Register of attendance and apologies for absence
Councillor Charmaine Morgan substituted for Councillor David Bellamy.
Every time South Kesteven's minutes name Councillor Morgan, as the council published it.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan substituted for Councillor David Bellamy.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared an interest as a member of Lincolnshire Wildlife Trust for application S26/0237. She would remain open minded on this application.
(Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared she was a Member of Grantham Town Council, however, she remained open minded).
Councillors Harrish Bisnauthsing and Rhea Rayside were proposed and seconded to take the position on the Health Scrutiny Committee at Lincolnshire County Council, in place of Councillor Charmaine Morgan, the incumbent.
Councillor Morgan was also proposed and seconded.
However, Councillors Bisnauthsing and Rayside withdrew from the vote after hearing a short speech from Councillor Morgan on why she continued to be suitable for the position.
- Cllr Tim Harrison - Cllr Gareth Knight - Cllr Paul Martin - Cllr Matt Bailey (written statement) - Cllr Ben Green (written statement) - Cllr Charmaine Morgan (written statement) Against:
Prior to the consideration of application S26/0363, Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared that she was a member of the Grantham Civic Society, however, approached the application with an open mind.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared an interest on S25/2345 and S25/1653, S25/1526 as a member of Grantham Town Council. She came to the Committee with an open mind.
· Comments received from Grantham Town and District Ward Councillor Charmaine Morgan.
Councillor Pam Byrd substituted for Councillor Charmaine Morgan and Councillor Helen Crawford substituted for Councillor Zoe Lane.
Question Four – Councillor Charmaine Morgan to the Cabinet Member for Housing Councillor Morgan asked what provision was currently in place to support homeless people.
Question Two – Councillor Charmaine Morgan to the Leader of the Council Councillor Morgan asked the Leader of the Council to join her in welcoming the completion of the United Lincolnshire Hospitals Trust’s (ULT) consultation on the future of the old Grantham Hospital site. They had committed to listen to the views of residents before a final decision was reached as to its future.
Councillor Baxter was not surprised that Councillor Morgan was raising this issue following her hard work with the local community on this issue.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared that the applicant to application S25/0553 was a relative of a Councillor . All Members had been trained to retain their independence and were not pre-determined of the application.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared the following on behalf of the Committee:
- An amendment to the list of Chairmen and Vice-Chairmen was proposed and seconded, which would see Councillor Charmaine Morgan continuing as the Chairman of the Planning Committee. The Leader of the Council confirmed that a rollcall vote could take place on an alternative candidate for this role.
Question Six – Councillor Charmaine Morgan to the Leader of the Council.
Councillor Morgan asked the Leader to join her in thanking SKDC officers and external agencies in their collaborative work on flooding in the district.
Councillor Morgan declared an interest that her daughter had been involved in the Grantham Dramatic Society.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan and Councillor Tim Harrison declared an interest in application S25/0069 as members of Grantham Town Council.
However, Councillor Morgan and Councillor Harrison confirmed they were approaching the application with an open mind.
Note: Councillor Charmaine Morgan arrived at the meeting.
Question 4 – Councillor Charmaine Morgan to Councillor Ashley Baxter, Leader of the Council and Cabinet Member for Finance, HR and Economic Development Councillor Morgan asked the Leader of the Council to join her in urging all members to view consultations related to the Grantham hospital building and dementia ward on Manthorpe Road in Grantham.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared an interest on application S24/1040 as she was a Member of the National Trust. She did not have a pecuniary interest and would be open minded on the application.
