Homes for Ukraine Scheme Update
Following a suggestion made by Councillor Anna Bradnam, it was agreed that a letter of thanks should be extended from the Cabinet to host families.
Every time South Cambridgeshire's minutes name Councillor Bradnam, as the council published it.
Following a suggestion made by Councillor Anna Bradnam, it was agreed that a letter of thanks should be extended from the Cabinet to host families.
Councillor Anna Bradnam, as representative of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee, advised that the committee had thoroughly discussed the presented options of Local Government Reorganisation. It was noted that the Scrutiny and Overview Committee investigated all options rather than endorsing any particular option to Cabinet.
Councillor Anna Bradnam proposed, and Councillor Heather Williams seconded the appointment of Councillor Katie Thornburrow as Chair of the Joint Planning Advisory Group (JPAG). This was approved unanimously.
Councillor Anna Bradnam was in attendance on behalf of the Committee and presented Members views in relation to the 2025-2026 Quarter One Performance Report which would be considered by the Cabinet as the next agenda item.
Councillor Anna Bradnam summarised each of the points raised by the Committee relating to:
It was further suggested by Councillor Anna Bradnam that onsite assistance at communal housing areas would support residents in educating them on what items should be placed in which bins. This suggestion was noted by the Cabinet.
In doing so, he thanked Councillor Anna Bradnam for the views and comments of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee which had largely been addressed under the previous agenda item.
Councillor Anna Bradnam welcomed reference to the “Lack of land to improve for nature” as a key challenge within the consultation document. This echoed earlier comments made by the Scrutiny and Overview Committee when discussing the 2025-2026 Quarter One Performance Report.
Councillor Anna Bradnam queried whether the process for selling shared ownership homes was straightforward for homeowners.
As this was outside of the scope of the report, Councillor Anna Bradnam undertook to raise this matter with Officers outside of the meeting.
Item 6 (24/04191/OUT) - Councillor Anna Bradnam was contacted by email regarding the application but did not engage / respond to the email.
Councillor Bradnam drafted comments on the proposed ice-cream trader conditions, which were circulated to the Committee prior to the start of the meeting and are included below (deleted text is struck through and additional text is underlined): Condition 1 - the trader must have obtained permission from the parish/town council to trade in the location.
Councillor Anna Bradnam asked her question, as set out in the agenda.
As the Vice-Chair of planning committee wasn’t present at the meeting Councillor Bradnam proposed and Councillor Hawkins seconded the nomination of Councillor Peter Sandford as Vice Chair for this planning committee meeting. The committee approved the appointment by affirmation.
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Bradnam who reserved her right to speak until later in the debate.
As seconder of the recommendations, Councillor Bradnam thanked all those involved and recognised the importance of the plan within the planning process.
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Anna Bradnam, who commended the proposals to Council, feeling that they regularised and harmonised the work of all the planning committees across the shared service. It was felt, however, that the Joint Planning Committee would be a more appropriate name for the shared committee.
Councillor Anna Bradnam sent apologies.
Councillor Anna Bradnam was in attendance on behalf of the Committee.
In relation to the Draft Corporate Plan and Corporate Action Plan, Councillor Bradnam explained that the Scrutiny and Overview had felt that meaningful and easy to interpret graphs would be well-received, particularly where it was unclear whether an increase in reported figures was good or bad.
Councillor Bradnam advised that she would update Cabinet on any other Scrutiny and Overview discussion at the relevant agenda items.
Councillor Anna Bradnam, as representative of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee, raised the following points during consideration of the report:
Councillor Anna Bradnam was appointed as Chair.
Councillor Anna Bradnam, as representative of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee, raised the following points during consideration of the report:
Councillor Bradnam asked her question, as set out in the agenda.
As a supplementary question, Councillor Bradnam asked whether the Local Government Association had been informed and had expressed its view to government.
Councillor Anna Bradnam declared an interest as a member of the Waterbeach Level Internal Drainage Board.
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Anna Bradnam, who advised that a lot of work had gone into the proposals, with constructive cross-party discussions taking place during the Licensing Committee debate.
Councillor Anna Bradnam asked her question, as set out in the agenda.
Councillor Anna Bradnam believed that the County Council would determine this application.
Councillor Anna Bradnam explained that as Chair of the Corporate Parenting Sub Committee she was well aware of the challenges caused by child poverty and she expressed her support for the motion.
Councillor Anna Bradnam was in attendance on behalf of the Committee, and she explained that the Committee had praised the cost of living support that the Council was providing its residents. The Committee had requested that the mobile food hubs be advertised in the parish e-bulletin.
Councillor Anna Bradnam was in attendance on behalf of the Committee, and she explained that the Committee had reviewed the Greater Cambridge Housing Strategy where ways of improving engagement with residents were discussed. The Committee had requested clarification with regards to climate change targets and how these related to planning applications.
Councillor Anna Bradnam reported that she was a representative on the Board and whilst the budget was small, its funds were well spent.
Councillor Peter Fane, seconded by Councillor Anna Bradnam, proposed that Peter Sandford be appointed as Vice-Chair for the duration of the meeting. The Committee agreed to the proposal by affirmation. The Chair then made several brief housekeeping announcements.
Councillor Anna Bradnam was present as a substitute.
With respect to Minute 5, Councillor Anna Bradnam declared that she was a member of Cambridge Natural History Society.
Councillor Anna Bradnam declared that she knew one of the public speakers (Gillian Elwood, Clerk of Hauxton Parish Council) in a personal capacity but had not discussed the application.
Councillor Anna Bradnam, seconded by Councillor Heather Williams, proposed that the Committee move to the decision and the Committee agreed by affirmation.
Councillor Anna Bradnam declared Other Registerable Interests as a Cambridgeshire County Councillor and as a member of the Combined Authority Scrutiny and Overview Committee.
