Moved30 Jun 2026County Council
Report from Audit and Governance Committee - Proposed Amendments to the Constitution
The recommendations were moved by Councillor Smith and seconded by Councillor Shiri, Chair and Deputy Chair of the Audit and Governance Committee. Members thanked the members of the working group and the officers supporting it for their work.
Named12 Jun 2026Performance & Corporate Services Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Apologies for Absence and Temporary Appointments
- Cllr Greenaway (for whom Cllr Smith was substituting) - Cllr Mallon (for whom Cllr Evans was substituting) - Cllr Shiri (for whom Cllr Roberts was substituting)
Named12 May 2026Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Chair for the 2026/27 Council Year
Councillor Smith was nominated by Councillor Rawlins and seconded by Councillor Shiri. There were no other nominations.
Named12 May 2026Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Chair for the 2026/27 Council Year
Councillor Smith was deemed elected Chair of the Committee for the 2026/27 Council Year.
Named12 May 2026Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Deputy Chair for the 2026/27 Council Year
Councillor Shiri was nominated by Councillor Smith and seconded by Councillor Shiri There were no other nominations.
Named12 May 2026County Council
Election of Vice-Chair for the 2026/27 Council Year
Councillor Leffman moved, and Councillor McLauchlan seconded, that Councillor Roz Smith be elected as Vice-Chair of the Council for the 2026/27 Council Year.
Named12 May 2026County Council
Election of Vice-Chair for the 2026/27 Council Year
There being no other nominations and no dissent, Councillor Smith was duly declared elected.
Moved12 May 2026County Council
Audit and Governance Committee Annual Report
The report was proposed by Councillor Smith and seconded by Councillor Shiri, Chair and Deputy Chair of the Committee for the 2025/26 Council Year.
Asked24 Mar 2026County Council
Report of the Cabinet
Councillor Smith asked for reassurance that engagement with parishes and neighbourhood meetings would continue during devolution for Oxfordshire.
Moved24 Mar 2026County Council
Officer Code of Conduct (Constitutional Amendment)
The recommendation was moved by Councillor Smith, Chair of the Audit & Governance Committee and seconded by Councillor Shiri, Deputy Chair. Following discussion, the recommendation was approved unanimously with 62 votes in favour, none against and no abstentions.
Asked23 Feb 2026Planning & Regulation Committee
Land at Thrupp Farm, Radley, Abingdon, Oxfordshire Grid (Ref: SU 51539 97065)
Councillor Smith asked for clarification regarding the Section ‘C’ area totalling 50% of the gravel extraction for the entire site and asked the speaker if he knew that to be correct. [name removed] stated that the applicant would have their view but that it was his understanding that the 50% figure was correct.
Named22 Jan 2026Transport Management
Petitions and Public Address
- Danny Yee - Paul Troop - Robin Tucker - Kevin Hickman Item 8: East Oxford CPZ Review 2025 - Cllr Emily Kerr - Cllr Emma Garnett - Danny Yee - Aeron Buchanan - Siobhann Mansell- Pleydell (Items 8 & 9 combined) - Robin Tucker (Items 8 & 9 combined) Item 9: Headington Central CPZ Review 2025 - Cllr Emily Kerr - Cllr Roz Smith - Danny Yee - William Cooke - Hannah Kirby Item 10: Proposed No Waiting Restrictions – Cadogan Park, Woodstock - Cllr Andy Graham - Michael Trumper Item 11: Abingdon Centre East – Proposed Waiting Restrictions - Tim Moose - Jonathan Gayther - Robin Tucker Item 12: Abingdon Town Centre – Parking Amendments - Robin Tucker Item 13: Proposed Pedestrian Crossing & Bus Stops – Twelve Acre Drive, Abingdon - Robin Tucker Item 14: Blackthorn Road, Ambrosden – Traffic Calming and Speed Limits - Robin Tucker
Declared16 Jan 2026Performance & Corporate Services Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Declaration of Interests
Cllr Smith declared that her daughter worked for Oxfordshire Educational Services.
Asked9 Sep 2025County Council
Report of the Cabinet
Councillor Smith asked if an assurance can be given that urban areas like Headington and Quarry will also receive attention in terms of available banks and noted that the post office was also due to close.
Moved9 Sep 2025County Council
Review of Outside Bodies
The recommendations were moved by Councillor Smith and seconded by Councillor Shiri, Chair and Deputy Chair of the Audit and Governance Committee.
Said16 Jul 2025Audit & Governance Committee
Apologies for Absence and Temporary Appointments
The Chair Councillor Roz Smith welcomed everyone to the meeting, especially new independent members Kate Cartwright and Paul McGinn.
Asked8 Jul 2025County Council
Report of the Cabinet
Councillor Smith asked about the Council’s record with apprenticeships.
Moved8 Jul 2025County Council
Appointment of Independent Members of the Audit & Governance Committee
The report was proposed by Councillor Smith and seconded by Councillor Shiri.
Named20 May 2025Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Chair for the 2025/26 Council Year
Councillor Smith was nominated by Councillor Rawlins and seconded by Councillor Hingley. There were no other nominations.
Named20 May 2025Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Chair for the 2025/26 Council Year
Councillor Smith was deemed elected Chair of the Committee for the 2025/26 Council Year.
Named20 May 2025Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Deputy Chair for the 2025/26 Council Year
Councillor Shiri was nominated by Councillor Smith and seconded by Councillor Batstone. There were no other nominations.
Seconded20 May 2025Planning & Regulation Committee
Election of Chair for the 2025/26 Council Year
Councillor Lugova was nominated by Councillor Hannaby and seconded by Councillor Smith.
