Fire Safety Policy
Councillor Sanders requested that this item be deferred until the next meeting on 5 August. This was so the team could examine current practice in other councils with a view to benchmarking.
Every time Portsmouth's minutes name Councillor Sanders, as the council published it.
Councillor Sanders requested that this item be deferred until the next meeting on 5 August. This was so the team could examine current practice in other councils with a view to benchmarking.
The nomination was seconded by Councillor Darren Sanders.
Liberal Democrat Cllr Darren Sanders 3.
Eastern Avenue ( Baffins ward) Deputations Jeffery Cushway (resident) Councillor Kadir (ward councillor) Councillor Sanders (ward councillor) Members' Questions In response to Members' questions, it was clarified that:
Hayling Avenue ( Baffins ward) Deputations Councillor Kadir (ward councillor) Councillor Sanders (ward councillor) Members' Comments A Member reported witnessing an accident near Hayling Avenue and highlighted ongoing visibility and traffic flow issues on ... view the full minutes text for item 13.
Councillor Sanders declared a non-prejudicial interest in relation to agenda item 3 as he was a resident in a licensed House of Multiple Occupation.
Councillor Sanders declared a personal, non-prejudicial interest in two respects in relation to agenda item four, Private Sector Housing Fees and Charges:
Cabinet Member comments Councillor Sanders noted that despite the increase in rents, the HRA would still be in a deficit position meaning that there was decreased scope to improve people's homes, not least because of the regulatory requirements for work currently being carried out to make sure buildings were safe.
Cabinet Member Comments Councillor Sanders noted the increase of 3% was below inflation and below the increases in private rents. He noted the need to balance the needs of residents with the needs of private landlords. Full cost recovery was a fundamental principal agreed by all political parties during discussions for the main council tax budget.
Cabinet Member Comments Councillor Sanders stressed that Portsmouth City Council offer all the support possible to tenants to ensure the gas in their homes is safe. DECISION The Cabinet Member for Housing and Tackling Homelessness:
Cabinet Member's Comments Councillor Sanders welcomed the report, highlighting it as a positive outcome. He noted the increased number of moves achieved including for homeless households, veterans and care leavers and the reduction in the waiting list. He observed the measures had provided greater hope for residents seeking rehousing and commended officers for their work in improving outcomes for vulnerable people.
Members Questions and Comments There were none Cabinet Member Comments Councillor Sanders stated that the intention was to achieve a more integrated approach across the local authority and welcomed the policies. However, he noted disappointment that the Housing Ombudsman had decided to separate the issues. He observed that people have the right to feel safe in their own homes and welcomed the policy specific training for officers as every council DECISION The Cabinet Member:
Cabinet Member Comment Councillor Sanders observed that experiencing domestic abuse was the third biggest cause of homelessness in the city and it was important that the person experiencing the abuse and their lived experience was at the heart of all policies. Employing a new Domestic Abuse Advisor demonstrated that the Council was serious about dealing with the issue and made sure that there were targeted training sessions to ensure everyone understood the signs of abuse.
Members' Questions and Comments There were none Cabinet Member Comments Councillor Sanders observed the strategy was designed to avoid homes in the city staying empty for years and that it was a fine balancing act. The Council had managed to cut in half the number of weeks that council properties were void since 2018. He noted the use of Empty Dwelling Management Orders and that the present government may introduce a Compulsory Purchase Orders Act which would include an element of 'fair compensation' rather then the current 'hope value' which was a step in the right direction.
Councillor Sanders considered the strategy would start to work to reduce the number of empty private properties across the city.
Cabinet Member Comments Councillor Sanders commented that the Government approach of cutting rents for residents living in council houses but not for people who rent privately was not productive to the cost of living between 2016 and 2021. This approach had also removed several million pounds from the HRA which was less money to spend on making homes safe and making home improvements. He was, however, pleased with the certainty that had been provided for the next 10 years.
Cabinet Member Comments Councillor Sanders was pleased with the work done with temporary accommodation and the proactive approach. DECISION The Cabinet Member:
Cabinet Member's Comments Councillor Sanders noted that a policy around tenant access had been approved at the previous decision meeting as it was important to be able to make sure that properties were safe. He recommended that the Water Hygiene Policy could be enforced as part of those tenancy update visits.
Proposed by Councillor Darren Sanders and Seconded by Councillor Jason Fazackarley, it was RESOLVED that Council :
Councillor Sanders advised that Mary was no longer a representative of the Resident Consortium and noted his thanks to her for her participation and contributions at previous meetings.
Councillor Sanders agreed to consider agenda item 9 - 'Amendment to Portsmouth City Council's Allocations Policy' second but for ease of reference the minutes will remain in the original order as per the published agenda.
Councillor Sanders stated he understood this may be an infringement on people's freedoms but, to be able to demonstrate full compliance with the new standards and to ensure people's homes were safe, it was a necessary and responsible thing to implement.
Councillor Sanders noted three things coming together all at the same time.
Members' Questions and Comments There were none Councillor Sanders noted that in 2018 it took about 10 - 11 weeks to turn a void around. It was now 5 weeks, on average. He observed that many of the housing blocks were built at a time when environmental issues and the link between a greener home and cheaper bills were not considered.
Councillor Sanders stated he was delighted the government had changed the decent home standard so that it was now based around how good an appliance was as opposed to how long it had been in the home.
Councillor Sanders advised that the next five reports should be read together as they collectively addressed the delivery of housing standards. He noted the Council's tenant satisfaction measures were consistently 10 to 20 points higher than the national average which was positive. However, he recognised there was always room for improvement.
Councillor Sanders noted that one of the issues was that residents want the council to do something about the serious issue of anti-social behaviour but very often it was not within their power to solve the problem, and it was important to manage expectations. He was pleased that there was now a Portsmouth Homes anti-social behaviour policy. He noted the issue of hate crime which was a serious issue and was pleased that a separate report would be coming to a Portfolio meeting decision meeting soon.
Councillor Sanders noted that opposition spokespersons were briefed, by him, on the report on 17 September, prior to the pre-election period which commenced on 18 September. The report had been intended to be taken to a Housing Cabinet decision meeting on 30 September which could not go ahead as planned due to the pre-election period. The decision was time critical so the Cabinet Member noted at the briefing that the decision would be taken via executive powers as per Standing Order 58.
Resident Consortium There were no questions Members' Questions and Comments There were none Councillor Sanders noted that some of the priorities in the policy reflect the administration priorities to give veterans and people in the armed forces a good home, along with survivors of domestic abuse and care leavers. He noted that the changes in the Allocations Policy had seen more moves happening and requested a more detailed report be brought to a future meeting.
Councillor Barrett was attending as a Standing Deputy for Councillor Mason and Councillor Sanders was attending as a Standing Deputy for Councillor Kadir.
This nomination was seconded by Councillor Darren Sanders.
Liberal Democrat Cllr Darren Sanders 4.
Cllr Sanders noted that the idea around education versus enforcement was a hard judgement call but it was positive there would now be set of principles to work to. He welcomed the strategy and noted this was a significant improvement on the previous strategy.
Cllr Sanders stated he would want the issue of social rents to be relayed to Homes England and to continue to be looked at to provide those social rents for residents.
Council voted on the recommendations contained in the Governance & Audit & Standards Committee minute 7, as proposed by Councillor Steve Pitt and second by Councillor Darren Sanders.
Cabinet Member Comments Councillor Sanders noted this was the biggest single investment in homelessness the city had ever seen. The key was to make sure that the savings were delivered and he stressed that 200 purchases was the minimum number of properties - the aim was that there would be more. He welcomed the Governments investment in temporary accommodation but noted it wouldn’t touch the sides of the problem.
Cabinet Member Comments Councillor Sanders noted the following:
Councillor Hunt noted that this report has been agreed by Councillor Sanders, Cabinet Member for Housing and Tackling Homelessness and is here for noting today.
Councillor Darren Sanders declared that he lived in private rented accommodation and a House in Multiple Occupancy but was not affected by any of the issues being decided on.
Cabinet Member Comments Councillor Sanders outlined three principles behind his decision:
Cllr Darren Sanders 134 Personal.
Cllr Sanders knew [name removed] and [name removed] in his capacity as Cabinet Member for Housing & Tackling Homelessness.
(iii) Insert new final paragraph: 'Council also asks the administration to investigate how affected customers will be supported should these branches close, including helping shop owners in both locations research what having a Post Office counter may entail and how they would go about it.' Following debate, the proposer of the original motion, Councillor Lee Hunt agreed to subsume the amendment put by Councillor Darren Sanders into the motion.
Following a vote, the motion in including the subsumed amendment in the name of Councillor Darren Sanders was declared CARRIED.
Members' comments Councillor Sanders welcomed the reduction in sickness absence overall. As Cabinet Member for Housing and Tackling Homelessness, he noted that housing officers recorded high levels of absence for psychological reasons and asked for a more detailed briefing from officers. This was agreed.
