Access Arrangements Update
Councillor McLoughlin stated that he appreciated the need for the report, which was effectively a balancing act in reference to the risk matrix, vulnerabilities of the customers concerned in the 87 properties identified.
Every time Solihull's minutes name Councillor McLoughlin, as the council published it.
Councillor McLoughlin stated that he appreciated the need for the report, which was effectively a balancing act in reference to the risk matrix, vulnerabilities of the customers concerned in the 87 properties identified.
Councillor McLoughlin queried what proportion of properties had people with vulnerabilities. Members were informed that three addresses from the pilot scheme each had five different components of no access, which included mental health conditions, hoarding and vulnerable characteristics all being noted.
Councillor McLoughlin referenced back to previous discussions around hoarding and the Health and Well Being Board’s review of self-neglect and queried how this policy was being applied, with it ideally being seen as outreach work rather than enforcement.
The Director of Operations agreed with the point made by Councillor McLoughlin and advised that legal enforcement action was not the first course of action adopted in such cases.
Councillor McLoughlin was invited to make a deputation on the issue of the composition of the Committee.
Councillor McLoughlin expressed concern that the proposed change to the Governance Committee's membership had only been communicated on the day of the meeting. He noted that political balance requirements could have been achieved through any one of five committees with identical membership allocations, and argued that there was no constitutional provision or agreed rule requiring the change to be made to the Governance Committee. It was further suggested that amending the membership of the Planning Committee would be less disruptive and consistent with previous practice.
Councillor McLoughlin requested that the composition of the Governance Committee should not be altered for the current meeting.
Cllr McLoughlin commented that the Net Zero Action Plan had been replaced by the Climate Change Action Plan and asked for assurance around the data being used.
Cllr McLoughlin commented on the challenge of the Committee adding further value at this stage, noting the LGA peer challenge had not yet taken place. The Chairman commented that it was important for the Committee at this stage to have assurance that there was a robust, performance management system in place, and the DoR added that further member input would come through Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board, as the Council Plan and Outcomes Framework develop.
Cllr McLoughlin asked whether the potential £15–20?million of external borrowing would be taken as a single lump sum or phased (and how this might relate to the timing of any DSG funding).
Cllr McLoughlin asked where the detail behind the investment returns could be seen, and whether the council’s investment strategy included social value considerations.
Concerns around the overall assurance level were echoed by Cllr Gethen and Cllr McLoughlin, and the Chairman commented that concerns had been raised by the Committee previously regarding the reduction in resources.
Cllr McLoughlin asked for an update on the savings delivery associated with the MTFS (target date of February 2027).
Cllr McLoughlin asked how the issues identified in the Peterbrook Primary School audit (updates on governance concerns identified in previous year’s AGS) would be taken forward now it had academy status. The Audit Manager explained that when a maintained school becomes an academy, the Council pass the audit findings directly to the new academy leadership, ensuring they are aware of the risks and recommendations.
In addition, Cllr McLoughlin raised a broader point about transparency, suggesting that even where concerns and risks were confidential, it was important to consider how the type of risks could be reported publicly so residents could see the overall picture.
Cllr McLoughlin asked whether the Committee could consider what an acceptable risk level was for Children’s Services.
Cllr McLoughlin raised a concern regarding the phrasing of the climate change risk, noting that the risk appeared to have a focus on reputational issues and meeting Council targets, rather than the practical consequences for residents (for example, heat mortality and fuel poverty), and it was suggested that Officers review how the human impact of climate change could be most effectively captured within the Council's risk framework.
Councillor J Lamden’s appointment was supported unanimously by Members of the Scrutiny Board (*Councillor M McLoughlin was not present).
Referencing the priority ‘ Respond to youth unemployment by ensuring that young people have the right careers offer, support and opportunities to reach their potential’ , Councillor McLoughlin sought further clarity around the goals for reduction of youth unemployment. Members were informed there was no hard reduction target as such for addressing youth unemployment, but rather about having the right opportunities available at the right time for young people to access.
Councillor McLoughlin noted that it was important to understand the impact of youth unemployment on those unemployed.
Councillor M McLoughlin presented a petition signed by residents of Tamar Drive and their supporters seeking a review of parking arrangements for residents and visitors.
(ii) Councillor McLoughlin to Councillor Parker, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Housing “Can the Cabinet Member confirm that in 2025/26, according to the Council's Quarterly Monitoring Board homelessness dashboard: main housing duty acceptances rose from 75 in Q1 to 111 in Q4; the proportion of cases successfully prevented or relieved fell each quarter, from 59.7% to 53.7%, below the 60% target; quarterly successful outcomes into private rented accommodation fell from 57 to 42; and total social housing lettings fell to 489, from 537 the previous year, and what assessment has been made of the additional social rented supply required to meet this rising demand?” The Cabinet Member stated that the figures quoted from the Quarterly Monitoring Board homelessness dashboard were correct. The number of households approaching the Council for homelessness assistance and the outcomes achieved could fluctuate from quarter to quarter depending on demand, case complexity, and the availability of accommodation. For that reason, performance was best considered over the full year as well as at individual quarter level.
Councillor McLoughlin pointed out to the Leader that she had previously commented on the need for Group Leaders to organise Standing Order 8 questions so that those relating to Motions were listed first and he noted that the Green Group’s questions were all listed in this manner.
Councillor S Ashraf MBE – Councillor M McLoughlin substitute.
Councillor M McLoughlin proposed, seconded by Councillor J Bradley, that Councillor J Bradley be appointed as Chair.
Councillor J Bradley proposed, seconded by Councillor M McLoughlin, that Councillor M McLoughlin be appointed as Vice-Chair.
On being put to the vote it was RESOLVED that Councillor M McLoughlin be appointed as Vice- Chair for the 2026/27 municipal year.
Councillor Den O’Neil requested to speak on application 2025/01267 – 214 Cooks Lane, Kingshusrt ; Councillor Kathryn Thomas on 2026/00519 – 63 Castle Lane, Olton; Councillor Laura McCarthy on 2026/00520 – 18 Windsor Drive, Elmdon; Councillor Max McLoughlin on 2026/00656 – 94 Widney Lane, Solihull; and Councillor Wazma Qais on 2026/00714 – 102 Buryfield Road, Solihull.
Ward Councillor Max McLoughlin spoke in broad favour of the application.
Councillor McLoughlin to Councillor Karen Grinsell – Leader of the Council and Lead Member for Children and Education Can the Leader advise whether the Department for Education has restored funding for the school at Sans Souci, and if so, when was the Leader made aware that funding would be restored?
Councillor McLoughlin referred to a live petition shared on Conservative newsletters, and requested that attention be given to ensuring that imprints were added to political campaigns.
Councillor Max McLoughlin, seconded by Councillor Shahin Ashraf MBE, proposed the following ... view the full minutes text for item 9.
