Declarations of Interest
Councillor Helen Kay declared an interest on agenda item 6 for Saxonvale, Frome, as she had shares in Mayday Saxonvale and that she would remove herself from the room for the main debate and decision on the item.
Every time Somerset's minutes name Councillor Kay, as the council published it.
Councillor Helen Kay declared an interest on agenda item 6 for Saxonvale, Frome, as she had shares in Mayday Saxonvale and that she would remove herself from the room for the main debate and decision on the item.
This included: Councillor Shane Collins, Councillor Helen Kay, Councillor Martin Dimery, Councillor Adam Boyden and Councillor Dawn Denton. Questions and points raised included: the history of the site; concern on the use of CBRE again; the Homes England grant; the local plan and mixed sites; ensuring the town got what it needed from the site;
The next speaker was Division Member for Frome East, Councillor Helen Kay.
Councillor Michael Dunk for substituted for Councillor Kay.
Substitutes were Councillors Simon Carswell (for Councillor Boyden), Alistair Hendry (for Councillor Ham) and Shane Collins (for Councillor Kay).
Councillors paid tribute to him at the meeting, including Councillor Helen Kay.
· Councillor Dave Mansell proposed that Councillor Helen Kay be appointed as Vice Chair of Planning Committee – East.
It was proposed by Councillor Helen Kay and seconded by Councillor Martin Dimery to approve the minutes, with an amendment to the resolution of agenda item 4 – Planning Application 2021/167/EOUT. She proposed the removal of the words “whether the overall harms outweigh the benefits” in the first sentence and to include the words “overall, the harms outweigh the benefits” at the end of the sentence. This made the sentence read correctly when compared to what was said at the meeting.
Regarding the minutes of the 3 December, Councillor Helen Kay said she had spent a lot of time checking the minutes and preparing a lengthy amendment which had been distributed to the Committee beforehand. The Legal Advisor advised that as she was not the legal representative at that meeting, her amendments could not be verified today as the Legal Advisor at the meeting was not in attendance today.
The Service Manager – Development Management said that and if there if there was uncertainty about the minutes of the meeting and that they were not a true reflection, she would be willing to work with Councillor Kay to come up with a set of minutes that she was happy with.
Councillor Michael Dunk was substitute for Councillor Helen Kay.
Councillor Helen Kay proposed and Councillor Edric Hobbs seconded that the second set be accepted as a true and accurate record and were approved.
At the conclusion of the debate, it was proposed by Councillor Philip Ham and seconded by Councillor Helen Kay to refuse the application contrary to the Officer’s recommendation due to the impact on the landscape character.
At the conclusion of the debate, it was proposed by Councillor Edric Hobbs and seconded by Councillor Helen Kay to defer the application to allow the applicant to make changes to the painting scheme proposed in their application, which would be more sympathetic to the Grade II* listed building.
It was noted that Councillor Helen Kay was on a leave of absence.
It was noted that Councillor Helen Kay was on a leave of absence.
It was noted that Councillor Helen Kay was on a leave of absence.
It was noted that Councillor Helen Kay was on a leave of absence and that Councillor Michael Dunk was acting as her substitute.
It was noted that Councillor Helen Kay was on a leave of absence and Councillor Michael Dunk was acting as her substitute.
Councillor Michael Dunk substituted for Councillor Helen Kay and Councillor Tessa Munt substituted for Councillor Adam Boyden.
Councillor Philip Ham substituted for Councillor Clarke and Councillor Shane Collins substituted for Councillor Helen Kay.
Councillor Helen Kay declared she was pre-determined for application 2023/1036/FUL and stated she would not take part in the debate or vote. She would, however, speak as Divisional Councillor.
The Committee was then addressed by Councillor Helen Kay who had declared at agenda item 3 that she was pre-determined for this application and therefore she would not take part in the debate or vote. She would, however, speak as Divisional Councillor. She made a number of points regarding the amenity of the future occupiers of the already approved nearby dwelling and suggested adding an extra reason for refusal regarding the access.
Councillor Kay then moved to the public gallery for the duration of the debate and vote.
