Asked7 Oct 2026Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Public On-Street Litter Bin Collections and Service Improvement Programme
Councillor McKiernan sought clarification on responsibility for bins located on different types of council-owned land. The Operations Manager North, Street Scene advised that bins located on the public highway fell within the service’s remit regardless of land ownership.
Asked7 Oct 2026Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Information briefing on RCV replacement
Councillor McKiernan asked whether the introduction of new vehicles would result in additional costs, including staff training or depot modifications. The Executive Director of Regeneration and Environment advised that some familiarisation and driver training would be required but did not anticipate significant additional costs.
Said7 Oct 2026Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Local Plan
Councillor McKiernan welcomed the discussion and noted the Improving Places Select Commissions ongoing engagement with officers regarding the , expressing support for ensuring appropriate scrutiny as the process progressed.
Said7 Oct 2026Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Improving Places Select Commission Scrutiny Review - School Road Safety
Councillor McKiernan thanked Kristianne Thorogood, Governance Advisor, the review group members and Councillor Tinsley, who had chaired the review, for their work. It was noted that evidence had been gathered from a range of sources, including discussions with external organisations and neighbouring authorities, which had helped inform the recommendations. Reference was made to learning from partners including South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority (SYMCA) and Sheffield City Council, and it was emphasised that the recommendations were intended to be ambitious, with Cabinet determining how they should be taken forward.
Said7 Oct 2026Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Work in Progress - Select Commissions
The Chair, Councillor McKiernan highlighted work undertaken by the Improving Places Select Commission, including scrutiny of the Investment and Development Office Business Centres review. It was noted that members had found the review informative and that a visit to one of the centres was being arranged.
Said8 Sep 2026Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Work in Progress - Select Commissions
Councillor McKiernan noted that the timing of meetings had created some overlap, as IPSC had met the previous week but too late for updates to be included in the current report.
Said8 Sep 2026Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Work in Progress - Select Commissions
Councillor McKiernan also advised that the School Road Safety Review had been approved by IPSC and would be submitted to OSMB at a future meeting.
Named1 Jul 2026Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
May 2026-27 Financial Monitoring Report
In response to a question from Councillor McKiernan, the Service Director, Financial Services clarified that the table set out the savings formally approved by Cabinet and Council for delivery during 2026/27. It was explained that the middle column showed the savings already secured alongside those still to be delivered during the remainder of the financial year.
Named1 Jul 2026Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Work in Progress - Select Commissions
Councillor McKiernan provided an update from the Improving Places Select Commission, advising that the Neighbourhood Leadership Strategy and the wider neighbourhoods policy framework would be considered as separate pieces of work. It was also reported that the Commission had considered the Local Nature Recovery Strategy during the pre-consultation stage and had recommended that correspondence be sent to the South Yorkshire Mayor and the relevant Government department regarding matters arising from the review.
Said1 Jul 2026Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Work in Progress - Select Commissions
Councillor McKiernan explained that the purpose of the strategy was to strengthen the "One Council" approach rather than create further division. It was intended to improve accountability, strengthen the role of neighbourhood teams, enhance tracking of Member enquiries through a casework system and ensure greater involvement of ward councillors in local service decisions and activities. Members were advised that the strategy aimed to improve coordination between councillors, neighbourhood teams and Council services, including engagement at neighbourhood meetings and consultation on local projects.
Named21 Apr 2026Improving Places Select Commission
Improving Places Select Commission - Work Programme 2025 - 2026
Councillor McKiernan mentioned that the Waterfront Café would have a Head Chef on-site and that Members had been told that if this worked out well, it was hoped that the Head Chef could work across other catering sites across the borough, such as Thrybergh.
Said8 Apr 2026Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Climate Emergency Annual Report
Councillor McKiernan raised concerns that a number of actions within the climate change action plan had been delayed across several areas, including where delays were not solely attributable to external factors. It was questioned whether the Council was taking delivery of the programme as seriously as required and whether sufficient urgency was being applied given the scale and breadth of the delays identified.
Said8 Apr 2026Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Work in Progress - Select Commissions
The Chair of Improving Places Select Commission, Councillor McKiernan reported on a recent site visit to Rother Valley Country Park, noting that attendance had been limited but that the visit had been productive and treated as a scrutiny exercise. It was stated that members reviewed what had worked well and what had not, with issues identified primarily relating to HR and procurement.