Councillor McLoughlin to the Leader of the Council Councillor McLoughlin asked why the leader had not been in favour of suspending Standing Orders to allow Standing Order 8 questions to be completed before moving on to motions. The Leader responded that this was permitted by the constitution and Group Leaders may wish to consider prioritising the order of their questions for future meetings.
Councillor McLoughlin to the Leader of the Council Councillor McLoughlin asked who was on the panel that would be selecting the neighbourhood board chair for Pride in Place in Chelmsley Wood, the Leader advised who was required to sit on the panel and that the selection of the Chair was subject to instructions from the Government. In response to further questioning, the Leader noted that it was not a stipulation of the interview panel for its members to live in the ward and she was not party to information about where panel members resided.
Councillor McLoughlin to the Leader of the Council Councillor McLoughlin asked a question regarding the appointment of the chairs of scrutiny and the Leader advised that she had not emailed the names of chairs or vice chairs out to members of the group.
Councillor McLoughlin to the Leader of the Council Councillor McLoughlin asked whether the details of the signatories to the petition submitted earlier would be shared with the Department for Education and not used for electoral purposes in this or any future elections?
The Leader confirmed that it would not be used for electoral purposes and she had submitted the petition without retaining a copy Councillor McLoughlin to Cabinet Portfolio Holder - Climate Change & Planning Councillor McLoughlin asked a number of questions regarding planning policy and the mechanism that would be used to ensure that infrastructure is delivered before development. He was advised that the Local Plan was the key mechanism used and in some cases funding would be required from WMCA or developers to enable infrastructure work up front. In terms of schools and GP surgeries there were specific formula based processes in place.
Councillor McLoughlin to Cabinet Portfolio Holder - Environment & Infrastructure Councillor McLoughlin asked questions regarding the conditions on the site assessment of Hurdis Road and road safety and was advised that the Cabinet Member had not been present at the site assessments and the question would need to be directed to Officers.
Councillor McLoughlin to Cabinet Portfolio Holder – Resources Councillor McLoughlin asked whether the Council had not met its payment terms to any small and medium sized enterprises (SMEs) in the last 14 months and the Cabinet Member stated that he would provide a written response.
Councillor McLoughlin to Councillor Mackiewicz – Cabinet Member for Climate Change & Planning How many responses were received to the Local Plan consultation that closed on 16th March 2026, and when will details from this consultation be published?
The fourth deputation was from [name removed] who was introduced by Cllr McLoughlin - [name removed] was against the proposal and suggested that the consultation was treated like a referendum, which it was not intended to be. Residents were fatigued by repeated consultations with an apparent predetermined outcome. Public engagement was very low, and the issue generated little public or social?media debate.
Ø Cllr McLoughlin asked whether MERS had resulted in any risk on service delivery. In addition, he asked whether the increase in materiality would impact on financial sustainability risks. o The External Auditor reported that this ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Ø Cllr McLoughlin commented that he felt uncomfortable with the changes regarding Scrutiny Board engagement with financial monitoring and the budget process (paragraphs 9.3 & 11.3) as he felt the change could result in less oversight. In addition, he noted that Independent Members did not have the same level of engagement with the budget process if they were not part of a Group.
In addition, changes to standards were summarised (noting no material impact expected on the Council’s accounts) and significant accounting estimates were noted by the Committee. Ø In discussion, Cllr McLoughlin asked whether there was best practice relating to the indexes, and in relation to financial assets measured at fair value, Cllr McLoughlin asked when Birmingham Airport Holding Limited and CSWDC (waste management company) were last subject to independent valuation.
Ø Cllr McLoughlin asked whether the mid-call solution for card payment had been implemented, and in relation to the number of level 4 audits, he asked whether there had been consistent themes identified. o The Head of Audit Services commented that the target date for mid-call was April, and it was his understanding that there was still some work to do before implementation.
Further detail could be provided if required. Ø Cllr McLoughlin commented that there appeared to be a cluster of whistleblowing activity related to CQC (Care Quality Concerns) with an outcome of evidence not being substantiated.
Ø Cllr McLoughlin commented on the value for money the audit service demonstrates.
Ø Cllr McLoughlin asked for clarification around affordable rent (Mell Square) noting volatility in the market.
Councillor McLoughlin referenced paragraph 5.5.2 of the report and queried whether energy prices for other fuel sources had the capacity to jeopardise any further biomass tariff rate reductions at a later point in 2026.The Director of Operations, SCH advised Members that he had scheduled a meeting with the company the council used for their energy provision, which was an ESPO contract. Members were advised the advantage of that contract was the company purchased energy in advance. The Director of Operations, SCH was hopeful that the impact of current world events would not have a detrimental impact in terms of the biomass tariff.
Councillor McLoughlin referenced paragraph 5.5.3 of the report which addressed the stock assessment position, which detailed approximately 75% of the homes were EPC Band C or above, but only 54% of them had a valid EPC.
Councillor McLoughlin queried when could it be anticipated that stock being at 100% with an in date EPC. Secondly, when could it be realistically expected to see 100% of the homes at Band C or above.
Councillor McLoughlin referenced page 63 of the report , indicator HO1A ( Average stay in temporary accommodation – families with children – days ). The target was given as 250 days.
Councillor McLoughlin queried whether there was any possibility for that target to be moving in the right direction, as he expressed a concern on seeing that a target for 2026 was close to what the year to date performance was, which was also worse than last year's performance.
Councillor McLoughlin raised the key performance indicators, specifically on page 46 of the report in terms of the strategic vision, which stated the Council cared about the environment and how it met its regulatory obligations.
Councillor McLoughlin noted that there were not any key performance indicators that related either to EPC’s or the number of insulation works completed, which would be useful, especially from the viewpoint of an SCH tenant whose biggest priority would likely be how warm was their home going to be and how well insulated. Any such KPI’s would also help track the trajectory of any related programmes of work and it would be useful for the Scrutiny Board to be able to see how many works for improvement on the insulation of properties were planned within the next twelve months. The Head of Customer Experience, SCH informed Members that the points raised could be taken back to SCH and discussed.
It was clarified for Members that the areas raised by Councillor McLoughlin were tracked and sat within the operational dashboards of which there were lots more of this kind of information, including management information, which sat within or below the above KPI’s.
Cllr McLoughlin to Cllr Hawkins – Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Environment and Infrastructure At the 3rd February meeting of Council, the Cabinet Member stated that repairs were conducted to the pavement in Widney Lane last year where they met DfT and SMBC intervention levels. Can the Cabinet Member confirm that SMBC has higher standards than the DfT and whether they comply with the standards set in “Inclusive Mobility” published by the DfT in December 2021?
