley Place Overview & Scrutiny Committee: Councillor Ley to replace Councillor Gregory Buckinghamshire Oxfordshire Berkshire West Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee: Councillor Hannaby to replace Councillor Ley Future Oxfordshire Partnership Scrutiny Panel: Councillor Constance to replace Councillor Walker Audit & Governance Committee: Councillor Hannaby to replace Councillor van Mierlo Remuneration Committee: Councillor Constance to replace Councillor Ford People Overview & Scrutiny Committee: Councillor Hannaby to replace Councillor Thomas Planning & Regulation Committee: Councillor Fenton to replace Councillor Bloomfield Place Overview & Scrutiny Committee: Councillor Constance to replace Councillor Fatemian Council noted the following appointment notified by the Leader:
Councillor Jane Hanna moved and Councillor Jenny Hannaby seconded the following motion:
The Chair welcomed Councillor Jenny Hannaby onto the Committee and Shilpa Manek as the Committee Officer.
Councillor Gregory replaced Councillor Hannaby as Cabinet Member for Community Services & Safety.
It was AGREED that the registered speaker, Cllr Hannaby, speaking of Chair of the Wantage Town Council Health Committee be invited to contribute alongside other speakers on the substantive item.
Councillor Phillips moved and Councillor Hannaby seconded the recommendations and they were approved.
With the Chair’s permission, Cllr Hannaby made a statement expressing concerns around the closures of the inpatient unit in Wantage Hospital, which have lasted for seven years. It was emphasised that the closure would not only impact Wantage residents in general but also those who could have potentially benefited from being treated at the hospital; and that residents would have to receive treatments in various other locations.
Cllr Hannaby then proceeded to praise the workshop with Oxford Health and the Integrated Care Board (including the work of the Board’s place lead for Oxfordshire) in attempting to resolve this.
Cllr Hannaby referred to some of the transportation and access challenges for patients who would have to receive treatment elsewhere.
Cllr Hannaby then emphasised the imperative for any information relevant to the engagement to be shared well in advance.
The Chair concluded with a suggestion that Cllr Hannaby have an additional discussion with the Chair to discuss the nature and scope of the public engagement further, and reiterated Cllr Hannaby’s emphasis on relevant information being shared with participants well in advance of any workshop. The Chair also stated that, as per the agreement of the committee at the last meeting, a shared history of developments is to be provided to NHS colleagues in relation to Wantage Hospital.
Cllr Jenny Hannaby, Cabinet Member for Community Services and Safety, and Rob MacDougall, Chief Fire Officer, and the Thames Valley Police Crime Prevention Design Advisor also attended.
It was AGREED that Cllr Hannaby, who wished to speak in regards to Wantage Hospital, be able to do so prior to the relevant item (Chair’s Update).
Cllr Hannaby addressed the Committee in relation to Wantage Hospital, specifically the activity of Wantage Town Council and its Health Sub-Committee. A formal consultation on the temporary closure of beds at Wantage Hospital remained outstanding, almost seven years after the closure. The Town Council had taken legal advice around this and it had been informed that as Oxford Health had not declined to undertake a consultation there was little basis for the Town Council to make any form of challenge.
Cllr Hannaby also reported that she had sought clarity over what would happen to community hospital beds across the county if the model of providing care at home more extensively were to be pursued but had not received a satisfactory reply. The Town Council’s views were that an independently-facilitated workshop would need to take place, and to take place quickly in light of the impending changes to HOSC’s powers of referral to the Secretary of State. An extraordinary meeting of the Town Council’s sub-group would be taking place to identify its suggestions for services (not primary care) at the hospital.
Cllr Hannaby thanked the HOSC for its support in trying to find a shared solution.
Council noted the following appointments:- Cllr Elphinstone to be appointed to the vacancy on Audit and Governance Committee Cllr Elphinstone to replace Councillor Edosomwan on People Overview and Scrutiny Committee Cllr Povolotsky to replace Cllr Gregory on People Overview ad Scrutiny Committee Cllr Gregory to replace Cllr Povolotsky on Place Overview and Scrutiny Committee Shadow Cabinet changes Cllr Fenton has replaced Cllr Bulmer, shadowing Cllr Hannaby, Cabinet Member for Cabinet Member for Community Services and Safety Cllr Constance has replaced Cllr Fenton, shadowing Cllr Sudbury, Cabinet Member for Climate Change Delivery and Environment
Wantage – Market Place West – proposed permanent amendment to vehicle access and parking places Bill Falkenau – Clerk, Wantage Town Council (3 mins, in person) Cllr Jenny Hannaby (5 mins, in person) General comments in support of 20mph speed limits in Oxfordshire Danny Yee – Oxfordshire Liveable Streets (3 mins, in person) 15. Uffington : proposed 20mph speed limits Mike Tustin (3 mins, MS Teams) Benjamin Rule (written statement) Carineh Shahbazian (written statement) 18.
