Declarations of Interest
Councillor Filmer declared he is a member of the Axe Brue Internal Drainage Board who is a lead consultant for an Application on the Agenda, he has taken part in no discussions and comes to the meeting with an open mind.
Every time Somerset's minutes name Councillor Filmer, as the council published it.
Councillor Filmer declared he is a member of the Axe Brue Internal Drainage Board who is a lead consultant for an Application on the Agenda, he has taken part in no discussions and comes to the meeting with an open mind.
After deliberations Councillor Filmer proposed to grant listed building consent.
Vice-Chair vote in Councillor Hendry nominated Councillor Ham to be Vice-Chair for the Meeting, this was seconded by Councillor Filmer.
After deliberations Councillor Filmer proposed to grant planning permission.
After deliberations Councillor Filmer proposed to grant planning permission.
Member questions were received from:- · Councillor Bob Filmer · Councillor Frances Nicholson · Councillor Diogo Rodrigues · Councillor Lucy Trimnell · Councillor Susannah Hart · Councillor Dawn Denton The questions and responses are attached to the minutes in Annexe B.
Councillor Bob Filmer and Councillor Alistair Hendry declared they were a Member of the Axe Brue Internal Drainage Board but had taken part in no discussions on the Planning Applications being considered and come to the Committee with an open mind.
(Voting: 4 For, 5 Against, 0 Abstentions) Councillor Filmer then proposed to Grant planning permission.
Councillor Bob Filmer declared an Other Registrable interest in all applications as a member of the Axe Brue Internal Drainage Board but had not taken part in any discussions.
Councillor Bob Filmer declared a Registrable interest in application 31/24/00005 as Division member for Brent.
This was seconded by Cllr Filmer, and when taken to the vote was carried by 11 in favour (unanimous).
Subject to a change to include the Councillors who had sat as substitutes at the meeting, the minutes were proposed by Councillor Bob Filmer and seconded by Councillor Lucy Trimnell and were approved as a true and accurate record.
Councillor Bob Filmer declared an Other Registrable interest as a member of Axe Brue Internal Drainage Board but had not taken part in any discussions.
Before moving on to the next agenda item, the Chair, Councillor Pugsley, paid tribute to the former Chair, Councillor Bob Filmer. He thanked him for his hard work which was appreciated and valued by all and was pleased that he was continuing to be a Committee Member.
During the discussion, the following points were raised:- · The following additional changes were also highlighted, that Councillor Diogo Rodrigues be removed from the Scrutiny Committee for Corporate and Resources and that Councillor Bob Filmer be added to the committee.
· The Leader of the Council thanked Councillor Filmer for his hard work as the previous Chair of the Scrutiny Committee for Corporate and Resources.
To also approve the removal of Councillor Diogo Rodrigues from the committee and be replaced by Councillor Bob Filmer.
Councillor Bob Filmer declared an Other Registrable Interest as he was a member of the Somerset Drainage Board.
Councillor Filmer also declared an Other Registrable Interest in Planning Application 15/24/00010 Tavener Court, Front Street, Stone Allerton, Axbridge , Somerset, BS26 2NN as he was a Councillor for Stone Allerton and was present at the Parish Council meeting but took no part in the discussions on that application.
After discussions that followed Councillor Bob Filmer proposed to grant outline planning permission with conditions as discussed subject to a Deed of Variation to the approved Outline Planning Permission.
Abstain:1) After consideration that there was no highways objection, the extant permission at the site, and the location of the site in flood zone 1 Councillor Alistair Hendry proposed to grant permission subjected to condition 12 being amended and additional condition 15 regarding the required travel plan to be added, which was duly seconded by Councillor Bob Filmer.
Councillor Bob Filmer declared an Other Registrable Interest in Planning Application 12/24/00001 Oak Tree Farm, Bristol Road, Edithmead , Highbridge, Somerset, TA9 9HA as he was predetermined having spoken to the agent and would withdraw from the Committee for that item.
This was seconded by Councillor Bob Filmer.
The Committee then heard from Councillor Bob Filmer from Brent Ward Parish who spoke in support of the application. He highlighted that the extra traffic this coffee shop would cause was minimal, especially since there was to be a major route network scheme to come through which would completely enhance the area. He confirmed that this was, in fact, being held up by Somerset Council waiting for funding from National Government and suggested that the Committee members contact the Secretary of State to push for this to be granted.