Councillor Peter Fane proposed and Councillor Anna Bradnam seconded the recommendation in the report. A vote was taken and by affirmation Council Agreed to approve the Calendar of Meetings 2024/2025, as set out in Appendix A.
Councillor Anna Bradnam explained that there were 652 children in care in Cambridgeshire and the County Council had passed a similar motion last summer recognising them as a protected characteristic. She hoped that the Council could agree the motion that would help these children with their education, work, benefits payments and accommodation.
Councillor Anna Bradnam explained that it was important that care leavers were given the same opportunities as all other children.
Councillor Anna Bradnam proposed and Councillor Pippa Heylings seconded the motion.
Councillor Anna Bradnam was in attendance on behalf of the Committee and advised that the committee were particularly keen to encourage Cabinet to consider options to enable council house tenants wishing to do so to foster additional children.
Councillor Anna Bradnam, made the following comments on behalf of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee:
Councillor Anna Bradnam addressed the Committee as local Member in opposition to the application and, in response to a question, clarified that she had shared the details of the site licence to provide context of the licensing requirements to provide recreational space, despite licensing requirements being outside of planning considerations.
Councillor Anna Bradnam was in attendance on behalf of the Committee and advised that she would update Cabinet at the relevant agenda items.
Councillor Anna Bradnam made the following comments on behalf of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee:
Councillor Anna Bradnam was in attendance on behalf of the Committee and advised that the Committee had welcomed a report around Northstowe . It had been felt that the lessons learnt from developing new communities should be noted. The Committee had also considered a report on the Cost of Living and considered the work undertaken by the Council to be over and above what was expected.
This policy would be sent through to Councillor Anna Bradnam for information.
Councillor Anna Bradnam, made the following comments on behalf of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee:
Having regards to Policies SC/10 and SC/14 of the South Cambridgeshire Local Plan 2018 and the requirements of Paragraph 187 of the National Planning Policy framework, officers consider that the review of this technical information and officers conclusions upon issues raised in the respect of noise, vibration and electromagnetic radiation is necessary prior to a decision being taken on the application.” Councillor Anna Bradnam, seconded by Councillor Peter Fane, proposed that the Committee move to a vote; the Committee agreed to the proposal by affirmation.
Council Agreed to approve the appointment of Councillor Richard Stobart as representative on the Rural Services Network and the appointment of Councillor Anna Bradnam and Councillor Paul Bearpark as representatives on the A10 Ely to A14 Improvements Scheme Working Group.
Councillor Anna Bradnam was pleased to see the new KPI AH245 (Percentage of South Cambridgeshire District Council homes with active Housing Health & Safety Rating Categories 1 or 2 damp and mould cases).
Noting officers’ pro-active approach, Councillor Bradnam welcomed the fact that the Council had recognised the risk caused by damp and mould and was taking steps to address it.
Councillor Anna Bradnam was appointed as Chair.
Councillor Anna Bradnam (Chair) Councillor Jose Hales Councillor Mark Howell SCDC Officers:
Councillor Anna Bradnam was in attendance on behalf of the Committee, and advised that she would feed back at each of the following agenda items:
Councillor Anna Bradnam, Scrutiny and Overview Committee member stated the CSP was an extremely useful gathering forum in which views from all parties were brought together.
Councillor Anna Bradnam stressed a lot of questions were asked and satisfactory answers were received. In regard to the Mystery Shopper exercise, questions were asked whether staff knew it was taking place, if there was customer access in the evening and if calls were answered late at night.
Councillor Anna Bradnam stated they were reassured that procedures were in place to avoid unconscious bias and arrangements for disabled access during work at the council were in place.
Councillor Bradnam urged Cabinet to reflect the findings of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee Task & Finish Group that looked at Orchard Park a few years ago and consider incorporating into the Operational Plan lessons learned from places like Cambourne and Northstowe about the delivery of community facilities and measures designed to minimise the incidence of anti-social behaviour.
Councillor Anna Bradnam, Scrutiny and Overview Committee member asked for confirmation that the Investment training for members requested by Scrutiny and Overview Committee, item 12, page 9 was to be actioned.
Councillor Anna Bradnam thanked the Scrutiny and Governance advisor for their precise notes. The Committee congratulated the Homes for Ukraine team and Moving on team for their work and stated their reassurance that Ukrainian families had the same access to Home Link as South Cambridgeshire residents.
Councillor Anna Bradnam referred to 14.1, page 16 of the report, regarding boundaries and noted previous member Douglas De Lacey expressed concern where sites crossed them and how residents would know whether they were in a district or city council area.
Councillor Anna Bradnam confirmed Scrutiny and Overview’s support, noting the requirement for close monitoring of musculoskeletal injuries, as this was more prevalent in the Waste Service area than any other department.
Cllr Bradnam reported that the feedback received from the service and staff was positive, many had reported looking forward to spending their day off with families.
Councillor Anna Bradnam was elected unopposed as Vice Chair for the meeting.
Councillor Anna Bradnam, Scrutiny and Overview Committee member expressed concerns raised at Scrutiny regarding the data on dry recycling and composting in the Shared Waste and Environment (ES418) report.
Councillor Anna Bradnam noted Scrutiny had been provided with the requested evidence and was happy to support the proposal.
Councillor Anna Bradnam asked if it had been brought to the attention of Joint Development Control Committee, the Assistant Director Planning and Building Quality confirmed it had not been to the Committee but emphasised it had been sent to every member.
Councillor Anna Bradnam enquired how members communications were being monitored, the Chief Executive, confirmed that phone contacts were monitored through the relevant customer contact centre performance indicators, but explained that emails had not been monitored previously as it was difficult to do so.
Councillor Anna Bradnam raised an anomaly in the table 8.4.1 - Debt to Net Service Expenditure (NSE) Ratio on Page 132.
Councillor Anna Bradnam asked that all available data (both internal and external) should be analysed so that the Council could give evidence-based justification for continuing support and focus such support on those people in greatest need. Officers were able to provide limited data during the meeting.