Bill Falkenau, Clerk of Wantage Town Council delivered his written statement, which was subsequently endorsed by Cllr Jenny Hannaby.
The recommendations were proposed by Councillor Miller, seconded by Councillor Hannaby and agreed.
Councillor Hannaby seconded the recommendations and they were agreed.
Oxfordshire Temporarily Closed Services Update Julie Mabberley Councillor Jenny Hannaby 7. Healthwatch Oxfordshire Report Carol Stavris and Marie Walsh (on behalf of Didcot Against Austerity)
Councillor Miller moved and Councillor Hannaby seconded the recommendations which were agreed.
Councillor Enright moved and Councillor Hannaby seconded the recommendations and they were agreed.
Councillor Hannaby seconded the recommendations and they were agreed.
The recommendations as amended were proposed by Councillor Gant and seconded by Councillor Hannaby. The recommendations were approved with 6 votes in favour and 1 against.
Item 6 Integrated Care Programme for Oxfordshire Julie Mabberley Councillor Jenny Hannaby (statement only)
The recommendations as amended were proposed by Councillor Sudbury and seconded by Councillor Hannaby.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby welcomed the proposal to move on vacant properties, which had been a frustrating issue for local Members. She asked that Members and residents be consulted on any proposals in their area.
The recommendation was proposed by Councillor Miller, seconded by Councillor Hannaby and agreed.
The recommendations were moved by Councillor Brighouse, seconded by Councillor Hannaby and agreed.
Council noted the following appointments:- Cllr Howson to replace Cllr Povolotsky on Pension Fund Committee Cllr Mallon to replace Cllr Corkin on Performance Overview and Scrutiny Committee Cllr Leverton to replace Cllr Ash on People Overview and Scrutiny Committee Cllr Hannaby to replace Cllr Fawcett on Oxfordshire County Council Joint Consultative Committee for Uniformed Members of the Fire Service Cllr Constance to replace Cllr Ford on Audit and Governance Committee Cllr Ford to replace Cllr Corkin on Remuneration Committee Cllr Levy to replace Cllr van Mierlo on Oxfordshire Joint Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee Cllr van Mierlo to replace Cllr Levy on Place Overview and Scrutiny Committee Shadow Cabinet Leader – Cllr Reeves Deputy Leader – Cllr Ford Children, Education and Young People’s Services – Cllr Simpson Corporate Services – Cllr Ford Community Services and Safety – Cllr Bulmer Highways Management – Cllr Walker Finance – Cllr Bartholomew Adult Social Care – Cllr Leverton Travel and Development Strategy – Cllr Snowdon Climate Change Delivery and Environment – Cllr Fenton
In relation to question 3 (Question from Cllr Eddie Reeves to Cllr Calum Miller) Cllr Miller undertook to provide a written reply detailing the amount of funding from the Housing and Growth Deal and DLUCH for the A34 junction at Lodge Hill In relation to question 5 (Question from Cllr Donna Ford to Cllr Jenny Hannaby) Cllr Hannaby confirmed that she would provide an update on the proposed relocation of Banbury Library
The recommendations were proposed by Councillor Enright, seconded by Councillor Hannaby and agreed.
The recommendation was proposed by Councillor Lygo, seconded by Councillor Hannaby and agreed.
Item 5 Oxfordshire Integrated Improvement Programme Julie Mabberley Councillor Jenny Hannaby
Councillor Jenny Hannaby , Wantage & Grove, noted that demographic information was very important in planning health and care services. She asked if the census data by age range and postcode for 2011 and 2021 could be provided as well as growth forecasts to the end of the local plan period in 2031.
Cllr Pete Sudbury explained the measures being taken to reduce Scope 3 carbon emissions and a report would be submitted to the Cabinet in the autumn In relation to a question from Cllr Roz Smith, Cllr Jenny Hannaby said that she intended to visit all 44 of the county’s libraries and would be looking at the measures needed to improve buildings and services where required In relation to a question from Cllr Robin Bennett, Cllr Calum Miller said that the new administration had put in place new capital expenditure controls and steps to deal with inadequately funded schemes inherited from the previous administration.
The recommendations were moved by Councillor Phillips, seconded by Councillor Hannaby and agreed.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby, Cabinet Member for Adult Social Care and Karen Fuller, Interim Corporate Director of Adult and Housing attended the meeting and provided an overview of adult services in Oxfordshire, the adult social care market and delivery.
Cllr Hannaby confirmed that similar assurances would be given to adult care staff.
