Asked8 Sep 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Follow up report – Building Safety?
Councillor Thomas queried when would the Spandrel replacement programme be completed and was advised that the programme was still in progress. Formal reporting was due to go through the planning process shortly prior to works commencing via planning and building control. Members were also informed that the Council had been concerned regarding the time taken by the building regulator authorities to authorise the works which may take up to twelve months to secure approval.
Declared29 Jul 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Declarations of Pecuniary or Conflicts of Interest
In respect of Agenda Item 5 ‘Air Quality: The Annual Status Report’, Councillor Thomas declared that She was employed by Jaguar Land Rover (JLR) who were consulted for one point within the report.
Named29 Jul 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
The SCH Public Sector Equality Duty Annual Report 2025
Councillor Thomas observed that statistics and projects without context were potentially misleading. In terms of the observation regarding younger residents and complaints arising from anti-social behaviour, the nature of the complaints should be correlated to the type of properties concerned in order that the data could be run against property/access type.
Said29 Jul 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
The SCH Public Sector Equality Duty Annual Report 2025
Councillor Thomas also highlighted a passage within the report with detailed analysis of young people’s complaints which appeared to imply young people overly complained and that consequently their expectations had to be managed, which Councillor Thomas found this to be the wrong approach.
Named29 Jul 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
The SCH Public Sector Equality Duty Annual Report 2025
The Executive Director Customer Experience & Executive Support, SCH clarified that it was not the intention for the report to convey the impression Councillor Thomas received from it. Rather, the intention was to identify any potential disadvantage caused to specific groups through the way services were delivered. For example., younger people may be complaining more , not because they were inclined to complain, but rather because the manner of the service delivery was less favourable to them.
Named29 Jul 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
The SCH Public Sector Equality Duty Annual Report 2025
Councillor Thomas clarified that the statement which drew her to the conclusion above was detailed on page 182 of the report, under the heading Next Steps , which stated ‘ Targeted communications to younger customers to understand and manage expectations’ .
Named29 Jul 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
The SCH Public Sector Equality Duty Annual Report 2025
It was use of the word ‘expectations’ which had implied to Councillor Thomas that the younger persons expectations were seen as unreasonable and that they should complain less.
Said29 Jul 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
The SCH Public Sector Equality Duty Annual Report 2025
Councillor Thomas noted that page 187 of the report detailing the Action Plan also repeated the above statement.
Said29 Jul 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
The SCH Public Sector Equality Duty Annual Report 2025
The Executive Director Customer Experience & Executive Support, SCH informed the Scrutiny Board that the points raised by Councillor Thomas would be taken away for further review and consideration.
Said29 Jul 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Solihull Council Housing Tenancy Agreement
Councillor Thomas expressed some concern with the new tenancy agreement expectations placed on elderly and disabled tenants in terms of garden maintenance and the painting and decorating ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Asked29 Jul 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Access Arrangements Update
Councillor Thomas asked whether SCH initially wrote to tenants or whether they were given a choice of time, date and due notice. Members were informed that a letter was issued three months in advance of access being sought to the property concerned, with a text message sent before the appointment and a letter giving further notice issued two weeks prior to the appointment.
Declared16 Jul 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Declarations of Pecuniary or Conflicts of Interest
Referencing Agenda Item 7 ‘Cabinet Portfolio Holde Priorities for 2026/27’, Councillor K Thomas declared that her husband was employed by the National Careers Service.
Seconded16 Jul 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Rail service frequency in the Borough
At the Full Council meeting held on 3 February 2026, a motion put forward by Councillor Bradley and seconded by Councillor Thomas regarding rail service frequency in the Borough was referred to the Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board, with an aim for it to:
Named16 Jul 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Rail service frequency in the Borough
The Chairman invited Councillor Bradley to address the Scrutiny Board in respect of the Council Motion, followed by Councillor Thomas as seconder for the Council Motion.
Named16 Jul 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Rail service frequency in the Borough
Having taken note of the respective addresses by Councillor Bradley and Councillor Thomas, the Chairman invited David Balme (Transport Planner) to introduce the report before the Scrutiny Board, which addressed and expanded upon the Council Motion submitted by Councillor Bradley. Having received the report introduction from the Transport Planner, the Chairman invited Peter Sargant (West Midlands Rail Executive) to address the salient points arising from the Council Motion and detailed within the report before the Scrutiny Board. Finally, before opening the floor to questions, the Chairman invited the Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and Infrastructure to comment.
Said16 Jul 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Rail service frequency in the Borough
In terms of passenger numbers, Councillor Thomas noted that they were close to being back to pre-covid pandemic levels, although there had been a shift towards more leisure travellers who did not pay as much to travel as did commuters.
Asked16 Jul 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Rail service frequency in the Borough
Councillor Thomas enquired whether any consideration had been given to reducing fares to make them more competitive and whether the reduction in fare price would be outweighed by a potential increase in passenger numbers.
Named14 Jul 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Appointment of Chairman to the Resources and Delivering Value Scrutiny Board for the 2026/27 Municipal Year
Councillor Wigley nominated Councillor Thomas, seconded by Councillor O’Nyons.
Named14 Jul 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Appointment of Chairman to the Resources and Delivering Value Scrutiny Board for the 2026/27 Municipal Year
All Members of the Resources and Delivering Value Scrutiny Board supported the appointment of Councillor Thomas as Chairman for the 2026/27 municipal year.
Named14 Jul 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Appointment of Vice-Chairman to the Resources and Delivering Value Scrutiny Board for the 2026/27 Municipal Year
Those indicating support for the appointment of Councillor Holt:- - Councillor O’Nyons - Councillor Baker - Councillor Tomlinson - Councillor Holt Those indicating support for the appointment of Councillor Campbell:- - Councillor Johnson - Councillor O’Neil - Councillor Thomas - Councillor Wigley - Councillor Campbell The Resources and Delivering Value Scrutiny Board:
Said14 Jul 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Corporate Performance Report ('Top 40’)
Referring to the Resources Performance Scorecard, Councillor Thomas highlighted the KPI ‘Time taken in days to process changes relating to Housing Benefit’ , noting that the actual assessment period in days was substantially below the target figure of 14 days and queried whether the target would be figure would therefore be lowered this year. The Director of Resources clarified that the target figure may potentially be amended subject to clarification of any potential national target setting for this KPI, with the fourteen days target potentially being an accepted default position. The service was, however, conscious of processing any claims as quickly as possible for claimants and had ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
Asked14 Jul 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) update – 2025/26 Final Outturn
Councillor Thomas sought confirmation that the non-planned MTFS saving being taken forward was £2.115M. The Director of Resources confirmed that the £2.115M was the additional savings that had been put into the Council’s reserves.
Asked14 Jul 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) update – 2025/26 Final Outturn
Regarding the DSG, Councillor Thomas questioned in the scenario where the Government continued to cover 90% of the DSG amount outstanding, would the Council then be able to stabilise the remaining DSG costs. The Director of Resources advised that it was in the Council’s interests that it could demonstrate to the Department of Education that it was managing and controlling DSG costs, for which the related DSG reform plan had been put in place.
