Moved10 Jun 2026Scrutiny Committee - Corporate and Strategic
Minutes from the Previous Meeting
Proposed by Councillor Hobhouse, seconded by Councillor Seib, and approved unanimously, the Scrutiny Committee Corporate and Strategic RESOLVED that the minutes of the meeting held on 29 April 2026 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chair. There were no matters arising.
Said7 May 2026Constitution and Governance Committee
Declarations of Interest
Councillorspresent atthe meetingdeclared thefollowing personalinterests in their capacity as a Councillor of a Town or Parish Council or any other Local Authority:- SOMERSET COUNCILLOR CITY, TOWN AND/OR PARISH COUNCIL Simon Carswell Street Parish Council Tim Kerley Somerton Town Council Marcus Kravis Minehead Town Council Martin Lovell Shepton Mallet Town Council Councillor Henry Hobhouse advised that he was the Division Member for Castle Cary who had collected the signatures for the petition that triggered the Community Governance Review for Ansford and Castle Cary.
Named25 Mar 2026Scrutiny Committee - Corporate and Resources (was operational until 18/05/26)
Minutes from the Previous Meeting
Nutrient Neutrality In his written response, Chris Hall, Executive Director for Community, Place & Economy had explained that the Council had sought joint legal advice with Councillor Hobhouse on the potential use of headroom from Wessex Water upgrades. The opinion contained assumptions which required further evidence, and officers and the Lead Member had continued work on these matters.
Moved25 Mar 2026Scrutiny Committee - Corporate and Resources (was operational until 18/05/26)
Scrutiny Corporate and Resources Outcome Tracker
Proposed by Councillor Hobhouse and seconded by Councillor Hobbs, the Committee agreed that the Group would elect its own Chair at the first meeting. Jack Latkovic advised that due to the time critical nature of the Task and Finish Group, the first meeting would be arranged for the following week, with further online or hybrid meetings to follow. Around three to four meetings were anticipated.
Said5 Mar 2026Scrutiny Committee - Climate and Place (was operational until 18/5/2026)
Lead Member Report for Public Health, Climate Change and Environment
Cllr Hobhouse raised concerns regarding the legal robustness of Somerset ’ s Ramsar site designations, questioning whether Natural England had fulfilled its obligations to update and maintain site data and warning that such gaps could expose the Council to legal challenge. Officers agreed to provide a written briefing on the statutory position, update cycles and associated risks.
Named18 Feb 2026Scrutiny Committee - Climate and Place (was operational until 18/5/2026)
Public Question Time
Stuart Carruthers Agenda Supplement for Scrutiny Committee - Climate and Place, 18/02/2026 10:00 Cllr Hobhouse provided a technical response clarifying:
Asked18 Feb 2026Scrutiny Committee - Climate and Place (was operational until 18/5/2026)
Somerset Council First Consideration and Section 102 Reports
1) Cllr Hobhouse sought clarity on how the baseline established and defined, along with data sources and its collection. The officers acknowledged the challenge and confirmed that baseline evidence will stem principally from the Local Nature Recovery Strategy, which is being finalised advising:
Named12 Feb 2026Scrutiny Committee - Children and Families (was operational until 18/5/2026)
Apologies for Absence
Cllr Henry Hobhouse) and Carswell.
Named15 Jan 2026Scrutiny Committee - Climate and Place (was operational until 18/5/2026)
Apologies for Absence
Cllr Hobhouse, who as Vice-Chair took on the role to Chair this meeting with Cllr Ashton as Vice-Chair after a unanimous vote), Kravis (sub.
Said26 Nov 2025Scrutiny Committee - Corporate and Resources (was operational until 18/05/26)
Scrutiny Corporate and Resources Work Programme
Councillor Henry Hobhouse requested that an item be added to the forward plan concerning an anticipated external audit relating to the Red Brick building. This raised concerns that the project might involve compliance or governance issues significant enough to attract adverse attention from external auditors.
Seconded25 Sep 2025Full Council
Motions
Councillor Habib Farbahi introduced the Motion, which was seconded by Councillor Henry Hobhouse.
Moved25 Sep 2025Full Council
Motions
· Councillor Henry Hobhouse proposed a named vote be taken on the Motion.