Motion on the immediate bilateral ceasefire in Israel-Gaza conflict Councillor Helen Kay introduced the Motion and gave some background information on her Jewish heritage, the reasons why she had brought the Motion to Full Council and how she felt some connection to Israel and was very shocked by the attacks on innocent civilians on 7 October 2023. She also noted the following:- · The Hamas ideology and the representation of the Palestinian cause for land rights and freedom and the political vacuum re: other political parties representing the cause.
Councillor Helen Kay proposed the recommendations which were seconded by Councillor Habib Farbahi.
It was proposed by Councillor Helen Kay and seconded by Councillor Martin Dimery to approve the application in accordance with the Officer’s recommendation.
Councillor Shane Collins substituted for Councillor Kay.
· Councillor Mandy Chilcott proposed the following amendment which Councillor Helen Kay duly seconded:- In line with the Constitution and Governance Committee guidance, that the committee was to give a steer to officers before any proposals came forward, that two members of the Constitution and Governance Committee be added to the Constitution Review Working Group for the Planning Committee Terms of Reference, along with the Chairs and Vice Chairs of each Planning Committee and the Lead Member for Economic Development, Planning and Assets.
· Councillor Dawn Johnson proposed the following amendment, which Councillor Helen Kay duly seconded:- That all councillors be surveyed to ask for feedback and comments on the Planning Committee Terms of Reference which would feed into work of the Constitution Review Working Group for the Planning Committee.
Councillor Helen Kay proposed and Councillor Edric Hobbs seconded that they be accepted. These Minutes were taken as a true and accurate record and were approved.
As there was no debate amongst Members, it was proposed by Councillor Helen Kay and seconded by Councillor Heather Shearer to approve the application in accordance with the Officer’s Recommendation.
Councillor Helen Kay proposed some amendments as follows:
This was proposed by Councillor Helen Kay and seconded by Councillor Claire Sully. There were 5 in favour and 2 against this proposed amendment, therefore the proposal was carried.
She also proposed a change to the 6 th bullet point to add “ which if found to be a problem might lead to ‘viability’ issues for the developer and result in them reapplying for permission with fewer affordable homes.” The amendments were proposed by Councillor Helen Kay and seconded by Councillor Susannah Hart.
Councillor Helen Kay then proposed to refuse the application in accordance with the Officer’s Recommendation, with an additional reason being the effect on dark skies.
Councillor Helen Kay then proposed to refuse the application in accordance with the Officer’s Recommendation, with an additional reason being the impact on dark skies.
This was seconded by Councillor Helen Kay. On being put to the vote, the proposal was carried with 10 votes in favour and 1 abstention.
Frome Town Councillor Max Wide was nominated by Councillor Adam Boyden, seconded by Somerset Councillor Helen Kay.
Councillor Adam Boyden was nominated by Councillor Claire Sully, seconded by Councillor Helen Kay.
Councillor Helen Kay proposed an amendment to the substantive motion to add these additional words and this was seconded by Councillor Michael Dunk. On being put to the vote the amendment was carried by 5 votes to 4, with 2 abstentions.
After a brief discussion, it was proposed by Councillor Edric Hobbs and seconded by Councillor Helen Kay that the application be approved in accordance with the Officer’s Recommendation set out in the Report. On being put to the vote, the Members were unanimously in favour.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Kay attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Kay's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Kay was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Somerset has not published attendance for Councillor Kay's meetings yet.
What Councillor Kay declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 23 Sep 2026 | Executive, item 59 | Councillor Helen Kay declared an interest on agenda item 6 for Saxonvale, Frome, as she had shares in Mayday Saxonvale and that she would remove herself from the room for the main debate and decision on the item. | |
| 9 Jan 2024 | Planning Committee - East, item 99 | Councillor Helen Kay declared she was pre-determined for application 2023/1036/FUL and stated she would not take part in the debate or vote. She would, however, speak as Divisional Councillor. | Took no part |
Where Councillor Kay sits, from the attendance records.
No committee attendance recorded for Councillor Kay yet.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.