Questions from the Public
The following question was asked by Nick Crawley Question: Councillor Evans recently stated that the increased parking charges in Plymouth, left Plymouth in line with other areas in the Southwest.
Every time Plymouth's minutes name Councillor Evans, as the council published it.
The following question was asked by Nick Crawley Question: Councillor Evans recently stated that the increased parking charges in Plymouth, left Plymouth in line with other areas in the Southwest.
Could Councillor Evans specify exactly which Council’s he is referring to from his research and if they have similar demographic and financial profile to Plymouth. Answer:
Smith proposed that Council moved to the vote on the substantive motion which was seconded by Councillor Evans.
a) Councillor Evans welcomed Steve Reed MP’s appointment as Secretary of State for Housing and Local Government, citing his record of delivering 18,000 homes in Lambeth Borough Council. It was proposed to invite [name removed] to Plymouth to discuss housing and regeneration opportunities;
Councillor Evans expressed optimism about their potential to support Plymouth’s ambitions;
d) Councillor Evans proposed inviting Angela Eagle, the new Minister of State for Food Security and Rural Affairs, to Plymouth and writing to Daniel Zeichner , the outgoing fishing minister, to thank him for his support on Plymouth’s fisheries and marine projects.
Councillor Evans, do you agree that the Labour Government’s cuts to welfare will significantly impact the people of Plymouth and are you prepared to publicly condemn the actions of government in relation to these cuts, in the same way that labour councillors have done in other parts of the country?
Councillor Evans (Leader of the Council) introduced the item and highlighted the following points:
Councillor Evans (Leader of the Council) added:
Councillor Evans (Leader of the Council) gave the following announcements:
The following question was submitted by [name removed]: Cllr Evans do you support and agree with the Chancellor & the Prime Minister in removing the £300 Winter Fuel Allowance that will have a detrimental effect on thousands of pensioners living in Plymouth?
This was proposed by Councillor Tudor Evans and seconded by Councillor Andy Lugger .
The report was introduced by Councillor Lowry (Cabinet Member for Finance) and seconded by Councillor Evans (The Leader of the Council) .
Following advice from the Lord Mayor, Councillor Evans asked for an adjournment word the motion.
It was agreed that Councillor Bingley is appointed as Chair, and Councillor Evans is appointed as Vice Chair for this meeting.
Councillor Tudor Evans, OBE (Leader) provided an overview of the following – (1a) the Council’s long term commitment to securing a sustainable future for the city’s fishing industry which included - ?
Councillor Tudor Evans, OBE (Leader) highlighted the following in his announcements – (a) urged everyone to do all that they could to keep the virus from spreading, not just for the sake of the city but also for family and friends who were at risk if they caught this hideous virus and to follow the guidance stay at home, wash hands regularly, wear a face mask and keep social distance;
Councillor Tudor Evans, OBE (Leader) advised that – (a) when this administration had been re-elected it saw Brexit as an issue that it could not hide from, even if it was politically uncomfortable; it wanted Plymouth’s citizens to be able to be well informed about the impacts Brexit would have on the City Council and the local economy;
Councillor Evans, OBE (Leader), Giles Perritt (Assistant Chief Executive) and Kevin McKenzie (Policy and Intelligence Advisor) presented the report.
Councillor Tudor Evans, OBE (Leader). David Draffan (Service Director for Economic Development) and Rodney Anderson (former DEFRA director of fisheries and marine) presented the Brexit fisheries update. The update summarised the implications of the UK-EU Trade and Cooperation Agreement on Plymouth’s fishing sector.
Can Councillor Evans ensure the proper consultation will ensue?” The Leader, Councillor Evans OBE, gave the following response:
Councillor Evans spoke with the applicant and Councillor Tuohy took no part in the debate or the discussion.
Councillor Evans regarding information available on the council website The Committee noted the update from the Director of Public Health.
Councillor Evans (Leader) highlighted - · Proud of how the city had come together in this current crisis and how people had supported each other;
At the start of the debate Councillor Evans (Leader) proposed, Councillor Bowyer seconded and Council agreed that in accordance with Part B, Council Procedure Rule 14.6 of the Constitution, Rule of Debate 4.2 (in Appendix one) (which limits speeches to five minutes) is suspended for this item in relation to the speeches by the Leader and the Leader of the Opposition.
Councillor Evans (Leader) proposed and Councillor Lowry seconded an amendment to Recommendation 2 to the Revenue and Capital Budget 2020/21 report from ‘To consider council tax levels for 2020/21’ to read:
For the motion (30) – Cllr Allen, [name removed], Cllr Buchan, Cllr Coker, Cllr Corvid, Cllr Dann, Cllr Derrick, Cllr Evans, Cllr Goslin, Cllr Haydon, Cllr Hendy, Cllr Laing, Cllr Lowry, Cllr Mavin, Cllr McDonald, Cllr Morris, Cllr Murphy, Cllr Neil, Cllr Parker-Delaz-Ajete, Cllr Penberthy, Cllr Rennie, Cllr Pete Smith, Cllr Stevens, Cllr Jon Taylor, Cllr Kate Taylor, Cllr Tuffin, Cllr Tuohy, ... view the full minutes text for item 32.
Councillor Evans introduced an audio clip on behalf of Councillor Laing, Cabinet Member for Children and Young People on Care Journeys.
This was seconded by Councillor Evans, OBE, Leader of the Council.
Councillor Evans, OBE (Leader), Councillor Haydon (Cabinet Member for Customer Focus and Community Safety), Giles Perritt (Assistant Chief Executive) and Nina Sarlaka (Enterprise and Inward Investment Manager) presented the current position relating to the Brexit risks which highlighted the following key areas – (a) economic development - ?
The Leader, Councillor Evans, OBE introduced the item on Brexit preparation and risk management.
South West Forensics Councillor Evans (OBE) introduced the motion on .
Councillor Evans (Leader) introduced a report on the Plymouth 2020-2030.
Councillor Evans (Leader) introduced a report on the 2020-2030.
At the start of the debate Councillor Evans (Leader) proposed, Councillor Bowyer seconded and Council agreed that in accordance with Part B, Council Procedure Rule 14.6 of the Constitution, Rule of Debate 4.2 (in Appendix one) (which limits speeches to five minutes) is suspended for this item in relation to the speeches by the Leader and the Leader of the Opposition.
For the motion (52) – Cllr Aspinall, Cllr Haydon, Cllr Coker, Cllr Dann, Cllr Evans, Cllr Hendy, Cllr Lowry, Cllr McDonald, Cllr Morris, Cllr Murphy, Cllr Parker-Delaz-Ajete, Cllr Penberthy, Cllr Rennie , Cllr Singh, Cllr Pete Smith, Cllr Stevens, Cllr J Taylor, Cllr K Taylor, Cllr Tuffin, Cllr Tuohy, Cllr Ball, Cllr Mrs Beer, Cllr Bowyer, Cllr Mrs Bowyer, Cllr Darcy, Cllr Deacon, Cllr Downie, Cllr Drean, Cllr Fletcher, Cllr Foster, Cllr Mrs Johnson, Cllr James, Cllr Jordan, Cllr Kelly, Cllr Goslin, Cllr Michael Leaves, Cllr Mrs Leaves, Cllr Dr Mahony, Cllr Mrs Pengelly, Cllr Corvid, Cllr Wigens, Cllr Mrs Bridgeman, Cllr Buchan, Cllr Derrick, Cllr Neil, Cllr Mavin, Cllr Carson, Cllr Winter, Cllr Mrs Loveridge, Cllr Cook, Cllr Rebecca Smith, Cllr Laing Absent / did not vote (0) Councillor Evans (Leader) proposed and Councillor Lowry seconded an amended report and recommendations to item six, the Revenue and Capital Budget and Proposed Council Tax Levels for 2019/20.
Following a brief adjournment Councillor Darcy seconded the amendment and Councillor Evans (Leader) moved to go to the vote on the amendment, seconded by Councillor Rennie.
For the move to vote on the amendment (29) Cllr Aspinall, Cllr Haydon, Cllr Coker, Cllr Dann, Cllr Evans, Cllr Hendy, Cllr Lowry, Cllr McDonald , Cllr Morris, Cllr Murphy, Cllr Parker-Delaz-Ajete, Cllr Penberthy, Cllr Rennie, ) Cllr Singh, ) Cllr Pete Smith, Cllr Stevens, Cllr J Taylor, Cllr K Taylor, Cllr Tuffin, Cllr Tuohy, Cllr Wheeler, Cllr Goslin, Cllr Corvid, Cllr Buchan, Cllr Derrick, Cllr Neil, Cllr Winter, Cllr Laing Against (24) Cllr Ball, Cllr Mrs Beer, Cllr Bowyer, Cllr Mrs Bowyer, Cllr Darcy, Cllr Deacon, Cllr Downie, Cllr Drean, Cllr Fletcher, Cllr ... view the full minutes text for item 81.
Councillor Tudor Evans (Leader) provided an update on – · Closure of Barden Corporation in Plymouth, associated meetings with the Ministry of Defence and Defence Procurement Minister and letters to owners;
The motion was seconded by Councillor Evans (Leader).
Councillor Tudor Evans (Leader) seconded the report.
Councillor Coker (Cabinet member for Strategic Planning and Infrastructure) and Councillor Evans (Leader of Plymouth City Council) introduced the report. Paul Barnard (Service Director for Strategic Planning and Infrastructure), Phillip Heseltine (Head of Transport, Infrastructure and Investment) were also present for questioning. It was highlighted that – · the Government was consulting on plans for the next cross country rail franchise in 2019;
· Concerns were raised by Councillor Penberthy and Councillor Evans at the previous administrations’ failure to maximise benefit of the Discretionary Housing Payment grant.
Councillor Evans invited members to comment on the report. Members noted that – The extensive manifesto would lead the development of the new plan. Members highlighted that children and young people, educational attainment, poverty, housing and car parking would be key areas of focus for the new administation in the future.
Councillor Mrs Aspinall was appointed Chair for the meeting having been proposed by Councillor Evans and seconded by Councillor Bowyer.
Councillor Evans proposed an amendment, Councillor Coker seconded the amendment. Following debate and a vote the amendment was lost.
Councillor Evans proposed and Councillor McDonald seconded a motion titled Plan for Education – Representation.
At the start of the debate Councillor Bowyer proposed, Councillor Evans seconded and Council agreed that in accordance with Part B, Council Procedure Rule 14.6 of the Constitution, Rule of Debate 4.2 (in Appendix one) (which limits speeches to five minutes) is suspended for this item in relation to the speeches by the Leader and the Leader of the Opposition.
Councillor Ian Bowyer (Leader) presented the report on the Torbay Childrens’ Services Contractual Arrangement, Councillor Evans seconded the report. Following the vote, the Council agreed to endorse the Cabinet’s decision to enter into a formal contractual arrangement for Plymouth City Council to manage Torbay Council’s Children’s Services with effect from 1 April 2018.
