Declarations of Interest
Councillor L McCarthy – had supported the application for NCIL funding within the Elmdon Ward.
Every time Solihull's minutes name Councillor McCarthy, as the council published it.
Councillor L McCarthy – had supported the application for NCIL funding within the Elmdon Ward.
Councillor McCarthy welcomed the report, particularly regarding the Council’s offer to younger people in terms of activities and resources. Related to this, she asked if some improvement could be made to the tennis courts in Elmdon Park. The Leader noted this was a cross-portfolio issue.
Councillor McCarthy requested a briefing on UK2 for Elmdon ward councillors and was advised that there were some commercial sensitivities involved but at the appropriate point, a briefing would be delivered.
Councillor Den O’Neil requested to speak on application 2025/01267 – 214 Cooks Lane, Kingshusrt ; Councillor Kathryn Thomas on 2026/00519 – 63 Castle Lane, Olton; Councillor Laura McCarthy on 2026/00520 – 18 Windsor Drive, Elmdon; Councillor Max McLoughlin on 2026/00656 – 94 Widney Lane, Solihull; and Councillor Wazma Qais on 2026/00714 – 102 Buryfield Road, Solihull.
[name removed] and Ward Councillor Laura McCarthy spoke against the application.
· Councillor L McCarthy (Liberal Democrat Group nomination).
resolved That, Councillor L McCarthy be appointed Vice-Chairman for the 2026/2027 Municipal Year.
Councillor Laura McCarthy seconded the proposal.
Councillor McCarthy thanked the Cabinet Member for his attention to the question she had raised previously regarding tree roots which had been progressing The Cabinet Member for Adult Social Care and Health presented the report and noted the results of the Council’s CQC Inspection He commended the work of the Adult Social Care and Public Health teams for their work.
Councillor McCarthy sort clarification as to how elected Members and the electorates voices would be brought into the process.
Councillor L McCarthy – a family member had previously received support from the Council as a victim of domestic abuse.
· Councillor L McCarthy – thanked officers for the report and for ongoing work to improve pedestrian crossings. She asked whether additional funding was expected for further schemes, noting long ? standing requests for a crossing on Old Lode Lane near Mayswood Road to support pupils travelling to Lyndon School. The Cabinet Member confirmed that the pedestrian crossing programme had progressed well, with recent schemes approved through the Local Network Improvement Plan, and recorded thanks to officers for securing funding, including £1.2?million for the A41 scheme.
· Councillor L McCarthy - raised concerns about safety on public transport, noting personal experiences of feeling vulnerable and witnessing disorder on buses. She emphasised that improving safety would increase public confidence and support greater use of sustainable travel. She also asked whether the Strategy includes measures to assess social harm—the wider impact of crime and anti?social behaviour on ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Perry Wardle, Director for Economy & Infrastructure Natalie Goulding, Head of Employment and Skills Leeanne Parker, Strategy & Performance Manager Tom Dixon, Delivery Manager Clare Rudge, Group Manager for Growth, Strategy & Commissioning Sarah Ashford, Visit Solihull Manager Satnam Kaur, Assistant Director for Housing Paul Edwards, Executive Director for Customer Experience & Customer Support, SCH Paul Rogers, Democratic Services Councillor Karen Grinsell, Leader of the Council and Lead Member for Children & Education Councillor Ian Courts, Deputy Leader of the Council and Lead Member for Managed Growth Councillor A Mackiewicz, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Climate Change & Planning (V) Councillor H Delaney, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Economy, Business & Skills Councillor W Qais, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Communities Councillor Mark Parker, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Housing Councillor Laura McCarthy (V) Councillor Dave Pinwell, Chairman for Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board Nancy Buckley, Vice Principal Solihull College and University Centre and Member of Solihull Employment & Skills Board Susie Ankrett, Plume Executive and Member of Solihull Employment & Skills Board Chet Parmar FRSPH, Chief Executive Officer for Colebridge Trust & Enterprises Will Shpherd, Cohesion Recruitment and Chairman for the Solihull Employment & Skills Board Roy Nash, Hotel Manager for The Arden Hotel & Leisure Club Becky Frall, Head of Tourism, West Midlands Growth Company The Ec
Motion: Councillor L McCarthy moved, and Councillor Thomas seconded - Call on the Mayor of the West Midlands and Solihull Council to Respond in Support of the Visitor Levy Consultation This Council notes:
As the mover of the Council Motion, Councillor L McCarthy was invited to address the Scrutiny Board to outline why the Motion was put forward.