In responding to a further question from Cllr McLaughlin the Cabinet Member confirmed that he would not be taking part in any political stunts at the location referenced in the deputation, but he would ask officers to join [name removed] and Cllr McLoughlin on site if they wished.
Cllr McLoughlin put a question to the Deputy Leader requesting clarification on remarks he made regarding ownership of the budget recommendations. The Deputy Leader confirmed that Council were approving a budget for 2026/2027, and not as was suggested for 2027/28 and 2028/2029. The report before Council included a strategy and challenges faced, but the Council was not approving a budget beyond 2026/2027.
Cllr McLoughlin referenced a comment made by the Leader concerning alleged inflammatory language being used and questioned what she was referring to. The Leader advised she was making a general comment.
Cllr McLoughlin then followed up on a number of responses Cabinet Members had previously given to questions under SO8:
The Cabinet Member for Resources confirmed that information on business rate relief was available on public websites and if further information was presented on a specific case Cllr McLoughlin/Ashraf had referred to, a written response would be provided.
Ø Cllr McLoughlin commented on the core spending power in 2013/14 (prior to the Adult Social Care Act) compared to today’s core spending power, and he queried what options were available to the Council. o The Chief Executive commented that it was the opinion ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Ø In relation to the ambition for having the right conditions for everyone to thrive, Cllr McLoughlin commented on affordability feedback from residents, and he noted that there was a widening ratio between median earning and median house prices. He highlighted the importance of preventative action to address inequalities.
In addition, Cllr McLoughlin queried how the Council would assess whether Solihull was an affordable place to live. o The Director of Resources commented that ambitions needed ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Following the update Cllr McLoughlin asked for confirmation that there would be detail in relation to ombudsman challenges upheld etc, and the Health, Safety and Risk Manager confirmed this was the case.
Ø Cllr McLoughlin asked for clarification of whether changes to the DSG could result in an under borrowing position in the future, but not any short-term impact on the budget.
Ø Cllr McLoughlin commented that the PWLB rates in table 2.2.1 (aggregated) were not comparable to the PWLB rates in table 4.1.
Ø In addition, Cllr McLoughlin commented that the treasury management training for Audit Committee Members was well received and that there could be some value in opening the training to ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
In discussion, Cllr McLoughlin commented that CIPFA and the external auditors had previously expressed concern around the Council’s levels of reserves and he queried how the Council would approach the replenishing of reserves and whether under borrowing could create a treasury management challenge (in maintaining some clearance for potential volatility within certain areas of the Council).
Councillor McLoughlin referenced paragraph 3.1 of the report, noting that Full Cabinet would be receiving the MTFS update reports, with no reports going forward to individual portfolios, and queried why this was the case.
Secondly, regarding paragraph 2.2., Councillor McLoughlin advised that the detail referenced could not be found. Regarding paragraph 3.1, the Director for Resources advised that the process for scrutinising the budget had been agreed for the budget proposals in 2025 on the basis of the resource required to produce the number of reports required for the budget process. It was therefore agreed to produce a single budget report which was used by all the forums in the Council involved in reviewing the budget proposals, with the Resources and Delivering Value Scrutiny Board acting as the main Scrutiny Board to review the financial proposals across the organisation.
Referencing Page 20, Table 3 (‘Forecast Reserve Usage’), Councillor McLoughlin queried how realistic was the forward projection when considering the dip in reserve value as at 1 st April 2025, as detailed in the ‘Profile of Use of Available Reserves – 2023/24 – 2027/28’ graph. Members were advised that the dip had already effectively taken place in the last financial year, with a significant amount of reserves being used at that time to support the budget, to address budget pressures and to invest additional resources into Children’s Services which had obviously worked based on the last Ofsted inspection findings. The position on reserves was realistic until the 2027/28 financial year which was currently reliant on a number of targets being delivered to reach a balanced budget and to avoid future calls on the Council’s reserves which could lead to issues in the future.
Councillor McLoughlin referenced paragraph 3.8 of the report, noting that ‘…. CIPFA’s External Assurance Review and Grant Thornton (as external auditors) have both recommended that we increase our reserves and reduce our ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Cllr McLoughlin to Cllr Parker – Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Housing Whilst the recommendation to the SCH Board from the Biomass Task & Finish Group and EDMGS Scrutiny are yet to be finalised, has the Cabinet Member been informed of the role the price modelling played in making the system unaffordable to residents, and the subsequent impact on the financial viability of the system?
The Cabinet Member in responding to a question from Cllr McLoughlin confirmed that 7 applications were carried over from Solar Together, lessons learnt from the previous scheme have been taken on board and publicity for the new campaign Switch Together had been developed.
There was an exchange of views between Cllr McLoughlin and the Cabinet Member regarding the development of the Local Plan.
Cllr McLoughlin requested that letter from the Minister of State for Housing and Planning received in December regarding the Council's Local Plan be made available to the public.
Cllr McLoughlin to the Leader of the Council Cllr McLoughlin raised concerns over the time it took for the Council to respond to Freedom of Information requests. The Leader advised she would seek a response from Officers.
Cllr McLoughlin to the Cabinet Member for Resources Cllr McLoughlin referred to recent research which highlighted a number of properties in Solihull with hidden ownership and questioned what the Council was doing to assess the scale of this issue, as well as reassurance that these hidden ownerships were not associated with avoidance of tax payable to the Council. The Cabinet Member advised he would seek a written response.
Cllr McLoughlin to the Chairman of Planning Committee Cllr McLoughlin asked a number of questions around the Planning Committee meeting held on 10 December. The Chairman confirmed that no Member of the Cabinet had asked for his deputation on a planning application to be blocked.
The Chairman did not know whether any other planning application had received such support from other Members of the Council, in recent years as the one referred to by Cllr McLoughlin.
In response to the amount of time Cllr McLoughlin was given to speak on an application this was in accordance with the Planning Handbook.
Cllr McLoughlin to the Cabinet Member for Climate Change and Planning Cllr McLoughlin questioned whether the Cabinet Member had had any contact from developers in relation to the planning application that related to £8m of affordable housing that was not required. The Cabinet Member confirmed he had not.
Ø Cllr McLoughlin commented on the introduction of an Exceptional Circumstances Relief (ECR) policy in relation to the Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL) and noted his concerns regarding the delegation arrangements proposed at the June meeting of Cabinet.
Ø Cllr McLoughlin asked whether an increase in the costs of servicing debt was anticipated.
Ø In relation to debt maturity, Cllr McLoughlin queried to what extent this could be a problem later down the line.
Ø In relation to appendix A2, and the ratio of financing costs to net revenue stream (housing and non-housing), Cllr McLoughlin queried how this compared to other local authorities. o The Treasury and Corporate Accountant commented that this was a snapshot of a particular point in time. Solihull had come down in recent times (around 15% in housing) compared to the national picture which was nearer 20%. The wider picture was largely authority dependent, depending on their schemes at the time.
