Appointment of Chair
Councillor Anna Bradnam proposed, and Councillor Heather Williams seconded the appointment of Councillor Katie Thornburrow as Chair of the Joint Planning Advisory Group (JPAG). This was approved unanimously.
Every time South Cambridgeshire's minutes name Councillor Williams, as the council published it.
Councillor Anna Bradnam proposed, and Councillor Heather Williams seconded the appointment of Councillor Katie Thornburrow as Chair of the Joint Planning Advisory Group (JPAG). This was approved unanimously.
Councillor Heather Williams proposed, and Councillor Katie Thornburrow seconded an amendment to the JPAG standing orders to include a paragraph on voting as follows:
Councillor Simon Smith proposed, and Councillor Heather Williams seconded the appointment of Tumi Hawkins as Vice-Chair of JPAG.
· Councillor Heather Williams queried whether the types of calls coming into the call centre, for example by service area or issue/subject matter, were being monitored and whether this could be shared with Members. The Lead Cabinet Member for Resources indicated that this level of data was available and that he would give some thought on how to communicate this out to Members.
· Given that the Council’s housing stock was increasing, a further query was raised by Councillor Heather Williams on whether any thought had been given to staffing ratios per house within the housing team as this appeared to be placing additional demands upon the service. The Head of Housing acknowledged the changing world the Council was operating in and reported that there were a multitude of other factors to consider such as the implications of the right to buy scheme, responding and supporting tenants with additional needs (for e.g. social care), meeting the increasing expectations from tenants as well as the requirements from the housing regulator on matters such as compliance. He further commented that there was a need to ensure the relevant skills set were available within the team.
It was agreed that the matter would be picked up with Councillor Heather Williams outside of the meeting.
Councillor Heather Williams suggested that reference should be made to Local Government Reorganisation within the consultation document to enable members of the public to be aware that the Council would strive to achieve targets that were directly within its control.
A further suggestion was made by Councillor Heather Williams to differentiate between local and national policy within Figure 5 – South Cambridgeshire District Council timeline of achievements and targets 2015 – 2050.
The Cabinet were encouraged by Councillor Heather Williams to consider those submitting responses on behalf of local groups, for example Parish Councils, whom were often reliant on volunteers to complete and submit responses. Comment was made that the Council should work with these groups to make it easier for them to respond to the consultation.
Item 4 (25/00054/REM) – Councillor Heather Williams declared an interest in this application being a member of South Cambs District Council and believed the evidence discussed during the consideration of the application suggested that the council had a significant interest in the application.
The interest did not fall within the definition of a ‘Regulation 3’ application Item 6 (24/04191/OUT) – Councillor Heather Williams was contacted about the application, and she advised that she could not discuss the application with them.
Item 8 (Appeals against Planning Decisions and Enforcement Action) – Councillor Heather Williams noted there were appeals in her ward and she had had discussions with officers about them but noted the agenda item was for noting.
Councillor Heather Williams declared, in relation to agenda item 13 ‘Greater Cambridge Partnership’, that she was a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Assembly.
Councillor Heather Williams asked her question, as set out in the agenda.
As a supplementary question, Councillor Heather Williams asked whether the administration regrated attending a protest march and opposing the introduction of the Cambourne to Cambridge busway.
The motion was seconded by Councillor Heather Williams, who reserved her right to speak until later in the debate.
As seconder of the motion, Councillor Heather Williams advised that the motion wording had been kept to a minimum in order to avoid any financial implications.
Councillor Heather Williams moved her motion and, in so doing emphasised the significance of the equestrian community. It was felt to be important to ensure that supporting one group within the district did not negatively impact another. It was further noted that, particularly in rural and isolated areas, pony clubs could be vital for a sense of community and improving mental health.
Councillor Heather Williams, as mover of the original recommendation, advised that she accepted the amendment.
As mover of the original motion, Councillor Heather Williams summed up and, in so doing, suggested that the relationship between the Greater Cambridge Partnership and the local horse riders association could be more inclusive.
Councillor Heather Williams declared an Other Registerable Interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly.
Councillor Peter Fane and Councillor Heather Williams sent apologies and Councillor Corinne Garvie and Councillor Sue Ellington attended as substitutes.
Councillor Heather Williams made her annual statement as the Leader of the Opposition. The statement is attached in full at Appendix A to the minutes.
Councillor Heather Williams declared, for the sake of transparency, that she had sat on the Local Government Association roundtable when this issue was discussed.
Councillor Heather Williams declared an Other Registerable Interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly.
Councillor Heather Williams asked that the document be edited slightly to clarify the role of the Employment & Staffing Committee in the recruitment of senior officers, and the name change of the Government department to the Ministry for Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG).
Councillor Heather Williams sought clarification about the so-called ‘Star Chamber’ that was referred to.
Replying to Councillor Heather Williams, Andy Cardoza considered South Cambridgeshire District Council to be in a healthy financial position to play a key role in future negotiations about local government reorganisation.
Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000 Councillor Heather Williams asked that a RIPA update be provided at the Audit & Corporate Governance Committee meeting on 20 March 2025.
Councillor Heather Williams declared an interest in item 5 (Planning Committee Review – Scheme of Delegation) by virtue of being a member of the Civic Affairs Committee which would give further consideration to these matters at a later meeting but would remain in the meeting for the duration and voting on the item.
Councillor Heather Williams declared an interest as being the applicant for the provisional tree preservation order at item 6 on the agenda.
Councillor Heather Williams indicated that she had heard locally about proposals under item 8 at Guilden Morden but indicated that she proposed to remain in the meeting for the duration of voting on the item Councillor Tumi Hawkins stated that she had attended public meetings at the village hall in relation to item 7 (Branch Road, Comberton) on the agenda but that she had not indicated any view at those meetings and had remained of an open mind and would remain in the meeting during the discussion and voting on that item.
Councillor Heather Williams expressed the view that members ability to call in applications should be clearly set out as her view was that the propose scheme read as if it were taking local members voices out of consideration. Officers indicated that guidance could be issued about call-in without jeopardising the time frame of the review and its implementation.
Councillor H Williams withdrew from the membership of the committee for this item and addressed the committee as applicant The committee considered a report of the Joint Director of Planning and Economic Development regarding a request for a provisional tree preservation order at Coton Orchard, Cambridge Road, Coton. The request for a tree preservation order had been made by the same person who had previously made an application which had been declined under delegated powers in November 2024. The members had before them that original report and a further report from 17 December 2024 which had reached the same recommendation.
Additionally the committee heard from Councillor Heather Williams as the applicant.
Councillor H Williams rejoined the committee for the remaining items of business.
Councillor H Williams asked a question of the applicant why they believed that the council no longer had a five year land supply. [name removed] stated that they had submitted a letter to the council in the previous week sitting out why they had taken this view.
By seven votes for, one vote against (Councillor H Williams), the Committee approved the application in accordance with the officer’s unconditional recommendation and associated informatives with the inclusion of informatives about the public right of way and expansion of commentary on highways requirements.
Councillor Heather Williams left the meeting at 1:03 PM and did not return for the remaining business on the agenda.