In relation to paragraph 5 of the report (Question from Cllr Ted Fenton to Cllr Jenny Hannaby) Cllr Hannaby said that the wording of the report was correct In relation to paragraph 5 of the report (Question from Cllr Nick Leverton to Cllr Jenny Hannaby) Cllr Hannaby confirmed that the Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee (HOSC) would stay in place.
The Chair welcomed Members of the Board and other attendees noting that this was an “In-Person” meeting, but that Councillor Jenny Hannaby was attending “virtually” via Microsoft Teams.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby participated remotely due to isolating.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby, Cabinet Member for Adult Social Care, introduced the report and thanked its author, Ian Bottomley, for an excellent report. There has been an agreement in place to pool health and social care budgets since 2013. In 2020/21 the partners developed the Health, Education and Social Care Integrated Commissioning Team.
The partnership had worked well and Councillor Hannaby had every confidence that it would continue to do so. She noted that none of the pooled budgets may be spent without all of the partners’ agreement. She put the recommendations to Cabinet.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby, Cabinet Member for Adult Social Care, introduced Jayne Chidgey-Clark, Independent Chair, OSAB; Alison Chapman, Designated Nurse and Safeguarding Lead, Oxfordshire Clinical Commissioning Group and Karen Fuller, Deputy Director Adult Social Care.
Councillor Hannaby welcomed Jayne Chidgey-Clark and thanked officers for the report and for all the work of the wonderful team in safeguarding.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby praised library staff for being so welcoming and had been delighted to see so many children using the library on a recent visit.
In relation to Item 10, Community Services Strategy, Councillor Jenny Hannaby stated that she had a non-pecuniary interest as Chair of the League of Friends of Wantage Hospital and Trustee of Wantage Community Nursing Home.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby introduced Alison Chapman , Designated Nurse and Safeguarding Lead , Oxfordshire Clinical Commissioning Group, and Karen Fuller, Deputy Director Adult Social Care, Oxfordshire County Council, who highlighted the following points:
Councillor Jenny Hannaby supported the principles and looked forward to seeing how the community and voluntary sector would be incorporated into plans as they developed. She was pleased to see that GPs were being involved. She felt that they needed more support with communications with patients.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby welcomed the Plan adding that decisions on allocating the funds were made after real discussion in the partnership and the funds enabled us to ensure that people were Home First and Living Well.
In relation to paragraph 7 of the report (Question from Councillor Ian Corkin to Councillor Jenny Hannaby) Councillor Hannaby undertook to provide Councillor Corkin with a written answer on the delayed transfer of care figures for the county, including the number of patients currently delayed and the average length of any such delay.
In relation to paragraph 16 of the report (Question from Councillor Ian Corkin to Councillor Jenny Hannaby) Councillor Hannaby undertook to provide Councillor Corkin with a written answer to confirm how many default Social Care assessments had been issued and what was being done to stop the practice.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby summarised the report. This strategy sat above the individual councils’ strategies and would strengthen the resolve to work together.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby nominated Councillor Mark Lygo.
In relation to item 9, Oxfordshire Community Services, Councillor Jenny Hannaby declared a non-pecuniary interest as Chairman of Wantage Community Hospital League of Friends.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby, Cabinet Member for Adult Social Services, noted that maternity services in Wantage Community Hospital had been closed due to staff shortages only months after being reopened. Those in need of services had to go to Wallingford or the John Radcliffe in Oxford.
Julie Mabberley Cllr Jenny Hannaby
Councillor Jenny Hannaby recounted the history of the closure of in-patient beds at Wantage Hospital for new members of the Committee. She blamed the closure in 2016 on a lack of maintenance by Oxford Health. She praised the hard work of the local community in campaigning for the hospital and participating in the work of the stakeholder group.
Councillor Hannaby, as new Cabinet Member for Adult Social Care, stated that she was well aware of the excellent work supporting people in their homes but she believed that there was still a place for Community Hospitals and she asked that a strategy be implemented and not just talked about.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby is the Chairman of Wantage Hospital League of Friends and Chairman of the Trust of Wantage Nursing Home.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby noted that Wantage Hospital will have been closed for five years which could not be considered temporary. She said that the closure was due to Oxford Health’s failure to maintain the hospital properly. She asked if any other community hospitals were being engaged in the process.
