Complaints Policy
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes.
Every time South Cambridgeshire's minutes name Councillor Milnes, as the council published it.
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes.
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes who made comment that offering such schemes would only be possible owing to the financial prudence of the Council.
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes.
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes.
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes.
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes, who reserved his right to speak until later in the debate.
As seconder of the recommendations, Councillor Brian Milnes acknowledged a number of concerns, including parishing , the ability to attract a diverse range of people to stand as Councillors, and losing connections with localities if there was a higher number of electors per Councillor. It was advised that the submission should be as evidence led as possible, but the administration had expressed a preference for a ‘Greater Cambridge’ model.
Councillor Brian Milnes, as the new Chair of the Greater Cambridge Partnership, updated Members on the recent decisions of the partnership, including the Waterbeach Station and the final wave of funding for infrastructure improvements.
In response, Councillor Brian Milnes advised that the earlier report on Local Government Reorganisation addressed the issue of establishing member workshops to support the development of business cases. It was felt that this would be a more flexible approach to ensure that as many Members were involved as possible.
Councillor Cone thanked Councillor Milnes for the response, explaining that his question had been submitted prior to the agenda publication.
In response, Councillor Brian Milnes advised that the 2018 Local Plan required development at Bourn Airfield to provide a public transport solution to Cambridge. Consideration of the merits of the proposal was a matter for the ongoing examination process, though it was advised that the Spatial Strategy within the Local Plan had been adopted to avoid piecemeal development, which should be supported by the appropriate infrastructure. It was advised that the Council was supportive of the Greater Cambridge Partnership project.
Councillor Milnes advised that he would provide a written response.
In response, Councillor Brian Milnes advised that officers had developed a communications plan to promote the upcoming Shared Prosperity Fund and the Rural England Prosperity Fund grant schemes. The Council would also be working with partners to promote the schemes with residents and local business and would be making in person visits to parish councils.
In response, Councillor Brian Milnes advised that since the new website had gone live there had been a 30% increase in views compared to last year, with 750,000 since March. It was noted that the new ‘localisation’ feature had proven popular with residents, with some further suggestions being received as to what should be added. It was further advised that the new website was significantly more accessible than before as well as achieving a better carbon emissions rating.
In response, Councillor Brian Milnes advised that the Greater Cambridge Partnership Executive Board had approved the progression of the Waterbeach Station project, with a contractor to be appointed shortly. The contractor would then appoint a designer before work commenced, which was scheduled for mid-2026, to be completed by the end of 2027.
An amendment to the motion was moved by Councillor Brian Milnes and was seconded by Councillor Bridget Smith.
This was seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes.
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes.
Councillor Brian Milnes, as the representative, advised that he looked forward to hearing what plans the Combined Authority Mayor had for the county and was keen to hear the contribution of the Assembly.
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes.
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes, who noted the Council’s performance and skill in managing its finances correctly.
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes, who noted that the strategy had been consistently grounded and contributed to the Council’s financial rectitude.
A question had been received from Jason Weston, who asked, “Does SCDC believe that cost should be prioritised over the well-being of villagers and rare species, particularly in terms of health, mental health and the anticipated disruption of up to seven years of construction work (7 years quoted by EWR) And will SCDC actively support the use of a bored tunnel for the Caldecote section to reduce the long term adverse effects on the local community?” Councillor Milnes responded that the Council was required to produce a Local Impact Report in relation to the project, which officers were currently working on through a detailed review of consultation material to assess the design options and potential impacts. Further details on health and wellbeing impacts were anticipated in the form of a Health Impact Assessment, within the Environmental Impact Assessment. It was advised that concerns had been raised around biodiversity proposals within the Caldecote section of the design and officers would continue to explore this.
Councillor Milnes and the Joint Director of Planning and Economic Development advised that a full response would be provided in writing, but that the Council was aware of residents’ concerns and could take them forward.
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Milnes, who noted that the uptake up to now had been less than hoped for and that increasing the grant would hopefully encourage more applications.
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Milnes, who advised that the aims of the programme had been virtuous, but the level of grant insufficient.
Councillor Brian Milnes, as member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Executive Board, reported that the Board meeting on 7 November had discussed feedback from the Joint Assembly, the Waterbeach Railway, Waterbeach to Cambridge public transport, greenways and the Cambridge Southwest Travel Hub.
In response, Councillor Milnes commended the officer team who organised the event and advised that it would be held again next year. There had been 68 attendees, as well as many Council Members.
Councillor Milnes responded that, in order to give a more considered response, he would provide an answer in writing.
Councillor Heather Williams moved a proposal to extend the meeting, which was seconded by Councillor Milnes. The Council (unanimously) agreed for the meeting to extend beyond four hours.
