Approval of the Statement of Accounts 2025/26
Councillor Thomas stated that, year after year, the Council appeared to be carrying forward significant sums in both capital and revenue budgets.
Every time Rushcliffe's minutes name Councillor Thomas, as the council published it.
Councillor Thomas stated that, year after year, the Council appeared to be carrying forward significant sums in both capital and revenue budgets.
Councillor Thomas suggested that the recurring surpluses were considerable and questioned whether the Council was being overly cautious. She further suggested that, if Rushcliffe did not require those funds, consideration should be given to reducing Council Tax. The Assistant Director for Finance replied that reserves were intended to help secure the Council’s future, particularly in light of reductions in Government settlements and Business Rates income and to avoid the need to reduce services.
Councillor Thomas stated that Rushcliffe appeared to be doing what was needed to improve its housing land supply position.
Councillor Thomas requested that this particular risk be reassessed and that the results of that assessment be shared with the Group.
Councillor Thomas sought clarification regarding vacancies within the Council’s investment properties. It was noted that this information would be circulated following the meeting.
Councillor Thomas and Councillor Edyvean requested sight of meetings scheduled beyond the current cycle up to the Annual Council meeting. They noted that this would assist Councillors in forward planning and enable work programmes to be developed and populated further in advance. The Chair echoed this view and expressed a desire for future meeting schedules to be drafted and shared with the Group at an earlier stage.
Councillor Thomas welcomed the new incumbent and thanked Ifty Ali. She questioned if the increase in cost for the post was directly attributed to Local Government Reorganisation (LGR), and if so, should the additional cost be accounted for under the LGR budget..
Councillor Thomas stated that she would have preferred some attempt to consider whether all current allowances were justified, given current workloads. However, she agreed that the review appeared to have followed due process, and the Leake Independent Group accepted the outcome.
He acknowledged the considerable work undertaken by Councillor Rex Walker, in conjunction with Councillor Thomas in drafting the alterations, and he was pleased that Councillor Thomas had agreed to second the recommendation and thanked them both. The Leader expressed concern that this legislation would reduce local democracy and input from Ward Councillors when representing their residents, making their job more difficult.
Councillor Thomas seconded the recommendation and reserved the right to speak.
Councillor Thomas reiterated thanks to [name removed] and expressed disappointment that the Council had been unable to employ a member of staff for this important role, and she felt that the additional costs incurred, as detailed in the report were not a good use of public money.
Councillor Thomas asked the Leader if he believed that the difficulty in recruitment was related to uncertainties over Local Government Reorganisation (LGR), and if so, would Rushcliffe reconsider bonuses for staff remaining at Rushcliffe until April 2028, who did not obtain a position with the new council, and were not eligible for redundancy.
The Leader agreed that there was uncertainty regarding LGR, with announcements expected soon, and he felt that the comments raised by Councillor Thomas were interesting and could be discussed going forward as LGR progressed.
The Group considered a scrutiny request relating to Management of Open Spaces on New Build Estates Cllr Way and Cllr Thomas joined the meeting to present the case for this potential scrutiny. They presented the following:
Question from Councillor Thomas to Councillor Upton.
Councillor Thomas was unable to attend the meeting, so her question was read out by the Leader, Councillor Clarke MBE.
Question from Councillor Thomas to Councillor Brennan.
Councillor Thomas was unable to attend the meeting, so her question was read out by the Leader, Councillor Clarke MBE.
As a member of the Task and Finish Group, Councillor Thomas agreed that this had been a very constructive process and stated that Fairham Parish Council would initially need to be supported, particularly by local Ward Councillors.
Councillor Thomas asked why Gamston SPD had not been selected for review. [name removed] said that the selection process was multi phased, incorporating the Council’s own risk registers alongside an understanding of key risks within the sector along with discussion with the Executive Management Team. He said that it was considered that the risk could be managed through existing controls and did not necessarily merit a full internal audit as there were ongoing assurances in place.
Councillor Thomas referred to the risk related to staff retention and asked whether the Council had any budgetary provision to deal with this, particularly in the LGR transition year. The Assistant Director for Finance said that the Council had an LGR reserve and whilst it had not been allocated to specific items as yet, staffing was a potential allocation in the future.
Councillor Thomas referred to an increase in risk for Gamston SPD and noted its impact on the five-year housing supply and GNSP and asked whether the mitigations in place were sufficient. The Communications and Customer Services Manager said that the Council was lobbying Government to review national policy and noted the difficulty in managing a site of this size and complexity and the associated impact on housing land supply.
Councillor Thomas thought that the Council needed to be ... view the full minutes text for item 32.
Councillor Thomas said that LGR had changed the risks faced by the Council and thought that this could have been an opportunity to reassess the risk strategy. The Chair said that in light of LGR the organisation needed to review its way of managing its risk register.
Councillor Thomas asked about membership of the Risk Management Group and the Assistant Director for Finance said that it was the Executive Management Team, in consultation with the Monitoring Officer.
Councillor Thomas asked about fees, including additional fees for events. The Head of Finance explained that these were annual fees for licences, being both a standard fee and also an enhanced fee which could be charged for circumstances which met certain triggers and required additional work by the Licensing Team, for example a large event with a large number of attendees.