Said14 Jul 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Private Minutes
RESOURCES AND DELIVERING VALUE SCRUTINY BOARD 14 JULY 2026 PRIVATE MINUTES Present: Councillors S Tomlinson, R Holt, J O’Nyons, T Baker, K Thomas, A Wigley, J Campbell, R Johnson, D O’Neil Officers: Andy Felton, Director for Resources Samantha Gilbert, Assistant Director Finance & Property Services Paul Rogers: Democratic Services Councillor Thomas highlighted a spelling error in the second paragraph of page 96, that should be amended to read as follows:
Asked14 Jul 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Private Minutes
‘ Councillor Thomas questioned, based on the above, whether based on that, would that then influence the three options that were under consideration for the Solihull Council House and subsequently making the auctions actions pointless’.
Said7 Jul 2026Council
Petitions
Councillor K Thomas presented a petition from residents of Marcot Road, Brean Avenue and Wichnor Road seeking reinstatement of bus stops on the A45 near Gilbertstone Avenue Councillor P Sharma presented a petition from residents calling for the installation of a pedestrian crossing at Yarley Wood Road opposite Peterbrook School.
Moved7 Jul 2026Council
Motion 5: A Fair Share of Speeding Fine Revenue to Improve Local Road Safety
Councillor K Thomas, seconded by Councillor K Hawkins, moved the Motion as printed.
Named17 Jun 2026Planning Committee
Requests of Members to address the meeting
Councillor Den O’Neil requested to speak on application 2025/01267 – 214 Cooks Lane, Kingshusrt ; Councillor Kathryn Thomas on 2026/00519 – 63 Castle Lane, Olton; Councillor Laura McCarthy on 2026/00520 – 18 Windsor Drive, Elmdon; Councillor Max McLoughlin on 2026/00656 – 94 Widney Lane, Solihull; and Councillor Wazma Qais on 2026/00714 – 102 Buryfield Road, Solihull.
Said17 Jun 2026Planning Committee
PL/2026/00519/PPFL - 63 Castle Lane
Ward Councillor Kathryn Thomas spoke against the application. [name removed] requested to speak in support but was not in attendance.
Said14 Apr 2026Council
Declarations of pecuniary or conflicting interests from Members
Councillor Kathryn Thomas advised Members that she was employed by Jaguar Land Rover (JLR) and her husband was employed by the National Careers Advice Service.
Said14 Apr 2026Council
Questions and Deputations under Standing Order 9 and 12
Councillor Kathryn Thomas introduced Debbie Matthews, who addressed Council on ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Said14 Apr 2026Council
Minutes of Scrutiny Boards
Councillor Kathryn Thomas noted that she was incorrectly recorded as attending Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board on 9 March 2026 as an observer and it was confirmed that this typographical error would be rectified.
Named16 Mar 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
The Council Plan 2025-30
Councillor Thomas referenced paragraph 4.1.2 of the report regarding the SEND deficit and queried whether there was a plan in place to address it. The Director for Children’s Services advised that Officers were working a6 pace to have a draft plan in place by the end of April / beginning of May, and then for the draft plan to be submitted to Department of Education advisors by 19 th June 2026.
Asked16 Mar 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
The Council Plan 2025-30
Councillor Thomas questioned when the report for the Scrutiny Board was written, as paragraph 4.7.6 in the report appeared to imply the report had been written before the Planning Committee meeting held in January 2026. The Head of Policy clarified that the wording milestone was given in italics and agreed as what would be the actual milestone in the summer of 2025, with the non-italics detail proving an update drafted tow to three weeks ago.
Named16 Mar 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
The Council Plan 2025-30
Councillor Thomas referenced the Community Advice Services decision made to delay the procurements to allow further market shaping activities to be undertaken and questioned why and what led to that decision and what was the concern that led Officers to make that decision. The Director for Adult Social Care advised that the procurement exercise had b een submitted to the Health and Adult Social Care Scrutiny Board several times, including inviting members from other Scrutiny Boards to make sure that the right decisions were made in terms of both the model, the funding and the way forward. Although rated as amber and needing management attention, the result arising was a very good decision because of the feedback from scrutiny and the work undertaken with communities leading to a better model.
Named16 Mar 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Corporate Procurement Strategy Update
Councillor Thomas referenced the figure of 87% of influenceable expenditure as detailed in the report and queried what influenceable meant in this context and whether a number figure for 87% could also be provided. The Head of Procurement advised that she would come back to Members and confirm what that figure was. In terms of what was meant by influenceable, Members were advised there were a number of areas of expenditure where the Council committed to spending with public bodies.
Named9 Mar 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
East Birmingham / North Solihull Corridor Governance Arrangements– Update Report
Councillor Thomas observed that the Bickenhill ward would only exist for approximately another eleven weeks and to be geographically accurate queried which of the new or existing wards were to be affected. Members were advised that the EBNS was very much designed by the geography of where the particular sites were located, and it did not follow ward boundaries at the current time. The actual geography as identified would remain the same.
Named26 Feb 2026Council
Questions under Standing Order 8 (30 Minutes)
Cllr Thomas to Cllr Hawkins– Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and Infrastructure Why did the Council manage to misrepresent the views of Barston Parish Council so comprehensively at the Environment & Infrastructure decision session in January?
Seconded26 Feb 2026Council
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) 2026/27 – 2028/29
Cllr Adeyemo proposed an amendment which was seconded by Cllr Thomas which read:
Said25 Feb 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Children’s Services Budget Update
Councillor Thomas expressed considerable concern at the cost of looked after children in residential placements, noting a considerable number of submitted planning applications seeking to provide further residential homes offering placements.
Asked25 Feb 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Children’s Services Budget Update
Councillor Thomas queried how much awareness Children’s Service had of these applications and to what degree were the developers concerned simply seeking to profit from such planning applications. The Assistant Director for Corporate Parenting confirmed that some applications were from speculative providers, who were attracted due to market conditions and service demand for residential placements. The Council did not go out to the market seeking ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Named25 Feb 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Corporate Transformation Programme
Councillor Thomas observed that the Council was reliant on the streams in the Transformation Programme to realise savings of £11M by 2027/28, yet it appeared that the implementation journey was only just beginning.
Asked25 Feb 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Corporate Transformation Programme
Councillor Thomas asked how confident were Officers that the savings would be delivered and what was the estimated savings arising from each of the transformation workstreams.
Said25 Feb 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Corporate Transformation Programme
Councillor Thomas noted that the White Paper for the DSG implied that the Council would be taking approximately one-tenth of its deficit on to the Council books, with another £6.6M which obviously was not factored in.
Asked25 Feb 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Corporate Transformation Programme
Councillor Thomas queried whether that affected the £11M calculation, requiring to move beyond a one off, or was the intention of the Council to borrow the money to cover the DSG .