Ø Cllr McLoughlin queried the impact of the mapping error for the temporary Board and Lodge accommodation on individual claimants, and he queried whether there have been any instances of overpayment.
Ø In relation to the Joint Housing Risk, Cllr McLoughlin asked for clarification regarding recruitment to full capacity.
Ø Cllr McLoughlin noted his concern regarding the time taken for the replacement of spandrel panels (33%).
Ø Cllr McLoughlin commented on the risk of no overall control at the Council and the possible impact on achieving a balanced budget. Ø In relation to page 157 of the pack, Cllr McLoughlin ... view the full minutes text for item 13.
Councillor R Long nominated Councillor M McLoughlin, seconded by Councillor M McLoughlin.
For Councillor S Tomlinson: Councillors A Burrow, A Feeney, E Fitter, M McCarthy, P Sharma, A Rolf For Councillor McLoughlin: Councillor R Long, Councillor M McLoughlin Councillor S Tomlinson was duly appointed as Chairman to the Economic Development, Managed Growth & Skills Scrutiny Board for the 2025/26 municipal year.
Councillor McLoughlin raised the following corrections to the Agenda Item 5 ‘Proposed Response to the WMCA Consultation on How Buses Are Run in the West Midlands’, Page 7, Paragraph 4.
‘Councillor McLoughlin questioned whether urban bus services made for natural monopolies and secondly, what were the costs specifically associated with the FFA process in light of the modelling output saying for the most financially efficient ways to restore bus services was the franchising model, which excluded public ownership.’ but the modelling excluded public ownership as an option.’ Agenda Item 5 ‘Proposed Response to the WMCA Consultation on How Buses Are Run in the West Midlands’, Page 7, Paragraph 4, 1 st bullet point. Change:
‘Councillor McLoughlin commented that having reviewed the Department for Transport annual bus statistics, Solihull West Midlands was the fifth most dependent area on bus transport with 79 passenger journeys per head of population’.
‘Councillor McLoughlin highlighted the response to question L10 on Page 34 of the report, advising that the response did not make sense and required re-wording.
Finally, Councillor McLoughlin advised the meeting that having read additional material authored by the Department for Transport (DfT), it was apparent that network branding was not as significant as provision of quality transport connections and ensuring passenger safety whilst travelling on the network sunk costs of car ownership, reliability, ease, safety, journey time and flexibility as factors which would increase passenger numbers and patronage’.
Towards conclusion of Agenda Item 7, Councillor McLoughlin submitted a Minority as follows:
Greater public control of the services will be of greatest strategic benefit and will hopefully offer greater value for money for the public in the future.” Councillor McLoughlin rephrased it on request by the Chair to read:
Councillor McLoughlin question with regard to Arden Cross whether the Health Tech Campus would have any impact on the housing numbers as anticipated in the previous draft of the Local Plan and whether any further detail could be given on the development numbers. Secondly, how much progress was expected to be seen with Chelmsley Wood Town Centre in ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Cllr McLoughlin attended the meeting and reiterated the concerns that he had highlighted when originally presenting the Motion at Full Council.
Having considered the report, Cllr McLoughlin now urged the Board to give greater weight to the consideration of the health implications of car idling at peak times, and a more proactive approach to car idling enforcement (around schools) within existing resources. It was considered that some resources would be better spent providing enforcement, rather than engagement initiatives that needed to be regularly repeated and appeared to have limited impact. Car idling was also perceived to be linked to other, driver related, anti-social behaviours around schools.
Cllr McLoughlin also highlighted that the report before the Board had not fully captured and considered all of the wider concerns raised within the Motion.
On the motion of Councillor M McLoughlin, seconded by Councillor A Adeyemo it was:
Cllr McLoughlin submitted a petition on behalf of residents of Bills Lane requesting that Council address the issue of vehicle speeds and make Bills Lane safer for everyone.
Cllr McLoughlin wished to congratulate Shirley Golf Club for winning club of the year award.
The first deputation was from [name removed], who was introduced by Cllr McLoughlin. [name removed] deputation related to accessibility, obstruction, and condition of pavements. [name removed] spoke of his own personal experiences as a wheelchair user.
Cllr McLoughlin to Cllr Hawkins – Cabinet Member for Environment and Infrastructure Having requested speed monitoring equipment (speed strips) at three locations in my ward, two where issues of speeding have been reported and are on the approach to a location of two different fatalities, and one where a reduction in the speed limit has been requested, I was told that this was “non-essential spending” and could not be afforded at this time. Is speed monitoring “non-essential”?
The Cabinet Member was aware that Cllr McLoughlin, on the 11th of March 2025 received a detailed response from the Head of Highway Management on this matter.
Cllr McLoughlin was provided with copies of historic speed surveys which contained relevant data. This information together with the most recent 3-year road traffic collision data confirmed that neither Bills Lane or Dog Kennel Lane feature on the Council’s current Road Safety Improvement programme.
Cllr McLoughlin followed up by referencing the number of times this location had been raised in deputations and questions at Council, the volume of traffic and the numerous times the speed limit was broken, and whether the Cabinet Member still thought the road was safe. The Cabinet Member confirmed that the data from this road was reviewed regularly, by the Council, Police and Fire Service, and was not a priority.
Cllr McLoughlin did not accept the Cabinet Members response and asked the Cabinet Member to commit to further action. The Cabinet Member advised that with any future development in the area, 106 monies could be used. The Cabinet Member stated that roads in Solihull were safe.
Motion One - Cllr A Wilson will move, and Cllr McLoughlin will second:
Cllr McLoughlin to the Cabinet Member for Environment and Infrastructure- Cllr Hawkins Cllr McLoughlin questioned whether the Cabinet Member would investigate the use of permeable pavements around mature trees in the Borough from a cost saving view.
There was then a follow up question from Cllr McLoughlin concerning the issue of the Arden School and the earlier answer the Cabinet Member gave to a Standing Order 8 question (Cllr Mrs Holl-Allens Question re Arden Triangle). A discussion than followed in relation to the Local Plan and the decision the Administration took and the merits of that decision, which were contrary to the Inspectors recommendations.
Cllr McLoughlin also referred to the timing of the Local Plan being withdrawn after the elections and picked up on the point of costs, which Cllr Adeyemo referenced. The Cabinet Member explained that the money had not been wasted as the work done to date could be used going forward.
Cllr McLoughlin to Cllr Parker– Cabinet Member for Housing Two separate infrastructure improvements to Baxters Road missed multiple houses due to permission not being granted by Solihull Community Housing in time. Can the Cabinet Member provide reassurance that there are effective processes in place for communication between the Council, SCH and third-parties that ensure that work can be conducted in a timely and efficient manner that minimises disruption to residents?