Councillor Thomas asked about reference to wrong accounting under for the new standards. [name removed] said that this related to an investment property and the Head of Finance explained that it was an asset that the Council already had in its asset register that was then brought under the scope of IFRS16 and when added to the IFRS16 asset register it had not subsequently been removed as an investment property.
Councillor Thomas asked about risks to the Council’s reserves with LGR, including s106 and CIL funds and New Homes Bonus (NHB). The Head of Finance said that LGR was a complicated process and expected that this would be determined in the future. The Director for Finance and Corporate Services added that much of the NHB funding was earmarked for projects and thought that amounts would be small by the point of LGR.
Councillor Thomas asked about £25m Freeport seed funding for 25/26 and the Director for Finance and Corporate Services said that the seed capital was allocated for infrastructure projects to help ... view the full minutes text for item 15.
Councillor Thomas asked how much this risk amounted to and the Head of Finance said that this risk related to the possibility of a new facility in the Borough and that it could amount to around £200k per year dependent upon what the rent was set at. She said that the risk was deemed to be low but had been included on the risk register so that there was visibility on it.
Councillor Thomas asked about the reduction in NHB to yellow rather than green if there was ... view the full minutes text for item 16.
Councillor Thomas felt that the actions in the motion were insufficient, suggested that all Councillors should be involved in responding to Government planning consultations, and that she would be more interested in a proactive motion that looked at what Rushcliffe could do if it was forced to accept more housing.
Councillor Thomas questioned how the Council could accelerate the build out of existing strategic sites, identify more sites, and identify gaps which could be filled.
Question from Councillor Thomas to the Leader of the Council, Councillor Clarke MBE.
Councillor Thomas was unable to attend the meeting, so her question was read out by Councillor Clarke.
Councillor Thomas addressed the Group and explained briefly the complexity of developers providing affordable housing and the different government initiatives and schemes that have been rolled out across the Borough.
Councillor Thomas expressed the need for the Council to take the opportunity to ask questions of the process for delivering affordable housing. Following debate of both versions of the request, the Group agreed for the Councillors version of the request to come forward for scrutiny and for it to be programmed into the Growth and Development Scrutiny Group for 25 March 2026.
Councillor Thomas referred to the most cost effective option of a single unitary authority, questioned why it had been discounted for political reasons and felt that it should be reconsidered, because if implemented with a commitment to running local area committees, it could deliver for everyone.
Councillor Thomas was ... view the full minutes text for item 21.
Councillor Thomas advised that Equality, Diversity and Inclusion is reported annually to the Corporate Overview Group for consideration and comment.
Councillor Thomas asked a specific question relating to the Disabled Facilities Grant process and whether the actions raised related to officer practice or limitations of the automated system.
Councillor Thomas thanked the Mayor on behalf of the Leake Independent Group for his effective chairing of meetings and the thought provoking speakers that he had invited.
Question from Councillor Thomas to Councillor Inglis.
What criteria and consultation processes were used to ensure that all sites that would benefit from the tighter limit were included in the order?” Councillor Inglis thanked Cllr Thomas and was pleased that she recognised the work undertaken to include a measure in the revised PSPO in relation to the maximum number of dogs that could be walked in public places. The figure of six was consistent with other local authorities that had similar PSPOs and it was also referenced as a maximum figure in the statutory guidance for dog day care establishments. The RSPCA suggested limit of four was only in relation to commercial dog walkers and clearly exceeded Government guidance for the same activities.
There would be an opportunity to review the effectiveness of the PSPO over the next three years and Councillor Thomas could then look to provide further evidence at this time.
Councillor Thomas asked a supplementary question.
Councillor Thomas proposed the following amendment, which was seconded by Councillor Way, who reserved the right to speak.
Councillor Thomas felt there was a role for debate about important issues outside the direct responsibility of the Council, to allow Councillors to come to a joint view and agree to put pressure on other agencies regarding issues that concerned residents. She felt that more work was required on the proposed amendments and that it should be considered again by the Governance Scrutiny Group.
Question from Councillor Thomas to Councillor Brennan.
Councillor Thomas was unable to attend the meeting, so her question was read out by Councillor Brennan.
Councillor Thomas thanked Kath for her help and support over the years to the Leake Independent Group.
Councillor Thomas suggested that the Terms of Reference should take into account the ability to change the timetable, and to allow the Task and Finish Group to consider the timelines. The Monitoring Officer clarified that as a valid petition had been received, the Council had a statutory timetable to comply with, and it would be within the remit of the Task and Finish Group to amend the current proposed timetable, as appropriate.
Councillor Thomas asked for clarification around authorisations and the process for reporting of authorisations. The Monitoring Officer and Head of Chief Executive’s Department said that this was monitored both through the management of staff to ensure that they did not undertake work without appropriate authorisation and ensuring that relevant Officers undertook the required training, with a new training module being introduced at the beginning of October.
