Cabinet's Response to the Health Select Commission’s Recommendations – Menopause
Councillor Steele praised the positive impact that Scrutiny was having and Councillor Currie voiced his support for the recommendations.
Every time Rotherham's minutes name Councillor Steele, as the council published it.
Councillor Steele praised the positive impact that Scrutiny was having and Councillor Currie voiced his support for the recommendations.
Seconding the report, Councillor Steele emphasised the strong partnership working between Members representing Rawmarsh West and Rawmarsh East. He highlighted a range of community activities supported within the ward, including seasonal events in Rosehill Park, work to establish a Friends group for the park, support for community centres and older residents, community skips and environmental improvement projects. He also praised local volunteers and residents for their contribution to strengthening community life and improving the local environment.
The Chair, Councillor Steele sought assurance that future phases of the replacement programme would be delivered on time. In response, the Executive Director of Regeneration and Environment advised that work was underway to develop a long-term replacement programme and that lessons learned from the recent procurement exercise would help streamline future commissioning and procurement processes.
The Chair, Councillor Steele outlined the next stages of the process, noting that the report would be submitted to Cabinet for consideration, with a formal response to be provided before the recommendations were presented to Full Council for approval. The Board subsequently supported the review and its recommendations.
The Chair, Councillor Steele reported that, since the previous meeting, the Committee had considered concerns regarding anti-social behaviour at the bus station in Barnsley.
In reference to Minute 40 – Notice of Motion – Stop Polluting Our Rivers and Hiking Out Bills – Councillor Steele confirmed that Yorkshire Water and Severn Trent had been invited to a special meeting of scrutiny. To date, Severn Trent had confirmed attendance. Yorkshire Water had not yet responded.
Councillor Steele, Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, thanked all Members and Officers involved in Scrutiny. He noted that, throughout 2025/26, Scrutiny had considered 97 substantive items, completed pre-decision scrutiny on 42 reports, held 12 workshops, completed three reviews and progressed another two, had six site visits and had 15 off-agenda briefings. One decision had also been subject to the call-in procedure.
Councillor Steele, as Chair of the review, introduced the report and thanked Members and officers for their contributions, with particular thanks to Sam Barstow, Service Director, Community Safety and Street Scene for supporting the review and providing the information needed to develop the recommendations.
Councillor Steele thanked Members for their involvement, noting that although there had been differing views and extensive discussion, consensus had ultimately been reached on the recommendations.
Councillor Steele was proposed as Chair of the review group, and all Scrutiny Commission Members would be invited to participate. The proposed scope was agreed.
The amendment was moved by Councillor Read and seconded by Councillor Steele. The substantive motion was:
The Governance Manager confirmed that any suggested items for scrutiny sent by Members to Councillor Steele, would be reviewed and considered by the OSMB Steering Group at a meeting on 29 June 2026.
Following the Council meeting at which the motion on lighting columns was agreed, a joint scrutiny review had been established, chaired by Councillor Steele and involving members from OSMB and the Improving Places Select Commission. An initial scoping meeting had taken place, identifying key lines of enquiry and information requirements from officers. It was noted that a survey of parish councils would be undertaken to gather their views.
Councillor Steele, in moving the report, thanked all Members and Officers involved in Scrutiny. Since the last Council meeting, the following had been undertaken, with further detail set out in the report:
Councillor Steele agreed to look into the matter.
At the Chair’s invitation, Councillor Marshall, Cabinet Member for Street Scene and Green Spaces (Cabinet Member), introduced the item and welcomed Charlotte Evans from the Rotherham Allotment Alliance Ltd (RAA) and Councillor Steele, Chair of the RAA, to the meeting.
Councillor Steele explained the background to the RAA, a co-operative, non-profit organisation . The RAA was established as a limited company in 2020 and took over the management of council-owned allotments on behalf of the council from this date.
Councillor Steele reported that the RAA was still waiting to complete the lease arrangements associated with the transfer of allotment sites into long-term self-management by the RAA. This delay had been due to legal complexities but officers at the RAA and the council had been working with solicitors to try and resolve outstanding issues.
Councillor Steele further explained that the RAA had two different types of allotments – those that were directly managed by the RAA and those which were managed under “Societies”, which managed the allotments on the RAA’s behalf. Each Society had a small committee, a Chair, a Secretary, a Treasurer and two other members and would manage the site and collect rents themselves.
Councillor Steele responded that the allotment holders themselves generally came forward to sit on the Board. There were two spaces on the Board for members with more specialist knowledge, in areas such as Finance and Health & Safety.
This had been requested by Councillor Steele (as overarching Scrutiny lead) and the Monitoring Officer to ensure consistency of practice across the different Scrutiny commissions. These meetings would take place via Teams and were likely to occur around 5pm on the Thursday evening before each Tuesday meeting. Invites would be sent out for these pre-meetings in due course.