Said8 Apr 2026Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Work in Progress - Select Commissions
Councillor McKiernan explained that procurement issues had contributed to delays in opening, with some ordered items arriving late. Further difficulties were highlighted in relation to catering supplies, where standard procurement arrangements designed for school catering had not aligned well with the needs of a café setting. It was noted that, as a local authority, procurement was required to follow government legislation, including formal tendering and framework agreements, which limited flexibility in purchasing day?to?day items.
Asked8 Apr 2026Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Councillor McKiernan asked for clarification on progress relating to the devolution proposals involving the South Yorkshire Fire Authority and its potential incorporation into SYMCA. Concerns were raised about the lack of clarity around the governance and scrutiny arrangements, and it was requested that this be raised through SYMCA scrutiny channels. The Chair advised that the matter had previously been raised and that plans were still developing.
Named11 Mar 2026Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Work Programme
Councillor McKiernan reminded the group that the previous review was closed because it had become too broad and noted that the current process aimed to focus on specific, evidence?based issues. This was why the Chair had written to all members requesting clear priorities.
Asked3 Feb 2026Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Inclusion Strategy and Annual Report
Councillor McKiernan asked about the section on page 99 relating to consultations. He noted that the report suggested there was fragmentation across Council services in how public consultations were carried out. He queried whether there were plans to establish a ... view the full minutes text for item 99.
Named3 Feb 2026Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Work in Progress - Select Commissions
Councillor McKiernan provided an update on recent meetings reporting that the Commission had considered the Annual Bereavement Services Report, noting subsequent news of significant price increases which had caused concern among members, although this was outside the Council’s control.
Named3 Feb 2026Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Work in Progress - Select Commissions
No further questions were raised for Cllr McKiernan.
Named12 Nov 2025Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Work in Progress - Select Commissions
Councillor McKiernan, Chair of Improving Places Select Commission reported that the previous meeting on 21 October covered the Housing Strategy 2025–2030 and its Draft Action Plan, which will monitor progress under four key priorities.
Asked15 Oct 2025Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Work in Progress - Select Commissions
Councillor McKiernan sought clarification on the position of Healthwatch and if it had been considered? The Chair of Health Select Commission responded that the Commission had discussed the role of the council in what was expected to happen going forward. It was confirmed that Healthwatch was going to be phased out.
Asked9 Sep 2025Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Work Programme
Councillor McKiernan sought clarification that members of the Improving Places Select Commission would be invited to attend OSMB to consider the Selective Licensing Policy as part of OSMB’s pre-decision scrutiny work? The Governance Manager confirmed that this was due to be considered at the next Cabinet meeting, therefore members of IPSC would be invited to join the OSMB meeting scheduled for the 8 October 20205.
Asked2 Jul 2025Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Financial Outturn 2024-25
Councillor McKiernan queried a line in the budget showing a negative £2.8 million under “Unallocated Flood Alleviation” for 2027–28, asking if money was being removed from the budget. The Assistant Director Financial Services said it appeared to be a reallocation issue. The unallocated fund was a central pot for future flood schemes.
Named2 Jul 2025Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Work in Progress - Select Commissions
Improving Places Select Commission Presented by: Councillor McKiernan, Chair Key Updates:
Asked14 May 2025Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Review of the Non-Residential Charging Policy
Councillor McKiernan asked for clarification on what the lower middle rate and higher rate was? The Strategic Director for Adult Care, Housing and Public Health explained that the numerous benefits discussed came at different rates depending on the assessment that the person had received in terms of their needs by benefit agencies. There could be a lower rate and a higher rate or different rates within that which were dependent on the assessment for the disability benefit.
Asked8 Apr 2025Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Licensing Act 2003 - Statement of Licensing Policy
Councillor McKiernan sought clarification on how current licence holders would be informed of the proposed changes to the Statement of Licensing Policy. Concern was expressed that simply issuing the updated policy may not be sufficient and that additional steps should be taken to ensure ... view the full minutes text for item 109.
Said15 Jan 2025Council Meeting
Members' Questions to Designated Spokespersons
Councillor McKiernan explained that Rotherham fire station continued to provide 24/7 cover, supported by other stations and fire engines across the borough and across the county. The fire and rescue service had received significant, real-term reductions in funding since 2010.
