Declarations of Interest
Councillor T Birch declared a non-pecuniary interest as the Ward Councillor for Cropwell for application 26/01498/REG3 and would remove himself from the discussion and vote during this item.
Every time Rushcliffe's minutes name Councillor Birch, as the council published it.
Councillor T Birch declared a non-pecuniary interest as the Ward Councillor for Cropwell for application 26/01498/REG3 and would remove himself from the discussion and vote during this item.
Councillor T Birch removed himself from the Committee and did not contribute to the discussion or vote on the following application.
21 26/01498/REG3 - Creation of additional off street parking spaces - Land East Of 136 Hoe View Road, Cropwell Bishop, Nottinghamshire Updates In accordance with the Council’s Public Speaking Protocol for Planning Committee, Councillor T Birch (Ward Councillor) addressed the Committee.
DECISION PLANNING PERMISSION BE GRANTED SUBJECT TO THE CONDITIONS SET OUT IN THE REPORT PUBLISHED WITH THE AGENDA Councillor T Birch rejoined the meeting.
Councillor T Birch declared a non-pecuniary interest for application 25/01484/FUL and would remove himself from the discussion and vote during this item.
Councillor Birch agreed that there had been regional funding and investment through EMCCA, although he agreed ... view the full minutes text for item 35.
Councillor R Walker moved to reject the recommendation on the grounds that the balance of public amenity benefit outweighed the health and safety concerns of the tree at this time and this was seconded by Councillor T Birch and the vote was carried.
Notice of motion to be proposed by Councillor Birch and seconded by Councillor Chewings.
The Mayor stated that he had been advised that Councillor Birch wished to alter his motion, and asked Councillor Birch to confirm that.
Councillor Birch confirmed that he wished to propose the following altered motion:
Councillor Birch proposed his original motion as follows:
Councillor Birch stated that this motion was not an allegation of misconduct against any Councillor, or that anyone had broken any rules, nor was it about naming and shaming individuals, as throughout his discussions with colleagues and officers over the past six months, he had been concerned if the current rules still commanded public confidence. He believed that there was a difference between something being allowed and something being appropriate, and referred to the Parliamentary expenses scandal in 2009, which had highlighted that the vast majority of claims made had been within the rules.
Councillor Birch clarified that he was not comparing Rushcliffe with Westminster; however, some parallels existed, with the Council writing its own Councillor Expenses Scheme, just as Parliament had then, and despite having an independent advisory board, the Council was not obliged to ... view the full minutes text for item 22.
a) Question from Councillor Birch to The Leader, Councillor Clarke MBE.
The Mayor asked Councillor Birch if he had a supplementary question.
The Mayor ruled on the supplementary question by Councillor Birch and it was rephrased and put as:
Councillor Birch thanked the Mayor for his service and wished him well for the future.
Question from Councillor Birch to Councillor Upton.
Before reading out his question, Councillor Birch asked to make a statement, which the Chair did not allow.
Councillor Birch read out his question.
Councillor Birch asked ... view the full minutes text for item 63.
The following notice of motion was proposed by Councillor Birch and seconded by Councillor Chewings.
Prior to presenting the motion, Councillor Birch informed the Mayor that he wished to make an amendment to the motion to refer to Council-owned and operated premises, and to clarify the referral process to scrutiny.
After outlining this alteration, consent was given by the meeting and Councillor Birch proceeded to move the following motion. Council therefore resolves to:
In moving the motion, Councillor Birch stated that he had brought this motion for two reasons, an element referring to Rushcliffe itself, and a wider, ideological debate. He stated that cash was vital for a liberal democracy and it was inclusive, given that some communities disproportionately used cash more than others, particularly the elderly. It was also important to mitigate against systems failures by having the option to take cash payments.
Councillor Birch referred to the issue of fairness and confidence, with people on low income relying on cash more and the motion was asking for good housekeeping, as detailed above. Turning to the wider debate, he felt that losing cash gave inordinate power to faceless corporations and the state, and it was important to keep cash, to retain privacy, as digital transactions could be monitored, and to ensure resilience. He stated that cash was a technology currency, allowing people to physically see their outgoings and it helped trades people and small businesses.