The Chair, Councillor Steele, noted that the report had reached this stage as ... view the full minutes text for item 100.
Councillor Steele, in moving the report, highlighted that 40 substantive items had been considered across all Commissions since the last update in July 2025. There had been 16 opportunities for pre-decision scrutiny and 3 workshops. One reviewed had been completed in relation to Access to Contraception.
Two reviews were ongoing, and Councillor Steele was going to look into the By-Laws review as he was unhappy with the length of time it was taking to conclude. One item had been called-in, and 3 site visits were planned for early 2026.
He also thanked Councillor Steele for his leadership.
Councillor Steele asked whether any additional funding could be put into the projects that were not successful in this bidding round and enquired what consultation would be undertaken with ward members regarding Strategic CIL funding?
Councillor Steele confirmed that the recommendation from Improving Places Select Commission (IPSC) for the alternative wording for Priority 4 of the Housing Strategy 2025-2030 had been put to Cabinet at its meeting on 15 th September 2025 but that Cabinet had rejected the proposal and approved the original wording.
· Members’ Suggestions for Work Programme topics Suggestions for work programme topics that had been submitted to Councillor Steele over the summer had been considered and incorporated into the IPSC Work Programme, where suitable. The Governance Advisor confirmed that members had been contacted separately to confirm how their suggestions had been incorporated or where they would be considered via an off-agenda method. Members were asked to contact the Governance Advisor if they had any queries.
Councillor Steele thanked officers for their hard work in supporting scrutiny. He noted that throughout 24/25, Scrutiny had considered 84 substantive items, there had been 29 pre-decision reports scrutinised, two decisions had been called in, seven workshops had been held, one site visit conducted and there had been 26 off-agenda briefings. He also noted that the Improving Lives Select Commission had co-opted three external members.
Councillor Steele thanked Councillor Pitchley, former Chair of Improving Lives and Councillor Knight, former Vice-Chair of Improving Lives, for the work they carried out. He reaffirmed that Scrutiny should be a cross-party matter, and it had to be non-political.
It was moved by Councillor Steele and seconded by Councillor Clarke that:
Councillor Steele, Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, moved the report and placed on record his thanks to the Assistant Chief Executive who had also been the Scrutiny Link Officer for OSMB. He also placed on record his thanks to the former Chair and Vice-Chair of the Improving Lives Select Commission and the former Chair of the Audit Committee.
Councillor Steele provided an update on the informal grass cutting and grounds maintenance review and thanked Councillor Tinsley for his work on water safety.
Councillor Steele agreed to provide a written response.
The Governance Manager introduced the work programme report and highlighted how Councillor Steele, Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, would be emailing out requesting items for future work for incorporation into this year’s work programme.
In moving the report, Councillor Steele highlighted the work that had been done on scrutinising the 2025-26 Budget proposals. There had been two Call-in’s since the last update was presented and a number of reviews had progressed.
Councillor Steele thanked all members and officers involved in scrutiny for their work.
As Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, Councillor Steele thanked Scrutiny Officers for their work in organising the takeover meeting. He also thanked the Youth Cabinet for their hard work during the meeting and in forming the recommendations.
Councillor Steele queried whether the amount allocated through vouchers for children was sufficient, particularly in light of rising inflation and the current value of money.
In relation to Minute Number 95, Councillor Steele declared a Non-pecuniary interest as a member of the Trans-Pennine Trail in relation to Item 6, Transport Capital Programme 2025/2026.
Councillor Steele declared a Non-pecuniary interest as a member of the Trans-Pennine Trail in relation to this item.
In moving the report, Councillor Steele offered his thanks to Caroline Webb for all the support she had given him, and the scrutiny function, over the years.
Councillor Steele confirmed he would raise this with Councillor Sheppard.
Councillor Steele agreed to look into this. There was further debate on the call-in item and whether chairs of scrutiny should come from opposition parties.
The Chair welcomed Councillor Sheppard, Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Social Inclusion and Neighbourhood Working, Councillor Steele, Chairperson, Rotherham Allotment Alliance Ltd, along with the officers in attendance.
Since taking up his role in 2021, he had become part of the Allotment Alliance Board, which was chaired by Councillor Steele. He noted the lease was still awaiting conclusion to handover ultimate control to the alliance. He noted there was high demand for plots at certain sites, but the occupancy rate was in a really good position.
He placed on record his thanks to Councillor Steele and all other members and directors of the board for the work they put in throughout the year. He explained that as part of the terms and conditions there were two seats available on the Allotment Alliance, he fulfilled one of those seats but would welcome another member to come forward.
Councillor Steele as Chairperson of the Rotherham Allotment Alliance explained there were six directors currently, which took on the work of running the allotments along with one support officer, who manged the day to day running of the allotment sites. They had currently let around 98% of sites. The sites they managed were in Wath, Rawmarsh, Kimberworth and the town centre.
