Notice of Motion - Let's have pride in Rotherham
The original Motion was moved by Councillor Adam Carter and seconded by Councillor Tarmey.
Every time Rotherham's minutes name Councillor Carter, as the council published it.
The original Motion was moved by Councillor Adam Carter and seconded by Councillor Tarmey.
Councillor A Carter questioned whether a five-day response target for overflowing bins was sufficiently ambitious and suggested the introduction of QR codes on bins to make reporting easier for residents. Officers reported that the average response time was around three days and the Cabinet Member for Communities welcomed the QR code proposal for further consideration.
Councillor A Carter questioned whether the policy represented a proportionate response to a relatively limited issue and sought information on the likely officer resources required to implement and administer it. The Executive Director of Regeneration explained that the policy was intended primarily to create opportunities for legitimate trading activity and provide a fair regulatory framework rather than address a significant enforcement problem.
Councillor A Carter sought clarification regarding the proposed delegation arrangements and asked how members would be involved in scrutinising emerging site allocation options. Assurance was provided by the Head of Planning and Building Control and the Cabinet Member for Transport, Jobs and the Local Economy that no final policy decisions would be made through the delegated consultation stages and that both Planning Board and the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board would receive updates throughout the plan's preparation.
Councillor A Carter declared a personal interest in Item 17 (Notice of Motion – Protecting Rotherham Residents’ NHS and Council Data – Rejecting Reliance on Palantir) as he was a member of the British Medical Association. He remained in the Chamber and voted on the item.
The original motion was moved by Councillor Adam Carter and seconded by Councillor Tarmey.
Labour Leader – Councillor Read Deputy Leader – Councillor Cusworth (31 Members) Conservative Leader – Councillor Z Collingham Deputy Leader – Councillor Bacon (13 Members) Liberal Democrat Leader – Councillor Adam Carter (3 Members) There were twelve non-aligned members: Councillors Beck, Bennett-Sylvester, Bower, Currie, Elliott, Harrison, Havard, Hussain, Jones, Ryalls, Sheppard and Yasseen.
The original Motion was moved by Councillor A Carter and seconded by Councillor C Carter.
Councillor A Carter raised concerns about the Equality Impact Assessment, noting it stated no impact on protected characteristics. It was suggested that enforcement could disproportionately affect these groups and that the consultation plan lacked measures to engage hard-to-reach groups, such as those with disabilities or limited literacy.
Councillor A Carter did not support recommending the consultation to Cabinet in its current form.
Councillor A Carter confirmed agreement with previously stated reasons for the call-in and requested either a revision of the decision or, at ... view the full minutes text for item 61.
Councillor A Carter stated that the spending had nothing to do with elections but simply that 2024 had been the start of a new cycle and new projects took time to plan.
Councillor A Carter expressed concern about the sustainability of using reserves to cover overspends. He questioned how many more years the Council could continue this practice before ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Councillor A Carter noted the Local Offer for Kinship Carers was being considered by the Improving Lives Select Commission but suggested that OSMB may wish to consider the Ethical Procurement Policy as a topic for pre-decision scrutiny.
Labour Leader – Councillor Read Deputy Leader – Councillor Cusworth (32 Members) Conservative Leader – Councillor Z Collingham Deputy Leader – Councillor Bacon (13 Members) Liberal Democrat Leader – Councillor Adam Carter (3 Members) There were 144 seats available on committees, boards and panels and under the calculations the Labour Group were entitled to 80 seats, the opposition Group (Conservative) 32 seats and the Liberal Democrat Group 7 seats. The seats allocated to the non-aligned councillors was 25 and the Council had previously enabled these Councillors to take seats on the various bodies as permitted by the Legislation.
It was moved by Councillor Adam Carter and seconded by Councillor Charlotte Carter:
At the Chairs invitation Councillor A Carter put forward the reasons for calling in this decision. It was noted that twelve projects were put forward for consideration, five were by the Integrated Care Board (ICB) and seven by the Council. It was felt that the discussion during the Cabinet meeting on 10 February 2025 did not explain the allocation of council resources in deciding which projects the council prioritised in progressing forward through the use of the strategic Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL).
