Flood Risk Management Delivery and Performance
Dean Ward – Head of Highways; and Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Member (Environment & Infrastructure Portfolio).
Every time Solihull's minutes name Councillor Hawkins, as the council published it.
Dean Ward – Head of Highways; and Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Member (Environment & Infrastructure Portfolio).
Dean Ward – Head of Highways; Duljit Madahar – Strategic Lead (Highways Management); Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Member (Environment & Infrastructure Portfolio).
Councillor K Hawkins, Cabinet Member for Environment and Infrastructure advised that the work was on the programme to be completed in the current financial year.
(i) Councillor Whelan to Councillor Hawkins, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and Infrastructure “There are many alleyways across the Solihull borough that are in desperate need of maintenance and improvement. Issues include poor surfacing, significant weed growth, overgrown trees and shrubs, inadequate or non-existent lighting, and damaged fencing.
Councillor K Hawkins, seconded by Councillor W Qais, proposed that the Motion be referred to Scrutiny for consideration. This was put to the vote and agreed.
Councillor K Thomas, seconded by Councillor K Hawkins, moved the Motion as printed.
In attendance: Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Member (Environment & Infrastructure Portfolio); Dean Ward – Head of Highways; Louise Baggott – Head of Regulatory Services; and Claire Rudge - Group Manager - Growth Strategy & Commissioning.
Councillor K Grinsell – Leader of the Council, Lead Member for Children & Education Councillor H Delaney – Deputy Leader of the Council and Economy, business & Skills Portfolio Councillor D Pinwell – Resources Portfolio Councillor K Hawkins – Environment & Infrastructure Portfolio Councillor T Dicicco – Adult Social Care & Health Portfolio Councillor W Qais – Communities Portfolio Councillor A Mackiewicz – Climate Change & Planning Councillor M Parker – Housing Portfolio
Councillor Bradley to Councillor Hawkins – Cabinet Member for Environment & Infrastructure On the 1st April, the WMCA’s West Midlands Cycle Hire scheme transitioned to using Lime e-bikes. Many cities with Lime schemes seem to have a corresponding issue of bikes or scooters being dumped in random places.
Councillor Dawkins to Councillor Hawkins – Cabinet Portfolio Holder - Environment & Infrastructure How do residents report fly tipping when council officials are no longer promoting Fix My Street due to the issues of locating the fly tipping.
Councillor Sharma to Councillor Hawkins – Cabinet Portfolio Holder - Environment & Infrastructure Aqueduct Road has become a dumping ground with deteriorating conditions and increased fly-tipping since closure.
Councillor Dawkins to Councillor Hawkins – Cabinet Portfolio Holder - Environment & Infrastructure Can the Cabinet Member tell me why some areas are denied a black bin, given the environmental and health risks to the local area?
· Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Member (Environmental & Infrastructure Portfolio).
Cllr McLoughlin to Cllr Hawkins – Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and Infrastructure At the 3rd February meeting of Council, the Cabinet Member stated that repairs were conducted to the pavement in Widney Lane last year where they met DfT and SMBC intervention levels. Can the Cabinet Member confirm that SMBC has higher standards than the DfT and whether they comply with the standards set in “Inclusive Mobility” published by the DfT in December 2021?
Cllr Thomas to Cllr Hawkins– Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and Infrastructure Why did the Council manage to misrepresent the views of Barston Parish Council so comprehensively at the Environment & Infrastructure decision session in January?
Cllr Gough to Cllr Hawkins – Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and Infrastructure I've seen pothole complaints flooding in from residents and colleagues across all parties. Our roads are literally crumbling! How has the Conservative administration allowed this to get so bad?
· Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Member (Environmental & Infrastructure Portfolio).
Councillor Karen Grinsell, Leader of the Council and Lead Member for Children & Education Councillor Ian Courts, Deputy Leader of the Council and Lead Member for Managed Growth Councillor Bob Sleigh OBE, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Resources (V) Councillor Ken Hawkins, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment & Infrastructure Councillor Andrew Mackiewicz, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Climate Change & Planning Councillor Mark Parker, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Housing Councillor Wazma Qais, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Communities Councillor Heather Delaney, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Economy, Business and Skills Corporate Leadership Team:
Cllr Hawkins submitted a petition signed by 331 residents objecting to planning application PL/2025/02373/PPOL – Land East of Joseph House Stratford Road, Shirley, Solihull.
In attendance: Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Member (Environment & Infrastructure Portfolio); and Sarah Alder - Assistant Director (Highways, Environment & Sustainability).