Councillor Birch stated that voting for the motion was the kind and humane thing to do, helping elderly and disadvantaged residents and as a democratic institution, the Council had a duty to act against the ‘creep’ of digital currency.
Councillor Virdi thanked Councillor Birch for bringing forward the motion, recognising his genuine concerns; however, he felt that the motion failed to reflect the current position, with it suggesting that residents risked being excluded from Council services, which was not the case. He confirmed that cash was accepted across a number of Council services and locations, with cash payments for bills still accepted. The Council had adapted specific services, which supported digital payments, including leisure centres, with this model adopted during Covid, together with around 99% of Council Tax payments made digitally.
Question from Councillor Birch to Councillor Upton.
Councillor Birch was unable to attend the meeting, so his question was read out by the Leader of the Council, Councillor Clarke MBE.
The following notice of motion was proposed by Councillor Birch and seconded by Councillor Chewings.
In moving the motion, Councillor Birch felt that these were sensible actions, and in respect of potential concerns regarding sanctions, which he shared, particularly around suspensions, the report stated that this would only be for the most egregious cases, and he hoped that everyone would endorse this.
Councillor Birch thanked everyone for supporting the motion and he agreed with Councillor Way. He stated that he had been shocked at some of the behaviour that had been levelled at him and his family during the 2023 election by a member of Cabinet and the lack of action taken by the Conservative Association. He stated that this was why the Code of Conduct needed to be followed and that the current standards system was not fit for purpose.
Councillor Birch thanked Councillor Fletcher for his service, advised that he had family members who were veterans and was aware of the challenges veterans faced daily. He felt that as a country, veterans should be given far more respect, thanked officers and confirmed that his Group would ... view the full minutes text for item 22.
Councillor Ellis moved to reject the recommendation and refuse permission on the grounds of insufficient parking, access and safety issues and the displacement parking on neighbouring streets, this was seconded by Councillor Birch. The vote concluded in 5 for, 5 against and 1 abstention. The Chair had the casting vote and the vote was not carried.
The Head of Finance advised the Group that the question raised by Councillor Birch at the previous meeting in February had been resolved.
Councillor A Brown moved to reject the recommendation and refuse the application and this was seconded by Councillor T Birch and the vote was carried.
Councillor Birch was concerned about tax communication to residents and felt that Rushcliffe should be communicating more clearly what each council was responsible for and requested that his vote against this be recorded.
Councillor Birch voted against the recommendation.
Councillor Birch expressed concern about limiting the scope of motions as he felt that this helped Councillors represent their constituents better, was educational and allowed democratic debate.
Councillor Birch asked for information about Co2 emissions from Bingham Arena. The Head of Finance said that she would feedback this request.
Councillor Birch asked about the risk to investments and whether the Council had received any advice about the impact of geopolitical events. The Head of Finance confirmed that global events did impact on interest rates and said that Advisors looked at the wider economic environment and gave advice based on events taking place, such as advice about making investments, with constant monitoring taking place.
Councillor Birch said that he thought that opposition Councillors required tools to be able to provide scrutiny of the ruling Group and thought that recorded votes were a part of that. He said that opposition groups were disadvantaged and had the odds stacked against them and said that the proposal in relation to recorded votes was counter to democracy and transparency.
Councillor Birch asked whether the Council had time limits for completion of complaints. The Monitoring Officer confirmed that there set time periods for completion of the different stages of the complaints procedure. She confirmed that the amendment did not change the right for members of the public to complain to the Ombudsman, only that they would need to go through the Council’s formal complaints procedure first as required by the Ombudsman.
Councillor Birch asked for information about Co2 emissions from Bingham Arena Head of Finance to check if the information was available 37.
Question from Councillor Birch to Councillor Virdi.
“How does this Conservative-led Council justify a 2.46% rise in Council Tax on hard working residents when, as a whole, Rushcliffe's residents pay higher overall Council Tax than 95% of councils in the UK, the majority of which is forced on them by the Conservative-led County Council?” Councillor Virdi thanked Councillor Birch for his question and confirmed that the budget only concerned the Rushcliffe element of Council Tax and had nothing to do with Nottinghamshire County Council. The key point was that Rushcliffe remained within the lowest 25% nationally for district and borough councils for the Council Tax it levied; and remained the lowest in Nottinghamshire in comparison to the other borough or district councils.