Cllr McLoughlin advised he had provided Officers with the additional information.
Cllr McLoughlin advised this had been an ongoing issue and questioned whether the Cabinet Member was aware of this. The Cabinet Member confirmed that CityFibre had been given permission to visit homes, and he would investigate further and discuss with SCH the communication path between SCH owned and managed land, and access by contractors.
Councillor McLoughlin referenced Agenda Item 8 ‘Kingshurst Village Centre Regeneration’, Page 18, second paragraph, final sentence to be amended to include the underlined additions as follows:
‘ Councillor McLoughlin welcomed the desired public health approach being taken by the Council with regard to future public health service provision in Kingshurst.
Councillor McLoughlin stated he appreciated the uncertainty over securing future funding for the project and the change in material build costs.
However, regardless of whether future development costs were to rise or predicted future returns change, Councillor McLoughlin advised that he would still be supportive with proceeding with the project, as to do otherwise would be extremely detrimental to the Kingshurst and Smiths Woods wards and Council reputation’ .
Councillor McLoughlin referenced the final paragraph on Page 32, requesting that the following sentence be added:
Councillor McLoughlin questioned whether urban bus services made for natural monopolies and secondly, what were the costs specifically associated with the FFA process in light of the modelling output saying for the most financially efficient ways to restore bus services was the franchising model, which excluded public ownership .
Councillor McLoughlin clarified that he was trying to understand the merits between franchising or public ownership model, which many areas were now starting to say was the most efficient way of delivering those services. The Technical Director, SWIFT advised that:
Councillor McLoughlin referenced paragraph 2.1.1 in the report relating to ‘Stock Condition Data’, noting that 70% of properties had been surveyed.
A question had been raised concerning biomass, although Councillor Mcloughlin recognised that Energy Performance Certificates (EPC’s) were a totally separate element.
Councillor McLoughlin questioned whether the EPC’s were assessed as a desk-based process or if there were reasons to visit any property in the housing stock that an EPC could be undertaken at the same time. The Assistant Director for Housing advise that:
Councillor McLoughlin observed that the material components in a property would directly impact on the EPC rating and therefore recommended that the accuracy of the EPC information for all properties could be supported through stock survey visits, which would remove potential duplication of activity and time.
Regarding paragraph 2.2.4 in the report, Councillor McLoughlin quoted ‘ Of the sixteen high rise blocks which have spandrel panels, five had replacement panels installed ….’ Which implied a process was installed which satisfied the requirements of the Building Safety Regulator. How long would the remaining eleven blocks take to be upgraded with non-combustible material on the spandrel panels, which had been of the greatest concern to residents in those high-rise blocks.
Secondly, referring to paragraph 2.2.5, Councillor McLoughlin stated that the damp, mould and condensation data could provide an insight as to whether people were under heating or under ventilating their properties.
Councillor McLoughlin questioned whether there was a higher incidence of such reports in those properties served by biomass boilers, and if that data were not available would it be possible for such data to be compiled. The Director of Operations (SCH) advised that:
Councillor McLoughlin referenced paragraph 6.2.2 in the report, which detailed that the updated themes and proposed objectives which had been informed by a half-day conference, ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Councillor McLoughlin proposed that the Net Zero Action Plan and Biomass system across North Solihull be included in the Work Programme 2025/26.
Regarding the biomass report, Councillor McLoughlin proposed that the Resources and Delivering Value and Health and Adult Social Care Scrutiny Boards also be invited to attend for that report.
Cllr McLoughlin to Cllr Hawkins – Cabinet Member for Environment and Infrastructure Is the junction between Highlands Road and Cranmore Boulevard safe?
Cllr McLoughlin requested that further investigative work be undertaken in relation to speeding on Highlands Road and Cranmore Boulevard and the junction be redesigned or speed reduction measures be put in place. The Cabinet Member confirmed that the junction complied with DfT design. In a 20-year period four slight collisions had been reported to the police.
Cllr McLoughlin referred to several recent incidents and questioned whether the Cabinet Member was aware of them as they had not been registered on CrashMap and reiterated his request for mitigating measures to be put in place. The Cabinet Member confirmed he was aware of some collisions, but risk assessment work had been undertaken and was used to inform safety work. The Cabinet Member advised he would mention the issue at the next Regional Road Safety Partnership meeting.
Cllr McLoughlin referenced an answer Cllr Parker – Cabinet Member for Housing gave at the last Council meeting in relation to the cost of biomass pellets.
Cllr McLoughlin referred to the latest cost of the pellets per tonne which was around £325 of which 44% contributed to the cost of the tariff in 2024-5 but in 2022-3 when cost per tariff was 11.8p per kWh when pre-Ukraine the pellets were lower, why at 30p kWh in 2025-6 is it still 250% higher than it was in at pre-Ukraine war?
Cllr McLoughlin referred to an answer Cllr Hawkins - Cabinet Member for Environment and Infrastructure gave in relation to CIL funding earlier in the evening and asked what the difference was between parish and ward CIL and what it was used for . The Cabinet Member advised that this information could be found on the Council website. The Cabinet Member went on to explain what the strategic CIL was used for.
Cllr McLoughlin to Cllr Dicicco_- Cabinet Member for Adult Social Care Have any decisions been taken in relation to commissioned information and advice services since the Health and Adult Social Care Scrutiny Board met on the 12th of February 2025?
Cllr McLoughlin asked a supplementary question requesting that the Cabinet Member would follow up on a recommendation that any decisions are scrutinised.
Cllr McLoughlin commented that there was a risk that the assets that would realise the best return for the Council for the short term were likely to be the assets that would have the best return for the buyer in the long term. He noted his concerns ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Cllr McLoughlin commented that decisions taken in the short-term can have challenging long-term implications . .
Cllr McLoughlin commented that it was important for papers to be discussed in the public sphere where possible, and that Members were sometimes asked to consider public reports, with private appendices (moving into private session where appropriate). The Director of Resources reported that the authors of the paper had taken advice on how to categorise the paper and it had been categorised as private because elements of the paper were commercially sensitive.
The following Topic of Debate was introduced by Cllr McLoughlin:
“How can Councillors ensure we are providing the best support for people with special educational needs and disabilities, as well as their parents, carers or close relations across all our services.” Cllr McLoughlin introduced the topic, and the Mayor then opened the debate.
Cllr McLoughlin referred to the Local Plan being withdrawn and sought assurance that there would still be sufficient school places. The Cabinet Member confirmed there would be.
The Cabinet Member confirmed he would get a response to Cllr McLoughlin regarding the higher rate for the Council Tax Base.
In relation to a question from Cllr McLoughlin concerning a new pavement on Dog Kennel Lane the Cabinet Member confirmed this was a planning matter.