In attendance: Sarah Alder - Assistant Director (Highways, Environment & Sustainability); Duljit Madahar – Strategic Lead – Highway Management; and Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Member (Environment & Infrastructure Portfolio).
· Councillor Karen Grinsell –Leader of the Council, Lead Member for Children and Education · Councillor Ian Courts – Deputy Leader of the Council, Managed Growth Lead · Councillor Ken Hawkins – Environment and Infrastructure Portfolio;
Cllr McLoughlin to Cllr Hawkins – Cabinet Member for Environment and Infrastructure Having requested speed monitoring equipment (speed strips) at three locations in my ward, two where issues of speeding have been reported and are on the approach to a location of two different fatalities, and one where a reduction in the speed limit has been requested, I was told that this was “non-essential spending” and could not be afforded at this time. Is speed monitoring “non-essential”?
In attendance: Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Member (Environment & Infrastructure Portfolio); Sarah Alder - Assistant Director (Highways, Environment & Sustainability) ; and Dean Ward – Head of Highway Infrastructure.
Cllr McLoughlin to Cllr Hawkins – Cabinet Member for Environment and Infrastructure Is the junction between Highlands Road and Cranmore Boulevard safe?
Cllr Dawkins to Cllr Hawkins – Cabinet Member for Environment and Infrastructure Residents in Eileen Gardens have contacted me with their concerns regarding parking on their road and how it has led to threats of a criminal nature from other residents. In addition, due to the number of vehicles to property ratio, the parking has led to incidents where emergency Services are unable to drive down the road.
Cllr McLoughlin referred to an answer Cllr Hawkins - Cabinet Member for Environment and Infrastructure gave in relation to CIL funding earlier in the evening and asked what the difference was between parish and ward CIL and what it was used for . The Cabinet Member advised that this information could be found on the Council website. The Cabinet Member went on to explain what the strategic CIL was used for.
Councillor Ian Courts, Lead Member for the Economy and Business and Leader of the Council Councillor Karen Grinsell, Lead Members for Children & Education and Deputy Leader of the Council Councillor Bob Sleigh OBE, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Resources Councillor Ken Hawkins, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment & Infrastructure Councillor Andrew Mackiewicz, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Climate Change & Planning Councillor Mark Parker, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Housing Councillor Wazma Qais, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Communities Councillor Michael Gough, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Employment, Skills and Inclusion Councillor Tony Dicicco, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Adult Social Care & Health (V) Corporate Leadership Team:
Cllr S Sheshabhatter to Cllr K Hawkins – Cabinet Member for Environment ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
The Cabinet Member for Environment and Infrastructure, Cllr Hawkins responded.
Cllr Hawkins expressed his deepest sympathy to [name removed].
Cllr Hawkins offered to meet with [name removed] and road safety partners, to discuss his concerns in more detail.
Cllr B Grinsell to Cllr Hawkins – Cabinet for Environment & Infrastructure With regards to the Dual Cycle Lane that runs along Blossomfield Road (B4102).
Cllr McLoughlin to Cllr Hawkins – Cabinet Member for Environment & Infrastructure What actions has the Cabinet Member taken to make Bills Lane safer for cyclists and pedestrians?
Cllr McLoughlin to Cllr Hawkins – Cabinet Member for Environment & Infrastructure Has the School Streets scheme been a success in Clifton Crescent?
Cllr M Wilson to Cllr Hawkins -Cabinet Member for Environment & Infrastructure How many vehicles need to travel between 55-65mph down a 30mph residential road in a single week for you to acknowledge there is a problem with speeding on that road?
Cllr Sheshabhatter to Cllr Hawkins – Cabinet Member for Environment & Infrastructure Can the Cabinet Member confirm how many new, accessible items of play equipment for children with disabilities have been installed in our parks in the past 5 years and what action has the Cabinet member taken on this matter since I raised a similar question in July 2023? The Cabinet Member responded that over the last 5 years the Council have installed 9 new inclusive play items including interactive play panels at ground level, communication panels to assist non-verbal children, roundabouts for wheelchair users and pushchairs, spinning dish and so on. Solihull have had inclusive play equipment in some of our parks for more than 20 years and that we have a good range of inclusive equipment across all the 36 play areas we manage.
Cllr Sheshabhatter to Cllr Hawkins – Cabinet for Environment & Infrastructure Can the Cabinet Member confirm how frequently our parks are monitored for maintenance to benches and play equipment? The Cabinet Member advised that park visits were undertaken by officers and Council contractors on a daily basis.