Seconded20 May 2025Planning & Regulation Committee
Election of Deputy Chair for the 2025/26 Council Year
Councillor Worgan was nominated by Councillor McLean and seconded by Councillor Smith.
Seconded20 May 2025Performance & Corporate Services Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Election of Deputy Chair for the 2025/26 Council Year
Cllr Middleton was nominated by Cllr Levy and seconded by Cllr Smith.
Seconded20 May 2025County Council
Annual Report of the Audit & Governance Committee
The report was proposed by Councillor Ted Fenton and seconded by Councillor Roz Smith, Chair and Deputy Chair of the Committee for the 2024/25 Council Year.
Asked1 Apr 2025County Council
Report of the Cabinet
Councillor Smith asked whether those 15 hours were well spent, and Councillor Leffman said that they were.
Seconded1 Apr 2025County Council
Constitutional Amendments
The report was moved by Councillor Ted Fenton and seconded by Councillor Roz Smith.
Asked10 Dec 2024County Council
Report of the Cabinet
Councillor Smith asked for an update on progress and when the first Shareholder Committee meeting would take place.
Seconded10 Dec 2024County Council
Financial Procedure Rules and Financial Regulations
The recommendations were proposed by Councillor Ted Fenton, Chair of the Committee and seconded by Councillor Roz Smith, Deputy Chair.
Seconded5 Nov 2024County Council
Appointment of Independent Persons
The recommendations were proposed by Councillor Ted Fenton, Chair of the Audit & Governance Committee, and seconded by Councillor Roz Smith, Deputy Chair. Following discussion the recommendations were approved with 52 votes in favour, one abstention and no votes against.
Named18 Sep 2024Audit & Governance Committee
Audit Working Group Update
· Members for the AWG needed to also nominate substitutes · Members nominated to the AWG were, Cllr Ted Fenton, Cllr Roz Smith, Cllr Jenny Hannaby, Cllr Glynis Phillips and Co-optee Geoff Jones as the Chair.
Named12 Sep 2024Oxfordshire Joint Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Apologies for Absence and Temporary Appointments
Cllr Freddie van Mierlo, with Cllr Roz Smith substituting.
Seconded22 Jul 2024Education and Young People Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Election of Chair for the 2024/25 Council Year
Cllr Waine proposed Cllr Simpson and Cllr Smith seconded the nomination.
Moved22 Jul 2024Education and Young People Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Election of Deputy Chair for the 2024/25 Council Year
Cllr Smith proposed Cllr Hannaby and Cllr Bennett seconded the nomination.
Named17 Jul 2024Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Deputy Chair for 2024-25 Council Year
Councillor Johnston proposed Councillor Smith, and this was seconded by Councillor Hannaby.
Named17 Jul 2024Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Deputy Chair for 2024-25 Council Year
After a vote was taken, it was AGREED that Councillor Smith be elected as the Deputy Chair for the 2024/25 Council Year.
Moved9 Jul 2024County Council
Independent Persons
The report was moved by Councillor Roz Smith, Chair of the Audit & Governance Committee, and seconded by Councillor Brad Baines, Deputy Chair.
Named6 Jun 2024Oxfordshire Joint Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Apologies for Absence and Temporary Appointments
Cllr Nigel Champken-Woods Cllr Michael O’Connor Cllr Nick Leverton Cllr Freddie van Mierlo, with Cllr Roz Smith substituting.
Named21 May 2024County Council
Report of the Cabinet
In response to a question from Councillor Roz Smith, Councillor Pete Sudbury advised that the reason the Council chose to lead on climate change was to encourage others to do the same.
Moved21 May 2024County Council
Audit & Governance Committee Annual Report
Councillor Roz Smith, Chair of the Audit & Governance Committee, moved and Councillor Brad Baines, Deputy Chair of the Audit & Governance Committee, seconded that Council receive the report.
Moved16 Apr 2024County Council
Review of Arrangements for Dealing with Complaints against Members
The report was moved by Councillor Roz Smith, Chair of the Audit & Governance Committee, and seconded by Councillor Brad Baines, Deputy Chair. Following discussion the recommendations were approved unanimously.
Moved16 Apr 2024County Council
Audit & Governance Committee Terms of Reference - Whistleblowing Policy
The report to Council was moved by Councillor Roz Smith, Chair of the Audit & Governance Committee, and seconded by Councillor Brad Baines, Deputy Chair. Following discussion, the recommendations were approved unanimously.
Moved18 Jan 2024Education and Young People Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Election of the Deputy Chair for the remainder of the 2023-24 Council Year
Cllr Smith proposed Cllr Graham and this was seconded by Cllr Hannaby.
Seconded12 Dec 2023County Council
Future Council Governance Group - Final Report
The report was introduced and proposed by Councillor Stefan Gawrysiak, Chair of the Future Council Governance Group, and seconded by Councillor Roz Smith, Chair of the Audit & Governance Committee. An amendment to the recommendations from the proposers was published in Addenda 2.
Moved12 Dec 2023County Council
Audit & Governance Committee Terms of Reference
The recommendations were moved by Councillor Roz Smith, Chair of the Audit & Governance Committee, and seconded by Councillor Brad Baines, Deputy Chair.
Named19 Jul 2023Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Chair for the 2023-24 Council Year
As a result of a nomination from Councillor Ted Fenton and seconded by Councillor Nick Leverton , it was AGREED that Councillor Roz Smith be elected as the Chair for the 2023/24 Council Year .
Named19 Jul 2023Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Deputy Chair for the 2023-24 Council Year
The elected Chair, Councillor Roz Smith, invited the Committee to elect the Deputy Chair for the 2023/24 Council Year.