Councillor Thomas noted that the updates to the policy were not specified through track changes and the Monitoring Officer and Head of Chief Executive’s Department said that this was not done in part to keep the length of papers down. The chair suggested that changes could be highlighted to help identify them. It was RESOLVED that the Governance Scrutiny Group:
Councillor Thomas suggested that there may be benefit in appointing more than one, perhaps two or three, Independent Members to the Group. The Chair said that that could be something for review in the future and given that the current recommendation was to appoint one.
Questions to the Leader of the Council, Councillor Clarke MBE were submitted by Councillor Thomas, Councillor Jen Walker and Councillor Birch in relation to Exempt Item 8 on the agenda – Rushcliffe Carbon Offsetting Framework – Land Acquisition.
Supplementary questions to the Leader of the Council, Councillor Clarke MBE were asked by Councillor Thomas, Councillor Jen Walker and Councillor Birch.
Councillor Thomas presented her scrutiny request and explained the reasons for submitting it. She said that there were two main arms to the submission, one related to adapting existing housing and one related to adaptations in new homes being built. She noted that the Council was no longer going to top up the Disabled Facilities Grant (DFG) which would lead to increased waiting times for access to adapted housing.
Councillor Thomas presented her scrutiny request and explained the reasons for submitting it. She said that there were two main arms to the submission, one related to adapting existing housing and one related to adaptations in new homes being built. She noted that the Council was no longer going to top up the Disabled Facilities Grant (DFG) which would lead to increased waiting times for access to adapted housing.
Councillor C Thomas declared a non-pecuniary interest as Ward Councillor for application 23/02182/FUL and 24/00211/RELDEM and would remove herself from the discussion and vote for this item.
Councillor C Thomas left the Council Chamber to remove herself from the discussion and vote.
Councillor C Thomas rejoined the meeting.
Councillor D Mason moved to accept the recommendation to refuse the application, and this was seconded by Councillor C Thomas and the vote was carried.
Councillor Thomas stated that it was a good report but referred to paragraph 4.2 and to the change in terminology to use the term ‘reducing discretionary expenditure’ rather than ‘reducing wasteful spend’ and advised that those two things were completely different. She hoped going forward that if the new Government had different requirements, some of the barriers highlighted could be removed.
Councillor Thomas referred to the visibility of s106 to town and parish councils and the level of understanding ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Councillor C Thomas moved to accept the recommendation and approve the application with the additional condition and advisory note and this was seconded by Councillor J Chaplain and the vote was carried.
Councillor C Thomas moved to accept the recommendation and approve the application and this was seconded by Councillor R Walker and the vote was lost.
Question from Councillor Thomas to Councillor Virdi.
Councillor Thomas was unable to attend the meeting, so her question was read out by the Leader, Councillor Clarke.
“As the Business Rates relief offered to businesses on the Freeport will be subsidised by tax payers (through central government) what democratic involvement has there been in drawing up the policy to encourage particular types of businesses, for example companies with green and ethical track records, evidence of creation of jobs and exemplary employment practice, or in terms of the Ratcliffe LDO site, alignment with the principles of the Local Development Order?” Councillor Virdi thanked Councillor Thomas for her question and referred to the Cabinet report considered in February 2022, which all Members were sighted on, that had stated in the environmental implications that “the transformation of Ratcliffe on Soar Power Station from the production of coal-fired energy to other more sustainable forms of energy including Research and Development into clean energy will help the region’s plans to become carbon neutral and then net zero”. The same report had also stated “the development of Ratcliffe on ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
He felt that everyone should be working together to get the issue resolved, and it was not relevant if it was a Key Decision or not, as the priority was to ensure that management companies were regulated Question from Councillor Thomas to Councillor Upton “In Agenda Item 8 there is a proposal for the Council to acquire 50ha of land and maintain it for carbon sequestration, at an estimated maintenance cost over 15 years, including initial planting and replacement but not land purchase, of around £1M.
Councillor C Thomas declared a non-pecuniary interest as Ward Councillor for application 24/00050/TPO and would remove herself from the discussion and vote for this item.
Councillor C Thomas removed herself from the Committee and did not contribute to the discussion or vote on the following application.
Councillor C Thomas rejoined the meeting.
Councillor Calvert confirmed that he had been one of two Governance Scrutiny Group Members, together with Councillor Thomas, who had sat on the Working Group, which had considered amendments to Planning Committee arrangements.
Councillor Thomas echoed the concerns expressed by Councillor Calvert, advised that she had also not found any significant changes and welcomed the constructive process that had been undertaken for this review.
Councillor Thomas asked if it could be considered to make the West Bridgford Special Expenses and CIL Advisory Group a public meeting. The Director – Finance and Corporate Services agreed to take this back as an action.
In respect of grant fraud, Councillor Thomas raised the issue of targeted cold calling which caused residents to be suspicious and potentially missed out on grant funding. The Service Manager – Finance explained that residents could call the RCCC to verify the calls were genuine and [name removed] offered to provide samples of the properties that received the LAD3 grant funding.
Councillor Thomas joined the meeting to present the matrix for Accessible Housing. She said that this had arisen from budget discussion about the Disabled Facilities Grant and proposals for the Council to stop topping up the Central Government funding pot from its own funds. She noted that the £500k top up was a one-off amount which came from the Council’s sale of council houses.