Councillor A Carter raised concern that the recommendations to delegate authority to the Strategic Director, Regeneration and Environment, in consultation with the Cabinet Member for Transport, Jobs and the Local Economy did not lead to enough transparency and democratic oversight of the decision.
Councillor A Carter felt the process how the requests were submitted, how they were assessed ... view the full minutes text for item 97.
In response to the statement, Councillor Z Collingham and Councillor A Carter echoed the Mayor’s words in relation to the passing of Dame Julie Kenny. Both also asked questions in relation to Forge Island relating to keeping the pressure on to fill all of the units and on what lessons could be taken forward from the Forge Island development to the Markets and Library development. The Leader explained that the previous failure to fill some units was with the umbrella company that had wanted to fill them.
Councillor A Carter asked a question in relation to Minute 87 of the Cabinet Minuets from 16 December 2024 – Waste Collections Policy. The item had been Called-In for scrutiny and this had taken place on Tuesday 14 January 2025.
Councillor A Carter questioned the Leader about this Policy and whether the already stretched enforcement team would be able to enact the Policy.
It was moved by Councillor Tarmey and seconded by Councillor A Carter that:
Councillor A Carter noted the number of repairs carried out over the years but queried what key performance indicators (KPI’s) were being met withing the policy. The Assistant Director for Housing indicated the KPI’s could be shared outside of the meeting with members noting that many of them were corporate KPI’s as part of the Council Plan. They were reported on quarterly and could be shared.
The original Motion and amendment were moved by Councillor A Carter and Councillor Tarmey.
Councillor A Carter: Do you think the £65 million black hole in South Yorkshire Police's Budget shows that the previous Police and Crime Commissioner, as well as the South Yorkshire Mayor have failed in their duty to local taxpayers?
Councillor A Carter for the designated spokesperson on South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority: Will SYMCA consider increasing the text size on bus stop timetables so that it can be more easily be read by residents with visual impairments, rather than leaving blank space on the timetable sheets?
Councillor A Carter stated that that was good news. The question had arisen because as the number of bus routes shortened, the timetables shortened and were now mainly blank space. It was a simple solution to increase the size of the information available to fill the blank space.
Councillor A Carter: At the last meeting you told us that the parking scheme outside the shops on Brinsworth Lane was due to be completed in June. This has not happened. Can you please explain why this has been further delayed?
In his supplementary, Councillor A Carter stated that the response sounded very optimistic, and he hoped that the optimism was not misplaced like it was at the last meeting.
Labour Leader – Councillor Read Deputy Leader – Councillor Sheppard (33 Members) Conservative Leader – Councillor Z Collingham Deputy Leader – Councillor Bacon (13 Members) Liberal Democrat Leader – Councillor Adam Carter (3 Members) It was noted that there were 144 seats available on Committees, Boards and Panels, and under the calculations, the following were entitled to:
Name of Group Designated Leader & Deputy Leader (Number of Members) Labour Leader – Councillor Chris Read Deputy Leader – Councillor Sarah Allen (34 Members) Conservative Leader – Councillor Simon Ball Deputy Leader – Councillor Lewis Mills (15 Members) Liberal Democrat Leader – Councillor Adam Carter (4 Members) Independent Conservative Leader – Councillor Emily Barley (2 Members) *Non-Aligned Members: Cllr(s) Bennett-Sylvester, Wilson, Elliott, Jones **maternity leave from 7 August 23 The nominations to Committees, Board and Panels were as follows:
Councillor Adam Carter started by offering his congratulation to Councillor Harper on behalf of the Liberal Democrat group. He also agreed with the Leader that the flooding in Catcliffe and Treeton should not have happened, at least to the extent that it did.
