Minutes of the previous Council Meeting
Councillor Ball asked for clarification regarding substitutes in relation to Council Procedure Rule 11(5), Questions to Spokesperson. The Monitoring Officer confirmed that he would respond by email.
Every time Rotherham's minutes name Councillor Ball, as the council published it.
Councillor Ball asked for clarification regarding substitutes in relation to Council Procedure Rule 11(5), Questions to Spokesperson. The Monitoring Officer confirmed that he would respond by email.
There was one question from Councillor Ball:
Councillor Ball: Following Health and Wellbeing Board on 2 September, will the Cabinet Member name the social housing complex with the ongoing Legionella outbreak, confirm the landlord, whether it is council-operated, what tenants have been told, whether anyone has been ill, and the date the water will be declared safe?
In his supplementary, Councillor Ball stated that this had been ongoing since June 2024 and was referred to at the Health and Wellbeing Board as an ongoing outbreak. He asked what happened if it was still ongoing on 1 October 2026?
Councillor Ball: Will the Cabinet Member set out how Pride in Place and High Street investment, though Maltby East designated, will deliver measurable outcomes in Hellaby and Maltby West, and confirm what West consultation has already informed the Regeneration Plan due by end of 2026?
Councillor Ball: Given FOI figures of over £175,000 spent clearing fly-tipping in 2024/25 and 2025/26 and Hellaby and Maltby West being named hotspots, will ward level clearance costs, FPNs and enforcement outcomes be published, ... view the full minutes text for item 72.
- Grant Licensed Taxi Drivers access to bus lanes across Rotherham (59 signatures – Lead Petitioner: Councillor Simon Ball) - Improved Road Safety and School Crossing - Thorpe Hesley Primary School (117 signatures – Lead Petitioner: Katie Dawson) Councillor Ball was unable to attend the meeting. [name removed] attended the meeting and spoke to her petition. In accordance with the Council’s Petition Scheme, the Executive Director of Regeneration and Environment would provide a written response to each petition within 10 working days.
Councillor Ball was unable to attend the meeting.
Councillor Stables stated that the focus for her and Councillor Ball had been to listen to residents and deliver real visible improvements. They had organised the first Community Christmas Tree and St. George’s Day event for Hellaby and Maltby West.
It was moved by Councillor Ball and seconded by Councillor Bacon that:
In accordance with Procedure Rule 19 (2) Councillor Ball had requested that a recorded vote should be taken on the proposed motion. Five Members stood to show their support for a recorded vote to be taken on the motion.
Councillor Ball declared a Personal and Prejudical Interest in the cases of [name removed].U. and [name removed].E.
Councillor Ball was not present to ask his question and as such would receive a written response.
Councillor Ball asked a question in relation to the Housing Delivery Programme and Cumwell Lane. He stated that residents in Hellaby had been assured that the land would not be developed for a number of years.
Councillor Ball asked the Leader to write to the government to oppose the development and push for a reassessment of Rotherham’s housing targets.
(1) Councillor Ball noted the data sharing assisted bin collection collaboration between RMBC and SYFR had now started so asked how could this be promoted more as it would ultimately save lives?
In a supplementary question Councillor Ball gave praise to Barry Connolly and his team they had got this well organised. He, therefore, asked if the Spokesperson could provide assurances that this would be effectively monitored and reviewed to ensure it delivered real safety improvements to the residents of Rotherham and how would he let all Members know.
(2) Councillor Ball referred to Labour’s plan to ban zero hours contracts which would directly impact SYFR. He asked what would be the financial cost of replacing this flexible workforce and how did the service plan to fund it without cutting other vital services or increasing taxes?
In a supplementary question Councillor Ball expressed his worry about a possible strike happening where there was not cover anymore. He asked the Spokesperson to explore a little further into if there was a house fire in say Maltby, where there was not the contingency crew, who and how were they going to get an adequate response to that house fire when it needed three appliances to get to.