Cllr McLoughlin referenced the Adult Social Care Performance Progress Quarter 2 2024-25 and highlighted a number ... view the full minutes text for item 11.
a) Audit Committee 6 January 2025 b) Governance Committee 22 January 2025 c) Licensing Committee 23 January 2025 d) Remuneration Committee 27 January 2025 In relation to MERS Cllr McLoughlin sought clarification as to whether this was a Council decision, given the sums involved. The Chief Executive clarified the position and confirmed that if a further Council decision were required this could be included in the budget recommendations at the end of February.
In relation to a question from Cllr McLoughlin the Cabinet Member for Climate Change and Planning confirmed he was aware that the projection was for colder winters.
Cllr McLoughlin related this question to the need to insulate homes. The Cabinet Member reminded Members that money had been set aside from general fund to help residents with insulation. The Cabinet Member also referenced his frustrations regarding the need for longer term funding.
Councillor McLoughlin raised the matter of scrutinising the Net Zero Action Plan during the 2024/25 municipal year and proposed that the NZAP should be considered by the Scrutiny Board via an additional meeting. The Director of Economy and Infrastructure advised Members that the NZAP was scheduled to be considered at the Cabinet Portfolio Holders (Climate Change and Planning) decision session scheduled for 21 st January 2025. The report was to state that the NZAP would be refreshed on a three-year cycle.
Councillor McLoughlin confirmed that he was satisfied to consider the emerging amendments to the NZAP through the refresh process via the Scrutiny Boards Work Programme for 2025/26, possibly in July 2025 (subject to confirmation).
Councillor Andrew Burrow requested to speak on application 2023/02647 – Barn, Barretts Lane Farm, Barretts Lane, Balsall Common; and Councillor Max McLoughlin on applications 2024/00011 – De Vere Hotel, Dog Kennel Lane, Shirley; and 2024/00868 – 26 Langcomb Road, Shirley.
[name removed] and Councillor Max McLoughlin spoke against the application.
Cllr McLoughlin introduced [name removed].
Cllr McLoughlin to Cllr Hawkins – Cabinet Member for Environment & Infrastructure What actions has the Cabinet Member taken to make Bills Lane safer for cyclists and pedestrians?
Cllr McLoughlin followed up by wanting to know what specific actions had been taken. The Cabinet Member advised a range of measures would be taken, and work was prioritised based on the data.
Cllr McLoughlin referred to a number of locations where speeding was an issue, and asked what measures the Cabinet Member would take to make those roads safer.
The Cabinet Member advised data was used to prioritise road safety work across the Borough, but he would ask Officers to review the locations Cllr McLoughlin had referred to.
Cllr McLoughlin asked the Cabinet Member for Housing how many Council owned homes for Social rent were in the Local Plan. The Cabinet referred to the letter sent to the Planning Inspector on 8 May.
Cllr McLoughlin asked the Leader for a further explanation regarding the Leader’s response to his question under SO 8 about comments made by a member of the Conservative Group at the Civic Service. The Mayor requested that Cllrs Courts and McLoughlin discuss this matter outside the meeting, to which both agreed.
Cllr McLoughlin to Cllr Hawkins – Cabinet Member for Environment & Infrastructure Has the School Streets scheme been a success in Clifton Crescent?
Cllr McLoughlin referred to drives being blocked and no evidence of enforcement. The Cabinet Member advised enforcement was a police matter.
On the motion of Councillor McLoughlin, seconded by Councillor Groom it was:
Cllr McLoughlin submitted a petition on behalf of residents of Blackford Road requesting the speed bumps should be removed and alternative speed management introduced. They also note the weight restriction is not enforced which is causing damage to the road.
Cllr McLoughlin referenced the petition he had presented to Council regarding HMO’s around Lindridge Road, Shirley.
The Cabinet Member confirmed he had considered this and encouraged Cllr McLoughlin to keep Officers advised of any issues.
In response to a question about a trip hazard on the pavement outside Phoenix care home from Cllr McLoughlin, the Cabinet Member for Environment and Infrastructure advised that this should be considered an emergency and will follow this up.
The Cabinet Member for Environment and Infrastructure also responded to a number of questions from Cllr McLoughlin concerning dog fouling bins and missing dog fouling bins.
Having received the introduction to the report, Councillor McLoughlin advised the Scrutiny Board that he had requested the report to be submitted for consideration as it could sometimes be the case that there was a carousel type effect when discussing various initiatives for North Solihull, when the requirement existed to draw all such strategies in to one place.
Councillor McLoughlin referenced paragraph 3.14 of the report, in which the policy think tank Centre for Local Economic Strategies (CLES) addresses means of recirculating spending power within a community. CLES describes an approach which directs pension funds to local investment priorities. Currently WM Pension Fund contribution equates to 0.14% of equities in the fund.
Councillor McLoughlin questioned whether there were any further opportunities to direct anymore of the £9.2B of the pension fund into projects into the North Solihull area and whether there was any scope for a further £12.5M to be distributed.
In respect of business support available to SME’s, Councillor McLoughlin questioned whether any statistics were available for North Solihull specifically at a sub-local level (excluding Birmingham). The Assistant Director, Growth and Infrastructure advised that a significant amount of data was available, with the most prominent scheme being the former European Regional Development Fund (ERDF), for which there was strict reporting requirements producing ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Cllr McLoughlin to Cllr Mackiewicz Cabinet Member for Climate Chage and Planning The Cabinet Member has previously stressed the need for an adopted Local Plan to protect Solihull’s greenbelt.
Cllr McLoughlin asked what the highest number of dwellings that Solihull Council had ever delivered in a single year. The Cabinet Member advised the figure was in the region of 800.
Cllr McLoughlin noted that 2572 dwellings had been applied for since May and questioned whether this was anomalous, or was it expected. The Cabinet Member advised that it was anomalous.
a) Minutes of the WMCA Overview and Scrutiny Minutes - 9 October 2023 Cllr McLoughlin asked what additional funding would be available as a result of the deeper devolution deal. Cabinet Member for Resources advised that negotiations were ongoing.
Cllr McLoughlin questioned whether the WMCA are taking the Climate Change Action Score Card more seriously than the Council or giving it equal weight. The Cabinet Member for Climate Change and Planning advised that the main difference is that the Council supports an airport and jobs in the north, and do not operate a congestion charge like Birmingham City do.
Cllr McLoughlin referenced the engage status of West Midlands Police and asked when the HMICFRS Peel Inspection report would be published.
Cllr McLoughlin asked the Leader if he was prepared to extend the election compact to include the Nolan Principles. The Leader advised that all Councillors were subject to the Nolan Principles already.
Cllr McLoughlin clarified that he was referring to those who were standing for election, and not already Councillors, it was important that honesty and integrity was observed during the election campaign.
Cllr McLoughlin referenced an answer to a question given by Cllr Hawkins regarding the yearly clearance of drains, having seen one which had not been cleared within the timeframe suggested.