Named24 Feb 2026Stronger Communities and Neighbourhood Services Scrutiny Board
Questions and Deputations
Councillor K Thomas put a question regarding localised flooding in Rock Grove, Solihull. It was agreed that additional operational information would be sought as to the background to the flooding to enable Severn Trent Water to provide a response.
Named24 Feb 2026Stronger Communities and Neighbourhood Services Scrutiny Board
Questions and Deputations
[Post-meeting note – Councillor Thomas was provided with an answer to her question by Council Officers following the meeting which detailed investigations that had been carried out, together with proposed future action].
Said11 Feb 2026Planning Committee
Requests of Members to address the meeting
Councillor Kathryn Thomas requested to speak on application 2022/02050 – Residential Parking Site, Campden Green, Solihull; Councillor Heather Delaney on application 2025/01628 – Brickmakers Arms, 307 Station Road, Balsall Common; Councillor Mark Parker on application 2025/02139 – 43 Charles Road, Shriley; and Councillor Alan Feeney on application 2025/02222 – 77 Hawthorne Road, Castle Bromwich.
Said11 Feb 2026Planning Committee
PL/2022/02050/MINFDW - Campden Green
[name removed] and Councillor Kathryn Thomas spoke against the application.
Named5 Feb 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) 2026/27 – 2028/29
Councillor Thomas referenced Page 31, paragraph 5.4 in the report, noting that for the 2027/28 and 2028/29 financial years, the Council needed to find substantial savings on top of what amounted to a 9.99% Council Tax.
Named5 Feb 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) 2026/27 – 2028/29
Councillor Thomas observed that in previous years when substantial savings were required there had been a plan in place to deliver them and therefore questioned whether the Council had any such plan in place in place to deliver the required savings. The Director of Resources advised that there was an emerging plan from an Officer perspective, with conversations already having commenced regarding the required 2027/28 savings. It was the intention to further develop the emerging proposals and to provide detail for further discussion with Members by September 2026.
Named5 Feb 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) 2026/27 – 2028/29
Councillor Thomas referenced Page 53, paragraph 1.3 in the report, querying whether the detail therein was true (‘The proposed 2026/27 budget is balanced with the application of one-off reserves (£1.038M)’), in light of Page 51 of the report (‘Summary of Reserves’) which detailed the spending of £30.397M of reserves in-year.
Named5 Feb 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) 2026/27 – 2028/29
Councillor Thomas qualified her question through recognising the probable deferral of the DSG figure, bringing the spend of reserves closer to £18.840M, but sought clarification that paragraph 1.3 reflected the position. The Director of Resources clarified that there was a difference between what had been assumed and programmed into the budget from the use of reserves point of view, and the additional use of reserves which had not been planned that were now being proposed to close the remaining residual gap in the MTFS.
Said5 Feb 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Council Tax Reduction Scheme 2026-27
Councillor Thomas noted that there were residents residing in band G and H housing who were receiving council tax relief and questioned why this was the case. The Head of Income and Awards clarified that these cases may relate to scenarios involving significant large families or inherited family homes. Members were further advised that there were other cases whereby some residents remained eligible for CTRS relief regardless, which may involve properties classified as belonging to Bands G and H.
Named5 Feb 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Council Tax Reduction Scheme 2026-27
Councillor Thomas referenced page 177, paragraph 3.6 of the report which detailed that additional claimants (April-December 2025) had generated an additional £390,000 of pressures on the CTRS and sought clarification as to what exactly had created these additional pressures. The Head of Income and Awards advised that the total cost of scheme in April 2025 was £14.3M, which was more than the forecasted MTFS position. This equated to the difference of the £811,000 detailed.
Said5 Feb 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Council Tax Reduction Scheme 2026-27
Councillor Thomas commented that she was not fundamentally comfortable with the proposals , as they appeared to be taking away support form the most vulnerable people in the borough.
Named5 Feb 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Council Tax Reduction Scheme 2026-27
Councillor Thomas was also nervous about the burden potentially falling on people with the lowest CTRS in Solihull. Furthermore, the CTRS consultation questions appeared to be relatively leading with respondents potentially not having fully understood the implications or impact of the proposals.
Said5 Feb 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Dedicated Schools Grant Management Plan 2025/26
Councillor Thomas requested that a further DSG be brought back to a meeting of the Resources and Delivering Value Scrutiny Board in six months’ time when the detail in the White Paper would be known, as well as what expectations would have been placed on the Council. Members of the Resources and Delivering Value Scrutiny Board agreed to schedule a DSG report into the 2026/27 Work Programme.
Named5 Feb 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Dedicated Schools Grant Management Plan 2025/26
Councillor Thomas also observed that the money invested to date has not prevented the DSG deficit from growing.
Asked5 Feb 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Dedicated Schools Grant Management Plan 2025/26
Regarding primary school intakes, Councillor Thomas queried whether reduced classroom intakes were a feature across the while of Solihull. The Head of Access to Education confirmed that it was a feature across all of Solihull, with birth rates dropping and reduced intakes.
Named3 Feb 2026Council
Reports from Cabinet
In responding to a question from Cllr Thomas in relation to staff retention, the Cabinet Member confirmed that she had no concerns.
Declared19 Jan 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Declarations of Pecuniary or Conflicts of Interest
Councillor K Thomas declared that her husband was an employee of the National Careers Service.
Seconded19 Jan 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Council Motion 9th December 2025 - Implications of Proposed Visitor Levy in England
Motion: Councillor L McCarthy moved, and Councillor Thomas seconded - Call on the Mayor of the West Midlands and Solihull Council to Respond in Support of the Visitor Levy Consultation This Council notes:
Named19 Jan 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Solihull Community Housing Delivery Plan 2025/26 Quarter 3 update
Referencing page 79 of the report addressing resident’s satisfaction levels, Councillor Thomas shared her experience that a reply from SCH seemed to be forthcoming only once good news appeared to be available to be shared with the customer, with no communication during the interim period.
Said19 Jan 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Solihull Community Housing Delivery Plan 2025/26 Quarter 3 update
Councillor Thomas felt that this may be attributable to the low customer satisfaction rates detailed in the report and recommended that it was preferable to communicate with a customer to update them during an interim period before a final response could be provided.
Said19 Jan 2026Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Solihull Community Housing Delivery Plan 2025/26 Quarter 3 update
Referencing paragraph 4.12 of the report, regarding temporary accommodation arrangements, Councillor Thomas noted that there were some very poor figures detailed in terms of the length of stays that families had been in temporary accommodation and suggested that rather than having families.
Said5 Jan 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Workforce Report
With reference to the ethnicity and gender profile of the Council’s workforce, Councillor Thomas noted that it was overwhelmingly female with high BME in its composition in relative percentage terms for the boroughs demographic profile.