He would question this with the Chief Fire Officer so asked Councillor Ball to forward him by email the exact wording and he would raise it ... view the full minutes text for item 133.
It was moved by Councillor Ball and seconded by Councillor Thorp that:
Councillor Ball: Rotherham’s night-time fire cover, once a shining beacon of protection, has dwindled alarmingly over the past decade. What stirring actions, what bold and decisive measures, have you personally undertaken to arrest this deeply worrying erosion of safety for our residents?
Councillor McKiernan stated that the bold and decisive measures that Councillor Ball took were to join the Conservative Party and become an advocate for austerity. Meanwhile, it has continued to receive single year funding settlements for many years, creating further financial uncertainty. Both the service and the Authority had continued to lobby successive government ministers for a fair and long term funding settlement for the fire and rescue service.
In his supplementary question, Councillor Ball asked Councillor McKiernan to provide specific examples (names, dates, decisions) of meaningful change .
Councillor McKiernan advised Councillor Ball to search online.
Councillor Ball: Dearne’s on-call pump, a critical lifeline for large-scale emergencies, has become about as reliable as a British summer. What plans, what mighty and immediate steps, do you have to restore this vital resource to a state of robust operational readiness, ensuring that the people of Rotherham are not left high and dry in their hour of need?
In his supplementary question, Councillor Ball asked how the people of Rotherham could trust the plan to improve the reliability of on-call fire engines at Dearne fire station when the problem had persisted for years? He asked if the timeline was weeks, months or another decade.
Councillor McKiernan stated that he had not been on the Fire Authority long enough to know the specific details but as Councillor Ball had previously been a member, ... view the full minutes text for item 111.
Councillor Ball: How much additional pressure will the increase in NI cause to the finances of SYP and will you provide a forecast of how much this will cost to implement these labour tax hikes?
Councillor Ball did not attend the meeting and, as such, would receive a written response.
Councillor Ball: How much additional pressure will the increase in NI cause to the finances of SYFR and will you provide a forecast of how much this will cost to implement these labour tax hikes?
Councillor Ball: Can the Leader inform me if he will be applying to GB energy to supply small scale clean energy projects such as solar panels on council houses, schools and hospitals?
In accordance with the Council’s Petition Scheme, the lead petitioner, Councillor Ball, was entitled to address the Council for a period of five minutes.
Councillor Ball asked the following questions on the Cabinet 1. In relation to burials and cemeteries, Maltby Cemetery and many others were quickly running out of room. Could they be given the same level of interest as those mentioned in the Cabinet minutes?
The Leader stated that Councillor Ball would be kept informed of the progress.
Councillor Ball asked the following questions on the minutes:
Councillor Ball referenced a section of the minutes that stated: “Given that much of the impact that air pollution had on mortality was linked with cardiovascular deaths, it was considered that it made a contribution to some of, perhaps even all, cardiovascular deaths.” He stated that the Council was therefore failing to protect its residents and contributing to a lower mortality rate. He asked when the Council would get a grip of the emissions it produces in order to help residents.
Councillor Ball for the designated spokesperson on South Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Authority: Can the member please provide data from the last 5 years on what the budget forecast was compared to the actual financial expenditure?
In his supplementary, Councillor Ball stated that SYFR’s forecast was wildly out, and the Advertiser had picked up that £1.5m was being put back into reserves. With Rotherham residents being told there was no money to provide a night-time cover and two appliances in Rotherham whilst year on year, SYFR bank more millions, why was Rotherham left with a diminished cover, despite having the money to facilitate a night shift?
Councillor Ball for the designated spokesperson on South Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Authority: Can you inform me how much SYFR has in reserves?
As Councillor Ball was aware, reserves were earmarked for specific purposes and could not be called on for day-to-day use. The Authority anticipated useable earmarked reserves reducing to just £5.7m during the planning period 2024-27.
