Declarations of Interest
Councillor Mansell raised an interest that they are the local member for Agenda Item 6 but they are not pre-determined and have kept an open mind.
Every time Somerset's minutes name Councillor Mansell, as the council published it.
Councillor Mansell raised an interest that they are the local member for Agenda Item 6 but they are not pre-determined and have kept an open mind.
Councillor Mansell arrived at this point, and as a result could not vote on the item.
Councillor Dave Mansell raised the following amendments to the previous minutes:
Councillor Dave Mansell advised that the minutes incorrectly referred to councillors querying the inclusion of a sewer. He clarified that the discussion had in fact focused on flooding risk within the drainage system below the site. Raised to amend wording to reflect that councillors raised concerns about the risk of flooding.
Councillor Dave Mansell raised concern that the minutes implied the Council’s Climate Positive Planning Guidance was not policy. He stated that the document itself describes it as policy guidance, and that the minutes therefore misrepresented the position. Suggested the removal of problematic wording and amend the text to state that the planning officer clarified that gas remained acceptable under building regulations and that solar panels were being used alongside gas at Orchard Grove, without implying the guidance lacked policy status.
Councillor Mansell highlighted four outstanding requests not captured, including briefings on Ramsar designations, climate service plan workshops, SRA levy representations, and solar policy clarity.
The discussion was introduced with reference to a suggestion from Councillor Mansell that the Committee should undertake more focused scrutiny of travel planning approaches, including how travel plans associated with development are designed, implemented, and monitored.
Councillor Mansell briefly outlined the rationale for the proposal, suggesting that travel plans are a critical but often under-scrutinised element of the planning system. He indicated that while travel plans are routinely required as part of development proposals, there is limited visibility of how effectively they are implemented in practice, and whether they deliver the intended behavioural changes in terms of transport choices.
· Councillor Mansell asked for a condition specifying the renewable energy and the use of this. The Chair opined that this was not possible at this time as it was not supported by policy at this time.
Significant concern was raised by Councillor Mansell regarding scrutiny recommendations on planning, agreed by this Committee in October 2025 and subsequently approved by Full Council, which appeared to have been inaccurately reported or misrepresented in an Executive report. It was highlighted that Member resolutions should not be rewritten by officers and that the Executive report in question appeared to state the opposite of what Full Council had resolved. Members expressed concern about the seriousness of this procedural issue and its potential implications.
It was agreed that Councillor Mansell would write to Democratic Services setting out the specific discrepancies identified, to enable officers to review the matter promptly and take corrective action where necessary. The Chair emphasised the importance of safeguarding the integrity of scrutiny outcomes.
Cllr Mansell stressed that there was no clear delivery plan for achieving carbon neutrality by 2030 and that confusion persisted between the Council’s organisational target and a wider Somerset-wide ambition.
Councillor Dave Mansell raised an issue regarding a lack of clarity in the previous minutes under the Planning Motion item and asked that this be clarified.
Councillor Mansell and O’Donell declared an interest that they knew some of the public speakers but were not predetermined.
Councillor Mansell left at this point, so it was noted he could not partake in the debate or vote on this item.
Councillor Dave Mansell spoke and raised that Wiveliscombe Town Council have objected to the development.
1) Cllr Mansell opened the discussion by noting that two items from the November meeting were missing from the tracker. One concerned Quiet Lanes, which he acknowledged had since been progressed via the Active Travel LCN Steering Group, so he no longer required further action.
3) Given concerns about transparency, impact, and enforcement, Cllr Mansell proposed establishing a short scrutiny review—either a Task & Finish Group or a Spotlight Review—to examine:
9) Cllr Mansell emphasised the importance of inviting external groups (cycle groups, bus groups, developers), as well as planning and transport officers. Other members supported this, noting that many concerns originate from organisations trying to use Travel Plans in practice.
3) Cllr Mansell delivered an extended intervention expressing deep concern about:
1) Cllr Mansell welcomed the report but highlighted several inaccuracies relating to Task & Finish Groups, noting that the minutes sometimes mis ? recorded whether such groups had been initiated or completed.
Chair, and Cllr Mansell for confirmation.
· The amended report be shared with the Chair, Vice-Chair and Cllr Mansell prior to submission to Full Council.
1) Cllr Mansell raised a strong concern: some items previously on the forward plan had disappeared without explanation. He cited four areas in particular:
· They suggested holding a Teams meeting with Cllr Mansell to go through those recommendations line ? by ? line and confirm how they feed into ongoing service planning.
· Cllr Stanton – Chair of the Somerset Rivers Authority Board · Cllr Ashton – Member of the Somerset Rivers Authority Board · Cllr Mansell – queried whether payment of parking charges constituted an interest; was advised by officers that it fell under the same general category as council tax and did not require declaration.
Cllr Mansell pressed for progress on the red ? rated highways communications interface item (on the tracker since May 2023), observing generic “ no safety/no action ” responses were driving further casework; officers confirmed resourcing constraints had eased and that a session can now be scheduled.