The motion was seconded by Councillor Milnes, who reserved his right to speak until later in the debate.
As seconder of the motion, Councillor Milnes noted that recent impacts of climate change had attracted a high cost. These ... view the full minutes text for item 75.
Councillor Brian Milnes, as a member of the GCP Executive Board, reported that the Board had met on 2 October 2024 and had discussed the Cambridge South-East Transport Scheme, which had £7.2million allocated to it by Government in the previous budget, and would now be moving forward.
In response to a question, Councillor Milnes advised that he would investigate with officers whether the GCP would be taking advice from the Royal National Institute of Blind People on the safety of ‘floating bus stops’ for blind and partially-sighted people.
The amendment was seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes, who reserved his right to speak until later in the debate.
As seconder of the amendment, Councillor Brian Milnes advised that this was an issue for Cambridgeshire roads, not South Cambridgeshire District Council, which allocated funding according to need and funding. It was felt that the amendment reflected this.
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environment, introduced the report and moved the recommendations.
In so doing, Councillor Milnes advised that in the past six years, vast improvements had been made to the Council’s ICT support. It was felt, however, the further work was needed to create a vision for digital services beyond the Council’s website, including the appointment of a Chief Digital Services Officer who could support the Council’s transformation ideals.
Councillor Brian Milnes explained that in respect of East West Rail the Council was a statutory consultee but the decision with regard to the route would be taken by the Secretary of State. The Council was yet to see the preferred route.
Councillor Milnes explained that all phases of Northstowe had outline planning permission. The Council was committed to helping to deliver the necessary facilities to Northstowe. The recent King’s speech had indicated that delivering infrastructure was one of the new Government’s priorities and the Council looked forward to seeing this being put into practice.
Councillor Milnes stated that the issue of water shortages had been raised with the previous Government. The current plan was for a fen reservoir but this was not due for completion until the 2030s.
Councillor Brian Milnes explained that whilst progress had been made on the Sawston greenway, work on the Stapleford to the Shelford section had been delayed.
Councillor Brian Milnes expressed his support for the motion and suggested that in future, the grant should be increased by inflation.
Councillor John Williams proposed and Councillor Brian Milnes seconded the recommendations in the report.
Councillor Brian Milnes said that there were no plans for the ... view the full minutes text for item 8b
Councillor Brian Milnes opposed the amendment and asserted that the Conservative Government was partly responsible for the financial pressures faced by residents.
Councillor Brian Milnes explained that there had been a delay in bringing this recommendation to Council due to the need to replace a member of the Independent Remuneration Panel. He stated that the recommended increase was lower than inflation and that Council had agreed increases lower than those proposed by the Independent Remuneration Panel twice since 2018.
Councillor Brian Milnes proposed and Councillor Peter McDonald seconded the recommendations in the report. A vote was taken and were cast as follows:
Councillor Brian Milnes proposed and Councillor Graham Cone seconded the proposal that Council be able to continue beyond its duration of four hours. This was agreed by affirmation.
Councillor Brian Milnes explained that a new version of Insite had been launched the week before but it was still being developed. He thanked the communications team for their work on this.
Councillor Brian Milnes agreed to pass this request on to those developing Insite, although he did not think it was appropriate to include the location of officers on Insite. It was agreed that officers should be contactable.
Councillor Brian Milnes stated that Meadow Community centre provided free sanitary products and he supported the motion.
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes.
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes, who thanked officers for the valuable report.
Councillor Brian Milnes was in attendance online.
agreed the content of the Cambridge Waste Water Treatment Plant Relocation Project Local Impact Report in Appendix 1 to the r Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environment, introduced the report and moved the recommendations.
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes.
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes, who noted that the Peer Review had referenced the Council’s minimum revenue position.
Councillor Brian Milnes explained that at the Greater Cambridge Partnership Executive Board meeting on 28 September there had been a lack of political consensus on whether to develop the Sustainable Travel Zone and so the decision had been made not to proceed.
Councillor Heather Williams respected the honesty of Councillor Brian Milnes on this issue. She expressed her concern that the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly had not been permitted to scrutinise the report before it went to the Board.
Councillor Brian Milnes explained that the three Council members on the Board needed to agree for a decision to be taken and there had not been a political consensus across the three authorities.
Councillor Brian Milnes explained that changes had been made to the energy partnership scheme and lessons had been learned as the service was being reappraised as it moved into its second phase.
Councillor Brian Milnes stated that he would discuss this matter with officers, who were keen to improve the service.
The recommendations were seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Deputy Leader, thanked the officers for their work and acknowledged the improvement of the service there had been over the last few years.