For the Motion (55) Councillors Ball, [name removed], Bowyer, [name removed], Churchill, Darcy, Deacon, Downie, Drean, Fletcher, Foster, Fry, James, Jordan, Kelly, Martin Leaves, Michael Leaves, [name removed], [name removed], Nicholson, [name removed], Wigens, [name removed], Riley, Storer, Carson, [name removed], Cook, Aspinall, Bowie, Coker, Dann Davey, Davey, Evans OBE, Hendy, Lowry, McDonald, Morris, Murphy, Parker-Delaz-Ajete Penberthy, Rennie, Singh Smith, Stevens, J Taylor, K Taylor, Tuffin, Tuohy, Vincent, Wheeler, Sparling, Mavin Winter Against the motion (0) Abstentions (1) Lord Mayor Absent/Did not vote (1) Councillors Ricketts Following the re-instatement of standing orders Councillor Ian Bowyer moved and Councillor Evans seconded the report. Following the vote, Council agreed to- 1. approve the proposals for changes to the Plymouth City Council Senior Leadership Team.
Councillor Winter proposed a motion on Plastic Free Plymouth, the motion was seconded by Councillor Evans.
Councillor Downie would write to Councillor Evans.
Councillor McDonald proposed and Councillor Evans seconded a motion on Political Representation for School Improvement.
Councillor Evans proposed and Councillor Ian Bowyer seconded a motion titled Defence Cuts to Devonport.
During the debate, Councillor Evans proposed and Councillor Jon Taylor seconded a procedural motion without notice under Part B, procedure rule 14.6 of the constitution. The motion was to refer the new to Cabinet, following further consideration by the Scrutiny Select Committee before a final decision is taken by Council , in order to prevent an application for Judicial Review of the Council’s decision, based on a flawed or non-existent consultation and scrutiny process.
Councillor Evans proposed and Councillor Smith seconded a motion on the Conservative/UKIP controlled council’s war on small business.
Councillor Penberthy proposed and Councillor Evans seconded a motion of no confidence in the Police and Crime Commissioner.
Councillor Evans and Councillor Rennie seconded a procedural motion to move to the vote. Following a vote the procedural motion was carried.
Councillor Nicholson (Chair of the Lord Mayor’s selection committee) proposed and Councillor Evans seconded the recommendation of the Lord Mayor’s Selection Committee.
Councillor Evans made the following statement and left the Chamber for the debate – “As a Councillor subject to the jurisdiction of this council’s agreed disciplinary process, I will not remain in the chamber for this item, which prejudges an outcome without evidence being presented.” The monitoring officer asked if any other councilor wished to make the same statement.
At the start of the debate Councillor Bowyer proposed, Councillor Evans seconded and Council agreed that in accordance with Part B, Council Procedure Rule 14.6 of the Constitution, Rule of Debate 4.2 (in Appendix one) (which limits speeches to five minutes) is suspended for this item in relation to the speeches by the Leader and the Leader of the Opposition.
During the debate, Councillor Evans proposed and Councillor McDonald seconded an amendment for an additional recommendation on fees and charges for bereavement services.
During the debate Councillor Evans moved a procedural motion under the Constitution, Appendix One (2) Rules of Debate (11.1) for the meeting to be adjourned, Councillor Lowry seconded the motion.
Having been proposed by Councillor Dr Mahony and seconded by Councillor Evans, it is agreed that Councillor Nicholson is appointed Chair of the Lord Mayor Selection Committee for the municipal year.
Having been nominated by Councillor Nicholson and seconded by Councillor Evans, it was agreed unanimously to extend a cordial invitation to Councillor Mrs Wendy Foster to accept the office of Lord Mayor for the following municipal year.
Councillor Bowyer proposed the motion, seconded by Councillor Evans as follows:
The following declarations of interest were made by councillors in accordance with the code of conduct in respect of items under consideration at the meeting - Name Minute Number Reason Interest Councillor Mrs Aspinall 25a 25c School Governor Born after 6 April 1951 Personal Personal Councillor Bowie 25a 25c School Governor Born after 6 April 1951 Personal Personal Councillor Bowyer 25b Grandparent Personal [name removed] 25a 25b School Governor Grandparent Personal Personal Councillor Mrs Bridgeman 25b 25c Parent Born after 6 April 1951 Personal Personal Councillor Carson 25b Parent Personal Councillor Churchill 25a School Governor Personal Councillor Cook 25b Parent Personal Councillor Dann 25c Born after 6 April 1951 Personal Councillor Darcy 25a and 25b Parent Personal Councillor P Davey 25a School Governor Personal Councillor Deacon 25b Parent Personal Councillor Downie 25b Parent Personal Councillor Drean 25a School Governor Personal Councillor Evans 25a 25b Family member is a school teacher Grandparent Personal Personal Councillor Fry 25b Grandparent Personal Councillor James 25b Grandparent Personal Councillor Jordan 25a 25b School Governor Parent Personal Personal Councillor Kelly 25b parent Personal Councillor Martin Leaves 25a 25b Daughter starting at an Academy Parent Personal Personal Councillor Mike Leaves 25b Grandparent Personal Councillor Sam Leaves 25a 25b 25c Daughter starting at an Academy Parent Born after 6 April 1951 Personal Personal Personal Councillor Ma
Councillor Bowyer (Leader) proposed and Councillor Evans seconded the recommendations in the report for a Devolution Deal for the Heart of the South West. Following a vote, Council agreed to:
Councillor McDonald proposed and Councillor Evans seconded a motion on the .
Councillor McDonald proposed and Councillor Evans seconded the motion on Family Holidays and School Fines.
An amendment was proposed by Councillor Mrs Aspinall and seconded by Councillor Evans as follows – Delete recommendation 11 and insert – A timetable of meetings to be to be agreed by the Chair and Vice Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee in consultation with the Monitoring Officer and published once agreed.
An amendment was proposed by Councillor Stevens and seconded by Councillor Evans as follows – To amend recommendation 3 – After ‘considered’ insert ‘and only implemented following a positive vote’.
A further amendment was moved by Councillor Stevens and seconded by Councillor Evans as follows – To add an additional resolution – ‘4. The proposals shall be based on meaningful consultation with the public and principal partners and stakeholders.’ Following the vote the amendment was agreed unanimously.
A further amendment was moved by Councillor Stevens and seconded by Councillor Evans as follows – To add an additional resolution 4 or 5 as appropriate – ‘The work of the Constitution, Civic and Councillor Development Working Group, referred to above in 3, be chaired and co-ordinated by a politically independent non-Councillor/non Council employee recommended by the Monitoring Officer and agreed by the Constitution, Civic and Councillor Development Working Group.’ (The Lord Mayor left the meeting to attend an engagement and the Deputy Lord Mayor took the Chair until the end of the meeting.
Councillor Smith moved, and Councillor Stevens seconded, that Councillor Evans is elected as Leader of the City Council.
For Councillor Evans (26) Councillors [name removed], Bowie, Coker, Dann, Phillipa Davey, Sam Davey, Evans, Hendy, Lowry, Mavin, McDonald, Morris, Parker-Delaz-Ajete, Penberthy, Rennie, Singh, Smith, Sparling, Stevens, Jon Taylor, Kate Taylor, Tuffin, Tuohy, Vincent, Wheeler and Winter.
Councillor Evans (Leader) invited the Cabinet to send thoughts and condolences to those in Brussels following the bombings which had taken place that morning. He advised that the flags outside the Guildhall were being flown at half-mast as a mark of respect.
Councillor Evans (Leader) proposed and Councillor Mrs Beer seconded the recommendation of the Lord Mayor’s Selection Committee.
Councillor Evans proposed and Councillor Lowry seconded and Council agreed a proposal to move straight to the vote.
Councillor Penberthy proposed and Councillor Evans seconded a recommendation on the Ernest Brock Home for the Aged Charity.
Councillor Smith proposed and Councillor Evans seconded the Annual Calendar of Council and Committee meetings 2016/17.
Having been proposed by Councillor Mrs Aspinall and seconded by Councillor Mrs Beer, it was agreed that Councillor Evans is appointed Chair of the Lord Mayor Selection Committee for the municipal year.
· Councillor Evans – award of OBE;
Councillor Lowry (Cabinet Member for Finance) proposed and Councillor Evans (Leader) seconded the report of the Corporate Management Team (Cabinet minute 52 refers).
Councillor Evans, Leader proposed and Councillor Bowyer seconded the report of the Chief Executive on a Devolution Deal for the South West subject to the removal of the words ‘before the end of the year in recommendation 2’.
During the debate Councillor Evans proposed and Councillor Smith seconded an amendment to the motion as follows – · delete the words, ‘Jeremy Corbyn M.P.
Councillor Philippa Davey proposed and Councillor Evans seconded a motion on police funding subject to changing the last word ‘missions’ to ‘millions’.
At the start of this item and following a proposal from Councillor Evans and seconded by Councillor Smith, it was agreed to amend Council Procedure Rule 10 to extend the time for adjournment until 8pm to conclude the business for the meeting.
Councillor Penberthy proposed and Councillor Evans seconded a motion on maintaining support for community energy.
Councillor Evans proposed and Councillor P Davey seconded a motion on EU referendum task group.
Councillor Smith responded on behalf of the Leader as set out below – Question No Question By Cabinet Member Subject 3 (15/16) [name removed], Leader Responses to public questions Asking, receiving and responding to questions takes up time, energy and other resources of the electorate, officers and cabinet members.
The Growth Board met five times a year and was an informal public/ private partnership and was represented by Plymouth City Council with the membership of Councillor Evans (Leader of the Council), Tracey Lee (Chief Executive) and David Draffan (Assistant Director for Economic Development);
Councillor Evans (Leader) referred to the full details of the tender process which for reasons of commercial confidentiality were contained in a separate private report.
Councillor Evans (Leader) referred to further information relating to the need for the additional placements and the provider market and performance which for reasons relating to individuals and commercial confidentiality were contained in a separate private report (referred to in minute 43 below).
Councillor Evans responded as set out below - Question No Question By Cabinet Member Subject Q 5 (15/16) [name removed] Evans (Council Leader) Use of Mobility Scooters Disability and the use of mobility scooters has increased, whilst many drivers have little/no training causing a danger to themselves and the public. Enforcing speed limits, compulsory training and dealing with offenders appropriately will encourage the sensible use, keeping users and the public safer.
The following question and response were circulated and [name removed] having declined to ask the question at the meeting, was advised that the written response would be set out in the minutes of the meeting - Question No Question By Cabinet Member Subject Q 6 (15/16) [name removed] Evans (Council Leader) Planning Committee Joint Chairs I see now joint political leadership which will help towards the council’s commitment to Planning Committee being non-political.
In the absence of [name removed] , the following question and response were circulated and a written response would be sent to him after the meeting - Question No Question By Cabinet Member Subject Q 7 (15/16) [name removed] (Council Leader) Legal Action against OPOB (our place our base) How much money did the council spend on the court case by taking legal action against OPOB (our place our base), along with what was the outcome of such action to have any benefit to the residents of Plymouth, and why compensation had to be paid out of the council’s coffers. Response The Council can issue a Community Protection Notice ( a CPN ) to any individual aged over 16 years of age, or a body such as a Company, if satisfied on reasonable grounds that (1) the conduct of the individual or body is having a detrimental effect, of a persistent or continuing nature, on the quality of life of ... view the full minutes text for item 26.
Councillor Evans (Leader) moved and Councillor Smith (Deputy Leader) seconded the Corporate Plan Second Year Review which had been amended following Cabinet on 8 September 2015 and was submitted to the City Council. (Cabinet minute 28 was also submitted).
Councillor Evans also referred to the visit by some councillors to the newly completed Closed Circuit Television centre prior to this meeting and indicated that an alternative date would be offered to those councillors who were unable to attend today.