Seconded25 Sep 2025Full Council
Motions
Councillor Habib Farbahi proposed the recommendations which were seconded by Councillor Henry Hobhouse.
Named25 Mar 2025Planning Committee - South
Public Question Time
The legal opinion, jointly commissioned by Somerset Council and Cllr Hobhouse, sought to clarify the position on the extent to which Wessex Water’s investment in WwTW upgrades and associated headroom can be relied upon as mitigation, for the purposes of undertaking an ‘appropriate assessment’ under the Habitat Regulations. The recording of the meeting and a copy of the legal opinion will be published shortly. Officers are working through the next steps and collating the evidence required, as advised in the opinion.
Named25 Mar 2025Planning Committee - South
Planning Application 24/01203/FUL - Manor Farm, Pound Lane, Yarlington, Wincanton, Somerset, BA9 8DG
The Division Member, Councillor Hobhouse, spoke in support of the application, and advised that he does have a financial interest in the proposal due to his business relationship with the landowner. He asked that the committee consider that the removal of the existing Manor Farm is crucial for the people who live nearby, who have suffered for years with issues from Manor Farm in its current state. i.e flooding, traffic, noise, farm waste. ? In response to questions from Members, the Planning Officer advised that;- Neighbourhood plans are given equal weight to ... view the full minutes text for item 89.
Moved24 Mar 2025Scrutiny Committee - Corporate and Resources
Minutes from the Previous Meeting
Councillor Hobhouse proposed and Councillor Seib seconded that they be accepted as a true and accurate record and were approved subject to recording that Councillor Dave Mansell was a substitute at that meeting.
Named12 Mar 2025Scrutiny Committee - Communities
Apologies for Absence
Simon Coles (Councillor Henry Hobhouse substituted), Councillor Pauline Ham (Councillor Martin Lovell substituted).
Named3 Mar 2025Executive
Parking Policies 2025/26
Cllr Wilkins invited the Vice-Chair of Scrutiny Committee – Corporate and Resources, Cllr Henry Hobhouse, to speak.
Said3 Mar 2025Executive
Parking Policies 2025/26
Cllr Hobhouse highlighted: the engagement of every member of the Committee on this topic; the improved Equalities Impact Assessment (EIA) following Scrutiny comment on disability; that some car parks are operated by the town or village council to enable continued free parking; and the importance of car parks for people who live in accommodation with no parking.
Moved24 Feb 2025Scrutiny Committee - Corporate and Resources
Minutes from the Previous Meeting
Councillor Hobhouse proposed and Councillor Trimnell seconded that they be accepted as a true and accurate record and were approved subject to adding Councillor Dave Mansell to those present online. And also, an addition on page 16 of the minutes in the resolution in connection with the restructuring programme that waste services and the climate team be included in the potential consequential impacts.
Seconded29 Jan 2025Scrutiny Committee - Corporate and Resources
Housing Revenue Account Rent Setting and Fees & Charges 2025/26
This was seconded by Councillor Henry Hobhouse and approved.
Seconded6 Jan 2025Scrutiny Committee - Corporate and Resources
Minutes from the Previous Meeting
Councillor Coles proposed and Councillor Hobhouse seconded that they be accepted as a true and accurate record and were approved.
Named20 Dec 2024Scrutiny Committee - Climate and Place
Task and Finish Group Update - Water Quality in Somerset
Vice Chair Cllr Hobhouse provided a verbal update on the Task and Finish Group. The following points were noted: Protocol Document - Officers confirmed that a protocol document for the Task and Finish Group had been agreed upon following discussions with the Vice Chair. The document outlines the group's objectives, scope, and initial steps.
Said20 Dec 2024Scrutiny Committee - Climate and Place
Scrutiny Climate and Place Work Programme
Councillor Hobhouse requested that recent landslides on the A371 be placed at the top of the risk register for the entire council. Call for Action on Rights of Way:
Named20 Dec 2024Scrutiny Committee - Climate and Place
Scrutiny Climate and Place Work Programme
Councillor Hobhouse mentioned new legislation allowing councillors to call up issues personally and requested action on the governance of rights of way. Early Release of Agenda Papers:
Seconded18 Dec 2024Full Council
Report of the five Scrutiny Committees
Councillor Leigh Redman proposed the recommendations, which were seconded by Councillor Henry Hobhouse.