Having been proposed by Cllr Filmer and seconded by Cllr Redman, it was resolved that the minutes of the Scrutiny Committee - Corporate and Resources held on 28 August 2024 be confirmed as a correct record, subject to the following amendment being made to Minute 43 – Recommendation 4:
The Chairs of Somerset Council’s Scrutiny Committees, Councillor Leigh Redman, Councillor Gwil Wren, Councillor Bob Filmer and Councillor Martin Dimery, introduced each of their reports, which detailed the activity of each of the five Scrutiny Committees since the previous meeting of Full Council.
Councillor Bob Filmer who was substituted by Diogo Rodrigues.
Councillor Bob Filmer declared an Other Registrable Interest in applications 21/23/00023 and 24/23/00018 as he was a member of the Parrett Drainage Board but had taken no part in any discussions.
Following the debate, Councillor Bob Filmer proposed to defer the application pending a site visit and receipt of further advice form the Highway Authority, which was duly seconded by Councillor Brian Smedley.
Councillor Bob Filmer proposed that the application be granted based on the assurance that there would only be one access point and Councillor Matt Martin seconded the proposal. Further debate followed with Officers assurance that the access opening had been reduced from the original suggested 6 metre opening to 3 metres in order to minimise the impact on the wall.
After further discussion by the committee it was proposed by Councillor Bob Filmer to grant permission and this was seconded by Councillor Brian Bolt.
After discussions by the committee regarding the flood risk assessment, septic tank and for the area to remain a gypsy and traveller site, Councillor Bob Filmer proposed to grant permission which was seconded by Councillor Alistair Hendry subject to conditions detailed within the officer’s report.
The five Chairs (or Vice Chair in the absence of the Chair) of Somerset Council’s Scrutiny Committees, Councillor Leigh Redman, Councillor Dawn Johnson, Councillor Bob Filmer, Councillor Gill Slocombe and Councillor Martin Dimery, introduced each of their reports, which detailed the activity of each of the five Scrutiny Committees since the previous meeting of Full Council.
Councillor Filmer proposed that the assessment be endorsed and this was seconded by Councillor Grimes.
At the conclusion of the debate, Councillor Slocombe proposed that the application be granted approval and this was seconded by Councillor Filmer.
At the conclusion of the debate, Councillor Murphy proposed that the application be refused on the grounds of noise and visual impact on the residents and that it was considered that there were insufficient details to demonstrate whether the mitigation measures would be fit for purpose; this proposal was seconded by Councillor Filmer.
Councillor Filmer proposed that the application be refused and this was seconded by Councillor Grimes.
Councillor Filmer proposed the officer recommendation to approve and this was seconded by Councillor Hendry.
Councillor Hendry proposed that the application be granted and this was seconded by Councillor Filmer.
Councillor Dave Mansell proposed an amendment, which was seconded by Councillor Bob Filmer. The amendment had been brought forward based on the concerns raised on the process followed for the review, working groups and workshop:- In Paper D, replace recommendations on Part D8 – Planning Committee Terms of Reference with the following new 2.1, 2):
The Chair of Scrutiny Committee for Corporate and Resources, Councillor Bob Filmer, introduced the report on the which was considered and endorsed by the Scrutiny Committee for Corporate and Resources at its meeting on 25 April 2024 and the Executive at its meeting on 8 May 2024.
Councillor Bob Filmer proposed the recommendations which were second by Councillor Leigh Redman.
The five Chairs of Scrutiny, Councillor Leigh Redman, Councillor Gwil Wren, Councillor Bob Filmer, Councillor Gill Slocombe and Councillor Henry Hobhouse, introduced each of their annual reports, which detailed the activity of each of the five Scrutiny Committees since vesting day.
Cllr B Filmer declared an Other Registerable interest in respect of applications 24/23/00016 and 06/23/00013 as he was the Division Member but had taken no part in discussions on the applications. He also confirmed that whilst he had taken part in the referral process in respect of application 06/23/00013. he retained an open mind. He also declared an Other Registrable Interest as a member of the Internal Drainage Board.
It was proposed by Cllr Filmer and seconded by Cllr Bolt that the application be deferred to allow a site visit and for updated officer comments to be obtained.
The Officer introduced the application with a PowerPoint presentation and the Committee was addressed by the Agent Members felt that the proposal was an improvement on what was currently there and it was proposed by Cllr Filmer and seconded by Cllr Grimes that the application be approved.
At the invitation of the Leader of the Council, Cllr Bill Revans, the Chair Scrutiny Committee Corporate and Resources, Cllr Bob Filmer and the Chair Scrutiny Committee Adults and Health, Cllr Gill Slocombe, commented on the .
