Council Motion Response: Fly Tipping & Environmental Crime
Councillor W Qais – Cabinet Member (Communities Portfolio); and Councillor S Gethen (Council Motion Proposer).
Every time Solihull's minutes name Councillor Gethen, as the council published it.
Councillor W Qais – Cabinet Member (Communities Portfolio); and Councillor S Gethen (Council Motion Proposer).
Councillor S Gethen thanked Officers for the report and acknowledged progress since the previous update, noting the increased use of mobile CCTV, the establishment of regular partner meetings, and the provision of up-to-date fly-tipping data. However, concern was expressed that, despite an increase in investigations, enforcement outcomes appeared limited, with relatively few fixed penalty notices issued and no prosecution figures reported. The Member emphasised that residents expect visible enforcement action against offenders and requested greater focus on outcomes.
Councillor Gethen noted that the report detail showed that of SCH’s customers, 33% had a reported disability or vulnerability, with 42% of that cohort having submitted a complaint to SCH regarding anti-social behaviour ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Councillor Gethen queried whether schools and support services would have sufficient capacity to meet increasing SEND needs. She also raised concerns around the potential consequences for families should the reforms not be implemented as planned (noting possible impact on exclusions and home education numbers).
Cllr Gethen asked whether the DfE had raised concerns about the number of EHCPs being ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Cllr Gethen raised concerns around the complaints relating to the Children with Disabilities Team, the number (and nature) of EHCP-related complaints, and the potential for compensation payments to increase as EHCP numbers rise.
Cllr Gethen asked how the government’s Best Start in Life initiative would impact on existing Family Hubs.
Cllr Gethen commented on the financial pressures in Children’s Services, and asked whether the High Needs Stability grant, if/when received, would be ring?fenced for Children’s Services.
Concerns around the overall assurance level were echoed by Cllr Gethen and Cllr McLoughlin, and the Chairman commented that concerns had been raised by the Committee previously regarding the reduction in resources.
In relation to the risks associated with Children’s Services, Cllr Gethen queried whether the risk ratings would decrease in the light of the recent ‘Good’ Ofsted inspection.
Councillor Gethen referenced Table 1 in the report, ‘ Solihull MBC CRSTS Funded Schemes’ , noting that scheme delays appeared to have detrimental associated costs.
With that in mind, Councillor Gethen enquired whether there would be any performance data to compare actual outcomes with the original scheme’s business case once the schemes had been implemented.
Councillor S Gethen signed by residents calling for the retention of an accessible Police Station in Solihull Town Centre with a public front desk.
Councillor S Gethen proposed the Motion as printed and was seconded by Councillor S Brown.
Amendment Councillor S Gethen, seconded by Councillor A Feeney, proposed the following amendment (additions in bold and underlined, deletions in strikethrough):
Councillor C Brown nominated Councillor S Gethen, seconded by Councillor L Taylor.
Councillor C Brown nominated Councillor S Gethen, seconded by Councillor Taylor.
In relation to the plan around child sexual abuse response, Cllr Gethen noted that the report stated that needs would be assessed and responded to in a timely manner.
Cllr Gethen commented that she would like to see Youth Justice scheduled on the work programme and it was noted that this was currently earmarked for the end of 26/27 or the start of 27/28. It was noted that the Work Programme was for the Board to decide and that if the Board felt that a report needed to take precedence at a particular meeting, they may need to consider the overall balance of the plan, and whether other items could be moved to a later meeting/deferred. It was important for there to be some flex built into the plan to accommodate changes.
On the motion of Councillor Gethen, seconded by Councillor Whelan, it was:
Cllr Gethen introduced [name removed] who addressed Council on the 31% increase in business rates she was facing in 2026/2027 and the lack of support given to small businesses in the town. The Cabinet Member for Resources in responding confirmed that Business Rates were set by the Value Office Agency (VOA) and the multiplier applied was determined by government on an annual basis. The Councils role was to collect the business rate on behalf of government.
Councillor Gethen raised the following points:
Councillor Gethen requested further information on the support in place.