Councillor Sanders proposed amendments to recommendations a) and c) replacing the word 'note' with 'welcome' in each case. Following discussion, it was agreed to make this amendment to recommendation c) only.
Following debate, the proposer of the original motion, Councillor Darren Sanders did not agree to subsume the amendment in the name of Councillor Charlotte Gerada into the motion.
Bob Hughes, HNB Business Team Manager, presented the information only report, which had been requested by Councillor Darren Sanders. The purpose of the report was to outline the approach taken by Business Support Services in the renewal of the Tenants Home Contents Insurance which came into effect on 30 th June 2024. The report also outlined the benefits of the Tenants Home Contents Insurance scheme to promote the take up of the scheme with local authority tenants.
Councillor Sanders echoed these comments, noting that the positive working relationship with the unions had developed since the pandemic and that the council recognised the benefits of having a strong local TU team. He suggested that following the recent King's Speech, a future report on emerging legislation would be useful.
This was seconded by Councillor Darren Sanders.
Councillor Darren Sanders nominated Councillor Jason Fazackarley for election to the office of Lord Mayor for the ensuing municipal year.
Liberal Democrat Cllr Darren Sanders 4. Independent Member Vice-Chair Cal Corkery 5.
Labour Cllr Asghar Shah Liberal Democrat Standing Deputy Mark Jeffrey Liberal Democrat Standing Deputy Richard Adair Labour Standing Deputy Cllr Yinka Adeniran Labour Standing Deputy Cllr George Fielding PIP Standing Deputy Cllr George Madgwick Appointments and Other Appointments Hampshire Fire & Rescue Authority Appointment Cllr George Madgwick Police and Crime Panel Appointment Cllr Richard Adair (Deputy: Cllr Ian Holder) Local Government Association General Assembly Appointments Cllr Tom Coles Cllr Suzy Horton Cllr George Madgwick Cllr Steve Pitt Cllr Darren Sanders (reserve member) Langstone Harbour Board Group Appointments 1.
Liberal Democrat Cllr Darren Sanders 4.
For Portsmouth, the Band D average increased by 108.4% under the Labour Government from 1997 to 2010 and by 50.7% under the Coalition and Conservative Governments from 2010 to 2024." Following debate, the proposer of the original motion, Councillor Graham Heaney agreed to subsume the amendment in the name of Councillor Darren Sanders into the motion, but not the amendments in the name of Councillor Matthew Atkins or Councillor Simon Bosher.
Upon being put to a vote, the substantive notice of motion incorporating the amendment in the name of Councillor Darren Sanders was declared CARRIED .
Councillor Sanders proposed a change Recommendation 1 s that rather than reading "Note the change in absence levels across the organisation", it would now read " Welcome the reduction in overall absence levels across the organisation". This was agreed by the Committee.
Members' comments Councillor Sanders commented that the gender pay gap (both mean and median) have reduced over the past two years and this was pleasing and showed the organisation was travelling in the right direction. He expressed support for the council's recently published Equalities, Diversity and Inclusion strategy.
Members' comments Councillor Sanders noted that pay which is unrelated to market pay puts the council in a difficult situation and it needs to plan for the future.
Councillor Darren Sanders as a member of the Planning Committee.
Councillor Darren Sanders as Vice-Chair of the Planning Committee .
Members' comments Councillor Darren Sanders noted that as Cabinet Member for Housing and Tackling Homelessness he would be making decisions relating to the Council's Housing Budget 2024/25 on 26 January 2024. He commented that that the HRA had budgeted for NLW and that to move to RLW would add £200,000 cost to the service. It was sad that despite aspirations to pay RLW, it was not possible whilst also maintaining financial sustainability and resilience.
Councillor Sanders, Cabinet Member for Housing and Tackling Homelessness, noted that RWL affected the general fund and housing revenue account, and he would ask for further information about how many housing contactors pay the RLW.
Langstone Harbour Board Councillor Darren Sanders appointed as a PCC representative.
Councillor Darren Sanders had offered his apologies for absence. Apologies had also been received from David Williams, Chief Executive.
Councillor Darren Sanders commented that he was delighted to have additional information set out in the report as it presented a more realistic picture. He added that the work Union colleagues do is essential and helpful, particularly in relation to disciplinary matters. He also added that, in relation to paragraph 5.3 of the report, that he supported the on-going work to provide Unions with a sustainable funding process.
Cllr Darren Sanders made a deputation in favour of this item. Deputations are not minuted but can be viewed here:
Cllr Darren Sanders, Vice-Chair of the Employment Committee;
· Cllr Peter Candlish · Cllr Lewis Gosling · Cllr Graham Heaney · Cllr Abdul Kadir · Cllr Mary Vallely · Cllr Gerald Vernon-Jackson · Cllr Kimberly Barrett (standing deputy) · Cllr Ryan Brent (standing deputy) · Cllr Charlotte Gerada (standing deputy) · Cllr Steve Pitt (standing deputy) · Cllr Darren Sanders (standing deputy) 17.
Councillor Darren Sanders declared for transparency, that he was a private tenant.
In recommendation (vi), replace the first word 'Sign' with 'Consider signing' Following debate, the proposer of the original motion, Councillor Cal Corkery agreed to subsume the amendment put by Councillor Darren Sanders into the motion.
Upon being put to a vote the substantive notice of motion incorporating the amendment in the name of Councillor Darren Sanders was declared CARRIED It was therefore RESOLVED that:
Councillor Sanders explained that the aim was to get new Councillors democratic duties up and running as quickly as possible.
As an amendment it was Proposed by Councillor Darren Sanders Seconded by Councillor Scott Payter-Harris That the recommendations set out in Appendix 4 attached to these minutes (a cross party amendment in the name of Councillor Sanders) be adopted .
Councillor Darren Sanders spoke to the amendment, which was the first cross party budget amendment ever considered by the council and reflected comprises on all sides.
In closing, the Leader of the Council confirmed that he was happy to subsume the cross party amendment standing in the name of Councillor Darren Sanders into the Cabinet recommendations proposed by him and seconded by Councillor Suzy Horton at the beginning of the item.
Council voted on the Conservative Group amendment, the Labour Group amendment and the amendment in the name of Councillor Cal Corkery in turn before voting on the substantive motion incorporating the subsumed cross party amendment in the name of Councillor Darren Sanders.
The following members voted in favour Councillor Yinka Adeniran Councillor Tom Coles Councillor Cal Corkery Councillor George Fielding Councillor Charlotte Gerada Councillor George Madgwick Councillor Asghar Shah Councillor Judith Smyth Councillor Graham Heaney Councillor Kirsty Mellor Councillor Russell Simpson The following members voted against Councillor Dave Ashmore Councillor Chris Attwell Councillor Kimberly Barrett Councillor Simon Bosher Councillor Ryan Brent Councillor Jason Fazackarley Councillor Stuart Brown Councillor Lewis Gosling Councillor Ian Holder Councillor Suzy Horton Councillor Lee Hunt Councillor Mark Jeffery Councillor Abdul Kadir Councillor Leo Madden Councillor Lee Mason Councillor Gemma New Councillor Terry Norton Councillor Scott Payter-Harris Councillor Darren Sanders Councillor John Smith Councillor Benedict Swann Councillor Linda Symes Councillor Gerald Vernon-Jackson Councillor Matthew Winnington The following members abstained from voting Councillor Matthew Atkins Councillor Hugh Mason Councillor Robert New Councillor Daniel Wemyss The amendment in the name of Councillor Cal Corkery was therefore declared LOST Upon the original recommendations in Cabinet minute 7 - PCC Portsmouth City Council Budget & Council Tax 2023/2024 & Medium Term Budget Forecast 2024/25 to 2026/27 with the subsumed amendment in the name of Councillor Darren Sanders being put to the vote.
The following members voted in favour Councillor Yinka Adeniran Councillor Matthew Atkins Councillor Dave Ashmore Councillor Chris Attwell Councillor Kimberly Barrett Councillor Ryan Brent Councillor Simon Bosher Councillor Tom Coles Councillor Stuart Brown Councillor Jason Fazackarley Councillor Cal Corkery Councillor Charlotte Gerada Councillor George Fielding Councillor Graham Heaney Councillor Lewis Gosling Councillor Suzy Horton Councillor Ian Holder Councillor Mark Jeffery Councillor Lee Hunt Councillor Leo Madden Councillor Abdul Kadir Councillor Hugh Mason Councillor George Madgwick Councillor Lee Mason Councillor Gemma New Councillor Terry Norton Councillor Darren Sanders Councillor Russell Simpson Councillor Judith Smyth Councillor Linda Symes Councillor Daniel Wemyss Councillor Kirsty Mellor Councillor Robert New Councillor Scott Payter-Harris Councillor Asghar Shah Councillor John Smith Councillor Benedict Swann Councillor Gerald Vernon-Jackson Councillor Matthew Winnington No members voted against and no members abstained from voting The Cabinet recommendations in Cabinet minute 7, with the subsumed amendment in the name of Councillor Darren Sanders was therefore APPROVED and declared CARRIED.
