Chair's Announcements
Councillor Geoff Harvey, Chair of the Committee welcomed Members, Officers and members of the public to the meeting.
Every time South Cambridgeshire's minutes name Councillor Harvey, as the council published it.
Councillor Geoff Harvey, Chair of the Committee welcomed Members, Officers and members of the public to the meeting.
Suggestion was made to clarify within the Annual Report that Councillor Harvey had been a member of the committee earlier in the year, but no longer was.
Appointed Councillor Geoff Harvey as Chair of the Climate and Environment Advisory Committee.
With the vacancy in the Chair, Councillor Geoff Harvey assumed the role of Chair for the meeting.
The Committee was informed that it was to be proposed to Council that Councillor Harvey be appointed as Chair of the Committee for future meetings.
Councillor Geoff Harvey joined the Committee representing the Climate and Environment Advisory Committee in his role as Vice-Chair of the Committee.
Councillor Geoff Harvey assumed the role of Chair for the meeting and advised that the usual Chair, Councillor Pippa Heylings, was unable to attend the meeting as she was attending COP28. Prior to receiving apologies, the Chair invited the Project Officer (Climate and Environment), Orla Gibbons, to provide an update on the Local Climate Action Conference 2023 which the Council had hosted on 28 November 2023. Members thanked the Project Officer for the update and requested that a summary of the event be produced and published by the Council.
With respect to Minutes 7 & 8, Councillor Geoff Harvey declared that he was a resident of Great Abington but was coming to the matter afresh.
The Committee agreed, by affirmation, to the appointment of Councillor Geoff Harvey as Vice-Chair for the duration of the item.
With respect to Minutes 6 & 7, Councillor Geoff Harvey declared that he was a resident of Great Abington and thus would take part in the debate but not vote on the applications.
Councillor Geoff Harvey left the meeting In response to Member questions, officers provided clarity on the following considerations:
Councillor Geoff Harvey welcomed the availability to Members of Leadership Team emergency telephone numbers.
Councillor Geoff Harvey requested that Internal Audit investigate ways of monitoring the effectiveness of e-mail communication between members of the public and Council officers.
Councillor Henry Batchelor proposed and Councillor Bridget Smith seconded that Councillor Peter Fane be elected as Chair of Planning Committee, Councillor Geoff Harvey as Vice Chair and Councillor Sunita Hansraj be appointed as Substitute Member of the Adults and Health Committee. A vote was taken and Council unanimously Agreed to endorse the following appointments:
B) The election of Councillor Geoff Harvey as Vice Chair of the Planning Committee C) The appointment of Councillor Sunita Hansraj as Substitute Member of the Adults and Health Committee to fill the vacancy arising from the resignation of Alex Malyon.
Councillor Geoff Harvey praised the work of officers and volunteers in the production of the Plan which was over 90 pages long and would complement the Local Plan. He praised parish councillor David Sargeant for his monthly updates.
Councillor Dr Tumi Hawkins proposed and Councillor Geoff Harvey seconded the recommendations in the report. A vote was taken and by affirmation Council A) Notes that the referendum for the West Wickham Neighbourhood Plan took place on 11 August 2022, B) As it was a successful referendum ‘makes’ (adopts) the (The made version of the plan is Appendix 1 of this report).
Councillor Geoff Harvey seconded this motion. He stated that the Environment Agency had been very critical of Anglian Water and the CEO of this organisation was in denial of the facts. The storm overflow drains were no longer fit for purpose and greater regulation was required.
Councillor Pippa Heylings proposed and Councillor Geoff Harvey seconded the amended motion. A vote was taken and by affirmation Council agreed the following motion:
With respect to Minute 5 (21/03822/FUL – Granta Park), Councillor Geoff Harvey declared that he lived in Abington but had not held any discussion regarding the application and was coming to the matter afresh.
Councillor Geoff Harvey supported the need for additional staff and Councillor Mark Howell’s suggestion that the work of the Team be publicised.
In respect of Minute 6, Councillor Geoff Harvey declared a non-pecuniary interest as he lived in Great Abington and had some informal discussions regarding the application but would be coming to the matter afresh.
