Follow up report – Building Safety?
Councillor Holt referenced paragraphs 3.16 and 3.17 of the report noting that they addressed several building safety risks.
Every time Solihull's minutes name Councillor Holt, as the council published it.
Councillor Holt referenced paragraphs 3.16 and 3.17 of the report noting that they addressed several building safety risks.
Councillor Holt sought clarification as to whether any building safety recommendations remained outstanding and advised that he was happy to receive a written response.
The Assistant Director Finance & Property Services confirmed that a written reply would be issued to Councillor Holt.
Councillor O’Nyons nominated Councillor Holt, seconded by Councillor Tomlinson.
Those indicating support for the appointment of Councillor Holt:- - Councillor O’Nyons - Councillor Baker - Councillor Tomlinson - Councillor Holt Those indicating support for the appointment of Councillor Campbell:- - Councillor Johnson - Councillor O’Neil - Councillor Thomas - Councillor Wigley - Councillor Campbell The Resources and Delivering Value Scrutiny Board:
Councillor Holt noted that the RAG rating for the KPI ‘Percentage of rent collected by Solihull Community Housing’ (Appendix A, Top 40 Performance Scorecard) was rated amber and queried why this was not green. The Assistant Director for Finance clarified that for rent collection reporting the KPI would also typically include rent arrears. For that reason, the performance should read as over 100% for the current years target for rent ‘debit’.
Councillor B Grinsell proposed, seconded by Councillor J O’Nyons, that Councillor R Holt be appointed as Chair.
Councillors J Johnson, J O’Nyons, B Grinsell and R Holt requested that their votes in favour of Councillor Holt be noted in the minutes.
Councillor B Grinsell proposed, seconded by Councillor J O’Nyons, that Councillor R Holt be appointed as Vice-Chair.
· Cllr R Holt – queried whether, as part of the Covenant, consideration would be given to developing a directory or mapping system of VCSE organisations and services in order to help identify gaps in provision, particularly within critical advice and support services across the borough. In response, it was confirmed that a significant amount of information regarding VCSE groups and organisations operating across the borough is already available. Members were advised that this information is currently published through “My Solihull Maps” on the Council’s website and is regularly maintained by the Community Development Team.
The third deputation was from [name removed] who was introduced by Cllr Holt - [name removed] noted that only 10% of residents responded, but many likely felt the issue did not directly affect them. Of those who did respond, 63% supported the merger. Ward councillors also supported the merger, as did the majority of parish councillors, with only three voting against.
Councillor R Holt (Chairman) – as a resident of Dickens Heath and in regards to a parochial discussion on how third party land ownership may impact on both the maintenance of the public realm and public safety.
· Councillor R Holt (Chairman) – thanked officers for the report and noted that the Armed Forces Covenant would be considered later in the meeting. He requested an update on the implementation of the Chelmsley Wood PSPO, previously delayed due to technical issues, and asked whether any further barriers remained. The Board was advised that the PSPO is now in place and operating effectively, with police updates indicating a positive deterrent impact even where enforcement is not required.
· Councillor R Holt (Chairman) – highlighted the importance of recognising and supporting veterans in Solihull and the significant contribution they make. He noted the new duties introduced by the Armed Forces Act and expressed interest in how services respond to veterans’ needs, particularly where trauma or PTSD may lead to contact with the criminal justice system. He stressed the need to ensure appropriate support for veterans facing such disadvantages and invited Members to comment on how future service delivery could continue to reflect the needs of the armed forces community.
· Councillor R Holt (Chairman) - noted that Members were content with the approach and requested future updates on how the new Act will affect support for veterans and how the Council will continue to respond. He confirmed that the Board would welcome further information as the new duties take effect.
· Councillor R Holt (Chairman) – sought clarification the Council’s responsibilities in relation to road traffic collisions, particularly where such incidents occur outside the direct control of the local authority and asked for an explanation of how these responsibilities are defined and applied. Officers explained that in the event of a road traffic collision, the emergency services lead the initial response. Once the scene is declared safe, the Council assumes responsibility for coordinating the clear ? up and restoring the highway, which may include dealing with damaged barriers, diesel spillages and carriageway repairs.
Councillor Holt noted the Council’s efforts to have children educated locally and referenced page 203, paragraph 5.1 of the report, questioning what the costs for the independent special schools provision were out of area in terms of the overall £12M deficit in the current financial year.
Secondly, Councillor Holt raised the impact of such policies directly on the children themselves when educated outside of the borough.