Councillor Steele indicated the alliance had some funding to invest and could also apply for grants to assist with this. There were a number of projects that could benefit from any funding provided by the Council following the sale of allotment lands. They also worked with community groups.
Councillor Steele noted that it was very difficult to make some allotment sites totally accessible because of the nature of the sites. Where the alliance had been contacted by people with disabilities they had tried to improve the tracks to the allotments, they had also been more relaxed with the rule around cultivating 85% of the allotment.
Councillor Steele, Chair, welcomed everyone to the special meeting of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board which was once again supporting the Children’s Commissioner’s Takeover Challenge (CCTOC) by working with Rotherham Youth Cabinet (RYC), many of who were present today.
As the new Chair, Councillor Steele, would like to ensure the meeting remained non-political and would listen fairly to the debates and discussions.
Councillor Steele, Chair, was unable to change the political membership arrangements for scrutiny, but he maintained his impartiality and would not take sides. He would continue to adopt frank and open discussions as part of the meetings and would ensure Chairs were equipped to undertake their roles effectively.
Original moved by Councillor Steele and seconded by Councillor Hughes and the amendment was moved by Councillor Tarmey and seconded by Councillor A. Carter.
Councillor Steele confirmed that discussion of the petition was on the published agenda for the OSMB meeting on Wednesday 24 July. The lead petitioner had been notified.
Councillor Steele advised that any questions that members of the public wanted to ask on the petition should be submitted to governance before the meeting.
Councillor Steele explained that if discussions regarding the processes and standing orders were required, that would be for the Leader to act upon as part of a working group. He also explained that the petition had been pulled from the agenda of the last OSMB meeting due to the calling of the General Election and the start for purdah. There was no other reason.
Councillor Steele reassured [name removed] that the petition would be discussed at the meeting on 24 July 2024.
It was moved by Councillor Steele and seconded by Councillor Jackson:
Councillor Steele, who had led the Working Group, thanked all the Members who had taken part in the review for their contribution.
Councillor Steele expressed his surprise at Councillor Carter’s comments given the distinct lack of interest in the scrutiny process where he would have found in-depth knowledge had he attended the many meetings and sub-groups.
Councillor Steele pointed out all these elements had been subject to a full discussion and not all those involved with in agreement. However, he praised the Council how quick it had reacted to the pandemic to get its meetings back up and running, a reflection on how open and transparent it was.
Councillor Steele, Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, introduced a further update for 2020/21 on the latest work carried out by the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board and the Select Commissions - Health, Improving Lives and Improving Places as set out in detail as part of the report.
Councillor Watson was keen to point out that Rotherham’s scrutiny process was held in high regard and described how both he and Councillor Steele had attended an East Midlands meeting to talk about how scrutiny worked in Rotherham.
In his right to reply Councillor Steele was keen to be provided with proof by Councillor Carter when the Borough’s scrutiny integrity was brought into question. Even the Commissioners were keen for Rotherham’s scrutiny process to return when it was initially suspended, which was tribute to the dedication and commitment in the process. He had spoken at several conferences and even spoke in Sheffield about how the system worked.
Councillor Steele, as Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board advised that when the revised statement of Licensing Policy had been considered by Board that they had recommended to Cabinet that the Cumulative Impact Zone for Wickersley be reconsidered and ... view the full minutes text for item 337.
Councillor Steele, as Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board welcomed the report, noting that the Board had endorsed the report and its recommendations at its meeting in March 2020.
Councillor Steele welcomed the tree planting policy and noted that the Covid-19 pandemic ... view the full minutes text for item 338.
Councillor Steele declared a non-pecuniary interest in the urgent item on the Implementation of the South Yorkshire Devolution Deal as he was a member of the Sheffield City Region Combined Authority Overview and Scrutiny Committee.
Councillor Steele welcomed everyone to the special meeting of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board which was once again supporting the Children’s Commissioner’s Takeover Challenge (CCTOC) by working with Rotherham Youth Cabinet (RYC). It was positive to have so many young people there, with many new faces who Members had not worked with before.
Councillor Steele, Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, introduced the latest update of the work carried out by the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board (OSMB) and the Select Commissions - Health (HSC), Improving Lives (ILSC) and Improving Places (IPSC) during the last few months. Although fewer scrutiny meetings took place during the autumn due to the General Election, work continued, but the scrutiny work programme for the rest of 2019-2020 needed to be reviewed to re-prioritise and reschedule items to ensure the focus remained on the key issues.
It was reported that following the resignation of Councillor Steele as the Authority’s representative on the Board of Citizens Advice ... view the full minutes text for item 104.
Councillor Steele, Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, introduced the first update for 2019/20 on the latest work carried out by the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board and the Select Commissions - Health, Improving Lives and Improving Places as set out in detail as part of the report.