Said22 Oct 2024Planning Committee - South
Planning Application 22/01598/OUT - Land South Of High Street, Sparkford, Yeovil, Somerset.
The Division member, Councillor Henry Hobhouse addressed the committee and echoed the concerns of residents about the sewage system in Sparkford which is inadequate, and that in his opinion there is enough employment land in the local area.
Named30 Sep 2024Scrutiny Committee - Corporate and Resources
Apologies for Absence
· Councillor Henry Hobhouse (no substitute) · Councillor Nick Cottle (no substitute) · Councillor Tony Lock (no substitute) · Councillor Andy Soughton (substituted by Cllr Dawn Johnson) · Councillor Diogo Rodrigues (substituted by Cllr Mandy Chilcott) · Councillor Lucy Trimnell (substituted by Cllr Rosemary Woods) and · Councillor Brian Smedley (substituted by Cllr Leigh Redman). ?
Named26 Sep 2024Full Council
Annual Report of the Armed Forces Covenant
The Somerset Armed Forces Member Champion, Councillor Henry Hobhouse, introduced the annual report of the Armed Forces Covenant.
Asked24 Sep 2024Planning Committee - South
Planning Application 22/02814/FUL - Land Os 6200, Land East of Station Road, Castle Cary, Somerset
The Division Member, Councillor Henry Hobhouse (who was predetermined and therefore unable to vote on the item) asked officers in Planning and Legal for several points of clarification including:
Named24 Sep 2024Planning Committee - South
Planning Application 22/02814/FUL - Land Os 6200, Land East of Station Road, Castle Cary, Somerset
Officers are unable to advise members on the case that Cllr Henry Hobhouse has referred to at short notice.
Named24 Sep 2024Planning Committee - South
Planning Application 23/02258/OUT Land West Of South Street, Castle Cary, Somerset, BA7 7NY
Division member Councillor Hobhouse had concerns around sewage and enforcement of drainage conditions, and felt that the committee should not be passing a decision until the Council has employed an appropriate enforcement officer. He added that to his knowledge there is no shortage of affordable housing in Castle Cary.
Named23 Sep 2024Scrutiny Committee - Climate and Place
Task and Finish update: Water Quality in Somerset.
Yours sincerely Mickey Green Executive Director – Climate and Place · Vice Chair Cllr Hobhouse provided a verbal update on the Task and Finish Group. The following points were noted.
Said23 Sep 2024Scrutiny Committee - Climate and Place
Task and Finish update: Water Quality in Somerset.
Cllr Hobhouse requested volunteers with scientific backgrounds for the same.
Named28 Aug 2024Scrutiny Committee - Corporate and Resources
Apologies for Absence
Councillor Collins was present online and Councillor Henry Hobhouse sent apologies.
Named27 Aug 2024Planning Committee - South
Planning Application 23/03085/FUL - Centaur House, Centaur Services Ltd , Torbay Road, Castle Cary, Somerset, BA7 7EU
The Division Member, Councillor Henry Hobhouse, spoke in support of the development, and agreed with the applicant that the development would bring huge economic benefits to the town of Castle Cary. He also felt that the officer reasons for recommending refusal of the application are not substantial enough to outweigh the benefits as stated by the applicant, and that in response to the Urban Landscape and Design Officer’s concerns regarding the size and appearance of the 16m high storage facility, this was unfair given the fact that a very similar structure had been constructed at a neighbouring manufacturing business. ? ? Following the comments made by the Applicant and Division Member, members, members sought clarity that the application could be approved, subject to conditions related to appearance which could be agreed upon by the Applicant, Planning Committee Chair and Division Member, and were then content with the proposals put before them, and largely supportive of the application.
Moved27 Aug 2024Planning Committee - South
Planning Application 23/03085/FUL - Centaur House, Centaur Services Ltd , Torbay Road, Castle Cary, Somerset, BA7 7EU
?At the conclusion of the debate, it was proposed by Councillor Henry Hobhouse and seconded by Councillor Kevin Messenger to overturn the officer’s recommendation on economic grounds and approve the application.? When put to the vote, the proposal was carried by 10 in favour, 0 against and 0 abstentions.
