Declarations of Members' Interest
Councillor Candlish advised he was featured in one of the objections but that it was not prejudicial to his decision making.
Every time Portsmouth's minutes name Councillor Candlish, as the council published it.
Councillor Candlish advised he was featured in one of the objections but that it was not prejudicial to his decision making.
The second question was from Councillor George Fielding to the Cabinet Member for Transport, Councillor Peter Candlish.
'Could the Cabinet Member for Transport provide Full Council with an update regarding planned traffic schemes and road safety schemes across the City including any backlog issues?' In reply, Councillor Candlish reported that road safety had become a fundamental principle embedded within all transport projects undertaken by the council. While some schemes were specifically designated as road safety projects, road safety considerations formed a key element of every transport-related scheme across the city.
Councillor Candlish confirmed that there were typically around 100 or more active road safety schemes at any given time, demonstrating the council’s ongoing commitment to improving safety on the city’s road network.
In response to supplementary questions, Councillor Candlish advised that the proposed raised zebra crossing on Lawrence Road had received budget allocation and was now at the feasibility stage. Timelines could not be confirmed until this work had been completed, although an update was expected in the summer. He also undertook to confirm whether pedestrian surveys had been carried out and to ensure all relevant ward councillors were involved in consultation.
Regarding the suggestion of a one?way system for Sutherland Road, Londesborough Road and Esslemont Road, Cllr Candlish stated that whilst one?way arrangements could offer benefits, they also brought risks such as increased traffic speeds. Each road had different characteristics, and any proposal would require careful assessment, resident consultation and consideration of wider impacts on surrounding streets.
Councillor Candlish highlighted the high volume of requests for road safety measures and the significant backlog of schemes. He noted that funding was limited, with larger projects often requiring external investment, and that even medium?scale schemes could be costly. Parking implications and local congestion, particularly in central Southsea, were often key factors in feasibility assessments.
In response to wider questions, Councillor Candlish undertook to provide further information on the criteria for 20mph zones, noting that requirements for physical traffic?calming measures could substantially increase costs. A written update would also be provided on the status of proposals for Portsbridge Roundabout, which remained under consideration but no longer formed part of the programme.
Councillor Candlish expressed concern that potential local government reorganisation could negatively affect road standards in Portsmouth if merged with areas that lacked comparable investment or PFI arrangements.
Deputation [name removed] - opposing Cabinet Member Comments Councillor Candlish noted the question regarding the status of the ownership of the land as raised in the deputation and acknowledged this was being investigated but was outside of the scope of the Transport Decision meeting which was purely focused on the application for a disabled parking bay. He noted the concerns regarding the validity of the claim but observed that officers had completed the due diligence and found that the applicants met the criteria for a disabled parking bay and so the application would be approved but the wider issue of parking in the area would be considered separately.
Cabinet Member's Comments Councillor Candlish noted that an RPZ creates boundaries and can lead to issues with displacement parking. The creation of RPZs is centred around parking with environmental issues being a secondary consideration. He noted that the Council exceed the minimum legal thresholds for consultation and make all reasonable efforts to ensure that people are consulted.
The first question was from Councillor Simon Bosher to the Cabinet Member for Transport, Councillor Peter Candlish.
Can the cabinet member provide an update on the scheme and the proposed timeline for implementation?' In reply, the cabinet member, Councillor Peter Candlish, disagreed that there had been little progress and advised that transport schemes were complex. Final designs on the project were however expected shortly and would be shared with ward councillors. A statutory consultation was planned for Spring 2026 and, subject to consultation outcomes and Traffic Regulation Order (TRO) approval, construction was expected to commence later in the year and be completed by the end of 2026.
In reply to a supplementary question in respect of a four month delay from the Transport department to receive an answer to a ward member enquiry about the matter, Councillor Candlish had not been party to the emails, but detailed the pressure that the department was under and that the scheme had been worked on. He believed that ward councillors had been informed in September 2025 about the changes that were required and the associated delay. He regretted the delay, but confirmed that the project was progressing.
In reply, Councillor Candlish explained that the cycle diversion route had been a more recent piece of work and whilst it had contributed to the delay, it had not been the sole cause.
The third question was from Councillor Judith Smyth to the Cabinet Member for Transport, Councillor Peter Candlish.