During the course of Minute no. 7 (Greater Cambridge Local Plan) and in accordance with Standing Order no. 9, the Chair proposed, Councillor Anna Bradnam seconded, and the Committee agreed by affirmation that the meeting should continue beyond the four-hour mark.
At the Leader’s invitation, Councillor Anna Bradnam, a Scrutiny and Overview Committee member appointed by the Chair of that committee to do so, introduced a late report of the meeting held on 6 September 2022 which developed that aspiration.
On the proposal of Councillor Anna Bradnam, which was seconded by Councillor John Williams, Council agreed to appoint Councillor Richard Stobart as the Council’s Board Member on both the South Cambridgeshire Investment Partnership LLP and the South Cambridgeshire Projects LLP.
Councillor Anna Bradnam explained that she had been involved with a County Council group that encouraged children in care to express their views.
Councillor Anna Bradnam thanked Officers for bringing the policy to Cabinet, and was pleased with the use of maps within the report but asked about the land between Landbeach and Waterbeach. The Natural Environment Team Leader said that these were indicative maps, based on the current evidence from the published Local Plan.
Councillor Anna Bradnam responded on the increase in visitors to Milton Country Park during the Covid-19 Pandemic. The Joint Director of the Shared Planning Service highlighted the difference between the country park and the biodiversity net gain land highlighted within the report.
Councillor Anna Bradnam commented on the Cambridgeshire County Council’s use of ‘trip budgets’ and asked whether this had been reviewed within the consultation response. The Joint Director of Planning and Economic Development responded that trip budgets were already used by Cambridgeshire County Council and suggested that no amendments were required to be added to the report.
Councillor Anna Bradnam asked if the ‘trip budget’ approach would be incorporated into other developments. The Joint Director of Planning and Economic Development noted that this would be kept under review.
There were no declarations of interest although Councillor Anna Bradnam noted the significance to all Members present of the Greater Cambridge Local Plan.
Councillor Anna Bradnam welcomed the wide-ranging nature of the Local Plan consultation exercise in terms of both the number of different methods used to obtain feedback and the breadth in the demographic of respondents.
In response to a question from Councillor Anna Bradnam, the Head of Finance clarified that Cabinet would be recommended to increase the Capital Programme allocation for Northstowe to £34.6 million.
Councillor Bradnam said there must be no compromise in community facilities complying with South Cambridgeshire District Council’s ‘Green to our Core’ aspirations.
Councillor Anna Bradnam was present as a substitute.
Councillors Judith Rippeth substituted for Councillor Henry Batchelor and Councillor Tumi Hawkins substituted for Councillor Anna Bradnam.
Councillor Anna Bradnam asked if there was any ongoing work to improve staff retention. The Head of Transformation, HR and Corporate Services responded that the HR team was working on improving staff retention, and noted the introduction of Exit Interviews, and the circulation of staff surveys.
Councillor Anna Bradnam, while pleased with the policy, asked if any work was being investigated for Members.
Councillor Anna Bradnam raised concerns at the cost of Domestic Homicide Reviews detailed within the report, for which there is no central government funding.
Councillor Bridget Smith, Leader of the Council, requested that Councillor Anna Bradnam keep the Communities Manager aware of progress made on the Cambridgeshire County Council’s Police and Crime Panel.
In response to a question from Councillor Anna Bradnam about AH212 (Bed and Breakfast costs), Councillor John Batchelor, Lead Cabinet Member for Housing, informed the Committee that a substantial part of the increased expenditure necessary during the past two years had been met by benefits received and by Covid grants made by Central Government.
Councillor Anna Bradnam was pleased to note that there was a commitment to recognise the Council’s ‘Green to our Core’ objective by transitioning towards the installation of environmentally friendly energy facilities in new-build properties.
Councillor Bridget Smith proposed and Councillor Judith Rippeth seconded Councillor Anna Bradnam.
There being no other nominations Councillor Anna Bradnam was elected unopposed as Chair of Council by secret ballot.
Councillor Bradnam read out and signed her declaration of acceptance of office form.
Councillor Anna Bradnam presented this report on the work of the Civic Affairs Committee over the past year, as the Chair of the Committee. She noted the report author was Patrick Adams and that the Committee had met three times.
The Chair, Councillor Anna Bradnam, praised all those who had ensured the involvement of the whole community in the development of the Waterbeach Neighbourhood Plan.
Councillor Anna Bradnam stated that in addition to the Chair’s engagements on the agenda she had:
Councillor Anna Bradnam proposed, Councillor Peter Fane seconded and Council by affirmation, Resolved that the press and public be excluded from the meeting during consideration of the following item in accordance with the provisions of Section 100(a)(4) of the Local Government Act 1972 (exempt information as defined in paragraph 3 of Schedule 12A (as amended) of the Act).
Councillor Anna Bradnam asked if Members’ allowances would continue while on parental leave. The Leader responded that this policy would bring the Members’ Parental Leave closer to that of Officers of the Council.
Councillor Anna Bradnam asked whether lifetime tenancies would cease if the tenant died, and other family members were living in the property. The Service Manager for Housing Strategy responded that this would be considered on a case-by-case basis.
Councillor Anna Bradnam was supportive of the business plan, and the continued support for local business throughout the pandemic.
Councillor Anna Bradnam questioned how the Council would manage disputes. The Deputy Leader responded that a collaborative approach would be taken and would work closely with other neighbour councils.
Councillor Anna Bradnam declared a non-pecuniary interest i n Minute 6 (North East Cambridge Area Action Plan) as a Milton Parish Councillor, a local District Councillor for Milton & Waterbeach, and the Cambridgeshire County Councillor for the Electoral Division or Waterbeach, which includes the Parish of Milton.
Councillor Anna Bradnam (a local Member for Milton and Waterbeach) said that recreation space must be provided on site because Milton was already lacking in the level of recreational facilities needed to meet the demand of its own residents.