· Comments received from Anglian Water · No comments received from Cadent Gas · Comments received from Grantham Civic Society · Comments received from Grantham Town Council · Comments received from Heritage Lincolnshire · No comments received from Historic England · No comments received from Lincolnshire County Council (Education) · Comments received from Lincolnshire County Council (Highways & SuDS) · No comments received from Lincolnshire Fire & Rescue · No comments received from Lincolnshire Police Crime Prevention Officer · No comments received from Lincolnshire Wildlife Trust · Comments received from LNER · Comments received from NHS Lincolnshire Integrated Care Board · Comments received from SKDC Conservation Officer · No comments received from SKDC Environmental Protection · No comments received from SKDC Planning Policy Officer – Affordable Housing · Comments received from SKDC Urban Design Officer · Comments received from Network Rail (Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared this application was within her District Ward) During questions to Public Speakers, Members commented on:
Question 2 – Councillor Charmaine Morgan to Councillor Paul Stokes, Deputy Leader of the Council and Cabinet Member for Leisure and Culture Councillor Morgan asked for an update on the works to Dysart Park, Grantham, in particular the flooded area.
At 10.46 AM Councillor Phil Gadd left the Chamber and Councillor Charmaine Morgan joined the Chamber.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared that she was familiar with a few of the public speakers for application S24/1414. She declared that there was no pecuniary interest and would remain impartial when debating and voting on the application.
Question 5 – Councillor Charmaine Morgan to Councillor Rhea Rayside, Cabinet Member for People and Communities Councillor Morgan asked the Cabinet Member to clarify what support the Council was planning to offer pensioners affected by the governmental changes to the winter fuel payments?
None, however, Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared an interest in respect of the agenda item on Build and Acquisition update as she was the Chairman of Planning and took no part in the discussion.
(Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared an interest in this item as Chairman of the Planning Committee and took no part in the discussion) The scheme of 20 units at Swinegate, Grantham was progressing and was on target for completion by July 2025.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan substituted for Councillor Vanessa Smith.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan had been ill and was not in attendance and sent her apologies after the meeting.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan disclosed that she was a member of the Woodland Trust and Lincolnshire Wildlife Trust, but this did not preclude her from taking part in or voting on item S23/1177.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan stated on behalf of the Planning Committee that for application S23/1177 that Helen Powell, a speaker objecting to this application was known to some members as she had previously sat on the Planning Committee in 2005. Additionally, members had been lobbied on the application by both the applicant and objectors.
Councillor Morgan also put on record that she knew [name removed] in a personal capacity. She had discussed procedural matters relating to determining planning applications with her but had not discussed the merits of S23/1177 and remained open minded to determine the application.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan highlighted that she had called-in Application S23/1240, however, she came to the meeting with an open mind.
(Councillor Charmaine Morgan acted as Chairman for this application).
Councillor Charmaine Morgan submitted the following statement:
The Deputy Leader thanked Councillor Charmaine Morgan for the work that she had undertaken in respect of circulating and collating a questionnaire in respect of Grantham market and the questions posed by the letter circulated. It was disappointing that only one response to date, had been received from one Stamford Town Councillor.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan substituted for Councillor Virginia Moran.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan provided the Committee with a verbal update on Grantham Hospital.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared that she was the District’s representative on the Health Scrutiny Committee at Lincolnshire County Council and would be willing to pass on any concerns.
Question 1 - Councillor Charmaine Morgan to the Cabinet Member for Environment and Waste (this role was a jobshare , and the question was answered by Councillor Patsy Ellis) Councillor Charmaine Morgan asked the Cabinet Member whether she would engage and work with Planning Officers on looking at the public consultation policy for trees protected by a Tree Preservation Orders.
Note: Both Councillor Charmaine Morgan and Nicola McCoy-Brown left the Council Chamber during the debate and vote on this item, as they were Directors of LeisureSK Ltd.
Note: Councillor Charmaine Morgan and Nicola McCoy-Brown returned to the Council Chamber.
Councillor Anna Kelly was substituted by Councillor Charmaine Morgan.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared that she was the deputy Mayor of Grantham.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan substituted for Councillor Bisnauthsing.
Councillor Morgan informed the Committee that she was an active campaigner for Grantham Hospital and NHS Services and had a long-standing interest in health issues.