Councillor Heather Williams declared an Other Registerable Interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly.
It was suggested that information in relation to staff sickness that had been provided to Employment and Staffing Committee could be provided to Councillor Heather Williams.
Councillor Heather Williams declared, in relation to agenda item 7(a) ‘Council Tax Charges for Long Term Empty Properties and Second Homes’ and 14(b) Motion ‘Standing in the name of Councillor Heather Williams’, that she had a non-registrable interest, which didn’t affect her views.
Councillor Heather Williams further declared, in relation to agenda item 10 ‘Greater Cambridge Partnership’, that she was a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Assembly.
Councillor Heather Williams asked her question, as set out in the agenda.
As a supplementary question, Councillor Heather Williams asked whether there would be a question in the four-day week consultation on whether residents were happy to fund the four-day week.
Councillor Heather Williams moved her motion and, in so doing, advised that the life of a farmer was a hard one, working both physically and emotionally in isolation, with a suicide rate higher than the general population.
Councillor Heather Williams advised that she did not accept the amendment, as she felt it negated the motion.
Councillor Heather Williams, ... view the full minutes text for item 74.
Councillor Heather Williams moved a proposal to extend the meeting, which was seconded by Councillor Milnes. The Council (unanimously) agreed for the meeting to extend beyond four hours.
An amendment to the motion was moved by Councillor Heather Williams as follows:
That government must support residents to meet targets as soon as possible without inflicting unreasonable increased financial pressure on them.” As mover of the amendment, Councillor Heather Williams advised that it was difficult to get buy-in from residents if they were suffering financially for home adaptations.
The Council voted (6 voting in favour, 16 voting against, 2 abstaining from voting) on an amendment submitted by Councillor Heather Williams, which was defeated.
Councillor Heather Williams, in relation agenda item 10 ‘Greater Cambridge Partnership’, declared that she was a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Assembly.
Councillor Heather Williams asked her question, as set out in the agenda.
As a supplementary question, Councillor Heather Williams asked whether process changes had been provided to analysers, so that they could determine whether changes were due to process changes or the four-day week.
The motion was seconded by Councillor Heather Williams, who reserved her right to speak until later in the debate.
Councillor Heather Williams, moved her motion and, in so doing advised that BOG STANDARD was about trying to give those who had gone through prostate cancer dignity by having sanitary provision in public toilets and to promote men’s health through encouraging blood testing. It was noted that 78% of men who’d had prostate cancer felt anxious about sanitary provision when leaving home.
As mover of the motion, Councillor Heather Williams, summed up the debate and noted that, as a public body, the Council should be encouraging all action possible for people to feel confident leaving the house.
The amendment was seconded by Councillor Heather Williams, who reserved her right to speak until later in the debate.
As seconder of the amendment, Councillor Heather Williams advised that the intention of the amendment was to look forward and be positive, as cancer affected everyone equally.
Later in the meeting, Councillor Heather Williams congratulated the three new MPs on their election and wished them well in their new roles. She thanked the former MPs Anthony Browne and Lucy Frazer for their service and expressed concern regarding the increase in threats to those working on election campaigns. She reiterated her support for the Local Government Association’s Debate Not Hate campaign.
Councillor Heather Williams asked what the Leader was doing to ensure that residents’ views were acted upon regarding the Kingsway Solar Farm at West Wratting. The Leader replied that a relaxing of planning laws had been announced in the King’s speech and the Council waited for the Government to clarify what this would mean in practice.
Councillor Heather Williams suggested that as this was a political matter, the letter resulting from any agreed motion should be sent by the Leader, not the Chief Executive. The Chair suggested that the motion should be amended to state that either the Chief Executive or the Leader should write to the Secretary of State.
Councillor Heather Williams stated that disabled people suffer from discrimination every day and she supported this motion.
Councillor Heather Williams agreed that the Government should tackle child poverty but was not going to support the motion as she calculated that nearly £500m of Child Tax Credit was already going to families who were not in poverty. She concluded that there were better ways to tackle child poverty than abolishing the two child benefit cap.
Councillor Heather Williams declared an Other Registerable Interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly.
Councillor Heather Williams expressed concern that fees had been increased whilst the delay in the audit had been substantial. The Head of Finance reported that he had discussed the fees with EY and was satisfied with the process, which was subject to the decision made by the PSAA.
With respect to Minute 9, Councillor Heather Williams declared that an application listed in the report was in her ward, but she had held no discussions regarding the application.
Councillor Dr Richard Williams joined the meeting The Chair, seconded by Councillor Heather Williams, proposed that the Committee move to the decision. The Committee agreed to the proposal by affirmation.
Councillor Heather Williams sent apologies for lateness.
Councillor Heather Williams declared that she was a member of the GCP Assembly.
Councillor Heather Williams joined the meeting Members discussed the report and asked officers a number of questions. With regards to the delivery of Biodiversity Net Gain (BNG) measures off-site, officers advised that sites where delivery could take place were not designated by the Local Planning Authority; instead, sites would come forward from private initiatives and secured through Section 106 (S106) agreements or conservation covenants. Officers informed the Committee that the hope was that a range of different types of habitat banks would come forward within the region to allow for the delivery of BNG measures and maximise their impact.
Councillor Anna Bradnam, seconded by Councillor Heather Williams, proposed that the Committee move to the decision and the Committee agreed by affirmation.
During Minute 6, Councillor Heather Williams declared that she was a member of the Great Cambridge Partnership (GCP) Assembly when the GCP development of the Horningsea Greenway was discussed.
The Minutes of the meeting held on 17 January 2024 were amended the reflect that Councillor Heather Williams left the meeting at the start of Minute 7 (Gamlingay) and at the start of Minute 9 (TPO, Shepreth . With the amendments, the Committee authorised the Chair to sign the Minutes of the meeting held on 17 January 2024 as a correct record.
Councillor Heather Williams and Councillor Paul Bearpark declared an Other Registerable Interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly.
Councillor Heather Williams expressed concern that the amount of savings identified this year was less than last year, which was increasing the budget gap and unlike Huntingdonshire District Council, this authority had not made provision for the financial impact of the MRF contract.
Councillor Heather Williams stated that the figure of £2m savings from the Transformation Programme needed to be corrected so that it was consistent with the figure of £1.6m in the Medium Term Financial Strategy. It was agreed that the Chief Executive should be authorised to make these two factual amendments to the Plan.
Councillor Heather Williams asked if the mystery shopper exercise could be extended to other departments and not just focus on the contact centre. She also suggested that e-mails should be monitored as the Council was receiving far more e-mails than it was sending out, which indicated that some e-mails were not being answered.
Councillor Heather Williams asked what steps would be taken to ensure the safety of officers and councillors with regards to the renting out of office space.
Councillor Heather Williams expressed concern regarding short-term loans and the proposed increase of the authorised debt limit.
Councillor Heather Williams asked about the associated risks with short term and long term borrowing and whether the Council would borrow on a variable or fixed interest rate. She expressed her opposition to the proposed increase in external borrowing.
Councillor Heather Williams expressed concern about the amount of money in the Transformation Reserve and how those funds were being spent.