Councillor Sanders noted that councillors appointed to the interview panel needed to have experience of interviewing candidates and he enquired about the timing of interviews. Natasha Edmunds informed the Committee that interviews would likely take place after the elections and Annual Council in May.
Councillor Sanders commented this was sensible as the Council currently had three independent members and they should also be represented on the panel. The Vice Chair agreed that "summer 2023" was vague and suggested a deadline of the end of June. Natasha Edmunds advised that the Employment Committee normally met each July.
Councillor Sanders noted that HR capacity would need to be considered, that July should be the latest date and that a special Committee meeting could take place earlier if necessary. It was agreed that the words "in summer 2023" be amended to read, "by no later than June/ July 2023".
Councillor Sanders noted that it would be helpful if the appointment of an interim Director of Regeneration had democratic oversight. David Williams, Chief Executive, confirmed that Group Leaders would be consulted although the decision to appoint would be delegated to him as Chief Executive. It was agreed to amend the recommendation to reflect this.
Councillor Sanders noted that it was not certain that the new Chief Executive would also be appointed as Chief Executive of Gosport. David Williams commented that although there was a section 113 agreement in place, both councils remained sovereign. He added although Portsmouth has an interest in perpetuating the relationship, the candidates may not wish to take on both roles and Gosport may decide to make a separate appointment.
Councillor Sanders updated on the situation with Councillor Cal Corkery who was currently an independent councillor having been expelled from the Labour party and was attending as ward councillor for Charles Dickens ward.
Councillor Sanders took the deputations for agenda item 6, Council Housing Budget 2023/2024 (including rent setting) prior to the other agenda items, but for ease of reference they were minuted under agenda item 6.
The Chair's summing up Councillor Sanders noted the service was trying to mitigate the cost-of-living crisis for everyone and that some of the residents of the Park Homes would be subject to the forthcoming increases in mortgage rates and interest rates. He advised he would have liked to use the lower CPI figure for the increase but noted that legally this could not happen. The only sensible option available was to increase the pitch fees by an average over the year, in order that costs can be covered, and therefore the rate of 6% was approved, with the proviso that should the RPI rate be lower than 6%, officers would consider their discretionary powers to reduce the rate of increase in line.
The Chair's summing up Councillor Sanders thanked officers for the report. He noted the extension of the additional licensing scheme since the current Cabinet had been in post.
Councillor Sanders noted his acceptance of the two recommendations.
· In relation to the cost, Meredydd and Councillor Sanders had fed back to City Fibre on the key issue of making sure there is no digital exclusion for residents in local authority accommodation. The service are working closely with City Fibre and their partners regarding social tariffs or internet lite packages that could be offered to increase affordability for all.
Cllr Darren Sanders, Cabinet Member for Housing and Preventing Homelessness, thanked the panel for its diligence in respect of the review and provided updates against the seven recommendations approved by Cabinet. The panel discussed the importance of supplying tenants' with instructions on how appliances worked and in particular new technologies such as those found in homes with a Passive House design. In respect of Passive House design principles, the panel was aware that other house designs met high environmental standards and encouraged that they also be explored.
Cllr Sanders explained that he was keen for the councils housing stock to be as environmentally sound as possible with rents kept as low as possible. Passive House design was being explored on a small scale to begin with and he confirmed that those moving into these homes would receive information on how to make best use of the technology.
In response to questions from Councillor Sanders about integrating Safe at Home into packages of care, officers have had initial discussions with Adult Social Care and have agreed to come up with more detail and give them a presentation, hopefully in January. There would be a clearer picture by the end of February or early March. With regard to promoting the service, especially with the voluntary and community sector, officers had met last week to re-group the marketing strategy, which would include demonstrating equipment at voluntary organisations and others such as churches.
Councillor Sanders noted a befriending service had just been lost in the Baffins area so encouraging people to feel less vulnerable was good, especially in the winter.
Councillor Sanders said that in January he and Councillor Stagg had talked to Penny Mordaunt MP about establishing a food pantry in Baffins. He understood that Penny Mordaunt MP had found about £5,000 for food pantries in some wards where local community groups would run them, bearing in mind the rules about where they can be situated. For example, one operates from St Cuthbert's Church.
Councillor Sanders said giving spare food from empty properties to food banks added social value and he would like all housing associations and social housing providers to do so; he would like private landlords to do likewise but does not have control over them. He asked Meredydd Hughes, Assistant Director, Buildings, to write to social housing providers to consider adopting the same policy. James Hill, Director of Housing, Neighbourhood & Building Services, clarified that the report included Portsmouth City Council's housing stock located in Havant Borough Council (HBC) and officers would continue to include in the list food larders, pantries etc located in the HBC area.
Councillor Sanders said he was incredibly grateful for the initiative and urged officers to continue with it and persuade other providers.
"Can the cabinet member update the council on the current financial position of the Horatia and Leamington House regeneration project?" This and supplementary questions were answered by the Cabinet Member for Housing and Preventing Homelessness, Councillor Darren Sanders.
The fifth question was from Councillor Scott Payter-Harris " Can the cabinet member explain what the current plans are for the Hilsea Lodge site?" This and supplementary questions were answered by the Cabinet Member for Housing and Preventing Homelessness, Councillor Darren Sanders .
Councillor Sanders asked Councillor Madgwick to forward details of instances of tenants feeling forced to move, which Councillor Madgwick agreed to do.
Councillor Sanders thanked [name removed] for the report as matters relating to tenants' safety should be in the public domain.
Councillor Sanders said it would be good to have the figures for private sector housing as a recent survey found 30% houses in multiple occupation (HMO) had category 1 (the most severe) hazards. There are different regulations for different types of housing but there may be more work on this later.
Summing up, Councillor Sanders said Grenfell Tower had been a wake-up call to the obsession with deregulation and it will be interesting to see how much the new government rolls back regulation. Usually governments give financial help for a "new burden" but not in this case. However, everyone has the right to a safe home.
Councillor Darren Sanders proposed an additional recommendation:
Following a vote on the recommendations contained within the report and incorporating the additional recommendation in the name of Councillor Darren Sanders it was RESOLVED that i. The recommendations of the peer review in relation to the three key areas of investigation be NOTED;
Summing up, Councillor Sanders observed how useful it is to highlight the PCC work that happens in another authority. He was impressed that the webpage has already been published as this shows the benefit of meetings being public.
Councillor Sanders understood the confusion concerning the two housing lists and clarified his understanding that one is for Havant tenants and covers the whole of Hampshire, whereas the other list is focused on PCC tenants. It is important that PCC duties ... view the full minutes text for item 18.
This amendment was duly seconded by Cllr Darren Sanders and following a vote was declared CARRIED.
Councillor Gerald Vernon-Jackson proposed an amendment to Recommendation 3, as below: (additional text in italics ) (iii) the Employment Committee reiterates its commitment to the policy of paying PCC employees the , congratulates the administration on making this happen, and resolves to report annually on the impact of this policy This amendment was duly seconded by Cllr Darren Sanders and following a vote was declared carried.
Councillor Darren Sanders proposed an additional recommendation, as below:
Councillor Darren Sanders 4.
Councillor Sanders declared a personal interest as he is private sector tenant and knows people in Ian Gibson Court.
Summing up, Councillor Sanders said he would like the scheme to work but only if evidence shows it is working. Mediation is part of the overall package that makes renting in the private sector easier and safer. Processes have to run in parallel.
Councillor Sanders approved the report as it stands but added a recommendation requesting officers to explore alternative models.
Summing up, Councillor Sanders noted that recruitment issues for carers go deeper than wages. There are capacity issues for the roll-out of the scheme so a pragmatic and incremental approach is needed. However, he is delighted to see plans for progression.
Proposed by the Chairman, Councillor Vernon-Jackson, and seconded by Cllr Darren Sanders it was RESOLVED that the Employment Committee:
Councillor Sanders sent regards to those who were not present.
Councillor Sanders explained the policy of local and non-local rates was introduced in 2014 to incentivise people who lived in or near council properties to have cheaper parking but he realises there are people who commute. Therefore, for the sake of fairness and bearing in mind the cost of living crisis, it is sensible to have reasonable incentives for residents to park locally.
In the interests of transparency Councillor Sanders said that his mother is a PCC tenant.
Councillor Sanders acknowledged the concern and noted that other local authorities do not have the "two-tier" approach. Officers have been examining the approach and the "least worst" approach is a uniform increase with the LHA rate at the top so rents will not be more than housing benefit. The key point is that people can afford to pay their rent.
" Can the cabinet member update the council regarding the usage of temporary accommodation?" This and supplementary questions were answered by the Cabinet Member for Housing & Preventing Homelessness, Councillor Darren Sanders.
Under Standing Order 48b eight members of the Council requested a recorded vote on the substantive motion as proposed by Cllr Gerald Vernon-Jackson and seconded by Cllr Darren Sanders.