Asked5 Jan 2026Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Workforce Report
Consequently, Councillor Thomas queried whether the Council needed to target white ethnicity men with a campaign to encourage them to join the Council to work in Adult Social Care and other areas such as SEND. The Scrutiny Board was informed that the recruitment data for the Council did not suggest that the organisation was having any significant recruitment problems. Regarding the ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Named20 May 2025Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Election of chairman for the 2025/26 municipal year
All Members of the Scrutiny Board voted in favour of Councillor Pinwell’s appointment, except for Councillor K Thomas (against) and Councillor S Sheshabhatter (abstained).
Named20 May 2025Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Appointment of vice-chairman for the 2025/26 municipal year
All Members of the Scrutiny Board voted in favour of Councillor Holt’s appointment, except for Councillor K Thomas (abstained).
Declared20 May 2025Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Declarations of Pecuniary or Conflicts of Interest
Councillor K Thomas declared her employment with Jaguar Land Rover.
Named20 May 2025Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Corporate Transformation Programme
Councillor Thomas referenced paragraph 4.1.6 of the report (‘ Living Well in Solihull’ ) addressing preventative services and savings delivery and questioned how these aims aligned to those non-statutory services which still had a significant societal role and provided wider societal/community benefits e.g. Offender Management Services. The Director for Resources advised that this question would be better suited to be raised at the Stronger Communities Scrutiny Board.
Named20 May 2025Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Corporate Transformation Programme
Regarding A.I and digitalisation, Councillor Thomas referenced the Oracle launch and past outsourcing of work for the creation of reports from the system.
Said20 May 2025Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Corporate Transformation Programme
Councillor Thomas highlighted the proposals for the Council to take forward the whole scale implementation of digital services and questioned how many specialists digital staff the Council currently employed and how many A.I/data specialists, analysts and architects were currently working on dashboards. The Assistant Director, Business Systems advised that:
Asked20 May 2025Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Corporate Transformation Programme
Councillor Thomas questioned whether the Council had the tools to deliver the savings to the timescale of 2027/28. The Director for Resources advised that:
Said20 May 2025Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Private Minutes - 14 April 2025
Councillor Thomas raised that the Minutes meeting title and date was incorrect.
Declared14 Apr 2025Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Declarations of Pecuniary or Conflicts of Interest
In relation to Agenda Item 5 ‘WMCA Activity in Solihull MBC’, Councillor K Thomas declared that her husband worked for the National Careers Advice Service.
Named8 Apr 2025Council
Joint Arrangements and External Organisations
Cllr Thomas referenced the £10m savings required for 2025/26 Police budget and questioned what the impact would be on residents of Solihull?
Said5 Mar 2025Planning Committee
Requests of Members to address the meeting
Councillor Kathryn Thomas requested to speak on application 2024/02459 -100 Wellsford Avenue, Solihull.
Said5 Mar 2025Planning Committee
PL/2024/02459/MINFHO - 100 Wellsford Avenue
[name removed] and Councillor Kathryn Thomas spoke against the application and a statement of support was read out on behalf of [name removed].
Named4 Mar 2025Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Solihull Community Housing Delivery Plan 2025/2026
Councillor Thomas state that her main concern related to those new KPI targets which had been set lower than for last year; for example, for ASB and complaints handling.
Said4 Mar 2025Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Solihull Community Housing Delivery Plan 2025/2026
Councillor Thomas further noted that the 2024/25 performance was being used to set the 2025/26 performance targets.
Said4 Mar 2025Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Solihull Community Housing Delivery Plan 2025/2026
Councillor Thomas noted that complaints handling performance had improved by 10% but stated that to then lower the KPI target for 2025/26 did not show adequate ambition, which also applied to the ASB KPI target for 2025/26.
Said4 Mar 2025Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Solihull Community Housing Delivery Plan 2025/2026
Finally, with regard to complaints handling, Councillor Thomas noted that the SCH Delivery Plan did not specifically address this area and proposed that in the future this area be made a key theme in future iterations of the SCH Delivery Plan. The Assistant Director for Housing advised that:
Said27 Feb 2025Council
Questions and Deputations under Standing Order 9 and 12
Cllr Thomas introduced [name removed].
Named27 Feb 2025Council
Questions under Standing Order 8 (30 Minutes)
Cllr Thomas to Cllr K Grinsell- Cabinet Member for Children and Education How many children are currently out of school or are in placements that do not fully meet the requirements of their EHCP, because their EHCP indicates the need for specialist provision, but every school that the council has approached has been unable to offer them a place?
Asked27 Feb 2025Council
Questions under Standing Order 8 (30 Minutes)
Cllr Thomas questioned what plans there were to create more specialist provision. The Cabinet Member advised that the Council was working hard with the DfE to build a specialist school.
Named27 Feb 2025Council
Questions under Standing Order 8 (30 Minutes)
Cllr Thomas to Cllr B Sleigh OBE - Cabinet Member for Resources In ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Said12 Feb 2025Health and Adult Social Care Scrutiny Board
Review of commissioned Community Information and Advice Services
Councillor Thomas stressed the importance of clear oversight, to ensure all information issued was of the required quality and accurate.
Said10 Feb 2025Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
2024/25 Medium Term Financial Strategy update – Period 9 (December)
Councillor Thomas raised the £1.52M in year variance for Adult Social Care for incurred placement costs as part of the Medium-Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) savings 2025/26.
Said10 Feb 2025Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
2024/25 Medium Term Financial Strategy update – Period 9 (December)
Councillor Thomas noted that there were a number of savings proposals put forward for Adult Social Care predicated on securing reduced contractual pricing in the future and questioned in light of the service facing increased placement costs, how realistic were these proposals with the high number of special care requests presenting to the Council.
Said10 Feb 2025Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
2024/25 Medium Term Financial Strategy update – Period 9 (December)
Councillor Thomas noted the social care in-year pressures for Children’s Services, the high level of need and out of area placements, the volatility associated with some of the placements and queried how such volatility was built into the future model for Childrens Services social care.
Said10 Feb 2025Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
2024/25 Medium Term Financial Strategy update – Period 9 (December)
Councillor Thomas also noted that a comment in the key variances gave an explanation about how volatile the market was in terms of placement costs and that that can lead for cost to go both up and down. How was this built into the model that had been developed for costing children's social care leading to better forecasting in the future compared to this year.
Moved10 Feb 2025Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Resources and Delivering Value Scrutiny Board Work Programme 2024/25
Councillor Thomas proposed that an in-depth review be undertaken, in conjunction with the Children’s Services and Education Scrutiny Board, of the Councils Direct Services Grant (DSG) position at a future meeting of the Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board (preferably in April 2025).
Named4 Feb 2025Council
Declarations of pecuniary or conflicting interests from Members
Cllr Thomas reminded Members that she worked for Jaguar Land Rover, and Cllr L McCarthy advised Council that she had family members who were being supported by Solihull Social Services.
Named4 Feb 2025Council
Questions under Standing Order 8 (30 Minutes)
Cllr K Thomas to Cllr B Sleigh OBE– Cabinet Member for Resources The Mutual Early Resignation Scheme (MERS) was recently published. How will decisions be made as to agreeing which post holders can exit the organisation and how will the impact on remaining post holders in the same team be assessed?