· Cllr S Gethen – highlighted from the report that, going forwards, the Portfolio would continue to make significant progress in developing Solihull’s “Youth Offer” including building on the success of the Holiday Activity and Food Programme, growing clubs and activities, the support available to the youth sector, readiness for changes to national policy and investment, and promoting inclusion of children and young people with SEND.
Cllr Gethen welcomed this and asked, typically, what the service might look like. Officers advised of the work that had already been undertaken to support the priority and further work, going forwards, to promote the inclusion of children and young people with SEND. Additionally, further information was sought on the priority to implement a DBS solution that ensured compliance with the Department for Transport’s mandate for six-monthly DBS checks for all taxi drivers.
· Cllr S Gethen – welcomed the initiative of a new Strategy and highlighted events that had previously taken place within the Town Centre and at The Core.
Cllr Gethen asked what mechanisms were in place to ensure that the Strategy could adapt to change, and new cultural trends and community needs between 2025-2035. Also, how would the performance of the Strategy be monitored to ensure best value for money, what public engagement would there be to encourage participation, and how would the Council ensure that equal benefit was felt across all communities within Solihull. Officers advised that the main driver for developing a new Strategy was establishing a targeted approach to future investment, and that investment was attracted in the right places (the Council being a facilitator of culture with the ambition to deliver as much cultural and arts offer as possible.
RESOLVED Cllr Gethen was elected Chair of the Children’s Services and Education Scrutiny Board for the Municipal Year 2025-2026.
The third deputation was from [name removed], who was introduced by Cllr Gethen. [name removed] deputation related to traffic issues and road safety concerns on Churchill road, which had become a racing track.
Motion Two – Cllr Feeney will move, and Cllr Gethen will second:
Councillor Heather Delaney requested to speak on application 2023/02214 – Pheasant Oak Farm, Hob Lane, Balsall Common; Councillor Dave Pinwell on 2023/02294 – land south of Knowle (Arden Triangle), Warwick Road, Knowle; and Councillor Samantha Gethen on 2024/02704 – 5 Woodside Way, Solihull.
[name removed] and Councillor Samantha Gethen spoke against the application.
Deputations · Cllr S Gethen (Ward Councillor deputation) – spoke in support of the application made by the Friends of Hillfield Park; one of the projects not recommended for funding (NCIL24-011). The appendices to the Officers report highlighted the full reasons for that decision. Officers summarised that the application lacked sufficient information on costings and quotes, and funding for the entire project was being sought from Shirley South money only.
In relation to NurtureUK training, Cllr Gethen queried why some schools had not been partaking in the programme.
In relation to permanently excluded children from special schools, Cllr Gethen queried where these children received their education once excluded.
In relation to elective home education (EHE), Cllr Gethen queried how many children in EHE were on the SEND register and removed from school due to the child struggling in school.
Cllr Gethen asked how much education children on part time timetables were accessing.
Due to other Council business, apologies were received from Members of the Health and Adult Social Care Scrutiny Board: Councillor Mrs G Sleigh, Councillor D Cole, Councillor H Delaney, Councillor S Gethen, Councillor Mrs D Holl-Allen MBE, Councillor A Mackenzie, Councillor A Wilson, Councillor O Farr and Councillor K Jones.
Councillor Gethen as Council appointee to BSOL Mental Health Foundation Trust, Corporate Parenting Board, Solihull Schools Forum, West Midlands Combined Authority Transport Delivery Overview and Scrutiny Committee and West Midlands Pension Committee.
In relation to the administration issues highlighted by Ofsted, Cllr Gethen queried what had gone wrong and what was in place to ensure improvements were made.
RESOLVED That Councillor S Gethen be appointed Vice-Chairman for the 2024/25 Municipal Year.
· Cllr Gethen requested further details regarding children with EHCPs being below were they were expected to be.
· Cllr Gethen questioned what changes had been made to improve the review process of EHCP’s;
· Cllr Gethen referenced that some schools and/or parents had wanted EHCP Officers to attend review meetings and asked if this could be accommodated so ensuring EHCP's were done properly the first time.
5) Cllr Gethen submitted a petition on behalf of residents requesting that planning application No PL/2024/00011/PPEL, De Vere Village Hotel, Dog Kennel Lane be refused.
· Cllr Gethen asked that prior to a pupil being excluded were schools making action referrals.