Councillor Brian Milnes noted that due to recent elections and changes in local government there could be changes to the report.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Deputy Leader and Lead Cabinet Member for the Environment presented the report and thanked the Senior Policy and Performance Officer for their work.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Deputy Leader and Lead Cabinet Member for the Environment, commented on delivering houses for local residents within the district.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Deputy Leader, and Lead Cabinet Member for the Environment thanked Officers for their work, and noted the continued support for EV charging points within the towns and villages.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Deputy Leader, and Lead Cabinet Member for the Environment noted the proposal to Council was suitable during the cost of living crisis.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Deputy Leader, introduced the report and noted the progress of the key performance indicators against business plan, and any actions for Officers.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Deputy Leader, introduced the report, and significant funding from the Cambridge and Peterborough Combined Authority, to increase the electric capacity through renewable energy at the Waterbeach Depot.
Councillor Brian Milnes responded that the provision of renewables can be increased. The Head of Climate, Environment and Waste commented that the Council wants a phased replacement of the current refuse vehicles and further data from the current fleet of electric vehicles would be required.
Councillor Brian Milnes responded that there would be back-up from the national grid, and any snow accumulated on the solar panels would melt due to the generated heat.
Councillor Brian Milnes thanked the Head of Finance and Officers within the department for their ongoing work with the Medium-Term Financial Strategy.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Deputy Leader, thanked Officers for their work and considered the Council’s position when compared to other Local Government authorities across the Country.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Deputy Leader, also thanked the relevant Officers, and was pleased with the Council’s approach to investments.
Councillor Brian Milnes declared an interest in the same item as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Executive Board.
The Leader explained that Councillor Judith Rippeth had stood down as Deputy Leader, a role that was now being fulfilled by Councillor Brian Milnes.
Councillor Brian Milnes expressed his admiration for everyone involved in the production of the Gamlingay Neighbourhood Plan, which had taken seven years to develop. A referendum had been held on 10 November and 76.77% of those who had voted had supported it. If agreed, the Neighbourhood Plan would form part of the Local Development Plan.
Councillor Brian Milnes proposed and Councillor Henry Batchelor seconded the recommendations in the report. A vote was taken and Council unanimously Agreed to A) Note that the referendum for the Gamlingay Neighbourhood Plan took place on November 2022.
Councillor Brian Milnes agreed that additional work was required.
Councillor Brian Milnes seconded this proposal.
Cabinet The Leader appointed Councillor Brian Milnes as Deputy Leader and Councillor Henry Batchelor to join the Cabinet as Lead Cabinet Member for Environment, Waste and Licensing.
Combined Authority Transport and Infrastructure Committee: Councillor Brian Milnes replaces Councillor Bridget Smith as substitute member.
And, as a professional schoolteacher, will the Deputy Leader show her working out by providing the data to justify her answer?" Councillor Brian Milnes agreed to provide the detailed data, which he assured Council supported the contention that improved bus services would benefit those on low incomes the most.
Councillor Brian Milnes replied that the data was from nationally based statistics.
Councillor Brian Milnes replied that the charge would fund affordable alternative transport.
Councillor Brian Milnes explained that this authority was a voting member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Executive Board, which had decided to consult on the proposed sustainable travel zone. He stated that it would be pre-emptive of the Council to express a view on this matter before this consultation had concluded.
Councillor Brian Milnes explained that the location of the treatment plant was beyond the remit of this authority. He was therefore not going to support the motion.
Councillor Brian Milnes agreed to provide a written response regarding these issues.
Councillor Brian Milnes replied that those on the lowest incomes could not afford a car and would benefit from a more reliable bus service. The recent announcement from Stagecoach showed how important it was to provide a reliable and affordable bus service, with a discount for those on the lowest income.
Councillor Milnes replied that the details of how the congestion charge would work had not been determined and that the consultation process would ensure that these matters were considered.
Councillor Brian Milnes replied that several consultation exercises had taken place over the last five to six years including a citizens’ assembly and a public event at the Corn Exchange.
Councillor Brian Milnes explained that the purpose of the City Access proposal was to provide transport to the city that reduced people’s reliance on cars. This would also reduce air pollution that was killing approximately 100 residents a year.
Councillor Brian Milnes explained that the demand would have to sufficient to justify additional bus routes.
Councillor Brian Milnes replied that it was important that the consultation process could influence decisions. Possible charges had to be linked to service improvements, including more buses and reduced fares. There was no supplementary question.
Councillor Brian Milnes lamented the decline in water standards, which had been upheld by the European Union’s blue flags scheme. He expressed his wholehearted support for the motion.
Councillor Brian Milnes emphasised the importance of assuring residents that the trial was intended, among other things, to address any unexpected negative impact on the delivery of Council services.