The Chair of the Rotherham Allotments Alliance Board, Cllr Brian Steele introduced the briefing paper along with the Cabinet Member for Waste, Roads and Community Safety, Cllr Hoddinott.
Of the Board’s eight members, three were RADAA representatives and two were Borough Councillors: Cllr Steele and Cllr Hoddinott. The requirement for two Councillors (one being the Cabinet Member with responsibility for allotments) was included in the new company’s rules.
Cllr Hoddinott commented on the commitment and expertise of the alliance members in setting up this new entity and recorded her thanks to Cllr Steele for his work as Chair.
The Chair, Councillor Steele, declared a personal interest in agenda item 5 (Request for Review of Response to Petition – Webcasting at Overview and Scrutiny Management Board) on the basis that he had provided a response to the Lead Petitioner which was due to be the subject of the Board’s consideration.
Councillor Steele welcomed everyone to the special meeting of the OSMB which was once again supporting the Children’s Commissioner’s Takeover Challenge ( CCTOC ) by working with Rotherham Youth Cabinet ( RYC ). Several young carers were also present and it was a pleasure to have them there.
Cllr Steele – I have been tasked with looking at the Rothercard scheme and what we could build into that but it comes down to cost and I cannot guarantee anything.
Cllr Steele – Before closing the meeting as Chair of OSMB I can assure you that we will follow up on the report. OSMB is currently carrying out a review of Rothercard and its future remit so I am going to recommend that we co-opt either a young carer or Youth Cabinet member to attend the next meeting of that review. We will schedule the meeting so that they will be able to attend and input your ideas.
Councillor Steele, Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, provided an update on the latest work carried out by the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board and the Select Commissions - Health, Improving Lives and Improving Places over the last few months.
Councillor Steele supported the report and thanked Councillor Hoddinott and the officers for protecting the interests of those who worked in this industry and welcomed the equality impact assessment.
Councillor Steele, Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, provided an update on the latest work carried out by the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board and the Select Commissions - Health, Improving Lives and Improving Places over the last few months.
Proposed by Councillor Steele and seconded by Councillor Lelliott:- This Council supports:- · the work of the Rotherham Youth Cabinet and their Counterparts a cross South Yorkshire in developing the South Yorkshire Transport Charter.
The Chair (Councillor Steele) declared a personal interest in item 6 (Universal Credit Roll Out in Rotherham) on the basis of his role as a trustee of the Citizens Advice Bureau, which was providing support to individuals.
Proposed by Councillor Steele and seconded by Councillor Rose Keenan:- This Council notes that:- • Insecure work includes people working on zero-hours contracts, temporary and agency work, and low-paid self-employment.
Councillor Steele declared he was a former Secretary to an anti-fracking group, but was no longer involved.
Councillor Steele, Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, provided an update on the latest work carried out by the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board and the Select Commissions - Health, Improving Lives and Improving Places over the last few months.
Councillor Steele and Councillor Peter Short - Overview and Scrutiny committee.
Councillor Steele declared a person interest in agenda item 8 (Allotments Self-Management) on the basis that he held an allotment with a parish council within the borough.
Councillor Steele confirmed the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board had taken a key interest in the document as part of the pre-scrutiny process and sought clarification on issues from the Cabinet Member and relevant officers.
Mover :- Councillor Read Seconder:- Councillor Steele
Councillor Steele, on behalf of Scrutiny wished to thank Councillors Evans and Short and the rest of the Members for their work on this review. This highlighted the role of Scrutiny in policy decisions and that the work undertaken the Cabinet Members appreciate this and hoped this could be supported fully.
Councillor Cowles was happy to second and concurred with Councillor Steele. He commended him for the in-depth work that was undertaken and the avenues pursued and challenges being faced.
Councillor Steele welcomed everyone to the special meeting of the OSMB which was once again supporting the Children’s Commissioner’s Takeover Challenge (CCTOC) by working with Rotherham Youth Cabinet (RYC). Brief introductions were made to assist the young people in directing questions to the most appropriate person.
Councillor Steele thanked the partners for their contributions in answering the Youth Cabinet’s questions and thanked the Youth Cabinet for their questions and input and doing an excellent job. Toni Paxford was also commended for doing an excellent job as Chair.
The Chair was pleased to welcome Paul Whitehouse, BBC Local Democracy Reporter, and also Councillor Steele, Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board to the meeting.
Councillor Steele endorsed the Deputy Leader’s comments.
In particular he wanted to thank his Cabinet colleagues, and in particular Councillor Alam, for their selflessness in their approach and Councillor Steele and his Scrutiny colleagues who have been tireless in their efforts to ensure that nothing was missed.
Overview and Scrutiny Management Board Councillor Steele reported that the work was continuing on the review of agency, interim and consultancy staff and meetings had taken place with the Assistant Chief Executive and Head of Human Resources.