Councillor Morgan also represented South Kesteven District Council on the Lincolnshire County Council Health Scrutiny Committee.
Councillor Tim Harrison substituted for Councillor Baker, Councillor Charmaine Morgan substituted for Councillor Bisnauthsing and Councillor Graham Jeal substituted for Councillor Sandall.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared that she was Vice-Chairman of the Planning Committee.
That Full Council approves Councillor Charmaine Morgan as their representative on the PATROL Joint Adjudication Committee.
Question 1 – Councillor Charmaine Morgan to the Cabinet Member for Environment and Waste (this role was a jobshare , and the question was answered by Councillor Rhys Baker) Councillor Charmaine Morgan asked the Cabinet Member how householders would be expected to accommodate planned new recycling bins for paper and card if they had limited, or no additional space at their property.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan substituted for Councillor Steptoe.
Councillor Morgan requested that it was placed on record that she disagreed with the perimeters of the project and felt that London Road should have been included.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan substituted Councillor Virginia Moran.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan acted as Chairman, for this meeting only.
(Councillor Charmaine Morgan and the Assistant Director of Finance left the meeting at 15:40, declaring an interest in the report as respective nominees).
b) Approved the appointment of Councillor James Denniston, Councillor Charmaine Morgan and Craig Spence as Directors to LeisureSK Limited with immediate effect, and granted Councillor Graham Jeal as Leader of the South Kesteven Coalition Group with delegated authority to nominate and appoint a Member from his Group onto the Board c) Approved the appointment of Councillor Elvis Stooke and Alison Hall-Wright as Directors to Gravitas Housing Limited with immediate effect.
( (Councillor Charmaine Morgan and the Assistant Director of Finance rejoined the meeting at 15:47)
District Ward Councillor: Councillor Charmaine Morgan (statement read out by Democratic Services) Councillor Adam Stokes Against: Jim Smith Mike Lane Agent: Matt Hubbard Together with:
Question 4 – Councillor Chairmaine Morgan to the Leader of the Council Councillor Morgan highlighted the national cost of living issue and asked for an explanation of why the subject was not included on the agenda for this meeting, how the Council would manage the issue, and whether an extraordinary meeting could be considered.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan proposed the following motion:
Councillor Morgan in presenting the motion made the following points:
(Councillor Charmaine Morgan left the meeting at 14:40) Proposal: Partial demolition of Social Club; proposed 2-storey rear extension and roof extension. Change of use from A4 Drinking Establishment and D2 Assembly Hall to C3 residential use to create 15 residential units.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan noted with regards to Application S21/0442 that she was the Ward Councillor for the area and that she also had a daughter who attended the College as a student.
(Councillor Charmaine Morgan joined the meeting at 10:09).
A request was made by Councillor Selby and Councillor Morgan that their decision to abstain from the vote be recorded.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan urged Members to support her proposal as it was important to all Members and residents to do as much as possible to maintain High Streets.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan wished to disclose that her daughter attended Grantham College, which was referred to in application documents, and that she was a member of Grantham Civic Society.
Question 1 – Councillor Charmaine Morgan to The Leader of the Council Councillor Morgan noted the upcoming relaxation of Covid-19 restrictions on 19 July 2021, as set out by the Government and asked how Council leadership would be protecting staff and service users following this.
It was also noted that Councillor Charmaine Morgan had withdrawn her motion at Agenda item 11a), therefore this would not be discussed and any declarations of interest relating to that item were not required to be disclosed at the meeting.
Councillor Morgan joined the meeting at 10.40 .
A verbal presentation by Councillor Charmaine Morgan to greater promotion of the historical value of South Kesteven, including the Spitalgate Heath archaeological finds.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan was not in attendance.
Late attendance was received from Councillor Morgan.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan stated that she had been lobbied on application S20/0856 but approached consideration of the application with an open mind.