The Chair of the Scrutiny Committee Corporate and Resources, Cllr Bob Filmer, welcomed the Executive and Full Council decision to keep the current Scrutiny function structure and emphasised the positive role of Scrutiny in helping and challenging the Executive were necessary.
Cllr Filmer further commented on the importance of the coordinating of Scrutiny Committee and Executive meetings to aid the scrutiny feedback process.
At the end of the debate, Councillor Bob Filmer proposed that the application be approved subject to the amended wording on the conditions and Councillor Alistair Hendry seconded the proposal.
Councillor Bob Filmer declared an Other Registrable Interest on application 24/23/00016 as he was a Division Member, he had made comment on the Outline application but had made no comment on this application and declared that he had an open mind and had not made any decision and will listen to all the merits of the debate before casting his vote.
· Councillor Heather Shearer · Councillor Tony Grimes · Councillor Matt Martin · Councillor Bob Filmer · Councillor Paul Fineran, substituted by Councillor D Bradley-Palmer · Delia McCarthy
Councillor Filmer requested that Proposers and Seconders of applications be recorded and the Chair of the committee agreed that this would be actioned for future minutes.
Cllr Revans further thanked the Scrutiny Committee - Corporate and Resources, for the work and valuable contribution throughout the budget setting process, and invited the Chair of the Scrutiny Committee – Corporate and Resources, Cllr Bob Filmer to comment on the process and recommendations.
Councillor Bob Filmer declared a pre-determined interest in Application 07/23/00026 as he had made comment on the proposal as the Division Member and asked for the application to be referred to the committee.
Councillor Filmer left the committee before consideration of this application as he declared that he was pre-determined as he had supported the proposal as the Division Member.
Councillor B Filmer proposed the recommendation subject to the amended and additional conditions as agreed with the committee and officers and Councillor Hendry seconded the proposal.
As some concerns were raised about the lack of parking spaces proposed, Councillor Bruce proposed to approve the recommendation subject to an additional condition to secure a third parking space, this was seconded by Councillor B Filmer.
At the conclusion of debate, it was proposed by Councillor B Filmer to approve the application and this was seconded by Councillor Bradford.
Councillor B Filmer declared on application 12/23/00025 that he had referred the application for consideration by committee, however he confirmed that he retained an open mind and would listen to all the information presented before casting his vote.
Councillor Filmer proposed the officer`s recommendation and Councillor Grimes seconded the motion.
Councillor Bradford proposed the recommendation with the additional conditions ad this was seconded by Councillor Filmer. On being put to the vote, the recommendation was approved unanimously.
Councillor Bob Filmer declared a Non Registerable Interest in application 33/23/00021 as applicant was known.
Councillor Filmer also wished to clarify that in respect of 33/23/00021, he was not pre-determined as he had not made comment on the application as stated within the report.
Councillor Filmer requested that if the application was granted, an additional condition should be added in respect to biodiversity enhancements i.e. bird and bat boxes.
The Planning Officer confirmed that the report was incorrect as it had reported Councillor Filmer had commented on the application, however his comments related to the referral process and not the actual application and he apologised for this error.
Councillor Hendry proposed the approval of the application and was seconded by Councillor Filmer (For 8, Abstention 1).
This was seconded by Councillor Filmer and for conditions to be agreed with the Chair and Vice-Chair of the committee (Unanimous).
Councillor John Cook-Woodman proposed Councillor Suria Aujla for the position of Chair of the LCN, Councillor Bob Filmer seconded the proposal.
Councillor Bob Filmer proposed Kevin Bray from East Brent Parish Council as the Vice-Chair and this was seconded by Councillor Alistair Hendry, [name removed] was duly appointed as the vote was unanimous.
The Council discussed the report and the following points were raised:- · Councillor Bob Filmer proposed an amendment to the wording for the Development Committee that took place on 7 February 2023, under item ‘Other Planning Applications’ and application 07/22/00025 registered 07/11/2022: ‘ It was also requested to be noted that the scale of development was a factor in the decision of the committee and any expansion of the site would not be acceptable due to the impact on the amenity of the surrounding area.’ The proposed amended wording was agreed by the proposer and seconder.
This proposal was seconded by Cllr Filmer.
Cllr B Filmer confirmed that he had taken part in the referral process in respect of application 07-23-00006, but that he retained an open mind and would listen to all the merits of the argument before casting his vote. He also declared an Other Registerable interest in respect of application 15/23/00002 as he was the Division Member but had taken no part in discussions on the application.
It was proposed by Cllr Filmer and seconded by Cllr Grimes that the application be approved subject to the conditions in the Planning Officer’s recommendation outlined in the report. On being put to the vote the proposal was carried unanimously.