In the absence of the questioner, a written response would be sent to her as set out below - Question No Question By Cabinet Member Subject 2 (15/16) [name removed], Leader Public question criteria and process To stand by your quote for being an open and transparent, brilliant, co-operative council, can I ask - Why don't you be more like the police and crime commissioner panel, by allowing the public to ask two 100 word questions and have a 30 minutes open debate?
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) introduced the proposals. Peter Honeywell (Transformation Programmes Manager) attended the meeting for this item and highlighted the proposed changes.
Councillor Evans thanked everyone involved in the review of the plan.
Agreed that – (1) the proposed changes to the corporate plan are endorsed with drafting amendments to be agreed by Councillor Evans prior to submission of the plan to the City Council;
As Councillor Evans had tendered his apologies for this meeting, it was necessary to appoint a Chair.
Councillor Evans responded as set out below.
Question No Question By Cabinet Member Subject 1(15/16) [name removed], Leader Planning Committee Joint Chairs Can you please explain how you can justify having two chairpersons on the planning committee, resulting in taking an extra £5,000 out of the budget, instead of having a chairperson and vice chairperson? Also this arrangement is not what is set out in the council’s constitution. Response:
Councillor Evans responded as set out below - Question No Question By Cabinet Member Subject Q1 (15/16) [name removed] Evans (Leader) Administration of the Council Is it legally compulsory for a local authority to have a controlling group of one party or an alliance, representing a majority of the Authority’s Members, or is it possible for a political group to govern as a minority, and to submit its proposals for approval to the full Council? Response Yes, it is possible for a minority political group to form a minority administration.
Councillor Evans responded as set out below - Question No Question By Cabinet Member Subject Q4 (15/16) [name removed] Evans (Leader) Appointments to committees and Cabinet.
Councillor Evans proposed and Councillor Bowyer seconded a motion on the Government announcement on cuts to Public Health funding.
Councillor Evans (Leader) presented the proposals for changes within the Senior Management Team for approval, as recommended in the report of Tracey Lee (Chief Executive and Head of Paid Service).
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) introduced the proposals. Simon Dale (Interim Assistant Director for Street Services) attended the meeting for this item and reported that estimated savings of just under £1m would be achieved with the replacement of aged vehicles and reduced maintenance costs. He also advised that t he drivers of the vehicles had been given the opportunity to contribute towards the proposals.
Councillor Evans thanked everyone involved in the proposals.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) referred to the recent fire at Clowance Lane in Devonport and paid tribute to the fire, police and health services, Council staff and the people of Devonport.
As Councillor Evans had tendered his apologies for this meeting it was necessary to appoint a Chair.
Councillor Evans moved and Councillor Bowyer seconded the recommendations in the report.
Councillor Evans drew members’ attention to the private report on the agenda and stated that he did not intend to move the meeting into Part II, taking it as read that they had all considered and noted its content. He reminded members not to discuss the detail of that paper during this item.
Councillor Evans welcomed culmination of what had been a significant amount of work and offered his congratulations to everyone involved. Alternative options considered and the reasons for the decision – As set out in the report.
Councillor Evans (Leader) proposed and Councillor Nicholson seconded the recommendation of the Lord Mayor’s Selection Committee.
Abstentions (1) Lord Mayor (Chair ) Councillor Evans moved, Councillor Lowry seconded and the Council agreed that the motion as amended was put to the vote without further debate.
Upon reconvening, Councillor Evans proposed and Councillor Rennie seconded a proposal for the Council meeting to move into Part II (to exclude the press and the public) to consider the previous disclosure of commercially sensitive information.
Following the motion on ‘towns against tax dodging’ (minute 85 refers), and following a proposal from Councillor Evans and seconded by Councillor Rennie, it was agreed to waive Council Procedure Rule 10.1 to enable the conclusion of the business on the agenda.
Councillor Evans proposed and Councillor Stevens seconded a motion on Land Registry Proposals for Local Land Charges.
Councillor Stevens proposed and Councillor Evans seconded a motion on Members of Parliament.
Councillor Smith (Deputy Leader) presented and Councillor Evans seconded the draft calendar of meetings for Council and Committees 2015/16.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) presented his report on urgent Cabinet and key decisions taken since May 2014.
Stefan Krause (City Centre Manager) Patrick Knight (Economy and Employment Manager), David Draffan (Assistant Director for Economic Development) and Councillor Tudor Evans (Leader of the Council) provided Members with an update on the Plymouth City Centre Company Business Improvement District Ballot.
Councillor Peter Smith (Deputy Leader) congratulated Councillor Evans (Council Leader) on his award of Leader of the Year.
Councillor Evans indicated that the Council had received a number of other awards recently including partnership working for social enterprise, partnership working for energy and school catering. The Council had also won the award for large employer for apprenticeships, all of which were significant achievements.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) highlighted that, since May 2012, around £808m of major development projects had been approved and £497m of that work had been started or was already completed. A further £311m of development already had planning permission; all of which supported the Council’s ambitions for the city.
In response to recent discussions at the Co-operative Scrutiny Board, Councillor Evans (Council Leader) reminded Members that over 40% of land in Plymouth was classed as green space and there were nine sites of Special Scientific Interest, ten local nature reserves and twenty six county wildlife sites. Plymouth was a unique city and the Plymouth Plan would help to protect and enhance the city which already compared favourably against other cities in the south of England for measures such as publicly accessible green space, congestion, air quality and recycling. The information displayed at the meeting, which highlighted how well Plymouth was performing would be included on the Council’s website.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) reported that the proposals would take effect from 1 April 2015 and would radically transform how health and social care services were planned and delivered, bringing together services such as public health, hospitals, community safety, community health services and children’s services, with the focus being on individuals rather than on the institutions providing the services.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) introduced the proposals and indicated that officers had been working with employers and others to reduce youth unemployment and the rising number of NEETs (Not in Employment, Education or Training) but that there was more to be achieved.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) introduced the draft Annual Report which set out the Council’s priorities, achievements and this administration’s current plans for next year following approval of the 2015/16 budget.
The Council was advised that the recommendation would be formally considered at the next meeting of the Council to be held on 23 March 2015; (c) 2015 Councillor Achievement Awards congratulated Councillor Evans on his shortlisting by the Local Government Information Unit and the CCLA (Church, Charity and Local Authority Investment Management) for Leader of the Year as part of the 2015 Councillor Achievement Awards and wished him well at the Awards Ceremony in London on 2 March 2015; (d) Improvement and Efficiency Awards reported that the Council had been shortlisted in two categories of the national Improvement and Efficiency Awards 2015. He advised that the Council’s approach to being a partner had been recognised in the Working Together category where the partnership with the social enterprise sector had been acknowledged as being exemplary.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) moved that in accordance with Part B, Council Procedure Rule 14.6 of the Constitution, Rule of Debate 4.2 (in Appendix One) (which limits speeches to five minutes) is suspended for this item in relation to the speeches by the Leader and Leader of the Opposition.
Having been proposed by Councillor Mrs Aspinall, and seconded by Councillor Mrs Beer, it is agreed that Councillor Evans is appointed Chair of the Lord Mayor’s Selection Committee for the Municipal Year.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) and Tracey Lee thanked Nathan for attending the meeting and for his presentation. The thanks of Cabinet were also extended to Anthony Payne (Strategic Director for Place), David Draffan (Assistant Director for Economic Development) and his team, and to all staff who had worked on this project.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) proposed the response to the recommendations as detailed in the report of Tracey Lee (Chief Executive) and indicated that training should be included in the induction programme for new members to provide an improved grounding in scrutiny. Alternative options considered and reasons for the decision – As set out in the report.
Following an invitation from Councillor Evans (Council Leader), Cabinet Members reported on the improvements that had been delivered in their areas in the last 12 months, and also those that would be delivered in 2015/16, including – (l) an additional 40 beds in extra care schemes;
Councillor Evans also reported that this was the ... view the full minutes text for item 125.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) thanked the officers for their work.
Councillor Evans asked officers to include concerns on double counting for the Better Care Fund when making representations on the ‘missing millions’.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) asked to have sight of the comparisons with other local authorities in the south west and with Plymouth’s statistical neighbour local authorities, where either had received a greater amount of funding per head of population (under the age of five years) than Plymouth;
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) presented the proposals to finalise the Land Transfer Agreement to transfer areas of HM Naval Base South Yard from the Ministry of Defence to Plymouth City Council as part of the Plymouth and South West Peninsula City Deal which would benefit Devonport, Plymouth and the Peninsula.
Councillor Evans responded that it was not his portfolio and that Councillor Peter Smith was the portfolio holder.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) reported that the meeting had started later than usual because he and Tracey Lee (Chief Executive) had accompanied the Rt Hon Michael Fallon MP (Defence Secretary) on a boat trip to see Devonport Dockyard. They had taken the opportunity to explain the proposals for South Yard which were part of the City Deal and had asked him to consider naming one of the new frigates HMS Plymouth.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) asked officers to liaise with other regulatory services to ascertain any current work on public funerals and if possible to join with others and to ask the Local Government Association to lobby for the payment of grants for funeral expenses to local authorities.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) drew the attention of Cabinet Members to the separate private report, containing commercially sensitive information, referred to in minute 109 below.
Councillor Evans highlighted the method statement on child sexual exploitation and urged everyone to read it to gain an understanding of the harrowing cases that were dealt with by children’s social workers. He paid tribute to and thanked the social workers for their work. Emma Crowther (Commissioning Officer) attended the meeting for this item and reported that she had tried to balance the commercial elements of the agreements with the need to maintain a quality service.
(h) that Councillor Evans would be raising the issue with the Local Government Association.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) thanked Jamie and the events’ team for their work.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) drew the attention of Cabinet Members to the separate private report on options for the future delivery of Highways Maintenance Services, which contained commercially sensitive information and was referred to in minute 108 below. Anthony Payne (Strategic Director for Place) submitted a report on the options available to the Council for the delivery of Highways Maintenance Services, in both the long term and short and medium term. The report – (a) assessed the options and identified the relative advantages, disadvantages and risks of each;
Councillor Evans supported the amendment and – (h) indicated that the existing contract had not addressed the long history of the deteriorating road network and had not afforded Council tax payers any protection in relation to additional works that were required;
Councillor Evans (Council Leader ) introduced the proposals and reiterated his comments in relation to his discussions with the Rt Hon Michael Fallon MP (Defence Secretary). He indicated that during those discussions, he had paid tribute to role of Commodore Little in the progress of this initiative.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) welcomed Douglas Fletcher (Chair of the City Centre Company), Stefan Krause (City Centre Manager) and Amanda Lumley (Chief Executive Officer, Destination Plymouth) to the meeting in addition to David Draffan (Assistant Director for Economic Development) and Chris Grace (Head of Economy, Enterprise and Employment) who also attended the meeting for this item. Stefan Krause and Doug Fletcher advised that – (f) the focus of the new BID was on step change and major improvements to move it forward as a key shopping and community destination. Partnership was crucial to success of the BID and the support of the City Council was and would continue to be very valuable in this respect; (g) the proposals for the new BID business plan would be signed off by the City Centre Board on 10 December 2014;
Councillor Evans thanked Doug Fletcher for his commitment to the City Centre and for his drive, enthusiasm and support. Alternative options considered and the reasons for the decision – As set ... view the full minutes text for item 103.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) thanked all the officers for their work for this meeting and conveyed the compliments of the season to everyone.