There were no declarations of interest although in the interests of transparency Councillor Sanders said that he has sometimes been contacted by residents of Shootpool.
Councillor Sanders agreed timely engagement and communication with the residents is crucial and was keen they should have a permanent home. The decision to acquire the properties will help prevent homelessness and once it has been made, detailed negotiations can take place. Discussions could be held with Vivid and the landlords as to why the repairs noted in the report have not been done.
Upon being put to a vote, the amendment in the name of Councillor Darren Sanders was CARRIED .
Upon being put to a vote the substantive notice of motion incorporating the amendment in the name of Councillor Darren Sanders was CARRIED .
If the Government does not consider there to be justification then the Council demands a significantly lower housing target so that environmentally sensitive areas are not forced into development by the Government " Following debate, the mover of the original motion, Councillor Vernon-Jackson, agreed to subsume the amendment proposed by Councillor Darren Sanders into the substantive motion.
Council voted on the substantive motion which incorporated the amendments proposed by Councillor Judith Smyth, Councillor Matthew Atkins and Councillor Darren Sanders.
Upon being put to a vote, the amendment in the name of Councillor Darren Sanders was declared LOST .
Question 1 was from Councillor Cal Corkery "Will the Cabinet Member for Housing consider the request from residents of The Courts blocks in Landport for the long term empty ESO office on their estate to be converted into a community space?" This question was answered by the Cabinet member for Housing and Preventing Homelessness, Councillor Darren Sanders.
Councillor Sanders noted as Utilita was keen to work on the pilot he proposed deferring the report but it could still be discussed. Comments made could be incorporated into a revised report. Those present agreed with his suggestion.
Councillor Sanders noted the current situation will have a major impact on all local authorities and no-one knows what is happening. Using green energy as far as possible is good but not if it means having people on tariffs they cannot not afford and having to choose between heating and eating.
Summing up, Councillor Sanders noted the council's Energy Services Team had recently won a Green Public Service award from iESE (Innovation and Efficiency South East). Switched On Portsmouth results in residents having cheaper bills and a greener environment.
Councillor Sanders noted the cuts referred to are cuts made by the government not the council.
Summing up, Councillor Sanders said he did not recall a barrier to using any additional funding where it is required though he sympathised with the cuts to the Discretionary Housing Payment as the council needs "all the tools in its armoury." He was disappointed with the Credit Union's decision. A key reason for homelessness is eviction when people are behind with the rent and do not know what to do. The private ... view the full minutes text for item 22.
Councillor Sanders disagreed with some of the comments. He himself had brought in additional licensing for HMOs.
Councillor Sanders noted about one-sixth of landlords are "accidental" landlords and that additional licensing will not necessarily improve property standards or reduce rent arrears. He agreed with "nudge" policies. Mediation has worked reasonably well for the council ... view the full minutes text for item 23.
Summing up, Councillor Sanders agreed with members' comments, noting that the Policy is one of the council's most important documents. It is crucial for parents to know their children are safe and it helps children and young people feel more secure.
Summing up, Councillor Sanders noted the progress made with resolving homelessness over the last few years and emphasised the importance of treating people as individuals when it comes to their housing preferences. He noted that not ... view the full minutes text for item 18.
It was noted that the deputation which Councillor Sanders had given at the start of the previous application also covered this application.
Members' Questions In response to questions from members, Councillor Sanders explained that tailored support is provided to residents and is broken into three categories: one for residents who require the lowest level of support; two for those who need a little more and three for those whose needs are complex.
It was noted that the deputation which Councillor Sanders had given at the start of the other applications also covered this one.
Members' Questions In response to questions from members, Councillor Sanders explained that the support given to residents was tailed to their individual needs and included assistance with job hunting, mental health and increasing self-confidence. He added that funding for mental health support is available from Public Health England.
Councillor Sanders declared a personal and non-prejudicial interest as his mother lives in one of the blocks included in agenda item no.7 HRA Fire Safety Improvement Programme.
Summing up, Councillor Sanders requested that the development should be as green as possible and rents as low as possible though this may entail compromises and uncomfortable decisions. He noted that all costs are ceilings, not floors, as he does not want to request more money. He thanked officers for the report.
Councillor Sanders thanked officers for the report. DECISIONS The Cabinet Member for Housing and Preventing Homelessness 1. Approved Housing Revenue Account (HRA) Capital Expenditure of £18.7m, to deliver 63 new council housing dwellings.
Councillor Sanders requested an in-depth examination of the depreciation charge to try and reduce it. He noted the effect of the government's reduction of rent levels by 1% for three years which has significantly reduced rental income.
Councillor Sanders thanked officers for the report.
Summing up, Councillor Sanders said one of the first priorities for a landlord was to keep residents safe. He thanked officers for their work and members and Maria Cole for their comments and support. He noted how the developments in housing over the last two years had improved residents' lives.
Councillor Sanders declared a personal and non-prejudicial interest as he is a private tenant. The City Solicitor had advised him this does not preclude him from making a decision on agenda item 5 (Private Rental Sector Strategy).
Summing up, Councillor Sanders noted the situation was more complex as Havant Borough Council were involved.
Councillor Sanders noted that all groups see the need for change. There are people on housing waiting lists who would use the private rented sector but are deterred by the lack of security. Selective licensing has been discussed for years but does not seem to achieve what it purports to do.
Councillor Sanders hoped the accommodation would give occupants a life to lead and not just a place to stay. If lessons have been learnt from Covid it is to think ahead, not fall behind, and this proposal will change lives. He thanked Councillors Corkery and Payter-Harris for their support and officers for their report.
Summing up, Councillor Sanders said good internet access was now very important for schooling and it was shocking to have children in poorer homes without it; it was as important as heating.
Councillor Sanders had requested the report to show how upcoming laws on making buildings safe will impact on the council and tenants; as a landlord, tenants' safety is paramount for the council.
Councillor Sanders noted that attendance at the residents' associations in Horatia and Leamington Houses had declined though attendance in blocks in Landport and Buckland was good.
Councillor Sanders acknowledged the concerns over residents' privacy but pointed out some residents of Horatia and Leamington Houses had had gas canisters in their flats, despite being told not to because of the fire risk.
Councillor Sanders noted that some blocks have staff on site and asked what would happen in other blocks as there may be some unnecessary fear amongst residents, involving residents has been long overdue and if Grenfell Tower residents had been listened to the tragedy might not have happened. It is unclear if the proposals in the bills would be extended to low-rise blocks but making plans now is very ... view the full minutes text for item 16.
Councillor Sanders explained the report had been written in response to queries from Councillors Corkery and Payter-Harris and discussions with the City Solicitor. The disposal and replacement of council housing forms part of the powers delegated to the Director of Housing, Neighbourhood & Building Services but there was a balance to be struck between commercial sensitivity and openness.
Councillor Sanders acknowledged Councillor Corkery's views; however, the proceeds from the sold properties will go towards buying replacements, with a net gain of a couple of homes, which is a quicker way of finding new homes than building them. The council is investing £100 million in new homes over the next five years (about 100 homes each year) and this year it is buying 190 new homes, despite Covid-19.
Councillor Darren Sanders gave a deputation in support of the application.
· Councillor Jeanette Smith on behalf of the Chair of Milton Neighbourhood Planning Forum objecting to the application · Councillor Darren Sanders on behalf of a constituent objecting to the application.
Councillor Corkery also commented on the respect held for Pete at the Residents' Consortium and joined Cllr Sanders in expressing condolences to his family.
Councillor Sanders declared that his mother is a council tenant, but that this would not factor in his decision making and was not a pecuniary interest.
Cllr Sanders invited an interested resident to speak as she was attending the meeting for this item; deputations are not minuted in full and can be viewed as part of the webcast recording of the meeting here:
Councillor Sanders reported that "alternative giving" was being considered, such as meal vouchers that the public can contribute to rather than give cash direct if they were concerned how their money would be spent.
Councillor Sanders, as Cabinet Member, was grateful to the work of former councillor Paul Godier for his work and enthusiasm that had been important to the development of these non-statutory services. This had relied on government grants and imaginative ways of working such as doubling warden numbers. The model here was not formally called Housing First but took a similar approach, looking at the needs of the individual.
Councillor Sanders, as Cabinet Member for Housing, commented on the council's responsibility as a major landlord in Havant and felt it was right to learn lessons from other projects such as Doyle Avenue. He wanted as many social housing homes and green homes to be provided as possible, and welcomed the partnership work with Havant to help take people off the housing waiting list.
Councillor Sanders regretted that the central government's policy had meant £12m less to spend on investing in improvements.
Councillor Sanders, as Cabinet Member for Housing, asked about the energy efficiency schemes included in the report; this included installation of solar pv and solar battery storage, combined heating and power, and more energy efficient engines were being installed on the Charles Dickens estate (including Pickwick House). Meredydd Hughes reported that he also worked closely with colleagues in the Green & Clean Team, with landscaped areas being improved.