Councillor Ball: What would be the impact to local schools if Labour's proposals to remove VAT relief to independent schools was put in place?
As Councillor Ball was not present to ask his question, a written response would be provided.
Councillor Ball confirmed no procedural rules had been broken as part of the withdrawal from the agenda of the Palestinian motion.
Councillor Ball commended the work of Councillors that had been undertaken which had been very hard. There was a need for different councillors so challenge was very important.
Councillor Ball noted the concerns about Maltby Cemetery and asked what work was taking place to find space to allow the people to bury their loved ones in the home town of Maltby.
(2) Councillor Ball would receive a written response to his question as Councillor Haleem had left the meeting.
(3) Councillor Ball asked with the South Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service raising its precept, how would this impact the tax payers of Rotherham?
In a supplementary question Councillor Ball confirmed there was money in reserves by investing in other places. Council Tax being raised increased further pressure yet the spokesperson attended the Fire Conference paid by service so what justified this for the taxpayers of Rotherham.
Councillor Wyatt confirmed both he had Councillor Ball had received the same papers and the same invitation.
Councillor Ball asked for clarification regarding Minute 58 – Recommendations from the Independent Remuneration Panel – Members Allowances.
Councillor Ball: It has come to my attention the Mayor is suggesting that he takes the Police and crime panel into the Combined Authority if so how can this provide adequate independent scrutiny?
In his supplementary question, Councillor Ball stated that he was aware of the suggestion and asked if what was being suggested, which was less independent scrutiny, was really the way forward?
Councillor Ball: Can you inform me how many staff out of the OPCC will lose their jobs when transferring over to the Mayor’s office?
Councillor Ball welcomed Councillor Harper.
Councillor Ball also informed the Chamber that there had been three deaths in three weeks on roads in the Borough. He offered his thoughts to the families of those involved and praised the work of the emergency services.
Councillor Ball questioned why there was no longer a Cabinet Member who was dedicated 100% to transport following a rise in concerns?
Councillor Ball asked the following questions on the Cabinet 1.
In relation to Minute No. 46 of Cabinet held on 18th September, 2023, Councillor Ball asked for an update in relation to the selection of Labour candidates for the 2024 local elections. He asked if the Leader could confirm if there were sitting Councillors, some of whom were Chairs etc., not able to sit again as Labour Councillors and if so what new information had come forward to deselect these Councillors and what confidence did it give to the residents of Rotherham that this was happening?
In relation to Minute No. 65 of Cabinet held on 16th October, 2023, Councillor Ball stated that a group campaigning about cemeteries had been promised monthly meetings. He asked if this would be extended to all of the Borough as he understood that most local cemeteries were having issues and would welcome the chance to have monthly meetings to look at their problems?
In relation to Minute No. 72 of Cabinet held on 16th October, 2023, Councillor Ball stated that every one of the fast charges that he had visited in the last month in Rotherham had either been vandalised or not working. In the Climate Working Group he had said that these would not be viable for Rotherham and that a forecourt way of doing things would provide jobs and would be better to provide security to these points. What had been done about this to save the taxpayers of Rotherham money and would the Leader pause the Cabinet decision for the electric vehicle (EV) infrastructure in Rotherham whilst this matter is looked in to?
Councillor Ball also asked what had happened to the Climate Working Group; had it been disbanded?
In relation to Minute No. 76 of Cabinet held on 16th October, 2023, Councillor Ball stated that it was good to see houses being built that catered for all in terms of accessibility.
In relation to the first question asked for Councillor Ball, the Leader stated that announcements on the selection of Labour candidates for the May 2024 local elections would be made in due course and he would not speculate on those processes.
In relation to the second question from Councillor Ball, the Leader stated that Councillor Ball had misunderstood and there were no monthly ... view the full minutes text for item 52.
During the meeting, Councillor Ball asked if 100% of premises had disabled access.
This motion was withdrawn by Councillor Ball.
Councillor Ball shared the Leaders sentiments ... view the full minutes text for item 28.