Named19 Jul 2023Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Deputy Chair for the 2023-24 Council Year
As a result of a nomination from Councillor Roz Smith and seconded by Councillor Judy Roberts, it was AGREED that Councillor Brad Baines be elected as the Deputy Chair for the 2023/24 Council Year.
Said11 Jul 2023County Council
Independent Members of the Audit and Governance Committee
Councillor Roz Smith, Chair of the Audit & Governance Committee, stated that Council’s agreement was required before advertisements could be placed for the two independent positions.
Moved16 May 2023County Council
Audit and Governance Committee Annual Report
Councillor Roz Smith, Chair of the Audit & Governance Committee, moved and Councillor Brad Baines, Deputy Chair of the Audit & Governance Committee, seconded that the Council receive the report.
Said16 May 2023County Council
Audit and Governance Committee Annual Report
In response to a question from Councillor Michael Waine, Councillor Smith stated that the Committee’s Governance Working Group had met and the issue of having an Education Scrutiny Committee was discussed and will continue to be considered as part of their work.
Named23 Nov 2022Audit & Governance Committee
Apologies for Absence and Temporary Appointments
Councillor John Howson substituted for Councillor Smith.
Named1 Nov 2022County Council
Capital Governance - Amendments to the Financial Regulations, Section 5, Capital
RESOLVED : (on a motion from Councillor Roz Smith, seconded by Councillor Brad Baines, and carried nem con) to approve the amendments to the Financial Procedure Rules (Financial Regulations, Section 5 “Capital”) as set out in Annex 1 to the report, as recommended by the Audit and Governance Committee.
Moved1 Nov 2022County Council
Motion by Councillor Roz Smith
Councillor Roz Smith moved and Councillor Geoff Saul seconded the following motion:
Named7 Oct 2022Place Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Apologies for Absence and Temporary Appointments
Councillor Roz Smith substituted for Councillor Povolotsky
Named7 Oct 2022County Council
Amendments to the Council's Constitution and its Presentation (including recommendations from the Constitution Working Group)
Councillor Roz Smith, Chair of the Audit and Governance Committee presented the report.
Named7 Oct 2022County Council
Amendments to the Council's Constitution and its Presentation (including recommendations from the Constitution Working Group)
Following debate it was – RESOLVED (on a motion from Councillor Roz Smith and seconded by Councillor Brad Baines and carried nem con) to approve:- (a) The changes to the presentation of the Constitution on the Council’s website referred to in paragraphs 4 to 8 of the report (b) The video and diagram referred to in paragraphs 9 to 11 of the report for inclusion on the Council’s website (c) The proposals for the incorporation of all of the current Articles into the main body of the Constitution referred to in paragraphs 12 to 14 of the report (d) The proposals for amendment to the Protocol on Members’ Rights and Responsibilities, the Protocol on Member/Officer Relations, the Council Procedure Rules and the Contract Procedure Rules in the Constitution referred to in paragraphs 15 to 23 of the report (e) The proposed new Part 2 of the Constitution relating to the Fire and Rescue Service referred to in paragraphs 26 to 28 of the report;
Named7 Oct 2022County Council
Proposed changes to the Constitution of the Pension Fund Committee
RESOLVED (on a motion from Councillor Roz Smith and seconded by Councillor Brad Baines an approved nem con) to:
Moved7 Oct 2022County Council
Motion by Councillor Roz Smith
With the consent of Council, Councillor Roz Smith moved and Councillor Ian Middleton seconded the following motion amended by the suggestion of Councillor Roz Smith below This Council notes that:
Named12 Jul 2022County Council
Report of the Cabinet
Cllr Pete Sudbury explained the measures being taken to reduce Scope 3 carbon emissions and a report would be submitted to the Cabinet in the autumn In relation to a question from Cllr Roz Smith, Cllr Jenny Hannaby said that she intended to visit all 44 of the county’s libraries and would be looking at the measures needed to improve buildings and services where required In relation to a question from Cllr Robin Bennett, Cllr Calum Miller said that the new administration had put in place new capital expenditure controls and steps to deal with inadequately funded schemes inherited from the previous administration.
Moved12 Jul 2022County Council
Motion by Councillor Liam Walker
Following debate, the amendment by Councillor Duncan Enright was put to the vote and carried by 36 votes to 21 In accordance with Council Procedure Rule 14.1.(vii), Councillor Roz Smith moved and Councillor Pete Sudbury seconded that the question now be put.
Seconded5 Apr 2022County Council
Code of Conduct
RESOLVED (on a motion by Cllr Glynis Phillips and seconded by Cllr Roz Smith and carried nem con) to:- 1. adopt the revised Councillors’ at Appendix 1 for implementation from 1 st May 2022 2. ask the Audit and Governance Committee to consider a separate social media protocol to be incorporated in the and submit recommendations to the Council in due course
Named5 Apr 2022County Council
Motion by Councillor Donna Ford
With the consent of Council, Councillor Sally Povolotsky moved and Councillor Jane Murphy seconded the following motion amended by the suggestion of Councillor Roz Smith as follows:
Named15 Mar 2022Cabinet
HIF1 - Amendments to the Grant Determination Agreement
Councillor Smith was aware that the County Council had successfully secured some flexibility from government on the timeframe for delivery, which will allow the opportunity to rethink the design of the HIF infrastructure to identify ways of reducing the carbon impact and look again at ways to make this infrastructure more accessible for public transport and active travel. She asked Cabinet to accept the officers’ ... view the full minutes text for item 40/22
Named16 Dec 2021Highway Management
Petitions and Public Address
Witney: High Street – Proposed )Waiting Restrictions ) ) Maurice Daly County Councillor Roz Smith ) 6.