Councillor Holt that a child’s outcomes were likely to be more positive when educated within their local community with their local peer group. The Head of Access to Education advised that the independent provision cost was approximately £12M in itself.
Councillor Holt raised the related issues of performance and disciplinary capacity in instances involving mental health, specifically the number of cases being reported and whether this was a trend leading to further stress related absences. Members were advised that where a disciplinary investigation was taking place the employee’s sickness absence figures were known.
· Cllr R Holt – sought further information on the Active Travel Fund Tranche 5, specifically the upgrade of the Blossomfield Road Active Travel route and an extension of the route between that location and Dickens Heath Village, given the future increases in housing and those already recently built off Dog Kennel Lane.
Cllr Holt also highlighted that there were no West Midlands Cycle Hire bikes within Dickens Heath and asked if that future provision could be encouraged. The Cabinet Member advised that he had no direct control over the provision of the West Midlands Cycle Hire scheme. In relation to the Blossomfield Road Active Travel route, the Board was advised that issues existed regarding the safe deliverability of an extension to that route and the Active Travel Team was giving consideration how they might be overcome.
Alternative routes via Widney Lane and Cranmore Boulevard already existed for cyclists and Cllr Holt encouraged the Cabinet Member to formalise the use of those roads in any future extension to the Blossomfield Road Active Travel route, as an alternative to Marshall Lake Road. · Cllr A Wilson – asked for clarification as to what design provision was built into the active travel routes for users with mobility issues who may require additional space. Officers advised that further information regarding mobility access considerations when designing cycle routes would be sought and communicated after the meeting.
· Cllr R Holt – welcomed the formulation of the new Strategy and highlighted the importance of a financial model to ensure that the delivery of the Strategy was successful.
Cllr Holt also highlighted the employment benefits from a stronger cultural and arts offer, potentially using the Strategy as a catalyst to connect local talent to investment and linkages to television (studios), going forwards. In response, Officers highlighted the current creator’s network, a group of practitioners with differing specialisms. Officers also highlighted that ... view the full minutes text for item 9.
ELECTION OF CHAIRMAN FOR THE 2025/26 MUNICPAL YEAR Councillor Mrs Holl-Allen nominated Councillor D Pinwell, seconded by Councillor R Holt.
Councillor Mrs D Holl-Allen nominated Councillor R Holt, seconded by Councillor E Fitter.
For the appointment of Councillor R Holt as Resources and Delivering Value Scrutiny Board Vice-Chairman for 2025/26:
· Cllr R Holt – commended the Council on the work being undertaken via the Holiday Activity and Food Programme that, in 2024/25, had provided 71 holiday clubs, delivered by 44 providers (mostly local organisations and groups) and attended by over 4,000 children in receipt of free school meals or considered vulnerable.
Cllr Holt enquired if there was any future ambition to develop that offer going forwards to further support food security for children. The Cabinet Portfolio Holder acknowledged the importance of that initiative. Officers advised that in terms of the Holiday Activity and Food Programme, continuous improvements had been made, year on year.
Cllr Holt also highlighted Solihull’s Domestic Abuse Strategy and, specifically, male victims being a key focus in the coming year due to Solihull having two male Domestic Homicide Reviews (DHRs). The Scrutiny Board had previously expressed concern at the pathways of support for male victims of domestic abuse. The Deputy Director of Public Health advised the Board of the general learning from DHR’s, which was considered extremely important on a local level, with information being shared across all parts of the system to strengthen and improve practices in areas such as record keeping, referrals, training, and assessments.
Cllr Holt suggested that learning, where appropriate to do so, should be cascaded to Elected Members too. Officers ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
· Cllr R Holt – reiterated his concerns aired at the January meeting that such a change in policy could have an impact on blind and partially sighted residents and result in accidents. The current report had not satisfactorily addressed that concern. The report noted that at 100% energy use, the lighting Lux level was found to average at 9.87.
Cllr Holt remained of the view that he had concerns as to the effect of the new policy on residents with visual impairments which were adversely affected by reduced lighting levels. Officers reiterated that, as part of any new policy going forwards, they would consider each site on its individual merits as they were aware that, in some areas of the Borough, a reduction in street lighting energy might not be viable. Were necessary, the views of the emergency services would also be sought to enable informed judgements to be made on individual locations.
Councillor Holt noted that regarding financial implications around Special Educational Needs and Disabilities (SEND) places, children needed to be educated locally.