Please can the cabinet member explain what PCC is doing to improve the situation?' In reply, the cabinet member, Councillor Peter Candlish, felt that the question was very wide ranging and that it would be helpful if it could be narrowed down. He also sought clarity on who the 'we' referred to was, as no complaints about the matter had been received.
In response to a supplementary question, Councillor Candlish explained that dial-a-ride was unlikely to return, although the council was looking at ways to tackle accessibility. An option to fund improvements of the accessibility of taxis for wheelchair users had been explored, but a commercial case could not be found, even if taxis were to be offered to the trade for free. In Paulsgrove the council operated a dynamic demand responsive transport scheme, called Pompey Link.
In response to further supplementary questions, Councillor Candlish confirmed that he would be happy to meet with carers for adults with disabilities and he would find out when the city centre bus stop that had been recently demolished would be replaced.
The fourth question was from Councillor Simon Bosher to the Cabinet Member for Transport, Councillor Peter Candlish.
Can the Cabinet Member for Transport provide an update of the requests for double yellow lines in Watermead Road to enable delivery and refuse collection vehicles unfettered access to the Bird Estate and the proposed timeline?' In reply, the cabinet member, Councillor Peter Candlish, explained that this request was being progressed as part of the next 'Various Roads Traffic Regulation Order'. An indicative timetable would see this being published within MIS in mid-December, with public consultation to commence on 5 January, as it was best practice to avoid consulting over holiday periods.
In reply to a supplementary question around officer response times to member questions, Councillor Candlish could not respond about specific queries, but he was happy to be contacted if a response had not been received. He agreed that members were entitled to receive timely responses from officers and that the appropriate course of action if a response had not been received was to escalate to the relevant director in the first instance, followed by the Chief Executive.
The fifth question was from Councillor Simon Bosher to the Cabinet Member for Transport, Councillor Peter Candlish.
Will the cabinet member bring forward a report on the potential impact of the Chancellor's decision on the Electric Vehicle Infrastructure Strategy?' In reply, the cabinet member, Councillor Peter Candlish, confirmed that the council would continue to monitor the situation closely as national data on the EV market became available. Officers routinely monitored this data to inform delivery of the EVI Strategy and would continue to maintain this approach, bringing forward reports for Councillors as appropriate in what was a rapidly evolving policy environment.
In reply to a supplementary question, Councillor Candlish agreed with the stance taken by Ford and Volkswagen that this was the wrong tax at the wrong time.
Councillor Candlish noted that whilst these were approved, the service was also taking out disabled bays that were no longer needed and in this instance there were fewer going in than coming out.
Councillor Candlish noted this had been a long-standing request and a good thing to do, but noted that displacement was a possibility and the vehicles could not be chased through the city to prevent them parking legally in other places. The council would see what it could do to alleviate any issues for the Softball Team when matches were on but noted there was a limit to what could be done and similarly for all sporting events and activities around the city, DECISION The Cabinet Member for Transport:
The third question was from Councillor Judith Smyth to the Cabinet Member for Transport, Councillor Peter Candlish.
'Why does the number 18 bus still use Kent Rd to get from St Jude Church to the end of Castle Rd when there is a better route via Portland Rd and Osborne Rd?' In reply the Cabinet Member, Councillor Peter Candlish, explained that the extension of the No.18 route to Clarence Pier aligned with the Portsmouth Transport Strategy to improve seafront access and reduce congestion. Kent Road offered the most direct link between St Jude’s Church and the seafront, increasing accessibility and encouraging bus use. Future provision of a stop at Southsea Terrace would enhance connectivity to Castle Road businesses.
The eighth question was from Councillor Judith Smyth to the Cabinet Member for Transport, Councillor Peter Candlish.
(iv) To appoint Councillor Raymond Dent as the Reform UK Group member on the Planning Committee in place of Councillor Peter Candlish who had occupied the seat previously as a Liberal Democrat Group appointment on the committee prior to the revised proportionality of the council being agreed;
(v) To appoint Councillor Peter Candlish as a Liberal Democrat Group Standing Deputy on the Planning Committee;
Cabinet Member's Summary Councillor Candlish noted this was the start of a new era for electric transport and electric vehicles in the city. The process of putting in place infrastructure was being done in a pragmatic way to try and locate the Charge Points as close as possible to known demand but also, expecting that demand will rise, to locate in areas where that demand may exist in the future and whilst the opportunity was available to the Council through Government funding. In relation to the safety of electric vehicles, he noted there are now over a million electric vehicles on the road and there was no compelling evidence to show that they were particularly dangerous and noted there had been Charge Points in the city which had been operating safely for a considerable length of time.