He stated that increasing Council Tax was therefore a necessity, with the increase being less than 8p per week and questioned what services Councillor Birch would look to reduce if the Council did not increase Council Tax?
Councillor Birch raised a supplementary question; however, it was rejected by the Chair, on the basis that it did not arise directly from the reply, nor relate to the original question.
Question from Councillor Birch to Inglis.
Councillor Birch asked a supplementary question to Councillor Inglis.
Councillor Birch declared an interest in Item 15d Notices of Motion.
Councillor Birch questioned the accuracy of the minutes and asked that his vote against them be recorded.
Councillor Birch welcomed [name removed] and stated that he had been impressed since becoming a Councillor on how well the Council was run and thanked Kath for her help and assistance and wished her luck.
Councillor Birch supported the motion, which was designed to improve public safety and empower the Police and it was noted that this issue caused other problems, not just safety concerns, with current legislation needing to be strengthened, and the deterrent effect of this would make it worthwhile.
Councillor Birch referred to the enhancement ... view the full minutes text for item 24.
Questions to the Leader of the Council, Councillor Clarke MBE were submitted by Councillor Thomas, Councillor Jen Walker and Councillor Birch in relation to Exempt Item 8 on the agenda – Rushcliffe Carbon Offsetting Framework – Land Acquisition.
Supplementary questions to the Leader of the Council, Councillor Clarke MBE were asked by Councillor Thomas, Councillor Jen Walker and Councillor Birch.
Question from Councillor Birch to Councillor Brennan.
Councillor Birch was unable to attend the meeting, so his question was read out by the Leader.
She took no part in the debate a) The following Notice of Motion was proposed by Councillor Birch and seconded by Councillor Chewings.
Prior to presenting her motion, Councillor Birch informed the Mayor that he wished to make an alteration to the motion using Standing Order Paragraph 4.58.
After outlining the alteration, consent was given by the Council and Councillor Birch proceeded to move the motion.
By adopting this motion, we call on Nottinghamshire County Council, and central government, to recognize the urgency of the situation and to take decisive action to enhance the quality and effectiveness of SEND provision.” In moving the motion, Councillor Birch advised that the Rushcliffe Independents were launching a Nottinghamshire SEND Improvement Campaign, with a petition being launched asking the County Council to undertake a number of measures.
Councillor Birch highlighted what SEND included, as well as how a child could receive support, including an Education Health Care Plan (EHCP), and advised that there was a 20 weeks statutory time frame to receive a Plan once it had been requested. Currently the national average response rate was 50%; however, in 2022, the response rate at the County Council was 4.5%. Council was advised that a SEND Improvement Board had been set up by the County Council in 2023, following an Inspection by OFSTED and the Care Quality Commission, which had highlighted systemic failures.
Councillor Birch commented on a fraud investigation at Gedling Borough Council and asked if Rushcliffe could learn anything from this. The Director – Finance and Corporate Services advised the fraud investigation at Gedling was a long-term case and explained mitigation controls are in place, but they are not a guarantee that fraud won’t happen.
Councillor Chewings thanked officers but advised that he and Councillor Birch would not be supporting the report for the same reasons as aired at the Council meeting in March. He felt that efficiencies were cuts, the significant increase in parking revenue was effecting both residents and businesses, and the reductions in funding to public conveniences could not be supported. Whilst acknowledging that there was uncertainty and long standing issues regarding funding, he hoped that with the new Government in place things would change for the better.
a) The following notice of motion was proposed by Councillor Birch and seconded by Councillor Chewings.
Write to HM Government to request a change in our voting system from first past the post to proportional representation.” Councillor Birch requested a recorded vote and referred to the importance of this issue, given that the recent General Election had been the most unrepresentative since 1928, with 58% of the votes cast being totally unrepresented, which was unacceptable.
Councillor Birch stated that this could not be called a true democracy when the voting results did not reflect the will of the electorate, and the current First Past the Post (FPTP) system should be replaced by Proportional Representation (PR).