Guests In Attendance Perry Wardle, Assistant Director, Growth and Development Satnam Kaur, Assistant Director for Housing Walter Bailey, Group Manager -Transport & Infrastructure Commissioning David Balme, Transport Planner Paul Edwards, Executive Director- Customer Experience & Customer Support (SCH) Darren Baggs (V), Director of Operations (SCH) Paul Rogers: Democratic Services Councillor I Courts, Lead Member for Business & Economy and Leader of the Council Councillor K Grinsell, Lead Member for Children & Education and Deputy Leader of the Council Councillor Mark Parker, Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Housing Harriett O’Hara, Member Relationship Officer, WMCA Steve Hayes, Head of Network Transit, TfWM Matt Lewis, Technical Director, SWIFT Rachel Foy, Head of Marketing & Engagement, WMCA Councillor M Carthew, Councillor H Dawkins, Councillor K Green (V), Councillor R Holt, Councillor L Kaye, Councillor R Long, Councillor M McCarthy, Councillor S Sheshabhatter The Economic Development and Managed Growth Scrutiny Board meeting commenced at 6:00 p.m.
Ø Cllr Holt queried the reasons for HS2 connecting to Euston rather than London St. Pancras International.
Ø Cllr Holt asked what the plans ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
· Cllr R Holt – highlighted health and safety concerns and asked if Officers had sought any expert advice from either RoSPA or RNIB when developing the proposal.
Regular updates would be shared with the Cabinet Member before further locations were identified and enforced. · Cllr R Holt – welcomed the implementation of the new enforcement powers in light of the positive impact it would have on road safety.
Cllr Holt drew attention to the proposed yellow box junction contravention enforcement at the Warwick Road/New Road junction and stated that motorists could regularly incur financial penalties for inadvertently contravening this category of restriction.
Cllr Holt sought further assurances that the enforcement of yellow box junctions was an appropriate category of restriction, which, if enforced would give clear road safety benefits. Officers acknowledged that yellow box junctions were contentious. J6 of the M42 was given as an example where poor compliance gave rise to significant traffic congestion exiting the NEC at peak times.
Councillors: O Farr and [name removed] (Councillor R Holt – substitute)
· Cllr R Holt – sought further detail on the Domestic Abuse Delivery Plan and asked what changes to that were anticipated in the year ahead. The Portfolio Holder advised that the Delivery Plan for 2024/25 included improving access to information and advice developing new awareness-raising material to improve communication with victims and professionals. The Portfolio Holder also invited any other specific questions for this priority outside of the meeting.
· Cllr R Holt – asked what building safety challenges were perceived in relation to the Council’s high-rise residential buildings. Officers highlighted the new Building Safety Act, and as a result of that, any buildings of 18m or greater in height, now needed to be registered with the Building Safety Regulator. This would ensure safe compliance with fire risk, electrical and gas safety, lift operations, legionella, and asbestos.
Councillor Dave Pinwell assumed the role of Chairman as Councillor Richard Holt was not in attendance for this application.
· Cllr R Holt – I feel that the report does not pick up the detail of complaints in the same manner as the compliments.
§ Cllr R Holt – The report is too focussed on the compliments it doesn’t allow us to get a feel for the complaints.
Cllr Yvonne Clements proposed Cllr Richard Holt.
Cllr Laura McCarthy received 5 votes and Cllr Richard Holt received 8 votes.
RESOLVED Cllr Richard Holt was duly elected Vice Chair – Children’s Services, Education and Skills Scrutiny Board for the Municipal Year 2023-2024.
· Cllr R Holt – You have told us there are no unallocated cases but isn’t it the case that we will always capture some as there will naturally be some that aren’t yet allocated for example if they came in just before the reporting took place.
· Cllr R Holt – It would be useful to get some more detail on the risk of unallocated cases as it can be dependent on each case.
· Cllr R Holt – It would be useful to have some more detailed analysis of near misses with partners as we need to know if partners are letting us down.
Councillor Holt referenced the Multi-Agency Family Hub and the associated funding programme and sough further information as to what was planned for the physical hubs. The Director of Public Health confirmed that the hubs were being looked at in terms of their sustainability over the longer term. It was important to note that there was no new Capital spend available to place services under one roof, which clearly brings additional, longer-term costs.
Councillor Richard Holt was not in attendance at the commencement of this application and took no part in the debate or vote.
· Cllr R Holt with Cllr Mrs D Hol -Allen MBE attending as a substitution but sending her apologies.