Councillor Sanders was pleased to approve the report and welcomed the work with the Fire Service on the installation of sprinklers. He commended the report which showed that energy efficiency was a key priority in the council's response to the climate emergency.
There were no declarations of interest at the start of the meeting but during the meeting when reference was made to Ladywood House by another councillor, Councillor Sanders made a non-pecuniary interest in that his mother lives there, but did not have parking (which was referenced).
Councillor Corkery asked about notifications from other local authorities; Councillor Sanders confirmed there had previously been notifications of placements made by other local authorities in Portsmouth and some people would enter into arrangements with private landlords.
Councillor Sanders welcomed the report which sought to address the increasing problem with strained resources since the introduction of the Homelessness Reduction Act, with an increase of a third on numbers requiring temporary accommodation. This was also being tackled by Portsmouth City Council buying back properties and developing suitable accommodation.
Councillor Sanders invited comments and questions from the Residents' Consortium/CLG representatives. Madha Abrams raised the need to provide help in training to get homeless people into employment. Maria Cole asked if there was an impact on the Housing Revenue Account; it was confirmed there is not.
Councillor Sanders drew members' attention to Appendix 2 which assessed the possible risks and compared the options, and those options which were not financially viable were discarded. He was keen to help remove barriers for those on lower incomes, and rent controls were not possible so incentives were being considered, which needed to be sustainable.
Councillor Sanders welcomed the pilot review and stated that it was important not to have people struggling with finances getting into further debt through interest on loans; hence he would pursue the no-interest loan option 4b.
Councillor Sanders asked that this item be considered last as a result.
Councillor Sanders declared that with regard to the item concerning the private sector housing strategy, he rents a shared house privately but this is already a licensed property. He had been advised by the City Solicitor that he could participate and had a dispensation to do so.
Councillor Sanders was interested in all options being examined.
Councillor Sanders was grateful to the input of his spokespersons and was pleased that the strategy had gone out to consultation. He had also raised questions regarding demand and capacity at the Night Shelter to ensure that rough sleepers have this option. He was also keen to tackle the level of reliance on B&B accommodation and commended work with the Police & Crime Commissioner and domestic violence survivors.
Councillor Sanders was pleased to agree this strategy and asked that officers prioritise the 15 proposed actions into short, medium and long term timeframes (pages 21 and 22 of the strategy document), and for this to be published.
Councillor Sanders was pleased that in Portsmouth the links with the armed forces were formally recognised.
Councillor Sanders commented on paragraph 6.2 of the strategy which encourages the charging of social rent by registered providers (RPs), with the council charging affordable rents. He welcomed 5 year tenancies which would give more security and this would also be suggested to the RPs.
Councillor Sanders explained the background to bringing forward this report, with the private rented sector being a key part of the overall housing in the city and a wide approach to look at the options available had been called for. The subject had also been discussed in a Notice of Motion at the full Council meeting the previous week.
Councillor Sanders invited comments from the CLG representatives, who reflected their own views on problems in the private rented sector, with reference to Universal Credit and rent arrears. Paul Fielding, Assistant Director, referred to sign-posting tenants to 'Advice Portsmouth' when they had tenancy issues.
Councillor Sanders had emailed all councillors to ask for their views and to see what issues there are but had not received any replies. He was aware that there are too many people on the Council housing waiting list who chose to remain on there for years rather than consider renting privately, whilst some tenants in the private sector did have a ... view the full minutes text for item 24.
iv) Councillor Darren Sanders commented on this report following on from the cross party TECS Scrutiny panel report and welcomed the public exhibitions and the report was precautionary for where there may be cases of displacement.
Councillor Sanders invited comments from the Residents' Consortium representatives. Mada Abrams was pleased to see these good plans for the community and for the City Council. Adrian Blackwood welcomed disabled homes being provided.
Councillor Corkery asked Councillor Sanders to consider bringing back a decision, rather than delegating power to officers, should the rents need to be reviewed.
Councillor Darren Sanders made a non-pecuniary declaration in that his mother lives in Ladywood House, which was mentioned in the Maintenance of Council Housing item.
Councillor Sanders responded that this had previously been looked at approximately 5 years ago but a lot of options were being investigated and this could be revisited.
Councillor Sanders, as Cabinet Member for Housing, stressed the need for easier access to renting privately so he wished to investigate expanding the rent deposit scheme and looking further at guarantors and the level of demand. This also tied in with the Homelessness Strategy with people coming to the council having lost private rented tenancies and the reasons needed to be known for this.
Councillor Sanders requested that this information be sent to both opposition spokespersons and to him as Cabinet Member for Housing.
Councillor Sanders was keen for empty private properties to be brought back into use and asked if intervening at 6 months rather than the legal guideline of 2 years would be a problem to enforce? Clare Hardwick responded that a proactive approach was being taken, with enforcement action only being one tool to be used when trying to make improvements for local communities.
Councillor Sanders welcomed the report.
Councillor Sanders emphasised the need to have the financial model for the portfolio and there would also be utilisation of existing buildings, all of which would provide assistance to those needing it and he thanked all involved and would wish the accommodation to be of a suitable size.
With regard to the £1m work for sprinklers in Ladywood House and Handsworth House Councillor Sanders made his non-pecuniary declaration of interest, in that his mother lives in Ladywood House, and for transparency he asked that officers explain how these 2 blocks had been chosen for the installation of sprinklers. Steve Groves, Head of Buildings Maintenance, reported that sprinklers will be installed on a priority assessment criteria basis and that these blocks had been chosen as they were the tallest highest blocks with single escape stairways, which also included sheltered accommodation. This criteria had been adhered to in making the selection.
Councillor Sanders asked about the security of cloud storage; Graham Fairbrother reported that this is part of PCC's general IT strategy for Microsoft systems using secure storage in cloud.
Councillor Sanders asked why the major works did not identify improvements needed at Portsea; it was reported that planned works are assessed on a demand and priority assessment of the condition of the assets.
Councillor Sanders, as Cabinet Member for Housing, supported the proposed programme of works and welcomed the safety measures with the start of a rolling programme of sprinkler installation. He closed the meeting by thanking all involved in his decision meetings over the last municipal year.
Councillor Sanders had previously chaired the Housing & Social Care Scrutiny Panel referred to and he thanked his predecessor as Cabinet Member for Housing Councillor Jennie Brent, as well as the Cabinet Member with responsibility for Adult Social Care Councillor Matthew Winnington and his predecessor Councillor Luke Stubbs for their parts in this important investment for the city. He asked that it be a meaningful and inclusive consultation with residents and that they know who to contact during the construction if there were problems as part of the construction management plan.
Councillor Sanders also stressed the importance of involving the 3 ward councillors.
Councillor Sanders wished to make non-pecuniary declarations in that he had grown up near the site of the Southsea Community Centre and also his mother lives in a PCC block affected by the rents and service charges report on the budget.
Councillor Sanders read out the comments submitted by Councillor Stubbs (as Conservative Spokesperson for Housing) which questioned the cost of the scheme, believing the cost per unit to be expensive when compared to properties on the open market, although he supported the principle of the scheme. In response Jo Bennett confirmed that the PCC Quantity Surveyors had checked the values and she would report back to the 3 Housing Members on the outcome of the tender and she would also provide them with a breakdown of the costs.
Councillor Sanders was delighted by these positive proposals for a derelict site , which when built would help to tackle the issue of temporary accommodation.
Councillor Sanders, as Cabinet Member for Housing, explained that whilst individual circumstances could not be looked at here, the wider implications of medical input and "hidden" disabilities, such as mental health, would be kept under review.
Councillor Sanders had read and noted the comments from the Homelessness Working Group, which included reference to pets of rough sleepers which Elaine Bastable explained did not come under the allocations policy but was covered by the landlord rules for properties by both PCC and social landlords.
Councillor Sanders, as Cabinet Member for Housing, responded that the report showed how many people were becoming homeless in circumstances out of their control, such as the end of private rented tenancies, being evicted by family or friends (such as when 'sofa surfing') and those surviving domestic abuse. Maria Cole of the Residents' Consortium was pleased to see empty properties being reviewed and was interested in how ex-offenders were treated.
Councillor Sanders stressed that the strategy allowed for the approach to rehousing to be built around the individual and also welcomed the use of empty properties and voids. The strategy sought to tackle the causes of homelessness and to provide a better service for those experiencing homelessness. The consultation would go on-line the following day.
Councillor Sanders, as Cabinet Member for Housing, explained that he intended to start the meeting with a presentation by James Hill, Director of Housing, Neighbourhood and Building Services on the open part of the report, before questions that needed to be raised in the closed session were taken. He would then make his decision back in open session.
Paulsgrove ward councillors Gemma New and Jo Hooper entered the meeting during the exempt session; Councillor Sanders agreed they could stay on a business confidential basis.