Councillor Heather Williams expressed her support for Ermine Street Housing and its work.
Councillor Heather Williams stated that whilst her Group did support some of the individual projects described in the report they did not support the SCIP proposal, which did not benefit Cambourne residents and did not have the support of the Cambourne Secondary School.
Councillor Heather Williams proposed and Councillor Graham Cone seconded an amendment to the budget, as laid on page 225 of the agenda.
Councillor Heather Williams explained that the amendment proposed changes to the Budget that her Group disagreed with, whilst maintaining the parts the Group supported. She asserted that due to the cost-of-living crisis the Council should not be increasing its Council Tax. The Contact Centre and Planning Enforcement required more resources, as did tackling isolation and the amendment made provision for this.
Councillor Heather Williams explained that whilst her Group supported the new build in the capital programme, they could not support the increase in rent.
Councillor Heather Williams explained that her Group opposed the increase for reasons already stated earlier in the meeting.
Councillor Heather Williams expressed concern regarding the long-term sustainability of having a polling station at someone’s home in Tadlow.
Councillor Heather Williams suggested that the Council should have a policy on its pay ratio and the four-day week trial should have been referred to in the report. She asserted that the Council should aim to have no gender pay gap and instead there should be a guarantee that the best person for the job was being employed.
Councillor Heather Williams read out a statement from Councillor Ellington justifying the recommendation.
Councillor Henry Batchelor proposed and Councillor Heather Williams seconded the recommendation in the report. A vote was taken and by affirmation Council Agreed to retain the level of the Swavesey Bye-ways rate at £1.20 per hectare for land within the charge paying area for the period 2024/25 in order to fund the required level of maintenance.
Councillor Heather Williams opposed an increase in allowances whilst residents were going through a cost-of-living crisis.
Councillor Heather Williams requested that the provisional dates for meetings of Council for March and April 2025 be retained.
Councillor Heather Williams expressed concern on reports of bullying at the as safety of officers and councillors was of paramount importance. She asked if any members of this authority had seen the full report, when only the redacted version had been made public.
Councillor Heather Williams requested that future reports contain more information on this project.
Councillor Heather Williams replied that this would prevent councillors from asking supplementary questions, if they so wished.
Councillor Heather Williams asked if the length of wait before the Council made a decision on this important matter was acceptable.
Councillor Heather Williams supported the motion, but expressed concern at the amendment, which amounted to a complete rewrite of the motion and this risked setting a dangerous precedent regarding the actions of the ruling Group. She suggested that the letter should be sent by either the Chief Executive or Chair of Council instead of the Leader.
Councillor Heather Williams stated that period poverty was an important issue, as the cost of a single sanitary towel was expensive and the correct change was required for using a vending machine. Pain medication also needed to be made available.
Councillor Heather Williams thanked councillors for their support. She explained that period poverty not only affected young women, but also women who had just given birth and women going through the menopause, as their periods could be harder to predict.
Councillor Heather Williams proposed and Councillor Graham Cone seconded the motion. A vote was taken and Council unanimously agreed the following motion:
Councillor Heather Williams supported the motion to assist those who had grown up in care, as it was important that regardless of the start a person had in life, they should be given every opportunity to become the best they could be.
Councillor Heather Williams declared an Other Registerable Interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly.
Councillor Heather Williams made the following points:
Councillor Heather Williams suggested that EY were contractually obliged to audit the Council’s accounts.
Councillor Heather Williams declared that she was a Member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership (GCP) Assembly, with the GCP being referenced in the report, but had not been part of any discussions regarding the application.
Councillor Heather Williams rejoined the Committee.
Councillor Heather Williams left the meeting.
The Chair, seconded by Councillor Heather Williams, proposed a variance in the order of business to take items 8 & 9 (21/05642/FUL & 21/05634/LBC – Guilden Morden) as items 5 & 6. The Committee agreed to the variance in the order of business by affirmation.
With respect to Minutes 8 & 9, Councillor Heather Williams declared that she was the local Member and would withdraw from the Committee to speak as local Member.
By 4 (Councillors [name removed], Ariel Cahn, Bill Handley and [name removed]) votes to 1 (Councillor Dr Richard Williams), with 2 abstentions (Councillors Judith Rippeth and Peter Sandford) and 1 Member not voting (Councillor Heather Williams, the Committee approved the application ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Councillor Heather Williams withdrew from the Committee, in-line with her Declaration of Interest.
Councillor Heather Williams addressed the Committee in support of the application.
Councillor Heather Williams rejoined the Committee.
Councillor Heather Williams declared an Other Registerable Interest, as a member of the Audit and Corporate Governance Committee. It was noted that appendix C was missing from the agenda and would be included in the report to Council.
Councillor Heather Williams asked if the Leader had instructed the Chief Executive to intervene in response to the letter shown on page 21 of the agenda.
Councillor Heather Williams asked why the Leader had refused to allow all councillors to have a vote on the four-day week trial. The Leader explained that Council would vote on this matter at the end of the trial.
Councillor Heather Williams asked if the Leader was prepared to accept the consequences of not fully agreeing the four-day week before going ahead with the initiative. The Leader supported the decision taken to initiate a four-day week trial in response to challenges the Council was having in recruitment.
Councillor Heather Williams was present as a substitute.
With respect to Minute 6, Councillor Heather Williams declared that she had previously been involved in campaigning for fertility treatment.
Councillor Heather Williams requested that the second line of the penultimate paragraph of Minute 4 be amended from “…staff preferred to work from and how attendance…” to “…staff preferred to work from home and how attendance…” Councillor Sally Ann Hart requested that the abbreviation of CMT be clarified as Corporate Management Team in Minute 4.
With respect to Minute 10, Councillor Heather Williams declared that she was local Member for some cases listed in the report.
Councillor Heather Williams requested that Minute 6 be amended to reflect that the decision to pause CSET Phase 2 had been taken by the GCP Board, rather than by the Joint Assembly as recorded. With the amendment, the Committee authorised the Chair to sign the Minutes of the meeting held on 11 October 2023 as a correct record.
Councillor Heather Williams sent apologies for lateness.
With respect to Minute 6, Councillor Heather Williams declared that she was a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership (GCP), who had been referenced in the report, but had held no discussions regarding the application and was coming to the matter afresh.
Councillor Heather Williams joined the Committee The Chair noted that the Committee had visited the site on 4 October 2023. The Area Team Leader presented the report and provided the following updates to the report:
By 8 (Councillors [name removed], Peter Fane, Anna Bradnam, Ariel Cahn, [name removed], Judith Rippeth, Peter Sandford and Eileen Wilson) votes to 1 (Councillor Heather Williams), the Committee approved the application in accordance with the officer’s recommendation, and subject to the conditions, as laid out in the report from the Joint Director of Planning and Economic Development.
Councillor Heather Williams declared an Other Registerable Interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly.
Councillor Heather Williams expressed her disappointment in the proposed amendment, as the recommendation from the Civic Affairs Committee had enjoyed cross-party support. A resident could have two homes and so the amendment made the connection with the area weaker than being on the electoral roll.