Councillor Thomas expressed the view that the document felt like a box-ticking exercise. She felt that the consultation was too high-level, did not encourage engagement from Councillors and happened too late in the process and that the responses received appeared to have been ignored.
Councillor Thomas went on to highlight other aspects of the document that she felt were detrimental, such as its backward focus on achievements, that there were too many tasks in which the Council had limited control above setting its own goals, there was a lack of follow through relating to important Council initiatives such as increasing hedgerows, putting in requirements for solar panels on all new developments, making new homes more energy efficient, ... view the full minutes text for item 45.
Councillor Thomas asked a specific question in respect of S106 contributions not yet recognised as income due to conditions not yet being met and whether the Council’s Growth Boards had had a significant role in highlighting where there were potential issues. The Group were reminded that in the recent review of Growth Boards in some areas these had been removed. The Service Manager – Finance explained S106 contributions were held by other organisations such as Nottinghamshire County Council and that planning officers regularly liaise with the organisations who requested the contribution, as well as contacting beneficiaries where a contribution is nearing its expiry date.
Councillor Thomas asked why Rushcliffe Enterprises Account remains dormant and not closed and informed officers that the correspondence address requires updating to reflect the change in Monitoring Officer.
The Monitoring Officer presented the amendments to the constitution and reminded the Group that at the last meeting on 28 September 2023, the Group approved the creation of a Working Group to consider outstanding changes to the Council’s Constitution and nominated two members to sit on this Group, Councillor Calvert and Councillor Thomas.
Both Councillor Calvert and Councillor Thomas shared their experience with the Group. They felt the report overall was well drafted and approved the changes.
Councillor Thomas commented on the order in which speakers addressed the Committee as this was incorrect and asked the Monitoring Officer to check with planning officers.
Actions – 23 November 2023 Min No Action Officer Responsible 26 In relation to West Bridgford special Expenses and CIL Advisory Group, the Group asked for a historical list of annuity charges Service Manager – Finance 26 Councillor Thomas highlighted that the correspondence address for Rushcliffe Enterprises required updating with the current monitoring Officers details Monitoring Officer
Councillor Thomas moved for refusal of the application, against the officer recommendation.
Councillor Thomas suggested adding an opportunity risk related to the affordable housing capital in the budget and the Service Manager Corporate Services agreed to refer the suggestion back to the Group.
The Chair suggested that Councillors closer to Planning Committee would best fit to sit on the Working Group and Members of the Group agreed for their representatives to be Councillor Calvert and Councillor Thomas.
23 November 2023 · Internal Audit Progress Report · Annual Audit Completion Report 2022/23 · Statement of Accounts · Capital and Investment Strategy Update · Asset Management Plan · RIPA Review · Work Programme 22 February 2024 · Internal Audit Progress Report · Internal Audit Strategy · Risk Management Strategy · Risk Management – Update · Capital and Investment Strategy Update · External Annual Audit Plan · Annual Audit Letter and Value for Money Conclusion · Capital and Investment Strategy 2024/25 · Work Programme Page 77 · Agenda Item 9 xx June 2024 · Internal Audit Progress Report · Internal Audit Annual Report · Annual Fraud Report · Annual Governance Statement (AGS) · Capital and Investment Strategy Outturn · Constitution Update · Code of Conduct · Work Programme Actions – 28 September 2023 Min No Action Officer Responsible 16 In relation to hybrid main, the Group asked for information about how many email attachments were opened and why they were password protected Monitoring Officer 17 In relation to risk management, Councillor Thomas suggested adding an opportunity risk related to the affordable housing capital in the budget.
Question from Councillor Thomas to Councillor Virdi:
Councillor Thomas asked a supplementary question:
Councillor Thomas joined the meeting to present her matrix for Councillor diversity, recruitment and allowances. She explained that there are many barriers to becoming a Councillor including low incomes, childcare provision, students or the self-employed and part time workers, and how the Council may consider incentives or additional allowances such as childcare or loss of earnings allowances to help Councillors while attending Council meetings and business.
Councillor Thomas explained that there does not appear to be any mechanism for allowances and other support which needs to be publicised when recruiting Councillors. She added, the Council could look at alternative opportunities for virtual attendance at some of its meetings and training to help recruit a more diverse Council membership.
Councillor Thomas asked if there was anything further the Council could be doing to encourage diversity for Town and Parish Council’s also and asked how Rushcliffe compares with similar boroughs or districts and supported this be scrutinised during the next election cycle.
The following Notice of Motion was proposed by Councillor C Thomas and was seconded by Councillor S Mallender.
Council will include nitrogen fixing plants in future free plant schemes.” In moving the motion, Councillor Thomas stated that soil was the very stuff of life, a mixture of physical, chemical, and biological elements including minerals from rocks, organic matter from dead plants and animals, living organisms, air, and water.
Councillor Thomas advised that soil held three times as much carbon as the atmosphere, it reduced the risk of flooding by absorbing water and it delivered 95% of global food supplies; however, it was a limited resource under pressure from many factors.