The following changes were made: Councillor John Cottier and Councillor Louise Clack no longer served on the Committee, Councillor Helen Crawford and Councillor Charmaine Morgan were appointed to the Committee.
Councillor Morgan requested for her apologies to be reflected in the notes, rather than being listed as present, she had submitted her apologies prior to the meeting ACTION 2.
All Members were present, with the exception of Councillor Charmaine Morgan who had given her apologies and Councillor Robert Broughton.
All Members were present with the exception of Councillor Morgan.
All Members were present with the exception of Councillor Morgan.
Question 5 Councillor Morgan asked whether the Council would be getting a further briefing on the impacts of the withdrawal of Britain from the European Union on the residents and businesses in South Kesteven as well as the anticipated impact on the Council.
Councillor Morgan asked for the consent of the Council to change the wording under consideration from that which was included with the agenda pack to a version that was circulated at the meeting. Council indicated its consent by way of a show of hands.
Councillor Morgan proposed her motion:
In proposing her motion, Councillor Morgan referred to research which indicated that there was no consistent approach to the provision of sites for gypsies and travellers nationally. She stated that Newark and Sherwood, North Kesteven and West Lindsey district councils and Lincoln City Council had all allocated sites and made provision for both permanent and transit pitches for gypsies, travellers and show people. She said that she did not believe South Kesteven District Council’s reliance on windfall sites was working.
Councillor Morgan had given written notice that she had withdrawn her motion on high streets.
· Action point, page 11- The Cabinet Member for Finance was asked to consult with the Deepings District Councillors, rather than the Parish Councillors, regarding the Deepings Special Expense Area · Page 8, first bullet point- Councillor Morgan wished for the additional point to be made that herself and other Members expressed a strong objection to the reduction of the affordable housing requirement in the urban area of Grantham to 20%
Councillor Morgan for Councillor Clack and Councillor Bellamy to fill the Conservative vacancy on the Committee.
Councillor Bellamy to fill the vacant seat held by the Conservatives, Councillor Morgan for Councillor Clack and Councillor Benn for Councillor Mrs. Kaberry-Brown.
· Page 10, minute number 34: insertion of the word “not” – He concluded by saying the minutes did not capture a comment he made about the Lincolnshire fair share campaign not carrying the same clout as the national campaign…” · Page 12: correction of a typographical error – “One member also asked about what lessons had been learned” · Page 13, question 2: “Councillor Morgan also asked about the impact of Brexit on funding.” to be added to the end of the first paragraph · Page 14: correction of a typographical error – “The Cabinet Member for Growth stated that some comments she had received…” Councillor Dilks had requested that it be recorded that the Chairman turned off his microphone during a statement he was making under minute item 36 because it was an exceptional occurrence that had been picked up by the local media.
Councillor Morgan proposed her notice of motion:
In proposing her motion, Councillor Morgan referred to a statement made by the Minister for Exiting the EU, which indicated that whilst a deal would be preferable, there was a chance that there would not be a deal. She stated that she had repeatedly asked what impact a ‘no deal Brexit’ would have on the Council and that work that had been done to analyse the potential impact of the most likely exit scenarios. She illustrated her motion with an example concerning increased prices in food and whether that would have knock-on impacts that would directly affect the Council, for instance, residents not being able to afford their council tax or council rent.
Question 2 Councillor Morgan highlighted concerns that had been raised through the Local Government Association regarding a lack of government funding and the budgets made available to local authorities. She asked about the up-to-date position relating to South Kesteven District Council and how the situation affected the Council’s ability to budget for the forthcoming period.
Councillor Morgan also asked about the impact of Brexit on funding.
Question 3 Councillor Morgan referred to the lack of publicly accessible defibrillators in Grantham town centre, a matter about which she had spoken with the Chief Executive. She asked for a progress update.
The Leader suggested that Councillor Morgan should raise the matter through the Rural and Communities Overview and Scrutiny Committee and to take the matter up with the Cabinet Member for Communities, Health and Wellbeing.