It was moved by Councillor A Carter and seconded by Councillor Miro:
Question 3 – Councillor A Carter:
Councillor A Carter stated that the skips were full by 10am on the Saturday and were not replenished quickly enough. He stated that this should have been foreseen.
Councillor A Carter also confirmed that some residents felt that, in comparison to 2007, staff were not as proactive in trying to help them move destroyed property into skips.
Councillor A Carter indicated that by voting for this report they were passing no comments on the other groups nominations.
Notice of Motion – Adoption of a proportional mechanism for nomination of the Deputy Mayor To be moved by Councillor Drew Tarmey and seconded by Councillor Adam Carter:
Question 3: Councillor A Carter:
Question 4: Councillor A Carter:
Councillor A Carter welcomed the investment zones but highlighted the need to ensure those schemes represented and benefited the whole of the borough.
Councillor A Carter expressed concerns regarding the Constitution overall, in particular the officer delegations regarding the revenue budget as this took responsibility from members. He also sought clarification regarding member questions to this meeting, whereby a member had submitted a question which they were not able to ask. He expressed a need to ensure that officers understood that where the question did not specifically mention an individual and was intended to highlight a wider issue, it should be considered.
Councillor A Carter welcomed the proposals and that they would be back dated and sought clarification that the delegation would only be for a reduction in costs not to raise prices.
In his supplementary Councillor A Carter indicated his understanding of the paper was that it included significant parts of Brinsworth including areas of Phoenix Sports Club. He queried when that location and other locations that affected the Borough announced and when was the Leader planning to discuss that and seek the views of local councillors regarding use of that land moving forward?
Councillor A Carter explained that when the Liberal Democrat Group voted they were voting on the Liberal Democrat appointments to those committees.
Both Cllr A Carter and Cllr C Carter indicated that they were happy to meet further to discuss.
It was moved by Councillor Adam Carter and seconded by Councillor Charlotte Carter that:- This Council notes:- 1) The scrutiny process in Rotherham is currently chaired by Councillors from the MajorityGroup 2) That pre-scrutiny meetings happen where the press and public are unable toattend 3) Written scrutiny reports need to provide councillors, the press, and the public with the details needed to scrutinise decisions and policies of theCouncil 4) Council officers do important work in delivering services on behalf of theCouncil This Council believes:- 1) The scrutiny process works best when it is chaired by OppositionCouncillors 2) Pre-scrutiny meetings are anti-democratic, secretive, and are a means for the Majority Group and Cabinet to avoid properscrutiny 3) Written scrutiny reports lack detail,namely:- a) Specific, outcome-basedobjectives b) Key Performance Indicators (KPIs), metrics and quantitativedata c) Evidence-based assessment of benefitsmade d) Feedback from serviceusers e) Measures to mitigate the impact on those with Protected Characteristics (as defined by the Equality Act2010) f) Measures to tackle the ClimateEmergency g) Benchmarking against comparator localauthorities 4) Council officers work hard to answer questions from Councillors and appreciate the work they do in delivering services on behalf of theCouncil 5) Verbal presentations by officers on agenda items
Cllr A Carter declared a personal interest in respect of item 7, as a close family member was a current service user.
Councillor Carter noted his support for the delivery of new homes ... view the full minutes text for item 434.
Councillor Carter stated that the Council should not be increasing rents at a time when families across the Borough were facing tough financial times due the economic impact of the pandemic and advised that the Council should be freezing, not increasing rents at this difficult time.
(2) Councillor Carter asked had the Council reduced the frequency of litter and dog waste bin collections during the pandemic, and what had the impact of this been?
Councillor Carter was aware isolation was a big factor in the pandemic, but residents had noticed a visible deterioration in the street scene. He asked ... view the full minutes text for item 444.
Councillor Carter, however, expressed his concern about the transfer of Brinsworth Library and was of the view that the use of volunteers was the first step to removing professional operational staff and could lead to a reduction in usage. He provided an example of what had happened in Tinsley over the border in Sheffield. He saw no reason to invest in a new town centre library and believed the Council had failed in its relocation of the library to Riverside House.