Councillor Mansell also raised a point regarding the absence of outcome tracker for this committee. Scott Wooldridge (Head of Democratic & Governance Services) confirmed that an outcome tracker would be introduced from January to ensure consistency across all scrutiny committees.
Councillor Dave Mansell expressed concerns about the forthcoming budget, noting that it was likely to be challenging and involve substantial savings or cuts.
· Councillor Dave Mansell proposed that Councillor Helen Kay be appointed as Vice Chair of Planning Committee – East.
Councillor Hobhouse proposed and Councillor Seib seconded that they be accepted as a true and accurate record and were approved subject to recording that Councillor Dave Mansell was a substitute at that meeting.
Councillor Mansell said that during the meeting regarding agenda item 8 on the 2025/26 parking charges, he had requested an early “pre” consultation and suggested an amendment to the minutes.
It was noted that Cllr Dave Mansell arrived late so did not take part in the vote on this item.
Councillor Shane Collins for whom Councillor Dave Mansell substituted.
Councillor Hobhouse proposed and Councillor Trimnell seconded that they be accepted as a true and accurate record and were approved subject to adding Councillor Dave Mansell to those present online. And also, an addition on page 16 of the minutes in the resolution in connection with the restructuring programme that waste services and the climate team be included in the potential consequential impacts.
These updates reflect discussions from previous meetings and a separate meeting with Councillor Mansell. The updated documents include several changes and additions, with potential future agenda items added by officers. Landslides and Risk Register:
Councillor Dave Mansell queried whether the definition of “core network” had been addressed in the final version of the BSIP as without it, it would be difficult to understand what the plan was trying to achieve and the routes covered. In response, the Service Commissioning Manager explained that the core network would be established as the Local Transport Plan(LTP) was developed as it is supposed to reflect the LTP.
Councillor Dave Mansell requested that as the change to Service 25 did not involve a timetable change, could it be implemented right away? In response, Terrance James advised that they hoped to implement some of these changes sooner rather than later as it will be a benefit to passengers.
Councillor Dave Mansell proposed an amendment, which was seconded by Councillor Bob Filmer. The amendment had been brought forward based on the concerns raised on the process followed for the review, working groups and workshop:- In Paper D, replace recommendations on Part D8 – Planning Committee Terms of Reference with the following new 2.1, 2):
The C h air invited Cllr Dave Mansell of Somerset Council to give an update on the first meeting of the Transport Working group which had taken place that same afternoon .
Cllr Mansell advised of the following - · The group had discussed what they hope to achieve, a term of reference and a work programme. · Aiming to investigate public and community transport serving the LCN area · Aware that there may be shared interests with parishes to the north of Wiveliscombe so will look to contact Exmoor LCN in the future. · Look at potential services improvements and funding for public and community buses. Particularly the 25 service. · The working group is planning to meet monthly . · Want to look at connectio n between Wellington and Wiveliscombe · Better provision in villages around Wellington and Wiveliscombe · Review the slinky service and find out more information about Wiv i link . · Review recent surveys and may conduct own survey to better understand issues in the LCN area . · The aim is to bring a final report back to the LCN in October .
The Chair invited committee member Cllr Dave Mansell, the Chair of the Task and Finish Group to present the fi ndings and recommendations from the Somerset Energy Plan T ask and F inish group (Appendix B) which had met s ix times over the period Oct 23-Feb 24 . Members heard that the group had worked with Somerset Council officers and external consultants Regen and UK100 t o steer and put forward a ‘critical friend’ challenge to the development of the Somerset Energy Investment Plan (Appendix C) . The Chair thanked Cllrs Ashton, Kravis, Boyden, Mansell , Bradford and Hobhouse for thei r time and input into the development of the Plan and invited comments and questions from the wider committee.
Member Questions were received from:- · Councillor Dave Mansell/Cllr Gwil Wren - Flooding · Councillor Lucy Trimnell – Heritage · Councillor Norman Cavill – Phosphates · Councillor Sue Osborne – Planning · Councillor David Fothergill – Adult Social Care · Councillor Diogo Rodrigues – Car parks/Transport The questions and responses provided are attached to the minutes in Appendix B.
Ø Cllr Ashton Ø Cllr Boyden Ø Cllr Bradford Ø Cllr H Hobhouse Ø Cllr M Kravis Ø Cllr D Mansell Ø Cllr H Munt Ø Cllr T Power
Ø Cllr Bente Height Ø Cllr Henry Hobhouse Ø Cllr Marcus Kravis Ø Cllr Dave Mansell Ø Cllr Tom Power
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Mansell attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Mansell's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Mansell was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Somerset has not published attendance for Councillor Mansell's meetings yet.
What Councillor Mansell declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Mansell in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Mansell sits, from the attendance records.
No committee attendance recorded for Councillor Mansell yet.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.