Councillor Anna Bradnam suggested that one of the options to purchase the empty homes was through Shire Homes or Ermine Street Housing and questioned who would complete the valuation of the properties. The Head of Housing responded that this would be undertaken by the qualified surveyor.
Councillor Anna Bradnam requested clarification as to whether the policy to convert office buildings into homes was still part of the Investment Strategy. The Head of Finance confirmed this had been removed.
Councillor Anna Bradnam requested clarification when using the same acronym for both Cambridge City Council and Cambridgeshire County Council. The Head of Finance noted the comments.
Councillor Anna Bradnam was pleased with the introduction of a money advice service but asked if this service was being offered to tenants living in Council properties. The Head of Housing confirmed the new service would be available to all residents within the district.
Councillor Anna Bradnam declared a non-pecuniary interest in minutes 6 and 7 (Planning Performance) as a member of the Planning Committee Development Group.
Councillor Anna Bradnam said that clear communication was key given the potential financial implications for individuals of both the backlog and the ‘no amendments’ approach’.
Councillor Anna Bradnam was pleased with the update coming to Cabinet, and how the report linked with the Chair’s charity, Centre 33, along with the expansion in funding to Wimpole.
Councillor Anna Bradnam supported the improved infrastructure within North East Cambridge and noted the Scrutiny and Overview Committee’s endorsement of the initial project.
Councillor Anna Bradnam substituted for Councillor Geoff Harvey.
Upon a proposal from Councillor Heather Williams, seconded by Councillor Anna Bradnam, the Planning Committee approved , by six votes to three, the addition of the wording “in consultation with the Parish Council” be added to condition 3 set out in the report from the Joint Director of Planning and Economic Development.
Councillor Anna Bradnam (local Member) enquired as to why recent enforcements in the Milton and Waterbeach ward were not included in the report.
Councillor Anna Bradnam, Chair of the Council provided wording that she had referenced at the Scrutiny and Overview Committee regarding flood resilience, and the Lead Cabinet Member responded that it would be included.
“The Gambling Act defines “child” as an individual who is less than 16 years old, and “young person” means an individual who is not a child but who is less than 18 years old.” This amendment was proposed by Councillor Anna Bradnam and seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes. The amendment was agreed by affirmation. A vote was taken on the substantive motion and by affirmation Council Agreed to adopt the revised Statement of Licensing Policy under the Gambling Act 2005 for a period of up to three years from 31 January 2022, with the inclusion of the following sentence: “The Gambling Act defines “child” as an individual who is less than 16 years old, and “young person” means an individual who is not a child who is less than 18 years old.”
For Policy CC/FM: Flooding and integrated water management, strengthen the policy to include additional wording to require that the risk of flooding in the area is not increased because of new development (Councillor Anna Bradnam and Councillor Pippa Heylings to provide proposed wording for consideration).
Councillor Anna Bradnam welcomed the policy, and thanked the Officers for their work. She asked whether the Licencing Committee could assist with the workshops during the consultation period.
The Lead Cabinet Member thanked Councillor Anna Bradnam for the offer and referred this action to the Officers within the Licensing team.
Councillor Anna Bradnam said she supported the report but requested that the funding for Domestic Homicide Reviews should continue to be provided by all the relevant organisations or by Central Government.
Councillor Bill Handley thanked Councillor Anna Bradnam for her comments.
Councillor Anna Bradnam said she was pleased with how the Council had worked with partner authorities during the increased rainfall during the winter of 2020 and 2021 and asked if the flood defence costs had been agreed with Cambridgeshire County Council.
Councillor Anna Bradnam welcomed the report, and said she was pleased the Council was continuing performance for tackling the climate emergency.
Picking up on a comment from Councillor Cathcart, Councillor Anna Bradnam reiterated the need for some degree of protection for landlords.
Councillor Anna Bradnam, Chair of the Council referred to Section 2 of response refers to southern access and requested the following amendments to the consultation document ‘a ny deviation from the preferred route might impact other Heritage and Landscape sites and we request that if variations are considered, EWR evaluate the potential for other important sites to be impacted’.
Councillor Bridget Smith, Leader of the Council, nominated Councillor Anna Bradnam.
By secret ballot, Councillor Bradnam was elected unopposed as Chair of Council for the municipal year 2021/22.
Councillor Bradnam read out and signed her declaration of acceptance of office.
In response to a question from Councillor Heather Williams, Councillor Claire Daunton said the nomination to the remaining vacancy on the Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Police and Crime Panel was Councillor Anna Bradnam.
Councillor Bridget Smith proposed and Councillor Anna Bradnam seconded Councillor Peter Fane as Vice Chair for the meeting.
Councillor Anna Bradnam proposed, Councillor Peter Fane seconded and Council by affirmation, with one abstention (Councillor Dr. Richard Williams), Resolved that the press and public be excluded from the meeting during consideration of the following item in accordance with the provisions of Section 100(a)(4) of the Local Government Act 1972 (exempt information as defined in paragraph 3 of Schedule 12A (as amended) of the Act).
Councillor Anna Bradnam declared · A non-pecuniary interest in Minute 7 (20/03370/OUT - Waterbeach (95 Bannold Road)). She had discussed the application with one of the local residents and given advice on how to address the matter.
Councillor Bradnam was considering the matter afresh.
Councillor Anna Bradnam expressed concern about access to the site and the lack of public transport. She acknowledged though that, on balance, the application was more acceptable than it had been at the Outline stage.
Councillor Anna Bradnam spoke as a local Member.
Upon the proposal of Councillor Anna Bradnam, seconded by Councillor Dr.
Councillor Anna Bradnam noted the design and sustainability of the building but said it must also enhance the character of the area in which it is located.
Councillor Anna Bradnam was appointed as Chair.