Said15 Jan 2025Council Meeting
Members' Questions to Designated Spokespersons
Councillor McKiernan stated that the bold and decisive measures that Councillor Ball took were to join the Conservative Party and become an advocate for austerity. Meanwhile, it has continued to receive single year funding settlements for many years, creating further financial uncertainty. Both the service and the Authority had continued to lobby successive government ministers for a fair and long term funding settlement for the fire and rescue service.
Said15 Jan 2025Council Meeting
Members' Questions to Designated Spokespersons
In his role on the Fire Authority, Councillor McKiernan stated that he would be supporting the responsible decisions that needed to be taken, based on the risks facing the service and the public, and supporting a government that would back public services, not one that undermined them at every turn.
Named15 Jan 2025Council Meeting
Members' Questions to Designated Spokespersons
In his supplementary question, Councillor Ball asked Councillor McKiernan to provide specific examples (names, dates, decisions) of meaningful change .
Said15 Jan 2025Council Meeting
Members' Questions to Designated Spokespersons
Councillor McKiernan advised Councillor Ball to search online.
Said15 Jan 2025Council Meeting
Members' Questions to Designated Spokespersons
Councillor McKiernan explained that the service continued to take steps to improve the availability of its on-call fire engines- including at Dearne fire station. This included the regular recruitment and training of new on-call firefighters (including 6 at Dearne in 2024) and the introduction of an on-call support team, which had had a big impact on the availability of on-call fire engines across the county.
Named15 Jan 2025Council Meeting
Members' Questions to Designated Spokespersons
All fire and rescue services in the UK faced challenges in recruiting sufficient numbers of on-call firefighters due to the very specific eligibility requirements for the role, but Councillor McKiernan was confident the service was taking appropriate steps to address this issue in South Yorkshire.
Said15 Jan 2025Council Meeting
Members' Questions to Designated Spokespersons
Councillor McKiernan stated that he had not been on the Fire Authority long enough to know the specific details but as Councillor Ball had previously been a member, ... view the full minutes text for item 111.
Said27 Nov 2024Transportation Advisory Group
RMBC Transportation Unit - Updates
Councillor McKiernan thanked officers for the work on Centenary Way being completed ahead of schedule.
Said13 Nov 2024Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Response from Cabinet 16 September 2024 to the Scrutiny Review Recommendations - Referral from Council to Overview and Scrutiny Management Board (OSMB) - Petition "Rotherham's Commitment to a Permanent Ceasefire and To Promote Peace in Palestine and in the Region"
Councillor McKiernan noted Action four agreed that the Cabinet spokesperson continued to hold dialogue with petitioners to continue to seek peace in ... view the full minutes text for item 55.
Said10 Sep 2024Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Work Programme
Councillor McKiernan commented that in relation to the Improving Places Select Commission there had been some disappointment from Councillor Jones as this Commission would not be reviewing the Grounds Maintenance Policy but instead this would fall to OSMB.
Named10 Sep 2024Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Work Programme
Councillor McKiernan accepted that it was a decision that already had been taken and it had gone to OSMB for the reasons in relation to grass cutting.
Named10 Sep 2024Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Work in Progress - Select Commissions
Councillor McKiernan then proceeded to discuss the work programme for Improving Places Commission (IPSC) but noted that due to the General Election there had been some delays with meetings which had been frustrating for its Commission members. However, they were looking forward to their future meetings and their new work programme.
Said10 Sep 2024Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Work in Progress - Select Commissions
Councillor McKiernan confirmed that the upcoming IPSC meeting in October, would focus on the ‘Section 19 Flood’, which he believed would be an interesting area. He mentioned that he would be inviting external partners that contributed to the report so they could be questioned as part of this review.
Said10 Sep 2024Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Work in Progress - Select Commissions
Councillor McKiernan acknowledged the significance of this topic as it was an area that affected the entire borough. However, he noted that this review would only focus on the areas highlighted within the report and asked Commission Members to suggest who they should invite to the meeting to discuss ‘Section 19 Flood’.
Said10 Sep 2024Overview and Scrutiny Management Board
Work in Progress - Select Commissions
Councillor McKiernan then stated that the next item for the Commission would be ‘Flood Alleviation’ which had been delayed due to the ‘Section 19 Flood’ which needed earlier considered given its importance when there could be considerable ... view the full minutes text for item 29.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.