Councillor Carter wished to place on record his opposition to these changes. He believed the public were being let down and failed to see how the Council had changed given the further restrictions; with those in charge waiting to return to type with the making of decisions behind closed doors.
Councillor Cusworth pointed out that Councillor Carter merely made assertions and failed to challenge the robustness of such decisions as he failed to attend any meetings.
Invitations had been extended numerous times to Councillor Carter to attend meetings as this would be where he would find the answers to his questions.
Councillor Jepson echoed the comments and in particular the invitations to Councillor Carter and where he could, in fact, have a voice for the constituents he represented.
Councillor Carter did not believe Rotherham demonstrated true scrutiny nor an open democratic process as he believed it should be chaired by an Opposition Councillor.
Councillor Cusworth and Napper disagreed with Councillor Carter.
If he attended Councillor Carter would realise the wealth and breadth of cross-party involvement that scrutiny brought to Rotherham and 2 of the Vice-Chairs were from the Opposition Party.
They urged Councillor Carter to represent the people who elected him and not hide behind a non-democratic process.
Councillor Buckley was saddened by his Ward Colleague’s comments pointing out that Councillor Carter had the opportunity to become involved. It was such a pity for the people he represented that he failed to carry out the job he received an allowance for.
In his right to reply Councillor Steele was keen to be provided with proof by Councillor Carter when the Borough’s scrutiny integrity was brought into question. Even the Commissioners were keen for Rotherham’s scrutiny process to return when it was initially suspended, which was tribute to the dedication and commitment in the process. He had spoken at several conferences and even spoke in Sheffield about how the system worked.
Councillor Carter echoed the sentiments for Terri, but found it astounding that the Borough had gone all summer without a Director of Public Health in the middle of the pandemic. He, therefore, welcomed the appointment of Ben Anderson.
Councillor Carter echoed the remarks about the community and personal sacrifice made by people, but believed the Council should be doing more with the Public Health role. ... view the full minutes text for item 387.
Councillor Carter regarded this typically as overspending on the budget with huge overspends in Children’s Services during 2019/20 before the COVID-19 pandemic. This administration was trying to claim the financial outturn was a success when it was just fudging figures in the budget and in the statement presented. It was clear the Council could not manage a budget, failed to meet its obligations year after year and used precious reserve funds.
(2) Councillor Carter asked the Cabinet Member for Waste Roads and Community Safety given the challenges with Coronavirus continuing during the winter, how had the Council planned for winter pressures on essential Council services, specifically highway maintenance such as road gritting?
As a supplementary question Councillor Carter asked how the potential impact of staff absences over the winter would be mitigated in order to ensure that services continued to be delivered.
Councillor Carter declared a personal interest in Minute No. 367 (Motion in respect of the opening of schools during the Covid-19 pandemic) on the grounds of being a member of the British Medical Council.
(Councillor Carter declared a personal interest on the grounds of being a member of the British Medical Council)
Councillor Carter asked the Cabinet Member for Cleaner, Greener Communities “What impact do you believe the coronavirus outbreak has had on the Council’s plans to become the Children’s Capital of Culture?” In response the Cabinet Member for Cleaner, Greener Communities advised that the Children’s Capital of Culture was planned for 2025, and that by then it would be hoped that the impact of the pandemic would be minimal. The Cabinet Member advised that originally it had been planned that external funding would be sought for outline proposals, and that in the first year of planning these would be focused on early conversations and consultation with target groups with a view to developing a more formal ‘launch’ of the programme early 2021. The Cabinet Member advised that as these programmes needed funding to ensure that they had the resources required to meaningfully engage with children and young people across the Borough, early discussions had taken place with Arts Council England who were supportive of bid for funding.