After private discussions in the exempt session, Councillor Sanders asked the officers for further explanation of the £240,000 purchase cost of the family's existing property. Wayne Layton, Finance Manager, reported that the cost was approximately £190,000 for purchase, plus legal fees, stamp duty and refurbishment costs to give the total estimate of £240,000.
Councillor Sanders asked about the timescales involved in this case during the exempt session.
Councillor Sanders accepted that the officers were requesting a substantial financial commitment, but this had been analysed in the exempt session, and the alternative could mean that PCC would need to pay large care costs, so the recommended option was a more cost effective and preferable solution, which he supported.
Councillor Sanders as Cabinet Member for Housing asked that officers ensure that the capital cost as outlined at £670,000 be a maximum figure, and that if there was any variation above this a report would need to come back to the Housing portfolio for decision.
Councillor Darren Sanders, the Cabinet Member for Housing had sought guidance from the City Solicitor on his declarations which were:
In response to questions from Councillor Sanders, Bruce Lomax reported that this legislation only covered HMOs and not private home owners and that Portsmouth City Council (PCC) would give landlords 3 days' notice to remove litter before action was taken against them.
Councillor Sanders was mindful that the number of complaints about waste accumulating in the forecourts of HMOs had been increasing (as set out in the table at 4.5 of the report). He also recognised the request by the landlords in their deputations for there to be clarity on the PCC website about what is expected for waste management at HMOs.
Councillor Sanders further reported that following the wheelie bin trial the capacity allowance had been increased and bin collections would be kept weekly.
Councillor Sanders invited comments from the Residents Consortium and CLG representatives Maria Cole, Richard Blackwood and Mada Abrams who welcomed the steps being taken to address the problem of rubbish accumulating at HMO properties.
Councillor Sanders was in support of the proposals which would help make the city cleaner and agreed with the points made on the need to educate tenants, so there would be close liaison with HMO owners, tenants and the University of ... view the full minutes text for item 13.
James Hill, Director of Housing, Neighbourhood and Building Services had been asked by Councillor Sanders to provide a verbal update on the progress to rehouse households from Leamington House and Horatia House.
Councillor Sanders asked that Councillor Stagg be given the results of the study, and they welcomed the development of the bus lane enforcement.
Councillor Sanders reiterated the gratitude of councillors for Alan's professional advice and wished him well in his future endeavours.
Councillor Sanders would not participate in report item 3 for 27 Fawcett Road, having taken legal advice on the perception of having been spoken to by the applicants but not the objectors.
(Councillor Sanders had made an earlier declaration of interest and withdrew from the room for this item.) The City Development Manager reported that the report (page 13 regarding representations) should be amended to reflect that the three ward councillors had not objected but had asked for this to be determined by the committee.
· He had worked with the officers regarding this application and oversaw all of the applicant's HMO properties which had passed the licensing regime and this application exceeded the required standards · He listed the works taking place to the property to provide communal and sanitation facilities, with replacement plumbing and safety works, opaque windows for privacy · There would be cycle storage provision in the garage · The application was for 7 persons rather than up to 9 which could be accommodated to ensure the tenants' safety and comfort in good sized bedrooms and the layout also meant that the property could be used by a family again in the future (Councillor Sanders had been out of the room during part of the presentation/ deputation and would not therefore participate in this item or vote on it.) Members' Questions Further clarification on the shared facilities was sought, especially regarding the shared kitchen/diner space; it was reported that whilst this space was slightly smaller than desired officers felt this was compensated for by the extra size given to the individual bedrooms.
Councillor Darren Sanders attended the meeting as the Chair of the Housing & Social Care Scrutiny Panel to present some observations, as within their current review of 'Housing Need' the White Paper had been looked at. These points included:
· Concern on the retention of 1% reduction in social rents and the impact on the Housing Revenue Account budget, and wanted clarity on dates to assess the impact · On the Right to Buy pilot for Housing Associations it would be interesting to see what contribution is expected from local authorities · 5-10% selling off of higher value homes caused concern although the panel welcomed Jo Bennett's proposed Arms-Length company to build more council housing · The sections relating to private sector landlords were welcomed · More clarity was needed around the planning numbers for housing · Councillor Sanders hoped that the formal response could be shared and he later commented on the planning application and appeal system, rise of HMOs and the use of viability statements to reduce social housing provision.
iii) Councillor Darren Sanders - he thanked officers for taking down the Neville Road bus shelter. The 19/19A service provided good links across the city and the reasons of cost could also apply to No.16 and No22 services, especially at weekends. Many roads would be losing access to a bus service.
This application was being considered by the Planning Committee at the request of Councillor Sanders.
Deputations were heard from [name removed] (Agent) and Councillor Sanders. [name removed] included the following points in his representation:
Councillor Sanders included the following points in his representation:
Councillor Darren Sanders (who was not a member of the committee taking decisions but would be making deputations) declared that he lived in St.Mary's House which was opposite but some distance from the prison site.
Councillor Darren Sanders made a deputation and also read the comments from Councillor Lynne Stagg regarding the conservation elements of the proposal, and she felt there should be consistency for residents in the facing Victorian building of St. Mary's House (where residents were told to have sash windows in a listed building because they faced the prison) and she felt the new design was of featureless boxes.
Councillor Sanders wanted to ensure that there would be a proper construction management plan put in place to involve ward councillors and local residents to have contact points and information during the 4 year phased construction.
Langstone Harbour Board (6 Members) Applying political proportionality rules would equate to; 2 Liberal Democrat - Councillor Darren Sanders and Matthew Winnington 3 Conservative - Councillors Steve Hastings; Ian Lyon; Lee Mason 1 UKIP - Councillor Alicia Denny Plus 1 standing deputy - Councillor Ben Dowling, Liberal Democrat.
Councillor Darren Sanders then made a deputation stating that to cut congestion people should have the opportunity to use the bus routes and he was concerned that in north Milton there were a lot of elderly and vulnerable who would be affected by the proposed changes to the buses especially with the No 19, 13 and 14 in Baffins ward which was adversely affected.
Councillor Darren Sanders said that he had a personal, non-prejudicial interest in that his mother lives in one of the tower blocks in the zone concerned but said that he was able to be open minded.
It was proposed by Councillor Gerald Vernon-Jackson and seconded by Councillor Darren Sanders that Option 1 set out in the recommendations be adopted. Councillors Vernon-Jackson and Sanders voted for this option. Councillors Jones, Stubbs and Hastings voted against.
Councillor Winnington deputised for Councillor Sanders.
Councillor Darren Sanders declared a personal non-prejudicial interest in notice of motion 17(d) in that one of the deputations was being made by a member of the Red Cross for which he acts as a volunteer.
As an amendment it was Proposed by Councillor Darren Sanders Seconded by Councillor Yahiya Chowdhury That the following words be added after the words "the council" in the final paragraph " opposes the proposal and" Following debate, upon being put to the vote the amendment standing in the name of Councillor Darren Sanders was LOST.
Councillor Gemma New asked if Councillor Sanders had received a response to his email, from Portsmouth College.
Councillor Sanders responded by saying that an email had been received explaining that PUSH was part of the public health team who went into the college last year and carried out tutor group talks highlighting the dangers of drug and alcohol misuse.
Councillor Sanders also reported that the scrutiny management panel had agreed the next review topic of 'Housing need and empty properties in Portsmouth and the impact of Government Policy on those two things'.
Councillor Sanders said that the HSC was completing its existing topic on "Isolation of 16 - 24 year olds" and that he would suggest to the HSC that they would then look at "To look at Housing Need and Empty Properties in Portsmouth and the impact of Government Policy on those two things" HOSP Councillor Hastings said that Councillor John Ferrett was the Chair of the HOSP. The HOSP received reports on many topics during the course of the year but did not usually carry out its own reviews. Current topics coming forward to its meetings included:- Guildhall Walk Health Care Centre Vascular Services The recent CQC inspection of Queen Alexandra Hospital
Councillor Sanders welcomed paragraph 3.5 of the report which explained why this site was not in the Seafront Masterplan . The Chairman requested that this report be made available to all members of the City Council.
Councillor Darren Sanders was invited to speak at this point and he said that the same problem was evident at Milton Green and suggested that this should be considered at the same time as Milton Common and that perhaps members could be involved and perhaps also the Green and Clean team.
· It will oppose any proposal that contains an elected Mayor for the wider Hampshire area · It will seek the consent of the people of Portsmouth before agreeing to any proposal for a combined authority that takes existing powers away from Portsmouth City Council" Following debate, upon being put to the vote the amendment standing in the name of Councillor Darren Sanders was LOST.
Question No 5 was from Councillor Darren Sanders "How much did the Council receive in its bid to the Care & Support Specialised Housing Fund for a new dementia care home in Milton?" This was answered by the Cabinet Member for Health & Social Care, Councillor Luke Stubbs.
Councillor Sanders agreed to email the principal of the College, Steve Frampton to find out more about the work of this group with a view to inviting them along to a future meeting.