Councillor Evans proposed and Councillor Stevens seconded the following amendment - ‘To number the following recommendation - (1) Tamar Bridge Office Development is added to the Tamar Bridge and Torpoint Ferry Joint Committee’s capital programme with a budget of £3.33million;
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) presented his revision to the Cabinet Membership and the Leader’s Scheme of Delegation and welcomed Councillor Jon Taylor to the Cabinet.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) proposed and Councillor Peter Smith (Deputy Leader) seconded the recommendations in the report.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) introduced the report and Peter Honeywell (Transformation Programmes Manager) - (a) highlighted two of the achievements in relation to new homes where the target of 450 homes had been surpassed by 731 homes to date and that there was evidence that the Council was reversing recent trends on jobs;
Question No Question By Cabinet Member Subject Q6/ 14-15 [name removed], Leader Social Media Given the elected Members corporate parenthood role and the Council's duties and responsibilities in terms of openness and transparency, does the Leader require of himself, and of his colleagues, the utmost probity in the use of social media at all times and in all places?
Question No Question By Cabinet Member Subject Q8/ 14-15 Sarah Car Councillor Evans, Leader Plymouth Hoe Diving Boards As a mum of a child that tombstones will The Leader of the Council listen to the kids and the parents and consider supporting the campaign to bring back the Plymouth Hoe diving boards to give kids back somewhere to use instead of dangerous jumping off the rocks.
Councillor Evans (Leader) presented a report on the Corporate Plan review (Cabinet minute 24 referred).
Councillor Evans (Leader) seconded the recommendation.
Councillor Evans (Leader) presented a report on Brittany Ferries’ connections to Spain and Brittany.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) referred to the comments made in the press on interim staff by Councillor Bowyer and indicated that Councillor Bowyer had been part of the decision making process in the Appointments Panel. David Northey (Head of Corporate Strategy) also attended the meeting for this item. Alternative options considered and the reasons for the decision – As set out in the report.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) referred to the draft minute following the joint scrutiny review that had been held by the Working and Your Plymouth Panels on 28 August 2014 which supported the recommendations within the proposed business case in relation to this item.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) referred to the draft minute following the joint scrutiny review that had been held by the Working and Your Plymouth Panels on 28 August 2014 which supported the recommendations within the proposed business case subject to Cabinet reconsidering the delegation of decisions to officers and asking Cabinet to consider the commercialisation strategy at Cabinet, in the interests of openness and transparency. Alternative options considered and reasons for the decision – As set out in the report.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) referred to the draft minute following the joint scrutiny review that had been held by the Working and Your Plymouth Panels on 28 August 2014 which supported the recommendations within the proposed business case subject to Cabinet reconsidering the delegation of decisions to officers and asking Cabinet to consider any alternative service delivery for street services at Cabinet, in the interests of openness and transparency.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) whilst acknowledging the statutory responsibilities, reminded Cabinet Members that no additional resources had been allocated by government to support them and thanked officers for their work. Alternative options considered and reasons for the decision – As set out in the report.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) reported that o n 8 August 2014, Eric Pickles (Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government) had written to all council leaders about new regulations under the Local Audit and Accountability Act, which came into force last week and gave the press and public the right to film, to report all council meetings and the right to access information about the more important decisions taken by council officers. He advised that this council already webcast most of the main meetings and published major decisions taken by officers. Members of the public were not stopped from using social media at meetings and in fact, were encouraged to do so.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) welcomed the MTV Crashes event to Plymouth which was taking place on the Hoe this evening. Top named bands would be performing, including the Kaiser Chiefs, The 1975, Example and Kiesza . The event would be broadcast in August 2014 to a potential audience of two million people.
Councillor Evans (Chair) joined with Councillor Coker to thank the Panel and the Co-operative Scrutiny Board for their work, together with the co-operative review group members and all those who supported it.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) once again thanked the Council’s staff, who had worked above and beyond the call of duty during the storms and also the staff of Amey .
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) reported that pre decision scrutiny by the Your Plymouth Scrutiny Panel had asked Cabinet to delay the decision to adopt the framework pending a co-operative review being undertaken. However, this would prevent work with partners and communities on developing the detail of how this would work in practice.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) introduced the proposals.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) took the opportunity to thank officers for their hard work and commitment in progressing the Integrated Commissioning Business Case, the Integrated Community Health and Social Care Delivery and the Co-operative Children and Young People’s Services.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) seconded the Cabinet decision.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) welcomed new councillors to this first meeting of the City Council.
3 Councillor Ball Councillor Evans Would Councillor Evans retract the comments he made in the Herald about the use of the camera car?
Councillor Evans (Chair) referred to former Councillor Williams who had been unsuccessful in the recent local elections and thanked her for her invaluable services as Cabinet Member responsible for children and young people’s services and transformation.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) reported that the pledges formed a two year programme and proposed an amendment to pledge 7 to replace the word ‘Tory’ with ‘government’. Alternative options considered and the reasons for the decision – As set out in the report.
Agreed that the appointments are confirmed as indicated on the schedule subject to the appointment of Councillor Coker (replacing Councillor Evans) to the Destination Plymouth Board.
The Council received the report of the Council Leader ( Councillor Evans) which advised that changes had been made to Cabinet which would comprise the following Members – Portfolio Member Deputy Leader Councillor Peter Smith Finance Councillor Mark Lowry Children, Young People and Public Health Councillor Sue McDonald Health and Adult Social Care Councillor Ian Tuffin Co-operatives, Housing and Community Safety Councillor Chris Penberthy Environment Councillor Brian Vincent Transport Councillor Mark Coker The membership of Cabinet was noted.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) thanked Tracey Lee (Chief Executive), the senior management team, and all staff for their work towards the delivery of the outstanding results. He also thanked Peter Honeywell and his team for their work in monitoring progress.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) thanked Ian Ellis for his work on this scheme. Agreed that the contract for the provision of low energy street lighting luminaires is awarded to Urbis Schreder Limited, the most economically advantageous tenderer for - (1) Lot 1: residential luminaires (2) Lot 2: residential decorative luminaires (3) Lot 3: Main road luminaires (4) Lot 4: Main road decorative luminaires (5) Lot 5: Area and zebra crossing floodlights
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) thanked Nicola Kirby (Senior Democratic Support Officer (Cabinet)) for her work during the year.
Councillor Evans advised the panel that this was Councillor Monahan’s last working day as a councillor and thanked him for his extended period of commitment and service to the Council and the people of Plymouth over many years. He also offered him best wishes for his retirement.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) - (c) referred to the recent publication of Network Rail’s Five Year Investment Plan in Railways and highlighted the omission of the far South West of England. Although the existing, Victorian main line at Dawlish was re-opening, the campaign for a fast, resilient railway needed to be continued and he called on every Member of Parliament in the south west to support it; (d) announced the completion of 99 of the 100 pledges made by the Labour administration and the other, numerous achievements of the last 12 months. He extended thanks to the Chief Executive and all the staff for their work over the last 12 months and for their great public service to the citizens of Plymouth.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) presented a refresh of the for adoption (Cabinet minute 120 referred). Members also considered the Cabinet report together with the draft strategy and were advised that a summary document was also available.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) presented the Cabinet recommendation seeking Council’s approval to delegate authority to the Leader to add schemes and remove schemes from the capital programme and determine the priority of all schemes in the programme, provided that the total value of the capital programme as agreed by Council should not be exceeded. Members also considered the Cabinet report.
Councillor Evans (Chair of the Lord Mayor’s Selection Committee) presented the recommendation of the Lord Mayor’s Selection Committee (Lord Mayor’s Selection Committee minute 4 referred).
Councillor Evans (Chair of the Appointments Panel) provided an update on the decision of the Appointments Panel held on 20 March 2014 relating to the post of Director of Public Health and the process for the recruitment and dismissal of staff reporting direct to the post holder.
The proposal was seconded by Councillor Evans (Council Leader).
Councillor Evans summed up the substantive motion.
Councillor Rennie moved and Councillor Evans seconded that the vote was taken. Following a vote, the motion was carried.
The City Council agrees to – R ecommend that a decision is made within seven days of this meeting to help alleviate further speculation and uncertainty within the Plymouth economy.’ Councillor Coker proposed and Councillor Evans seconded the following amendment – To amend the motion as follows – Recommend that a decision is made within seven days of this meeting to alleviate further speculation and uncertainty within the Plymouth economy. at the July 2014 Cabinet meeting to enable proper consideration of the consultation responses.
Councillor Evans presented the written report on urgent Cabinet and key decisions taken since May 2013.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) proposed and Councillor Peter Smith (Deputy Leader) seconded the recommendations of the Chief Executive and Head of Paid Service in response to the report of the Monitoring Officer.
During the above item and following a proposal from Councillor Evans and seconded by Councillor Bowyer, it was agreed to waive Council Procedure Rule 10 to enable the conclusion of the business on the agenda.
Councillor Evans (Leader) introduced the proposals.
Duncan Selbie , Chief Executive, Public Health England has requested to meet Tracey Lee, Chief Executive, Councillor Sue McDonald, Cabinet Member for Adult Social Care and Public Health and Councillor Tudor Evans, Leader of Plymouth City Council following receipt of letter sent to the Secretary of State for Health to discuss Plymouth’s public health settlement;
David Draffan (Assistant Director for Economic Development) and Councillor Evans (the Leader) were also in attendance to answer the Committee’s questions.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) – (e) expressed concern that the Devon and Somerset Fire and Rescue Authority were meeting to agree their precept on the same day as the City Council to set the Council Tax and asked the Chief Executive to write to the authority to try and prevent similar circumstances in future years; (f) asked that recorded votes were taken on any amendments to and the final decision on the budget and Council Tax rates; (g) moved the recommendations in the written report of the Chief Executive to the City Council, including the 2014/15 Council Tax rates.
In presenting the proposals, Councillor Evans referred to – (h) the scale of the cuts made by the Coalition Government which had resulted in a real terms funding reduction of nine point five per cent (9.5%) amounting to £12m;
Councillor Evans moved and Councillor Bowyer seconded the following motion, with the corrections indicated – ‘This Council notes that:
Having been proposed by Councillor Drean and seconded by Councillor Peter Smith, it is agreed that Councillor Evans is appointed Chair of the Lord Mayor’s Selection Committee for the Municipal Year.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) advised that discussions with the government and Public Health England were on the basis of a Health Deal, similar to the City Deal, with the Council committing to health improvements in return for future increased funding (over and above the current recompense for underfunding in 2013/14 and 2014/15).
Councillor Evans (Chair) joined with Councillor Coker to thank Councillor Murphy for her work, together with the scrutiny group members and all those who supported the review. He also indicated that work had already started to provide improved journey planning and timetable information at each of the park and ride sites and that the work should be complete by the end of March 2014. Alternative options considered and reasons for the decision – As set out in the report.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) proposed the response to the recommendations as detailed in the report of Tracey Lee (Chief Executive) and thanked Councillor James for his chairmanship of the Board meetings and the conduct of the scrutiny sessions . With regard to comments in relation to transformation, he indicated that assurances could not be given at this stage on precise costs and benefits but that the alternative of cutting front line services was not acceptable to the current administration. If councillors were unwilling to support the transformation programme at the City Council meeting on 24 February 2014, he would want to see alternative proposals presented for a three year balanced budget.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) introduced the proposals and Cabinet Members were advised that the SEP, EU Structural and Investment Fund Strategy and City Deal would all relate to each other and would enable the city to secure the Plymouth Growth Deal. The importance of working across boundaries with Cornwall Council and partners was also stressed. In addition to addressing the needs of the long term unemployed, the focus on the employment needs of older people was welcomed.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) - (f) presented a framed signed picture of HMS Warspite to the Lord Mayor to be hung in the Council House to mark the 1 00 th anniversary of the launch of the battleship on 26 November 2013;
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) seconded the proposal.