Councillor Birch reiterated that results in the recent General Election had been greatly distorted, with the largest party having its votes exaggerated, with smaller parties marginalised. He also shared details of the 2015 General Election results in Belfast South, when the winning party had only received 25% of the vote, which he considered an afront to democratic principles and confirmed that the current voting system was not fit for purpose.
Councillor Birch also referred to the results in the 2019 Rushcliffe Borough Council Election and how unfair they had been, with that reflected across the country. He questioned why the current system was defended and whilst acknowledging that there were some reasonable defences of it, he considered that the disadvantages far outweighed any benefits.
Councillor Birch stated that there was considerable misinformation surrounding PR and advised that there was evidence to show that it had worked very well in many countries throughout western Europe since World War II. It usually produced strong, stable, coalition governments, which on average lasted longer than majority governments formed under FPTP.
Councillor Birch stated that citizens in those countries also reported greater satisfaction with their political system, with voter turnout measurably higher.
Reference was made to ongoing political instability in Italy, and Councillor Birch stated that this was not due to its use of PR, but rather to the very well-known regional, cultural and political differences experienced there, and he felt that Italy should therefore not be used as an example.
Councillor Birch referred to concerns that PR would lead to a break down in the ... view the full minutes text for item 22.
Councillor Birch commented on the late invoice payments at the Crematorium, noted that although it was not a huge risk, one invoice had been paid nearly five months late and questioned if there were clear terms on the contracts, and incentives to ensure timely payment.
Councillor Birch felt that given this was a relatively new service, it was important to have appropriate mechanisms in place to ensure timely payments. [name removed] confirmed that there was a 21 day credit period on ... view the full minutes text for item 3.
Councillor Birch asked which body set the fee, and [name removed] advised that the Council had opted into a framework appointment by Public Sector Audit Appointments (PSAA), which ran a contracting round, and bid and allocated pieces of work to different firms. As part of that process, PSAA determined a scale fee, to deliver the entire contract, which resulted in a level of subsidy. The Director – Finance and Corporate Services advised that the public sector audit market was currently in a challenging state, and was a high risk market, and there were issues recruiting auditors, and all that led to a degree of pressure.
Question from Councillor Birch to Councillor Upton.
Councillor Birch was unable to attend the meeting, so his question was read out by the Leader, Councillor Clarke.
Councillor Birch had submitted a supplementary question to Councillor Upton, which was read out by the Leader.
Updates In accordance the Council’s Public Speaking Protocol for Planning Committee [name removed] (Applicants Agent), [name removed] (Chair – Tythby and Wiverton Parish Meeting) and Councillor T Birch (Ward Councillor).
Question from Councillor Birch to Councillor Inglis “The basis for the recommendations in the 'Bingham Car Parking Project Update' report is the data accrued by traffic data collection company, ITP . The methodology they used to obtain their data consisted solely of 'in person' surveys of car park users.
Councillor Birch asked a supplementary question to Councillor Inglis.
With regard to the Country Park, Councillor Birch asked officers to explain why receipts hadn’t been provided for payment of services. [name removed] advised that this was a low level recommendation and referred to payments received for activities on the day, adding that these were documented on a spreadsheet for audit purposes, however a customer receipt had not been provided.
In accordance with the Council’s Public Speaking Protocol for Planning Committee, [name removed] (Applicants Agent) and Councillor T Birch (Ward Councillor) addressed the Committee.
b) Question from Councillor Birch to the Leader, Councillor Clarke Was an offer made by the Conservative-led Rushcliffe Borough Council administration in 2019 to take the proposed Butt Field car park site from Bingham Town Council by either a land swap, or by accepting a land transfer from Bingham Town Council?
The Mayor asked if Councillor Birch had a supplementary question.
Councillor Birch asked if this Council would please write and publish an open letter to the residents of Bingham and the surrounding villages that it served explaining precisely what the Rushcliffe Borough Council Conservative administration has done to attempt to fix the car parking problems in Bingham from 2011 to the present day?
Councillor Birch commented on the valuation of assets and asked what measures are in place to assure members that officer valuations are accurate. [name removed] explained that valuation of assets is a significant risk area based on assumptions, expectations and benchmarking and due to the high degree of estimation uncertainty this has been determined as a significant risk. The Director – Finance and Corporate Services informed the Group that valuations are undertaken by a senior officer and overseen by the Director – Growth and Economic Development and finance also review the valuations, in particular ... view the full minutes text for item 25.