Councillor Brian Milnes explained that the increase in utility prices had reduced the time it would take for the project to pay for itself from 20 to 10 years.
In response to Councillor Dr Redrup’s supplementary question, Councillor Milnes explained that the greening of South Cambridgeshire Hall was just one of several initiatives recently introduced by the Council, which included the provision of electric refuse vehicles and the decision to construct a solar panel array to power these vehicles at Waterbeach depot.
Councillor Brian Milnes supported the motion and he looked forward to the day when Council would debate a motion proposed by a youth council.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for the Environment, declared an interest in item 7, Lynton Way, Sawston, as a Member of Sawston Parish Council.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for the Environment, was supportive of the project, and noted, as one of the local Members for Sawston, the improvement in local community facilities.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for the Environment, commented on the interim report coming to the Climate and Environment Advisory Committee and Cabinet and allowing Members to review the interim approach.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for the Environment, commented on the consultation response between the local authorities, and referred to the need to enhance the response to seek amendments to references to the East West Rail link to Newmarket, and to electricity grid enhancements required to support the decarbonisation of both private and public transport across the area. The Principal Policy Planner Officer commented that the report had been approved by Cambridge City Council, and the additions from the Cabinet would be part of an out-of-cycle decision.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for the Environment, commented on the continued work of the Waste Service.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for the Environment, was supportive of the policy, commenting on the influx of technology being used by Officers to work remotely, and to work collaboratively, despite not working at South Cambridgeshire Hall.
Councillor Brian Milnes explained that the Council continued to encourage village events to decrease their waste and promote recycling. The Council also supported community action days that provided skips for recyclable material and set up repair cafes.
In response to Councillor Eileen Wilson’s supplementary question, Councillor Milnes agreed to ensure that parish councils were contacted regarding these events as their support was important.
Councillor Brian Milnes proposed the following amendments to the Motion:
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environmental Services and Licencing, praised the efforts of the Waste Services team during the past two years, and noted the positive feedback received from residents.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environmental Services and Licencing, welcomed the additional funding from the Greater Cambridge Partnership, and hoped this would solve the issue of inconsiderate parking within Shelford.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environmental Services and Licensing said he was pleased with the working practices noted within the report and hoped it would improve the diversity of wildlife.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environmental Services and Licencing noted the programme included the installation of solar panels at the Waste depot, and the facilities at Northstowe.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environmental Services and Licencing said that the newly acquired apartment blocks in Sawston were of the same quality as those within the commercial market.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environmental Services and Licencing, supported the Deputy Leader’s comments, and hoped the strategy would reduce the need for police attention.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environmental Services and Licencing, referenced issues regarding the availability of water resources, and highlighted the water demands of agriculture. The Joint Director said that the Council would continue to work with local partners regarding water availability.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environmental Services, introduced this report on the revised Statement of Licensing Policy under the Gambling Act 2005. He thanked the Licensing Officer for her work on this issue.
“The Gambling Act defines “child” as an individual who is less than 16 years old, and “young person” means an individual who is not a child but who is less than 18 years old.” This amendment was proposed by Councillor Anna Bradnam and seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes. The amendment was agreed by affirmation. A vote was taken on the substantive motion and by affirmation Council Agreed to adopt the revised Statement of Licensing Policy under the Gambling Act 2005 for a period of up to three years from 31 January 2022, with the inclusion of the following sentence: “The Gambling Act defines “child” as an individual who is less than 16 years old, and “young person” means an individual who is not a child who is less than 18 years old.”
Councillor Brian Milnes agreed and added that many concerns expressed about planning applications at a lower lever were not material considerations and he did want to see the Planning Committee dealing with trivial matters.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environmental Services and Licencing responded as follows.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environmental Services, introduced the report, and discussed the increase of street traders during the coronavirus pandemic. It was noted that the policy brought to Cabinet was fairer and simpler for all street traders across the district.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environmental Services and Licencing, was supportive of the project and thanked Officers for their work in providing the final draft.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environmental Services and Licencing said the Council was continuing to work collaboratively with the County Council, and other relevant authorities.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environmental Services and Licencing, noted further stakeholder meetings would be taking place, but the current consultation process was ignoring current Government guidance.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environmental Services and Licencing highlighted the Waste Disposal team had continued to exceed their targets during the fourth quarter.
Cabinet received the Private Sector Housing Policy, Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environmental Services and Licencing, introduced the report, noting the importance of the policy, which would ensure the Council would follow the guidance from the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, that it would enforce the powers fairly and enabled the landlords and letting agents within the district to understand how the council might use these powers.