Councillor Morgan was advised that an audit of current provision was underway, which would feed into a feasibility study to see what the Council might be able to do.
Councillor Morgan had been granted permission by the Chairman to make an announcement.
Councillor Robins for Councillor Brenda Sumner and Councillor Morgan for Councillor Dilks.
Councillor Morgan for Councillor Dilks.
Question 5 Councillor Morgan asked what measures the Council was taking in planning for Brexit, and she asked whether it was appropriate, given the agricultural nature of the district, to be building on prime agricultural land.
In accordance with the Constitution, the item had been called in by five Councillors, these being Councillor Ashley Baxter, Councillor Nick Craft, Councillor Phil Dilks, Councillor Charmaine Morgan and Councillor Paul Woods.
Councillor Baxter, Councillor Dilks and Councillor Morgan were in attendance for this meeting.
(10:10am Cllr Morgan arrived part way through this item and therefore took no part in the debate or decision)
notice of motion given under article 4.9 of the Council’s Constitution by Councillor Morgan. As [name removed] was unable to attend the meeting, her statement was printed in full and circulated to Members of the Council. The full text of [name removed] statement is copied below:
The notice of motion to which this statement relates was withdrawn from the agenda because Councillor Morgan was absent from the meeting and had submitted written notification i n accordance with Article 4.9.2 of the Council’s Constitution, stating that she wished to defer the motion until the meeting on 24 May 2018.
Written notification had been received from Councillor Morgan in accordance with Article 4.9.2 of the Council’s Constitution, stating that she wished to defer the motion until the meeting on 24 May 2018.
Councillor Judy Smith for Councillor Exton, Councillor Trollope- Bellew for Councillor Wilkins and Councillor Morgan for Councillor Dilks.
Councillor Morgan for Councillor Dilks, Councillor Judy Smith for Councillor Adam Stokes, Councillor Baxter for Councillor Wood and Councillor Rosemary Trollope- Bellew for Councillor Exton.
Councillor Morgan stated that she had withdrawn her motion from the agenda for this meeting and that she would work with members of other parties to word a motion that fully reflected the needs of the community and its desire to have a Town Council.
Councillor Trollope- Bellew for Councillor Jacky Smith and Councillor Morgan for Councillor Dilks.
Question 3 Councillor Morgan referred to a recent fire at Grenfell Tower in London and raised concerns about fire safety in residential premises in the district. She stated that as a member of the Development Control Committee she had raised the fact that Lincolnshire Fire and Rescue had not been consulted on applications for new developments or where significant changes to a property were proposed. As a member of Lincolnshire County Council she had worked with fire officers and continued to work with officers at Grantham Fire Station.
Councillor Charmaine Morgan substituted for Councillor Phil Dilks for this meeting only.
Councillor Dilks for Councillor Morgan.
Councillor Morgan arrived at 10.40am A Member queried how the Development Control Committee and the Environmental Overview and Scrutiny Committee would link together in respect of encouraging and promoting developments that used sustainable and renewable resources. Members were in formed that the Development Control Committee was not in a position to enforce the use of sustainable resources or put conditions on planning applications. A previous scheme called Merton Rule had enabled the potential to impose a requirement on sites to generate at least 10% of their energy needs using “on site renewable energy equipment” but these were for large industrial estates but this was no longer used.
Councillor Dilks for Councillor Morgan.
Question 3 Councillor Bryant addressed a question to the Cabinet Member for Finance about how he proposed to replace the monies lost from falling Revenue Support Grant while meeting rising costs and additional pressures created by the withdrawal of services by other organisations in light of the plans that the Leader revealed during the meeting Question 4 Councillor Powell asked a question about the impact of government-level changes on the work of the Development Control Committee and its non-political role Question 5 Councillor Morgan asked the Leader about ensuring that proposals made at the Budget meeting and work begun by the policy development groups would be carried forward Question 6 Councillor Ashley Baxter asked whether Members of the Cabinet would visit the Deepings after 4 May 2017 to meet with the Ward Councillors and local stakeholders to talk about the services and facilities available in the area
Councillor Charmaine Morgan arrived at 15:02.