Cllr Sheshabhatter to Cllr Hawkins – Cabinet Member for Environment & Infrastructure Can the Cabinet Member update Council on what progress has been made getting street cabinets decorated in ... view the full minutes text for item 18.
· Councillor Karen Grinsell – Deputy Leader of the Council, Lead Member for Children and Education · Councillor Ken Hawkins – Environment and Infrastructure Portfolio;
In attendance: Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Member (Environment & Infrastructure Portfolio) and Alan Brown - Assistant Director for Highways and Environment.
Cllr Hawkins suggested that Ward Members had a key role in communicating information such as this to their residents.
Cllr Hawkins outlined the Council’s process for Traffic Regulation Orders and confirmed that the contract for enforcement provided sufficient flexibility to deploy those resources to areas of greater non-compliance.
Present Councillors: M McCarthy (Chairman), K Meeson, S Gethen, L Kaye, N Moses, K Thomas, A Hodgson Officers Guests In Attendance Paul Johnson, Chief Executive Andrew Felton, Director of Resources Samantha Gilbert, Assistant Director, Finance & Property Services Julie Cooper, Head of Financial Operations Moji Olusoga (V), Insurance Manager Sara Barnes, Head of Business Intelligence & Improvement Paul Rogers: Democratic Services Councillor Ian Courts, Leader of the Council and Lead Member for the Econo Economy Councillor Karen Grinsell, Deputy Leader and Lead Member for Wellbeing, Skills & Inclusion Councillor Bob Sleigh OBE, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Resources Councillor Ken Hawkins, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment & Infrastructure Councillor Andrew Mackiewicz, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Climate Change & Planning Laura Shoaf OBE, Chief Executive, WMCA James Hughes, Member Relationship Manager, WMCA Dan Essex, Governance Manager, WMCA Councillor Cathy Bayton, Chair OSC, WMCA Councillor John McNicholas , Chair Transport Delivery OSC, WMCA The Resources and Delivering Value Scrutiny Board meeting commenced at 6:00 p.m.
3) Cllr Hawkins submitted a petition on behalf of residents objecting to the housing development on Tilehouse Lane, Dickens Heath.
Cllr McLoughlin referenced an answer to a question given by Cllr Hawkins regarding the yearly clearance of drains, having seen one which had not been cleared within the timeframe suggested.
Cllr Hawkins confirmed that drains were cleared yearly and suggested that if any Member spotted a problem to inform Officers.
In attendance: Lauren Beach (Economy & Infrastructure Finance Manager); Andrea Santer (Public Health Finance Manager); [name removed] - Assistant Director (Communities & Partnerships); Alan Brown (Assistant Director – Highways & Environment); Neeraj Malhotra (Deputy Director of Public Health); Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Member (Environment & Infrastructure Portfolio); and Councillor W Qais – Cabinet Member (Communities & Leisure Portfolio).
In attendance: Paul Tovey – Head of Highway Management; and Dean Ward – Head of Highway Infrastructure; and Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Member (Environment & Infrastructure Portfolio).
In attendance: Chris Barr – Head of Public Realm; David Turton – Forestry Services Manager; Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Member (Environment & Infrastructure Portfolio); and Cllr A Mackiewicz – Cabinet Member (Climate Change & Planning Portfolio).
Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Climate Change and Planning (Virtual) Councillor M Parker: Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Housing Councillor K Hawkins: Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment & Infrastructure Perry Wardle: Assistant Director, Growth and Development Austin Rodriguez: Head of Communities and Partnerships Clare Rudge: Group Manager, Growth, Strategy & Commissioning Ann Marie Attfield: Group Manager Climate Change & Sustainability Lauren Beach: Managed Growth Finance Manager Paul Rogers: Democratic Services Chet Parmar, Chief Executive Officer Colebridge Trust Katie Washbourne, Chief Executive Officer Ordinary Magic CIC The Economic Development and Managed Growth Scrutiny Board meeting commenced at 6:00 p.m.
Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Climate Change and Planning Councillor K Hawkins: Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and Infrastructure Councillor M Parker: Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Housing Perry Wardle: Assistant Director, Growth and Development Mark Andrews: Head of Planning (V) M Eastwood: Team Manager, CLAUDE N Walker: ERDF Development Officer Paul Rogers: Democratic Services The Economic Development and Managed Growth Scrutiny Board meeting commenced at 6:00 p.m.