Councillor Thomas referred to a 2019 report by the Environment Agency, which had highlighted that soil currently stored about ten billion tonnes of carbon, which was approximately equal to eighty years of annual UK greenhouse gas emissions.
Councillor Thomas stated that intensive agriculture had caused arable soils to lose about 40% to 60% of their organic carbon, and in England and Wales almost four million hectares of soil was at risk of compaction, over two million hectares of soil was at risk of erosion and the spread of some materials could give rise to 300,000 hectares being contaminated in the UK.
Councillor Thomas outlined the four actions set out in the motion and confirmed that the motion asked the Council to collectively recognise the importance of soil, the threat that it was under and to identify actions that could be taken.
Councillor Thomas asked a specific question in relation to the power station site, Freeport and Development Corporation projects and what are the likely financial regarding business rate income. The Director – Finance and Corporate Services advised that there is always a risk with any new project and that the Council’s expectations are that the closure of the power station would not have a detrimental effect on business rates as it is anticipated that the Freeport and development of this site would bring further business rate streams, however it was noted that this is difficult to predict or evaluate and such income is dependent on the speed at which the site becomes operational.
Part 4 – Standing Orders, Rules and Financial Regulations · Revisions to the timings of Planning Committee meetings · Revisions to the rules relating to public speaking at Planning Committee meetings · Revision to the rules relating to consultation on planning applications Prior to the Scrutiny Group meeting Councillor Thomas asked the Monitoring Officer if amendments could be made resulting from discussions at a recent Local Development Framework meeting in respect of amendments to the circumstances in which Certificates of Compliance must be considered by Planning Committee under Part 3 of the Constitution.
Councillor Thomas joined the meeting to present her matrix for Housing density in new housing sites. She said that housing site applications would come forward with an expected number of houses which often increased during the planning process, which was of concern to residents and impacted on the infrastructure available. She said that her proposal was to review how the initial housing numbers were determined and whether that process could be more robust.
Councillor Thomas referred to housing density being closely related to housing mix with bigger houses requiring more space, including how much open space was provided on the estate. She referred to Government proposals that housi ng density should be looked at in terms of existing housing density in the area, which would lead to replication of housing mix rather than a wider diversity. She said that a broadbrush approach may not provide the best housing mix and that it was important to make best and most efficient use of each piece of land.
Councillor Thomas presented her matrix for Management of ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Councillor C Thomas as the previous Ward Councillor for this application declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 22/01468/REM and would not take part in the discussion and vote for this item.
Councillor Thomas declared a non-pecuniary interest as a Ward Councillor in application 22/00319/FUL and would remove herself from the discussion and vote for this item.
Councillor Thomas removed herself from the meeting for this item.
A copy of a plan highlighting views from various locations on the site was circulated at the meeting In accordance with the Council’s Public Speaking Protocol for Planning Committee, [name removed] (on behalf of the Applicant), [name removed] (objector) and Councillor Thomas (Ward Councillor) addressed the Committee.
Councillor Thomas re-joined the meeting.
Councillor R Mallender and Councillor Thomas advised that their Groups would be supporting the recommendation.
Councillor Jones and Councillor Thomas informed Council that their Groups would be supporting the recommendation.
The Mayor advised that again given the time and as there were four motions, she would be reducing the time for speeches from 10 minutes to five minutes for the mover of the motion, and three minutes for the responder. a) The following Notice of Motion was proposed by Councillor Thomas and seconded by Councillor Way.
Council further commits to investigate ways that Rushcliffe could change the existing arrangements for recent new estates affected by the current policy.” In moving the motion, Councillor Thomas stated that many residents living on new estates in the Borough had to pay a development company directly for the management of public open spaces in their community, in addition to their Council Tax. Those additional sums were often way beyond the anticipated charge for cutting the grass and could also include future liability for capital works such as play areas and drainage ponds.
Councillor Thomas reported that a third of homes in her ward of Leake were now subject to those additional charges.
Councillor Thomas advised that unfortunately, residents on new estates often mistakenly believed that those payments meant that local open spaces and play areas were exclusively for the use of residents that paid those additional charges, and this could lead to conflict between local residents and perceived visitors. Local residents paid for maintenance, litter collection and dog fouling, so it seemed logical to them that the facilities were for their use solely.
Councillor Thomas stated that Section 106 Agreements differed significantly across different developments with a number of models in operation across the Borough and argued that despite the decision to move to this system being taken in good faith, it was not working and would lead to further problems in the future.
Councillor Thomas outlined three alternative options described in the motion and asked the Council to commit to undertaking this work before April 2024, to ensure there was a better solution in place for new estates attracting residents ... view the full minutes text for item 61.
Councillor Thomas joined the meeting to present her matrix for Council Tax options for empty homes. She explained that the budget briefing session had included a session on reducing the period for applying the empty homes premium from twenty four to twelve months and that discussions had included reference to a variety of factors such as including furnished and unfurnished properties, derelict homes and probate. She said that the proposals had referred to the financial impact but thought that the social impact also needed to be included.