Asked4 Feb 2025Council
Questions under Standing Order 8 (30 Minutes)
Cllr Thomas asked when the development of the scheme would be finalised so Members could have a better understanding of what the organisation may look like. It was confirmed the scheme would go live on 1 March and close at the end of March.
Named9 Jul 2024Council
Questions and Deputations under Standing Order 9 and 12
[name removed] was introduced by Cllr Thomas.
Named9 Jul 2024Council
Questions under Standing Order 8 (30 Minutes)
Cllr Thomas to Cllr Courts Leader of the Council Solihull Town Centre redevelopment is key not just to St Alphege but to all residents of Solihull. Given its importance to the whole of the borough, can an Opposition Spokesperson from each political party be added to the board overseeing the development?
Asked9 Jul 2024Council
Questions under Standing Order 8 (30 Minutes)
Cllr Thomas questioned as to how Members could have an input, rather than just a briefing, and how diversity of opinion could ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Named20 May 2024Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Appointment of vice-chairman for 2024/2025
Councillor K Thomas was proposed by Councillor S Sheshabhatter and Seconded by Councillor H Dawkins.
Named20 May 2024Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Appointment of vice-chairman for 2024/2025
On being put to the vote, Councillor H Delaney received six votes and Councillor K Thomas 3 votes.
Said20 May 2024Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Resources and Delivering Value Scrutiny Board Work Programme 2024/25
Councillor Thomas raised the matter of the Councils future operating model, proposing that the emerging detail for the operating model be considered on a quarterly basis at the Scrutiny Board alongside the quarterly Financial Update report which addressed Council is the budget status.
Said20 May 2024Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Resources and Delivering Value Scrutiny Board Work Programme 2024/25
Councillor Thomas further noted that the new operating model would impact and shape delivery of future budget management arrangements across the Council, including its spend.
Said20 May 2024Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Resources and Delivering Value Scrutiny Board Work Programme 2024/25
Councillor Thomas noted that the Budget Strategy Group did not get the opportunity to scrutinise in-depth or receive the same level of detail when compared to the Resources and Delivering Value Scrutiny Board. The new operating model could impact on services in terms of the service model and ways in which services were delivered, for example placing more SEND pupils into mainstream school settings.
Named20 May 2024Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Resources and Delivering Value Scrutiny Board Work Programme 2024/25
Councillor Thomas concluded that greater scrutiny was required beyond just financial matters, but scrutiny arrangements should also consider future service delivery arrangements in Solihull and any potential for selling-off of Council assets.
Said9 Apr 2024Council
Reports from Cabinet
Cllr Thomas highlighted those young people who had autism, who did training courses, but never found a route into employment. The Deputy Leader advised targeted support would help these young people into work.
Named9 Apr 2024Council
Minutes of Scrutiny Boards
a) Resources and Delivering Value 12 February and 11 March 2024 b) Economic Development and Managed Growth 29 February and 18 March 2024 In relation to the minutes of 29 February the Leader referenced a response he gave to a question from Cllr Thomas on page 113 and requested that the Board consider the accuracy of this minute.
Asked18 Mar 2024Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Solihull Community Housing Delivery Plan 2024/25
Councillor Thomas queried whether the detail in the Delivery Plan was correct in stating that action was to be taken in addressing mould and damp in 1,100 housing stock properties located in the borough. It was confirmed that this was correct and was a priority action for SCH. The Scrutiny Board was further advised that some of the housing stock included properties whose build construction was questionable, and which had led to issues such as mould, damp and condensation requiring remedial works to be undertaken.
Asked18 Mar 2024Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Solihull Community Housing Delivery Plan 2024/25
Regarding the theme of Strengthening SCH’s support for those experiencing domestic abuse and SCH’s stated objective of reducing the number of SCH tenants presenting as homeless because of domestic abuse, Councillor Thomas questioned how SCH intended to deliver that objective. Secondly, to achieve the objective would it force the person experiencing domestic abuse to remain with the abuser in the household. The Executive Director, Customer Services, Transformation & Business Support SCH clarified that would not be the case and that the theme had been included in the Delivery Plan at the Council’s request.
Asked18 Mar 2024Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Solihull Community Housing Delivery Plan 2024/25
Councillor Thomas questioned what the intent behind the phrasing was used for the theme, as it was unclear as written. The Assistant Director for Housing, SCH clarified that SCH’s intention was to have early interventions put in place for any person experiencing domestic abuse. SCH was also progressing the use of services provided by Domestic Abuse Housing Alliance (DAHA) in support of this objective.
Said18 Mar 2024Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Solihull Community Housing Delivery Plan 2024/25
Councillor Thomas stated the phrasing for the theme required reviewing, as in its current form there was ambiguity, which could be interpreted as encouraging the abused to remain in the home with the abuser.
Asked18 Mar 2024Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Solihull Community Housing Delivery Plan 2024/25
Regarding Key Performance Indicators (KPI’s) detailed in the Delivery Plan (page22/23), Councillor Thomas referenced ‘Satisfaction: approach to handling complaints’, noting that the target was 60% for 2024, but the new target moving forward to 2025 was established at 42%.Councillor Thomas sought further clarity as to why the target was missed. The Scrutiny Board was informed that SCH was reviewing all its KPI suite. All SCH KPI’s would reflect the national median in terms of performance or would retain the original target if better than the national median for the social housing sector.
Said18 Mar 2024Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Council Housing Asset Management Strategy 2023-2033
Councillor Thomas noted that regarding those lower performing properties in high rises, there appeared to be a good chance for a resident to secure a one-bedroom property, but not so much for a three- or four-bedroom property.
Asked18 Mar 2024Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Council Housing Asset Management Strategy 2023-2033
As such, Councillor Thomas questioned whether it was feasible to consider amalgamating / converting single- and two-bedroom properties into larger, multi-bedroomed properties. The Executive Director of Operations, SCH confirmed that SCH had given this option some consideration.
Said18 Mar 2024Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Council Housing Asset Management Strategy 2023-2033
Councillor Thomas noted that it may not be a stock problem, but rather one of measuring the correct determinants. The Executive Director of Operations, SCH advised that there was not one single, identified determinant responsible.
Asked18 Mar 2024Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Council Housing Asset Management Strategy 2023-2033
Councillor Thomas questioned whether attempting to lengthen the lifespan of the high-rise stock was in fact the correct strategy to pursue. Members were advised that this point was addressed through facilitation of a workshop. Work was also commencing on the commissioning of a Housing Masterplan which would continue to address such strategic questions.
Declared11 Mar 2024Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
Declarations of Pecuniary or Conflicts of Interest
Councillor K Thomas declared in relation to Agenda Item 7 ‘ West Midlands Combined Authority Annual Report 2022/23’ that her husband was employed by the National Careers Advice Service.
Asked11 Mar 2024Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board
West Midlands Combined Authority Annual Report 2022/23
Councillor Thomas questioned what should be expected from those Scrutiny Councillors who awere not part of any WMCA Scrutiny Committee.