In attendance: Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Member (Environment & Infrastructure Portfolio); Alan Brown (Assistant Director – Highways & Environment); and Paul Tovey – Head of Highway Management.
Cllr Hawkins advised it was disappointing to hear that, as there was a lot of work going on in the area of active travel. If Members had issues or heard of issues relating to services, then please report them to Transport for West Midlands and me.
In attendance: Councillor W Qais – Cabinet Member (Communities & Leisure) and Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Member (Environment & Infrastructure).
Councillor Karen Grinsell requested to speak on application 2022/00040 – 27 Danford Lane, Solihull; Councillor Ken Hawkins on 2022/00313 – 18 Griffin Lane, Dickens Heath; Councillor Ade Adeyemo on 2023/00450 – Richmond Road, Olton; and Councillor Bob Sleigh on 2023/00492 – 55 Marsh Lane, Hampton-in-Arden.
[name removed] and Councillor Ken Hawkins spoke against the application whilst [name removed] spoke in support.
· Councillor Ken Hawkins – Environment and Infrastructure Portfolio;
Cllr K Hawkins, CPH Environment and Infrastructure advised that January and February had been particularly harsh with low temperatures followed by a very wet March which had impacted the condition of the roads. The team was working on repairing potholes as quickly as possible and they had employed an extra crew to help tackle the backlog with this crew being extended throughout April.
In attendance: Councillor D Howell – Cabinet Member (Communities & Leisure) and Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Member (Environment & Infrastructure).
Cllr Hawkins responded to the deputation.
Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Climate Change, Planning and Housing Councillor K Hawkins: Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment & Infrastructure Christine Doel : Project Director, SQW Perry Wardle: Assistant Director, Growth and Development Rupert Waters: Interim Head of Economic Development Rachel Egan: Head of Inclusive Growth Paul Rogers: Democratic Services The Economic Development and Managed Growth Scrutiny Board meeting commenced at 6:00 p.m.
Councillor Hawkins (Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and Infrastructure) provided the following highlights from his portfolio for the 2022/23 municipal year:
· Councillor Ken Hawkins – Environment and Infrastructure Portfolio;
In attendance: Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Member (Environment & Infrastructure); and Alan Brown (Assistant Director – Highways & Environment).
Councillor Caudwell (Leader of Green Party Group) to Councillor Hawkins, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and Infrastructure “Council will be aware of recent media reports that a ballot has opened among GMB Union members for strike action over pay relating to the Strategic Environment Contract.
What action is the Cabinet Member taking to avert that potential strike action affecting our bin collections and street cleaning services and what mitigations are in place to ensure service continuity should the industrial action not be avoided?” Councillor Hawkins explained that Amey employ the workforce and deliver the Environmental Services Contract which includes refuse collections.
Officers Councillor I Courts, Councillor K Grinsell, Councillor A Rolf, Councillor T Dicicco, Councillor K Hawkins, Councillor R Sleigh OBE Nick Page: Chief Executive, Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council Paul Johnson: Director of Resources and Deputy Chief Executive Jenny Wood: Director, Adult Care & Support Ruth Tennant:
Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Climate Change, Planning and Housing Councillor K Hawkins: Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and Infrastructure Perry Wardle: Assistant Director, Growth and Development John Pitcher: Team Leader, Policy & Delivery Alison McGrory: Assistant Director, Communities and Partnerships John Halton :
Councillor Courts (Leader of the Council and Cabinet Portfolio Holder for the Economy), Councillor Hawkins (Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and Infrastructure) and Councillor Mackiewicz (Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Climate Change, Planning and Housing) were present to detail their respective portfolio priorities for the 2021/22 municipal year.
Councillor Hawkins (Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and Infrastructure) detailed his key priorities for the 2021/22 municipal year as:
Present: Councillors: M Gough, M Brain, S Caudwell, P Hogarth MBE, D Holl-Allen MBE, M McLoughlin, M Parker In Attendance: Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and Highways Councillor T Hodgson Councillor K Thomas Councillor D Cole Officers: Alan Brown: Assistant Director, Highways & Environment Paul Tovey: Head of Highway Management Joseph Bright: Democratic Services Paul Rogers:
The Chairman invited Councillor Hawkins, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and Infrastructure, to respond to the Call-In Notice.
Councillor Hawkins addressed the Call-In Committee and stated that Was a public transport scheme funded by the West Midlands Combined Authority (WMCA) and approved in July 2020. An initial tranche of 1,500 bicycles were to be introduced in all West Midlands towns. The scheme was a commercial transport scheme where customers were expected to pay a fee for cycle hire, with journeys taking place between docking stations, retail centres, public transport interchanges and significant public buildings such as hospitals, colleges, leisure facilities and workplaces.