Councillor Carter sought clarification in respect of council tax arrangements for individuals who had inadvertently become owners of second homes after not being able to sell their existing property during the lockdown in March, April and May, and referred to at least one such case that he was aware of within his ward. In response, the Leader indicated that he would be happy to look into the individual circumstances referred to and he did not wish for individuals to find themselves in difficult circumstances.
Councillor Carter advised of his concerns regarding the proposed Cumulative Impact Zone for Wickersley in light of the severe impact of the Covid-19 pandemic and that zone would create further difficulties for the hospitality industry as the country emerged from the pandemic.
The Mayor advised the meeting that, in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 11(11)(c), the Designated Spokespersons for the South Yorkshire Pensions Authority, South Yorkshire Police and Crime Panel and South Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Authority would respond in writing to Councillor Carter in respect of the following questions, which would be appended to the minutes of the meeting presented for approval on 22 July 2020 :
(3) Councillor Carter asked what had the impact been on the reported instances of fly-tipping since restrictions at the household waste recycling centres have been introduced and could the Cabinet Member please outline the plan and associated timescale for the re-opening of household waste recycling centres back to their normal operation.
Councillor Carter supported the sentiments of the report, but asked how greenfield sites could be protected. He was advised and information shared about the strategic acquisition programme, the use of Section 106 Agreements and the development of housing with significant market discounts in order to deliver high quality homes across the Borough including a large proportion which would be added to the Council’s housing stock.
(2) Councillor Carter asked what was the average waiting time for a 101 telephone call to be answered when the telephone call-back service was not in use and how did that compare to when the service was in use?
Councillor Carter believed the opposition should scrutinise executive functions of this Council and could not support the update due to there being a Labour Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board.
(1) Councillor Carter referred to s ome residents telling him they had to wait for almost two hours before their call to 101 was answered. He asked were there any plans to introduce a call-back function for the 101 service?
In a supplementary question Councillor Carter understood now there was no covert function place at the beginning of August. However, he asked were there plans to introduce the service on a 24/7 whether this would enable any caller wishing to use call-back assist to remain on the ‘log’ and then called back the day after.
In the period where Members could ask questions of the Leader’s statement, Councillor Carter echoed the comments about the Key Stage 4 and 5 results throughout the borough, but referred to the recent convictions arising from Operation Stovewood .
(2) Councillor Carter asked would the ... view the full minutes text for item 249.
(1) Councillor Carter asked did the Cabinet Member agree with him that the restrictions on volume of waste that residents could take to household recycling centres, and their opening times contributed to increasing fly-tipping within the borough?
In a supplementary question Councillor Carter asked given the changes to the brown bin and the payment service that happened in advance of October last year did the Cabinet Member not think this was a double whammy to residents who wanted to get rid of their garden waste in a safe and effective manner.
Councillor Carter was unable to offer his support believing the amendments stifled public debate and found the changes unacceptable.
Councillor Carter described how he and his Ward Councillors had consulted on proposals on which to use their core budget and the many events that had been attended. He was proud of the agreed priorities which residents had identified such as fly tipping hotspots and litter around the villages.
Councillor Carter particularly enjoyed the local Remembrance Day service and as a junior doctor himself he was proud to have been involved with partnership proposals to bring forward the installation of a new defibrillator that was installed in Catcliffe, which may help save someone’s life.
(2) Councillor Carter asked what plans were there currently to resurface roads such as High Hazel Road and Treeton Lane in Treeton?
Councillor Hoddinott confirmed if Councillor Carter had spoken to the Ward Councillor for Treeton he would have found out the Ward Members representing Treeton have already picked up the concerns of local residents, and as a result High Hazel Road, Treeton and Treeton Lane, Treeton have been included on the Highway Repair Programme for 2019/20.
Councillor Carter asked about the bus consultation and the review over the next twelve months and sought the Leader’s stance on having London-style bus contract for South Yorkshire that could lead to an ever more unified and joined up service.
(1) Councillor Carter asked what progress has been made with installing the twenty-one new CCTV cameras agreed for use by South Yorkshire Police?