Councillor Brian Milnes responded that current vacancies had been filled ahead of this policy being brought to Cabinet.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet member for Environmental Services and Licencing agreed the report continued the Council’s commitment to tackle Climate Change.
Councillor Brian Milnes (Lead Cabinet Member for Environment and Licensing) was in attendance to give evidence to the Committee.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Local Member for Sawston, stated that the proposed boundary change was straight forward and a large majority of local residents supported it. He thanked the officers for their work.
Councillor Brian Milnes was present as substitute.
While Councillor Brian Milnes was also disappointed by the lack of proper cycleways, he said that there was a strong case for linking the hotel with the economic viability of the Imperial War Museum.
For Councillor Milnes, the hotel’s visual appearance was not an issue.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environmental Health and Licencing, believed they had been successful for all parties involved, with Councillor John Williams, Lead Cabinet Member for Finance, said the community involvement led to an improved project once completed.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environmental Services and Licencing, mentioned the change the project would bring to the villages to the district, bur was pleased with the response.
The Chief Executive thanked Councillors Grenville Chamberlain and Judith Rippeth, and to Councillor Brian Milnes who had been the previous Chair of this Committee, for their having provided a safe pair of hands in a non-political way, as this had significantly contributed to the operation and policy of the council.
Councillor Brian Milnes, local member for Sawston, reported that both he and the local member for Babraham, Councillor Peter McDonald, supported the change of the boundary proposed by Sawston Parish Council. It was noted that Babraham Parish Council also supported this proposed change.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environmental Services and Licencing, was pleased empty properties were being brought back into use through the company.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environment Services and Licensing, seconded the proposal. He said the question of interest rates would become more prominent, including the prospect of negative interest rates, and it was important to be aware of the potential impact.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environmental Services and Licensing said he too supported Councillor Ellington’s diligence. Any change to this anomalous situation would require a change in primary legislation which would be expensive, so the way forward which had been identified was appropriate.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environment and Licencing, thanked Officers for their work, and noted how the Three Free Trees scheme had helped encourage tree-planting across the district.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environmental Services and Licensing commented the Council was adding environmental, social and governance considerations to all future investments.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for Environmental Services and Licencing, confirmed there was no evidence of this within the district.
Councillor Brian Milnes expressed the hope that Cabinet had recognised the error in paragraph 42 of the report, which had a comma instead of a decimal point.
The Chair proposed and Councillor Brian Milnes seconded the recommendations in the agenda front sheet.
Councillor Brian Milnes stated that the Council would take delivery of an electric bin lorry later in the year and the plan was to replace the entire fleet over an eight year period.
Councillor Milnes stated that whilst it was disappointing that new diesel vehicles had to be purchased, these would be replaced with electric vehicles in time. He hoped whole fleet could be replaced with electric vehicles well within the eight year timescale.
Councillor Brian Milnes supported the motion, but wanted to commend the work of the Development Officer – Climate and Environment carried out 18 months ago in her report to Cabinet.
This will use material produced by OPSS [Office for Product Safety and Standards], in partnership with the RSPCA, and as published at https://www.gov.uk/guidance/consumer-safety-awareness-campaigns-materials under section “Fireworks campaign”.” Councillor Bunty Waters expressed her thanks to Councillor Brian Milnes for his interest in the issue and explained that she had agreed the amendments that he had suggested.
Councillor Brian Milnes thanked Councillor Waters for proposing this motion. Fireworks had the potential to disturb, domestic and farm animals, as well as vulnerable people.
She announced that Councillor Brian Milnes had been appointed as the Lead Cabinet Member for Environment Services and Licensing.
Ian Sollom replaced Councillor Brian Milnes as a member of Audit and Corporate Governance Committee.
Tumi Hawkins replaced Councillor Brian Milnes as a member of Planning Committee and Councillors Geoff Harvey and Brian Milnes were appointed as substitutes.
Councillor Grenville Chamberlain thanked Councillor Peter McDonald for his work on the Scrutiny and Overview Committee and Councillor Brian Milnes for his hard work as a reliable Vice Chair of the Committee. It was noted that the Scrutiny and Overview Committee would elect its replacement Vice Chair at its next meeting.
Cabinet received and noted a report from the Scrutiny and Overview Committee, presented by Councillor Brian Milnes, Vice-Chair, Scrutiny and Overview Committee, informing it about the discussions at, and recommendations from the Committee’s meeting held on 12March 2020, 14 May 2020 and 9 th June 2020.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Vice Chair of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee said that the committee supported the plan.
Councillor Brian Milnes and Councillor Anna Bradnam both suggested that this would help with community cohesion and allow local communities to engage with developers and key stakeholders .