Councillor Steele, Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, was pleased to introduce the Overview and Scrutiny Update, which covered the last two months of work.
Councillor Brian Steele, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, provided an overview of the work carried out by the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board and the 3 Select Commissions during the last few months, outlined the pre-scrutiny decision making process and the decisions taken and gave a further update on the work of each of the Commissions in turn.
Councillor Steele declared a personal interest in Minute No. 15 (Advice Services Review) as a member of the Board of the Citizens Advice Bureau.
Councillor Steele remained in the meeting during the discussion of this item.
Councillor Steele also pointed out that the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board had also moved its meeting date to a Wednesday instead of a Friday to maintain a more appropriate pre-scrutiny work flow from Cabinet.
Moved by Councillor Steele and seconded by Councillor Williams Rotherham Council condemns Amber Rudd, Home Secretary’s rejection on 31st October 2016 in Parliament of an Orgreave Inquiry as a grave injustice. We believe the events of 18 th June 1984 here in Rotherham at Orgreave demand there be an inquiry.
Councillor Steele welcomed everyone to the meeting and referred to the background to the Children’s Commissioner Take-Over Challenge.
In closing the meeting, Councillor Steele thanked the Youth Cabinet Members, Elected Members and officers of each organisation for their participation in the meeting and contributions to the debate.
Councillor Steele provided an update on activity for the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board and Select Commissions during the last six months, using a range of different approaches to supplement the standard meetings, which included:- · Task and Finish Groups – current Emergency Planning Group from Improving Places.
(Councillor Steele declared a personal interest in Minute No. 75 (Budget Pressures in relation to Older People’s Services) on the grounds that his mother had Dementia.
Councillor Steele, Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, reported that he attended the Sheffield City Region Scrutiny Committee, which he had been appointed Vice-Chair, where the main item of business was in respect of the consultation on the Metro-Mayor election. consulting on Mayoral elections. He had also met with the Chief Executive to review scrutiny support for Chairs and Vice-Chairs and the support package from the Centre for Public Scrutiny.
Councillor Steele welcomed everyone to the meeting and referred to the background to the Children’s Commissioner Take-Over Day.
In closing the meeting, Councillor Steele thanked the Youth Cabinet members, the Commissioner, Elected Members and officers of each organisation for their participation in this meeting and contributions to the debate.
The Committee was also making progress with its reviews of the Council’s various risk registers Overview and Scrutiny Management Board:- Councillor Steele, Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, reported on recent discussions with the Council’s Chief Executive about the scrutiny work programme for 2016/17.
Councillor Steele welcomed the report and supported the work going forward.
Councillor Steele declared a personal interest in Minute No. 53 (Advice Service Review) on the grounds of being a non-voting member on the Citizens Advice Bureau Board.
Councillor Steele, Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, confirmed this report had been considered as part of the pre-scrutiny process. The recommendations were supported, but it was suggested the term domestic abuse’ be used consistently in relevant Council documentation and that information be provided on baseline indicators for all measures in order to enable a comparison to be made at year end.
Councillor Steele, Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, confirmed this report had been considered as part of the pre-scrutiny process and the recommendations supported.
Resolved :- That the minutes of the Cabinet and Commissioners’ Decision Making Meeting held on 9 th January, 2017, be agreed as a true and correct record of the proceedings, subject to Councillor Steele, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, being included as present.
Councillor Alam confirmed the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board had been heavily involved in the scrutiny of the budget, which was confirmed by Councillor Steele, Chairman. He outlined where concern had been expressed, further information sought and could now confirm the Board’s overall in support.
Councillor Steele confirmed this report had been received by the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board as an urgent item as part of the pre-scrutiny process. In line with Ofcom guidance the Council had consulted on the proposals, but it was not always clear who consultees had been and it was suggested this be improved in the future. No objections were, therefore, raised with the proposals.
Councillor Steele, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, confirmed scrutiny were to focus some attention on agency staff and how spend could be reduced.
Councillor Steele, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, confirmed this report had been presented to Scrutiny and it was suggested that there be careful monitoring of the user position prior to second implementation of charge increases. To this end a further update report should be presented to the Cabinet and Commissioners during July, 2017.
Councillor Steele, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, confirmed this report had been considered as part of the pre-scrutiny process. The investment and spend for Children and Young People’s Services would be closely monitored and evaluated by the Improving Lives Select Commission.
This was welcomed by Councillor Steele, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board.
Councillor Steele, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, requested that a report also be considered by Scrutiny to enable further comments to be invited, which were endorsed.
Councillor Steele, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, endorse the comments and was in full agreement with the revision to paragraph 4.2 in the report. He also asked that the report be submitted to Scrutiny has part of the consultation process.