Cabinet Member's Summary Councillor Candlish acknowledged some residents' comments about a later timeframe for the scheme, but considered that, given the proximity of the neighbouring RPZ the proposal for 4 - 6pm would be implemented. However, he did note that there was a need to look at all the time zones across the city to consider whether they still made sense next to each other but acknowledged this was not possible at the moment . He noted that RPZs do not always solve the problems of a heavily trafficked area, but they do improve the situation.
Councillor Candlish noted the particular circumstances around the sport being played and the circumstances of the parking arrangements that made it easier to accommodate this request and noted this would not be a universal precedent for other places. It was a modest amendment to a small scheme and he was therefore happy to approve the recommendation.
Cabinet Member's Summary Councillor Candlish noted that Portsmouth had been recognised for its enhanced bus partnership and suggested that there was potential for even greater collaboration including open-book economics and joint efforts to increase overall bus usage.
Councillor Candlish summarised by discussing the balance between citywide dispersion of EV charging units and the requirements of individual locations. He explained that while objections to specific sites were considered, they did not automatically rule out or approve a site. The decision was based on site specific evaluation of all the factors.
Councillor Candlish also mentioned that the current funding was for on-street residential charge points, but there was a hope for future funding to include alternative ... view the full minutes text for item 29.
The third question was from Councillor Suzy Horton to the Cabinet Member for Transport, Councillor Peter Candlish.
Are Southern Gas always this slow to do works?' In reply, Councillor Candlish explained that SGN had responded to an emergency gas leak in Winter Road on 13 May 2025, south of Oliver Road. This required a road section closure to access and work on the main in the carriageway. Whilst investigating the leak, SGN took the future-proof decision of replacing, via pipe insertion, the full length of the main to Devonshire Avenue.
Councillor Candlish read out a deputation from Marc Reddy, Managing Director, Stagecoach, who was unable to attend the meeting, in favour of the proposal.
Councillor Candlish said that ideally deputations should be in person but he would consider requests for them to be read out on a case-by-case basis. Written comments could usually be submitted in advance as part of the TRO (Traffic Regulation Order) process.
Summing up, Councillor Candlish noted that many comments related to the pressure on parking, which would be particularly acute this summer because of space taken up by work on the sea defences . However, he supported the proposal as it improved access to the bus network, especially for elderly and disabled people. It was a trade-off in an area where parking was a real issue.
In response to concerns that the cost of charging EVs was very expensive at 63p per kilowatt hour (kwh) and could deter people from using them, Councillor Candlish said it was dangerous to give a specific rate as it was subject to market forces. The aim was to be at an appropriate level with similar charging devices; the council was not aiming to be a price leader nor a price cutter. Officers were working with Zest (the chargepoint scheme operator) to have a charge of 49p per kwh.
Cabinet Member's Comments Councillor Candlish noted that he was working within the limitations of ... view the full minutes text for item 18.
Liberal Democrat Cllr Peter Candlish 3.
Councillor Candlish provided an update on the current situation. The decision to disconnect the EV charging points had been based on safety advice received from SSEN in 2023. SSEN had stated they could no longer underwrite the system and consequently all charging points were disconnected.
The second question was from Councillor Gerald Vernon-Jackson CBE to the Cabinet Member for Transport, Cllr Peter Candlish.
What work is being done to introduce "lane rental" on our main roads so there is a real cost to these companies to doing roadworks slowly?' In reply, Cllr Candlish explained that the Council was currently dealing with a significant increased presence of utility works on the city's roads, more often than not, classified as emergencies. These were in addition to scheduled work.
In response to supplementary questions Cllr Candlish confirmed that the aspiration was for lane rental to be up and running during 2025 and that key routes would be focussed on. As the Council was not an early adopter for such a scheme, it was predicted that the roll out would be smoother and quicker than it had been for those who had rolled out the scheme earlier.
Following debate, the proposer of the original motion, Councillor Peter Candlish did not agree to subsume the amendment in the name of Councillor Graham Heaney into the motion.