Councillor Hawkins acknowledged the issue of health inequalities and the 10 years life gap between residents in the north and south of the borough, which the Council Plan also addressed, highlighted that the main priority of the West Midlands Cycle Hire Scheme was to provide affordable public transport in the West Midlands region and provide further public transport options for residents. This was phase one of the scheme across the West Midlands and within Solihull.
Councillor Hawkins stated that the initiatives being delivered through his Portfolio would continue to address the life expectancy gap in the borough as a priority, with many of the schemes being open and promoted to schools and community groups.
· Leader of the Council, Lead Member for the Economy – Cllr Ian Courts · Deputy Leader of the Council, Lead Member for Partnerships and Wellbeing – Cllr Karen Grinsell · Environment and Infrastructure – Cllr Ken Hawkins · Resources – Cllr Bob Sleigh OBE · Stronger and Safer Communities – Cllr Alison Rolf · Children, Education and Skills – Cllr Richard Holt · Adult Social Care and Health – Cllr Tony Dicicco · Leisure, Tourism and Sport – Cllr Joe Tildesley · Climate Change, Planning and Housing – Cllr Andy Mackiewicz
Sherbourne Recycling Limited - Cllr K Hawkins was appointed Castle Bromwich Hall Gardens Trust Cllrs M McCarthy and J Tildesley were appointed LAYCA Trust Cllr A Mackenzie was appointed.
Councillor Hawkins – Cabinet Member for Environment and Highways The Cabinet Member advised Council of the decisions taken at the decision sessions on 16 February and 17 March 2021.
In attendance: Councillor Mrs A Rolf – Cabinet Member (Stronger & Safer Communities); Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Member (Environment & Highways); [name removed] (Assistant Director – Communities & Partnerships); Alan Brown (Assistant Director – Highways & Environment) and Nick Garnett (Senior Public Health Manager - Leisure).
In attendance: [name removed] (Assistant Director – Communities & Partnerships); Alan Brown (Assistant Director – Highways & Environment); Lauren Beach (Economy and Infrastructure Finance Manager); Councillor Mrs A Rolf – Cabinet Member (Stronger & Safer Communities); Councillor J Tildesley – Cabinet Member (Leisure, Tourism & Sport); and Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Member (Environment & Highways).
Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Member (Environment & Highways); and Inspector Sharon Jones (West Midlands Police).
The Chairman invited Councillor Hawkins, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and Highways, to respond to the Call-In Notice.
Councillor Hawkins stated that firstly he believed the Call-in of the decision was not required and believed that had a LACTO been established through his CPH Decision Session no Call-in Notice would have been enacted.
Councillor Hawkins noted that at the Stronger Communities and Neighbourhood Scrutiny Board meeting held on 16 th June 2020, Cross-Party Members had reviewed the contract and had recommended that the Strategic Environment Contract Procurement Strategy be supported.
Councillor Hawkins advised that he had attended the Stronger Communities and Neighbourhood Scrutiny Board meeting held on 16 th June 2020 and the Minutes arising from that meeting were a true and accurate note of the proceedings.
Councillor Hawkins proceeded to respond to the Call-In Notice, stating that there were distinct areas of the contract, which included proportionality and openness, cost, contract nature, contract length, Key Performance Indicators (KPI’s) and ICT.
In respect of proportionality and openness, Councillor Hawkins stated that the scope of the new contract would be the same as the current contract, with the addition of Forestry Services. However, there would be an emphasis on moving towards more sustainable vehicle choices and delivering the Council’s targets for carbon reduction. Options in the contract would also provide bidders with the option of bidding for food waste collections.
Councillor Hawkins stated that the Council’s current contract was exemplary and one of the best performing in the U.K.
Regarding cost, Councillor Hawkins stated that the figures provided to Cabinet in October 2019 were based on the current service provision, but some changes through procurement for the new procurement may have an effect on these costs, such as procurement of alternative fuelled vehicles, new collection methods and recycling a wider range of materials. No decision had been taken at this time regarding the final shape of the future service, only the method of procurement.
Councillor Hawkins submitted a petition on behalf of local residents which called on Solihull Council to reverse proposals to reduce opening hours at Dickens Heath Community Library.