Councillor Peter Smith (Deputy Leader) proposed and Councillor Evans (Council Leader) seconded the recommendations in the written report with a slight amendment to recommendation 4 as shown below (additional words underlined) - (4) the List of Polling Places and Districts and Stations attached to the written report is confirmed approved and to note the list of Polling Stations within the Polling Districts as approved by the Returning Officer.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) reported an amendment to his Scheme of Delegation for Executive Functions to clarify that the Cabinet Member with responsibility for finance was responsible for housing benefit and revenues apart from the Council’s Emergency Welfare Fund and other discretionary payments, which would be the responsibility of the Cabinet Member for Co-operatives and Community Development.
Councillor Peter Smith (Deputy Leader) proposed and Councillor Evans (Council Leader) seconded the recommendation on constitutional changes as set out in the written report of Tracey Lee (Chief Executive).
The proposal was seconded by Councillor Evans (Council Leader).
Councillor McDonald proposed and Councillor Evans seconded the following motion - ‘The health profiles recently published by Public Health England show the scale of the challenge that faces us in Plymouth. Only four of the 32 indicators are green and for 18 the situation in Plymouth is significantly worse than the national average.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) accepted Councillor Bowyer’s offer to co-sign the letter to the Secretary of State and also to assist Tracey Lee (Chief Executive) in making contact with the Chief Executive of Public Health England.
Accordingly, in the interests of the Council and the public, and with the consent of Councillor James (Chair of the Co-operative Scrutiny Board) and Councillor Evans (Council Leader), the decision was implemented on 16 December 2013).
Anthony Payne (Director for Place) reported on the current position of the City Deal bid and indicated that Councillor Evans (Council Leader) had led a delegation including representatives of Plymouth University to meet with four government ministers in early November 2013. He had presented the proposals which focussed on the marine sector (marine engineering and manufacturing) and included partnership working across Cornwall, Devon Somerset and Torbay. The bid had received support with regard to the business support and the skills agenda and a decision was expected shortly on funding requests and the proposal relating to South Yard.
Councillor Evans in particular highlighted the work of Patrick Hartop (Senior Policy, Performance and Partnerships Adviser) in progressing this bid and recognised the team effort in order to get to this position.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) introduced the item.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) advised councillors that this was Jayne’s last meeting of Cabinet before her retirement and thanked her for her service to the city and the Council.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) congratulated the officers on their work and asked that any learning from the process was communicated to other areas in the Council.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) introduced the proposals. Craig McArdle (Head of Joint Strategic Commissioning) emphasised that the proposals provided an opportunity to transform commissioning with co-development, co-production and co-evaluation of services with the core values at the centre of commissioning.
Councillor Lowry (Cabinet Member for Finance) and Councillor Evans (Council Leader) introduced the proposals, highlighting the Council’s ambitious transformation programme to help the Council become a brilliant co-operative council and deliver the priorities for the city despite the funding gap caused by government cuts, rising costs and increasing demand for some services. The programme included - (a) raising income by taking a proactive and fairer approach to fees and charges, following approval of the Fees, Charges and Concessions Policy, where fees and charges would be reviewed when appropriate instead of being part of the annual budget setting process;
The City Council – (1) Agreed the following appointments - Committees and Other Bodies Appointments 2013/14 (a) Devon and Somerset Fire and Rescue Authority Councillor Mrs Bowyer to replace Councillor Darcy (b) Plymouth Charity Trust Councillor Damarell to replace Councillor Penberthy (c) Admission Forum Councillor Mrs Bowyerto replace Councillor Monahan (d) LEP Community Interest Company (to replace current LEP Board) Nominated director: Councillor Evans Alternate director: Tracey Lee (Chief Executive) (e) Local Government Association General Assembly Councillor Peter Smith to be appointed as a substitute member for Councillor Evans (2) noted the following changes notified to the Assistant Director for Law, Democracy and Governance – Committee / Outside Body Membership (f) Co-operative Scrutiny Board Councillor Darcy to replace Councillor Ball (g) Ambitious Plymouth Overview and Scrutiny Panel Councillor Mrs Beer (Vice Chair) to replace Councillor Monahan (h) Caring Plymouth Overview and Scrutiny Panel Councillor Ricketts to replace Councillor Michael Leaves Councillor Mrs Foster to replace Councillor Mrs Beer ( i ) Working Plymouth Overview and Scrutiny Panel Councillor Martin Leaves to replace Councillor Ball Councillor Darcy to replace Councillor Ball as Vice Chair (j) Your Plymouth Overview and Scrutiny Panel Councillor Sam Leaves (Vice Chair) to replace Councillor Bowyer (k) Taxi Licensing Committee Councillor Jarvis to replace Councillor Singh (Councillor
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) - (f) wished Councillor Bowyer well in his new position of Leader of the Opposition; .
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) seconded the proposals.
The Council resolves to ask the Cabinet to bring forward the publication of the Plymouth Plan to March 2014 in order to give the citizens of Plymouth a further opportunity to be consulted on the Council’s preferred options for the growth of their City and to provide greater certainty on the potential funding for vital infrastructure works in the north of Plymouth.’ Councillor Vincent moved the following amendment which was seconded by Councillor Evans.
The Council calls upon the Cabinet to drive the redevelopment of Colin Campbell Court and the West End, in consultation with the local community and deliver investment in this vital sector of our local economy.’ Councillor Evans moved, Councillor Nicholson seconded and it was agreed that the motion is considered in private on the grounds that it involves the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined in paragraph 3 of Part 1 of Schedule 12A of the Act, as amended by the Freedom of Information Act 2000, and that the item is considered at the end of the meeting. (See minute 75 below)
Councillor McDonald proposed and Councillor Evans seconded the following motion - (The original motion submitted was subsequently amended and circulated prior to the meeting with the additional words shown underlined (no words were deleted)).
During consideration of the above item, the Lord Mayor congratulated male councillors on their moustaches in support of the Movember Campaign and Councillor Evans thanked everyone for their support, including those who had assisted with the cake sale.
Following reference by Councillor Evans to a former councillor in Bradford, the Lord Mayor ruled that the line of questioning should not be continued.
Councillor Evans responded that he would ask them to move out of plain sight.
In the absence of Councillor Evans (Council Leader), Councillor Peter Smith (Deputy Leader) introduced the proposals and advised that the report would be considered by the Co-operative Scrutiny Board on 27 November 2013.
David Draffan, Assistant Director for Economic Development, Patrick Knight, Economy and Employment Manager, Chris Grace, Head of Economy, Enterprise and Employment and The Leader, Councillor Tudor Evans, provided the panel with an update on the Plan for Jobs.
Agreed that Councillor Evans is appointed Chair and Councillor Peter Smith is appointed Vice Chair of this panel.
The Chair further advised that the Leader (Councillor Evans) wished to convey his gratitude for the hard work that had been undertaken by scrutiny and the value that this had added to the council’s business.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) and David Trussler (Interim Director for Corporate Services) provided a briefing on delivering the Brilliant Cooperative Council, which highlighted the following key points – (a) the impact of reduced funding from Central Government was being compounded by the rising demand for services such as adult social care for older people, falling income from commercial rents and the rising costs of contracted services and utilities;
The Chair thanked Councillor Evans and the Interim Director for Corporate Services for attending.
Councillor Evans asked Councillor James to pass the thanks of Cabinet to all councillors involved in the reviews and he looked forward to seeing the outcomes. Agreed that, in future, a written report is also presented to Cabinet on the work of scrutiny.
Councillor Evans (Chair) joined with Councillor Peter Smith to thank Councillor Tuffin for his work, together with the task and finish group members and all those who supported the review. The recommendations were noted and members were advised that a draft policy on libraries would be submitted to Cabinet in due course.
Councillor Evans (Chair) also drew Members’ attention to the separate private report containing commercially sensitive financial details, referred to in minute 56 below.
Agreed that Councillor Evans is appointed Chair and Councillor Peter Smith is appointed Vice Chair of this panel.
The Chair reported that he has received a letter from the Leader of the Council, Councillor Evans requesting that the PSAB instigate a review of care homes.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) - (d) reported that, as a result of major cuts in transport funding and in spite of a commitment by government to address under investment, the gap in spending between the south west and London and the UK as a whole, continued to increase. He had raised the issue at the Board of the LEP and it was agreed to work collectively at board level to make representations to the government using all available channels;
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) presented the Cabinet recommendation on the new Enterprise Units at Oceans Studios (Cabinet minute 25 referred) and updated the council on the figures, amending the figure of £794,000 to £802,655 due to the withdrawal of some anticipated funding.
Following a debate, Councillor Evans indicated that officers would take action to mitigate the risks and offered a briefing to Councillor Darcy if he so wished.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) presented the Cabinet recommendations on the Brilliant Co-operative Council Sustainable Three Year Plan (Cabinet minute 42 referred) and indicated that in order to avoid cuts to address the £65m predicted shortfall in three years’ time, a transformation programme was being developed with a view to adopting a commercial approach to providing services. The council would work with partners, communities and the Co-operative Scrutiny Board. In addition opposition members would be invited to join a proposed Transformation Advisory Group.
Following a debate, Councillor Evans advised members that he had appointed Councillor Williams as the Cabinet lead for transformation.
The recommendations of the Co-operative Scrutiny Board were noted, which endorsed the Cabinet recommendations and included a request for a further report to the Co-operative Scrutiny Board on 16 October 2013 when Councillor Evans and the Chief Executive would report on the transformation programme and its key elements, including governance proposals.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) proposed the recommendations in the written report and Councillor Fry (Leader of the Opposition) seconded the proposals.
Following a debate, Councillor Evans indicated that officers would be working with the staff side.
Tracey Lee (Chief Executive) and Councillor Evans (Council Leader) presented a report that identified some of the key financial challenges that the Council faced over the coming three years, proposed a revised approach to financial planning over the medium term and sought approval for a council-wide transformation programme based on co-operative values to substantially reduce the operating costs of the Council and ensure the maximum possible investment in achieving the Corporate Plan objectives.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) introduced the proposals which would provide a free wi-fi facility for visitor and residents in the City Centre and waterfront areas. Sheldon Ryan (Economic Development Officer) attended the meeting and outlined the procurement process for the network.
Agreed – (1) the progression of a concession to utilise Plymouth City Council assets (street furniture) in order to deliver a wireless communications network; (2) that authority is given to the Portfolio Holder for Economic Development (Councillor Evans (Council Leader)) to make the key decision to award a contract to deliver the wireless communications network to the winner of the concession process.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) introduced the proposals and indicated that - (a) the council was taking a structured approach to dealing with an unprecedented reduction in funding by the government; (b) a three year strategy was being proposed which it was hoped would provide a balanced financial position; (c) the transformation programme would need to be driven both by management and politicians.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) introduced the proposals and advised Cabinet Members that the council would be liable for any outstanding payments at the end of the 10 year loan period.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader), in the absence of Councillor Williams (Cabinet Member for Children and Young People), introduced the proposals.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) introduced the report in the absence of Councillor Coker (Cabinet Member for Transport) and indicated that the recommendations of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board Task and Finish Group on a review into subsidised bus routes and through ticketing had been accepted and wherever possible those relevant to subsidised bus services had been incorporated as part of the tender process. A separate private report was also included on the Cabinet agenda detailing the outcomes of the tenders and recommendations for awarding the contracts for specific bus services.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) reported that, although the outcome of the city of culture bid had been disappointing, he was intending to harness the enthusiasm generated and bring forward plans on individual initiatives.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) presented the Cabinet recommendation for approval and Councillor Peter Smith seconded the proposal (Cabinet minute 15 refers).
