Election of chairman of the council
A motion to appoint Councillor A Brown was moved by Councillor R Powell and seconded. Upon being put to the vote, with 26 votes in favour and 1 abstention the motion was carried.
Every time Rutland's minutes name Councillor Brown, as the council published it.
A motion to appoint Councillor A Brown was moved by Councillor R Powell and seconded. Upon being put to the vote, with 26 votes in favour and 1 abstention the motion was carried.
RESOLVED a) That Councillor A Brown be APPOINTED as Chairman of the Council for the 2023-24 municipal year.
Councillor A Brown was invested with the Chairman’s Chain of Office and took the Chair. The Chairman thanked Members for their support and set out his intention to serve the Council and county to the best of his ability and ensure Council meetings were efficient and chaired fairly but firmly.
It was agreed that Councillor Waller would speak with the Cabinet member regarding what the Task and Finish Group could do and by when and that Councillor Brown would contact Councillor Begy to confirm that he could still lead this Task and Finish Group.
Councillor A Brown briefed attendees on proposed new legislation for the country to be carbon neutral by 2050. During the discussion, the following points were noted:
· Councillor Brown queried what evidence there was to identify the ‘need’ stated in the report. Penny Sharp confirmed that a very detailed needs analysis report had been completed which the committee had been briefed about but that the full report was available to view if the committee wished to see it.
Councillor A Brown reported that he was a family magistrate on the Leicestershire and Rutland Magistrates Courts.
The nomination was seconded by Councillor A Brown. There were no other nominations received.
· Councillor A Brown thanked Lydia Bennett for the presentation and requested clarification regarding the Through Care Team. Lydia Bennett stated that the Through Care Team was a newly restructured team within the service to support care leavers and prepare them for adulthood from an early age.
· Councillor Brown stated that the document did not appear to reflect the current financial situation. He also stated that the report should have included SMART objectives, a clear financial plan, best estimates, required resources and details of the people responsible for the delivery of the strategy.
· Councillor Stephenson reminded Councillor Brown that the Scrutiny Committee had been asked to endorse to Cabinet/Council the vision for future waste management and that every Councillor was fully aware of the Council’s financial position.
Councillor A Brown declared a pecuniary interest item in item 5 – Planning Applications, application 2021/0672/FUL as the applicant, and that he would leave the meeting when the Committee came to consider the application.
Councillor M Oxley declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 5 – Planning Applications, application 2021/0672/FUL as a friend and political group leader to Councillor Brown, and that he would leave the meeting when the Committee came to consider the application.
Councillor A MacCartney declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 5 – Planning Applications, application 2021/0672/FUL as Councillor Brown was a regular customer in her shop, Councillor MacCartney confirmed she would remain in the meeting for consideration of the item.
Councillor Cross proposed and Councillor A Brown seconded and a vote was taken. It was noted a request from the Committee that officers discussed with the applicants its concerns regarding maintaining biodiversity on the site.
Councillor Brown further stated that it could take up to three years to get to the point the Council was currently in which would result in the Council not having a five year housing land supply; there would then be a presumption in favour of development and a real risk of uncontrolled development.
On Friday of last week Councillor Brown was advised of the provisional dates of the examination of the Plan which would take place virtually at the beginning of June ,…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….
· Councillor Brown had responded to the frequently asked question of why RCC should be liable for costs or other liabilities when the landowner would receive a surplus on the existing use value of their land by stressing that the agreements before Councillors actually protected Council from these liabilities; RCC would not be responsible for the construction of highways, meeting milestones or for remediation for any cost overruns. The risk to RCC was probably less than any other housing project because of the agreements that had been negotiated.
Councillor Brown, Portfolio Holder for Planning, replied that the issue would be discussed in exempt session later on in the meeting.
· Councillor Brown, the Portfolio Holder for Finance and Deputy Leader, together with the Leader of the Council, Cllr Hemsley, and the Rutland MP, Alicia Kearns had met with Luke Hall, Minister of State for Regional Growth and Local Government to highlight the unacceptable funding disparity between Rutland and other councils. 80% of Rutland’s spending came from Council Tax revenue as opposed to Government funding, whereas for most other councils this figure was c60%.