Asked6 Feb 2024Council
Reports from Cabinet
Cllr Thomas asked whether feedback could be provided on the Cop28, the Cabinet Member advised that this could be provided.
Asked6 Feb 2024Council
Minutes of Scrutiny Boards
Resources and Delivering Value – 11 December 2023 and 11 January 2024 Health and Adult Social Care – 9 January 2024 Economic Development and Managed Growth – 15 January 2024 Stronger Communities and Neighbourhood Services – 16 January 2024 Children’s Services, Education and Skills 17 January 2024 Cllr Thomas questioned why so many Special Needs Tribunal cases are lost. The Chairman advised this area of work could be picked up in the Board’s future work programme. The Cabinet Member offered a written response to the question.
Asked6 Feb 2024Council
Joint Arrangements and External Organisations
b) Minutes of the West Midlands Police and Crime Panel - 13 November and 18 December 2023 Cllr Thomas asked what the financial vulnerabilities were referred to in the minutes.
Said15 Jan 2024Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
MTFS Update - Budget Strategy 2024/25 to 2026/27
Councillor Thomas highlighted the position of the Statutory Youth Offer, as detailed in paragraph 3.17, specifically the requirement to identify additional resources moving forward to sustain the service.
Asked15 Jan 2024Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
MTFS Update - Budget Strategy 2024/25 to 2026/27
Councillor Thomas also sought clarification as to what level of reserve would be left for the pertinent directorates once the Budget Strategy had been implemented. The Managed Growth Finance Manager advised the respective reserve balances as:
Moved19 Jul 2023Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Confirmation of election of chairman and vice chairman to the economic development and managed growth scrutiny board for the 2023/24 municipal year.
Councillor McLoughlin was proposed by Councillor Thomas and seconded by Councillor Donnelly.
Said19 Jul 2023Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
MINUTES
Councillor Thomas raised a correction to the draft Minutes under Item 6 ‘Delivering Inclusive Growth in Solihull’, page 10, referencing employment opportunities arising through the East Birmingham/North Solihull Corridor.
Named19 Jul 2023Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
MINUTES
Councillor Thomas clarified that her reference was made to ensure that there was a sufficient range of employment opportunities offering a breadth of income ranges were made available.
Named19 Jul 2023Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Cabinet Portfolio Holder Priorities for the 2023/24 Municipal Year
Councillor Thomas referenced the original car park proposal for Arden Cross, which envisaged provision of over 7,000 car parking-spaces, and which had been presented a s a legal requirement.
Asked19 Jul 2023Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Cabinet Portfolio Holder Priorities for the 2023/24 Municipal Year
If the Arden Cross development was moving to a flat surface car park, Councillor Thomas questioned what resultant development loss would arise at the site.
Said19 Jul 2023Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Natural Capital Investment Strategy and Delivery Plan
Councillor Thomas noted that language used within the NCIS referenced ‘continuing degradation’ of the natural environment, which implied on-going degradation despite the Councils initiatives to negate such degradation, and questioned what could be done to counter this.
Asked19 Jul 2023Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Natural Capital Investment Strategy and Delivery Plan
Secondly, Councillor Thomas sought further clarity as to what specific actions were being proposed via the NCIS.
Named19 Jul 2023Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Natural Capital Investment Strategy and Delivery Plan
The Team Manager, CLAUDE advised that the wording used at paragraph 1.6 of the NCIS to which Councillor Thomas referenced referred to the concept of degradation in the broadest global sense and not solely to the borough. With reference to mitigating actions, Members were advised that it was important to note that substantial work had been undertaken over the past 6 years via the European Regional Development Fund (ERDF), and partnership working via the Environment Agency, Warwickshire Wildlife Trust and the Wetlands Partnership.
Seconded4 Jul 2023Council
Notice of Motion
Cllr L McCarthy , seconded by Cllr Thomas – Community Policing " This Council recognises the importance of community policing in maintaining the safety of our streets and supports the work of our borough PCSOs.
Named7 Jun 2023Health and Adult Social Care Scrutiny Board
Election of Chairman for 2023/2024
Cllr A Wilson proposed Cllr K Thomas.
Named7 Jun 2023Health and Adult Social Care Scrutiny Board
Election of Chairman for 2023/2024
Cllr G Sleigh received 5 votes and Cllr K Thomas received 4 votes.
Named7 Jun 2023Health and Adult Social Care Scrutiny Board
Appointment of Vice-Chairman for 2023/2024
Cllr S Gethen received 5 votes and Cllr K Thomas received 4 votes.
Said4 Apr 2023Council
Petitions
1) Cllr Thomas presented a petition calling on the Council to refuse permission for a 15m phone mast on Richmond Road.
Asked4 Apr 2023Council
Recommendations from Committees
Cllr Thomas queried the recommendation from Minute 5 2023/2024 Financial Regulations Update as on Page 221 there were missing pages from the report. The Acting Chief Executive advised Council that they could defer making the decision, referring it back to Governance Committee for clarification. (Later in the meeting the Acting Chief Executive provided Members with an explanation see minute 17, which enabled Members to make a decision , therefore negating the need to refer the matter back to Committee.)
Asked4 Apr 2023Council
Reports from Cabinet
Cllr K Thomas asked the Cabinet Member about the increase in residents seeking support from the Council due to the Cost-of-Living Crisis and whether the Council had the resource, both financial and staffing, to keep up with the demand. The Cabinet Member detailed how the support received from HM Government was supporting this work alongside schemes the Council were delivering from its own budget and that this would be secured for this Financial Year. The Cabinet Member also highlighted how the Universal Credit split showed how this was an issue not isolated to one area of the borough with 55% of claimants deriving from the North with 45% from the South.
Asked4 Apr 2023Council
Joint Arrangements and External Organisations
Cllr K Thomas asked about the Future Home project and Grant Register and Cllr M McCarthy advised that the detail had not been discussed in the meeting but if Cllr K Thomas had specific questions, then he would be happy to take them away and get an answer.
Said13 Mar 2023Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Delivering Inclusive Growth in Solihull
Councillor Thomas noted that a low level of funding had been received via the U.K Shared Prosperity Fund and directed towards the Kingshurst Village Centre development and questioned where other funding sources were expected to be sourced.
Said13 Mar 2023Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Delivering Inclusive Growth in Solihull
Councillor Thomas welcomed the potential employment opportunities to be created in ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Named23 Feb 2023Council
Questions under Standing Order 8 (30 Minutes)
1) Cllr Thomas to Cllr Howell Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Communities and Leisure For years Councillors in Elmdon and Lyndon have been trying to get their badly deteriorated tennis courts in Elmdon and Olton Jubilee Parks refurbished and whilst the council has never been able to afford the £50,000 required to do each of these, they did find £600,000 to refurbish the outdoor pitch at Tudor Grange Leisure Centre, as well as finding a further £267,000 to cover the overspend. Why can the council find 8.5 times the money for one pitch, but not the money for two tennis courts?