Councillor Brian Milnes, Vice Chair of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee, reported on the support of the committee for the strategy and was pleased to note that the committee’s comments had been incorporated into the document.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Vice Chair of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee, noted the support of the committee for the strategy and highlighted certain comments raised by the committee during its consideration of the document.
Councillor Brian Milnes indicated support for the project, discussing its importance during this period of recovery.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Vice-Chair of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee, provided feedback on the comments expressed by the committee when it had considered the proposal.
Councillor Brian Milnes, the Vice Chair of Scrutiny and Overview Committee, reported on the comments made by the committee in respect of the proposed investment. It was noted that the report had been updated to reflect some of the questions raised by the committee.
Councillor Brian Milnes in relation to Minute 6 (S/0158/20/FL - Sawston (Former Spicers Site, Sawston Bypass)) declared a non-pecuniary interest as this application had provoked a significant amount of discussion in Sawston, for which parish he was one of the local Members. He was considering the matter afresh.
Councillor Brian Milnes proposed that Permitted Development Rights Class A (enlargement or improvement of, or alterations to, a house) and Class E (the provision of buildings and other development within the curtilage of a house) be withdrawn.
Although present, Councillor Brian Milnes had missed part of the debate because of technical issues. Therefore, ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Councillor Brian Milnes explained that he and his family from Sawston had visited the park for 14 years and he supported the proposed grant.
Attendance list An amendment to clarify that, in the absence of Councillor Pippa Heylings, Councillor Brian Milnes had been appointed as Vice-Chairman of the meeting.
The Committee appointed Councillor Brian Milnes as Vice-Chairman of the Committee for this meeting by affirmation.
Councillor Brian Milnes seconded this proposal.
Cabinet received and noted a report from Councillor Grenville Chamberlain, Chairman, Scrutiny and Overview Committee, and Councillor Brian Milnes, Vice-Chairman, Scrutiny and Overview Committee, informing it about the discussions at, and recommendations from the Committee’s meeting held on 13 February 2020.
Councillor Brian Milnes declared a pecuniary interest in item 12 Report of the Independent Remuneration Panel, as Vice Chairman of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee.
Councillor Brian Milnes declared a pecuniary interest in this item as the Vice-Chairman of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee. He did not participate in the debate and did not vote.
Councillor Bridget Smith, Leader of Council, reported that Councillor Brian Milnes had been appointed as the Council’s representative on the A505 Royston to Granta Park Strategic Growth and Transport Study Steering Group, replacing former Councillor Peter Topping.
Upon the proposal of Councillor Brian Milnes,, seconded by Councillor Peter Fane, the Committee unanimously agreed that all substantive votes at the current Planning Committee meeting should be recorded by name and / or number and name.
At the request of Councillor Brian Milnes, Councillor Neil Gough said that efforts would be made to incorporate standard deviations into future reports.
Councillor Brian Milnes (Vice-Chairman of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee) said that the Committee had welcomed this project as a means of both saving money and demonstrating a commitment to the aim of being ‘Green to our core’.
Councillor Milnes added that the project provided an opportunity to address the issue of the inconsistent spacing of streetlights in many South Cambridgeshire villages.
On behalf of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee, Councillor Brian Milnes (Vice-Chairman) thanked officers for their commitment to the Local Plan process. His principal concern surrounded the timescales involved in consultation. He wondered whether the availability of ‘pre-information’ might ease the process, especially for those Parish Councils not meeting on a monthly basis.
Councillor Brian Milnes (Vice-Chairman of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee) welcomed the amount of public engagement but recognised that it was unlikely that a solution could be found that would satisfy all the interested parties.
Upon the proposal of Councillor Brian Milnes, seconded by Councillor Dr.
However, on a point of information, Councillor Brian Milnes explained that the GCP had pledged to support the rail station as part of the development of the Alconbury Enterprise Zone.
Councillor Brian Milnes stated that youth engagement could not be imposed from the top, but needed a catalyst, such as Greta Thunberg, to get young people interested in politics.
Councillor Brian Milnes reported that the Scrutiny and Overview Committee already interpreted the Key Performance Information relevant to the Planning Department and Councillor Peter McDonald expressed surprise that such questions about the KPIs did not appear to have been raised at the Committee.
Councillor Brian Milnes questioned the value of the information being requested.
In response to a comment from Councillor Brian Milnes, the Deputy Head of Finance updated those present about progress being made in replacing the Council’s telephone system. The Interim Chief Executive added that the deployment of new equipment at South Cambridgeshire District Council would take place ahead of similar deployment at Huntingdonshire District Council and Cambridge City Council.
Councillor Brian Milnes pointed out that the introduction of Smart Motorways might be paused to allow certain issues to be resolved.
Councillor Brian Milnes highlighted the need for effective technical support.