· Councillor Brown explained that the Minister was surprised how much of an impact the reduction in the New Homes Bonus had on small councils such as Rutland.
· Councillor Brown was frustrated by the ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
· Councillor Brown, the Portfolio Holder for Finance and Deputy Leader, together with the Leader of the Council, Cllr Hemsley, had met with Luke Hall, Minister of State for Regional Growth and Local Government to highlight the unacceptable funding disparity between Rutland and other councils. 80% of Rutland’s spending came from Council Tax revenue as opposed to Government funding, whereas for most other councils this figure was c60%.
· Councillor Brown was frustrated by the lack of action on the Fairer Funding Review but RCC had been promised a seat at the table in 2022/23 to discuss this issue.
· Although he agreed with the Section 151 officer that it would be prudent to increase Council Tax by the full 5%, Councillor Brown had recommended to Cabinet only a 3% increase in recognition of the financial hardships felt by residents and also in support of local businesses as every pound taken out ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
· Councillor Brown, the Portfolio Holder for Finance and Deputy Leader, together with the Leader of the Council, Cllr Hemsley, had met with Luke Hall, Minister of State for Regional Growth and Local Government to highlight the unacceptable funding disparity between Rutland and other councils. 80% of Rutland’s spending came from Council Tax revenue as opposed to Government funding, whereas for most other councils this figure was c60%.
· Councillor Brown was frustrated by the lack of action on the Fairer Funding Review but RCC had been promised a seat at the table in 2022/23 to discuss this issue. ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Councillor Brown reminded members that the action plan agreed in 2018 had these points included already, but due to factors such as COVID these had not been taken forward. A further point was raised questioning why the farming community was noted specifically in the motion.
Councillor A Brown to the Leader :
Councillor A Brown attended the Larkfleet Conference and asked about the sustainability of garden villages.
Councillor Brown explained that he considered the Paper to undermine democratic accountability and clarity was needed on the number of houses required.
Councillors Stephenson and Walters echoed the views of Councillor Brown and thanked him and officers for their comprehensive response.
· Councillor Brown, the Portfolio Holder for Planning, had joined a meeting with civil servants from the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) Neighbourhood Plan section where they had talked in more detail of what the changes to legislation and regulations might look like in particular;
Councillor A Brown said considered the white paper to be ill-conceived and ill- thought out. In contrast, he stated that the drafted response was well written and addressed some of the anomalies in the paper. He believed that the proposal on the white paper would take away involvement and scrutiny at a local level and would further erode the powers of local authorities with local communities having less involvement in local planning applications.
Councillor Hemsley proposed Cllr A Brown as Vice Chair and seconded by Cllr Razzell.
It was noted that Councillor A Brown and Councillor Jones would be appointed to the forum
Councillor Hemsley also reported a change to portfolios with environment and property moving from Councillor Brown to Councillor Stephenson and Councillor Hemsley respectively. This change was to take place with immediate effect.
Councillor A Brown submitted the following question:
What I would say is that I would welcome any ideas that you may have on how we make these meetings more welcoming to everyone in our communities and I am always happy to discuss any suggestions.” Councillor Begy further advised Councillor A Brown to discuss the matter directly with the Chairman and potentially the Constitutional Review Working Group.
In response to the answer given to his question, Councillor A Brown felt that it was discriminatory to prioritise one belief other others and said that he would bring a motion to Full Council to debate.
Councillor A Brown supported Councillor Waller’s views and felt that voting only to 26 disenfranchised voters.
Councillor Waller nominated Councillor Jones and Councillor A Brown and this was seconded by Councillor Oxley. There being no further nominations a recorded vote was taken.
· Councillor Brown could not guarantee that all residents would be reached, although it would use its database of residents who had taken an interest in the Local Plan and also urge Parishes to help the Council identify residents and get the message across.
· In response to a deputation that had been received, Councillor Brown confirmed that the Parish Forum was not a constituted body and therefore not a place where they could make representations on the soundness of the SCI and the Local Plan. Parishes could instead call their own meeting and have the SCI as a specific agenda item.
Before the vote was taken, Councillor A Brown asked whether Councillor Stephenson, as the daughter of Councillor Baines who if elected would receive an allowance for the role, should withdraw from voting. The Monitoring Officer clarified that this would not be necessary as it was accepted that Council positions were not a pecuniary interest.