Councillor Thomas noted that Officers had suggested reviewing the Empty Homes Strategy but had concern that this would only review what the Council was already doing and not what it was not doing. She said that the Strategy did not include derelict homes or furnished homes that were empty for long periods of time. She wanted to understand the fuller picture, including what was discretionary in terms of premiums and discounts.
Councillor Thomas supported the scrutiny item as revised by officers but asked that her original lines of enquiry be included in the scope, including the possibilities from section 76 of the Levelling Up Bill, to provide a wider understanding of who paid Council Tax, who could receive a waiver, what discounts and premiums were available and what powers the council had available to it, to examine the data and look at the impact from a social context. She thought that the Council did a good job but relied on empty homes being reported to it.
The Group thought that including the original submission along with the additional information requested by Councillor Thomas and the Empty Homes Strategy in the review would form a reasonable recommendation. The Chairman suggested that the item be titled a Review of Empty Homes Strategy including Council Tax and the Group agreed that ... view the full minutes text for item 29.
Councillor Thomas confirmed that the Leake Independent Group would be supporting the motion.
b) Question from Councillor Thomas to Councillor Moore “How much unspent money in total is currently being held by Rushcliffe as contributions from housing and other developers via Section 106 and CIL (Community Infrastructure Levy)?” Councillor Moore responded by stating that the up-to-date figure was as follows, for CIL £2,787,853.69 was held, of which £54,884 was committed or allocated and for Section 106, £39,476,585.23 was held, of which £12.3m was committed or allocated.
Supplementary Question Councillor Thomas stated that this meant that Rushcliffe was holding over £40m, which was unspent and noted that it was inevitable that spending would lag behind development; however, there came a point when that was unacceptable and she felt that the Council should be encouraging its partners, such as the County Council to spend the money to bring forward projects, to provide those much needed facilities.
Councillor C Thomas declared a non-pecuniary interest for application 22/01639/FUL as a member of the Crematorium member working group, but considered that she was not bias and pre-determined and would consider the application with an open mind, therefore could take part in the discussion and vote for this item.
Question from Councillor Thomas to Councillor Brennan “What progress has been made in implementing the council motions adopted on Quieter Fireworks (March 20), Protection of Hedgehogs (July 21) and Reducing use of Pesticides (March 2022)?” Councillor Brennan responded by stating that a briefing note had been prepared, which would be sent to all Councillors next week on the actions taken as a result of all supported Council motions and questions in 2021/22. However, in the ... view the full minutes text for item 38.
Councillor Thomas, on behalf of the Independent Group, added to the vote of thanks and highlighted that Councillor S Mallender had set an excellent example for sustainable travel options in carrying out the Mayoral role.
The comments made by Councillor Robinson were echoed by Councillor Walker, on behalf of the Labour Group; Councillor Jones, on behalf of the Liberal Democrat Group; Councillor R Mallender on behalf of the Green Group and Councillor Thomas on behalf of the Leake Independent Group.
Councillor Thomas said that ... view the full minutes text for item 13.
As Ward Councillor for East Leake , Councillor C Thomas removed herself from the meeting and did not take part in the following discussions or votes on the first two items.
Councillor Thomas advised that the Independent Group would be supporting the recommendation, but not because the Council Tax would be the cheapest in the county.
The following Notice of Motion was proposed by Councillor Thomas and seconded by Councillor R Mallender.
Call on the government to strengthen national planning policies relating to solar power generation and energy efficiency in new buildings so that this does not rely on local policies.” Councillor Thomas informed Council, in moving the motion, that in line with the Local Plan, the Council was providing development sites for new housing and employment for the Nottingham area. Council noted the vision of each new housing estate having the potential to become a mini power station by design, with solar power generation in mind. Newer technologies would also provide ways for other building materials to generate electricity.
Councillor Thomas stated that the required infrastructure to link to the grid and provide battery storage could efficiently be added during the build, whilst at the same time, building design could maximise energy efficiency to reduce the energy each new home consumes. Unfortunately, none of this was happening because it was not a planning requirement, and the objective of developers was, understandably, to maximise the profit for their stakeholders not improve energy efficiency or electricity generation for longer term benefit.
Councillor Thomas went on to highlight that in the meantime Rushcliffe’s green fields were being identified as locations for huge solar farms, to generate profit for a different group of developers. There was no question that this country needed to develop renewable energy sources, but it was also possible to build solar farms that sat well in the landscape without disrupting residents and the environment. Regrettably, if badly designed, these could also be obtrusive, ugly, disruptive, and damaging to wildlife, habitats, and biodiversity.
Councillor Thomas stated that resolving this issue ... view the full minutes text for item 60.
Question from Councillor Thomas to Councillor Edyvean.
Councillor Thomas was unable to attend the meeting, so her question was read out by the Chairman.
Question from Councillor Thomas to Councillor Robinson.
Councillor Thomas was unable to attend the meeting, so her question was read out by the Chairman.
Councillor C Thomas declared an interest as Ward Councillor on application 21/00804/CTY.
Councillor J Walker, Councillor Jones, Councillor R Mallender and Councillor Thomas all supported the recommendation in the report.