Councillor Hannaby agreed with the approach of supporting more people in their homes but believed that Wantage Hospital could play a valuable role in reablement, especially for those with no family. She asked why Wantage Hospital was being singled out rather than having a county-wide picture.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby asked if housing providers and district councils would be among the partners involved. Ansaf Azhar responded that the governing board was already in place and he certainly saw a role for district councils. He could see that there were some quick tangible actions that could be achieved but that the preventative approach would take some time.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby supported the comments from the previous speaker and thanked the members of the Task and Finish Group and support officers for their work and thanked the Committee for its support over the years. Wantage Town Council’s Health Committee had again called for the re-opening of the beds at the community hospital by whatever means it takes. They believed that the hospital was much valued by residents for the professional care it gave for rehabilitation, enablement and end-of-life care.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby referred to Page 5 of the presentation in Addenda 2: where it recognised that OX12 residents needed to have confidence in their access to effective rehabilitation whether in hospital or at home . She said that the question was “what hospital?” – Wantage or having to travel across the county?
Councillor Hannaby asked for the evidence that safe services can be provided long-term at home, free at the point of need. She noted that during the pandemic, patients who were not yet well enough to go home were put in a hotel with agency staff when they could have been looked after in Wantage Community Hospital.
Councillor Hannaby asked how much developer funding had been drawn down since OCCG took over primary care commissioning. She believed that there was £1.2m currently held by planners and suggested that some of that could be used to fund the proposed strategy.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby declared a personal interest in relation to Motion 7 as Chairman of the Wantage Hospital League of Friends in the event that there was discussion on hospitals.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby asked how bad debts were monitored as some of them were very large amounts.
Wallingford St Georges Road County Councillor Jane Hanna County Councillor Jenny Hannaby ) 10.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby declared a personal non-pecuniary interest in Agenda Item 12 by Virtue of her position as Chairman of a local Nursing Home and Chairman of Wantage Hospital League of Friends.
In relation to Question 30, Councillor Stratford undertook to provide Councillor Hannaby with a written answer detailing whether the contract gave the elderly and their families had the same rights and choices that existed when they had concerns and complaints as existed when the elderly received their reablement in Acute of Community Hospital provision and in relation to the new Living Well at Home future Commissioning which was a large part of the County budget spend. As the cost of delivering the new service would be met from the Pooled Budget fund, where would the accountability, monitoring and outcomes sit within the new service.
In relation to Question 31, Councillor Stratford undertook to provide Councillor Hannaby with a written answer on how the new way of working safeguards the elderly and vulnerable in their homes without 24hrs care continuity.
Councillor Hanna moved and Councillor Hannaby seconded the following Motion:
Councillor Jenny Hannaby, Chairman of the League of Friends of Wantage Hospital, summarised the history of the hospital and described how services and bed numbers had been reduced since it had been taken over by Oxford Health, culminating in the hospital being closed for four years due to a serious maintenance problem. She contrasted the experience with that of Wallingford Hospital which was lauded in a recent report in the Oxford Mail. She said that as Chairman of Wantage Town Council Health Committee she looked forward to meeting with Oxford Health to discuss the Strategic Development and Quality Improvement Plan.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby noted that some of the figures in the presentation were just percentages without the total numbers. The Chief Constable agreed to provide more detailed figures.
Councillor Hannaby also asked for more information on the independent group that reviews Stop and Search, what measures are taken to protect police from attacks and how that is balanced against the need for face-to-face contact which is important in terms of public confidence.
In relation to Question 24, Councillor Stratford undertook to provide Councillor Hannaby with a written answer detailing how many homes were participating in designated settings; how much more funding they would receive and how that would be funded.
McIlveen, Shadow Cabinet Member for Local Communities (gave apologies) Item 10 – Climate Action Framework Councillor John Sanders, Shadow Cabinet Member for Environment Item 11– OSCB Councillor Liz Brighouse, Chair of Performance Scrutiny Committee Item 12– OSAB Councillor Liz Brighouse, Chair of Performance Scrutiny Committee Item 13 – CPE Councillor Jenny Hannaby, local councillor for Grove & Wantage Councillor Judy Roberts, local councillor for North Hinksey (did not speak)
Cabinet considered a report seeking approval to make a formal application to the Department for Transport to implement CPE across the remaining districts Councillor Jenny Hannaby, local councillor for Grove & Wantage spoke in support of the proposals., Councillor Constance, Cabinet Member for Environment introduced the contents of the report and moved the recommendations.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby declared a personal non-pecuniary interest in Agenda Item 18 by virtue of her positions as Chairman of a Wantage Care Home and Chairman of Wantage Hospital League of Friends;
In relation to Question 18, Councillor Stratford undertook to provide Councillor Hannaby with a copy of the plans referred to in the answer, together with an explanation as to what monitoring would be taking place in relation supporting the vulnerable.
In relation to question 26 (Question from Councillor Hannaby to Councillor Hudspeth) Councillor Heathcoat undertook to take back the question to Councillor Hudspeth as to whether he would support the recent Healthwatch report into an enquiry of Care Homes.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby declared an interest in relation to Agenda Item 8 Homecare Budgets and Future Commissioning Arrangements in that she is the Chairman of the Trustees of Wantage Community Hospital and Chairman of Wantage Hospital League of Friends.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby stated that the situation was very upsetting. Some service users had been there 25 years. She confirmed that parents were pleased with the Council’s involvement and with the alternative arrangements made.