Named16 Dec 2021Highway Management
Oxford: Headington Quarry CPZ - Proposed Amendment to Waiting Restrictions and Parking Places
County Councillor Roz Smith reiterated her comments as set out in paragraph 12 of the officer report. However, regarding the issues raised on behalf of QMC motors. Using the highway in this way ... view the full minutes text for item 27/21
Named17 Nov 2021Audit & Governance Committee
Update on Closure of Accounts 2021/22
In response to a query from Cllr Roz Smith, Lorna Baxter confirmed that she will circulate a response to the Committee on the values of the Council’s non-current assets. ( ACTION ).
Named17 Nov 2021Audit & Governance Committee
Whistleblowing Policy
In response to a comment by Cllr Roz Smith, Anita Bradley confirmed that under the constitution, approval of this policy is taken following consultation with the Leader and Deputy Leader of the Council.
Named15 Sep 2021Audit & Governance Committee
Ernst & Young - Audit Results Report
In response to a question from Councillor Roz Smith, Lorna Baxter advised that the Pension Fund Annual Report for the year ended 31 March 2021 had been presented to the Pension Fund Committee meeting of 10 September 2021, and Maria Grindley advised that Officers have advised this document will be received today.
Moved13 Jul 2021County Council
Audit & Governance Annual Report
Councillor Roz Smith moved and Councillor Brad Baines seconded that the recommendations set out on the face of the Agenda be adopted. Following debate, the motion was put to the vote and was carried nem con.
Named3 Jun 2021Highway Management
Petitions and Public Address
North Leigh: A4095 – Proposed Extension of 40mph Speed limit and Turning Restrictions Written representations were received from Councillor Roz Smith in respect of Item (Osler Road recommendation (c)); Councillor Michael Waine & Councillor Les Sibley in respect of Item 6 and Councillor Ian Corkin in respect of Item 7. Their comments are detailed at the respective decision below
Said3 Jun 2021Highway Management
Oxford: Various Locations - Proposed Exclusion of Properties for Eligibility for Parking Permits
Councillor Roz Smith spoke in support of the proposals for Osler Road.
Named18 May 2021Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Chairman for the 2021/22 Council Year
It was moved and seconded that Councillor Roz Smith be elected Chair of the Audit & Governance Committee for the 2021/22 Council Year.
Named18 May 2021Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Chairman for the 2021/22 Council Year
( nem con) that Councillor Roz Smith be elected Chair of the Audit & Governance Committee for the 2021/22 Council Year.
Named21 Jan 2021Environment (including Transport)
Petitions and Public Address
Proposed Traffic calming Measures County Councillor Roz Smith 8. Trial of E-Scooters PC Jamie Howell 9. Oxford – East Oxford: Proposed Secure On-Street Pedal Cycle Parking Places
Said13 Jan 2021Audit & Governance Committee
Treasury Management Strategy Statement and Annual Investment Strategy for 2021/22
Councillor Roz Smith requested that for the next report, feedback on investments that have been considered and rejected would be interesting for Members.
Moved8 Dec 2020County Council
BOB Joint Health Scrutiny & Overview Committee
During debate, Councillor Roz Smith moved and it was seconded that there be a named vote (names recorded in the Minutes).
Named19 Nov 2020Environment (including Transport)
Petitions and Public Address
Speakers Item County Councillor Roz Smith 4.
Said19 Nov 2020Environment (including Transport)
Oxford - Headington Quarry: Proposed Controlled parking Zone (CPZ)
County Councillor Roz Smith advised that at a public meeting 15 years ago there had been great support for a CPZ which had been re-affirmed in the formal consultation. She welcomed proposals to make the signage and lining less intrusive. She was confident it would relieve pressure from commuter parking.
Named3 Nov 2020County Council
Report of the Cabinet
In relation to paragraph 1 of the report (Question from Councillor Roz Smith to Councillor Heathcoat) Councillor Hudspeth undertook to ask Councillor Heathcoat to provide a written response in relation to concerns about the rising number of unemployed 18 to 24-year olds and whether more apprenticeships were being offered this year?
Asked11 Sep 2020Pension Fund Committee
Climate Change Policy Implementation Plan Update
Councillor Roz Smith questioned whether [name removed] had any comment from the statement from Hymans Robertson from the training in the morning around setting a target on Reserves. [name removed] commented that he was happy to look at reserves. Brunel provided data around the Funds exposure to reserves on fossil fuel companies so it would be possible to set a target.
Asked11 Sep 2020Pension Fund Committee
Governance Review
Councillor Roz Smith questioned whether the training be coming out of a training budget for the County Council and indicated that her preference for training would be online and face to face training. The Chairman reported that Pension Fund Budget was separate from the County Council and would be coming from that.
Named14 Jul 2020County Council
Report of the Cabinet
In relation to paragraph 10 of the report (Question from Councillor Roz Smith to Councillor Constance) Councillor Constance undertook to provide Councillor Roz Smith with a written answer detailing how enforcement would be carried and by whom and whether there would be resource in place to monitor enforcement to ensure compliance.
Named14 Jul 2020County Council
Report of the Cabinet
In relation to paragraph 12 of the report (Question from Councillor Roz Smith to Councillor Constance) Councillor Constance agreed with Councillor Roz Smith that the Headington CPZ was overdue for a review and asked that she take the issue up with Councillor Walker who was now responsible for that area.
Asked27 May 2020Audit & Governance Committee
Steve Jorden, Corporate Director, Commercial Development, Assets and Investment - Introduction to Committee and overview of role
Councillor Smith asked how the joint role will be split between Cherwell District Council and Oxfordshire County Council? Steve Jorden responded that he aimed to continue supporting Councillors providing updates through Cabinet and Informal Cabinet meetings, and through the updates provided by the Chief Executive. His intention was that time would be split based on need, focused on outcomes for meeting the needs of Oxfordshire residents.