Resolved :- That the minutes be approved as a correct record, subject to Councillor Steele, Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board being included in the list of apologies.
Councillor Steele, Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, referred to the bi-monthly report monitoring report presented to scrutiny looking specifically at spend in this area.
Councillor Steele declared an interest in Minute No. 76 (Budget 2016/17 to 2017/18 - Consideration of Savings Proposals - RES7H Trade Union Secondment Budget).
Councillor Steele provided an update on activity and how the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board was focusing on the budget setting process for 2016/17 with initial budget savings proposals being referred on for consideration.
Councillor Steele, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, presented the Annual Report for 2014-15 for approval.
A94(17) where the member of the public in question requested the comment made by the Mayor be included prior to the commencement of the answer “The Mayor pointed out that Councillor Steele would be answering this question not Councillor Hussain”.
Councillor Steele referred to a decision that was called in by the Opposition and heard on the 13 th February, 2015.
Councillor Steele provided an update on activity and achievements so far for each of the Select Commissions:- · Overview and Scrutiny Management Board completed an intensive and in-depth scrutiny of plans to tackle Child Sexual Exploitation in Rotherham, over two full days, during December 2014. The Management Board have agreed the final report and it will be fed into the new decision making arrangements for the Council over the coming weeks.
Councillor Steele took on board all the concerns, but pointed out that the Police and Crime Commissioner and District Commander Jason Harwin had been present at the two day Scrutiny meetings to answer questions, but like everyone else in this Chamber wished to see more arrests and children protected.
Councillor Steele:
Councillor Steele thanked Members of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board and other Elected Members represented for their attendance and contributions to the questioning and discussion process.
Councillor Steele provided an update on activity and achievements so far for each of the Select Commissions and how the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board had overseen its own work programme as well as that of the Select Commissions .
Moved by Councillor Steele and seconded by Councillor Watson.
Health Select Commission:- Councillor Steele, Chairman, had nothing further to add for Health.
This meeting was very useful and Councillor Steele gave thanks and appreciation to Chris.
With regard to item 28 below (South Yorkshire Broadband Project), the meeting noted that:- (1) the Vice-Chairman, Councillor Steele, was unable to attend this meeting, because he has a disclosable pecuniary interest in the matter under consideration, as an employee of Barnsley Metropolitan Borough Council, the host organisation of the proposed project management team; and (2) Councillors Hoddinott and Russell declared their personal interests in the matter under consideration, as customers of British Telecom; having taken advice from the Council’s Monitoring Officer, both Members remained in the meeting to speak and vote on the matter.
(The Vice-Chair, Councillor Steele, assumed the Chair during consideration of items 14 and 16 below, in the absence of the Chair)
Audit Committee:- Councillor Cowles Councillor Kaye (Vice-Chairman) Councillor Sangster (Chairman) Councillor Sharman Councillor Sims (5) SELECT COMMISSIONS Overview and Scrutiny Management Board:- Councillor Ahmed Councillor Currie Councillor Hoddinott Councillor Middleton Councillor Parker Councillor Read Councillor Russell Councillor Sims Councillor Steele (Vice-Chairman) Councillor C.
Vines Councillor Watson Councillor Whelbourn (Chairman) (12) Health:- Councillor Dalton Councillor Havenhand Councillor Hoddinott (Vice-Chairman) Councillor Hunter Councillor Jepson Councillor Kaye Councillor Pitchley Councillor Steele (Chairman) ... view the full minutes text for item 13.
Moved by Councillor Steele and seconded by Councillor Kaye:- “ The Council notes with deep regret that the English Defence League ( EDL ) intends to hold a national demonstration in our town on 10th May. The EDL is perceived by many to be a racist organisation that seeks to promote division and disharmony in our communities via street demonstrations that typically attract people who are determined to cause fear through the use of intimidation and violence.
(2) That Councillor Steele, Chairman of the Health Select Commission, be confirmed as its nominee to sit on the Joint Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee (Yorkshire and the Humber) in relation to the new review of Congenital Heart Disease Services, in line with the terms of reference submitted.
Councillor Steele welcomed everyone to the meeting and referred to the background to the Children’s Commissioner Take-Over Day.
Further to Minute No. 64 of the meeting of the Health Select Commission held on 23 rd January, 2014 consideration was given to a report, presented by Councillor Brian Steele, Chair of the Review Group, which set out the main findings and recommendations of the scrutiny review of support for carers in Rotherham. The full text of the draft review report was also submitted for consideration by Members.
Councillor Whelbourn, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, welcomed the opportunity to give an update on activity and introduced Councillor Steele, Chairman of the Health Select Commission, to give a short overview of the work programme progress the Select Commission had carried out during the last year:- - Continuing Health Care - Autism - Child Obesity - Urgent Care Centre - Hospital Discharges - Residential Care The Select Commission was about to start work on a Review of Carers and how they accessed support and Access to GPs. Links had also been made with Healthwatch Rotherham.