Maggie Swain, Save Wantage Hospital Campaign Group Bill Falkenau, Clerk, Wantage Town Council Bernard Connolly, Wantage & Grove Campaign Group Terry Knight, Save Wantage Hospital Campaign Group Julie Mabberley, Chair of the Stakeholders’ Reference Group Councillor Jenny Hannaby, Grove and Wantage The Chairman decided to take the speakers at the start of Item 9.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby , Grove and Wantage, said that despite her reservations about the process she decided to participate. It was very disappointing that there was only one question about the hospital on the questionnaire. One thousand people marched and ten thousand signed a petition to say that they wanted the hospital back.
Officers also confirmed an amendment for paragraph 6 of the report to read as follows “Funding for the proposed measures has been provided by the Councillor Priority Fund and Oxfordshire County Council’s Parish Funded Works (South) Capital Budget” [name removed] confirmed support from the local member County Councillor Jenny Hannaby and Wantage Town Council. Referring to the response from the Fire & Rescue service he added that that had not been interpreted as an objection to the specific scheme but more a generic comment regarding enforcement.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby declared non-pecuniary interest in Agenda Item 14 (Motion by Councillor Eddie Reeves) by virtue of her position as Chairman of the Trustees for Wantage Community Nursing Home.
In relation to paragraph 2 of the report (HIF Marginal Viability (mv) Funding Agreements Bicester & Wantage) (Question from Councillor Hannaby to Councillor Hudspeth) Councillor Hudspeth undertook to look into when the final contracts would be signed so that work could commence; and to put as much pressure on the process as possible.
The real-life birthing experiences of local mothers cannot continue to be overlooked and Council will do all it can to ensure their voices are heard.” Councillor Tim Bearder moved and Councillor Jenny Hannaby seconded the following amendment as set out below in bold italics and Strikethrough:
Councillor Hannaby – In 2015 quarrying had finished but there had been annual applications for storage of material which then meant long delays for restoration. There had been a great deal of local objection to what was seen as a deliberate ploy to delay restoration of what ... view the full minutes text for item 25/19
· Didcot Town Councillor, Cathy Augustine, in relation to Agenda Items 5, 6, 8, and 10 · Julie Mabberly, on behalf of ‘Save Wantage Hospital Campaign, in relation to Agenda Item 7 · Maggie Swain, ‘Save Wantage Hospital Campaign’ – in relation to Agenda Item 7 · County Councillor Jenny Hannaby, in relation to Agenda Items 7, 9 and 10 · County Councillor Jane Hanna, in relation to Agenda Items 5, 7, 8, and 12
Councillor Jenny Hannaby called for a wider vision to the project, to include all localities in the south of Oxfordshire. It was her view that the CCG was not progressing very quickly on the Wantage Hospital project. She pointed out that Wantage Hospital had not been included within the consultation under scrutiny at this meeting and this was not the correct manner in which to approach it, time had been lost.
Prior to consideration of this item the Committee was addressed by Councillor Jenny Hannaby. She commented that she had been pleased that the CQC had recognised the work which had taken place on better working relationships with Health partners; and that it had been found that strategic development to be more robust in the usage of performance data. She suggested that this Committee should carry out an investigation into how far the voluntary sector would like more involvement/collaboration with the Health & Wellbeing Board, which could lead to better services.
She observed that Councillor Hannaby had focused on the work which was still required as a result of the inspection. As an outcome of the re-review, the CQC had noted that:
Councillor Jenny Hannaby stated she had asked why services were not being brought back to Abingdon and Wantage. She reported that she had spoken to the Chief Executive of Oxford Health about Wantage Hospital not being allowed to take over facilities and he, as a result, contacted the CCG to offer the service at Wantage. Unfortunately, by this time, Healthshare had made other arrangements for the service to be provided at Faringdon .
Councillor Hannaby thanked the Committee for convening the Task & Finish Group, which in her view had opened the public’s eyes to the situation.
Cllr Ian Corkin attended for Cllr Dr Simon Clarke, Cllr Jenny Hannaby for Cllr Alison Rooke and City Cllr Mark Ladbrooke attended for City Cllr Susanna Pressel.
Cllr Jenny Hannaby, local member for Wantage, expressed her concern that the physiotherapy department had ceased to operate from Wantage Hospital. Instead people were being allocated to premises in Faringdon , to which there were no bus services. She had recently been informed that people could also go to Witney and Wallingford community hospitals to access these services.