Bosworth for Councillor Reid, Councillor Morgan for Councillor Dilks and Councillor Ian Stokes for Councillor Mrs. Kaberry-Brown.
Councillor C Morgan arrived at 14:35 Members queried what impact 5.2 of the policy regarding Shared Additional Pension Contributions (APCs) would have and whether there was potential for retrospective payments. It was noted that previous guidance had been followed correctly and that the existing policy was not incorrect but new guidance provided greater clarity and brought all local authority pension schemes into line. Further guidance had been sought from both West Yorkshire Pension Fund (WYPF) and Freeths an external legal adviser.
Question 4 Councillor Morgan asked whether the Leader shared the view that the Prime Minister and Health Minister should do more to intervene and that elected representatives should have a greater say in decisions affecting the health services that support local communities.
Councillor Morgan wished to have noted that her preference was for the age to be increased to 18 rather than 21 due to potential issues such as the availability of a quiet area to study.
· Car Parking Strategy – to go to January 2017 PDG · Tourism Website · Wyndham Park Heritage Lottery Fund (HLF) Developments · Review of the Housing Strategy · Refresh HRA Business Plan · The Work and impact of the Neighbourhoods Team Councillor Morgan queried whether the NHS Sustainability & Transformation Plans (STPs) should be added to the work programme.
1) That the Work and Impact of the Neighbourhoods Team be added to the Work Programme, and 2) That the Strategic Director to arrange for the initial scoping work document template to be forwarded to both Councillor Morgan and Councillor Baxter.
Councillor Morgan noted that due consideration had been given to the current use of the car park by the working group and it had been identified as not being regularly used. Further information had been sought from other Deepings Members but no feedback had been forthcoming.
13:04 - Councillor Morgan entered the meeting
The PDG was notified that Councillor Adam Stokes would be substituting for Councillor Dobson for this meeting only and that Councillor Morgan would be substituting for Councillor Forman until the next Annual General Meeting.
· Councillor Martin Wilkins (Chairman) · Councillor Jacky Smith (Vice-Chairman) · Councillor Mrs Pam Bosworth · Councillor Barry Dobson · Councillor Helen Goral · Councillor Mrs Rosemary Kaberry-Brown · Councillor Michael King · Councillor Charmaine Morgan · Councillor Helen Powell · Councillor Robert Reid · Councillor Nick Robins · Councillor Mrs Judy Smith · Councillor Judy Stevens · Councillor Adam Stokes · Councillor Mrs Brenda Sumner · Councillor Brian Sumner · Councillor Rosemary Woolley Licensing Committee and Alcohol, Entertainment and Late Night Refreshment Licensing Committee · Councillor Mrs Pam Bosworth (Chairman) · Councillor Bob Russell (Vice-Chairman) · Councillor George Chivers · Councillor Tracey Forman · Councillor Ms Jane Kingman · Councillor Nikki Manterfield · Councillor Bob Sampson · Councillor Peter Stephens · Councillor Mrs Sarah Stokes · Councillor Frank Turner · Councillor Dean Ward Governance and Audit Committee · Councillor Ian Stokes (Chairman) · Councillor Dr Peter Moseley (Vice-Chairman) · Councillor Matthew Lee · Councillor David Mapp · Councillor Jacky Smith · Councillor Andrea Webster · Councillor Paul Wood Constitution Committee ·
Councillor Morgan joined the meeting at 2.40pm.
Councillor Morgan stated that she had been lobbied on applications S14/0305/MJNO and S14/0306/LB but approached consideration of the application with an open mind. She also brought to the attention of the Committee that she was a founder member of Conserving Grantham.