Named13 Feb 2020Environment (including Transport)
Petitions and Public Address
Speaker Item Graham Smith – Cyclox County Councillor Roz Smith (local member) ) ) 4.
Said13 Feb 2020Environment (including Transport)
Oxford - Access to Headington: Further Consultation on Traffic Measures
Councillor Roz Smith thanked the officers for their work on the detail of this scheme. The A2H scheme had been ambitious and was very much a case of retro fitting and so would never be safe from inappropriate driving. She highlighted a number of issues on Headley Way and Woodlands and Falklands Close.
Said13 Nov 2019Audit & Governance Committee
Changes to Constitution of Pension Fund Committee
Councillor Roz Smith, a Member of the PFC, stated that she could not see any reason why substitutes should not be allowed provided they had completed the training. Members might miss meetings due to unforeseen circumstances. There were only two Members of the PFC representing District Councils and she thought that it was particularly important that they should be able to be substituted.
Asked13 Nov 2019Audit & Governance Committee
Changes to Constitution of Pension Fund Committee
Councillor Roz Smith asked for it to be minuted that she was only opposed to recommendation c) and supported the other recommendations.
Asked13 Nov 2019Audit & Governance Committee
Audit & Governance Committee Terms of Reference
Councillor Roz Smith asked that training be provided for Members on Value for Money. Sarah Cox said that she would follow that up.
Named5 Nov 2019County Council
Report of the Cabinet
In relation to paragraph 13 of the report (Capital Finance Monitoring Report) (Question from Councillor Roz Smith to Councillor Bartholomew) Councillor Bartholomew undertook to provide Councillor Roz Smith with a written answer detailing how the urgent repairs to Windmill School were to be funded; and whether it would be from the contingency budget or capital school’s maintenance budget.
Named12 Sep 2019Environment (including Transport)
Petitions and Public Address
Speaker Item Derek Albiston – Resident Windmill Road Graham Smith – Cyclox County Councillor Roz Smith ) ) 4 – Access to Headington ) ) Louise Dodd – Resident, Harcourt Close Armadeep Takhar – Local Businessman County & Town Councillor Stefan Gawrysiak ) ) ) 8 - Greys Road, Henley-on -)Thames ) ) Ann Pritchard – Chalgrove PC 9 – Chalgrove , Monument Road Carolyn Jessop – Resident, Kennington Road County Councillor Bob Johnston ) ) 12 – Radley, Kennington Road ) Hugh Thomas – Cassington PC County Councillor Charles Mathew ) 14 – Horsemere Lane, Cassington )
Asked11 Sep 2019Audit & Governance Committee
Local Government Ombudsman - Annual Review Report
Councillor Roz Smith asked about the 17 complaints that were referred back to the Council (Agenda Page 77, paragraph 12). Glenn Watson responded that sometimes people go to the Ombudsman before they have exhausted the Council’s procedures and the Ombudsman refers them back to the Council. People often do this because they are eager for what they see as a more independent view.
Named10 Sep 2019County Council
Report of the Cabinet
In relation to paragraph 8 of the report (Bus Access to Queen Street, Oxford) (Question from Councillor Roz Smith to Councillor Constance) Councillor Constance gave an assurance to bring the state of the paving (including uneven slabs and poor patching) in front of the Westgate entrance to officers’ attention for action.
Named17 Jul 2019Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Chairman for the 2019/20 Council Year
Councillor Paul Buckley moved and Councillor Glynis Phillips seconded that Councillor Roz Smith be elected Chairman of the Committee for the 2019/20 Council Year.
Named17 Jul 2019Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Chairman for the 2019/20 Council Year
There were 4 votes for Councillor Nick Carter and 4 votes for Councillor Roz Smith.
Named17 Jul 2019Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Chairman for the 2019/20 Council Year
There were 5 votes for Councillor Nick Carter and 4 votes for Councillor Roz Smith.
Declared17 Jul 2019Audit & Governance Committee
Declaration of Interests - see guidance note
In relation to Agenda Item 12, Councillor Roz Smith declared that she was also a councillor for Oxford City Council.
Said17 Jul 2019Audit & Governance Committee
Review of Corporate Security
Councillor Roz Smith suggested that any new CCTV upgrade should link to the City Council’s existing system, however this will need to be reviewed and assessed in accordance with the security service specification which is going to be produced and if applicable.
Said17 Jul 2019Audit & Governance Committee
Internal Audit Charter
Councillor Roz Smith noted that the mission statement on the top of Agenda Page 96 was a very useful definition of what internal audit does.
Named31 May 2019Environment (including Transport)
Questions from County Councillors
Councillor Roz Smith I understand that the Access to Headington project works on Windmill Road are to take place this year; including reducing the number of residents parking spaces and increasing the number in nearby residential streets. I would be grateful if the Cabinet member could advise as to when the promised consultation regarding the extra parking spaces will be taking place?
Named31 May 2019Environment (including Transport)
Petitions and Public Address
Oxford – George Street/Hythe Bridge Street/Worcester Street Junction – Revised Amended Junction Layout and Pedestrian & Cycle Provision Councillor Roz Smith (Quarry City Councillor & Risinghurst Parish Councillor) County Councillor Glynis Phillips 6.
Named31 May 2019Environment (including Transport)
Oxford: A40 at Risinghurst - Proposed Closure of Central Reserve Gap at Junction with Access to Former Nielsens Site
While accepting the obvious safety concerns associated with a right turn out of this development site Councillor Roz Smith speaking as a City Councillor and Parish Councillor also supported deferral citing concerns regarding the environmental impact from increased rat running on residential areas in Risinghurst and Quarry. The requirement to review arrangements at the Collinwood junction which she agreed needed to be reopened with lights in tandem with the gap closure was paramount. Serious delays with traffic often queuing back to Wheatley needed to be addressed and adding more traffic to currently congested roads was not the answer.