Councillor Hannaby moved and Councillor Webber seconded the following motion:
In relation to question 5 (Question to Councillor Constance from Councillor Hannaby , Councillor Constance gave an undertaking to follow up on the suggestion that the Council extend its current maintenance Contract.
Item 6 – Councillor Nick Hards, Shadow Cabinet Member for Finance Councillor Liz Brighouse, Chairman of Performance Scrutiny Committee Item 7– Councillor Nick Hards, Shadow Cabinet Member for Finance Councillor Richard Webber, Leader of the Liberal Democrat Group Item 8 – Rachael Scott- Hunter who also submitted a petition in support of stopping the closure of day support centres Ted Cooper resident of Witney Maggie Swain, Chair of the October Club Management Committee Councillor Jenny Hannaby, local councillor for Grove & Wantage Councillor Janet Godden, Liberal Democrat Group spokesperson on adult social care Councillor Glynis Phillips, Shadow Cabinet Member for Adult Social Care Councillor Liz Brighouse, Chairman of Performance Scrutiny Committee Item 9 – Councillor Janet Godden, Liberal Democrat Group spokesperson on adult social care Councillor Glynis Phillips, Shadow Cabinet Member for Adult Social Care Item 10 – Councillor Glynis Phillips , Shadow Cabinet Member for Adult Social Care Item 11 – Jaqi Mason, Parish Councillor, Clifton Hampden & Burcot speaking on behalf of OXAGE Councillor Charles Mathew, local councillor for Eynsham Councillor Lynda Atkins, local councillor Councillor Steve Curran, Shadow Cabinet Member for Environment Councillor Godden, Liberal Democrat Group spokesperson on adult social care spoke together on Agenda Items 8 and 9.
Councillor Hannaby, local councillor for Grove & Wantage , expressed pleasure that Wantage was to retain its day centre. She commented that she had made the suggestion that Centres could amalgamate some time ago.
Councillor Hannaby whilst sorry that the review was necessary in light of government funding cuts she recognised that people with eligible needs would have those needs met. Her concern was for those on personal budgets or self funders . She added that transport needed more work to clarify how it would work in practice.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby declared a Personal Interest in relation to Agenda Items 11, 13 and 14 due to her role as Vice-President of the Wantage Branch of the Royal British Legion and also Chairman of the newly formed Friends of the Health & Wellbeing Centre Wantage Trust and Chairman of the Wantage League of Friends Hospital .
In relation to paragraph 6, (Development in the Oxfordshire Care Partnership Agreement) (Question from Councillor Hannaby ) responding to a request for assurances that the changes to the project agreement would have little impact on those residents already in the five care homes whose freehold would soon be transferred and that they would not be required to vacate to cheaper residential homes in the future and that the resident and families would be consulted at all times, Councillor Fatemian undertook to provide a written response.
In relation to Question 5, Councillor Fatemian undertook to provide Councillor Hannaby with a written response regarding Wantage Hospital, once he had received details on the specific situation from Councillor Hannaby .
Item 6 - Councillor Charles Mathew, speaking as Local Member [name removed] , Senior Planning Officer, West Oxfordshire District Council [name removed] , Member of CAGE [name removed], Member of PAGE Councillor Patrick Greene, speaking as Local Member Councillor Lynda Atkins, speaking as Local Member Councillor Anne Purse, Shadow Cabinet Member for Growth & Infastructure Professor John Dowling [name removed], Chairman of Cholsey Parish Council Item 8 - Councillor Susanna Pressel , speaking as Local Member [name removed], ROX Councillor Alan Armitage , speaking as Local Member [name removed] , Oxfordshire Unlimited Item 9 – Councillor Jenny Hannaby , Shadow Cabinet Member for Adult Services Item 11 - Councillor Jenny Hannaby , Shadow Cabinet Member for Adult Services Item 13 – Councillor Alan Armitage , Shadow Cabinet Member for Finance & Property Item 14 – Councillor Jean Fooks , Shadow Cabinet Member for Deputy Leader Item 15 - Councillor Jenny Hannaby , Shadow Cabinet Member for Adult Services.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby spoke in support of Health & Wellbeing being returned to the County. She urged the Director for Public Health to work closely with districts councils to ensure the well-being of those in rural areas. She expressed hope that Scruitny and Health Watch would provide a means of monitoring how well the new board was performing and that Oxfordshire could be a flagship for the rest of the Country.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby , Shadow Cabinet Member for Adult Services spoke in support of paragraphs 15, 16 and 17 of the report CA11, namely that Members should have a central role in the further development and promotion of personalisation in Oxfordshire and in the Adult Services Scrutiny Committee considering proposals for Members to take a more formal role in assuring service quality across key provision in their local area. She stressed that there would need to be a firm division of officers and member processes.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby , Shadow Cabinet Member for Adult Services stated that the area for Older people and people with Physical disabilities and People with Learning Disabilities had not historically in some areas preformed as well as she would have liked. She hoped the new agreement, which she noted had a cut off clause, would make a difference including a proper look at the services with more focus on areas needing improvement She sought assurance that their would be sufficient residential care and respite places available and that supported living support services, which would be funded through personal budgets, received the correct funding and that monitoring took place to make sure the funding is sufficient for their needs.