Councillor Evans moved and Councillor Fry seconded the following motion - ‘Council believes that the proposals by Devon and Somerset Fire and Rescue Authority to cut fire cover in the city are unacceptable.
Councillor Evans moved and Councillor Peter Smith seconded the following motion- ‘Council believes Plymouth should be on the and will campaign to this end.’ During the debate the issues raised included - (a) the city was not on the even though the city had a university, naval base and was a strategic port with cross channel ferries; (b) if the city was part of the network, there would be greater opportunities to improve rail and road connectivity and a higher priority given in the allocation of the scarce local transport monies; (c) it was vital for growth, business confidence, jobs and tourism. Following a vote, the motion was agreed as submitted.
Councillor Evans moved and Councillor Coker seconded the following motion - ‘The Council is extremely concerned about the recurrence of odour issues at the .
Councillor Coker responded that officers were working with the Royal William Yard and he was hoping to sign off a proposal in the next month. 2 Councillor Stark Councillor Evans He congratulated Councillor Evans on the success of the recent city of culture open day and proposed that the city should be an English City of Culture as an independent venture.
Councillor Evans responded that he had not heard the term but that the city had a successful track record in new ventures.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) presented the proposals which – ?
Agreed – (1) the following appointments - Committees and Other Bodies Membership Appointments 2013/14 (a) Plymouth Arts Centre up to two observers Cllr Jarvis Cllr Jordan (b) Local Government Association General Assembly up to four representatives Current representative is Cllr Evans (five votes) Councillor Nicholson (Deputy Leader).
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) referred to – (a) the progress of the pledges made by the Labour administration;
Councillor Penberthy (Cabinet Member for Cooperatives and Community Development) presented the Cabinet recommendation for approval and Councillor Evans (Council Leader) seconded the proposal (Cabinet minute 6 referred).
Councillor Lowry (Cabinet Member for Finance) presented the Cabinet recommendation and Councillor Evans (Council Leader) seconded the proposal (Cabinet minute 7a referred).
The Leader, Councillor Tudor Evans and the Chief Executive, Tracey Lee, provided the Board with an overview of the Corporate Plan 2014-2017.
Councillor Evans continuing position as Leader of the City Council was noted.
The Council received the report of the Council Leader ( Councillor Evans) which advised that there were no changes to Cabinet which would comprise the following Members – Portfolio Member Deputy Leader Councillor Peter Smith Public Health and Adult Social Care Councillor Sue McDonald Finance Councillor Mark Lowry Children and Young People Councillor Nicky Williams Environment Councillor Brian Vincent Cooperatives and Community Development Councillor Chris Penberthy Transport Councillor Mark Coker The membership of Cabinet was noted.
Councillor Evans, Leader of the Council, David Draffan, Assistant Director for Economic Development and Amanda Ratsey, Enterprise and Inward Investment Manager presented a report and provided an update on Inward Investment.
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) referred to – (a) the Devon and Somerset Fire and Rescue Service Fire Plan: the council was advised of the contents of a letter that he had written to the chair of the service confirming that the council was opposing the plans relating to Plymouth on the basis that the proposals did not acknowledge or address the issues raised by councillors. The letter was available to councillors on request and could be viewed on the council’s website;
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) presented the Cabinet recommendations for approval and Councillor Peter Smith (Deputy Leader) seconded the proposals (Cabinet minute 155 referred).
add at the end of paragraph 2.5.15 ‘Any change of use from family home to a HMO in streets or areas that have no HMOs will be resisted’.’ In response to a point of order by Councillor Evans (Council Leader), Councillor Nicholson indicated that he was not a landlord. Where councillors were landlords of property, the Assistant Director for Democracy and Governance advised councillors should have considered the agenda and declared interests as appropriate. The Assistant Director for Democracy and Governance reported that if the council changed the Cabinet recommendations, that decision would be an in principle decision and that the Leader would have an opportunity to object to it.
Following a request for an adjournment by Councillor Evans to take advice from planning officers, the Lord Mayor adjourned the council meeting.
Councillor Vincent (Cabinet Member for Environment) presented the Cabinet recommendations for approval and Councillor Evans (Council Leader) seconded the proposals (Cabinet minute 166a referred). Agreed that – (1) the Community Infrastructure Levy Charging Schedule is adopted as set out in Appendix 1 to the written report, and to set the date for the Charging Schedule to take effect as 1 June 2013;
Councillor Evans (Chair of the Lord Mayor’s Selection Committee) presented the recommendation of the Lord Mayor’s Selection Committee (Lord Mayor’s Selection Committee minute 3 refers).
Councillor Evans (Council Leader) moved and Councillor Coker seconded an amendment as follows – ‘This Council considers it scandalous that the only mainline railway connection to the fifteenth largest city in the country, as well as to the entire County of Cornwall, continues to rest upon a bank of pebbles which wash away when it rains too much. A 21st century city cannot prosper when it relies upon 19th century infrastructure. We therefore call upon the Government to replace mere discussion with urgent practical action, and to immediately allocate the money required spend just a tiny fraction of the £30 billion being proposed for the Midlands' HS2 scheme to install in the very near future at Cowley Bridge outside Exeter, and any similarly vulnerable sites on the route to Plymouth , a concrete viaduct or other robust technical solution.‘ During the debate, issues raised included - (a) action already undertaken by the city’s leaders, including meetings with the Prime Minister, to highlight the continuing impact of the current situation on the economy of the south west; (b) the original motion would not achieve immediate action as the budget for the Midlands’ HS2 scheme had yet to be determined; (c) a multi agency approach was required on behalf of Plymouth and the sub region with a view to achieving a commitment by the government to improve transport links; (d) members of the Management Board had met with Alison Seabeck MP and they had been advised that there was t
Councillor Evans in summing up stressed the urgency of the situation and the need to convey to the government what the south west did and what Plymouth did for the south west. He was due to meet the minister and his position would be strengthened with a united council, united Devon and united south west.
Councillor Evans moved, Councillor Rennie seconded and it was agreed that the meeting reconvenes at 5pm tomorrow (23 April 2013).
Councillor Evans moved and Councillor Tuffin seconded the following motion - ‘ Council notes:
Councillor Evans moved and Councillor Peter Smith seconded the motion as follows – ‘Construction Industry Blacklisting A number of construction companies have been challenged about supporting the existence of and subscribing to unlawful construction industry ‘blacklists’, which detail covertly gathered information on construction trade unionism, militant tendencies, poor timekeeping, trouble making, etc. Blacklisting is an unacceptable practice and cannot be condoned. The GMB union is leading a national campaign aimed at forcing those who have been involved in blacklisting to apologise to those who have been affected by it.
(d) will encourage its partners to take similar measures with regard to their suppliers.’ In moving the motion, Councillor Evans indicated that he was supporting local people and employment. He was aware of issues with some companies and a list of those companies would be provided to the procurement team for them to scrutinise.
Councillor Peter Smith (Deputy Leader) moved and Councillor Evans (Council Leader) seconded the draft programme of ordinary meetings of the council and committees 2013/14 for approval.
Councillor Evans presented a written report on urgent Cabinet and key decisions in accordance with the constitution (paragraphs 3.5 of the Cabinet Procedure Rules and 18.3 of the Access to Information Rules referred) relating to – ?
Councillor Evans responded (in the absence of the portfolio holder for children and young people), that the school had 172 pupils and would shortly receive investment of £2.4m.
Councillor Evans presented the report.
Having been proposed by Councillor Fry and seconded by Councillor Mrs Aspinall, it was agreed that Councillor Evans is appointed Chair of the Lord Mayor’s Selection Committee for the Municipal Year.
Councillor Evans, Leader of the Council, David Draffan, Assistant Director for Economic Development and Chris Grace, Head of Economy, Enterprise and Employment, presented a report outlining the Plan for Jobs. The panel heard – (a) that the Plan for Jobs was a new innovative initiative for Plymouth which aimed to deliver 19 projects which in turn would create 2,000 jobs over the next two years;
The Chair thanked Councillor Evans, David Draffan and Chris Grace for their informative report and attendance.