· Councillor Geoff Harvey declared a non-pecuniary interest and stated that, as Member for the Balsham ward, he had been present at Parish Council meetings in which Item 5 was discussed.
Councillor Harvey informed the Committee that he would be approaching the matter afresh.
The Member for Balsham, Councillor Geoff Harvey, enquired if there had been any progress towards the organisation of a joint visit to the Cottage Nursery, Cardinals Green, Horseheath site as it was part of his Ward. The Delivery Manager was unable to answer the question at the meeting but stated that he would seek an answer from the Principal Enforcement Officer and provide the information to the Member.
Councillor Anna Bradnam substituted for Councillor Geoff Harvey.
Councillor Geoff Harvey sent apologies for absence and Councillor Dr. Claire Daunton was his substitute.
Councillor Geoff Harvey proposed and Councillor Pippa Heylings seconded the following motion:
Where appropriate officers will seek the advice of the Council’s sustainability officer in addition to experts in conservation to contribute to the assessment exercise.” Councillor Geoff Harvey explained that this motion was about conservation and heritage, set in the wider context of planning law. He asked Council to support this motion which would balance the needs to protect the historic buildings with the need to address climate change.
Councillor Geoff Harvey stated that Policy GP/CC (Adapting heritage assets to climate change), should not be less enabling for owners of Listed Buildings than the current policy.
Improving efficiency of domestic heating Councillor Geoff Harvey suggested that air quality could be greatly improved by replacing inefficient home heating systems. The Chair suggested that Building Control be contacted about this matter.
Minute 5 - S/2896/19/FL - Duxford (Imperial War Museum, Royston Road) Replace the paragraph beginning “For Councillor Geoff Harvey…” with “ For Councillor Geoff Harvey, the benefit to tourism and leisure was significant. He said that the design of the hotel should protect future residents of it from noise from the airfield.” At the end of that minute, “…in favore …” should be “…in favour…”
Councillor Geoff Harvey was in attendance remotely as a substitute.
For Councillor Geoff Harvey, the benefit to tourism and leisure was significant. He had some concern about additional noise but accepted this would primarily be background noise.
Councillor Geoff Harvey declared a non-pecuniary interest in Minute 10 (20/02593/OUT - Weston Colville (Garage Plot to North of 14 Horseshoes Lane)); As the local Member for Balsham Ward, he had been involved in discussions with Weston Colville Parish Council about this application but was considering the matter afresh.
Councillor Geoff Harvey agreed with Tumi Hawkins that the applicant had explained why the location had chosen and he agreed with Councillor Peter Fane that the application met the “very special circumstances” that would permit building on the green belt.
Councillor Geoff Harvey offered to serve on this Group.
Councillor Geoff Harvey moved a motion as follows:
We note from the Investment Strategy Statement of the Cambridgeshire County Council Pension Fund, ‘ The Fund supports the principles of the [Financial Reporting Council] UK Stewardship Code and is working with the Fund’s advisers with the intention to sign up to the Code.’” Councillor Geoff Harvey said Trinity College and ... view the full minutes text for item 17.
Councillor Ian Sollom was a substitute for Councillor Harvey.
Councillor Geoff Harvey proposed the following motion:
- requests the Leader and Chief Executive to raise the matter of timely consideration of energy infrastructure for the Ox-Cam Arc, within its political and governmental structures, as they deem appropriate.” Councillor Geoff Harvey stated that the development proposed in the Ox-Cam Arc needed to focus more on the provision of sustainable energy and he hoped that Council would agree that this authority ... view the full minutes text for item 13b
There was insufficient time for Councillor Harvey to ask a supplementary question.
Councillor Geoff Harvey proposed the following motion:
“This Council - resolves to support the Bill, - authorises the Leader to contact our MPs to discuss their support for the Bill and how they can enable its passage into law - authorises the Chief Executive to write to the Minister of State for Business Energy and Industrial Strategy, supporting the aims of the Bill and asking for these aims to be taken into account in the forthcoming Energy White Paper.” Councillor Geoff Harvey explained that it was very difficult for community energy companies to be established, due to the one-off set-up costs. He urged Council to support this motion to contact our local MPs and the Minister to support the Private Members Bill.