Councillor Ball declared a personal interest in application RB2022/0017 (outline application for the erection of up to 217 dwellinghouses including details of access at land off Shrogswood Road, Whiston for Ernest V.
Councillor Ball welcomed the investment in the region. He had previously asked a question regarding the SYMCA Strategic Plan, he had not received any response from April when it was raised, and the potholes mentioned were still on the A6321 and he would welcome an update.
Councillor Ball seconded the report noting all the members of the Constitution Working Group had worked together to produce the amendments which would be kept under constant review.
Councillor Ball declared a disclosable personal interest in RB2022/1806 (Increase in height of part of building from two to three storeys to create apartments with two additional apartments in the roof space at Phoenix Court, 67 Blyth Road, Maltby) on the grounds that he had objected to the application prior to becoming a Planning Board Member.
Councillor Ball declared a disclosable personal interest in RB2022/1806 (Increase in height of part of building from two to three storeys to create apartments with two additional apartments in the roof space at Phoenix Court,67 Blyth Road, Maltby) on the grounds that he had objected to the application prior to becoming a Planning Board Member.
(1) Councillor Ball asked the designated spokesperson on the South Yorkshire Police and Crime Panel if they were happy that residents of Rotherham were having to pay an increased precept to cover the failures of South Yorkshire Police over CSE and Hillsborough?
In a supplementary question Councillor Ball confirmed no reasonable person was happy to pay for this but asked should this not have come out of the earmarked reserves that this Force holds and why this was not considered as an option given the current climate.
(2) Councillor Ball asked the designated spokesperson on the South Yorkshire Police and Crime Panel if they could provide a figure of how much CSE cases and Hillsborough have cost the taxpayers of Rotherham in total and per head?
In a supplementary question Councillor Ball asked if the spokesperson was comfortable with some of the figures due to Labour-led decisions.
The Chair welcomed Councillor Ball to his first meeting of the Audit Committee and Councillor Browne who had re-joined the Committee as Vice-Chair.
Councillor Ball noted that the Council had been successful in attracting funding for Rother Valley Country Park and queried if this would be shared across the rest of the borough. He felt there was no priority given to peripheral towns and villages. The Leader indicated the challenge of how to ensure that all parts of the borough were getting access to investment opportunities was fair.
A question was received from Councillor Ball who asked where the non-compliant vehicles go now that buses within Sheffield had to comply with the clean air scheme?
A question was received from Councillor Ball who asked if the Leader had full confidence in the Cabinet Members who remained silent after the Jay Report?
- Health Select Commission – Councillor Elliott to be removed - Licensing Committee – Councillor Ball to be removed - Licensing Board – Councillor Ball to be removed - Mayoral Combined Authority Audit and Standards Committee – Councillor Ball to be removed
Councillor Ball asked about Coronation Park which he raised at the last Cabinet Meeting. He stated that he had attended the Park that week and there had never been as much glass.
Councillor Ball asked what help could be provided for Coronation Park at this moment in time because it was dangerous? Children could not play there, dogs could not be walked there. Nothing could be done in the Park without a risk of harm.
(3) Councillor Ball asked how many home electric charging points had been added to new builds in an effort to combat climate change?
In his supplementary question, Councillor Ball asked whether these would be moved onto a 3-phase system to future proof?
(2) Councillor Ball stated that this Council adopted the IHRA after accusing a member of public of bringing it up due to it being political at the time. The Leader said it would not be adopted unless a complaint had been made. Can the Leader inform how many complaints have been made regarding anti-semitism between the question asked and adopting the definition?
In his supplementary, Councillor Ball asked why the IHRA was not accepted in the first place. He had been to Auschwitz and come back to realise the Council had no definition in place. He asked the Council to adopt it and the Leader had flatly turned it down.
That led to the Council adopting it around 6 months after Councillor Ball had asked the question.
The Chair welcomed Cllr Ball to the meeting as Lead Petitioner.