Councillor L McCarthy advised ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
· Cllr L McCarthy – highlighted the consultation and publication of new Domestic Abuse Strategy 2026, which would include a focus on children and families.
Cllr McCarthy asked if that would specifically include mental health support for children. The report also highlighted that ASB in private rented housing would be manged by the Council’s Regulatory Services Team from July 2025; Officers were asked to provide more detail as to what the Team’s day-to-day responsibilities might look like. The Board was advised that further information would be sought from colleagues in Public Health and that information provided after the meeting.
· Cllr L McCarthy – highlighted from the report that throughout 2025/26, work would continue to develop plans to replace Moat Lane Depot and Bickenhill Household Waste Recycling Centre.
Cllr McCarthy sought a more detailed progress update on that priority and was advised that work was currently ongoing with colleagues in the Council’s Strategic Land Team regarding the development of the proposals and a Steering Group had been established. A more detailed update was anticipated later in the year to the Cabinet Member.
Councillor McCarthy raised the issue of ‘ghost buses’ (i.e. buses shown as pending arrival, but not actually operative) and queried what measures were being taken to improve live travel data for passengers waiting at bus stops. The Member Relationship Manager, WMCA advised that:
Councillor McCarthy raised the issue of fractured land ownership holding back delivery of brownfield development projects and questioned whether this issue was now being addressed.
Cllr L McCarthy advised Council that she had family members who were being supported by social services.
The second deputation was from [name removed], who was introduced by Cllr L McCarthy. [name removed] deputation related to her and her family’s experiences of SEND support in the Borough and in particular the EHCP service.
· Cllr L McCarthy had supported an application for Neighbourhood Community Infrastructure Levy (NCIL) funding in the Elmdon Ward.
· Cllr L McCarthy had a male family member who had previously been a victim of domestic abuse in 2023 and summarised the Council’s interaction at that time.
Councillor McCarthy observed that borough growth included attracting new businesses into the borough and questioned whether the Council undertook any analysis for those instances where businesses chose not to locate to the borough.
Cllr L McCarthy advised Council that she had family members who were being supported by Solihull Social Services.
Councillor McCarthy noted Councillor Thomas’ proposal and advised that the matter would be raised with Councillor Burrow in his capacity as Chairman of the Children’s Services and Education Scrutiny Board.
Cllr Thomas reminded Members that she worked for Jaguar Land Rover, and Cllr L McCarthy advised Council that she had family members who were being supported by Solihull Social Services.
· Cllr L McCarthy – asked if the School Streets restrictions could be enforced by MTC cameras and how the implementation of the new powers might be communicated, particularly the spilt between the Police and the local authority with regards to enforcement. Officers advised that one of the ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Councillors Tony Dicicco and Alison Rolf requested to speak on application 2024//01917 – Birmingham International Airport; and Councillor Laura McCarthy on application 2024/02588 – 121 Victor Road, Solihull.
[name removed] spoke against the application and a statement was read out on behalf of Councillor Laura McCarthy opposing the application.
Councillor Andrew Burrow requested to speak on application 2024/00678 – Telecommunications Mast, Kenilworth Road, Balsall Common; and Councillor Laura McCarthy on application 2023/02225 – 121 Victor Road, Solihull.
[name removed] spoke against the application and a statement opposing the application was read out on behalf of Councillor Laura McCarthy.
Councillor McCarthy referenced the correspondence received from the WMCA, in which a request was made for the WMCA to report to the Resources and Delivering Value Scrutiny Board on three occasions during the 2024/25 municipal year.
Councillor McCarthy noted that once proposals for the new operating model matured then the Scrutiny Board could give it consideration within its Work Programme. The Director for Resources advised that the Financial Sustainability Board frequently reviewed the position of the Council’s budget. Members were advised that all options were being explored to address the financial position of the Council.
Councillor McCarthy agreed that this was an area which could be addressed via the Digital Strategy report.