Councillor Heather Williams proposed an amendment to the new recommendation to include a legal definition of the word “resident” so that it would be clear who was able to apply for the position.
Councillor Heather Williams stated that she had supported the original recommendation and as her view had not changed she would vote against the amended recommendation.
Councillor Heather Williams stated that her motion of September 2019 had been rejected but then a similar motion had been approved last year. She hoped that those who had voted against her motion in 2019 would not repeat their mistake and the Council would act to benefit future generations.
Councillor Heather Williams asked for clarification of the statement made by the Council’s representative at the last meeting of the Board that the option of a road charge remained on the table.
Councillor Heather Williams respected the honesty of Councillor Brian Milnes on this issue. She expressed her concern that the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly had not been permitted to scrutinise the report before it went to the Board.
Councillor Heather Williams asked whether the Council’s representatives on the Partnership was responsible for the authority’s position with regards to the Partnership or whether the ruling Group’s prospective candidate to be MP for South Cambridgeshire was in control. The Leader explained that parliamentary candidates had a free voice, as did the current MP, who was regularly critical of his own Government. The Leader was the Council’s representative on the Partnership and she led on environmental issues, which she believed that the opposition group would also support.
Councillor Heather Williams asked if the Leader could give a total number of hours worked every day.
The Leader reported that Councillor Heather Williams would receive a written response to this question.
Councillor Heather Williams introduced her motion.
Councillor Heather Williams asserted that the four-day week affected all residents and in 12 months £3.3m of salaried hours would not be worked. This was such an important matter all residents should have been consulted on and all councillors should be involved in its decision. She stated that the ruling political group had changed its mind on many previous issues, including the introduction of blue bins, the provision of community facilities at Northstowe, a motion on youth engagement and the congestion charge.
Councillor Heather Williams asked whether there had been any analysis into where members of staff preferred to work from and how attendance at South Cambridgeshire Hall was being monitored. In reply, the Head of Transformation, HR and Corporate Services said that no such analysis had been carried out at this stage. It was possible to monitor attendance at the office by analysing the use of access passes, but attendance was not the primary reason for doing so.
Councillor Heather Williams sought clarification of the relationship between hard-to-fill posts and the budgeted for 20% reduction in staff. The Head of Transformation, HR and Corporate Services said that there was no fixed target for staff reductions.
Councillor Heather Williams reported that this was likely to become a statutory requirement in the near future.
Councillor Heather Williams asserted that only elected councillors should have voting rights and it would be undemocratic to allow the independent person to vote at the committee meetings.
Councillor Heather Williams declared a registerable interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly, as the agenda referred to the Greater Cambridge Partnership.
Councillor Heather Williams asked if future audit reports could indicate what percentage of the audit was completed.
Ombudsman annual report Councillor Heather Williams asked if the annual ombudsman’s letter would be considered by the Committee. The Chair replied that the annual report from the ombudsman would come to a future meeting of the Committee.
Councillor Heather Williams requested that the recommendations in the report be amended to ensure that both any risks identified by the ombudsman and the impact of the four-day week be included in the audit plan. The Committee had a brief adjournment whilst this was considered.
Councillor Heather Williams asserted that the Council had a moral obligation to tackle fraud to show that the authority would not tolerate the defrauding of the taxpayer. The Head of Finance stated that the anti-fraud training would examine these issues.
Councillor Heather Williams agreed and expressed concern that it would be difficult to recruit a person of sufficient skills for the remuneration on offer.
Councillor Mark Howell and Councillor Heather Williams stated that they would not be voting on the recommendation. They could consider this matter afresh as members of the Civic Affairs Committee.
Councillor Heather Williams, Opposition Group Leader asked when the council was aware of the environment agencies concerns, regarding the five-year housing land supply that was in amber, reminding members of the application put in, in 2018 which went to committee in 2021, still waiting a decision. It was questioned whether it was included in calculations and what the impact would be.
Councillor Heather Williams emphasised, full council and planning committee members would likely appreciate a briefing ahead of committee to understand what was going on and to understand repercussions.
Jeff Membery, Head of Transformation clarified the cost of the Mystery Shopper exercise was £8,800 Councillor Heather Williams stated although the results were good, believed the contact centre were singled out and other departments could have been part of the exercise.
Councillor Heather Williams substituted for Councillor Bygott.
In response to concern raised by Councillor Heather Williams, the Corporate Programme Manager outlined the steps taken to support Contact Centre staff during the exercise.
Councillor Heather Williams asked officers to make the narrative more “substantive” and called on the Cabinet to make sure that available resources were sufficient to complete tasks on time.
However, Councillor Heather Williams said care was needed to differentiate between the local and national contexts, especially when referring to ‘staff’. The Committee encouraged the identification of new sources of data as they emerged and added that the presentation of trends would be helpful.
Councillor Heather Williams, Opposition Group Leader, asked for the Waste Service to be updated with changes quicker to enable missed bins to be logged.
In reply to Councillor Heather Williams, it was explained by Cllr Batchelor, that there would be an extra day in the week for missed bin collections and due to use of more permanent staff, there would likely be a reduction in the number of missed bins.
Councillor Heather Williams stated it would be useful for all councillors to be provided with upfront costs and officer hours, including Waste Services and office-based staff, to gain a reflection on what time ... view the full minutes text for item 10.
Councillor Heather Williams declared that she was a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Assembly.
With respect to Minute 8, Councillor Heather Williams declared that she knew the supporting public speaker, Ray Manning, but had held no discussions regarding the application.
Their substitutes were Councillor Heather Williams and Councillor Paul Bearpark respectively.
Councillor Heather Williams declared an interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly.
The Committee authorised the Chair to sign, as a correct record, the minutes of the meeting held on 12 January 2023 subject to an amendment being made to show Councillor Heather Williams as having been present in the Chamber.
Regarding AH204 (Housing, percentage of tenants satisfied with responsive repairs), Councillor Heather Williams drew a distinction between major and minor repairs asking that future reports should differentiate between the two. The Head of Housing and the Lead Cabinet Member for Housing informed the Committee that a new methodology for collecting data for this KPI was currently being developed.
Councillor Heather Williams declared an interest at a member of the Greater Cambridge Joint Assembly.
Councillor Heather Williams proposed and Councillor Michael Atkins seconded the recommendations in the report. A vote was taken and by affirmation The Committee Approved the audited statement of accounts for 2019/20.
Councillor Heather Williams asked about the protection of the green belt and the viability of the affordable housing.
Councillor Heather Williams was supportive of the current strategy, and noted the cross-party support for the current proposals.
Councillor Heather Williams declared an interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly.
Referring to Risk no. 22 (Compliance Risk – Council Housing), Councillor Heather Williams sought assurance that the risk to tenants’ health from mould had been considered. The Head of Housing said the Risk no. 22 was intended to address instances of statutory compliance. Instead, he agreed to review the extent of Risk no. 24 ( New Mears contract fails to deliver service) to specify the need for Mears contractors (and other authorised visitors to Council properties) to report signs of damp.