Councillor Sanders raised the issue of future review topics and asked members if they had any suggestions. The topic of private student housing was raised. Members were keen to find out how the privately rented student accommodation affects the local community and what impact this has on the city as a whole in terms of housing.
Councillor Darren Sanders made his deputation again in support of the application and said he was pleased about this and that it was supported in the area.
Councillor John Ferrett was in attendance for Councillor Gray and Councillor Darren Sanders was in attendance for Councillor Hugh Mason.
Councillor Darren Sanders declared a personal interest in planning application 1, Roko Health & Fitness Club, as he had previously given money to Portsmouth Football Club.
Councillor Darren Sanders spoke in support of the proposal and asked which neighbouring Local Authorities would be engaged with; in response it was reported that this was still to be decided.
Councillor Sanders then made comment welcoming this ambitious project to address the problems associated with these Somerstown housing blocks and voiced concern on behalf of his group spokesperson, Councillor Fuller, regarding the high cost of these studies. It was reported that these would represent approximately 6-7% of the total project costs.
Councillor Sanders requested information on the spending on Housing IT over the last 5 years, which would be provided to him.
As an amendment it was Proposed by Councillor Darren Sanders Seconded by Councillor Ben Dowling That the recommendations set out in Appendix 5 attached to these minutes (Capital Programme amendment in the name of Councillor Darren Sanders) be adopted.
Upon the amendment to the Capital Programme 2014/15 to 2019/20 standing in the name of Councillor Darren Sanders being put to the vote, the following members voted in favour.
The amendment standing in the name of Councillor Darren Sanders was therefore LOST.
Councillor Sanders spoke as a ward councillor and welcomed the report asking about the timing of the monitoring of Lichfield Road as other roads in the area may also be interested in adopting one way schemes. He also asked where the saving on this scheme would be used.
Councillor Sanders asked when the alternatives would come forward regarding Ferry Road. It was reported that officers were working on this but there were some legal issues that would affect the timeframe.
Councillor Sanders also highlighted the concern regarding protection of the dropped kerb at Whitecliffe Avenue as there may be an extension to the double yellow lines to help indicate where this was.
Councillor Darren Sanders then spoke whose points included park and ride had been brought in by his previous administration. It was important to the regeneration of Tipner and he welcomed keeping the fare at £3. There was a need to extend this to Southsea but no budget had been identified.
Councillor Sanders was present and declared that his mother lives in council accommodation and her block would be affected by the charges, but this was a non-pecuniary interest.
Questions were asked by Councillor Potter and Councillor Sanders regarding the length and method of recovery of cost on drying charges and its relationship to energy prices which may require its review. Nick Haverly confirmed that it was anticipated that cost recovery could be achieved over the next three years.
Following debate, Councillor Darren Sanders (as the original mover of the motion) agreed to accept the amendment standing in the name of Councillor Winnington.
The minutes of the Housing and Social Care Scrutiny Panel meeting held on 22 July 2014 were agreed as a correct record and signed by Councillor Sanders.
Councillor Sanders as chair introduced the report.
Councillor Sanders thanked everyone ... view the full minutes text for item 29.
Councillor Darren Sanders made his deputation which included the following points · He was pleased with the recommendation before the Cabinet Member today · He was delighted that the traffic survey had been carried out by volunteers · He wanted the Cabinet Member to give an assurance he would rule out the land swap proposal re Langstone part of the proposed development Claire Upton-Brown was asked to respond to the issues raised which she did as follows · With regard to the plague pit issue, this was new to them and they would need to look for evidence. If found, this would not prohibit development, but would be another thing to be taken into account.
Councillor Darren Sanders included the following points in his deputation:
Councillor Stephen Hastings as mover of the original motion agreed to incorporate the amendment standing in the name of Councillor Darren Sanders into his notice of motion.
Upon the substantive motion incorporating the amendment standing in the name of Councillor Darren Sanders being put to the vote, this was CARRIED.
Councillor Darren Sanders as mover of the original motion agreed to incorporate the amendment standing in the name of Councillor Julie Swan into his notice of motion.
Question number 1 was from Councillor Darren Sanders asking "Should the fountain at Baffins Pond be switched back on? ".
These had been received from Councillor Gerald Vernon-Jackson (who was represented by Standing Deputy Councillor Darren Sanders), Councillor Lee Mason and Councillor Ken Ellcome.
Councillor Darren Sanders declared that he had spoken to both the developer and opponents of 93 Havant Road (application 4) regarding the previous application, and he had a friend who worked for McCarthy & Stone but he had not discussed this with him and this was not a pecuniary or prejudicial interest.
Councillor Darren Sanders then spoke and agreed that this should go ahead to ensure that this was a safe walking route for the local residents. In response to members' questions it was reported that there was a contingency figure of approximately 10% within the estimated £60,000 for this project.
(iii) Councillor Darren Sanders appeared to support the proposal and also asked that the raised tables were made visible and he was pleased by the Vehicle Activated Signs.
Councillor Sanders queried whether the 'snow dump' area at Milton Common/ Eastern Road opposite the ambulance station could be moved away from the ambulance station area as it could have an impact on the traffic in that area and the ambulances; Jane Tume would look at this.
Councillor Sanders also asked questions regarding the siting and demand for the 80 salt bins. In response it was reported that these were difficult to maintain and were kept topped up by Colas and whilst these are in areas where problems are most likely but there is flexibility in their siting.
These had been received from Councillor Fuller, who had requested that Councillor Sanders attend the meeting to represent his group, and from Councillor Horne.
Questions were then asked, firstly by Councillor Sanders regarding how properties would be allocated after the works had taken place and it was reported that tenants could go back to their previous properties if they wish as it was their residency. [name removed] asked the cost of decanting and it was reported that there was a relocation allowance available to help compensate with the expenses involved with moving out and back where they wished to.
Councillor Sanders commented that the authority had to undertake this line due to the court cases, he was pleased to see that the authority was ahead of schedule and felt that this gave tenants in the private sector more security so was supportive of this.
Councillor Sanders commented that he was delighted with the report and the way forward was felt that it was right to review the effectiveness of the assistance policy which helped those most in need.
Councillor Sanders, made a deputation as ward councillor and included the following points in his representation · He had spoken to local residents and reported that everyone spoken to had agreed that there is an issue with the access to the premises; however nobody wanted to stop the pre-school from being allowed to increase the number of children.
The City Development Manager advised the committee that if members considered that it was necessary to refuse the application unless the suggested conditions put forward by Councillor Sanders were imposed, that the application would need to be deferred to examine whether such a scheme could be agreed, as it is not possible to grant an application subject to these being put in place when they had not been considered fully. Members' Questions Members asked whether the entrance way was wide enough to place bollards to create a separate walkway alongside the road. Officers advised that there would not be sufficient space for bollards as this would restrict access for residents wishing to access ... view the full minutes text for item 99.
· Councillor Sanders proposed that the matter be referred back to the Cabinet Member for decision as he felt the process should be robust. He felt that alternative options were not explored at the decision meeting. He said that there was a need to reconsider the decision.
Upon being put to the vote the proposition put by Councillor Sanders to refer the matter back to the Cabinet Member for review was lost.
Councillor Darren Sanders made a deputation outlining his concerns which were that the council had more options for developing the St James' site other than the proposed housing. He said that the extra houses were not needed in the city at the moment. He reiterated the views expressed by others that the loss of green space would have a significant impact on wildlife.
The lead call-in member, Councillor Darren Sanders introduced the reasons for the call-in which were that the decision not to proceed with the 3GS contract had been based on inadequate information. He queried the dispute over the contract start date. He said that had the contract with 3GS gone ahead, this would not be a replacement service but would work alongside existing enforcement teams.
· Councillor Sanders confirmed that there was no formal consultation by the previous administration although he said it was clear that people wanted a crackdown on dog fouling and litter.
· Councillor Sanders confirmed that in some urban areas for example in Swansea, the council had made a profit after entering into a contract with 3GS.
· Councillor Sanders confirmed that the previous administration had not carried out formal consultation but had doorstep conversations, emails and informal surveys and the level of response was such that the previous administration felt a pilot scheme would be sensible to introduce.
· Councillor Sanders said that the call-in had been based on inadequate financial information being available to Cabinet at the time of its decision.
Councillor Sanders said that the timing of the previous administration's Cabinet decision shortly before the election was because stage 1 of the shared services scheme was due to finish around the same time as the pilot in order to maximise flexibility.