Cllr Collingham joined Cllr Ball as a signatory to the petition, having declared an interest in this item. The Cabinet Member for Transport and the Environment and officers were also welcomed.
The Chair invited to Cllr Ball to present the call for action. He noted with regret the need to submit the petition. Referring to previous serious accidents including some fatalities, he stated that the lanes were used as a shortcut between villages.
Board Members were invited to ask questions of Cllr Ball, as the Lead Petitioner. Clarification was sought if there were actions other than the installation of an average speed camera that could be taken by the Council to improve road safety.
· Containing 643 signatures calling on the Council to “Improve Road Safety on Cumwell Lane/ Kingsforth Lane.” Councillor Ball and Councillor T. Collingham addressed the Council as part of the presentation of the petition.
Councillor Ball made reference to Minute No.
(1) Councillor Ball asked a question in relation to referrals from the Fire Service to Rotherham Council Social Services. He noted that there were 45 referrals in Rotherham but that Sheffield had over 700 and this had been the case for the last 3 years. There had been some training ... view the full minutes text for item 116.
Councillor Ball explained that there had been another death on Cumwell Lane and that he had been to Cabinet in December 2021 following a death on the road to ask for more safety measures.
An e-petition had been launched on the same day as the recent accident and Councillor Ball ... view the full minutes text for item 101.
(2) Councillor Ball asked how many children took up the offer of Beat The Street in Maltby, Hellaby and Hooton Levitt?
In a supplementary question Councillor Ball explained the need for more programmes such as Beat The Street as bus services had been suspended in the evening and young people needed more things to do. He asked whether there were plans to continue with such programmes?
(1) Councillor Simon Ball asked the following question to the Cabinet Member for Housing, Councillor Brookes:
(1) Councillor Ball withdrew his question.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Ball attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 25 May 2022 | Council Meeting | Outcome of the wickersley neighbourhood development plan referendum | Lost | 455 for, 334 against | |
| 2 Mar 2022 | Council Meeting | Notice of motion - lifesaving equipment | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Ball was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 6 of 15 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Ball declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 30 Jun 2025 | Licensing Board Sub-Committee, item 1 | Councillor Ball declared a Personal and Prejudical Interest in the cases of [name removed].U. and [name removed].E. | |
| 20 Jul 2023 | Planning Board, item 3 | Councillor Ball declared a personal interest in application RB2022/0017 (outline application for the erection of up to 217 dwellinghouses including details of access at land off Shrogswood Road, Whiston for Ernest V. | |
| 18 May 2023 | Planning Board, item 195 | Councillor Ball declared a disclosable personal interest in RB2022/1806 (Increase in height of part of building from two to three storeys to create apartments with two additional apartments in the roof space at Phoenix Court, 67 Blyth Road, Maltby) on the grounds that he had objected to the application prior to becoming a Planning Board Member. | |
| 27 Apr 2023 | Planning Board, item 187 | Councillor Ball declared a disclosable personal interest in RB2022/1806 (Increase in height of part of building from two to three storeys to create apartments with two additional apartments in the roof space at Phoenix Court,67 Blyth Road, Maltby) on the grounds that he had objected to the application prior to becoming a Planning Board Member. |
Where Councillor Ball sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council Meeting | Member | May 2021 | 33 | 13 Jan 2027 |
| Transportation Advisory Group | Member | Jul 2023 | 8 | |
| Licensing Board Sub-Committee | Member | Jun 2022 | 6 | 7 Dec 2026 |
| Licensing Sub-Committee | Member | Jun 2026 | 1 | 23 Nov 2026 |
| Planning Board | Member | Apr 2023 | 10 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Management Board | Member | Aug 2023 | 4 | |
| Licensing Board | Member | Feb 2002 | 2 | |
| Audit Committee | Member | Mar 2023 | 2 | |
| Staffing Committee | Member | Jul 2023 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.