Webcasting Protocol Councillor Peter Smith (Deputy Leader) moved and Councillor Evans (Leader) seconded a revised proposal to recommendation (3) in the written report as follows - ‘Add the following words to recommendation 3:
Councillor Peter Smith (Deputy Leader) moved and Councillor Evans (Leader) seconded a proposal to amend the recommendations in the written report of the Assistant Director for Democracy and Governance, as follows - Add the following words to recommendation 2:
Showing the latest 300 of 435.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Evans attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 29 Jun 2026 | City Council | Appointment of Honorary Aldermen | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jun 2026 | City Council | Support for people dying in poverty | Carried | 51 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 29 Jun 2026 | City Council | Putting Plymouth Residents First | Carried | 35 for, 15 against, 3 abstained | |
| 29 Jun 2026 | City Council | Putting Plymouth Residents First | Carried | 36 for, 16 against, 1 abstained | |
| 29 Jun 2026 | City Council | Putting Plymouth Residents First | Carried | 34 for, 15 against, 4 abstained | |
| 29 Jun 2026 | City Council | Protecting the Dartmoor Ponies | Carried | 48 for, 0 against, 2 abstained | |
| 29 Jun 2026 | City Council | Stop the blockage of traffic flow on Mutley Plain | Carried | 45 for, 2 against, 1 abstained | |
| 29 Jun 2026 | City Council | Stop the blockage of traffic flow on Mutley Plain | Lost | 17 for, 29 against, 3 abstained | |
| 29 Jun 2026 | City Council | Smells from South West Water Treatment Work | Carried | 49 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 29 Jun 2026 | City Council | Holding South West Water to account | Carried | 46 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 23 Apr 2026 | Chief Officer Appointments Panel | Recruitment to the role of Service Director for Quality Assurance, Safeguarding and Partnership | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 2 Mar 2026 | Chief Officer Appointments Panel | Recruitment to the role of Interim Service Director for Education, Participation & Skills | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 9 Feb 2026 | Cabinet | Budget Scrutiny Recommendations | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 May 2025 | City Council | To Elect the Lord Mayor and Deputy Lord Mayor for the Period up to the Next Annual Meeting | Carried | 49 for, 1 against | |
| 16 May 2025 | City Council | To Elect the Lord Mayor and Deputy Lord Mayor for the Period up to the Next Annual Meeting | Carried | 50 for, 0 against | |
| 16 May 2025 | City Council | Vote of thanks to the retiring Lord Mayor and Deputy Lord Mayor | Carried | 50 for, 0 against | |
| 16 May 2025 | City Council | To agree Committees and their members and appoint Chairs and Vice Chairs | Carried | 51 for, 0 against | |
| 16 May 2025 | City Council | To nominate or appoint representatives to outside bodies | Carried | 51 for, 0 against | |
| 28 Apr 2025 | City Council | Referendum for Proposed Alternative Executive Governance Arrangements | Carried | 43 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 17 Mar 2025 | City Council | Declarations of Interest | Carried | 49 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 17 Mar 2025 | City Council | Net Zero Action Plan | Carried | 45 for, 0 against, 4 abstained | |
| 17 Mar 2025 | City Council | Gambling Statement of Principles (Gambling Policy) | Carried | 48 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 17 Mar 2025 | City Council | Plymouth City Council Local Government Reorganisation Interim Plan | Carried | 47 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 17 Mar 2025 | City Council | Lord Mayoralty 2025/2026 | Carried | 6 for, 40 against, 0 abstained | |
| 17 Mar 2025 | City Council | Lord Mayoralty 2025/2026 | Carried | 41 for, 4 against, 1 abstained | |
| 17 Mar 2025 | City Council | Senior Management Structure | Carried | 46 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 17 Mar 2025 | City Council | Designation of Section 151 Officer | Carried | 45 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 17 Mar 2025 | City Council | End of Life Care | Carried | 44 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 24 Feb 2025 | City Council | Declarations of Interest | Carried | 48 for, 0 against, 2 abstained | |
| 24 Feb 2025 | City Council | Proposed Revenue and Capital Budget 2025/26 | Carried | 43 for, 4 against | |
| 14 Feb 2025 | Chief Officer Appointments Panel | Recruitment to new role of Service Director for Adult Social Care | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Feb 2025 | Chief Officer Appointments Panel | Recruitment to the role of Chief Operating Officer | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Feb 2025 | Chief Officer Appointments Panel | Recruitment to the role of Strategic Director for Growth | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Jan 2025 | City Council | Freedom of the City | Carried | 51 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 27 Jan 2025 | City Council | Council Tax Base Setting 2025/26 and Council Tax Support Scheme 2025/26 | Carried | 49 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 27 Jan 2025 | City Council | Pay Policy Statement 2025/26 | Carried | 48 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 27 Jan 2025 | City Council | Committee Calendar 2025/26 | Carried | 49 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 27 Jan 2025 | City Council | Strengthening Measures to Combat Youth Vaping | Carried | 46 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 27 Jan 2025 | City Council | To Call for Auto Enrolment for Free School Meals | Carried | 47 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 9 Jan 2025 | City Council | English Devolution White Paper | Carried | 42 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 9 Jan 2025 | City Council | English Devolution White Paper | Carried | 38 for, 1 against, 4 abstained | |
| 25 Nov 2024 | City Council | Council’s Electoral Cycle | Lost | 16 for, 32 against, 6 abstained | |
| 20 Sep 2024 | Chief Officer Appointments Panel | Recruitment to the role of Service Director for Finance | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Sep 2024 | Chief Officer Appointments Panel | Recruitment to the role of Interim Chief Operating Officer | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 28 Jun 2024 | Chief Officer Appointments Panel | Recruitment to the role of Strategic Director for Adults, Health and Communities | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jun 2024 | City Council | Council Electoral Review | Carried | 51 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 24 Jun 2024 | City Council | Council Electoral Review | Carried | 45 for, 3 against, 4 abstained | |
| 24 Jun 2024 | City Council | Appointment of Honorary Aldermen | Carried | 51 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 14 Jun 2024 | Chief Officer Appointments Panel | Recruitment to the role of Service Director for Integrated Commissioning | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 May 2024 | Chief Officer Appointments Panel | Recruitment to the role of Service Director Children, Young People and Families | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 May 2024 | Chief Officer Appointments Panel | Recruitment to Service Director Finance | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 May 2024 | City Council | To Elect the Lord Mayor and Deputy Lord Mayor for the Period up to the Next Annual Meeting | Carried | 51 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 17 May 2024 | City Council | To Elect the Lord Mayor and Deputy Lord Mayor for the Period up to the Next Annual Meeting | Carried | 50 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 17 May 2024 | City Council | Vote of thanks to the Retiring Lord Mayor and Deputy Lord Mayor | Carried | 51 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 17 May 2024 | City Council | To agree changes to Part D of the Constitution (Scrutiny Arrangements) | Carried | 51 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 17 May 2024 | City Council | To agree committees and their members and appoint Chairs and Vice Chairs | Carried | 51 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 17 May 2024 | City Council | To nominate or appoint representatives to outside bodies | Carried | 51 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 18 Mar 2024 | City Council | Net Zero Action Plan 2024-2027 | Carried | 45 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 18 Mar 2024 | City Council | Lord Mayoralty 2024/25 | Carried | 49 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 18 Mar 2024 | City Council | Motion on Notice - Parental Leave | Carried | 46 for, 0 against, 2 abstained | |
| 18 Mar 2024 | City Council | Motion on Notice - Keyham Unexploded Bomb - Motion of Thanks | Carried | 46 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 8 Mar 2024 | City Council | Declarations of Interest | Carried | 48 for, 0 against | |
| 8 Mar 2024 | City Council | Tamar Bridge and Torpoint Ferry - Future Financing and 2024/25 Revenue Budget and Capital Programme | Carried | 33 for, 12 against, 4 abstained | |
| 8 Mar 2024 | City Council | Revenue and Capital Budget and Proposed Council Tax Levels for 2024/25 | Carried | 33 for, 1 against, 15 abstained | |
| 8 Feb 2024 | Lord Mayor Selection and Advisory Committee | Lord Mayoralty 2024/25 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 8 Feb 2024 | Lord Mayor Selection and Advisory Committee | Lord Mayoralty 2024/25 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2024 | City Council | Plymouth City Airport | Carried | 31 for, 20 against | |
| 29 Jan 2024 | City Council | Plymouth City Airport | Carried | 51 for, 0 against | |
| 29 Jan 2024 | City Council | Council Tax Base Setting 2024/25 and Council Tax Support Scheme 2024/25 | Carried | 48 for, 0 against | |
| 29 Jan 2024 | City Council | Council Tax Discounts and Premiums | Carried | 49 for, 0 against | |
| 29 Jan 2024 | City Council | Proposed amendments to the Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Licensing Policy 2022 in relation to Livery and Topographical Knowledge of Plymouth test | Carried | 45 for, 2 against | |
| 29 Jan 2024 | City Council | Licensing Act 2003 – Statement of Licensing Policy 2024 - 2029 | Carried | 49 for, 0 against | |
| 29 Jan 2024 | City Council | Stage Two - Constitutional Changes | Carried | 43 for, 6 against | |
| 29 Jan 2024 | City Council | Electoral Cycle Consultation | Carried | 33 for, 15 against | |
| 29 Jan 2024 | City Council | Appointment of Statutory Officers (Monitoring Officer and s151 Officer) | Carried | 49 for, 0 against | |
| 29 Jan 2024 | City Council | Pay Policy Statement 2024/25 | Carried | 49 for, 0 against | |
| 29 Jan 2024 | City Council | Local Democratic Access | Carried | 39 for, 7 against | |
| 29 Jan 2024 | City Council | Excess Profits by Private Companies Providing Children’s Social Care | Carried | 48 for, 0 against | |
| 29 Jan 2024 | City Council | Unauthorised Encampments | Carried | 35 for, 5 against, 0 abstained | |
| 29 Jan 2024 | City Council | In lieu of loos | Carried | 42 for, 0 against, 4 abstained | |
| 8 Jan 2024 | Cabinet | Council Tax Discounts and Premiums | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Jun 2023 | City Council | Appointment of Honorary Aldermen / Alderwomen | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Jun 2023 | City Council | Appointments to Committees, Outside Bodies etc | Carried | 51 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 19 Jun 2023 | City Council | Corporate Plan 2023-26 | Carried | 49 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 19 Jun 2023 | City Council | Designation of Statutory Chief Officers | Carried | 51 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 19 Jun 2023 | City Council | Armada Way | Carried | 38 for, 0 against, 13 abstained | |
| 19 Jun 2023 | City Council | Armada Way | Lost | 13 for, 36 against, 2 abstained | |
| 19 Jun 2023 | City Council | Fixing Plymouth's Roads | Carried | 50 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 19 Jun 2023 | City Council | Fixing Plymouth's Roads | Lost | 16 for, 34 against, 0 abstained | |
| 19 Jun 2023 | City Council | Strategic Rail Working Group | Lost | 17 for, 29 against, 3 abstained | |
| 19 Jun 2023 | City Council | BBC Local Radio | Carried | 48 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 19 Jun 2023 | City Council | Livewell Southwest CIC Health Worker Pensions and Pay | Carried | 41 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 13 Jun 2023 | Chief Officer Appointments Panel | Recruitment to Service Director for HROD | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 May 2023 | City Council | Appointment of Honorary Aldermen | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 May 2023 | Lord Mayor Selection and Advisory Committee | Lord Mayoralty 2023/24 | Carried | 6 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 17 May 2023 | Lord Mayor Selection and Advisory Committee | Lord Mayoralty 2023/24 | Carried | 6 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 27 Mar 2023 | City Council | Freedom of the City | Carried | 48 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 27 Mar 2023 | City Council | Appointments to Committees, Outside Bodies etc | Carried | 49 for, 0 against | |
| 27 Mar 2023 | City Council | Suspension of Standing Orders to Allow for Nominations to be made for the Appointment of a New Leader | Lost | 8 for, 36 against | |
| 27 Mar 2023 | City Council | Questions by the Public | Carried | 48 for, 0 against | |