In a supplementary question Councillor Carter asked how many of the twenty-one have already been installed in their locations.
The full breakdown was:- 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 TOTAL Bulgaria 18 30 39 25 0 112 Czech Republic 31 43 61 27 21 15 198 Eritrea 5 15 16 14 6 56 Italy 12 15 18 24 29 11 109 Lithuania 40 27 38 45 51 30 231 Pakistan 56 26 47 55 39 44 267 Poland 134 106 132 97 62 42 573 Romania 9 131 206 279 190 72 887 Slovakia 131 137 76 55 52 29 480 Spain 9 16 31 30 18 10 114 Others 236 208 238 274 223 204 1.383 TOTAL 663 727 892 941 724 463 4,410 (3) Councillor Carter asked how much more did it cost to have an out of hours burial in Rotherham compared to Sheffield?
(4) Councillor Carter asked what discussions had the Cabinet Member had with the Red Box Project and what were the outcomes regarding introducing free sanitary wear in secondary schools?
Councillor Watson confirmed this was one of the rare occasions where he and Councillor Carter were in agreement on where this should go. He explained the Red Box project was a voluntary charity that provided sanitary protection for girls in school. All schools have a small budget for girls who needed help during the day where they could be given products.
(1) Councillor Carter asked, since the last Council meeting, on how many occasions had the Council Leader met with the City Region Mayor Dan Jarvis both individually and alongside the other three South Yorkshire Local Authority Leaders?
(2) Councillor Carter asked if meetings have taken place, what discussions have taken place about the awaited devolution deal proposed by the Government.
In a supplementary question Councillor Carter explained that the Elected Mayor of South Yorkshire had a casting vote in these discussions and he asked would the Leader be supportive of an approach giving the Mayor a time-limited period to come to an agreement say over the next three to six months and if not would he encourage and support the Mayor into using his casting vote in pushing the devolution deal forward.
(3) Councillor Carter referred to his understanding that Sheffield City Region would automatically have received £150m of funding from Government if it had an agreed devolution deal in place and asked what other funding sources had the region missed out on due to the failure to implement the devolution deal?
Councillor Carter supported the policy and the proposals to regulate the industry, safeguard rights of the workers and ensure rights of all individuals were safeguarded. He supported the consultation with regards to sex establishments in Rotherham.
(1) Councillor Carter asked was he able to know the full final legal bill – including detriment costs – following the outcome of the Judicial Review into the unlawful duty system, Close Proximity Crewing in South Yorkshire?
In a supplementary question Councillor Carter asked would South Yorkshire Fire Authority be increasing the Council Tax precept to the maximum amount to help cover the cost of the detriment payments.
(2) Councillor Carter asked what were SYFR's reserves balance at the time CPC was rolled out?
In a supplementary question Councillor Carter asked would the Fire Authority be dipping into reserves to cover the detriment payments and/or increase the provision of fire cover as determined by this Council in the motion to the Fire Authority earlier this year given there was £25 million in the pot and did he agree there were now funds to enable this to happen.
(3) Councillor Carter asked how many other rape victims who have had children consequently have had their rapists contacted about parental responsibility?
In a supplementary question Councillor Carter asked given that a number had not been provided how many rape victims have been contacted ... view the full minutes text for item 120.
Councillor Carter made reference to the Tram Train, which was a good result for Rotherham and South Yorkshire as a whole, and asked, providing the teething issues got ironed out, would the Council be pushing for further expansion of the Tram Train throughout South Yorkshire.
(2) Councillor Carter would receive an answer to his question in writing.
(4) Councillor Carter asked what action had been taken by RMBC since the Council passed an anti-fracking motion to disassociate RMBC from fracking?
(1) Councillor Carter was unable to attend today’s meeting so his question would be responded to in writing by the Designated Spokesperson for South Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service.
Whilst in support of the model put forward, Councillor Carter was of the view that this was of benefit to allotment holders now more appropriate management arrangements in place.