Councillor Allen to Councillor Hawkins, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and Highways “The A34 Stratford Road in Shirley has been identified in the Council’s Road Safety strategy because of the high collision history especially at the junction with Stanton Road.
In attendance: Alan Brown (Assistant Director – Environment & Highways, Managed Growth and Communities Directorate); [name removed] (Assistant Director - Stronger Communities, Managed Growth and Communities Directorate); Lauren Beach (Finance Manager – Managed Growth and Communities); Councillor Mrs A Rolf – Cabinet Member (Stronger & Safer Communities); Councillor K Hawkins – Cabinet Member (Environment & Highways); and Councillor J Tildesley – Cabinet Member (Leisure, Tourism & Sport).
Present: Cabinet Members: Councillors: M Parker (Chairman), J Ryan (Vice Chairman), D Howell, W Qais, P Thomas, M McLoughlin, T Hodgson, C Williams and M Brain Guests: Councillor I Courts: Leader of the Council and Cabinet Portfolio Holder for the Economy Councillor A Mackiewicz: Cabinet Portfolio Holder Climate Change, Planning & Housing Officers: Perry Wardle (Assistant Director, Growth & Development) Lauren Beach (Managed Growth Finance Manager) Sangeeta Leahy (Assistant Director, Public Health) Amanda Clover (Senior Development Officer, Planning, Design & Engagement Services) Paul Tovey (Group Leader - Sustainable Travel and Highway Management) Tom Layzell (Growth Policy Officer, Growth and Development) Paul Rogers (Democratic Services) Councillors in Attendance: Councillor K Hawkins, CPH - Environment & Highways The Economic Development and Managed Growth Scrutiny Board meeting commenced at 6:00 p.m .
· Leaders Portfolio (Economy) - Cllr I Courts · Growth & Infrastructure Delivery - Cllr T Richards OBE · Environment & Highways - Cllr K Hawkins · Resources - Cllr B Sleigh OBE · Stronger & Safer Communities - Cllr A Rolf · Children, Education & Skills - Cllr K Meeson · Adult Social Care & Health and Deputy Leader - Cllr K Grinsell · Leisure, Tourism & Sport - Cllr J Tildesley · Climate Change, Planning & Housing - Cllr A Mackiewicz
Councillor Hawkins submitted his apologies.
· Councillor Hawkins submitted a petition from local residents calling on Transport for West Midlands and Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council to establish a seated bus shelter on Station Road, Solihull, for users of the number 5 bus service.
· Councillor Hawkins submitted a petition from local residents objecting to the introduction of a motorway service area at Junction 4 M42.
Accordingly, Councillor Mrs Holl-Allen MBE proposed Councillor Ken Hawkins, seconded by Councillor Martin McCarthy.
Councillor Hawkins was duly appointed as Chairman for the Health and Adult Social Care Scrutiny Board and took the Chair
The Scrutiny Board considered the report of the Assistant Director Growth and Development on the Cabinet Portfolio Holder (CPH) for Environment , Housing and Regeneration`s new and on-going Priorities for 2017/18.The Scrutiny Board received a presentation from the CPH, Councillor K Hawkins on the above report. The report and presentation detailed the following on-going and new CPH Priorities for 2017/18:
The CPH, Councillor Hawkins replied in detail to the comments made by Members and confirmed that Ward Members and all interested parties would be kept informed of the progress of the Shirley Business Improvement District (BID).
In attendance: Councillor K Hawkins – Portfolio Holder for Environment, Housing & Regeneration and Jim Harte (Assistant Director - Stronger Communities, Managed Growth and Communities Directorate).
The Board welcomed Councillor Hawkins to the meeting who presented the priorities for his Portfolio over the coming 12 months.
The Call –In request related to the decision of Councillor K Hawkins ,Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment, Housing and Regeneration in respect of the Meriden Park Adventure Park .
The Call-In Committee considered a report prepared on behalf of Councillor K Hawkins which responded to the reasons for the Call-In request. The report advised that the Meriden Adventure Playground was established in 2007 with big lottery funding. In 2012 a friends of group (MAPA) was established to support the playground.
From Cllr Tim Hodgson to Cllr Hawkins – Cabinet Portfolio Holder Environment, Housing and Regeneration “Given the change in the legislation meaning that 18-21 year olds who find themselves needing housing benefit won’t get financial support any more, please can you explain to Council what Solihull Community Housing (SCH) is doing to enable them to pay rent on a property to live in when they find themselves homeless?” The Cabinet responded, confirming the Council and SCH would be working with DWP and housing providers to put local arrangements in place to ensure the correct support was offered to those affected.