Councillor Geoff Harvey acted as substitute.
Councillor Harvey abstained.)
· Councillor Claire Daunton · Councillor Geoff Harvey · Councillor Richard Williams Input from other members would be welcomed and Councillor Anna Bradnam also indicated that she would be willing to be a reserve member of the group if further input was required.
Councillor Geoff Harvey reported that the Climate and Environment Advisory Committee had benefited from a great depth of knowledge and cross-party co-operation.
Councillor Pippa Heylings proposed and Councillor Geoff Harvey seconded the new terms of reference of the Climate and Environment Advisory Committee.
Councillor Geoff Harvey thanked officers for their work in producing the Plan and delivering on it. He asserted that by making South Cambs Hall more energy efficient provided an exemplar for other organisations in the District.
Councillor Geoff Harvey moved the following motion, as set out in the agenda:
In the absence of Councillor Geoff Harvey, Councillor Peter Fane moved the following motion, as set out in the agenda:- “Onshore wind is the cheapest new source of energy in the UK today - and the UK is the windiest country in Europe. New government policy is now needed to realise these benefits. Onshore wind can play a key role in an ambitious industrial strategy delivering clean, cheap and smart energy.
The Chairman reported that Councillor Harvey wished to withdraw his question as the issue raised would be addressed via the developing climate change action plan.
Councillor Harvey asked whether the Council’s website could be updated to provide prominent guidance to EU nationals on the EU settlement scheme, noting that Cambridgeshire County Council’s website contained such information. The Leader undertook to arrange for the website to be updated accordingly.
Renewable Energy Councillor Geoff Harvey suggested that the planned photo voltaic array would only deliver a small amount of the settlement’s energy needs. The developers explained that a number of different renewable energy sources were being considered and the wishes of prospective home owners would also determine how energy was provided on the site. The Committee expressed the hope that the development would deliver far more than the minimum of 10% of its energy needs from renewable sources.
Councillor Sue Ellington was present as a substitute for Councillor Betson and Councillor Geoff Harvey was present as a substitute for Councillor Cheung Johnson.
Councillor Geoff Harvey was present as a substitute for Councillor Bradnam, Councillor Sue Ellington was present as a substitute for Councillor Chamberlain, and Councillor Nigel Cathcart was present as a substitute for Councillor Clayton.
Councillor Geoff Harvey, Chairman of the Brexit Advisory Group, was in attendance for this item.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Harvey attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Harvey's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Harvey was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
South Cambridgeshire has not published attendance for Councillor Harvey's meetings yet.
What Councillor Harvey declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8 Nov 2023 | Planning Committee, item 3 | With respect to Minutes 7 & 8, Councillor Geoff Harvey declared that he was a resident of Great Abington but was coming to the matter afresh. | |
| 11 Oct 2023 | Planning Committee, item 3 | With respect to Minutes 6 & 7, Councillor Geoff Harvey declared that he was a resident of Great Abington and thus would take part in the debate but not vote on the applications. | |
| 16 Jun 2022 | Planning Committee, item 3 | With respect to Minute 5 (21/03822/FUL – Granta Park), Councillor Geoff Harvey declared that he lived in Abington but had not held any discussion regarding the application and was coming to the matter afresh. | |
| 9 Feb 2022 | Planning Committee, item 3 | In respect of Minute 6, Councillor Geoff Harvey declared a non-pecuniary interest as he lived in Great Abington and had some informal discussions regarding the application but would be coming to the matter afresh. | |
| 8 Dec 2021 | Planning Committee, item 3 | · Councillor Geoff Harvey declared a non-pecuniary interest and stated that, as Member for the Balsham ward, he had been present at Parish Council meetings in which Item 5 was discussed. | |
| 26 May 2021 | Planning Committee, item 3 | Councillor Geoff Harvey declared a non-pecuniary interest in Minute 10 (20/02593/OUT - Weston Colville (Garage Plot to North of 14 Horseshoes Lane)); As the local Member for Balsham Ward, he had been involved in discussions with Weston Colville Parish Council about this application but was considering the matter afresh. |
Where Councillor Harvey sits, from the attendance records.
No committee attendance recorded for Councillor Harvey yet.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.