Councillor Anna Bradnam (Chair) Councillor Bill Handley Councillor Deborah Roberts SCDC Officers:
James Littlewood (Cambridge, Past Present and Future – objecting), Superintendent James Sutherland and Colin Luscombe (Cambridgeshire Constabulary - applicant), Don Wildman (Chairman of Milton Parish Council) and Councillor Anna Bradnam (as a local Member) addressed the meeting.
He thanked the Vice Chair, Councillor Anna Bradnam, the Leader, Councillor Bridget Smith, and all the Council’s officers, for their support during what had been a challenging time.
Councillor Anna Bradnam, Vice Chair of the Council, thanked officers for their work in producing the forthcoming civic year’s timetable of meetings, and moved the recommendation.
Councillor Anna Bradnam, the Vice Chair of the Council, seconded the motion.
Councillor Anna Bradnam declared a non-pecuniary interest in Minute 4 (S/3440/18/OL - Bourn (Bourn Airfield)) as a member of Cambridgeshire County Council.
In Councillor Heylings’ absence, and by affirmation, the Committee that Councillor Anna Bradnam be appointed Vice-Chair of the meeting.
Upon a proposal from Councillor John Batchelor, seconded by Councillor Anna Bradnam, and by affirmation, the Committee deferred the application.
The following three Councillors declared non-pecuniary interests in Minute 4 (S/2075/18/OL - Waterbeach (Land adjacent to Waterbeach Barracks and Airfield Site) Councillor Anna Bradnam as a Member for Milton and Waterbeach had been involved in discussions locally and had been a member of the South Cambridgeshire District Council Planning Committee when related applications had been considered previously.
Councillor Bradnam was considering the matter afresh.
· Barbara Bull (resident objector) · Katherine Else (objector) · Nigel Seamarks (resident objector) · Jane Williams (resident objector) · Chris Goldsmith (for the applicant) · Councillor Kate Grant (Waterbeach Parish Council) · County Councillor Tim Wotherspoon (mandated to speak on behalf of Cambridgeshire County Council) · Councillor Hazel Smith (local Councillor) · Councillor Anna Bradnam (Committee member speaking as a local Councillor) · Councillor Judith Rippeth (Committee member speaking as a local Councillor) During the meeting, the principal issues raised and discussed were:
By affirmation, the Committee agreed that Councillor Anna Bradnam should act as Vice-Chair of the meeting.
Councillor Anna Bradnam declared a non-pecuniary interest in Minute 6 (S/3290/19/RM - Fulbourn (Land East of Teversham Road)).
Councillor Bradnam had been a Planning Committee member when the Outline application had been determined but was considering the matter afresh.
There was sympathy for the Parish Council in terms of the parking of delivery vehicles and, upon a proposal from Councillor Pippa Heylings, seconded by Councillor Anna Bradnam, and by eight votes to three, the Committee agreed that the Traffic Management Plan be amended to state that, during the construction stage, delivery vehicles shall not park on any street within the village of Longstanton.
Tumi Hawkins, seconded by Councillor Anna Bradnam, the Committee voted unanimously to add an Informative to the planning consent urging the establishment of a liaison mechanism between residents, the Site Manager and Longstanton Parish Council to monitor compliance with the Traffic Management Plan and to resolve any disputes.
Councillors Henry Batchelor, Bradnam, Cahn, Fane, Hawkins, Heylings and Wilson voted against.) Councillor Anna Bradnam left the meeting at this stage. By affirmation, the ... view the full minutes text for item 9.
Councillor Bradnam had left the meeting.)
After taking advice from the Senior Planning Lawyer and Delivery Manager (Strategic Sites), the Chair proposed, seconded by Councillor Anna Bradnam, that the application be deferred. By affirmation, the Committee deferred the application until after the end of public consultation on 29 December 2020.
Councillor Anna Bradnam requested that the details of the matter at Fen Road, Milton be updated to reflect that this site is in Milton and not Chesterton.
Further, Councillor Bradnam sought clarity in respect of the requirements of the enforcement notice and when they would take effect. The Delivery Manager (Strategic Sites) advised that this information would be provided by the Enforcement Officer outside the meeting.
Councillor Anna Bradnam was appointed as Chair.
Councillor Anna Bradnam (Chair) Councillor Eileen Wilson Councillor Deborah Roberts SCDC Officers:
Councillor Anna Bradnam declared a non-pecuniary interest in Minute 5 (S/4207/19/RM - Cottenham (Land North East of Rampton Road)) as a Cambridgeshire County Councillor, given that the applicant Company is wholly owned by Cambridgeshire County Council.
Councillor Bradnam was satisfied that there was no conflict of interest and that she would be considering the matter afresh.
(Councillor Bradnam did not vote.)
Councillor Anna Bradnam expressed her support for this motion, stating that parking was a problem in Milton, due to the proximity of the Science Park. The challenge was that all civil parking had to be self-funding.
The Chair proposed, Councillor Anna Bradnam seconded and Council by affirmation, with one vote against (Councillor Deborah Roberts), Resolved that the press and public be excluded from the meeting during consideration of the following item in accordance with the provisions of Section 100(a)(4) of the Local Government Act 1972 (exempt information as defined in paragraph 3 of Schedule 12A (as amended) of the Act).
Councillor Anna Bradnam was appointed as Chair of the Licensing (2003 Act) Sub-Committee.
Councillor Anna Bradnam (Chair) Councillor Bill Handley Councillor Peter McDonald SCDC Officers:
Councillor Anna Bradnam declared a Non-Pecuniary interest in Minute 12 (S/0009/20/FL - Waterbeach (Recreation Ground, Cambridge Road)).
Councillor Bradnam was aware of this application as a local Member for Milton and Waterbeach Ward, but had not contributed to any discussion locally in a prejudicial manner, and was considering the matter afresh.
This was seconded by Councillor Anna Bradnam and, upon a vote being taken by roll call, the motion was approved by seven votes to four, with Councillors Roberts, Heather Williams, Richard Williams, and Wright voting against.