Councillor Brian Milnes seconded the motion.
· Councillor Brian Milnes declared a non-pecuniary interest.
Noting the approximately 20-year history of the matter in question, Councillor Milnes said that, as a Sawston resident for much of that time, he had from time to time commented on factors concerning the Drying Shed prior to him becoming a South Cambridgeshire District Councillor. He was considering the matter afresh.
Upon the proposal of Councillor Heather Williams, seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes, the Committee unanimously agreed that all substantive votes at the current Planning Committee meeting should be recorded by name and / or number and name .
Noting the approximately 20-year history of the matter in question, Councillor Milnes declared a non-pecuniary interest because, as a Sawston resident for much of that time, he had from time to time commented on factors concerning the Drying Shed prior to him becoming a South Cambridgeshire District Councillor. He was considering the matter afresh.
In Councillor Heylings’ absence, the Committee by affirmation appointed Councillor Brian Milnes as Vice-Chairman for the meeting.
Upon the proposal of Councillor Brian Milnes, seconded by Councillor Dr.
Councillor Bill Handley proposed, seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes, that the meeting move to a vote.
In Councillor Heylings’ absence, the Committee agreed by affirmation that Councillor Brian Milnes be appointed Vice-Chairman for this meeting.
Upon the proposal of Councillor Brian Milnes, seconded by Councillor Dr.
The report referred to · Bourn Airfield Supplementary Planning Document · Strategic Risk Register · 2018-19 Quarter 4 Performance Report · Scrutiny ICT Working Group Update In connection with the ongoing issues with ICT, Councillor Brian Milnes (Vice-Chairman, Scrutiny and Overview Committee) reported that he had met with the new Head of 3C ICT and discussed the preparation of a ‘priorities report’. He anticipated that this would be presented to, and discussed at, the Scrutiny and Overview Committee meeting in July 2019. Cabinet recalled that the Local Government Association would be providing five days support, and the intention was that the Head of 3C ICT would be engaged so that South Cambridgeshire District Council could get best value from that support. 3C ICT operational issues were ongoing, most recently due to problems (not revealed in testing) in the roll out of Council Anywhere in the Planning Department. 3C ICT staff were doing their utmost to resolve these issues in what remained a fragile ICT environment.
Councillor Brian Milnes seconded the motion.
Councillor Brian Milnes (Vice-Chairman, Scrutiny and Overview Committee) attended the meeting. He delivered to the Cabinet a brief verbal update on the Scrutiny and Overview Committee’s further views about the 3C ICT Shared Service, and reported on Members’ continuing concerns about such matters as the lack of transparency, the need to review several processes (including Terms of Reference), ineffective governance, and the absence of an exit strategy.
The Scrutiny and Overview Committee had supported the proposal, and Councillor Brian Milnes, Vice-Chairman of that Committee, was pleased to note that concern at the possible impact on the District’s housing waiting list had been described as minimal.
Councillor Brian Milnes highlighted the challenges in controlling parking in a rural district.
Councillor Brian Milnes left the Chamber during the debate and also did not vote.
He summarised the latest observations by he ICT Task and Finish Group about 3C ICT, In particular, he reported · Disappointment with the level of access to requested documentation · frustration with the apparent lack of an effective management structure · concern about business continuity · the apparent ineffectiveness of partnership working · discussion about the Exit Strategy · concern at the lack of clarity about the ownership of new equipment · comments about the Business Plan Councillor Milnes said that the Chief Executive Officers of South Cambridgeshire District Council, Huntingdonshire District Council and Cambridge City Council had been invited to attend the next meeting of South Cambridgeshire District Council’s Scrutiny and Overview Committee.
The Scrutiny and Overview Committee had expressed satisfaction with the recommendations, although Councillor Brian Milnes (Vice-Chairman, Scrutiny and Overview Committee) remained frustrated that the constraints of local government prevented South Cambridgeshire District Council from doing more to help the situation.
Hawkins proposed and Councillor Brian Milnes seconded this recommendation.
Councillor Brian Milnes seconded the motion.
above being agreed by officers in consultation with the Chairman of the Planning and Vice-Chairman for this item (Councillor Brian Milnes) prior to the issue of a Decision Notice.
(Reason - In the interest of highway safety in accordance with Policy HQ/1 of the adopted South Cambridgeshire Local Plan 2018) 2. the final wording or amendment of Conditions and Informatives referred to in 1. above being agreed by officers in consultation with the Chairman of the Planning Committee and Vice-Chairman for this item (Councillor Brian Milnes) prior to the issue of a Decision Notice.
The Scrutiny and Overview Committee meeting on 22 January 2019 had been chaired by the Vice-Chairman Councillor Brian Milnes.