Councillor Heather Williams suggested that having permanent staff instead of interims would create more stability. The Head of Finance explained how the existing two Interims in Finance were contributing to the work in hand and expressed confidence in the resilience within the team finalising the accounts.
Councillor Heather Williams and the Head of Finance agreed to discuss, outside the meeting, the development of a Audit Efficiency Toolkit for Members.
Councillor Heather Williams asked a number of questions that the Head of Finance then answered.
Written answers to unanswered questions Councillor John Williams promised written answers to the following questions from Councillor Heather Williams:
Councillor Heather Williams congratulated those involved in the production of Gamlingay’s Neighbourhood Plan and welcomed the positive impact the Plan would have on Gamlingay and the surrounding area.
Councillor Heather Williams suggested that in the current economic climate Council should vote to reject the recommendations made by the Panel to increase allowances for 2022/23.
Scrutiny and Overview Committee The appointment of Councillor Judith Rippeth and Councillor Tom Bygott in place of Councillor Sunita Hansraj and Councillor Heather Williams as ordinary Members of the Committee, and the appointment of Councillor Paul Bearpark in place of Councillor Peter Sandford as the Liberal Democrat Group’s 2nd Substitute Member.
Councillor Heather Williams wished the Mayor a swift recovery and asked about the interim arrangements.
Councillor Heather Williams reported that the minutes of the recent Joint Assembly were 60 pages long and she urged members to look at them to get an impression of the meeting.
Councillor Heather Williams stated that there was a lack of transparency regarding the Ox-Cam Regional partnership and asked if the minutes and agendas of the Partnership would become publicly available. The Leader agreed that the Partnership should be open and transparent but up until now the Government was in control of the project and had decided not to set up a website. In response to questioning the Leader assured Council that according to the Government, the Partnership’s focus was on the environment and the economy and not additional housing.
As her supplementary question Councillor Heather Williams asked how much the Council had paid in compensation for failing to enforce planning conditions.
Councillor Heather Williams stated that other councils were making representations as part of the consultation process and this authority needed to be clear on what its vision was. On behalf of the District’s residents, she expressed her opposition to the proposed charge, in particular for those visiting the Addenbrookes site.
Councillor Heather Williams asserted that the proposed charge would impact more on those living in rural areas and those who had to visit loved ones in hospital.
Councillor Heather Williams proposed and Councillor Graham Cone seconded the motion. A vote was taken and cast as ... view the full minutes text for item 18a
Councillor Heather Williams assured Council that officers were not being criticised and that councillors were responsible for giving direction to the planning team and ensuring that they had the resources to carry this out. The purpose of the motion was to highlight that currently there were too many cases to enforce.
Councillor Heather Williams explained that the relocation of the treatment plant was linked to the Local Plan and the purpose of this motion was to ensure that the Councill gave a view on this issue.
Councillor Graham Cone proposed and Councillor Heather Williams seconded the motion. A vote was taken and were cast as follows:
Councillor Heather Williams thanked the administration for managing to get this report ready in time for this Council meeting, as she was opposed to any further delay to the provision of community facilities at Northstowe. She reminded Council that the Conservative Group had previously supported the recommendation proposed in the report and she hoped that the administration would listen to their practical solutions in the future. She also agreed with the decision to have the discussion in open session, noting that Council’s previous debate on this matter had been in closed session.
Councillor Heather Williams declared an interest in agenda item 13 as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly Partnership.
Councillor Heather Williams thanked those involved in the Plan, which would make it easier for the Planning Committee to make its decisions by ensuring that there would be a steer from the local community.
Councillor Heather Williams suggested that the Chair write to [name removed] to formally thank him on behalf of the Council.
Councillor Heather Williams suggested that the decision taken by Stagecoach to reduce buses on its routes indicated that buses could not provide an alternative to those not wanting to pay a future congestion charge.
Councillor Heather Williams requested that reports from the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly be included in the agenda. The Chair agreed to consider this.
Councillor Heather Williams asked what the administration wanted the project to achieve and how the Leader was representing the District at the meetings. The Deputy Leader explained that the country had a new Prime Minister and a new Minister for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities and the Council was awaiting developments.
Councillor Heather Williams asked if the administration was satisfied with a letter that had been sent to all staff which implied that any improvement on a pay offer could result in redundancies. The Deputy Leader replied that she had not seen the letter and agreed to provide a written response to the supplementary question.
Councillor Heather Williams welcomed the cross-party support of this amended motion.
Councillor Heather Williams proposed and Councillor Graham Cone seconded the following amendments · “Chief Executive” is amended to Leader” · The word “considers” is added to the last sentence before the numbered points.
“And will oppose the introduction of congestion charging in Cambridge” Councillor Heather Williams stated that the motion was clearly political and the purpose of the motion was to mitigate this. In her view the letter should be sent by the Leader not the Chief Executive and VAT charges on luxury items should remain at 20%. The congestion charge should be opposed as it will add to the cost of living crisis.
Councillor Heather Williams (Leader of the Opposition speaking on behalf of herself and former Conservative Group leaders Peter Topping, [name removed], and Ray Manning) made a statement.
In response to comments from Councillor Heather Williams, Leader of the Opposition, Councillor Smith pointed out that variances were not unusual in the first Quarter of a financial year, and the Head of Finance undertook to provide Councillor Williams with a written explanation regarding the specific query raised.
Councillor Heather Williams declared an other registerable interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly.
Councillor Heather Williams suggested that determining the level of reserves was a political decision and reviewing this was the responsibility of the Scrutiny and Overview Committee. The Chair decided that this issue could be reviewed outside the meeting.
Councillor Heather Williams stated that since 2018 she had asked whether the Committee could be provided with a audit effectiveness toolkit.
Councillor Heather Williams requested that recommendation ix be amended to include a recommendation that a report come back to Council in six months’ time regarding the Enterprise Zone development.
Councillor Heather Williams stated that there was cross party support for the provision of community facilities at Northstowe but she wanted assurances that the large sums of money were being well spent and that a thriving Enterprise Zone would be established, unlike in Cambourne where houses were being built on the Business Park. The Chief Executive replied that the terms of sale prohibited the building of housing on the Northstowe Enterprise Zone until 2042.
In response to questioning from Councillor Heather Williams, Councillor Bridget Smith explained that the extraordinary meeting of the Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Combined Board was split over two separate days.
On the proposal of Councillor Heather Williams, which was seconded by Councillor Graham Cone, Council agreed to appoint Councillor Mark Howell to the Housing Engagement Board.
Councillor Heather Williams proposed and Councillor Graham Cone seconded the following motion:
Councillor Heather Williams stated that the Council had rejected a similar motion in 2019.
Councillor Heather Williams welcomed the comments made and hoped that Cabinet would be able to allocate funding to the project.
Head of Climate, Environment and Waste, referred to the toolkit aimed at addressing this issue.” Attendance list Councillor Heather Williams attended the meeting and was present in the Council Chamber.
The Chair invited Councillor Heather Williams to speak.
Councillor Heather Williams declared that she was a member of the Greater Cambridgeshire Partnership Assembly and that this would have no bearing on her decision making for the application.