· Cllr Gethen questioned whether every child permanently excluded attended the 6 th day provision, and why the number of exclusions in Solihull were higher than the national average.
· Cllr Gethen expressed concern over the high number of exclusions in special schools, as she hoped they would be better placed to support children and questioned whether this was being monitored.
· Cllr Gethen questioned whether some children who were excluded go on to be diagnosed with SEND?
Councillor Thomas Councillor McKenzie (Councillor Burrow – substitute) Councillor Gethen (Councillor Marwa MBE – substitute)
· Cllr S Gethen – I am disappointed at the number of complaints. On Page 36, it also leaves me disappointed that the complaints seem to be easily avoidable. What are we doing to make sure that these won’t be in the report next year?
Cllr S Gethen requested that an item be added to the Work Plan looking at the provision of Post-16 education for SEND children and whether this was sufficient which the Board agreed to review in March 2024.
The Chair informed the board that he had met with Cllr S Gethen, S Freeman and Democratic Services after there had been some concern that there was not enough focus on the work plan relating to SEND issues. The outcome of that meeting was that there would be a request for more data on the upcoming EHCP Complaint Report to inform whether further scrutiny was needed on issues relating to EHCPs and the addition of an item to the work plan that would focus on the Emotional Base School Avoidance pathway scheme that was ended by the Council.
Cllr A Mackenzie proposed Cllr S Gethen.
Cllr S Gethen received 5 votes and Cllr K Thomas received 4 votes.
RESOLVED Cllr S Gethen was duly elected Vice Chair – Health and Adult Social Care Scrutiny Board for the Municipal Year 2023-2024.
Councillor S Gethen attended the meeting in relation to the summary and assessment of bids for funding from the neighbourhood proportion of the Community Infrastructure Levy and spoke in support of the proposed allocation of funding to the Malvern Park play area improvements.
Councillor S Gethen attended the meeting and spoke in support of the proposed allocation of funding to the Malvern Park play area improvements.
· Cllr S Gethen – What does a virtual school look like?
· Cllr S Gethen – Page 55 highlights a new referral pathway which if it works as I think will be very welcomed by the community. Can you please just expand on this? o AD-E – Colleagues in the Integrated Care Board have designed this process where you will need a single referral and ... view the full minutes text for item 12.
· Cllr S Gethen – The current pathway for crisis support isn’t working, are we going to see an improvement?
· Cllr S Gethen – Do all schools work well with your team?
· Cllr S Gethen – Does your team support children/young people with SEND?
On the motion of Councillor K Grinsell, seconded by Councillor Gethen, it was:
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Gethen attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 23 May 2023 | Children’s Services & Education Scrutiny Board | Draft Work Plan - MY 2023-2024 | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Gethen was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 29 of 43 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Gethen declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Gethen in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Gethen sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | May 2022 | 22 | 8 Dec 2026 |
| Children’s Services & Education Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Jun 2022 | 20 | |
| Health and Adult Social Care Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Jun 2022 | 18 | |
| Resources & Delivering Value Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | May 2023 | 9 | 15 Dec 2026 |
| Cabinet | Committee Member | May 2026 | 8 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| CPH Children and Education Decision Session | Committee Member | Jun 2025 | 5 | 24 Nov 2026 |
| CPH Adult Social Care and Health Decision Session | Committee Member | Apr 2024 | 4 | 16 Dec 2026 |
| Audit Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2026 | 4 | |
| Solihull Health & Wellbeing Board | Committee Member | Jun 2025 | 3 | 24 Nov 2026 |
| Governance Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2026 | 3 | 19 Nov 2026 |
| Economic Development, Managed Growth and Skills Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | Jul 2026 | 3 | |
| CPH Housing Decision Session | Committee Member | Jun 2025 | 2 | |
| Schools Forum | Committee Member | Jul 2026 | 1 | |
| Joint Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2024 | 3 | |
| Stronger Communities and Neighbourhood Services Scrutiny Board | Committee Member | May 2025 | 1 | |
| CPH Climate Change & Planning Decision Session | Committee Member | Jun 2025 | 1 | |
| CPH Communities Decision Session | Committee Member | Jun 2025 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.