Named25 Jul 2024Scrutiny Committee - Climate and Place
Items for Information
Resolved The membership of the Task and Finish group: Water Quality in Somerset was agreed as: Cllr Kravis, Cllr Coles, Cllr Rigby, Cllr Hobhouse, Cllr Bradford, and Cllr Norman Cavill and Cllr Steve Ashton (non-committee members in attendance).
Seconded28 May 2024Planning Committee - South
Planning Application 21/00311/OUT - Land to the North of Somerton Road, Adj. The White Bungalow, Somerton Road, Langport.
It was proposed by Councillor Tim Kerley and seconded by Councillor Henry Hobhouse, to approve the application as per the officer recommendation as set out in the agenda report and subject to Section ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Moved28 May 2024Planning Committee - South
Planning Application 24/00568/FUL - Ilford Farm, Ilford Lane, Ilton, Ilminster TA19 9EB
There being no debate it was proposed by Councillor Henry Hobhouse and seconded by Councillor Tim Kerley, to approve the application as per the officer recommendation as set out in the agenda report.
Named22 May 2024Full Council
Annual Report of the five Scrutiny Committees
The five Chairs of Scrutiny, Councillor Leigh Redman, Councillor Gwil Wren, Councillor Bob Filmer, Councillor Gill Slocombe and Councillor Henry Hobhouse, introduced each of their annual reports, which detailed the activity of each of the five Scrutiny Committees since vesting day.
Named26 Apr 2024Scrutiny Committee - Climate and Place
Election of a vice-chair for the meeting
Cllr Harry Munt proposed that Cllr Henry Hobhouse be elected , which was seconded by Cllr Mike Rigby.
Named26 Apr 2024Scrutiny Committee - Climate and Place
Election of a vice-chair for the meeting
Members Voted unanimously in favour and Cllr Henry Hobhouse was duly elected as the vice chair for the meeting.
Named25 Apr 2024Scrutiny Committee - Corporate and Resources
Review of Terms of Reference for Local Community Networks
Following the discussion, it was proposed that a Task and Finish Group be set up, led by Councillor Hobhouse and to consist of 4 or ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Said23 Apr 2024Full Council
Motions
Councillor Henry Hobhouse thanked councillors for their support on the Motion.
Seconded23 Apr 2024Full Council
Motions
Councillor Mark Healey proposed the recommendations which were seconded by Councillor Henry Hobhouse.
Moved20 Mar 2024Scrutiny Committee - Climate and Place
Section 19 Reports from 2020-2022 Flood Events
At the end of the debate Cllr Henry Hobhouse proposed that : The Scrutiny Committee -Climate and Place recommends that the Somerset Council Planning Service review its policies and advice to residents regarding the application of flood defence mechanisms to listed buildings.
Named20 Feb 2024Full Council
Report of the Monitoring Officer
Approve the appointment of Councillor Henry Hobhouse as the Vice-Chair of Scrutiny Committee – Corporate and Resources Paper B:
Named2 Feb 2024Scrutiny Committee - Corporate and Resources
Appointment of Vice Chair
Resolved that Cllr Henry Hobhouse was appointed as vice-chair.
Named30 Jan 2024Planning Committee - South
Apologies for Absence
It was noted that Councillor Kevin Messenger was attending as a substitute for Councillor Henry Hobhouse.
Moved17 Jan 2024Scrutiny Committee - Climate and Place
Minutes from the previous meeting
Cllr Hobhouse proposed a revote to progress this as an urgent matter , seconded by Cllr Ashton , and the committee voted unanimously in favour to progress this as soon as possible . · Regarding item 39 the Action Tracker – Proposed r evision to wording regarding the outcomes of Scrutiny recommendations . · Regarding item 40 t he Committee Forward plan – Revision to wording to reflect that the committee did not note a forward plan , but that they note d an update report on the approach to the deve l opment of the forward plan.