With respect to Minute 10 (22/00951/HFUL – Arrington), Councillor Heather Williams declared that she had been involved in conversations around the application and would not take part in the debate and vote on the item, instead she would speak as local Member.
Councillor Heather Williams addressed the Committee as local Member and urged the Committee to approve the application.
Councillor Heather Williams queried the previous comment on staff engagement and the percentage of staff that complete surveys.
The Head of Transformation, HR and Corporate Services confirmed that completion of staff surveys remained high and would provide the figure to Councillor Heather Williams after the meeting.
Councillor Heather Williams was pleased with the policy but asked if provisions were being made for Officers who were established in their careers. The Head of Transformation, HR and Corporate Services noted that mentors would be appointed for new staff.
Councillor Heather Williams supported the partnership but requested that rural communities be represented within the ongoing work, and rural specific crimes be noted within the report. The Communities Manager responded that rural crime is discussed regularly at the Board, which meets every six months, and at the monthly Tasking and Tactical Coordination group.
Councillor Heather Williams thanked the Chair for agreeing to take the Planning scheme of delegation separately as it was important to have agreement where possible but on this matter this was not possible.
Councillor Heather Williams, Leader of the Opposition, congratulated all councillors elected this month and welcomed those newly elected members to their first Council meeting and advised them that the work was both challenging and rewarding.
Councillor Heather Williams expressed her sadness at the untimely deaths of James Brokenshire MP and Sir David Amess MP. She was also sorry to hear of the death of Roger Hall, former district councillor for Bar Hill. Her thoughts were with his widow Jo and their family.
Councillor Heather Williams concluded that the role of the Opposition was to represent its residents, agree with the administration where it could but to be unafraid of opposing it when necessary.
Councillor Heather Williams stated that according to the minutes of the Committee a discount had been agreed in the past. The Committee Agreed that the auditor’s fees should be subject to a PSAA review.
Councillor Heather Williams stated that she was on maternity leave when she was first elected and she supported this policy as it would allow new parents to continue to be councillors. She added that it was important to ensure that the Council had facilities to allow new mothers to come to the office.
Councillor Heather Williams stated that as a member of the Planning Committee she recognised the significance that the Plan would have on future planning applications. She supported the adoption of the Plan.
Councillor Heather Williams proposed the above Motion, praising the Ukrainians for their resistance to the invasion of their country. She accused Putin of undermining democracy and urged Council to support the Ukrainians and the Motion.
Councillor Heather Williams expressed her support for the Motion. ... view the full minutes text for item 14c
Councillor Heather Williams said this was an opportunity for action to be taken across the district.
Councillor Heather Williams commented that biodiversity was becoming more prevalent within housing developments and expected this would be implemented through all new housing developments across the district.
Councillor Bridget Smith, Leader of the Council, invited Councillor Heather Williams to introduce the Conservative Group’s alternative budget proposal.
Councillor Heather Williams introduced her Group’s alternative budget proposal. She said it would not increase council tax and would provide additional resources for reducing fly tipping and enhancing fraud prevention.
Councillor Heather Williams wanted to confirm if the yield of each investment would be reviewed individually or combined with all of the Council’s investments.
Councillor Heather Williams was supportive of the continued scheme, but commented that changes would be required if inflation continued to increase.
Councillor Heather Williams asked whether any updates would be provided after the 2021 census data had been published. The Head of Housing responded that this document would be continually updated.
Councillor Heather Williams suggested that if any changes were made to the accounts the Committee members should be informed.
Councillor Heather Williams suggested that if the accounts were not signed off by the end of February a meeting of the Committee should be held in early March.
External Auditors’ fees Councillor Heather Williams expressed concern that the External Auditors were attempting to charge over £120,000 more than originally estimated, and that EY had been partly responsible for some of the delay. The Head of Finance replied that he planned to discuss the fees with the External Auditors, but getting the accounts signed off was the priority.
Councillor Pippa Heylings, seconded by Councillor Heather Williams, proposed an amendment to condition G to change the BREEAM requirements from “Very Good” to ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Councillor Heather Williams commented on the low number of responses from Council tenants, and formal complaints. The Head of Housing responded that a range of options was being investigated, and the Head of Transformation mentioned that further resources had been allocated to address the backlog.
Councillor Heather Williams asked if the figures in the published report relating to suitability would need to be updated ahead of the final Council decision.
Councillor Heather Williams asked about the variances from the external funding. The Head of Finance commented that this formed part of the reprofiled Capital Programme, and it was relating to Cambridge City Council.
Councillor Heather Williams asked about the use of agency staff across the Council.
The report had been prepared in response to a motion from Councillor Heather Williams at Full Council on 23 September 2021, which had been referred to the Scrutiny and Overview Committee.
Councillor Richard Williams, seconded by Councillor Heather Williams, proposed an amendment of the Materials Planning condition.
Tumi Hawkins, seconded by Councillor Heather Williams, proposed the addition of a Construction Management Plan.
Tumi Hawkins, seconded by Councillor Heather Williams, proposed an informative on the subject of foul water drainage.
Councillor Heather Williams questioned the report on Whitehall Farmhouse as it was identical to the report presented at the last meeting. The Councillor questioned if the inclusion of this report was an error and asked if the Principal Enforcement Officer had assumed responsibility for the review of the application. The Delivery Manager informed the Member that the reports inclusion was an error, and that the Principal Enforcement Officer had assumed responsibility for the application.
Councillor Heather Williams stated that she was pleased to hear that the application on Mill Lane, Sawston had been brought to a hearing and enquired as to when a decision would be presented to the Committee. The Councillor also noted that there was no table detailing those appeals that were awaiting decision and stated that the inclusion of such a table in future reports would be useful.
Councillor Heather Williams welcomed the report but was concerned by the increase in parking charges for residents wanting to access Wimpole Hall.
Councillor Heather Williams read out a statement on behalf of Councillor Grenville Chamberlain who had known Sir David Amess MP for over twenty years.
Councillor Heather Williams, Councillor Bridget Smith and Councillor Gavin Clayton expressed their shock over the MP’s murder but also affirmed their support for his family and the democratic ideals that he represented.
Councillor Heather Williams explained that it was important that the update on the auditing of the 2018/19 accounts was discussed at a public meeting to ensure that the Council was open and transparent.
Councillor John Williams proposed and Councillor Neil Gough seconded the recommendation in the report: “To note the position on the Audit of the Accounts for 2018/19.” Councillor Heather Williams proposed and Councillor Nick Wright seconded the following addition to recommendation “… and the Cabinet’s commitment to resolving the issues giving as much resource as is needed to get the accounts up-to-date by October 2022 subject to external auditors questions and requests.” Councillor John Williams accepted this amendment and it became part of the substantive recommendation without debate.
Councillor Heather Williams declared a non-pecuniary interest in Minute 12 (Enforcement) as the report included a site in her ward (The Mordens).
Upon a proposal from Councillor Heather Williams, seconded by Councillor Anna Bradnam, the Planning Committee approved , by six votes to three, the addition of the wording “in consultation with the Parish Council” be added to condition 3 set out in the report from the Joint Director of Planning and Economic Development.