What more can be done to persuade the energy supplier SSEN to complete the restoration of the whole network after this year of disruption for electric vehicle users?" In reply the Cabinet Member for Transport, Councillor Peter Candlish, explained that ensuring public safety was of the utmost importance and since SSEN had raised safety concerns in November 2023, the council had continued to work with SSEN and charge point operators to re-energise residential 'lamppost' charge points; noting that across the network there had been differing complexities in doing this, with each charge point having to be reviewed individually.
In response to supplementary questions, Councillor Candlish explained that the number of EV charging points working at any given point in time had fluctuated and that delays around their reinstatement had centred around the number of charge point operators that had been involved, SSEN and the associated legal, insurance and safety standard considerations. In particular, clarity around the safety standards required by SSEN remained a little unclear to operators.
Councillor Candlish confirmed that it had come as a surprise to the council that a particular charge point being able to be used when records had shown that it had not been approved for reinstatement. It did however demonstrate the issue faced around a lack of a consistent solution in place for the stable operation of these charging points.
In respect of Zest, the new supplier, Councillor Candlish was confident that there had been a thorough procurement process and did not believe that the council had been at fault when the current contract had been specified. The current solution had operated well for several years prior to safety concerns being raised by SSEN. Technology was moving very quickly, and he believed that there was a need for national standards and protocols around on street electric vehicle charging points to prevent such issues reoccurring.
Cllr Peter Candlish, Cabinet Member for Transport gave his response.
Cllr Candlish explained that he had considered the whole transport mix within the city without favour when making his decision. When making his decision he did so using a frame and considered elements including:
Turning to the reasons given for the call-in request, Cllr Candlish spoke on each in turn. The call-in councillors had titled these as per the paragraph numbers in the 24 October 2024 report, which are also used below.
Cllr Candlish confirmed that a hard evidence base was quite limited. The hard evidence available provided no clear argument either to extend the scheme or not and could be interpreted in different ways. Assertions that PHV drivers might be more inclined to register within the city should the scheme be extended was a view rather than fact, although this was likely to contribute to their decision.
Cllr Candlish believed that all projects with significant expenditure attached to them required compelling and positive evidence in order to commit public funds and he did not believe that the proposal to extend the scheme did.
Cllr Candlish had challenged officers about the proposal and funding had been identified as a key issue. He was not convinced that spending money to extend the PHVs in bus lanes scheme was one of the highest priorities, particularly given the financial stresses on the council.
Cllr Candlish explained that the Department for Transport's own recommendations had been cited within the report. It was very hard to quantify the deterrent to cyclists, however bus lanes did afford a degree of protection to cyclists and in making his decision he had looked at the impact on all transport methods. In respect of the RSA's he explained that there had been no further issues identified and that they were only usually included when they identified a significant impact.
Cllr Candlish believed that this was also very hard to measure, however a lot of money had been spent on signage and communication during the trial for the five existing roads forming the scheme as it had been deemed necessary to do so.
In respect of the additional report flaws alleged, Cllr Candlish explained:
· Cllr Candlish believed the question posed about why enforcement cameras were now needed was a fair challenge, as historically these had not been used and were expensive. He understood why they hadn't been needed previously, however with the increase in the number of vehicles in bus lanes he felt that their implementation would be relevant and had therefore been included within the costs of extending the scheme.
In reply, Cllr Candlish did not believe that there had ever been an explicit policy on the matter. The council had an overarching transport strategy and the trial for PHVs in five bus lanes had been made permanent because the alternative would have been to undo the work and lose the investment made. A benefit of making the trial scheme permanent was that it allows better safety information to be gathered over a longer period of time to inform any future decisions In respect of views previously aired to the PHV trade, he had attended a Licensing meeting earlier in the year and at that point had been optimistic to find evidence to back up a decision to extend the scheme.
In response to further questions from the panel, Cllr Candlish:
Cllr Candlish, the cabinet member, summed up his response to the call-in.
Cllr Candlish advised that RSA's were not always published within reports and sometimes not all information was available. The question was whether he had made a reasonable decision and whether the information he had based his decision upon had been adequate and correct.