Consequently, and it was proposed by Cllr Filmer and seconded by Cllr Bolt that the application be approved subject to the conditions in the Planning Officer’s recommendation outlined in the report. On being put to the vote the proposal was carried unanimously.
Cllr B Filmer confirmed that he had taken part in the referral process in respect of applications 07-23-00006 and 07-23-00007. But that he retained an open mind and would listen to all the merits of the argument before casting his vote.
It was subsequently proposed by Cllr Filmer and seconded by Cllr Slocombe to recommend approval of the application subject to the imposition of appropriate conditions to be agreed in consultation with the Chair and Vice-Chair. On being put to the vote the proposal was carried unanimously.
Consequently, it was proposed by Cllr Filmer and seconded by Cllr Slocombe that the application be approved subject to the conditions in the Planning Officer’s recommendation outlined in the report. On being put to the vote the proposal was carried unanimously.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Filmer attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Filmer's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Filmer was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Somerset has not published attendance for Councillor Filmer's meetings yet.
What Councillor Filmer declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11 Aug 2026 | Planning Committee - North, item 28 | Councillor Filmer declared he is a member of the Axe Brue Internal Drainage Board who is a lead consultant for an Application on the Agenda, he has taken part in no discussions and comes to the meeting with an open mind. | |
| 8 Apr 2025 | Planning Committee - North, item 24 | Councillor Bob Filmer declared an Other Registrable interest in all applications as a member of the Axe Brue Internal Drainage Board but had not taken part in any discussions. | |
| 8 Apr 2025 | Planning Committee - North, item 24 | Councillor Bob Filmer declared a Registrable interest in application 31/24/00005 as Division member for Brent. | |
| 14 Jan 2025 | Planning Committee - North, item 11 | Councillor Bob Filmer declared an Other Registrable interest as a member of Axe Brue Internal Drainage Board but had not taken part in any discussions. | |
| 12 Nov 2024 | Planning Committee - North, item 171 | Councillor Bob Filmer declared an Other Registrable Interest as he was a member of the Somerset Drainage Board. | |
| 12 Nov 2024 | Planning Committee - North, item 171 | Councillor Filmer also declared an Other Registrable Interest in Planning Application 15/24/00010 Tavener Court, Front Street, Stone Allerton, Axbridge , Somerset, BS26 2NN as he was a Councillor for Stone Allerton and was present at the Parish Council meeting but took no part in the discussions on that application. | Took no part |
| 8 Oct 2024 | Planning Committee - North, item 161 | Councillor Bob Filmer declared an Other Registrable Interest in Planning Application 12/24/00001 Oak Tree Farm, Bristol Road, Edithmead , Highbridge, Somerset, TA9 9HA as he was predetermined having spoken to the agent and would withdraw from the Committee for that item. | |
| 13 Aug 2024 | Planning Committee - North, item 141 | Councillor Bob Filmer declared an Other Registrable Interest in applications 21/23/00023 and 24/23/00018 as he was a member of the Parrett Drainage Board but had taken no part in any discussions. | |
| 14 May 2024 | Planning Committee - North, item 102 | Cllr B Filmer declared an Other Registerable interest in respect of applications 24/23/00016 and 06/23/00013 as he was the Division Member but had taken no part in discussions on the applications. He also confirmed that whilst he had taken part in the referral process in respect of application 06/23/00013. he retained an open mind. He also declared an Other Registrable Interest as a member of the Internal Drainage Board. | |
| 12 Mar 2024 | Planning Committee - North, item 91 | Councillor Bob Filmer declared an Other Registrable Interest on application 24/23/00016 as he was a Division Member, he had made comment on the Outline application but had made no comment on this application and declared that he had an open mind and had not made any decision and will listen to all the merits of the debate before casting his vote. | |
| 16 Jan 2024 | Planning Committee - North, item 68 | Councillor Bob Filmer declared a pre-determined interest in Application 07/23/00026 as he had made comment on the proposal as the Division Member and asked for the application to be referred to the committee. | |
| 14 Nov 2023 | Planning Committee - North, item 48 | Councillor B Filmer declared on application 12/23/00025 that he had referred the application for consideration by committee, however he confirmed that he retained an open mind and would listen to all the information presented before casting his vote. | |
| 10 Oct 2023 | Planning Committee - North, item 37 | Councillor Bob Filmer declared a Non Registerable Interest in application 33/23/00021 as applicant was known. |
Where Councillor Filmer sits, from the attendance records.
No committee attendance recorded for Councillor Filmer yet.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.