This proposal had been seconded by Councillor Anna Bradnam and, upon a vote being taken by roll call, the motion had been approved by seven votes to four.
Councillor Anna Bradnam was appointed as the Chair of the Licensing Appeals Sub-Committee.
Councillor Anna Bradnam (Chair) Councillor Eileen Wilson Councillor Bill Handley SCDC Officers:
Councillor Anna Bradnam declared a non-pecuniary interest in Minutes 8 and 9 (20/01463/HFUL and 20/01464/LBC - Little Wilbraham (5 Primrose Farm Road) by virtue of being friends with the applicant and a colleague of Councillor Dr. Claire Daunton.
Councillor Bradnam confirmed that she had not discussed this application with either of them, and was considering the matter afresh.
This was seconded by Councillor Anna Bradnam and, upon a vote being conducted by roll call, the Committee approved both the amended Condition and additional Informative by eight votes to one with one abstention.
· Councillor Claire Daunton · Councillor Geoff Harvey · Councillor Richard Williams Input from other members would be welcomed and Councillor Anna Bradnam also indicated that she would be willing to be a reserve member of the group if further input was required.
Councillor Brian Milnes and Councillor Anna Bradnam both suggested that this would help with community cohesion and allow local communities to engage with developers and key stakeholders .
Councillor Anna Bradnam expressed support for the report, noting its’ clarity, and asked when the workshop would be held in relation to the new scheme. In reply, the Leader said this had been scheduled to take place in July 2020, and finally concluded the discussion.
Councillor Anna Bradnam noted that the figures for waste collection had reduced.
Councillor Anna Bradnam in relation to · Minute 8 (S/2896/19/FL - Duxford (Imperial War Museum Royston Road, Duxford) ) declared a non-pecuniary interest. In her capacity as South Cambridgeshire District Council’s representative on the Board of Trustees to Denny Abbey and the Farmland Museum, she knows another Trustee on that Board, Michael Peirson , who is the Retail and Admission Manager for the Imperial War Museum at Duxford.
While she and [name removed] had discussed the generalities of museum finances and strategies for the future, Councillor Bradnam confirmed that she had not discussed this application for a hotel at the Imperial War Museum, Duxford with [name removed] at any time.
Councillor Bradnam was considering the matter afresh.
· Councillor Anna Bradnam declared a non-pecuniary interest having discussed the application with Waterbeach Parish Council but was now considering the matter afresh.
Councillor Bradnam welcomed the opportunities that the new town would offer.
This proposal was seconded by Councillor Anna Bradnam and, by affirmation, agreed by the Committee with the final wording to be agreed by officers in consultation with the Chair and Vice-Chair of the Planning Committee.
At the recommendation of Councillor John Batchelor, seconded by Councillor Anna Bradnam, and by affirmation, the Committee deferred planning applications S/4302/19/FL in Girton (16 High Street), S/4081/19/FL in Fowlmere (Hideaway, Lynch Lane) and S/3858/19/FL in Whittlesford (2 Whiskins ) to the Planning Committee meeting on 10 June 2020.
Upon the proposal of Councillor Heather Williams, seconded by Councillor Anna Bradnam, the Committee unanimously voted to withdraw Permitted Development Rights Class B (additions or alterations to roofs which enlarge the house) and Class C (other alterations to roofs).
This was seconded by Councillor Anna Bradnam and carried by the Committee by affirmation.
Councillor Hazel Smith read out a statement from Councillor Anna Bradnam, a local Member.
Councillor Anna Bradnam declared a non-pecuniary interest as a local member for agenda items 7 and 8. She confirmed that she came to this matter afresh.
Attendance List The addition of Councillor Anna Bradnam as having been in attendance.
Councillor Bridget Smith, Leader of Council, proposed and Councillor Anna Bradnam, Chairman, seconded the Calendar of Meetings for 2020/21, as detailed in the agenda.
The proposal was seconded by Councillor Anna Bradnam.
(Note: Councillor Anna Bradnam indicated after the meeting that she inadvertently voted in ... view the full minutes text for item 13c
The Chairman having moved, and Councillor Anna Bradnam having seconded the motion, Council, by affirmation
(i) Councillor Bill Handley replaced by Councillor Anna Bradnam as a member of the Committee; and (ii) Councillor Anna Bradnam replaced by [name removed] as a substitute member of the Committee.
Councillor Anna Bradnam explained that the engagement of a contractor had been discussed at the Scrutiny and Overview Committee and it was a reasonable solution to the challenges being faced.
Councillor Anna Bradnam suggested that A.99 of the draft response should be strengthened by emphasising the need for public transport links between villages in South Cambridgeshire.
In response to a question from Councillor Anna Bradnam, the Principal Planning Policy Officer undertook to find out whether provision was being made for charging points specifically for electric Hackney Carriages and Private Hire Vehicles.
However, Councillor Anna Bradnam took a contrary view and made an impassioned plea that the electronic conduct of meetings should require individual Members to opt in and be supported by extensive Member training.
· Councillor Anna Bradnam was concerned that the Council’s representative on the GCP could be accused of pre-determination if the motion was passed.
Councillor Anna Bradnam was nominated by Councillor Dr.
That Councillor Anna Bradnam be appointed Vice-Chairman of the Council for the 2019/20 Civic Year.
Councillor Bradnam read out and signed the declaration of acceptance of office.
Following her appointment, Councillor Bradnam expressed her gratitude to Members for their continuing support.
It was pointed out by Councillor Bradnam, who was a member of the Crime and Disorder Reduction Partnership, that the powers the Police had in relation to illegal traveller encampments were not as straightforward as the public thought and may not meet with public expectation. The interim Chief Executive would respond to Cambourne Town Council.
Councillor Anna Bradnam seconded the motion.