Further to Minute No. 43 of the meeting of the Self Regulation Select Commission held on 22nd November, 2012, consideration was given to a report, presented by Councillor Steele, which contained an overview of the workshop held by a sub-group of the Health Select Commission, with officers from various services in the Council, to consider the re-commissioning of childhood obesity services in Rotherham. The report provided details of:- : the background to the workshop;
Further to Minutes of previous meetings of the Health Select Commission (Minutes Nos. 76 of the meeting held on 18 th April 2013 and 29 of the meeting held on 12 th September, 2013), consideration was given to a report presented by Councillor Steele which set out the findings and recommendations of the scrutiny review of hospital discharges in Rotherham. The draft review report was included with the submitted report.
Councillor Steele would be in attendance.
Mover :- Councillor Whelbourn Seconder:- Councillor Steele
Updates were provided to the meeting in relation to the work in progress of the Select Commissions as follows:- Select Regulation Select Commission Councillor Steele provided an update on the progress of the Select Commission:- - A meeting had taken place with regard to the scoping of the Commissioning Review - Members were submitting requests for the work programme which would be further discussed at the away day Improving Places Select Commission Councillor Falvey provided an update on the progress of the Select Commission:- - An additional meeting had been held which had discussed potholes and off-road motorcycles Improving Lives Select Commission Councillor A.
Russell provided an update on the progress of the Select Commission:- - Reviews were continuing on Domestic Violence and Bullying Health Select Commission Councillor Steele provided an update on the progress of the Select Commission:- - Rotherham Heart Town -1 st year report of the 5 year project. The work that had been carried out in the 1 st year had been excellent. Defibrillators had been placed around the Authority both on Council premises and private properties - Hospital Discharge arrangements – Rotherham Foundation Trust’s draft Policy had been submitted.
- Health Select Commission: - Councillor Steele, Chair of the Health Select Commission, reported that a representative of the Rotherham Foundation Trust had attended the previous meeting to discuss the Trust’s proposed budget cuts and how some services currently provided at the hospital could be provided in the community in the future. The representative of the Rotherham Foundation Trust made a commitment that laundry and cleaning services would not be outsourced in order for high quality standards to be maintained. The meeting also considered data in relation to whether the Rotherham Foundation Trust had met quality NHS targets.
Mover :- Councillor Whelbourn Seconder :- Councillor Steele
Health Select Commission Councillor Steele reported attendance at:- Centre for Public Scrutiny Annual Conference. Issues covered included where scrutiny fit with the Localism Bill, Marmot Report, Localism Bill – Right to Challenge.
Health Select Commission Councillor Steele reported that the Commission had responded to a Government consultation paper on Obesity and a proposal to introduce standardised packaging for tobacco.
Consideration was given to a report presented by Councillor Steele and Kate Green, Scrutiny Officer, which set out how Rotherham had been involved in a programme of work with the Centre for Public Scrutiny (CfPS) to look at the way in which scrutiny could be used to help tackle health inequalities at a local level. Being part of this project involved undertaking a scrutiny review looking at an issue in relation to health inequalities; Rotherham chose to look at the quality of life and services provided for people with a BMI > 50.
Deborah Fellowes reported, on behalf of Councillor Steele, work of the Health Select Commission which included;- - Verbal report about the ongoing work with the British Heart Foundation in the Borough. 2 Elected Members (Councillors Barron and Dalton) would attend meetings - Rotherham Foundation Trust Quality Accounts 2012/13 - Health Inequalities Scrutiny Review BMI>50.
Councillor Steele and Kate Green was to attend a national meeting by the Centre for Public Scrutiny - Scrutiny Work Programme – The Commission felt that the focus was on the ‘right’ issues and happy with the approach and process taken. The work programme was achievable but it was agreed that officers should not be overburdened with work and any work set should be prioritised with all parties concerned in recognition of the limited resources available - Commencement of a joint review between health/Improving Lives Select Commission into NHS continuing healthcare and NHS funded nursing care. The Review Group consisted of Councillors Steele (Chairman), Beck, Jack and Pitchley, Russell Well and Anne Clough
Moved by Councillor Steele and seconded by Councillor License:- “Council notes that the Local Government Pension Scheme is a sustainable, good quality pension scheme that benefits from being funded and locally managed.
It was confirmed that Councillor Steele had been appointed to the Recycling Group by the Members’ Training and Development Panel.
Agreed :- That Councillor Steele be this Panel’s nominated representative.
Health Conference – Leeds The Chair reported that she and Councillor Steele had been invited to a Yorkshire and Humber Health Scrutiny Network meeting in Leeds on 15 th July, but that she was unable to attend.