Asked8 May 2019Audit & Governance Committee
Petitions and Public Address
Councillor Roz Smith asked that the Council’s Democratic Services team look at the application form for speakers to ensure that it is clearer that requests to speak must relate to an item on the agenda.
Said25 Apr 2019Environment (including Transport)
Oxford Controlled Parking Zones - Outcome of Informal Consultation Responses
Councillor Roz Smith thanked officers for the excellent and detailed analysis. Supporting the recommendations and welcoming the high response to the consultation she stressed the need for a fair distribution between business interests and residents. She supported the proposals for Quarry district which 13 years previously residents had opposed on the grounds of intrusive signing and lining which in parts of Headington was old and confusing and suggested a review of all CPZs with regard to signing and adoption of the new system at the entrance to a CPZ area as used in Headley Way.
Named20 Dec 2018Environment (including Transport)
Questions from County Councillors
Would it be feasible to consider re-siting that sign?” Reply by the Cabinet Member for Environment “Officers will investigate the possibility of relocating that sign.” Councillor Roz Smith “At the 16 October Cabinet meeting I asked questions about the non-residential parking permits issued and the monitoring of them. Unfortunately, I don’t ... view the full minutes text for item 63/18
Asked14 Nov 2018Audit & Governance Committee
Work Programme
Additions to January 2019- Financial Management Action Plan Update (Lorna Baxter) Update on the Carillion Recovery Plan (Alexandra Bailey) Review of effectiveness of internal audit (Glenn Watson) Moved from January to March 2019- Governance of the Housing and Growth Deal Additions to March 2019- Governance of Oxfordshire Local Enterprise Partnership Highways Update (Owen Jenkins) Section 117 Aftercare funding Councillor Roz Smith asked that the Committee look at the partnership agreement with Oxford Direct Services at the March or May meeting.
Named18 Sep 2018Cabinet
Elective Home Education Working Group Report
The working group comprised of Councillor Waine and Councillor Smith. The Cabinet had before it a report which presented the findings of the investigation and the recommendations to Cabinet for consideration.
Named25 Jul 2018Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Chairman for the Council Year 2018/19
Councillor Liz Brighouse moved and Councillor John Howson seconded that Councillor Roz Smith be elected Chairman of the Committee for the 2018/19 Council Year.
Named25 Jul 2018Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Chairman for the Council Year 2018/19
There were 3 votes for Councillor Roz Smith and 4 votes for Councillor Nick Carter.
Said7 Jun 2018Environment (including Transport)
Oxford: Controlled Parking Zones - Future Programme
Referring to Headington & Quarry Councillor Smith pointed out a number of circumstances peculiar to that area including an urgent need to review the current situation in London Road and the high expansion of employment sites in the area – 6 hospitals and the University of Oxford moving onto the Churchill site. That represented a 20% increase in employment levels and more than supported the introduction of a workplace levy. She referred to an anomaly in the rules governing size of vehicles, income from permits needed to cover maintenance and policing costs and concerns regarding sale of permits.
Named22 May 2018Cabinet
Petitions and Public Address
Oxford – Gathorne Road Wingfield House – Proposed Restoration of Parking Permits Julian Philcox , Director, JP Planning Ltd Harold Grant, local resident District Councillor Altaf -Khan, Councillor for Headington and Deputy Opposition Leader, Oxford City Council Councillor Roz Smith, local councillor for Headington & Quarry Councillor John Sanders, Shadow Cabinet Member for Environment 7.
Named12 Apr 2018Environment (including Transport)
Petitions and Public Address
Speaker Item County Councillor Glynis Phillips County Councillor Roz Smith 4.
Said12 Apr 2018Environment (including Transport)
Oxford: Various Streets in Barton and Risinghurst Area - {Proposed Waiting restrictionson Area - Proposed Waiting Restrictions
Councillor Roz Smith also welcomed the proposals. Endorsing the comments regarding The Roundway she understood that there was some space and unused garages to the rear of properties 1 – 8 which could, conceivably, be used to the benefit of residents and businesses and advised that the City Council might be able to assist in identifying ownership. She also asked that the proposals be monitored.
Said7 Mar 2018Audit & Governance Committee
External Auditors
Councillor Roz Smith stated that she and other councillors had suggested the inclusion of a break clause in the contract with Carillion.
Named8 Feb 2018Environment (including Transport)
Petitions and Public Address
Speaker Item Councillor Roz Smith (local member) 4. Oxford Gathorne Road – Proposed Restoration of Parking Permites to Wingfield House (2A Gathorne Road) 5.
Named8 Feb 2018Environment (including Transport)
Oxford Gathorne Road - Proposed Restoration of Parking Permits to Wingfield House (2A Gathorne Road)
Councillor Roz Smith endorsed those comments citing once again the pressures on parking in that area. She queried the accuracy of a statement saying restoration of permits as that facility had not existed in the first place. She supported the process and looked forward to a comprehensive and robust review being carried out.
Named8 Feb 2018Environment (including Transport)
Oxford - Headington Area - Bickerton, Latimer and Stapleton Roads - Proposed Amendments Waiting Restrictions
With regard to Stapleton Road the schedules were being similarly amended, except that in the vicinity of house Nos. 19, 25 and 60 Stapleton Road double yellow lines were being proposed instead of informal access protection markings at the request of residents to better prevent obstruction to their respective driveways, Councillor Roz Smith appreciated the time officers had spent on this but as the CPZ had been put in some time ago a wholesale review was required and she urged that that should be done as soon as possible.