Councillor Birch asked a specific question relating to the transfer of reserves from the New Homes Bonus (NHB) to offset the Minimum Revenue Provision (MRP) charges in relation to the capital cost of the Arena and Cotgrave Master plan, and whether this would have any impact on the building of new and affordable homes. The Service Manager – Finance explained that the NHB is not ringfenced for housing and the Council is free to use the NHB how we choose to help facilitate growth within the Borough.
Councillor Birch asked a specific question in relation to Business Rates collection and highlighted the Ratcliffe on Soar power station being a large contributor and whether any future development at the site had been secured. The Service Manager – Finance explained the loss of the power station business rates have been calculated and new models are being worked on. With regards to future development at the site the Group were advised this is still unknown.
Question from Councillor Birch to Councillor Clarke.
Councillor Birch did not attend the meeting, so his question was read out by the Chair, Councillor Clarke.
Question from Councillor Birch to Councillor Clarke.
The Mayor asked if Councillor Birch had a supplementary question.
Councillor Birch asked the Leader to justify to tax payers why it was necessary to spend £954 on an overnight stay for three people before giving a presentation at the shortlisting stage of the process.
Question from Councillor Birch to Councillor Inglis “Could you please inform residents how many times the Conservative Party have ever brought motions to Council with regards to Bingham's parking?” Councillor Inglis responded by stating that as the leading Group, the Conservative Group would not bring a motion, it would bring a report on such a matter, as it had in particular on the agenda this evening, and he confirmed that no motions had been brought to Council on this issue.
Councillor Birch asked a supplementary question to Councillor Inglis “Given that in 2019, the Conservative Party, including the Rushcliffe Conservative Party held the majority on Rushcliffe Borough Council, Bingham Town Council, Nottinghamshire County Council and Newark and Sherwood District Council, in other words, all four councils that could conceivably be necessary to help build a new car park, why did the Rushcliffe Conservatives not seek a solution to the car parking crisis in Bingham when it had the chance?” Councillor Inglis responded by stating that there was considerable history related to the provision of this car park and the feasibility of it all.
The following Notice of Motion was proposed by Councillor Chewings and seconded by Councillor Birch.
Question from Councillor Birch to Councillor Virdi.
Councillor Birch was unable to attend the meeting, so his question was read out by the Chair.
“How much money does Rushcliffe Borough Council currently have in cash reserves and investments?” Councillor Virdi thanked Councillor Birch for his question and responded by stating that it was important to understand that the reserves held were to cover future risks and opportunities. The Council’s Medium Term Financial Strategy brought together the revenue and capital pressures, funding risks and use of the reserves.
Question from Councillor Birch to Councillor Brennan.
Councillor Birch asked a supplementary question to Councillor Brennan.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Birch attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 Jul 2025 | Planning Committee | Planning Applications | Lost | 5 for, 5 against, 1 abstained | |
| 10 Jul 2025 | Planning Committee | Planning Applications | Carried | 5 for, 5 against, 1 abstained | |
| 26 Sep 2024 | Council | Greater Nottingham Strategic Plan | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Birch was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 11 of 15 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Birch declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12 Nov 2026 | Planning Committee, item 18 | Councillor T Birch declared a non-pecuniary interest as the Ward Councillor for Cropwell for application 26/01498/REG3 and would remove himself from the discussion and vote during this item. | |
| 8 Oct 2026 | Planning Committee, item 15 | Councillor T Birch declared a non-pecuniary interest for application 25/01484/FUL and would remove himself from the discussion and vote during this item. | |
| 5 Dec 2024 | Council, item 33 | Councillor Birch declared an interest in Item 15d Notices of Motion. |
Where Councillor Birch sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | May 2023 | 20 | 3 Dec 2026 |
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2025 | 17 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| Governance Scrutiny Group | Committee Member | Jun 2023 | 8 | |
| Member Development Group | Committee Member | Sep 2023 | 3 | |
| Standards Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2024 | 2 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.