Showing the latest 300 of 326.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Sanders attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 19 May 2026 | Full Council | Vote of Thanks to Retiring Lord Mayor and Lady Mayoresses | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 May 2025 | Full Council | Vote of Thanks to Retiring Lord Mayor and Lady Mayoress | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 May 2024 | Full Council | Vote of Thanks to Retiring Lord Mayor and Lady Mayoress | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Jun 2023 | Full Council | Commencing Salary for the post of Chief Executive Officer (Head of Paid Service) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Jun 2023 | Full Council | To receive and consider the recommendation of the Appointments Sub Committee regarding the appointment of the Chief Executive Officer (incorporating the roles of Returning Officer and Electoral Registration Officer) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Jun 2023 | Full Council | Appointment of New Honorary Recorder | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 May 2023 | Full Council | Vote of Thanks to Retiring Lord Mayor and Lady Mayoress | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 May 2023 | Full Council | To appoint the Deputy Lord Mayor and Deputy Lady Mayoress for the ensuing Municipal Year | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 May 2023 | Full Council | Proportional Representation on Panels and Committees | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 May 2022 | Full Council | Vote of Thanks to Retiring Lord Mayor and Lady Mayoress | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 May 2022 | Full Council | Vote of Thanks to Retiring Deputy Lord Mayor and Deputy Lady Mayoress | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 May 2022 | Full Council | To appoint the Deputy Lord Mayor for the ensuing Municipal Year | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 May 2022 | Full Council | Proportional Representation on Panels and Committees | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Feb 2022 | Full Council | Freedom of the City - Transfer of Honorary Grant To Reflect Subsumed Changes in Royal Naval Structure | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 7 Dec 2021 | Full Council | Granting of the Freedom of the City - Falklands Veterans | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 7 Dec 2021 | Full Council | Granting of the Freedom of the City - Royal Naval Association | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 7 Dec 2021 | Full Council | Granting of the Freedom of the City - Royal Marines Association | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 7 Dec 2021 | Full Council | Granting of the Freedom of the City - The Association of Wrens and Women of the Royal Naval Services | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Nov 2016 | Full Council | Notices of Motion | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 12 Jul 2016 | Full Council | Admission to the Roll of Honorary Aldermen - Dr Eleanor Scott | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 12 Jul 2016 | Full Council | Recommendations from the Governance & Audit and Standards Committee Meeting held on 1 July 2016 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 12 Jul 2016 | Full Council | Notices of Motion | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 12 Jul 2016 | Full Council | Notices of Motion | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 12 Jul 2016 | Full Council | Notices of Motion | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 May 2016 | Full Council | Vote of Thanks to Retiring Lord Mayor and Lady Mayoress | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 May 2016 | Full Council | To elect the Lord Mayor for the Ensuing Municipal Year | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 May 2016 | Full Council | To appoint the Deputy Lord Mayor for the ensuing Municipal Year | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 May 2016 | Full Council | Presentation of the Freedom of the City of Portsmouth | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Mar 2016 | Full Council | Admission to the Roll of Honorary Aldermen - Terry Hall | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Mar 2016 | Full Council | Admission to the Roll of Honorary Aldermen - Alistair Thompson | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 9 Feb 2016 | Full Council | Notices of Motion | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 Dec 2015 | Scrutiny Management Panel | Call-in of decision taken by the Cabinet Member for Traffic and Transportation at his meeting on 26 November 2015 in respect of item 4 of that agenda - specifically in relation to LB zone. | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 Oct 2015 | Full Council | Granting of the Freedom of the City to Honorary Alderman Syd Rapson BEM ISM | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 7 Jul 2015 | Full Council | Cabinet Recommendations from its meetings on 11 June 2015 and 3 July 2015 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 7 Jul 2015 | Full Council | Notices of Motion | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 May 2015 | Full Council | Vote of Thanks to Retiring Lord Mayor and Lady Mayoress | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 May 2015 | Full Council | To elect the Lord Mayor for the ensuing Municipal Year | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 May 2015 | Full Council | To appoint the Deputy Lord Mayor for the ensuing Municipal Year. | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 May 2015 | Full Council | Vote of Thanks to Retiring Deputy Lord Mayor and Deputy Lady Mayoress | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 May 2015 | Full Council | To receive such communications as the Lord Mayor may desire to lay before the Council, including apologies for absence. | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 9 Dec 2014 | Full Council | Notice of Motion - Motor Neurone Disease Charter | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Nov 2014 | Full Council | Notices of Motion | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Oct 2014 | Full Council | Admission to the Roll of Honorary Aldermen - Caroline Scott | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Jul 2014 | Full Council | Admission to the Roll of Honorary Aldermen - Jim Patey | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Jul 2014 | Full Council | Admission to the Roll of Honorary Aldermen - Mike Park | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Jul 2014 | Full Council | Notices of Motion | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Jul 2014 | Full Council | Notices of Motion | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 3 Jun 2014 | Full Council | Vote of Thanks to Retiring Lord Mayor and Lady Mayoress | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 3 Jun 2014 | Full Council | To elect the Lord Mayor for the ensuing Municipal Year. | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Feb 2014 | Full Council | Notices of Motion | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Feb 2014 | Full Council | Notices of Motion | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Feb 2014 | Full Council | Notices of Motion | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Dec 2013 | Full Council | Petition on Designation of the Drayton & Farlington Ward as an Area of Special Residential Character | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Dec 2013 | Full Council | Notices of Motion | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Dec 2013 | Full Council | Start time of the Annual Council Meeting 2014 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Oct 2013 | Full Council | Notices of Motion | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Sanders was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 16 of 24 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Sanders declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 Mar 2026 | Housing and Tackling Homelessness, item 9 | Councillor Sanders declared a non-prejudicial interest in relation to agenda item 3 as he was a resident in a licensed House of Multiple Occupation. | |
| 3 Feb 2026 | Housing and Tackling Homelessness, item 2 | Councillor Sanders declared a personal, non-prejudicial interest in two respects in relation to agenda item four, Private Sector Housing Fees and Charges: | |
| 19 Feb 2025 | Housing and Tackling Homelessness, item 5 | Councillor Darren Sanders declared that he lived in private rented accommodation and a House in Multiple Occupancy but was not affected by any of the issues being decided on. | |
| 23 Mar 2023 | Housing and Preventing Homelessness, item 8 | Councillor Darren Sanders declared for transparency, that he was a private tenant. | |
| 22 Mar 2022 | Housing and Preventing Homelessness, item 9 | Councillor Sanders declared a personal interest as he is private sector tenant and knows people in Ian Gibson Court. | |
| 8 Mar 2021 | Housing and Preventing Homelessness, item 9 | Councillor Sanders declared a personal and non-prejudicial interest as his mother lives in one of the blocks included in agenda item no.7 HRA Fire Safety Improvement Programme. | |
| 25 Jan 2021 | Housing and Preventing Homelessness, item 2 | Councillor Sanders declared a personal and non-prejudicial interest as he is a private tenant. The City Solicitor had advised him this does not preclude him from making a decision on agenda item 5 (Private Rental Sector Strategy). | |
| 9 Mar 2020 | Housing, item 7 | Councillor Sanders declared that his mother is a council tenant, but that this would not factor in his decision making and was not a pecuniary interest. | |
| 21 Oct 2019 | Housing, item 21 | Councillor Sanders declared that with regard to the item concerning the private sector housing strategy, he rents a shared house privately but this is already a licensed property. He had been advised by the City Solicitor that he could participate and had a dispensation to do so. | |
| 13 Oct 2015 | Full Council, item 72 | Councillor Darren Sanders declared a personal non-prejudicial interest in notice of motion 17(d) in that one of the deputations was being made by a member of the Red Cross for which he acts as a volunteer. | |
| 3 Jun 2015 | Planning Committee, item 50 | Councillor Darren Sanders declared a personal interest in planning application 1, Roko Health & Fitness Club, as he had previously given money to Portsmouth Football Club. | |
| 1 Oct 2014 | Planning Committee, item 105 | Councillor Darren Sanders declared that he had spoken to both the developer and opponents of 93 Havant Road (application 4) regarding the previous application, and he had a friend who worked for McCarthy & Stone but he had not discussed this with him and this was not a pecuniary or prejudicial interest. |
Where Councillor Sanders sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full Council | Committee Member | May 2013 | 121 | 8 Dec 2026 |
| Cabinet | Vice-Chair | Oct 2013 | 101 | 24 Nov 2026 |
| Employment Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2014 | 52 | 17 Dec 2026 |
| Housing and Tackling Homelessness | Cabinet Member | Jul 2023 | 25 | 16 Dec 2026 |
| Planning Committee | Vice-Chair | Jun 2014 | 40 | |
| Housing & Social Care Scrutiny Panel | Chair | Jul 2014 | 23 | |
| Scrutiny Management Panel | Public | Jul 2014 | 21 | |
| Housing | Cabinet Member | Jul 2013 | 16 | |
| Housing and Preventing Homelessness | Cabinet Member | Dec 2020 | 16 | |
| Licensing Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Nov 2018 | 7 | |
| Licensing Committee | Standing Deputy | Mar 2019 | 5 | |
| Traffic & Transportation | Committee Member | Dec 2013 | 2 | |
| Traffic, Environment & Community Safety Scrutiny Panel | Standing Deputy | Sep 2016 | 2 | |
| Community Safety | Observer | Feb 2021 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.