Moved12 Sep 2017County Council
Motion from Councillor Mark Cherry
Council asks the leader of Oxfordshire County Council write to the Minister for Transport to ask that he give urgent consideration to the importance of extra funding for our failing roads in Oxfordshire.” Councillor Smith moved and Councillor Johnston seconded the following amendment as shown below in bold italics and strikethrough:
Asked6 Sep 2017Audit & Governance Committee
Statement of Accounts 2016/17
Councillor Roz Smith asked if any changes agreed with the chairman under point f) of the recommendations could be communicated to Committee Members. [name removed] responded that it would depend on the complexity of any change – more complex issues would be addressed at the next meeting.
Seconded11 Jul 2017County Council
Motion From Councillor David Bartholomew
Councillor Bartholomew moved and Councillor Roz Smith seconded the following motion:
Named5 Jul 2017Audit & Governance Committee
Audit Working Group Terms of Reference and Appointment of the Audit Working Group
· Councillor Nick Carter · Councillor Ian Corkin · Councillor Helen Evans · Councillor Roz Smith and the following substitutes:
Named16 May 2017Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Chairman for the 2017/18 Council Year
Councillor Paul Buckey moved and Councillor Helen Evans seconded that Councillor Roz Smith be elected Chairman of the Committee for the 2017/18 Council Year.
Named16 May 2017Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Chairman for the 2017/18 Council Year
There were 5 votes for Councillor Nick Carter and 3 votes for Councillor Roz Smith.
Moved16 May 2017Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Deputy Chairman for the 2017/18 Council Year
Councillor Roz Smith moved and Councillor Helen Evans seconded that Councillor Roz Smith be elected Deputy Chairman of the Committee for the 2017/18 Council Year.
Named16 May 2017Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Deputy Chairman for the 2017/18 Council Year
There were 5 votes for Councillor Tony Ilott and 3 votes for Councillor Roz Smith.
Said11 Jan 2017Audit & Governance Committee
Treasury Management Strategy Statement and Annual Investment Strategy for 2017/18
Councillor Smith suggested that the resolution part a) should be amended to “note” the strategy rather than “endorse” it. The Chairman put the resolution as proposed in the report to a vote and it was carried with 7 votes in favour and 2 abstentions.
Said11 Jan 2017Audit & Governance Committee
Progress update on Annual Governance Statement Actions
· Councillor Smith stated that the £5,000 allocated to schools for repairs and maintenance is far from enough, especially for schools with listed buildings.
Declared14 Sep 2016Audit & Governance Committee
Declaration of Interests - see guidance note
In relation to Agenda Item 7, Councillor Roz Smith declared that she receives a pension from Oxfordshire Local Pension Fund.
Asked14 Sep 2016Audit & Governance Committee
Local Government Ombudsman's Review of Oxfordshire County Council
Councillor Smith asked if the Council budgeted for claims against OCC. [name removed] responded that claims were not counted as complaints although some people can make a claim as well as lodging a formal complaint. [name removed] stated that the insurance team collects information on claims and this is be examined by the Performance Scrutiny Committee for any trends.
Named5 Sep 2016Planning & Regulation Committee
Petitions and Public Address
Speaker Item Peter West – Chair of St Anne’s Road Residents Association Ann Marie Dickenson – Local Resident City Councillor Ruth Wilkinson Paul Gredley – Vital Energi County Councillor Roz Smith ) ) ) 6.New Roads and Street Works Act )1991 Section 50 Licence for )Headington Heat Pipe application ) )
Moved13 Jul 2016Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Chairman for the 2016/17 Council Year
Councillor Roz Smith moved and Councillor Alison Rooke seconded that Councillor Nick Hards be elected Chairman of the Committee for the 2016/17 Council Year.
Moved13 Jul 2016Audit & Governance Committee
Election of Deputy Chairman for the 2016/17 Council Year
Councillor Roz Smith moved and Councillor Alison Rooke seconded that Councillor Nick Hards be elected Deputy Chairman of the Committee for the 2016/17 Council Year.
Declared13 Jul 2016Audit & Governance Committee
Declaration of Interests - see guidance note
In relation to Agenda Item 12, Councillor Roz Smith declared that she receives a pension from Oxfordshire Local Pension Fund.
Named9 Jun 2016Environment (including Transport)
Questions from County Councillors
Councillor Roz Smith “Access to Headington project – a question about costs Please could the Cabinet Member give further details on costs relating to the Project:
Named9 Jun 2016Environment (including Transport)
Questions from County Councillors
The additional costs will be funded from the existing project budget. · Approximate costs for the changes to the double mini-roundabouts and junctions in Headley Way - £2.5m (including public realm improvements) · Approximate costs to changes to the mini roundabout junction into the JR Hospital - £845,000 Costs may change as the detailed design process continues, but these are the latest estimates we have.” Supplementary question from Councillor Roz Smith “I note it’s estimated that for every £1 spent there would be a benefit of £3.50 but how would that be monitored and by who.” Response by Cabinet Member “Essentially there is a required minimum level of value for money which is part of the agreement for the scheme along with a requirement for before and after monitoring.”
Named9 Jun 2016Environment (including Transport)
Petitions and Public Address
Speaker Item [name removed] Hugh-Jones Mark Pitt Valerie Seagrott David Preiss Geoff Sutton City Councillor Mick Haines City Councillor Dee Sinclair City Councillor Ruth Wilkinson County Councillor Liz Brighouse County Councillor Roz Smith ) ) ) ) ) ) 4.