"Given the reassurances of the administration that Paulsgrove would have a number of roads resurfaced (first and foremost Chedworth Crescent), or have the top layer removed before the end of 2022 and then once again a renewed assurance by the end of 2023, can we have an update on why it's been delayed and what the plans are to complete the commitments made?" In reply, the Cabinet Member for Transport, Councillor Peter Candlish, confirmed that the funds attributed to the maintenance of Portsmouth highways under the PFI covered the cost of repairing the Tertiary Road Network (TRN) to a safe level. This was focused mainly on the structural security of the roads rather than aesthetics. The investigations and associated bid for funding to address thin surfacing had taken longer than first anticipated, but in 2023 a successful bid for additional capital (£200k) was made.
In reply to a supplementary question, Cllr Candlish confirmed that the roads mentioned did not require repair on functionality or safety grounds, as they remained sound, but a budget existed for addressing lower priority cosmetic repairs. This was however a lower priority than repairs needed on safety grounds.
In reply to further supplementary questions, Cllr Candlish confirmed that he was happy to advise all councillors of the schedule for priority roads for repair and to discuss further information that was, and could potentially be, forwarded to ward councillors by Colas in respect of the condition of roads and their schedules for repair. There was an established way for councillors to submit requests for specific feasibility studies and this was currently being refreshed because he was aware some councillors had not received replies.
" Can the Cabinet Member for Transport provide an update for the £600k funding for the Wheelchair Accessible Taxis Lease Rental Scheme that was agreed in the 2024 council budget?" In reply, the Cabinet Member for Transport, Cllr Peter Candlish, confirmed that officers had been exploring options and solutions following the allocation of the wheelchair accessible vehicle allocation. Initial investigations and industry engagement had found that the prudential borrowing scope of the funding agreed in the 2024 budget, where the funding needed to be paid back in full, was unlikely to be financially viable at rates which were attractive to an external provider. However, officers continued to explore alternative options.
In response to a supplementary question, Cllr Candlish was uncertain whether the scheme or something similar would be implemented during the current financial year. However, officers were looking at alternative options to achieve the same result, but he wasn't yet able to share any details.
Liberal Democrat Cllr Peter Candlish 3.
Councillor Candlish commended the report author for the use of summarising tables which made the report simple to understand and to focus on the key issues.
· Cllr Peter Candlish · Cllr Lewis Gosling · Cllr Graham Heaney · Cllr Abdul Kadir · Cllr Mary Vallely · Cllr Gerald Vernon-Jackson · Cllr Kimberly Barrett (standing deputy) · Cllr Ryan Brent (standing deputy) · Cllr Charlotte Gerada (standing deputy) · Cllr Steve Pitt (standing deputy) · Cllr Darren Sanders (standing deputy) 17.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Candlish attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 19 May 2026 | Full Council | Vote of Thanks to Retiring Lord Mayor and Lady Mayoresses | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 May 2025 | Full Council | Vote of Thanks to Retiring Lord Mayor and Lady Mayoress | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 May 2024 | Full Council | Vote of Thanks to Retiring Lord Mayor and Lady Mayoress | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Jun 2023 | Full Council | Commencing Salary for the post of Chief Executive Officer (Head of Paid Service) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Jun 2023 | Full Council | To receive and consider the recommendation of the Appointments Sub Committee regarding the appointment of the Chief Executive Officer (incorporating the roles of Returning Officer and Electoral Registration Officer) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Jun 2023 | Full Council | Appointment of New Honorary Recorder | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 May 2023 | Full Council | Vote of Thanks to Retiring Lord Mayor and Lady Mayoress | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 May 2023 | Full Council | To appoint the Deputy Lord Mayor and Deputy Lady Mayoress for the ensuing Municipal Year | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 May 2023 | Full Council | Proportional Representation on Panels and Committees | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Candlish was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 22 of 30 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Candlish declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Candlish in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Candlish sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planning Committee | Standing Deputy | May 2023 | 45 | 2 Dec 2026 |
| Full Council | Committee Member | May 2023 | 33 | 8 Dec 2026 |
| Cabinet | Cabinet Member | May 2024 | 23 | 24 Nov 2026 |
| Transport | Cabinet Member | Jul 2024 | 19 | 19 Nov 2026 |
| Solent Transport Joint Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2024 | 6 | |
| Economic Development, Culture and Leisure Scrutiny Panel | Committee Member | Jun 2023 | 7 | |
| Education, Children & Young People Scrutiny Panel | Committee Member | Jul 2023 | 5 | |
| Scrutiny Management Panel | ex-Officio | Jul 2023 | 4 | |
| Employment Committee | Standing Deputy | Jul 2025 | 2 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.