Councillor Gray, Councillor Jones, Councillor R Mallender and Councillor Thomas all supported the recommendation in the report.
Councillor Howitt, Councillor R Mallender and Councillor Thomas all supported the recommendations in the report.
Question from Councillor Thomas to Councillor Edyvean.
Councillor Thomas was unable to attend the meeting, so her question was read out by the Chairman.
Councillor C Thomas declared an interest as Ward Councillor on application 21/00804/CTY.
It was suggested that Councillor Thomas would receive answers to her questions in the scrutiny matrix in the short term as the item was not due to be scrutinised by the Growth and Development Scrutiny Group until October 2022.
Question from Councillor Thomas to Councillor Brennan.
Councillor Thomas was unable to attend the meeting, so her question was read out by the Vice-chairman.
Councillor Thomas asked a supplementary ... view the full minutes text for item 29.
Question from Councillor Thomas to Councillor Moore “ The CIL charge includes amounts collected for Leisure Centres and Playing Fields, which are held by Rushcliffe to be spent by Rushcliffe.
Supplementary question Councillor Thomas asked what the identified funding gaps for each of the five items on the CIL infrastructure list were.
Councillor Moore agreed to forward that information to Councillor Thomas.
a) Question from Councillor Thomas to Councillor Moore “ Please provide a statement showing how much CIL has been collected since introduction of the levy in October 2019, how much has been distributed (itemised by town, parish, West Bridgford etc) and what has been spent on the five items on the Infrastructure List (which includes playing fields and leisure centres), giving a description and location of each project.” Councillor Moore informed Councillor Thomas that information had been pulled together by officers and that she could collect that after the meeting.
CIL Admin (5%) £51,229.43 Strategic CIL £815,402.13 East Bridgford NCIL (15%) £626.22 (with £634.10* distributed to the parish council) Keyworth NCIL (25%) £12,514.15 (with £3,212.57* distributed to the parish council) Kneeton NCIL (15%, capped) £2,500.00 West Bridgford NCIL (15%) £63,604.64 Supplementary question Councillor Thomas asked if it was true that £20million was currently held by the Borough Council and remained unspent.
Cllr Thomas declared a non-pecuniary interest for item 3 on the basis that she is a Borough ward Councillor for East Leake .
Land and Planning Policies (2019).] As Ward Councillor for the following application, Councillor C Thomas removed herself from the meeting and did not take part in the following discussion.
Updates In accordance with the Council’s Public Speaking Protocol for Planning Committee Councillor C Thomas (Ward Councillor) addressed the Committee.
Question from Councillor Thomas to Councillor Brennan.
Councillor Thomas asked a supplementary question to Councillor Brennan.
As Ward Councillor for Leake , Councillor Carys Thomas removed herself from the meeting and did not take part in the following discussion.
“a suitable means of access can be provided to the development without detriment to the amenity of adjacent properties or highway safety and the provision of parking is in accordance with advice provided by the Highways Authority;" As Ward Councillor for the following application, Councillor C Thomas removed herself from the meeting and did not take part in the following discussion.
In accordance with the Council’s public speaking protocol for planning committee, Helen Dawkins (Applicant), Lloyd King and Cllr L Taylor (Objectors who split their allocated 5 minutes), and Councillor C Thomas (Ward Councillor) addressed the Committee.
Councillor Thomas expressed her misgivings in regard to this project and asked the Chief Executive to ensure a number of review points were included in the project plans, to enable the Council to withdraw in the future if the initiative was no longer beneficial to the Borough.
Councillor Thomas reported that she would have preferred to see no increase in Councillor numbers but was more interested in the next stage of the process where she hoped the opportunity to influence the drawing of ward boundaries that better respected community identity would be offered.
Question from Councillor Thomas to Councillor Inglis “Parking enforcement staff are very rarely seen in East Leake despite ongoing resident concerns about highway obstruction and infringements in the parking bays with time limits.
Councillor Thomas thanked the officers for their detailed work to update the Policy.
Councillor Thomas noted that previous motions had been discussed at Council meetings regarding commercialisation and requests for more funding, which were politically motivated and stated that all of the Councillors should be working together for the benefit of residents.
b) Question from Councillor Thomas to Councillor Upton “Various agencies are consulted on individual planning applications with regard to infrastructure such as roads, drainage, and sewerage.
Comments Councillor Thomas requested a recorded vote for this item, which was taken as follows:
Question from Councillor Thomas to Councillor Upton “In light of government proposals to reduce the opportunities for consultation on planning applications, how is the Council ensuring that residents fully understand that the options for growth identified in the Greater Nottingham Strategic Plan consultation could lead to huge areas for development being allocated on their doorsteps?” Councillor Upton responded by confirming that the current Growth Options consultation for the Greater Nottingham Strategic Plan has been publicised as widely as is possible, subject to national restrictions on activities during the pandemic. All statutory consultees, local stakeholders and others whose details were held by the Councils have been contacted directly. There has been extensive use of social media to publicise the consultation.
Councillor Thomas asked a supplementary question to Councillor Upton.