Councillor Anna Bradnam reported on her attendance at one of the briefings held for Members on the proposed changes and outlined the reasons why a banding system had been preferred, including providing greater certainty for residents and creating a system that was more manageable.
· Councillor Anna Bradnam welcomed the proposals to review taxi licensing policies to incentivise taxi operators and drivers to improve air quality. She also referred to a Government consultation on statutory guidance to be issued to taxi and private hire licensing authorities on protecting children and vulnerable adults and was pleased to note that the Council already undertook many ... view the full minutes text for item 9d
Councillor Anna Bradnam , the Vice-Chairman of the Council seconded the motion.
Councillor Anna Bradnam recognised the existence of local expertise in the field, and urged Cabinet to take advice from such sources, where appropriate. The Deputy Monitoring Officer reminded Members that this was an Executive function.
Councillor Geoff Harvey was present as a substitute for Councillor Bradnam, Councillor Sue Ellington was present as a substitute for Councillor Chamberlain, and Councillor Nigel Cathcart was present as a substitute for Councillor Clayton.
Councillor Anna Bradnam , the Chairman of the Licensing Committee, proposed the recommendations of the Licensing Committee, at its meeting held on 17 October 2018, with regard to adoption of the Statement of Gambling Act 2005 Policy.
Councillor Bradnam noted that a statement of this licensing policy was a requirement under Section 349 of the Gambling Act 2005. In preparing the revised policy statement, officers had given full regard to both the requirements of the Act itself and the guidelines issued by the Gambling Commission in September 2015, together with, where relevant, Council strategies. The draft policy had been subject to public consultation and four responses to the consultation had been received, although no changes had been recommended in relation to these responses.
Councillor Anna Bradnam , the Chairman of the Licensing Committee, proposed the recommendations of the Licensing Committee, at its meeting held on 17 October 2018, with regard to adoption of the Statement of Licensing (2003 Act) Policy.
Councillor Bradnam noted that a statement of this licensing policy was a requirement under Section 5 of the Licensing Act 2003. In preparing the revised policy statement, officers had given full regard to both the requirements of the Act itself and to revised guidelines issued in April 2018 by the Home Office. The revised policy had been subject to public consultation in July 2018, details had been circulated to all Responsible Authorities, together with persons or businesses who had been in contact with the Licensing section over the past year, and it had also been published on the Council’s website and circulated to Parish Councils.
Councillor Bradnam invited Council to additionally delegate authority to the Director of Health and Environmental Services to make any final grammatical or typographical corrections to the policy statement before publication.
Cllr Anna Bradnam was elected as Vice-Chairman for the meeting.
Attendance list Specify that Councillor Anna Bradnam is a local Member for Waterbeach, and delete the repeated words “and Heather Williams”.
Councillor Brian Milnes outlined the observations made by members of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee, and Councillor Anna Bradnam reminded those present about the report on this same topic in August 2017. The Deputy Leader said that any relevant aspect of the 2017 report would be incorporated into the new submission.
During the ensuing debate, Councillor Philippa Hart agreed with Councillor Anna Bradnam that staff should be involved in the process.
Councillor Steve Hunt was present as a substitute for Councillor Bradnam.
During questions addressed to the Council’s representatives on the Combined Authority:- · Councillor Anna Bradnam sought more information about the Independent Economic Commission, noting that it did not appear to be referred to in the Combined Authority’s report before Council.
In response, Councillor Topping acknowledged that whilst this issue might not be referred to in the papers, he had thought it important to keep Members up to date on progress with the Independent Economic Commission and could provide further information to Councillor Bradnam and other Members if this would be helpful. · The Leader reported that the Combined Authority Board had discussed the need for future budgets to have a “forward look”.
Additionally, she indicated that she would also welcome an update from the Leader on the position with the LEP • Referring to previous comments about relocation of the Anglian Water treatment site, Councillor Anna Bradnam reported that residents in Milton had worked hard with Anglian Water in liaison meetings to address odour issues associated with the site. She also suggested that assumptions should not be made about regeneration of the site in advance of the funding bid being agreed.
• Councillor Anna Bradnam supported the view that the engagement exercise should have sought residents’ views on areas with which they were dissatisfied and where improvements where needed. She also commented that the design of survey questions could influence the outcome ... view the full minutes text for item 10.
Councillor Anna Bradnam was present as a substitute for Councillor Hawkins.
In response to comments from Councillor Anna Bradnam, Councillor Howell said that he did not envisage any adverse impact on the Council’s recycling rates from discontinuing ‘paper out’ collections via paper caddies. A comprehensive communications plan would be implemented to ensure a smooth transition to the new co-mingled system, if approved.
Councillor Anna Bradnam said there was some concern regarding the lack of guidance about Neighbourhood Plans, and access to officers. She cited the complexity involved in pursuing a Neighbourhood Plan for Waterbeach.
Councillor Anna Bradnam raised three points exploring the relationships between SPDs and outline planning applications, the likely timing of planning applications for the two separate elements of Waterbeach New Town, and current location of the northern boundary of the Waterbeach New Town footprint and its proximity to Debby Abbey. In reply to the first point, the Planning Policy Manager said that the function of SPDs was simply to address capacity issues. It was for the development control process to deal with the specifics of individual planning applications.
Councillor Anna Bradnam referred to paragraph 22 of the report from the Joint Director for Planning and Economic Development. The Planning Portfolio Holder said that the Planning Inspector responsible for the public examination of the emerging Local Plans of both South Cambridgeshire District Council and Cambridge City Council had not yet indicated whether the proposed joint trajectory of the two Councils’ five-year land supply would be acceptable or not. The Planning Policy Manager highlighted the fact that, on its own, it was anticipated that South Cambridgeshire District Council would not be able to demonstrate a five-year land supply until 2019.