Councillor Milnes summarised the Committee’s consideration of the Waterbeach Supplementary Planning Document, Budget, and the recent ICT outage.
Speaking as a member of the Planning Committee, Councillor Milnes said it would be essential to prevent development of the new town from becoming disjointed. The Joint Director of Planning and Economic Development set out the mechanisms available through the SPD and the planning process generally to secure comprehensive development.
Councillor Brian Milnes (Vice-Chairman, Scrutiny and Overview Committee) said that the recent ICT outage had been of grave concern to the Committee. Members were grateful for the positive way in which officers had responded to that concern. The Committee was of the view that an ICT Shared Service Security Policy was long overdue, and had established a Scrutiny Task and Finish Group to examine ways of improving system resilience.
Councillor Brian Milnes (Vice-Chairman, Scrutiny and Overview Committee) said that the Committee had identified, as significant, the issues of transport (including car-free areas), infrastructure, permeability through the site, and capacity at Cambridge North railway station.
· The Vice Chairman would summarise his findings and provide these to the relevant directors; and · A sub-group (Councillor Brian Milnes and Sarah Cheung Johnson) would look into the ICT issues in consultation with the Lead Cabinet Member.
Councillor Brian Milnes (Vice-Chairman of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee) made the following points:
Councillor Grenville Chamberlain, the Chairman of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee, moved the recommendations of the Committee, which were seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes.
An amendment to include an additional caveat in respect of the extension of the loan facility was proposed by Councillor Tumi Hawkins and seconded by Councillor Brian Milnes.
Councillor Milnes reiterated his concern about the timeliness of submitting papers for consideration by Committee members. The Leader responded by saying she was aware of the challenges faced and was hopeful that some positive action could be taken to address this issue.
Councillor Brian Milnes, Vice-Chairman of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee, said that that Committee had discussed home and community composting as a means of reducing the need for a second green bin.
Councillor Brian Milnes (Vice-Chairman, Scrutiny and Overview Committee) highlighted the potential impart on the long-term strategy, and of Universal Credit.
In the absence of Councillor Grenville Chamberlain (Chairman of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee), Councillor Brian Milnes (Vice-Chairman) attended the Cabinet meeting by invitation.
Councillor Milnes summarised the Scrutiny and Overview Committee’s revised work programme for the next four months. He observed that, while the Authority had now adopted a pre-Scrutiny process, there remained a need to refer to documents issued, and decisions made, prior to that move. He said that Scrutiny and Overview Committee members needed as much notice as possible of issues to be considered by Cabinet.
The Forward Plan could be more dynamic and informative and, following discussion with Democratic Services Officers, Councillor Milnes said that the Committee’s workload would be addressed through the establishment, when appropriate, of Member-led Task and Finish Groups.
Councillor Philippa Hart engaged with Councillor Milnes in a brief discussion about his aspirations for the Forward Plan and undertook to find out what could be done to improve the situation.
Councillor Brian Milnes outlined the observations made by members of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee, and Councillor Anna Bradnam reminded those present about the report on this same topic in August 2017. The Deputy Leader said that any relevant aspect of the 2017 report would be incorporated into the new submission.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Milnes attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Milnes's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Milnes was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
South Cambridgeshire has not published attendance for Councillor Milnes's meetings yet.
What Councillor Milnes declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 24 Nov 2022 | Council, item 2 | Councillor Brian Milnes declared an interest in the same item as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Executive Board. | |
| 11 Jul 2022 | Cabinet, item 3 | Councillor Brian Milnes, Lead Cabinet Member for the Environment, declared an interest in item 7, Lynton Way, Sawston, as a Member of Sawston Parish Council. | |
| 20 Feb 2020 | Council, item 2 | Councillor Brian Milnes declared a pecuniary interest in item 12 Report of the Independent Remuneration Panel, as Vice Chairman of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee. | |
| 20 Feb 2020 | Council, item 12 | Councillor Brian Milnes declared a pecuniary interest in this item as the Vice-Chairman of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee. He did not participate in the debate and did not vote. | Took no part |
| 10 Jul 2019 | Planning Committee, item 2 | · Councillor Brian Milnes declared a non-pecuniary interest. | |
| 10 Jul 2019 | Planning Committee, item 6 | Noting the approximately 20-year history of the matter in question, Councillor Milnes declared a non-pecuniary interest because, as a Sawston resident for much of that time, he had from time to time commented on factors concerning the Drying Shed prior to him becoming a South Cambridgeshire District Councillor. He was considering the matter afresh. |
Where Councillor Milnes sits, from the attendance records.
No committee attendance recorded for Councillor Milnes yet.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.