Councillor McCarthy noted the Director for Resources comments and recommended that the matter of future meeting frequency for the Resources and Delivering Value Scrutiny Board be discussed by the new Scrutiny Board membership in May 2024.
Councillor McCarthy recommended that this subject be added to the long list for the 2024/25 Work programme.
Motion two was from Cllr L McCarthy seconded by Cllr Adeyemo:
Cllr L McCarthy asked the Cabinet Member for Housing why the waiting period for a three bedroom band A social housing application had rocketed in the last few months from 112 weeks to 183 weeks to 218 weeks on average.
Cllr L McCarthy requested the written response include the number of people on the waiting list for all bands.
· Cllr L McCarthy · S Golby · Director of Childrens Services with Assistant Directors representing the service.
Cllr L McCarthy , seconded by Cllr Thomas – Community Policing " This Council recognises the importance of community policing in maintaining the safety of our streets and supports the work of our borough PCSOs.
Cllr L McCarthy to Councillor Qais Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Communities and Leisure What is being done to increase the number of appointments to register a birth in the borough.
As Cllr L McCarthy had left the meeting, the Cabinet Member agreed to provide a written response.
In relation to the Delivery Plan in the new iteration we will be looking at how we can work across borders to help prevent exploitation but when it comes to renewing the plan, we will always look at evidence gaps, successes failures and where practice has now become business as usual. · Cllr L McCarthy – You talked about an increase in head count in the team, are these permanent roles or temporary?
· Cllr L McCarthy – You mentioned that there are deep dives into cases, how often do these occur?
· Cllr L McCarthy – Some years ago you circulated exploitation guides, however, the language on domestic violence focussed heavily on men being the perpetrator. Is there a way we can get this updated to be more inclusive that domestic violence can happen to men and women?
· Cllr L McCarthy – Partnership working is really important to the improvement journey we are going on. How is it going with our partners?
Cllr Ben Groom proposed Cllr Laura McCarthy.
Cllr Laura McCarthy received 5 votes and Cllr Andrew Burrow received 8 votes.
Cllr Laura McCarthy received 5 votes and Cllr Richard Holt received 8 votes.
The membership of each group would be fed into the Democratic Services Officer via Cllr A Burrow, Cllr L McCarthy and Cllr B Groom.
· Cllr L McCarthy – I have been on the board for circa 5 years now and this reporting style has provided the most clarity and been the most useful to understand progress than we have ever seen.
· Cllr B Groom – I would agree with Cllr L McCarthy on the usefulness of the report. It would also be helpful to have alongside the exception reporting a narrative of what good looks like so we can compare and contrast.
Cllr L McCarthy declared an interest on this item due to a close family member being investigated by the Local Safeguarding Partnership whom have responsibility for improvement in the Partnership Improvement Plan.
Cllr L McCarthy to Cllr Mackiewicz Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Climate Change, Planning and Housing Can the Cabinet Member please advise how many empty properties the Council are aware of in Solihull and of this number, how many are owned by private companies?
Cllr L McCarthy followed up by asking what powers the Council has to force or encourage companies to bring back properties in disrepair back into use. The Cabinet Member confirmed that the Council charge double council tax on empty properties, and that the Empty Homes Group work with residents to try and bring properties back into use. He also cited that there could be genuine reasons for an empty property such as probate or a resident moving into care.
Cllr L McCarthy questioned whether the Council was talking to companies to help meet the need for affordable housing. The Cabinet Member advised he was not aware of any such discussions but would check with officers.
Cllr L McCarthy echoed Cllr R Grinsell’s remarks and asked the Cabinet Member if the scheme could be rolled out across other schools in the borough. The Cabinet Member agreed the scheme was a great one and that she would enquire as to whether it could be ... view the full minutes text for item 11.
Cllr Laura McCarthy asked the Leader of the Council what he was doing to open the eyes of the Prime Minister in relation to the underlying issues with potholes. The Leader responded that the Council continued to lobby HM Government where possible on issues like this but as he had not advanced notice of the question then he was unable to provide the detail he would have liked to have given.