Declared17 Jan 2023Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Declarations of Pecuniary or Conflicts of Interest
Councillor Thomas declared a non-pecuniary interest in relation to ‘Draft Climate Change Supplementary Document’, informing the Scrutiny Board that her employer JLR submitted planning applications for site located in the borough of Solihull.
Named17 Jan 2023Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Net Zero Action Plan Annual Report 2021/2022
Councillor Thomas clarified that on page 19 of the NZAP Annual Report 2021/22 (5.4.1 Cycling Infrastructure ), the 2 cycle lanes referenced were not new, but rather had been subject to various improvements.
Said17 Jan 2023Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Net Zero Action Plan Annual Report 2021/2022
Councillor Thomas noted that the biggest gaps and challenges found within the NZAP were found on page 16, which referenced 11,000 households as being in fuel poverty and questioned whether the Council could bring them out of fuel poverty, and on page 25 (Section 8: Energy Supply ), asking why the Council was not seeking to accelerate renewable energy capacity as originally hoped for. Members were advised that there were several underlying issues in relation to addressing fuel poverty in the borough. Current energy costs would have a significant impact on achieving fuel poverty goals, as did the current cost of living crisis.
Asked17 Jan 2023Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Draft Climate Change Supplementary Planning Documnet (SPD)
Councillor Thomas queried whether in terms of Building Standards referenced in the Draft Climate Change SPD would it be possible to include reference to adherence to future 2025 Building Standards.
Asked17 Jan 2023Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Draft Climate Change Supplementary Planning Documnet (SPD)
In reference to dedicated recycling space, especially for apartments and low- rise blocks, Councillor Thomas questioned whether an addition could be made to include reference to provision of collecting waste from flats that does not rely on plastic sacks i.e. adequate waste collection services.
Said17 Jan 2023Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Draft Climate Change Supplementary Planning Documnet (SPD)
Referencing Solihull Cycle Network, Councillor Thomas stated that the canal routes were very challenging, difficult to access (with provision of steps only, not ramps) and that some sections of the route were too narrow to cycle on.
Said10 Jan 2023Stronger Communities and Neighbourhood Services Scrutiny Board
Questions and Deputations
Cllr K Thomas introduced Louise Whillock, a coordinator of the Lyndon Ward Community Street and Speed Watch Team who made a deputation to the Board. In summary, the deputation highlighted:
Seconded5 Jul 2022Council
Notice of Motion
Councillor Thomas seconded the motion.
Seconded5 Jul 2022Council
Notice of Motion
The motion was debated and then Cllr L McCarthy proposed an amendment seconded by Cllr Thomas, the amendment read:
Said5 Jul 2022Council
Reports from Cabinet
Cllr K Thomas welcomed the establishment of a walking orienteering programme within the borough and the Cabinet Member thanked her for supporting the initiative.
Named6 Apr 2022Children’s Services & Education Scrutiny Board
Apologies
Councillor J Hamilton Councillor L McCarthy (Councillor K Thomas – substitute) Parent Governor Representative S Golby Councillor A Rebeiro and [name removed], Diocesan representative, submitted their apologies and joined the meeting remotely.
Named5 Apr 2022Council
Petitions
From Cllr K Thomas – Submitted a petition on behalf of residents of Solihull calling for more community police on our streets and a fully functioning police station in the Town Centre.
Asked5 Apr 2022Council
Reports from Cabinet
Cllr Thomas questioned whether the Cabinet Member was satisfied with the quality of the consultation that had been undertaken in relation to Summerfield Education Centre, given the concerns raised by Lyndon School. The Cabinet Member advised he would discuss this with officers.
Asked5 Apr 2022Council
Reports from Cabinet
Cllr K Thomas queried whether Bookfest would be returning next year, the Cabinet Member hoped it was.
Said8 Mar 2022Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Solihull Community Housing: Delivery Plan 2022/23
Councillor K Thomas advised the meeting that for residents the SCH housing list waiting times was the most important of all KPI’s, which currently appeared to cover a timescale of between two to five years.
Asked8 Mar 2022Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Solihull Community Housing: Delivery Plan 2022/23
Councillor K Thomas queried what actions were being undertaken by SCH in order to reduce waiting times. The Chief Executive (SCH) stated that the key question to be addressed related to housing supply, for which SCH had no control. Housing supply in relation to waiting list times was a national issue and further factor which had to be considered within that was provision of social housing.
Said8 Mar 2022Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Solihull Community Housing: Delivery Plan 2022/23
Councillor K Thomas noted that reference was made within the SCH Delivery Plan to building sustainable housing supply, but that no detail seemed to be included in the Strategic ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Said8 Mar 2022Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Inclusive Growth Update
Councillor K Thomas welcomed the initiatives in the Inclusive Growth Strategy supporting pathways into employment and re-training, which Councillor K Thomas noted was particularly helpful for the long-term unemployed, but which also had the potential to act as unpaid work.
Said8 Mar 2022Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Inclusive Growth Update
With respect to the Levelling Up White Paper and entry level jobs, Councillor K Thomas noted that the salaries offered were not the best and that those taking up such employment were likely to still remain in some financial difficulty.
Asked8 Mar 2022Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Inclusive Growth Update
Councillor K Thomas further queried what actions were being taken to address the prospects of those already in employment, ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Asked8 Mar 2022Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Economic Development and Managed Growth Scrutiny Board Draft Work Programme 2022/2023
Having read the Clean Strategy and Air Quality Monitoring Briefing Note Update as supplied by the Senior Public Health Specialist, Councillor K Thomas queried whether the Council should consider reducing monitoring and instead increasing action to address problematic areas directly.
Named8 Feb 2022Council
Petitions
We are also asking West Midlands Police to increase the number of speed checks on Elmdon roads to deter excessive speeding.” 3) From Cllr L McCarthy – “Residents are asking Solihull Council to undertake another investigation into Rowood Drive with the view to installing average speed cameras to control the speeding or else consult with residents about their preferred method of traffic calming and implement this.” 4) From Cllr Gibbin – Speed Reduction/Traffic Calming Measures – “We the undersigned call upon SMBC to introduce speed reduction/traffic calming measures on Brook Lane.” 5) From Cllr Gibbin – Speed Reduction/Traffic Calming Measures –“ We the undersigned call upon SMBC to introduce speed reduction/traffic calming measures on Dovehouse/Lane.” 6) From Cllr K Thomas – “We, the undersigned, call on Solihull Council to renew the leases of The 1st Olton Scout Group and The Olton Park Guides, for their respective premises on Brackleys Way, ensuring that they have security of tenure for the foreseeable future.” 7) From Cllr B Grinsell – Road Safety Measures- “Following a fatal accident and other traffic incidents we the undersigned call upon SMBC to investigate suitable road safety options for the junction of Warwick Road and Grange Road as a matter of urgency.