Councillor Heather Williams requested that the list of consultation questions be made available to all Parish Councils, and also that the colour coding of the some of the maps within the reports include a key as it was causing confusion. The Lead Cabinet Member responded that the document would be made more accessible and that all Parish Councils would be provided with a list.
Councillor Heather Williams declared · a non-pecuniary interest in minute 7 (21/00629/S73 - Linton (Land to the North and South of Bartlow Road)) because of her work with Lucy Fraser M.P.
Councillor Heather Williams stated that she had not been involved in any correspondence with Lucy Fraser about this matter.
Upon a proposal from Councillor Pippa Heylings, seconded by Councillor Heather Williams, and by affirmation, the Planning Committee deferred the application, without debate, so that it could be determined in due course at the meeting at which would be considered the s ubmission of details required by Condition of surface water drainage on the same site.
In response to a query from Councillor Heather Williams, the Senior Planning Lawyer said that the appeal relating to Mill Road, Sawston would be heard during the week beginning 18 October 2021.
Councillor Heather Williams reiterated her request for guidance for councillors on how to ensure that the Audit and Corporate Governance Committee was effective.
Councillor Heather Williams declared a non-pecuniary interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly.
Councillor Heather Williams welcomed the continued success of Ermine Street Housing but expressed concern regarding the possible long-term implications of underspends in the commercial investments budget.
Councillor Heather Williams, as Chair of the Anti-Bullying Task and Finish Group, presented this report on the proposed new Model Code of Conduct, which was unanimously supported by the Civic Affairs Committee. It was proposed that the new Code of Conduct come into force in May 2022, to allow district and parish councillors to be trained and for a new Register of Interests form to be drawn up.
Councillor Heather Williams agreed that officers had worked admirably, but according to page 175 the deficit two years ago had been £3m and so the situation had got worse. She suggested that the administration needed to curtail spending on its political aspirations to improve the Council’s finances.
Councillor Heather Williams replied that the Local Plan had been agreed by all councillors.
Councillor Heather Williams stated that she would support the Plan as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly.
Councillor Heather Williams reported that the Greater Cambridge Joint Assembly had discussed travel to and around the city of Cambridge and opinion had been divided on the possible introduction of a congestion charge.
Councillor Heather Williams expressed her frustration at the fact the report did not include what the Leader was saying at these meetings. She asked if minutes of the OxCam arc meetings could be shared.
Councillor Heather Williams asked if the Leader or any member of Cabinet, if they were aware of any major developments that had not been shared with all members of the Council, as was the case of the Fakenham development.
As her supplementary question, Councillor Heather Williams asked if the Leader had in fact been aware of the Fakenham development two months before it was announced, which the Leader denied.
Councillor Dr Richard Williams proposed and Councillor Heather Williams the following motion:
Councillor Heather Williams reminded Council that in May 2020 Planning Committee had narrowly rejected the proposal to allow parish councils to refer planning applications to the Planning Committee. The assurance had been given that all parish councils would be consulted on the new scheme of delegation, but this had not happened.
Councillor Heather Williams proposed and Councillor Graham Cone seconded the following motion:
This report will cover the last 24months (September 2019 to September 2021)” Councillor Heather Williams explained that this motion was being brought back to Council to request the necessary statistics on this matter.
Councillor Heather Williams introduced this report, as the Chair of the Anti-Bullying Task and Finish Group. She explained that the Group unanimously supported the new Local Government Association and its attempt to tackle harassment. An implementation date of May 2022 would allow time to train councillors on the new .
Councillor Heather Williams supported the Council’s response to the consultation but requested all Members should review the final draft before submission.
Councillor Heather Williams supported the concerns about the biodiversity net gain but requested that firmer language be used within the consultation response.
Councillor Heather Williams was supportive of the overall project but urged the Council to provide a robust response to the proposals and ensure the full project would meet the needs of residents.
(Councillor Heather Williams voted that the Planning Committee should not determine the three applications mentioned above at this meeting.)
Councillor Heather Williams did not vote.)
Bullying and harassment Councillor Heather Williams stated that bullying and harassment was a serious offence and so should be a level 3 not 2. The HR Advisor explained that each case would be judged on its merits and according to the Council’s policies. A serious breach could lead to an officer being dismissed.
Stability index Councillor Heather Williams requested that the stability index could be shown by service.
Councillor Heather Williams · Declared a non-pecuniary interest in Minute 7 (21/01390/HFUL - Fulbourn (24 Shelford Road)) because she was friends with, and members of the same political group at South Cambridgeshire District Council as, Councillor Graham Cone, one of the applicants.
Councillor Heather Williams took no part in the debate, and did not vote.
In response to Councillor Heather Williams, the Assistant Director said that the review had been subject to an ‘open consultation’.
In response to a question from Councillor Heather Williams, the Delivery Manager (Strategic Sites) undertook to discover whether the Committee would be invited to say what its decision would have been regarding New Road, Over, which had been appealed for non-determination.
Councillor Heather Williams declared a non-pecuniary interest as she knew members of Bassingbourn Parish Council who may be affected by a complaint detailed in agenda item 5.
Councillor Heather Williams proposed and Councillor Mark Howell seconded the recommendations that the Committee recommend to Council that the proposed boundary be adopted and the Local Government Boundary Commission for England be requested to realign the ward boundaries between Sawston and Duxford so that they remain aligned with the new parish boundary.
Councillor Heather Williams declared a non-pecuniary interest in respect of Minute 10 (Enforcement). Notice EN/01582/20 had been issued and served in Hatley, which was within her ward of The Mordens.
Councillor Heather Williams accepted the location and principle of development, but expressed concern about the proposal’s design and appearance in the context of Policy E/7 of the South Cambridgeshire Local Plan 2018, and the absence of a viability assessment. The Development Manager (Strategic Sites) explained that Policy E/7 did not require a viability assessment.
Councillor Heather Williams summed up what the public speakers and County Councillor van de Ven had said by emphasising that the purpose behind the application was to formalise an existing use of the Hall for the benefit of local people. She was satisfied that there was not a significant car parking issue, the objection from the Local Highways Authority being based purely on the methodology used in conducting the assessment, By affirmation, the Planning Committee approved the application subject to the Conditions set out in the report from the Joint Director of Planning and Economic Development.
For Councillor Heather Williams, the issues to consider were density, loss of amenity, height of the proposal, and negative impact on the immediate neighbour.
Councillor Heather Williams read out a statement of support from Councillor Nick Wright (a local Member) for the recommendation in the report.
Councillor Heather Williams requested that Whitehall Farm, Arrington be added to future update reports.
Showing the latest 300 of 524.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Williams attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Williams's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Williams was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
South Cambridgeshire has not published attendance for Councillor Williams's meetings yet.