Councillor Anna Bradnam commended officers on their efforts, and asked what the chances were of South Cambridgeshire District Council recovering the costs of direct action. The Principal Planning Enforcement Officer said that payment would be secured by means of a legal charge against the property. The Planning Lawyer reminded the Committee that the costs of recovery might be equal to the costs of the enforcement recovered.
Councillor Anna Bradnam echoed these sentiments and agreed that supplementary documents should be able to be supplied in support of any questions.
Councillor Anna Bradnam asked the following question:
He agreed to provide Councillor Bradnam with the information outside of the meeting and also confirmed that the TUPE process was carried out in accordance with the regulations.
Councillor Bradnam referred to reassurances that had been given regarding shared services ensuring greater resilience. As a supplementary question, she asked whether there would continue to be a service desk facility at South Cambridgeshire Hall for elected Members, covering each of the services.
Councillor Edwards, in his capacity of Portfolio Holder for Finance and Staffing, was unable to answer the question as it related to services outside of his Portfolio and therefore offered to ensure that Councillor Bradnam received a written response to this supplementary question.
Councillor Anna Bradnam asked that there be greater clarity as to the list of material planning considerations.
Councillor Anna Bradnam queried whether recent planning permission given to the Arthur Rank Hospice near the Cambridge Babraham Road Park and Ride site would impact the green belt. In response to this, Members were informed that the most recent green belt study concluded that land could be released north and south of Worts Causeway, without significant harm to the green belt.
In response to a question from Councillor Anna Bradnam, officers believed that houses were currently under construction on the Land Settlement Association (LSA) Estate that had been permitted through the policy.
Councillor Anna Bradnam urged caution about the planning process becoming paperless, not least where computer networks fail.
Councillor Anna Bradnam was concerned about the proposal’s possible negative impact on providing land for employment purposes.
Councillor Anna Bradnam prompted a discussion focussing on the implications of the recent Appeal decision in Waterbeach and South Cambridgeshire District Council’s shortfall in its five-year housing land supply. The Planning and New Communities Director said that the ongoing Local Plan Examination would be considering a Memorandum of Understanding aimed at addressing the five-year housing land supply shortfall facing both the District Council and Cambridge City Council.
Councillor Bradnam has no connection with the applicant or the application itself.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Bradnam attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Bradnam's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Bradnam was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
South Cambridgeshire has not published attendance for Councillor Bradnam's meetings yet.
What Councillor Bradnam declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 17 Oct 2024 | Scrutiny and Overview Committee, item 2 | Councillor Anna Bradnam declared an interest as a member of the Waterbeach Level Internal Drainage Board. | |
| 10 Apr 2024 | Planning Committee, item 3 | With respect to Minute 5, Councillor Anna Bradnam declared that she was a member of Cambridge Natural History Society. | |
| 10 Apr 2024 | Planning Committee, item 3 | Councillor Anna Bradnam declared that she knew one of the public speakers (Gillian Elwood, Clerk of Hauxton Parish Council) in a personal capacity but had not discussed the application. | |
| 27 Feb 2024 | Council, item 2 | Councillor Anna Bradnam declared Other Registerable Interests as a Cambridgeshire County Councillor and as a member of the Combined Authority Scrutiny and Overview Committee. | |
| 16 Dec 2021 | Scrutiny and Overview Committee, item 3 | Councillor Anna Bradnam declared a non-pecuniary interest i n Minute 6 (North East Cambridge Area Action Plan) as a Milton Parish Councillor, a local District Councillor for Milton & Waterbeach, and the Cambridgeshire County Councillor for the Electoral Division or Waterbeach, which includes the Parish of Milton. | |
| 11 Nov 2021 | Scrutiny and Overview Committee, item 3 | Councillor Anna Bradnam declared a non-pecuniary interest in minutes 6 and 7 (Planning Performance) as a member of the Planning Committee Development Group. | |
| 13 Apr 2021 | Planning Committee, item 3 | Councillor Anna Bradnam declared · A non-pecuniary interest in Minute 7 (20/03370/OUT - Waterbeach (95 Bannold Road)). She had discussed the application with one of the local residents and given advice on how to address the matter. | |
| 19 Feb 2021 | Planning Committee, item 3 | Councillor Anna Bradnam declared a non-pecuniary interest in Minute 4 (S/3440/18/OL - Bourn (Bourn Airfield)) as a member of Cambridgeshire County Council. | |
| 13 Jan 2021 | Planning Committee, item 3 | Councillor Anna Bradnam declared a non-pecuniary interest in Minute 6 (S/3290/19/RM - Fulbourn (Land East of Teversham Road)). | |
| 14 Oct 2020 | Planning Committee, item 3 | Councillor Anna Bradnam declared a non-pecuniary interest in Minute 5 (S/4207/19/RM - Cottenham (Land North East of Rampton Road)) as a Cambridgeshire County Councillor, given that the applicant Company is wholly owned by Cambridgeshire County Council. | |
| 9 Sep 2020 | Planning Committee, item 3 | Councillor Anna Bradnam declared a Non-Pecuniary interest in Minute 12 (S/0009/20/FL - Waterbeach (Recreation Ground, Cambridge Road)). | |
| 26 Aug 2020 | Planning Committee, item 3 | Councillor Anna Bradnam declared a non-pecuniary interest in Minutes 8 and 9 (20/01463/HFUL and 20/01464/LBC - Little Wilbraham (5 Primrose Farm Road) by virtue of being friends with the applicant and a colleague of Councillor Dr. Claire Daunton. | |
| 10 Jun 2020 | Planning Committee, item 3 | · Councillor Anna Bradnam declared a non-pecuniary interest having discussed the application with Waterbeach Parish Council but was now considering the matter afresh. | |
| 11 Mar 2020 | Planning Committee, item 2 | Councillor Anna Bradnam declared a non-pecuniary interest as a local member for agenda items 7 and 8. She confirmed that she came to this matter afresh. |
Where Councillor Bradnam sits, from the attendance records.
No committee attendance recorded for Councillor Bradnam yet.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.