- Wellbeing, Skills and Inclusion - £269, 000 - Housing - - £265, 000 - Climate Change & Planning - £1.02M Councillor McLoughlin referenced Appendix B1 relating to the Visit Solihull website charges and queried whether these were realistic.
Councillor McLoughlin referred to paragraphs 3.15 - 3.17 of the report, stating that there was a great degree of uncertainty regarding the Councils future funding streams.
Councillor McLoughlin also stated that he believed the Councils position in regard to the Council Plan was under review, with major housebuilders intending to reduce the number of new housing units for development in the borough. This appeared to present more than a one-off funding challenge going forward.
Finally, Councillor McLoughlin noted that it was not clear if funding for 2026/27 was on-going, whilst funding detailed in Appendix A for 2024/25 appeared to be one-off funding.
Councillor McLoughlin was proposed by Councillor Thomas and seconded by Councillor Donnelly.
On being put to the vote, five Members of the Scrutiny Board voted for Councillor Pinwell and three Members voted for Councillor McLoughlin.
Councillor McLoughlin to Councillor Mackiewicz Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Climate Change and Planning Are the Council expecting any submissions for major planning applications in the greenbelt in the next 12 months?
Cllr McLoughlin to Cllr Hawkins Cabinet Member for Environment and Infrastructure – Bus wait times have led to a business in Blythe Valley having to leave the Business Park. What proposals are there to promote sustainable travel and subsidise routes?
The Leader of the Council made a statement in light of information circulated by the Labour party regarding the Kingshurst development, and in doing so would provide an answer to a question asked by Cllr McLoughlin under Standing Order 8. It was alleged that the Council no longer had the money to finish the Kingshurst development.
Cllr McLoughlin to Cllr Courts Leader of the Council and Lead Member for the Economy Can the Leader of the Council reassure residents that the much needed Kingshurst regeneration will be going ahead?
Cllr M McLoughlin asked the Leader a question relating to 1.5.2 The Commissioners Report, he thanked Sir Alan Wood CBE for the work he had done in Solihull and sought clarification from the Leader as to whether any future child’s deaths would be taken as seriously as the tragic case of Arthur Labinjo-Hughes. The Leader highlighted the immense focus on Children’s Services at the moment and reassured the Chamber that it was a big focus for the Cabinet Member, himself as the Leader, the Deputy Leader and Officers. He added that it is sad that there continues to be cases up and down the Country but that any future case in Solihull would of course be treated with the same level of scrutiny.
Councillor McLoughlin referenced figures for the recorded instances of damp and mould in SCH properties and queried whether the number of cases related to the recent rise in energy prices and domestic heating bills.
Secondly, Councillor McLoughlin highlighted the Key Performance Indicator (KPI) for Satisfaction Home is Safe , which detailed the sector benchmark at 82.9%, with the proposed SCH target for 2023/23 at 80%, querying why this was the case. The Scrutiny Board was advised by the Chief Executive (SCH) that the 80% target figure represented an increase on the current years target. Furthermore, due to the national focus on damp and mould in properties, SCH had publicised to tenants the need to report any such cases to SCH for them to be addressed.
Councillor McLoughlin referenced in the themes for 2023/24 section of the Delivery Plan, specifically the reference to SCH’s aspiration to grow the housing stock through acquisition and new build to help meet an ever-increasing need for housing. Considering the significantly challenging financial environment in terms of interest and borrowing rates, to what extent had the reduction in new build properties been attributable to the national economic conditions and, secondly, could the expectation of increasing the housing stock still be met whilst operating under such economic constraints.
Councillor McLoughlin questioned how the current U.K Shared Prosperity Fund compared with the former E.U funding programmes; noted the work undertaken around Investment Zones, noting that they had since ceased impacting on some Solihull projects, and queried in relation to poverty and inequalities how much was this being reduced arising from individual actions or the result of the Inclusive Growth Programme.
Councillor McLoughlin stressed the requirement to qualify impacts arising directly from the Inclusive Growth Programme.
The following motion was submitted by Cllr McLoughlin and seconded by Cllr Caudwell:
and (v) Bring to the soonest available decision session of the Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Climate Change Planning and Housing the viability and timescales for each of the resolutions.” An amendment was put by Cllr Mackiewicz which was seconded by Cllr McLoughlin which read:
Councillor McLoughlin welcomed receipt of the draft Climate Change SPD at the meeting of the Scrutiny Board, noting that it was important to receive it in draft form and at the development stage for scrutiny comment.
Councillor McLoughlin further commented that:
· he would welcome greater detail to be included addressing community projects and energy in the draft SPD. · Regarding paragraph 6.26 of the draft Climate Change SPD, Councillor McLoughlin stated that globally 11% of emissions arose from building materials and that the Councils recognition of reducing such embodied carbon as a key factor in reducing carbon emissions was very positive.
Councillor Max McLoughlin declared he had previously made submissions on earlier applications covering the site and would remove himself from proceedings once he had addressed committee.
Councillor Max McLoughlin withdrew from proceedings once he had addressed committee.
Councillor McLoughlin noted that regarding appendices A and B to the report, as a percentage of time spent on trade union activity a difference exited, whereas the total pay spent on time allocated to trade union activity did not converge.
Councillor McLoughlin queried whether this was due to more trade union representatives present in schools combined with lower trade union representation in the core Council representation, or a case of simply less trade union activity being required within the core Council.
Cllr Max McLoughlin to the Cabinet Member for Environment and Infrastructure Can the Cabinet Member inform the Council whether the Bike Hire Scheme and permission for Bikes to be on the Town Centre High Street had been removed?
Cllr M McLoughlin to the Cabinet Member for Environment and Infrastructure Does the Cabinet Member recognise that incineration is not recycling?
Cllr M McLoughlin to the Cabinet Member for Environment and Infrastructure Does the Cabinet Member know where the Council are in the Local Authority League Tables for recycling rates?
Councillor Max McLoughlin tended his apologies and Councillor Marcus Brain substituted.
“Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council formally resolves to petition the Secretary of State for Transport to introduce legislation pertaining to England and Wales that requires the driver of a quad bike on a public road/place within England to wear an approved helmet with an appropriate penalty for those who do not do so.” Cllr McLoughlin subsequently submitted an amendment, which following a short adjournment in the meeting, it was agreed that the following words be added to the end of the motion:- “and the Minister of State for Policing and the Fire Service and Home Secretary to give the Police the resources to prosecute the illegal use of off-road vehicles” Following a debate the proposed amendment was put and carried.
Councillor McLoughlin asked why the salary and costs equated to £370,109 but the saving was £334,000. The Head of Human Resources clarified that this was because there were some posts which had been deleted and new posts created in the new structure. This would then be factored in with the severance costs, which would confirm the savings to the service.