RESOLVED That Councillor Richard Holt be elected Vice-Chairperson of the Children’s Services, Education and Skills Scrutiny Board for the 2022/23 Municipal Year.
CONFIRMATION OF ELECTION OF CHAIRMAN AND VICE CHAIRMAN 2022/23 Councillor M Parker and Councillor R Holt were confirmed unanimously as Chairman and Vice Chairman respectively for the Resources and Delivering Value Scrutiny Board for the 2022/23 municipal year.
Councillor Holt requested an update in regards to the Minor Injuries Unit (MIU) at Solihull Hospital.
· Leader of the Council, Lead Member for the Economy – Cllr Ian Courts · Deputy Leader of the Council, Lead Member for Partnerships and Wellbeing – Cllr Karen Grinsell · Environment and Infrastructure – Cllr Ken Hawkins · Resources – Cllr Bob Sleigh OBE · Stronger and Safer Communities – Cllr Alison Rolf · Children, Education and Skills – Cllr Richard Holt · Adult Social Care and Health – Cllr Tony Dicicco · Leisure, Tourism and Sport – Cllr Joe Tildesley · Climate Change, Planning and Housing – Cllr Andy Mackiewicz
Cllr R Holt substituted by Cllr D Holl-Allen, Cllr P Thomas substituted by Cllr P Hogarth, Cllr A Rebeiro, [name removed] (Diocesan Representative)
Cllr R Holt declared an interest in so far his firm had been used by the Local Authority’s Legal Services Team.
Cllr R Holt declared an interest in so far his firm had been used by the Local Authority’s Legal Services Team.
Councillor R Holt made a declaration, on the basis he worked for a private legal practice that advised local residents on compensation claims for HS2.
Councillor Holt flagged up the matter of ... view the full minutes text for item 31.
Councillor Holt flagged up that a request had been received for local residents to meet with Committee Members outside of the Advisory Group meeting, to discuss the delegation and consultation arrangements for the HS2 applications. He explained this would not be the correct forum, on the basis the Advisory Group Members were not responsible for determining how HS2 related applications were managed.
Councillor Holt detailed how this responsibility sat with the Cabinet Member for Managed Growth, so as a consequence it would be appropriate to make any representations to him.
Cllr R Holt declared an interest in so far his firm had been used by the Local Authorities Legal Services department.
Councillor Holt gave a detailed presentation on his views on the Strategy with particular regard to cycling , he concluded with his Top eight Actions in respect of cycling, which in summary were:
Councillor R Holt submitted a petition on behalf of local residents, requesting for the provision of pavement facilities to Dickens Heath Sports club, in order to improve access.
Cllr R Holt declared an interest in so far as his law firm did work with fostering agencies.
Councillor R Holt substituted for Councillor Mrs D Holl-Allen.
Councillor R Holt noted the issues raised by Sheila Cooper and queried what the process would be for securing such a continuous haul route, once HS2 had received Royal Assent.
Cllr R Holt declared as interest in agenda item 7 in so far he was on the Governing body of Alderbrook School.
RESOLVED That Cllr R Holt be appointed as the Board’s Chairman for the ensuing Municipal Year
The Cabinet welcomed Cllr Richard Holt to the meeting who was in attendance to present the recommendations from the Hobs Moat North and Green Hill Task and Finish Group, which had been supported by the Economic Development and Land Scrutiny Board.
Councillor Holt declared a potential conflict of interest in respect of the request for a community governance review of Dickens Heath Parish Council, as he was a member of the Parish Council.
For the purposes of the record, Councillor R Holt advised the meeting that he was a Member of Dickens Heath Parish Council and a resident of Dickens Heath (in relation to the Dickens Heath Pavement and Grass Verge Parking Review).
The Chairman of the TFG Cllr R Holt was in attendance and presented the report to the Cabinet.
Included in the TFG report was a number of recommendations which Cllr Holt requested that the Cabinet consider namely:
Councillor Holt declared a prejudicial interest in application 2014/896 – Windward Way/Chester Road, Smiths Wood.
a) Audit Committee 3 November 2014 b) Licensing Committee 13 November 2014 c) Governance Committee 18 November 2014 Amendment to Minute 10 Councillor R Holt declared a potential conflict of interest in this item as an elected member of Dickens Heath Parish Council, not Cheswick Green Parish Council.
Councillor R Holt declared a potential conflict of interest this item, in matters relating to Cheswick Green and Dickens Heath Parish Councils, as an elected member of the Dickens Heath Parish Council). He remained in the meeting but did not take part in voting on this item).