Councillor Thomas reiterated the comments made by Councillor Jones and queried if developers were notifying officers when trigger points where met, which required work to be undertaken. That was particularly important when developments where passed over to management companies and residents, who might be charged if works were not completed. Although the proactive monitoring of developments over 50 dwellings was welcomed , it would be helpful if that 50 dwellings limit could be reduced.
Councillor Thomas commented on behalf of Councillor Way, who echoed the comments made by previous Councillors regarding the benefits of on-line meetings and welcomed the start-up of the service in East Leake .
Councillor Thomas, on behalf of the Independent Group, extended her thanks to the Mayor for the wonderful contribution she had made during her Mayoral year and wished her well for the future. She had been delighted to see the Mayor at the Normanton on Soar Fete last summer, when the Mayor had engaged with so many people and looked to be thoroughly enjoying the event.
Question from Councillor Thomas to Councillor Edyvean.
Councillor Thomas asked a supplementary question to Councillor Edyvean.
As a ward Councillor for East Leake, Councillor Carys Thomas withdrew from the meeting and did not take part in the following discussion.
In accordance with the Council’s public speaking protocol Councillor Carys Thomas (Ward Councillor) addressed the Committee.
Councillor Thomas stated that the main concern of the Independent Group was that the Development Corporation would be subject to delay and the Council was urged to continue to work closely with Uniper regarding the future development of the power station site.
Councillor Thomas confirmed that the Independent Group was happy to support the recommendation and congratulated all those involved.
Councillor Thomas confirmed that the Independent Group supported the recommendation. ... view the full minutes text for item 43.
Councillor Thomas confirmed that the Independent Group supported the recommendation and passed on its congratulations to all those involved in producing the Plan.
Councillor Thomas advised that the Independent Group would be unable to support the Strategy for the following reasons. The document had insufficient measures to combat climate change, the lack of a five-year housing supply and its associated impact had not been addressed, as had the housing needs of the elderly and specific issues related to the New Homes Bonus for East Leake and other areas. Section 106 Contributions were not used quickly enough, whilst Borough assets were being sold.
Councillor Thomas welcomed the report and referred to the importance of being proactive when spending funds locally. In non-parished areas where the Council retained control of income, it was important that the local communities were fully consulted on potential spending.
Councillor Thomas confirmed that although the Independent Group had previously raised some issues regarding the Plan that had been taken through representations the Independent Group was now in support of its adoption.
Councillor Thomas stated that before becoming a Councillor she had spoken using the Citizens’ Questions procedure and stressed the importance of having that opportunity. The Independent Group welcomed the adoption of the procedure and she thanked officers for the support and guidance she had received when she had submitted questions and stressed the importance of maintaining that support in the future.
Question from Councillor C Thomas to Councillor A Edyvean.
Councillor C Thomas asked a supplementary question to Councillor A Edyvean.
Councillor C Thomas declared an interest in application 19/00323/FUL and advised that she would withdraw from the meeting during this item.
Councillor Thomas thanked the retiring Mayor for everything she had done for the Borough during her year of office.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Thomas attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
Meetings Councillor Thomas was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 8 of 19 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Thomas declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 Oct 2024 | Planning Committee, item 13 | Councillor C Thomas declared a non-pecuniary interest as Ward Councillor for application 23/02182/FUL and 24/00211/RELDEM and would remove herself from the discussion and vote for this item. | |
| 11 Apr 2024 | Planning Committee, item 36 | Councillor C Thomas declared a non-pecuniary interest as Ward Councillor for application 24/00050/TPO and would remove herself from the discussion and vote for this item. | |
| 9 Mar 2023 | Planning Committee, item 36 | Councillor Thomas declared a non-pecuniary interest as a Ward Councillor in application 22/00319/FUL and would remove herself from the discussion and vote for this item. | |
| 13 Oct 2022 | Planning Committee, item 17 | Councillor C Thomas declared a non-pecuniary interest for application 22/01639/FUL as a member of the Crematorium member working group, but considered that she was not bias and pre-determined and would consider the application with an open mind, therefore could take part in the discussion and vote for this item. | |
| 9 Dec 2021 | Planning Committee, item 18 | Councillor C Thomas declared an interest as Ward Councillor on application 21/00804/CTY. | |
| 11 Nov 2021 | Planning Committee, item 15 | Councillor C Thomas declared an interest as Ward Councillor on application 21/00804/CTY. | |
| 10 Jun 2021 | Planning Committee, item 20 | Cllr Thomas declared a non-pecuniary interest for item 3 on the basis that she is a Borough ward Councillor for East Leake . | |
| 13 Jun 2019 | Planning Committee, item 47 | Councillor C Thomas declared an interest in application 19/00323/FUL and advised that she would withdraw from the meeting during this item. |
Where Councillor Thomas sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2014 | 87 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | May 2019 | 41 | 3 Dec 2026 |
| Governance Scrutiny Group | Committee Member | Jun 2023 | 14 | 26 Nov 2026 |
| Growth and Development Scrutiny Group | Committee Member | Aug 2020 | 1 | |
| Communities Scrutiny Group | Committee Member | Jan 2024 | 1 | |
| Licensing Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2025 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.