Councillor McLoughlin questioned why there was a weak correlation between higher salaries and the years of severance costs. The Head of Human Resources confirmed that severance costs were determined by pay plus years’ service, alongside the pension strain. Those on higher salaries were more likely to older which would cost more to the employer to release the pension.
Councillor McLoughlin queried the impact of COVID-19 pandemic on the service, and the potential need to rehire after the pandemic. The Head of Catering Services stated that the service redesigned had been planned before the pandemic.
Councillor S Caudwell proposed the appointment of Councillor M Brain as Chairman, seconded by Councillor M McLoughlin.
In regard to the priority of creating and building new homes in the Borough, Councillor McLoughlin questioned how many were planned for in 2022 against those housing units expected to be lost through ‘Right to Buy’ and where did the Council expect to be in terms of housing stock depletion from 2020 through to 2022. The Chief Executive (SCH) advised the Scrutiny Board that fewer housing units had been lost in 2020 due to Right to Buy than compared to previous years, with 140 new build properties planned for, but not guaranteed for delivery in 2021. Provision of supported accommodation units dedicated to young people was expected to provide a further 20 to 30 dwellings in total, which would be new Council housing.
Councillor McLoughlin referenced the definition of provided in paragraph 6.7.1 in the report (Statutory Equality Duty) and stated that greater clarity was required as to what was indeed meant by .
Councillor McLoughlin commented that it was also vital to receive external input into the Inclusive Growth Strategy, with emphasis also ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Councillor Tim Hodgson introduced a motion, Climate and Ecological Emergency Bill, which was seconded by Councillor McLoughlin.
Amendment One: £10 million borrowing to support Community Led Development Councillor Allen proposed the amendment which was seconded by Councillor McLoughlin.
Councillor McLoughlin questioned whether the 250,000 trees which the Council committed to planting would still take place, or would the Arden Forest scheme change this. The Cabinet Member explained that the Arden Forest scheme was a long term project which would be linked across the whole Borough.
Councillor McLoughlin made reference to Appendix A of the report, specifically to the pressures on Waste Services and changes to co-mingled waste recycling and property growth and queried whether property growth in the borough would not off-set this pressure. Officers confirmed that council tax and business rates through property growth would off-set the pressure.
Councillor McLoughlin sought confirmation that no distance adjustment was now used for data compilation purposes and that all diffusion monitoring tubes were sited on facades in compliance with DEFRA guidance. Officers confirmed that this was the case.
Councillor McLoughlin queried whether any data had been received from the Transport and Highways service to correlate the reductions in readings between 2019 and 2020 in light of the reduction in vehicle movements during the C-19 pandemic period. Officers advised that they would clarify if any such information could be supplied by the Transport and Highways service.
With reference to Council’s the tree planting programme, Councillor McLoughlin noted that the type of tree species planted, location of planting and tree maturity all had an impact on the type and extent of benefits planting brought to an environment, which in turn inferred that a net loss of trees would have a detrimental impact on air quality.
Councillor McLoughlin noted that it was highly likely that the Economic Recovery Plan for Solihull would guide much of the Scrutiny Board’s future work during the 2020/21 municipal year and proposed that the following matters also be included in the 2020/21 work programme:
Councillor McLoughlin moved the following amendment to the draft Minutes arising from the Scrutiny Board meeting held on 13th November 2019:
Councillor McLoughlin expressed concern that the two housing related items detailed in the current Work Programmes ‘long list’ section would not be considered at the Scrutiny Board until the Work Programme for 2020/21 commenced, as both reviews addressed important issues for the borough. The Democratic Services Officer advised Members that they could give further consideration to the housing related Work Programme items, particularly in development of the scope and remit for the reports in advance of the new municipal year. Roll out of 5G across the West Midlands region ... view the full minutes text for item 75.
From Cllr McLoughlin to Cllr Richards – Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Transport and Highways “There are several areas where there are particular issues with parking surrounding the Cranmore Industrial Estate, the residential area next to the Stratford Road, the area towards Marshall Lake, and also around Widney Lane. What is the Cabinet Member doing to address the parking problems in each of these areas?” The Cabinet Member confirmed the locations in this area had been raised with the Highway Services Team and had been included in the annual Traffic Regulation Order prioritisation process. He detailed how this process considered a range of risks and the actual impact of the parking to identify the priorities for the available funding.
Cllr McLoughlin asked a supplementary question, where he thanked the Cabinet Member for the work undertaken in respect of Portway Close.
He confirmed he would convene a meeting with Officers and advise Cllr McLoughlin of what discussions had taken place, in due course.
Cllr McLoughlin asked a second supplementary question, where he queried whether it would be possible for him to be in attendance at such a meeting and contribute to it.
The Cabinet Member confirmed he would ask Officers to look into this case and, if any further discussions were held, he would look to involve Cllr McLoughlin .
Councillors S Holt (Councillor M McLoughlin – substitute) and [name removed] (Councillor J Tildesley) submitted their apologies.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor McLoughlin attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Mar 2017 | Council | Questions and Deputations under Standing Order 9 and 12 | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor McLoughlin was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 29 of 45 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor McLoughlin declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 13 Jul 2022 | Planning Committee, item 2 | Councillor Max McLoughlin declared he had previously made submissions on earlier applications covering the site and would remove himself from proceedings once he had addressed committee. |
Where Councillor McLoughlin sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | May 2016 | 49 | 8 Dec 2026 |
| Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Jun 2016 | 36 | |
| Cabinet | Committee Member | Mar 2020 | 33 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| Audit Committee | Vice-Chairman | Jun 2018 | 28 | |
| Governance Committee | Vice-Chairman | Jun 2024 | 8 | 19 Nov 2026 |
| CPH Housing Decision Session | Committee Member | Jan 2025 | 4 | |
| CPH Climate Change & Planning Decision Session | Committee Member | May 2026 | 4 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Jan 2025 | 3 | 15 Dec 2026 |
| Solihull Health & Wellbeing Board | Committee Member | Jun 2026 | 1 | 24 Nov 2026 |
| CPH Managed Growth Decision Session | Committee Member | Jan 2017 | 14 | |
| CPH Climate Change, Planning & Housing Decision Session | Committee Member | May 2019 | 13 | |
| Remuneration Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2021 | 4 | |
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2017 | 3 | |
| Stronger Communities and Neighbourhood Services Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Jun 2016 | 1 | |
| Licensing Act Panel | Committee Member | Feb 2017 | 1 | |
| CPH Children and Education Decision Session | Substitute | Jul 2019 | 1 | |
| Call In Committee | Committee Member | May 2021 | 1 | |
| CPH Environment and Infrastructure Decision Session | Committee Member | Mar 2024 | 1 | |
| Health and Adult Social Care Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Feb 2025 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.