Named8 Sep 2015County Council
Report of the Cabinet
In relation to paragraph 7 (2015/16 Financial Monitoring & Business Strategy Delivery Report – May 2015) (Question from Councillor Smith) Councillor Stratford gave an assurance to ask Councillor Nimmo Smith to provide Councillor Smith with a written answer to the following 2 questions:
Moved8 Sep 2015County Council
Motion by Councillor Roz Smith
With the consent of Council, Councillor Smith moved and Councillor Johnson seconded her motion as amended by Councillor Bartholomew below in bold italics and strikethrough:
Named4 Nov 2014County Council
Report of the Cabinet
In relation to paragraph 16 (2014/15 Financial Monitoring & Business Strategy Delivery Report) (Question from Councillor Smith) Councillor Stratford, undertook to provide a written response concerning the inclusion of £1.7m developer funding as a contribution towards the expansion of Cheney Academy. The question related to basic need.
Seconded18 Feb 2014County Council
Service & Resource Planning 2014/15 - 2017/18
Councillor Patrick moved and Councillor Roz Smith seconded an amendment to the Cabinet’s budget as set out in Additional Papers 1 (CC8 Liberal Democrat).
Named26 Nov 2013Cabinet
Questions from County Councillors
Councillor Roz Smith had given written notice of the following question to Councillor Fatemian "What has been the financial cost to the council, (so far this year), of the external fund manager, Investec’s failure to reach their benchmark return?" Councillor Fatemian replied:
Named10 Oct 2013Environment (including Transport)
Petitions and Public Address
Speaker Item Frank McKenna ( Highfield Residents Association) County Councillor Roz Smith ) ) 4. Proposed Removal of Parking )Bay – Lime Walk, Headington Matt Murton (Henley Resident) David Silvester (Henley Town Council) ) ) 5. Reading Road (Henley) Public ) Transport Infrastructure Graham Smith (CTC) 6.
Named10 Oct 2013Environment (including Transport)
Proposed Removal of Parking Bay - Lime Walk, Headington
Councillor Roz Smith endorsed the points made by [name removed]. Removal of the parking bay completely would mean everyone would lose. Residents currently suffered from speeding traffic at this very busy junction and as parked bays did have some beneficial effect on speeding vehicles that would undoubtedly worsen if this proposal went ahead.
Named12 Sep 2013Environment (including Transport)
Petitions and Public Address
Speaker Item Graham P Smith County Councillor Roz Smith ) 5. London Road, Headington – ) Proposed Improvements and Bus ) Lane
Said12 Sep 2013Environment (including Transport)
London Road, Headington - Proposed Improvements and Bus Lane
Councillor Smith thanked officers for their involvement in this process, attendance at local meetings and subsequent changes made during the consultation and initial design processes. However, she could not give unequivocal support for this new scheme. The surface of London Road was an embarrassment and dangerous.
Named12 Sep 2013Environment (including Transport)
London Road, Headington - Proposed Improvements and Bus Lane
[name removed] confirmed changes had been made to one of the drawings regarding cycle provision around the inbound bus stop which had been circulated to objectors and Councillor Smith for comment. More work on that was required including the need for some land dedication behind the bus stop and negotiations were in hand with the City Council to achieve that. Two trees would also need to be removed but they would be replaced.
Named12 Sep 2013Environment (including Transport)
London Road, Headington - Proposed Improvements and Bus Lane
Councillor Smith supported this change and considered it important that the concerns of cycling groups were taken on board. The land in question was not used so hopefully there would be no complications regarding dedication of the land and it would be safer for pedestrians.
Named27 Nov 2012Cabinet
Petitions and Public Address
Item 3 - Councillor Roz Smith on Minute 112/12 Item 6 – Deborah Glass- Woodin , local resident Susie Bagnall , Head Teacher, St Ebbes Item 7– Councillor Roz Smith, as local Councillor Councillor Liz Brighouse, as Local Councillor Mayte Siswick , Chair of Governors for Windmill School Andrea Bird, local resident Natalie Poynter , local resident
Named27 Nov 2012Cabinet
Expansion of Windmill Primary School to 3 Form Entry
Councillor Roz Smith, as local Councillor and Vice-Chairman of the Board of Governors referred to the eloquence of the concerns expressed so far. She recognised the need to build to fulfil Oxfordshire priorities but stressed the importance that it be done properly. A large capital expense would be needed to provide adequate facilities including a suitable hall and kitchen.
Declared3 Apr 2012County Council
Declarations of Interest - see guidance note
Councillor Roz Smith declared a Personal Interest in relation to Agenda Item 15 due to having family in the services.
Named16 Feb 2012Transport
Oxford, Highfield and Old Road Transport Improvements - Minor amendment to scheme to relocate proposed cycle by-Pass between Gipsy Lane and Old Road
Councillor Turner speaking on behalf of Councillor Roz Smith (local member) who had been unable to attend outlined her general support but also some concern that this expenditure had been correctly prioritised when compared to more dangerous and more accident prone spots elsewhere on Old Road.
Named15 Nov 2011Cabinet
Questions from County Councillors
The final decision as to whether Food with Thought is included in the Contract will be taken by Cabinet when it approves the preferred bidder probably at its meeting on 13th March 2012.” Councillor Roz Smith had given notice of the following question to the Leader (in the absence of Councillor Rose, Cabinet Member for Transport) "When will the proposed temporary closure of the right hand turn from the A40 into Collinwood Road, Risinghurst take place?" Councillor Mitchell replied:
Named18 Oct 2011Cabinet
Questions from County Councillors
Councillor Roz Smith had given notice of the following question to the Cabinet Member for Finance & Property “How many buildings owned by the County Council, are unoccupied or partly occupied for more than one year, and what is the cost of security contractors for these buildings?” Councillor Couchman replied:
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.