Cllr L McCarthy asked the Leader of the Council why the Council had not engaged meaningfully with support for Children’s Services in January 2022 when it had been in place, as stated in the Commissioners Report. The Leader advised that the Council had spent the last 12 months looking at what has happened in the service and cooperated with Sir Alan Wood CBE to support his report. The Leader stated he did not want to comment on specific cases but reassured members that a new leadership team was in place with action ongoing to drive improvement.
Cllr Thomas Deputy Leader of the Liberal Democrat Group- advised Council that Cllr Laura McCarthy had recently given birth to a baby girl.
On behalf of the Council the Mayor congratulated Cllr L McCarthy and her partner on the arrival of their daughter.
Cllr L McCarthy declared an interest to the Chairman.
· Cllr L McCarthy – Do the 34 children that have been identified include children under Kinship Care arrangements?
The motion was debated and then Cllr L McCarthy proposed an amendment seconded by Cllr Thomas, the amendment read:
Cllr L McCarthy to the Leader of the Council Can the Leader inform the Council of what support the Government is giving the Council to help residents with the increase in the Cost of Living?
Councillor Laura McCarthy declared a personal interest in the meeting. This matter has been discussed with the Chair and it has been agreed by the Chair her interest is noted and details of that interest will remain confidential.
Cllr L McCarthy to Cllr Hawkins Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and Infrastructure We are fortunate to have many community groups who are keen to arrange activities for their members. However, they are reporting that they are struggling to find a designated coach pick up spot in the town centre. Can the Cabinet Member advise where groups can arrange to be collected by coaches please?
Cllr L McCarthy sighted a particular community group who had been given conflicting advice by the Council regarding a number of unsuitable pick up spots, and asked if there was a specific location they could use.
We need people to visit Shirley and the lack of toilet facilities has an impact on elderly, very young, disabled people, our regular shoppers, those we want to attract for the first time and those who take advantage of the many attractions at Shirley Park.” 2) From Cllr L McCarthy – “ Residents are asking Solihull Council to undertake a comprehensive investigation into speeding across Elmdon and measures to tackle this. This includes exploring the rollout of average speed cameras across Elmdon, implementation of 20mph speed limits, or else consulting with residents about their preferred method of traffic calming on the worst streets and implementing this.
We are also asking West Midlands Police to increase the number of speed checks on Elmdon roads to deter excessive speeding.” 3) From Cllr L McCarthy – “Residents are asking Solihull Council to undertake another investigation into Rowood Drive with the view to installing average speed cameras to control the speeding or else consult with residents about their preferred method of traffic calming and implement this.” 4) From Cllr Gibbin – Speed Reduction/Traffic Calming Measures – “We the undersigned call upon SMBC to introduce speed reduction/traffic calming measures on Brook Lane.” 5) From Cllr Gibbin – Speed Reduction/Traffic Calming Measures –“ We the undersigned call upon SMBC to introduce speed reduction/traffic calming measures on Dovehouse/Lane.” 6) From Cllr K Thomas – “We, the undersigned, call on Solihull Council to renew the leases of The 1st Olton Scout Group and The Olton Park Guides, for their respective premises on Brackleys Way, ensuring that they have security of tenure for the foreseeable future.” 7) From Cllr B Grinsell – Road Safety Measures- “Following a fatal accident and other traffic incidents we the undersigned call upon SMBC to investigate suitable road safety options for the junction of Warwick Road and Grange Road as a matter of urgency.
The Second Motion was from Cllr Laura McCarthy and seconded by Cllr K Thomas and read:
Councillor L McCarthy asked what was being done to encourage male domestic violence survivors to access support.
Cllr L McCarthy declared that she had nominated [name removed] for enrolment as an Honorary Alderman.
(Councillor McCarthy in the Chair)
Councillor McCarthy asked why the number of schools which used the service had decreased and whether it only operated in Solihull. The Head of Catering Services explained that some of the reasons for decreased demand for the service included some schools had joined multi-academy trusts, some schools chose to operate internally and some schools had chosen a private sector provider. They did provide the service to some schools in Coventry but this had a separate operating model.
Councillor McCarthy questioned why the Area Managers had different salaries. The Head of Catering Services highlighted that they all had the same role however some were part time or on Coventry City Council terms and conditions, which led to differences.
Councillor McCarthy sought clarification that the positions could not have been protected. The Head of Catering Services outlined that the changes were about service redesign, which included the creation of roles in certain areas.