What Councillor Williams declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 Sep 2025 | Planning Committee, item 3 | Item 4 (25/00054/REM) – Councillor Heather Williams declared an interest in this application being a member of South Cambs District Council and believed the evidence discussed during the consideration of the application suggested that the council had a significant interest in the application. | |
| 17 Jul 2025 | Council, item 29 | Councillor Heather Williams declared, in relation to agenda item 13 ‘Greater Cambridge Partnership’, that she was a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Assembly. | |
| 10 Jul 2025 | Audit and Corporate Governance Committee, item 2 | Councillor Heather Williams declared an Other Registerable Interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly. | |
| 28 Jan 2025 | Civic Affairs Committee, item 20 | Councillor Heather Williams declared, for the sake of transparency, that she had sat on the Local Government Association roundtable when this issue was discussed. | |
| 23 Jan 2025 | Audit and Corporate Governance Committee, item 3 | Councillor Heather Williams declared an Other Registerable Interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly. | |
| 15 Jan 2025 | Planning Committee, item 3 | Councillor Heather Williams declared an interest in item 5 (Planning Committee Review – Scheme of Delegation) by virtue of being a member of the Civic Affairs Committee which would give further consideration to these matters at a later meeting but would remain in the meeting for the duration and voting on the item. | |
| 15 Jan 2025 | Planning Committee, item 3 | Councillor Heather Williams declared an interest as being the applicant for the provisional tree preservation order at item 6 on the agenda. | |
| 5 Dec 2024 | Audit and Corporate Governance Committee, item 2 | Councillor Heather Williams declared an Other Registerable Interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly. | |
| 28 Nov 2024 | Council, item 52 | Councillor Heather Williams declared, in relation to agenda item 7(a) ‘Council Tax Charges for Long Term Empty Properties and Second Homes’ and 14(b) Motion ‘Standing in the name of Councillor Heather Williams’, that she had a non-registrable interest, which didn’t affect her views. | |
| 28 Nov 2024 | Council, item 52 | Councillor Heather Williams further declared, in relation to agenda item 10 ‘Greater Cambridge Partnership’, that she was a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Assembly. | |
| 3 Oct 2024 | Council, item 15 | Councillor Heather Williams, in relation agenda item 10 ‘Greater Cambridge Partnership’, declared that she was a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Assembly. | |
| 16 May 2024 | Audit and Corporate Governance Committee, item 2 | Councillor Heather Williams declared an Other Registerable Interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly. | |
| 8 May 2024 | Planning Committee, item 3 | With respect to Minute 9, Councillor Heather Williams declared that an application listed in the report was in her ward, but she had held no discussions regarding the application. | |
| 10 Apr 2024 | Planning Committee, item 3 | Councillor Heather Williams declared that she was a member of the GCP Assembly. | |
| 13 Mar 2024 | Planning Committee, item 3 | During Minute 6, Councillor Heather Williams declared that she was a member of the Great Cambridge Partnership (GCP) Assembly when the GCP development of the Horningsea Greenway was discussed. | |
| 23 Jan 2024 | Audit and Corporate Governance Committee, item 2 | Councillor Heather Williams declared an Other Registerable Interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly. | |
| 17 Jan 2024 | Planning Committee, item 3 | Councillor Heather Williams declared that she was a Member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership (GCP) Assembly, with the GCP being referenced in the report, but had not been part of any discussions regarding the application. | |
| 18 Dec 2023 | Planning Committee, item 3 | With respect to Minutes 8 & 9, Councillor Heather Williams declared that she was the local Member and would withdraw from the Committee to speak as local Member. | |
| 14 Dec 2023 | Civic Affairs Committee, item 5 | Councillor Heather Williams declared an Other Registerable Interest, as a member of the Audit and Corporate Governance Committee. It was noted that appendix C was missing from the agenda and would be included in the report to Council. | |
| 9 Nov 2023 | Employment and Staffing Committee, item 2 | With respect to Minute 6, Councillor Heather Williams declared that she had previously been involved in campaigning for fertility treatment. | |
| 8 Nov 2023 | Planning Committee, item 3 | With respect to Minute 10, Councillor Heather Williams declared that she was local Member for some cases listed in the report. | |
| 11 Oct 2023 | Planning Committee, item 3 | With respect to Minute 6, Councillor Heather Williams declared that she was a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership (GCP), who had been referenced in the report, but had held no discussions regarding the application and was coming to the matter afresh. | |
| 5 Oct 2023 | Council, item 2 | Councillor Heather Williams declared an Other Registerable Interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly. | |
| 26 Jul 2023 | Audit and Corporate Governance Committee, item 2 | Councillor Heather Williams declared a registerable interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly, as the agenda referred to the Greater Cambridge Partnership. | |
| 8 Mar 2023 | Planning Committee, item 3 | Councillor Heather Williams declared that she was a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Assembly. | |
| 8 Mar 2023 | Planning Committee, item 3 | With respect to Minute 8, Councillor Heather Williams declared that she knew the supporting public speaker, Ray Manning, but had held no discussions regarding the application. | |
| 28 Feb 2023 | Scrutiny and Overview Committee, item 3 | Councillor Heather Williams declared an interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly. | |
| 21 Feb 2023 | Audit and Corporate Governance Committee, item 2 | Councillor Heather Williams declared an interest at a member of the Greater Cambridge Joint Assembly. | |
| 12 Jan 2023 | Scrutiny and Overview Committee, item 4 | Councillor Heather Williams declared an interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly. | |
| 22 Sep 2022 | Council, item 2 | Councillor Heather Williams declared an interest in agenda item 13 as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly Partnership. | |
| 28 Jul 2022 | Audit and Corporate Governance Committee, item 2 | Councillor Heather Williams declared an other registerable interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly. | |
| 16 Jun 2022 | Planning Committee, item 3 | Councillor Heather Williams declared that she was a member of the Greater Cambridgeshire Partnership Assembly and that this would have no bearing on her decision making for the application. | |
| 16 Jun 2022 | Planning Committee, item 3 | With respect to Minute 10 (22/00951/HFUL – Arrington), Councillor Heather Williams declared that she had been involved in conversations around the application and would not take part in the debate and vote on the item, instead she would speak as local Member. | Took no part |
| 13 Oct 2021 | Planning Committee, item 3 | Councillor Heather Williams declared a non-pecuniary interest in Minute 12 (Enforcement) as the report included a site in her ward (The Mordens). | |
| 29 Sep 2021 | Planning Committee, item 3 | Councillor Heather Williams declared · a non-pecuniary interest in minute 7 (21/00629/S73 - Linton (Land to the North and South of Bartlow Road)) because of her work with Lucy Fraser M.P. | |
| 23 Sep 2021 | Council, item 2 | Councillor Heather Williams declared a non-pecuniary interest as a member of the Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly. | |
| 10 Jun 2021 | Civic Affairs Committee, item 2 | Councillor Heather Williams declared a non-pecuniary interest as she knew members of Bassingbourn Parish Council who may be affected by a complaint detailed in agenda item 5. | |
| 9 Jun 2021 | Planning Committee, item 3 | Councillor Heather Williams declared a non-pecuniary interest in respect of Minute 10 (Enforcement). Notice EN/01582/20 had been issued and served in Hatley, which was within her ward of The Mordens. |
Where Councillor Williams sits, from the attendance records.
No committee attendance recorded for Councillor Williams yet.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.