The Cabinet Member for Adult Services responded to the points made commenting that he was aware of the concerns that Councillor Hannaby raised and would continue to monitor the situation carefully.
Item 8 - Councillor Zoe Patrick, Leader of the Opposition and Olive McIntosh-Stedman Item 9 – Councillor Jenny Hannaby , Shadow Cabinet Member for Adult Services Item 10 and 11– Councillor Jean Fooks , Deputy Leader of the Opposition
Councillor Hannaby recognised the need to make savings but expressed some concern regarding the reduction in the number of residential beds and monitoring of self funding and stressed that those not eligible for self funding should be helped. She highlighted the potential to work with district councils to include extra care housing in the local plan process.
The Cabinet Member for Adult Services commended the proposals and welcomed the comment by Councillor Hannaby regarding extra care housing. There would be further reports to the Adult Services Scrutiny Committee on these proposals and to the Cabinet in March regarding care home fees.
Item 8 Councillor Janet Godden as Shadow Cabinet Member for Children, Education & Families Item 10 Tim May, Vice-Chairman of the Trustees of Soldiers of Oxfordshire Item 11 Councillor Jenny Hannaby as Shadow Cabinet Member for Adult Services [name removed], Friends of Stowford, a charity which supports adults with learning disabilities in supported living Item 12 Councillor Jenny Hannaby as Shadow Cabinet Member for Adult Services Item 13 Councillor Jenny Hannaby as Shadow Cabinet Member for Adult Services Item 14 Councillor Jean Fooks as local member Item 16 Cllr Jean Fooks, Opposition Deputy Leader
Councillor Jenny Hannaby , Shadow Cabinet Member for Adult Services commented that the when considering the Transformation of Adult Social Care the Adult Services Scrutiny Committee had stressed the importance of adequate ICT and that enough funding be included to provide proper support of the new arrangements. A figure of £2m had been included and she was concerned that the latest proposal not to go for a new system was based on the need for savings and was concerned as to whether it would jeopardise the Transformation agenda.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby welcomed the report and congratulated officers on their efforts.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby - as local member 10.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby, speaking as a local member referred to local efforts to ensure the future of ‘Sweatbox’ and supported the transfer. She commented that the school had been supportive.
A petition was presented by Angie Goff, representing the Wolvercote Commoners requesting Oxfordshire County Council to ensure that the Godstow Road bridge over the canal and railway remains able to carry heavy goods vehicles up to at least a 26 tonne limit, until and when it is strengthened or rebuilt The Council has agreed the following requests to address the meeting:- Item 6 - Household Waste Recycling Centre Strategy Councillor Anne Purse, Shadow Cabinet Member, Councillor Charles Shouler , speaking as Efficiencies Champion at the invitation of the Chairman Item 7 - Children, Young People & Families Service Redesign Cllr Janet Godden, Shadow Cabinet Member, Cllr Zoe Patrick (as local member) Cllr Liz Brighouse, OBE (as local member), Cat Hobbs , Save Our Services Charlie Riley, Save our UK Youth Clubs but speaking on behalf of an individual Club Item 8 - Changes to the Internal Home Support Service Councillor Jenny Hannaby , Shadow Cabinet Member Item 10 - Charlton Primary School Councillor Zoe Patrick (as local member) Item 13 - Delegated Powers of the Chief Executive Councillor Zoe Patrick, Opposition Leader
She was working together with Councillor Hannaby to see what could be done. An application under the Big Society Fund had been submitted but there were many calls on this funding. She referred to the work of the Sweatbox and Beatbox and the high levels of local use.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby, Shadow Cabinet Member for Adult Services expressed her admiration for the staff who provided a flagship service that was the envy of other authorities. She stated that she had spoken before about her concern over the speed of the changes and the impact on the ability to assist the most vulnerable users of the service. She was pleased that the contract would be monitored and she would be pressing for a regular report to the Adult Services Scrutiny Committee.
Cllr Jenny Hannaby , Shadow Cabinet Member for Adult Services Item 10.
Cllr Jenny Hannaby , Shadow Cabinet Member for Adult Services Item 13.