Councillor McCarthy resubmitted a petition on behalf of Elmdon residents which opposed the potential relocation of the HWRC to Damson Parkway.
Councillor Adeyemo and Councillor McCarthy sought confirmation that the Household Waste Recycling Centre (HWRC) would not be located at Damson Parkway. The Leader highlighted that the Local Plan required land use allocation which would not mean that the land would be developed for that purpose. There remained a lease on the current site of the HWRC and would not support its location to Damson Parkway.
Councillor McCarthy asked if ward Members would be consulted if any changes to the Local Plan in their area were introduced, specifically if there were changes in relation to the Household Waste Recycling Centre being moved to Damson Parkway. The Cabinet Member confirmed that any changes would be made available in the public domain, and would follow the relevant legal process.
Councillor McCarthy asked whether there had been a rise in Discretionary Housing Payments as a result of COVID-19.
The Cabinet Member responded that he would get these figures to Councillor McCarthy.
Councillor McCarthy to Councillor Meeson, Cabinet Member for Children, Education and Skills “From January schools were able to opt in to receive free sanitary products for students. How many Solihull schools have currently opted in?” The Cabinet Member responded by outlining that:
Councillor McCarthy to Councillor Grinsell Cabinet Member for Adult Social Care and Health “Seven months ago the government committed to reviewing the six month life expectancy rule for those with a terminal illness trying to claim social security. Since then there has been very little progress, yet in that time 1,000 people have died of Motor Neurone Disease. Many of those died waiting for their benefits.
· Councillor L McCarthy submitted a petition from local residents, calling on the Council to explore implementing traffic calming measures on Rowood Drive.
Cllr L McCarthy to Cllr K Grinsell Cabinet Member for Adult Social Care and Health ‘Cervical cancer is one of the most common forms of the disease, but whilst 99.8% of cases are preventable the number of women attending their smear ... view the full minutes text for item 58.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor McCarthy attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 23 May 2023 | Children’s Services & Education Scrutiny Board | Draft Work Plan - MY 2023-2024 | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor McCarthy was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 11 of 18 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor McCarthy declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 23 May 2023 | Children’s Services & Education Scrutiny Board, item 11 | Cllr L McCarthy declared an interest on this item due to a close family member being investigated by the Local Safeguarding Partnership whom have responsibility for improvement in the Partnership Improvement Plan. | |
| 5 Jan 2023 | Children’s Services & Education Scrutiny Board, item 2 | Cllr L McCarthy declared an interest to the Chairman. | |
| 9 Jun 2022 | Children’s Services & Education Scrutiny Board, item 81 | Councillor Laura McCarthy declared a personal interest in the meeting. This matter has been discussed with the Chair and it has been agreed by the Chair her interest is noted and details of that interest will remain confidential. | |
| 23 Jun 2021 | Governance Committee, item 4 | Cllr L McCarthy declared that she had nominated [name removed] for enrolment as an Honorary Alderman. |
Where Councillor McCarthy sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Jul 2018 | 38 | 8 Dec 2026 |
| Stronger Communities and Neighbourhood Services Scrutiny Board | Vice-Chairman | May 2024 | 10 | |
| CPH Communities Decision Session | Committee Member | Jan 2025 | 7 | 18 Nov 2026 |
| Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Feb 2025 | 2 | 15 Dec 2026 |
| Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Mar 2025 | 2 | |
| CPH Children and Education Decision Session | Committee Member | Jun 2018 | 25 | |
| Children’s Services & Education Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Jun 2018 | 19 | |
| Cabinet | Committee Member | Jan 2020 | 19 | |
| CPH Leisure Tourism and Sport Decision Session | Committee Member | Jun 2018 | 10 | |
| CPH Adult Social Care and Health Decision Session | Committee Member | Jun 2019 | 10 | |
| Solihull Health & Wellbeing Board | Spokesperson | May 2020 | 4 | |
| Health and Adult Social Care Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Feb 2023 | 4 | |
| Governance Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2021 | 3 | |
| CPH Communities and Leisure Decision Session | Committee Member | Jan 2024 | 3 | |
| Joint Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2020 | 2 | |
| Remuneration Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2021 | 2 | |
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | May 2020 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.