· North Solihull Regeneration · Green Prospectus These were shared with Councillor K Hawkins, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment ,Housing and Regeneration.
Councillor K Hawkins, the Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment, Housing and Regeneration attended the meeting and presented the report. The purpose of the report was to enable the Scrutiny Board to review the priorities over the last 12 months (2016/2017) and the progress made within the Environment, Housing and Regeneration Cabinet Portfolio. The responsibilities of the Environment, Housing and Regeneration Cabinet Portfolio covered both the Managed Growth and Building Stronger Communities Priorities.
In attendance: Councillor K Hawkins – Portfolio Holder for Environment, Housing & Regeneration and Jim Harte (Assistant Director - Stronger Communities, Managed Growth and Communities Directorate).
The Board welcomed Councillor Hawkins to the meeting who presented the priorities from his Portfolio over the last 12 months and reported on the progress made towards them.
Specifically, Cllr Hawkins only reported on the Waste Strategy as other matters from his Portfolio were being reported to Economic Development & Managed Growth Scrutiny Board in the near future.
Cllr A Hodgson to Cllr Hawkins – Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment Housing and Regeneration:
The Chairman of the Committee, Councillor K Hawkins advised Members of the which was included with the agenda for the meeting. The purpose of the Procedure Note was to assist the Committee in its consideration of the request for Call-In submitted regarding the Review of the Parking Displacement Programme decision from the Transport and Highways Cabinet Portfolio Holder (CPH) Decision Session on 7 April 2016.
· Councillor Hawkins submitted a petition on behalf of residents to request the resurfacing of Rumbush Lane in Dickens Heath; and · Councillor Sheridan submitted a petition on behalf of residents requesting the provision of a pedestrian crossing on Windward Way near the junction with Shetland Walk/ Birbeck House.
In December, the Working Group also received evidence from Councillor Hawkins on how Members could support stronger communities through use of Social Media.
Cllr Hawkins invited each of the Chairmen to provide Members with a review of progress made, and also referred them to Item 7 on the agenda – Tracking of Scrutiny Recommendations 2014/15, and invited their comments on this issue as well.
Councillor Hawkins thanked the Board Chairmen for their attendance and input. He felt ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
b) Shop Mobility - Councillor Ken Hawkins c) Solihull Bereavement Counselling Service - Councillor Karen Grinsell
In attendance: Councillor K Hawkins (Chairman of 2014/15 Neighbourhood Services Scrutiny Board and Scrutiny Working Group), Ashley Prior (Head of Highway Services), David Lechmere (Highway Services – Principal Engineer Road Safety) and Paul Tovey (Highways Services – Principal Engineer Traffic Management).
Councillor K Hawkins (Chairman of 2014/15 Neighbourhood Services Scrutiny Board and Scrutiny Working Group), attended the meeting and spoke in support of the Group’s work and subsequent recommendations.
RESOLVED That Cllr K Hawkins be elected as the Board’s Chairman for the ensuing Municipal Year (Cllrs H Allen and M Sheridan asked to have their names recorded as having voted against this decision.)
The Cabinet welcomed Cllr Hawkins to the meeting who was in attendance to present two issues arising from Overview and Scrutiny.
“ The Cabinet agrees to the suggested re-instatement of the JLR Community Forum to be supported by the Council’s Economic Development and Regeneration Team” The Cabinet thanked Cllr Hawkins for attending the meeting and presenting the recommendations. Members welcomed the report from the Income Generation Task and Finish Group and felt that they had done a good job in analysing the issues. The recommendations provided the right mix of maximising income, while keeping an open mind regarding opportunities.
Cllr G Allport substituted by Cllr K Hawkins, Cllr M Sheridan and [name removed] (Co-opted Member)
Councillor Hawkins confirmed that Cllrs I Chamberlain, [name removed], T Hodgson and M Parker had been appointed to serve on the Task and Finish Group.
Cllr K Hawkins, Chairman of the Neighbourhood Services Scrutiny Board, reported on some of the more recent activities of the Board, including the review of Highways Services which had contributed to the savings requirements of the Medium Term Financial Strategy for that area.
Cllr Hawkins also outlined the expected activities of he Board at forthcoming meetings.
(ii) That in accordance with the suggested JOSC’s Terms of Reference in order to maintain political proportionality, the Council appoints Cllr Ken Hawkins a Member from the Conservative Group as the Council’s representatives on the WMITA and West Midlands Centro;
At this point in the meeting, Councillor Hawkins advised the Board that he was a Member of the Solihull Shop Mobility Board (a Council appointment).