Cabinet considered a report (CA9) that recommended the award of the Carers' Support contract to the successful bidder Age UK, Oxfordshire Councillor Jenny Hannaby, Shadow Cabinet Member for Adult Services sought clarification over the tendering process and in particular the role played by the representative of Age UK on the evaluation panel. She also sought reassurance that the service provided would be properly monitored and scrutinised.
Responding to a query from Councillor Hudspeth about the position being taken by Vale of White Horse District Council Councillor Hannaby stated that it was her understanding that they would not take on existing contracts but would seek to get a longer warranty. It was confirmed that maintenance could be included in personal\ budgets should individuals wish it. It was noted that if a decision was taken to discontinue maintenance then all lifts would be serviced before maintenance was discontinued.
Prior to consideration of this item the Cabinet was addressed by Councillor Jenny Hannaby. She commended the Director and his officers for their achievements as cited in the report. She asked that monitoring continue on the out-sourced areas of safeguarding dignity and on ensuring that sufficient information is conveyed with patients on their hospital discharge.
Councillor Jenny Hannaby, Opposition Shadow Cabinet Member for Adult Services spoke of the extremely high level of service that the County had always given. She hoped that it would be possible to find alternative employment so that the skills and experience of dedicated staff was not lost. She suggested that the proposals be taken forward with less speed, waiting until new providers were in place and all personal budgets transferred.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Hannaby attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 Nov 2025 | County Council | Appointments | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 4 Nov 2025 | County Council | Strategic Plan 2025-2028 | Carried | 39 for, 12 against, 12 abstained | |
| 4 Nov 2025 | County Council | Youth Justice Annual Plan 2025-26 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 4 Nov 2025 | County Council | Motion from Councillor Liam Walker | Lost | 22 for, 36 against, 2 abstained |
Meetings Councillor Hannaby was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 1 of 4 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Hannaby declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12 Sep 2024 | Oxfordshire Joint Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, item 61/24 | Cllr Hannaby declared that she was involved with Wantage Community Hospital. | |
| 23 Nov 2023 | Oxfordshire Joint Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, item 40/23 | Cllr Hannaby declared that she was Chair of the Wantage Town Council Health Committee. | |
| 21 Sep 2023 | Oxfordshire Joint Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee, item 27/23 | Cllr Jenny Hannaby declared that she was Chair of the Wantage Town Council Health Committee. | |
| 7 Oct 2021 | Oxfordshire Health & Wellbeing Board, item 3 | In relation to item 9, Oxfordshire Community Services, Councillor Jenny Hannaby declared a non-pecuniary interest as Chairman of Wantage Community Hospital League of Friends. | |
| 7 Apr 2021 | County Council, item 22/21 | Councillor Jenny Hannaby declared a personal interest in relation to Motion 7 as Chairman of the Wantage Hospital League of Friends in the event that there was discussion on hospitals. | |
| 8 Dec 2020 | County Council, item 70/20 | Councillor Jenny Hannaby declared a personal non-pecuniary interest in Agenda Item 12 by Virtue of her position as Chairman of a local Nursing Home and Chairman of Wantage Hospital League of Friends. | |
| 8 Sep 2020 | County Council, item 39/20 | Councillor Jenny Hannaby declared a personal non-pecuniary interest in Agenda Item 18 by virtue of her positions as Chairman of a Wantage Care Home and Chairman of Wantage Hospital League of Friends; | |
| 9 Jul 2020 | Performance Scrutiny Committee, item 22/20 | Councillor Jenny Hannaby declared an interest in relation to Agenda Item 8 Homecare Budgets and Future Commissioning Arrangements in that she is the Chairman of the Trustees of Wantage Community Hospital and Chairman of Wantage Hospital League of Friends. | |
| 5 Nov 2019 | County Council, item 68/19 | Councillor Jenny Hannaby declared non-pecuniary interest in Agenda Item 14 (Motion by Councillor Eddie Reeves) by virtue of her position as Chairman of the Trustees for Wantage Community Nursing Home. | |
| 3 Apr 2012 | County Council, item 150/12 | Councillor Jenny Hannaby declared a Personal Interest in relation to Agenda Items 11, 13 and 14 due to her role as Vice-President of the Wantage Branch of the Royal British Legion and also Chairman of the newly formed Friends of the Health & Wellbeing Centre Wantage Trust and Chairman of the Wantage League of Friends Hospital . |
Where Councillor Hannaby sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| County Council | Committee Member | Apr 2022 | 3 | 8 Dec 2026 |
| Planning & Regulation Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2026 | 2 | 30 Nov 2026 |
| People Overview & Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2026 | 1 | 3 Dec 2026 |
| Audit & Governance Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2023 | 2 | |
| Oxfordshire Joint Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2023 | 1 | |
| Education and Young People Overview & Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | May 2024 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.