She welcomed new members Councillor Jo Burton and Councillor Brian Steele, who was the new Vice-Chair.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Steele attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17 May 2024 | Council Meeting | Election of Chair | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 May 2024 | Council Meeting | Appointment of Vice-Chair | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 May 2018 | Council Meeting | Notice of motion - gender equality | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 8 Mar 2017 | Council Meeting | Notice of motion - save rotherham post office | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Jan 2017 | Council Meeting | Notice of motion - watson's tip | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Apr 2014 | Council Meeting | English Defence League - National Demonstration | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Steele was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 25 of 29 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Steele declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12 Mar 2025 | Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, item 92 | In relation to Minute Number 95, Councillor Steele declared a Non-pecuniary interest as a member of the Trans-Pennine Trail in relation to Item 6, Transport Capital Programme 2025/2026. | |
| 12 Mar 2025 | Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, item 95 | Councillor Steele declared a Non-pecuniary interest as a member of the Trans-Pennine Trail in relation to this item. | |
| 18 Mar 2020 | Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, item 161 | Councillor Steele declared a non-pecuniary interest in the urgent item on the Implementation of the South Yorkshire Devolution Deal as he was a member of the Sheffield City Region Combined Authority Overview and Scrutiny Committee. | |
| 7 Sep 2018 | Planning Board, item 27 | Councillor Steele declared he was a former Secretary to an anti-fracking group, but was no longer involved. | |
| 4 Jul 2018 | Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, item 23 | Councillor Steele declared a person interest in agenda item 8 (Allotments Self-Management) on the basis that he held an allotment with a parish council within the borough. | |
| 11 Oct 2017 | Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, item 13 | Councillor Steele declared a personal interest in Minute No. 15 (Advice Services Review) as a member of the Board of the Citizens Advice Bureau. | |
| 13 Jan 2017 | Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, item 70 | (Councillor Steele declared a personal interest in Minute No. 75 (Budget Pressures in relation to Older People’s Services) on the grounds that his mother had Dementia. | |
| 18 Jan 2016 | Cabinet and Commissioners' Decision Making Meeting (during Government Intervention, item 48 | Councillor Steele declared a personal interest in Minute No. 53 (Advice Service Review) on the grounds of being a non-voting member on the Citizens Advice Bureau Board. | |
| 15 Jan 2016 | Overview and Scrutiny Management Board, item 72 | Councillor Steele declared an interest in Minute No. 76 (Budget 2016/17 to 2017/18 - Consideration of Savings Proposals - RES7H Trade Union Secondment Budget). |
Where Councillor Steele sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overview and Scrutiny Management Board | Chair | Jan 2012 | 108 | 9 Dec 2026 |
| Council Meeting | Member | Feb 2011 | 55 | 13 Jan 2027 |
| Licensing Board Sub-Committee | Member | Apr 2018 | 16 | 7 Dec 2026 |
| Improving Lives Select Commission | Member | Mar 2018 | 4 | 15 Dec 2026 |
| Improving Places Select Commission | Member | Mar 2018 | 3 | 1 Dec 2026 |
| Licensing Sub-Committee | Member | Jul 2024 | 3 | 23 Nov 2026 |
| Transportation Advisory Group | Member | Oct 2026 | 1 | |
| Planning Board | Member | Jan 2019 | 20 | |
| Cabinet and Commissioners' Decision Making Meeting (during Government Intervention | Councillor Member | Jan 2016 | 19 | |
| Information | Member | Jan 2014 | 14 | |
| Cabinet | Councillor Member | Jan 2019 | 14 | |
| Adult Social Care | Member | Jan 2012 | 13 | |
| Health and Wellbeing | Member | Jan 2012 | 9 | |
| Health Select Commission | Chairman | Jan 2012 | 8 | |
| Senior Officer Appointments Panel | Member | Mar 2015 | 8 | |
| The Former Performance and Scrutiny Overview Committee | Member | Jan 2011 | 5 | |
| Adult Independence Health and Wellbeing | Member | Jan 2011 | 5 | |
| Members' Training and Development Panel | Member | Jan 2011 | 4 | |
| Licensing Board | Member | Apr 2018 | 4 | |
| The Former Adult Services and Health Scrutiny Panel | Vice-Chairman | Jan 2011 | 3 | |
| Commissioners' Public Meeting with Councillors | Member | Jan 2016 | 3 | |
| The Former Members Sustainable Development Advisory Group (expired October, 2010) (See Sustainability Partnership) | Member | Jan 2011 | 2 | |
| Care Forum | Member | Feb 2013 | 1 | |
| Area Assembly Chairs | Member | Jan 2015 | 1 | |
| Commissioner's Licensing Hearings (Regulatory Function | Member | Jun 2015 | 1 | |
| Commissioner's Licensing Decisions Meeting | Member | Jan 2016 | 1 | |
| Licensing Committee | Member | May 2025 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.