Councillor Powell was proposed by Councillor Oxley and this was seconded by Councillor A Brown.
· In response to a question from Councillor A Brown, [name removed] confirmed that as a public body, the Council was not duty bound to advertise the interim post but was required to recruit on merit.
Councillor A Brown submitted a question in accordance with the Constitution:
In response Councillor G Brown I would remind Cllr Brown that when I presented the Motion to Council in October that I explained that we should not declare an Emergency but lay out an Action Plan and proceed to deal with the issues we face.
Cllr Brown introduced the report the purpose of which was to set out the statutory reports expected in relation to treasury and capital investment operations for 2020/21, linked to the Council’s Budget, Medium Term Financial Strategy and Capital Programme.
Councillor Brown, Portfolio Holder for Planning, Environment, Property and Finance introduced the report the purpose of which was to present a draft budget for consultation prior to the budget being formally set by Council in February 2020. During discussion the following points were noted:
Councillor Brown had produced a video for the Council’s website and for social media to explain this point. The video outlined the issue and made comparisons with the City of Westminster which was a much richer area but which still received more Government funding and therefore had lower council tax rates.
Councillor Brown, Deputy Leader and Portfolio Holder for Finance, introduced the report the purpose of which was to set out the proposals for fees and charges for services provided by the Council for the financial year 2020/21.
Councillor Brown, Deputy Leader and Portfolio Holder for Finance introduced the report the purpose of which was to set out the statutory reports expected in relation to treasury and capital investment operations for 2020/21, linked to the Council’s Budget, Medium Term Financial Strategy and Capital Programme.
· Councillor Brown was pleased that the Council now had this important document for parish councils and villages to guide them on the opportunities they had for speed management.
· Councillor Brown asked whether 2% was enough of an increase to provide us with the amount of residential care that was required in the County.
Councillor Brown, Portfolio Holder for Environment, Finance, Planning and Property introduced the report the purpose of which was to update Cabinet on progress with the preparation of the Local Plan and seek the views of Cabinet prior to Full Council considering the Pre-Submission (Regulation 19) publication version of the Local Plan. The recommendations are intended to ensure that the Plan is sound by being positively prepared, justified, and effective, as well as being consistent with national policy and being legally compliant.
· Councillor Brown pointed out to Members that the Plan was not just about the allocation of sites for housing but also about the policies which looked at the design of houses, the use of materials and other aspects that would affect climate change.
· Councillor Begy had a number of questions which he asked in the meeting and to which Councillor Brown, the Portfolio Holder responded.
Councillor Brown, in response, handed the committee copies of a letter (appended to the minutes) from Gavin Williamson the then Secretary of State for Defence. The letter highlighted that when the MOD vacated a site of this sort there was a presumption in favour of housing development which, in normal circumstances, would lead to the sale of land to a developer whose only constraints would be broader planning and building control rules and would therefore lead to a higher number of homes being built.
Councillor Brown the Portfolio Holder for Environment, Planning, Property, and Finance congratulated the work and achievements of Councillor Stephenson specifically with the Highways and Transport Working Group.
· Although there had been numerous comments from those presenting deputations that the decision making was being rushed, Councillor Brown felt that in fact the process had been conducted within a reasonable time-frame. In addition there were several upcoming Cabinet and Council meetings and a further Scrutiny meeting to consider the Local Plan.
Councillor Brown re-iterated to Members that he was also available to meet with them to discuss any of their concerns.
· Councillor Brown confirmed, for absolute clarity, that the St George’s Barracks development was only viable if the full amount of the HIF bid was accepted.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Brown attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Brown's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Brown was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Rutland has not published attendance for Councillor Brown's meetings yet.
What Councillor Brown declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 24 Aug 2021 | Planning and Licensing Committee, item 3 | Councillor A Brown declared a pecuniary interest item in item 5 – Planning Applications, application 2021/0672/FUL as the applicant, and that he would leave the meeting when the Committee came to consider the application. |
Where Councillor Brown sits, from the attendance records.
No committee attendance recorded for Councillor Brown yet.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.