Councillor Carter was unable to support the recommendation on the grounds that the public would find the salary unacceptable.
Whilst the majority of Members supported the implementation of the final recommendations Councillor Simpson abstained from the decision and Councillor Carter, whilst supporting the general principle and the sentiments and work involved with developing a community council, was unable to vote in favour based on the recharge of the establishment and consultation costs.
(1) Councillor Carter asked what independent legal advice had the Council taken that the service Dignity provided was not discriminatory?
In a supplementary question Councillor Carter believed February, 2018 was before the court case in London and asked if any subsequent legal advice in light of that Coroner’s case had been obtained.
Councillor Carter was also unable to support the recommendation on the grounds that the number of brownfield sites was not known, there was a need to rejuvenate the town centre and this Plan did not go far enough.
(1) Councillor Carter asked how did the spokesperson for the Police and Crime Panel propose to hold the commission to account for the discharge of their statutory functions now that these functions have been restricted to only those on the meeting agenda?
In a supplementary question Councillor Carter asked about representatives on the Panel being able to ask about these issues as and when they arose, when contacted by residents, and asked if the representative agreed.
(3) Councillor Carter asked when would he be able to see the expected improvements to road safety on Bawtry Road?
(4) Councillor Carter asked following earlier commitments, which two new pedestrian crossings did the Authority plan to erect during this financial year?
Councillor Hoddinott thanked Councillor Carter for raising this issue, but pointed out that it was part of the budget proposals to increase the number of pedestrian crossings each year which Councillor Carter had actually voted against.
In a supplementary question Councillor Carter asked given the crossings were based on order of priority where was Bawtry Road on the list.
(2) Councillor Carter asked could the Cabinet Member reassure him that all services tendered by the Council to external organisations paid the Rowntree Living Wage, as directly employed Council workers received?
Councillor Alam explained that as Councillor Carter was aware, the Council could not legally oblige all the providers of commissioned services to pay the Rowntree Living Wage.
In a supplementary question Councillor Carter pointed out the Cabinet Member mentioned the Living Wage in the Charter, but in the budget extra funds was being allocated for changes to the National Living Wage and asked if it was the National Living Wage in the Charter or the Rowntree Living Wage.
(1) Councillor Carter explained Rotherham had got a raw deal from the Fire Authority with the cut to Rotherham’s second overnight pump and asked could the Member guarantee that further cuts to frontline services in Rotherham would not happen under the current IRMP?
In a supplementary question Councillor Carter asked if Councillor Atkin could guarantee under the current IRMP going forward there would be no cuts given the fact that it’s a living document.
(2) Councillor Carter asked wouldCouncillor Atkin accept that the IRMP was a living document and could, therefore, be amended at any point?
In a supplementary question Councillor Carter pointed out that as the IRMP was a living document, in a different financial position from when the IRMP was introduced, and therefore, services had been cut, why could the second overnight pump in Rotherham not be reintroduced.
(3) Councillor Carter referred to Barnsley getting a new fire station, both Doncaster and Sheffield having their second overnight pumps protected and asked why have Rotherham’s representatives allowed Rotherham’s taxpayers to fund the bill for a worse service?
He invited Councillor Carter to join him on a visit.
(4) Councillor Carter asked did the Fire Authority representatives believe that Rotherham’s taxpayers were getting value for money with the fire precept increasing year on year?
In a supplementary question Councillor Carter asked as the Council had done its own analysis with similar authorities in the country showing the figures for burial were higher than average, what actions was the Council taking to try and reduce these fees for residents.
In a supplementary in relation to Question 2 Councillor Carter asked what would be said to residents who were choosing other Local Authority cremation services due to cost.
In a supplementary question in relation to Question 3 Councillor Carter asked as Councillor Hoddinott was part of the administration that signed the Dignity contact, would she agree with him that that the responsibility lay with her due to the ever increasing fees.
(2) Councillor Carter referred to health promotion being the backbone of preventing disease in our communities and asked what plans did the Council have to increase the uptake of exercise and sporting activities among younger children in the Borough?