Named4 Jan 2024Scrutiny Committee - Corporate and Resources
Apologies for Absence
Due to the change in membership and Councillor Richard Wilkins coming off the committee, it was proposed and seconded that Councillor Henry Hobhouse be elected as Vice-Chair for the meeting, this was agreed unanimously.
Named6 Dec 2023Local Community Network - South East Somerset (Wincanton)
Update on working groups
Councillor Henry Hobhouse also wished it noted that a meeting has been arranged for all parishes on the Cam valley on the 31 st January 2024 at 7pm Queen Camel to help support a River Cam Flood system and Flood Defence plan to help and support parishes in the future.
Named5 Dec 2023Scrutiny Committee - Corporate and Resources
Framework for Asset and/or Service Devolution
· A response to flooding issues would be provided to Cllr Hobhouse following the meeting after discussion with operational colleagues.
Said9 Nov 2023Scrutiny Committee - Corporate and Resources
Minutes from the Previous Meeting
Cllr Hobhouse raised queries in respect of the previous minutes and asked the legal position of the minutes being an accurate record in reference to statements provided by individual Councillors..
Moved24 Oct 2023Planning Committee - South
Planning Application 23/02106/HOU - Isle House, Muchelney Road, Muchelney, Langport TA10 0DP.
There being no debate, Councillor Henry Hobhouse proposed to approve the application, as per the officer’s recommendation as set out in the agenda report, this was seconded by Councillor Tim Kearley. On being put to the vote this was carried unanimously.
Named27 Sep 2023Full Council
Annual Report of the Somerset Armed Forces Covenant Partnership
The Chair of the Somerset Armed Forces Covenant Partnership, Councillor Henry Hobhouse, introduced the annual report.
Named20 Sep 2023Scrutiny Committee - Climate and Place
Somerset Energy Plan - Task and Finish Group
Ø Cllr Ashton Ø Cllr Boyden Ø Cllr Bradford Ø Cllr H Hobhouse Ø Cllr M Kravis Ø Cllr D Mansell Ø Cllr H Munt Ø Cllr T Power
Named21 Jul 2023Strategic Planning Committee
Apologies for Absence
It was noted that Councillor Henry Hobhouse was attending as substitute for Councillor Coles.
Said21 Jul 2023Strategic Planning Committee
Declarations of Interest
Councillor Henry Hobhouse advised that he was the Division Member for Castle Cary and knew many people within the area of Agenda items 5, 6 and 7 relating to footpaths in the Queen Camel and Sparkford areas.
Said21 Jul 2023Strategic Planning Committee
Progress Report: Phosphates and work undertaken to achieve nutrient neutral development
Councillor Henry Hobhouse noted that he had been promised briefings with the Lead Member for Economic Development, Planning and Assets but the briefing had not yet taken place.
Named19 Jul 2023Scrutiny Committee - Climate and Place
Public Question Time
The issue of phosphates considered at the last meeting was raised and Cllr Hobhouse made a proposal, seconded by Cllr Ashton and amended by Cllr Martin that:
Moved22 Jun 2023Local Community Network - South East Somerset (Wincanton)
To appoint the Chair of the Local Community Network
Councillor Henry Hobhouse proposed that Ewan Jones (Bruton Town Council) and Judi Morison (Castle Cary Town Council) be co-Chairs of the South East (Wincanton) Local Community Network.
Moved22 Jun 2023Local Community Network - South East Somerset (Wincanton)
To appoint the Vice-Chair of the Local Community Network
It was proposed by Councillor Henry Hobhouse and seconded by Tim Carty (Milborne Port Parish Council) that Councillor Nicola Clark be the Vice-Chair of the South East (Wincanton) Local Community Network.
Seconded23 May 2023Planning Committee - South
Planning Application 20/03725/FUL - Land at Frys Cottage, Cuttifords Door, Combe St Nicholas, Chard
This was seconded by Councillor Henry Hobhouse and on being put to the vote was carried unanimously.
Named17 May 2023Scrutiny Committee - Climate and Place
Infrastructure and Transport: Highways Service Responsiveness update
Ø Cllr Bente Height Ø Cllr Henry Hobhouse Ø Cllr Marcus Kravis Ø Cllr Dave Mansell Ø Cllr Tom Power
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.