| 27 Mar 2023 | City Council | Plymouth City Council Net Zero Action Plan 2023 - 2026 | Carried | 50 for, 0 against | |
| 27 Mar 2023 | City Council | Council Tax Discounts and Premiums | Carried | 44 for, 0 against | |
| 27 Mar 2023 | City Council | Lord Mayoralty 2023/24 | Carried | 42 for, 5 against | |
| 27 Mar 2023 | City Council | Senior Management Structure and Organisational Design | Carried | 49 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 27 Mar 2023 | City Council | Motions on Notice | Carried | 41 for, 6 against | |
| 27 Mar 2023 | City Council | Full Independent Review of the Armada Way Project and Establishment of a Tree Panel | Carried | 50 for, 0 against | |
| 27 Mar 2023 | City Council | An assessment of the impact of the UK Government's Election Act 2022 on voting rights and voter suppression in Plymouth | Carried | 49 for, 0 against | |
| 27 Mar 2023 | City Council | Urging the UK Government to Provide Additional Funds and Support to Help Plymouth Achieve Its Net Zero 2030 Target | Carried | 39 for, 0 against | |
| 27 Mar 2023 | City Council | Reconsideration of proposed Car Parking Charges | Carried | 26 for, 17 against, 0 abstained | |
| 27 Mar 2023 | City Council | Addressing impacts of rising Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMOs) numbers in Plymouth | Carried | 44 for, 0 against | |
| 27 Mar 2023 | City Council | Motion of No confidence in Leader and Cabinet | Carried | 19 for, 2 against | |
| 17 Mar 2023 | Chief Officer Appointments Panel | Senior Management Restructure | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Feb 2023 | City Council | Declarations of Interest | Carried | 53 for, 0 against | |
| 10 Feb 2023 | Lord Mayor Selection and Advisory Committee | Lord Mayoralty 2023/24 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 30 Jan 2023 | City Council | Freedom of the City | Carried | 46 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 30 Jan 2023 | City Council | Appointments to Committees, Outside Bodies etc | Carried | 6 for, 37 against, 2 abstained | |
| 30 Jan 2023 | City Council | Appointments to Committees, Outside Bodies etc | Carried | 40 for, 4 against | |
| 30 Jan 2023 | City Council | Petition - Armada Way Trees | Carried | 48 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 30 Jan 2023 | City Council | Petition - Armada Way Trees | Carried | 48 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 30 Jan 2023 | City Council | Council Tax Base and Council Tax Support Scheme 2023/24 | Carried | 41 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 30 Jan 2023 | City Council | Tamar Bridge and Torpoint Ferry 2023-2024 Revenue and Capital Estimates | Carried | 35 for, 5 against, 1 abstained | |
| 30 Jan 2023 | City Council | Licensing Cumulative Impact Policy | Carried | 40 for, 0 against | |
| 30 Jan 2023 | City Council | Annual Pay Policy Statement 2023/24 | Carried | 41 for, 0 against | |
| 30 Jan 2023 | City Council | Defibrillators | Carried | 45 for, 0 against, 2 abstained | |
| 30 Jan 2023 | City Council | Motion on Notice on the Loss of Trees in Armada Way | Lost | 6 for, 15 against | |
| 30 Jan 2023 | City Council | Sir Francis Drake Motion | Lost | 3 for, 20 against, 22 abstained | |
| 30 Jan 2023 | City Council | NHS Motion | Carried | 25 for, 0 against | |
| 30 Jan 2023 | City Council | Get Me Home Safely | Carried | 43 for, 0 against | |
| 30 Sep 2022 | Chief Officer Appointments Panel | To deal with any business deferred from the last meeting | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 Sep 2022 | Chief Officer Appointments Panel | Senior Management remuneration | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Jun 2022 | City Council | Appointments to Committees, Outside Bodies etc | Carried | 46 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 20 Jun 2022 | City Council | Capital and Revenue Outturn Report 2021 - 22 | Carried | 47 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 20 Jun 2022 | City Council | Ambulance Response Times | Carried | 46 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 20 Jun 2022 | City Council | Changes to the Planning System | Lost | 19 for, 27 against, 3 abstained | |
| 20 Jun 2022 | City Council | Standards in Public Life | Lost | 19 for, 25 against, 3 abstained | |
| 21 Mar 2022 | City Council | Freedom of the City | Carried | 53 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 21 Mar 2022 | City Council | Motion of No Confidence in the Leader and Election of New Leader | Carried | 29 for, 23 against, 1 abstained | |
| 21 Mar 2022 | City Council | Appointments to Committees, Outside Bodies etc | Carried | 49 for, 0 against | |
| 21 Mar 2022 | City Council | Public Consultation regarding the Council's Electoral Cycle | Carried | 45 for, 3 against | |
| 21 Mar 2022 | City Council | Public Consultation regarding the Council's Electoral Cycle | Carried | 49 for, 0 against | |
| 21 Mar 2022 | City Council | Taxi Licensing Policy | Carried | 49 for, 0 against | |
| 21 Mar 2022 | City Council | Lord Mayoralty 2022/23 | Carried | 48 for, 0 against | |
| 21 Mar 2022 | City Council | Revisions to the Members' Code of Conduct | Carried | 47 for, 0 against | |
| 21 Mar 2022 | City Council | Long Covid | Carried | 48 for, 0 against | |
| 21 Mar 2022 | City Council | Ukraine | Carried | 46 for, 0 against | |
| 21 Mar 2022 | City Council | Women’s Life Expectancy | Carried | 45 for, 0 against | |
| 21 Mar 2022 | City Council | £150 Government Council Tax Rebate | Carried | 45 for, 0 against | |
| 28 Feb 2022 | City Council | Appointments to Committees, Outside Bodies | Lost | 55 for, 1 against | |
| 24 Jan 2022 | City Council | Questions by the Public | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jan 2022 | City Council | Council Tax Base Setting 2022/23 and Council Tax Support Scheme 2022/23 | Carried | 46 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 24 Jan 2022 | City Council | Tamar Bridge and Torpoint Ferry Future Financing | Carried | 44 for, 0 against, 3 abstained | |
| 24 Jan 2022 | City Council | Tamar Bridge and Torpoint Ferry 2022-2023 Revenue and Capital Estimates | Carried | 46 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 24 Jan 2022 | City Council | Climate Emergency Action Plan 2022 | Carried | 46 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 24 Jan 2022 | City Council | Corporate Carbon Reduction Plan 2022 | Carried | 45 for, 0 against | |
| 24 Jan 2022 | City Council | Appointment of External Auditor | Carried | 45 for, 0 against | |
| 24 Jan 2022 | City Council | Audit and Governance Committee Terms of Reference | Carried | 45 for, 0 against | |
| 24 Jan 2022 | City Council | Tamar Bridge and Torpoint Ferry Joint Committee - Change to the Terms of Reference | Carried | 45 for, 0 against | |
| 24 Jan 2022 | City Council | Pay Policy Statement 2022/23 | Carried | 45 for, 0 against | |
| 24 Jan 2022 | City Council | Plympton St Mary Ward’s Polling Districts, Polling Places and Polling Stations Review 2021/2022 | Carried | 45 for, 0 against | |
| 24 Jan 2022 | City Council | Violence Against Women and Girls Commission | Carried | 45 for, 0 against | |
| 26 Nov 2021 | Chief Officer Appointments Panel | Chief Officer Resourcing Update | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Jun 2021 | City Council | Mental Health Services | Carried | 46 for, 0 against | |
| 14 Jun 2021 | City Council | Opting Out of NHS Patient Data sharing with the Private Sector | Carried | 46 for, 0 against | |
| 15 Mar 2021 | City Council | Organisational Design - Senior Management Arrangements | Carried | 51 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 15 Mar 2021 | City Council | Budget for NHS and Carers | Carried | 31 for, 0 against | |
| 15 Mar 2021 | City Council | Budget for NHS and Carers | Carried | 31 for, 0 against, 18 abstained | |
| 15 Mar 2021 | City Council | Weston Mill Recycling Centre | Carried | 30 for, 22 against | |
| 15 Mar 2021 | City Council | Weston Mill Recycling Centre | Carried | 30 for, 22 against | |
| 15 Mar 2021 | City Council | Weston Mill Recycling Centre | Carried | 30 for, 22 against, 0 abstained | |
| 15 Mar 2021 | City Council | Take Away Litter | Carried | 51 for, 1 against | |
| 15 Mar 2021 | City Council | Take Away Litter | Carried | 52 for, 0 against | |
| 15 Mar 2021 | City Council | Take Away Litter | Carried | 52 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 15 Mar 2021 | City Council | Future of Pounds House | Carried | 51 for, 0 against | |
| 15 Mar 2021 | City Council | Future of Pounds House | Carried | 51 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 15 Mar 2021 | City Council | Demise of the 'Friends of Central Park' | Lost | 21 for, 29 against | |
| 15 Mar 2021 | City Council | Demise of the 'Friends of Central Park' | Lost | 21 for, 29 against, 0 abstained | |
| 9 Mar 2021 | Cabinet | Brexit Scrutiny (Fishing) Recommendations | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Feb 2021 | City Council | Revenue and Capital Budget and Proposed Council Tax Levels For 2021/22 | Carried | 30 for, 2 against, 23 abstained | |
| 25 Jan 2021 | City Council | Appointment of Honorary Aldermen/Alderwoman | Carried | 56 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 25 Jan 2021 | City Council | Council Tax Base Setting and Council Tax Support Scheme 2021/22 | Carried | 56 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 25 Jan 2021 | City Council | Tamar Bridge and Torpoint Ferry 2021/22 Revenue Estimates and Capital Programme | Carried | 55 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 25 Jan 2021 | City Council | Pay Policy Statement 2021/22 | Carried | 56 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 25 Jan 2021 | City Council | Plymouth Plan Climate Change Review | Carried | 56 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 25 Jan 2021 | City Council | Climate Emergency Action Plan 2021 | Carried | 56 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 25 Jan 2021 | City Council | Corporate Carbon Reduction Plan 2021 | Carried | 56 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 25 Jan 2021 | City Council | Calendar of Meeting 2021/22 | Carried | 56 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 25 Jan 2021 | City Council | Marine Environment & Fishing | Carried | 30 for, 19 against, 7 abstained | |
| 25 Jan 2021 | City Council | Marine Environment & Fishing | Carried | 34 for, 0 against, 22 abstained | |
| 25 Jan 2021 | City Council | Tampon Tax | Carried | 38 for, 17 against, 0 abstained | |
| 25 Jan 2021 | City Council | Tampon Tax | Carried | 38 for, 0 against, 17 abstained | |
| 25 Jan 2021 | City Council | Supporting Student Renters and Student Landlords | Carried | 45 for, 1 against, 4 abstained | |
| 22 Jun 2020 | City Council | Announcements | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Jun 2020 | City Council | Plymouth and South West Devon Supplementary Planning Document | Carried | 53 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 22 Jun 2020 | City Council | Renaming of Sir John Hawkins Square | Carried | 31 for, 24 against, 3 abstained | |
| 22 Jun 2020 | City Council | Cashless Car Parking Payment in Plymouth | Lost | 25 for, 30 against | |
| 22 Jun 2020 | City Council | Garden Waste | Lost | 25 for, 30 against | |
| 22 Jun 2020 | City Council | Encampments | Carried | 30 for, 22 against, 5 abstained | |
| 16 Mar 2020 | City Council | Announcements | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Mar 2020 | City Council | Lord Mayoralty 2020/21 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Mar 2020 | City Council | Organisational Design – Senior Management Arrangements | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Evans was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 19 of 30 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Evans declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Evans in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Evans sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| City Council | Member | May 2002 | 214 | |
| Cabinet | Chair | Jan 2005 | 141 | |
| Chief Officer Appointments Panel | Chair | Dec 2002 | 130 | |
| Chair | Oct 2026 | 4 | 23 Nov 2026 | |
| Delegated Decisions | Member | May 2017 | 26 | |
| Ham and St Budeaux Area Committee | Member | Jul 2006 | 23 | |
| Audit and Governance Committee | Member | Jun 2008 | 23 | |
| Lord Mayor Selection and Advisory Committee | Chair | Mar 2007 | 18 | |
| Ham & Honicknowle Area Committee (replaced 26/6/06), see Ham and St Budeaux Area Committee and Budshead, Honicknowle and Southway Area Committee | Member | Jun 2003 | 17 | |
| Constitutional Review Panel | Member | Jun 2002 | 9 | |
| Support Services Overview and Scrutiny Panel | Member | Jun 2011 | 8 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Commission - replaced by Overview and Scrutiny Management Board | Guest | Mar 2007 | 6 | |
| Sustainable Communities Overview and Scrutiny Panel | Member | Sep 2008 | 6 | |
| Budshead, Ham, Honicknowle and St Budeaux Area Committee | Member | Jun 2002 | 5 | |
| Resources and Performance Overview and Scrutiny Panel | Member | Apr 2008 | 5 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Commission - Scrutiny Reviews | Member | Jun 2008 | 4 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Management Board | Member | Dec 2010 | 4 | |
| Health and Social Well-being Scrutiny Committee | Member | Jan 2003 | 3 | |
| Economic and Environmental Well-Being Scrutiny Committee | Member | Feb 2003 | 2 | |
| Natural Infrastructure and Growth Scrutiny Panel | Member | Nov 2018 | 2 | |
| Standards Committee.. | Member | Jul 2011 | 1 | |
| Growth and Prosperity Overview and Scrutiny Panel | Member | Jul 2012 | 1 | |
| Co-operative Scrutiny Board | Member | Dec 2015 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.