Councillor Holt declared a potential conflict of interest in respect of the request for a community governance review of Dickens Heath Parish Council, as he was a member of the Parish Council.
(Councillor R Holt declared a potential conflict of interest this item, as a member of the Dickens Heath Parish Council. He remained in the meeting but did not take part in voting on this item).
(Councillor R Holt declared a potential conflict of interest in matters relating to Cheswick Green Parish Council, as an elected member of the neighbouring Dickens Heath Parish Council).
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Holt attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 23 May 2023 | Children’s Services & Education Scrutiny Board | Draft Work Plan - MY 2023-2024 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 1 Mar 2017 | Council | Questions and Deputations under Standing Order 9 and 12 | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Holt was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 19 of 25 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Holt declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 13 Mar 2018 | Children’s Services & Education Scrutiny Board, item 2 | Cllr R Holt declared an interest in so far his firm had been used by the Local Authority’s Legal Services Team. | |
| 30 Jan 2018 | Children’s Services & Education Scrutiny Board, item 2 | Cllr R Holt declared an interest in so far his firm had been used by the Local Authority’s Legal Services Team. | |
| 15 Jan 2018 | Children’s Services & Education Scrutiny Board, item 2 | Cllr R Holt declared an interest in so far his firm had been used by the Local Authorities Legal Services department. | |
| 23 May 2017 | Children’s Services & Education Scrutiny Board, item 4 | Cllr R Holt declared an interest in so far as his law firm did work with fostering agencies. | |
| 9 Feb 2016 | Children’s Services & Education Scrutiny Board, item 3 | Cllr R Holt declared as interest in agenda item 7 in so far he was on the Governing body of Alderbrook School. | |
| 15 Jan 2015 | Governance Committee, item 12 | Councillor Holt declared a potential conflict of interest in respect of the request for a community governance review of Dickens Heath Parish Council, as he was a member of the Parish Council. | |
| 17 Dec 2014 | Planning Committee, item 2 | Councillor Holt declared a prejudicial interest in application 2014/896 – Windward Way/Chester Road, Smiths Wood. | |
| 2 Dec 2014 | Council, item 14 | a) Audit Committee 3 November 2014 b) Licensing Committee 13 November 2014 c) Governance Committee 18 November 2014 Amendment to Minute 10 Councillor R Holt declared a potential conflict of interest in this item as an elected member of Dickens Heath Parish Council, not Cheswick Green Parish Council. | |
| 18 Nov 2014 | Governance Committee, item 10 | Councillor R Holt declared a potential conflict of interest this item, in matters relating to Cheswick Green and Dickens Heath Parish Councils, as an elected member of the Dickens Heath Parish Council). He remained in the meeting but did not take part in voting on this item). | Took no part |
| 25 Sep 2014 | Governance Committee, item 11 | Councillor Holt declared a potential conflict of interest in respect of the request for a community governance review of Dickens Heath Parish Council, as he was a member of the Parish Council. | |
| 25 Sep 2014 | Governance Committee, item 18 | (Councillor R Holt declared a potential conflict of interest this item, as a member of the Dickens Heath Parish Council. He remained in the meeting but did not take part in voting on this item). | Took no part |
| 25 Jun 2014 | Governance Committee, item 9 | (Councillor R Holt declared a potential conflict of interest in matters relating to Cheswick Green Parish Council, as an elected member of the neighbouring Dickens Heath Parish Council). |
Where Councillor Holt sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Jul 2014 | 59 | 8 Dec 2026 |
| Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Jun 2015 | 47 | 15 Dec 2026 |
| Governance Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2014 | 16 | 19 Nov 2026 |
| Stronger Communities and Neighbourhood Services Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | May 2024 | 10 | |
| Planning Committee | Chairman | May 2018 | 36 | |
| Children’s Services & Education Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Feb 2016 | 20 | |
| Neighbourhood Services Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Jun 2014 | 6 | |
| HS2 Implementation Advisory Group | Committee Member | Jan 2017 | 6 | |
| Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Jun 2015 | 5 | |
| Cabinet | Committee Member | Jun 2021 | 5 | |
| CPH Children and Education Decision Session | Committee Member | May 2021 | 4 | |
| Economic Development & Land Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Jun 2014 | 3 | |
| Solihull Health & Wellbeing Board | Committee Member | Jun 2021 | 3 | |
| Health and Adult Social Care Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Feb 2023 | 3 | |
| Crime and Disorder Scrutiny Panel | Committee Member | Apr 2017 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.