Named8 Feb 2022Council
Questions under Standing Order 8
Councillor K Thomas to Councillor Rolf Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Stronger and Safer Communities Why are the Scouts and Guides huts on Brackleys Way, next to Olton Jubilee Park, still threatened with demolition, four years after promises were made that leases for both Groups would be renewed and they would be able to continue operating out of their current premises?
Asked8 Feb 2022Council
Questions under Standing Order 8
Councillor K Thomas asked what could be done to improve communication with the Scout and Guide Group as the matter progressed.
Asked8 Feb 2022Council
Questions under Standing Order 8
Councillor K Thomas queried what lessons could be learned from this matter to ensure other voluntary and community groups did not have similar experiences.
Seconded8 Feb 2022Council
Notice of Motion
The Second Motion was from Cllr Laura McCarthy and seconded by Cllr K Thomas and read:
Said8 Feb 2022Council
Reports from Cabinet
In reference to 1.4.4, Councillor K Thomas noted the significant increase in residents that requested additional support over the Christmas period, and asked if this had continued into January 2022.
Named8 Feb 2022Council
Reports from Cabinet
Further information would be provided to Councillor K Thomas.
Asked8 Feb 2022Council
Minutes of Scrutiny Boards
a) Resources and Delivering Value 2 December 2021 and 4 January 2022 b) Stronger Communities and Neighbourhood Services 6 January 2022 c) Children’s Services, Education and Skills 11 January 2022 d) Economic Development and Managed Growth 12 January 2022 e) Health and Adult Social Care 18 January 2022 Councillor K Thomas asked how the Building Safety Managers positions would be funded, which were referenced in the Resources and Delivering Value Scrutiny Board on 2 nd December 2021.
Named8 Feb 2022Council
Minutes of Scrutiny Boards
Cllr Parker as Chairman advised that a response would be sought for Councillor K Thomas.
Asked12 Jan 2022Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
MTFS Update – Budget Strategy 2022/23 – 2024/25
Councillor K Thomas queried whether the proposed Planning Services fees and charges schedule met the costs of the actual planning services being delivered and met the costs for the proposed additional planning staff. Members were informed that the Council did not set fees or charges associated with planning applications, but were set centrally. However, the Council did ensure that its costs were covered for supplying planning advice via Council staff.
Said7 Jun 2021Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Obstructions to New Housing Provision and Securing Land Supply in Solihull
Councillor K Thomas presented a Powerpoint presentation for the benefit of the Scrutiny Board, detailing properties for sale advertised on Right Move in August 2020 based on price, property size and impact on affordability for different demographics, including young people and first time buyers in relative terms.
Asked7 Jun 2021Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board
Obstructions to New Housing Provision and Securing Land Supply in Solihull
Councillor K Thomas questioned what steps were needed to be taken to reduce the cost of house building and what made houses so expensive when compared to rebuild costs for insurance purposes.
Said24 May 2021Call In Committee
Call-in notice
Councillor K Thomas addressed the Call-In Committee stating that she was concerned with the decision taken by the Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and Highways for the following reasons.
Said24 May 2021Call In Committee
Call-in notice
Councillor Thomas advised the Call-In Committee that the decision for the Call-In was not related to the decision to approve the West Midlands Hire Scheme in principle, nor was it a matter of governance process or procedure, but rather a matter pertaining to equality and fairness, life chances and health outcomes. The proposed first tranche for the 10 cycle hire locations in the Wards of Sillhill , St. Alphege , Knowle and Blythe rank as 75 th percentile and above nationally on the index of deprivation , whereas Ward in North Solihull fell within the top 10% nationally for measurements of deprivation.
Named13 Apr 2021Council
Questions under Standing Order 8
Councillor K Thomas to Councillor Mackiewicz, Cabinet Member for Climate Change, Planning and Housing “Like many councils, we have declared a climate emergency and the early working group sessions are indicating the scale of the change required. This level of change will require substantial investment. What national or regional funding is being made available to enable us to deliver the required change and what percentage/actions of our targeted improvement is this expected to deliver?” In response the Cabinet Member highlighted that the Net Zero Action Plan Green Paper had recently been published, which would flag what activities would be required to achieve net zero.
Said13 Apr 2021Council
Questions under Standing Order 8
Councillor Thomas requested further information about future funding streams.
Asked13 Apr 2021Council
Reports from Cabinet
Councillor Kathryn Thomas asked whether it would be possible to get an additional report provided for future full Council meetings from the Climate Change Commission to oversee the output the Commission’s meetings and activities. The Cabinet Member explained that the intention for the Committee would liaise with the Cabinet Member and Opposition Spokespersons, as well as present a report to full Council. It was not expected to present a report to every meeting.
Asked2 Feb 2021Council
Reports from Cabinet
Councillor K Thomas queried how the target of increased percentage of children walking to school would be met through the decision about Cheswick Green Primary School. The Cabinet Member explained that it would be expected that the children on the new housing development in Cheswick Green would walk to the school but there would still need to be capacity for parking facilities for those who would need to drive. ... view the full minutes text for item 12.
Said23 Jul 2020Call In Committee
Call-In Notice
Councillor K Thomas addressed the Call-In Committee stating that she was concerned with the decision taken by the Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and Highways for the following reasons.
Said23 Jul 2020Call In Committee
Call-In Notice
Councillor Thomas noted that since the proposals had been originally presented to Cabinet in October 2019, substantial changes had occurred since then, with the Council facing an £18M budget deficit arising through actions taken to address the Covid-19 pandemic, which placed additional need to deliver value for money. The Council’s preferred contract option did not offer Best Value for Money in this scenario.
Named12 Mar 2020Children’s Services & Education Scrutiny Board
Apologies
Councillors A Adeyemo (Councillor K Thomas - substitute), K Blunt, J Butler, J Hamilton (Councillor Dr Sexton - substitute), L McCarthy (Councillor G Slater - substitute) and co-opted Member [name removed].
Named27 Feb 2020Council
Questions under Standing Order 8 (30 Minutes)
Councillor K Thomas to Cllr Hawkins Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and Highways “When it comes to inconsiderate and illegal parking please could you clarify who between Solihull MBC and the police is responsible for taking the lead on tackling these issues?
Named27 Feb 2020Council
Questions under Standing Order 8 (30 Minutes)
Councillor K Thomas to Councillor Meeson Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Children, Education and Skills “If I was 15 and living in Lyndon, where could I go to hang around with my mates in an evening?” In Councillor Meeson’s absence, Councillor Rolf, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Stronger and Safer Communities responded with the following points:
Asked27 Feb 2020Council
Questions under Standing Order 8 (30 Minutes)
Councillor Thomas asked whether there was anywhere within Lyndon that young people could hang out at informally.
Moved12 Jul 2019Greater Birmingham & Solihull Local Enterprise Partnership Joint Scrutiny Committee
Appointment of Chairman and Vice Chairman to the GBSLEP Joint Scrutiny Committee
Councillor Thomas proposed Councillor Peaple for the position of Vice Chairman, seconded by Councillor Hart.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.