Councillor Carter proposed and Councillor Jepson seconded the following amendment for the motion to now read:- That this Council notes:- • With concern that the Government has made fracking a central plank of the UK’s energy policy.
(2) Councillor Carter asked why was it that 13 roads in the Leader’s Ward were scheduled to be repaired in the next year, whereas only 4 roads in Brinsworth and Catcliffe ward were scheduled for repair?
Councillor Hoddinott advised the Leader took road repairs very seriously and if Councillor Carter had attended the highways seminar last week he would see £50 million was being invested on roads over 5 years locally. There was only seven road repairs in the Leader’s Ward, 8 in the Sitwell Ward, 19 in Aston and Woodsetts and 14 in Rother Vale. Roads were assessed by officers to a set criteria.
Councillor Carter declared a personal interest in respect of the Minute No. 40 (Notice of Motion – NHS) on the basis of his employment in the NHS.
Councillor Carter asked the Leader of the Council whether it would be possible for Members Questions to be brought forward on the Council Agenda to follow Public Questions to demonstrate democratic accountability.
Councillor Carter proposed and Councillor Jepson seconded the following amendment:- To insert the words:
Councillor Carter referred to there being a few high profile fires in the area recently since the second overnight pump was cut and asked would the Spokesperson push for the second pump to be reinstated to guarantee our area was safe from fires?
In a supplementary question Councillor Carter again referred to the Integrated Risk Management Plan from 2013 and the one currently being considered and asked was the review of this second pump overnight going to be included for reconsideration by the Fire Authority.
(2) Councillor Carter asked what was South Yorkshire Labour’s united policy on devolution to the Sheffield City Region.
In a supplementary question Councillor Carter asked why, when the South Yorkshire Members of Parliament had taken a different stance looking towards a Yorkshire-wide version, could the Leaders not agree this between them.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Carter attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 25 May 2022 | Council Meeting | Outcome of the wickersley neighbourhood development plan referendum | Lost | 455 for, 334 against | |
| 2 Mar 2022 | Council Meeting | Notice of motion - lifesaving equipment | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 May 2018 | Council Meeting | Notice of motion - gender equality | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 8 Mar 2017 | Council Meeting | Notice of motion - save rotherham post office | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Carter was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 17 of 25 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Carter declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 15 Jul 2026 | Council Meeting, item 30 | Councillor A Carter declared a personal interest in Item 17 (Notice of Motion – Protecting Rotherham Residents’ NHS and Council Data – Rejecting Reliance on Palantir) as he was a member of the British Medical Association. He remained in the Chamber and voted on the item. | Stayed and took part |
| 24 Feb 2022 | Health Select Commission, item 63 | Cllr A Carter declared a personal interest in respect of item 7, as a close family member was a current service user. | |
| 22 Jul 2020 | Council Meeting, item 355 | Councillor Carter declared a personal interest in Minute No. 367 (Motion in respect of the opening of schools during the Covid-19 pandemic) on the grounds of being a member of the British Medical Council. | |
| 22 Jul 2020 | Council Meeting, item 367 | (Councillor Carter declared a personal interest on the grounds of being a member of the British Medical Council) | |
| 12 Jul 2017 | Council Meeting, item 29 | Councillor Carter declared a personal interest in respect of the Minute No. 40 (Notice of Motion – NHS) on the basis of his employment in the NHS. |
Where Councillor Carter sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council Meeting | Member | Mar 2017 | 52 | 13 Jan 2027 |
| Overview and Scrutiny Management Board | Member | Jun 2021 | 41 | 9 Dec 2026 |
| Health Select Commission | Member | Jun 2021 | 10 | 19 Nov 2026 |
| Transportation Advisory Group | Member | May 2023 | 2 | |
| Planning Board | Member | Aug 2025 | 2 | 19 Nov 2026 |
| Information | Member | Jul 2017 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.