Councillor Ken Hawkins spoke, requesting that Members undertake a site visit, on application 2014/636 – 2 Marshfield; and Councillor Gary Allport spoke against application 2014/1162 – Land adjoining 11 Withybrook Road.
Councillor Ken Hawkins spoke and requested that Members undertake a site visit.
Councillor Linda Brown spoke against application 2014/667 – Solihull Business Park, and a statement was read out on behalf of Councillor Ken Hawkins.
Councillors Linda Brown and Richard Holt spoke against application 2014/1032 – Land at Dickens Heath Road, and a statement was read out on behalf of Councillor Ken Hawkins.
A statement was read out on behalf of Councillor Ken Hawkins.
[name removed]/ [name removed] introduced [name removed]/ [name removed] who made a deputation to Council with regard to the Council’s Post 16 Travel Assistance Policy as it affects those young people attending Special Schools. Parents/ carers of these young people didn’t have a choice as to where they were educated and, given their circumstances, they could not travel independently using public ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Nominations for the election of chairman were received and seconded from the Board for Councillor K Hawkins and Councillor K Rushen.
RESOLVED Following a vote (5:4) in his favour, Councillor K Hawkins was elected Chairman of the Neighbourhood Services Scrutiny Board for 2014/15.
(Councillor K Hawkins having taken the chair.)
RESOLVED That Cllr K Hawkins be appointed Vice-Chairman of the Board for the ensuing Municipal Year.
Councillor Hawkins agreed to follow up with Carlo Malosti at the Council about progress on the derelict property in Cheswick Green and to report back to Cheswick Green Parish Council.
DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST – Councillor Hawkins declared an interest in application 2013/1689 on the grounds that he had been contacted by the owner/applicant.
REQUEST FROM MEMBERS TO ADDRESS THE MEETING – Councillor Hawkins addressed the meeting in relation to application 2013/1478, Councillors Brown and Hawkins in relation to applications 2013/1504, 2013/1679 and 2013/1705, and Councillors MacNaughton, Stephens, and Williams in relation to application 2013/1726.
[name removed], [name removed], and Councillor Ken Hawkins spoke against the application whilst [name removed] spoke in support.
Planning Committee The Leader informed Council of a change of membership for Planning Committee, where Councillor Hawkins was replacing Councillor Potts.
RESOLVED That Councillor Hawkins be appointed to the Solihull Shopmobility Management Committee.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Hawkins attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Mar 2017 | Council | Questions and Deputations under Standing Order 9 and 12 | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Hawkins was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 16 of 28 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Hawkins declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 29 Jan 2014 | Planning Committee, item 11 | DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST – Councillor Hawkins declared an interest in application 2013/1689 on the grounds that he had been contacted by the owner/applicant. |
Where Councillor Hawkins sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Jul 2013 | 67 | 8 Dec 2026 |
| Cabinet | Committee Member | Jan 2017 | 56 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| CPH Environment and Infrastructure Decision Session | Committee Member | Jun 2021 | 31 | 3 Dec 2026 |
| Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Mar 2017 | 15 | |
| Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Jun 2015 | 9 | 15 Dec 2026 |
| Overview and Scrutiny Management Board | Committee Member | Sep 2013 | 20 | |
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2013 | 13 | |
| CPH Environment & Highways Decision Session | Committee Member | Jul 2019 | 12 | |
| Health and Adult Social Care Scrutiny Board | Guest | Jun 2015 | 8 | |
| Education, Children and Young People Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Sep 2013 | 6 | |
| Neighbourhood Services Scrutiny Board | Chairman | Jun 2014 | 6 | |
| Children’s Services & Education Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Jun 2015 | 4 | |
| Crime and Disorder Scrutiny Panel | Committee Member | Sep 2013 | 3 | |
| Call In Committee | Committee Member | May 2016 | 3 | |
| CPH Environment and Housing Decision Session | Committee Member | Jun 2016 | 3 | |
| Healthier Communities Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Sep 2013 | 2 | |
| Remuneration Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2017 | 2 | |
| Stronger Communities and Neighbourhood Services Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Jan 2018 | 2 | |
| Economic Development & Regeneration Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Jan 2014 | 1 | |
| Economic Development & Land Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Jun 2014 | 1 | |
| Education, Skills & Culture Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Mar 2015 | 1 | |
| Joint Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2019 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.