13:03 Councillor Morgan entered the meeting
Councillor Morgan asked that it be recorded that she had been lobbied on application S13/3292/MJRR, but had no interest to record.
Councillor Morgan asked that it be recorded that she had been lobbied by a local resident in connection with application S13/2986 (KJC1), but had no interest to record.
Councillor Morgan advised that she was the County Councillor for Grantham South, the County Council Division in which application S13/0775 (SB1) was situated . She had had no involvement with the application, and no pecuniary interest.
Members were informed that Councillor Morgan had received a full, written response.
The Chairman informed Members that Councillor Morgan had been supplied with an answer to her question.
Councillor Morgan advised that she had been appointed as a Governor on the West Grantham Academy, the applicants in S13/1205 (PJM1).
The PDG was notified that Councillor Morgan would be substituting for Councillor Dilks until the next annual meeting of the Council.
The PDG was notified that, for this meeting only, Councillor Woolley would be substituting for Councillor Cooke and Councillor Morgan would be substituting for Councillor Dilks.
Councillor Morgan disclosed an interest in agenda item 10 (Notices of Motion given under Council Procedure Rule 12 – first notice of motion) as the new fundraiser for Grantham Foodbank.
Councillor Morgan spoke as a member of the public in her capacity as chairman of SOS Grantham Hospital. She read from a letter that had been sent to United Lincolnshire Hospitals NHS Trust by the group. The letter invited comments on provision of a number of acute services it considered critical for local residents:
Councillor Morgan declared an interest in agenda item 6, as a member of Grantham Conservation Group, to avoid the impression of pre-determination or bias.
(3.12pm – Councillor Morgan left the meeting, having declared an interest).
During the meeting Councillor Morgan declared a personal interest in the item of urgent business on street processions as a member of the group responsible for organising Grantham carnival.
The minutes of the meeting held on 7 February 2012 were approved as a correct record of decisions taken, subject to it being recorded that Councillor Morgan had not declared a personal and prejudicial interest in application KJC1, merely an interest.
Councillor Morgan declared a personal and prejudicial interest in application PWM1 as she had extensively lobbied against approval of the application, and in KJC1, to avoid the impression of bias.
Councillor Morgan declared a personal interest in agenda item 6 (Updates from previous meeting – Rural Broadband), as a former employee of a broadband provider.
Councillor Morgan declared a personal and prejudicial interest in application PJM1, as she had predetermined the application by circulating to members a lengthy email objecting to the proposals.
Councillor Morgan declared a personal and prejudicial interest in application PWM1, as she had extensively lobbied against approval of the application.
Councillor Morgan made a statement in which she apologised for any misunderstanding which might have arisen from a statement she made at the Development Control Committee meeting on 28 June 2011. She said that her comments reflected correspondence which had been received from English Heritage, and not circulated prior to the meeting. However she felt that the comments she had made could be perceived to undermine the expertise of the District Council’s Conservation Officer, Ian Wright.
Councillor Morgan declared a personal interest in applications JJ2 and JJ3, as a member of the Labour and Cooperative party, and the applicants were the Cooperative Society.
Councillor Morgan declared a personal interest in agenda item 9 (Rural Broadband Update), as a former employee of British Telecom.
Councillor Morgan presented a paper she had drafted illustrating a potential workflow process for the Policy Development Groups. This would ensure that all policy ideas put forward (from any source) could be tracked, assisting transparency. Cabinet Members were concerned that the workflow could duplicate the Forward Plan, which was required by statute.
15:01 Councillor Wootten left the meeting Councillor Morgan stated she would e-mail the draft document to PDG members and invited comments on the paper. She stated she would review the draft, taking consideration of the role of the Forward Plan.
Councillor Morgan to e-mail draft workflow process report to PDG members
Policy Development Group workflow Councillor Morgan reported that work was underway to clearly layout a process that captured ideas coming into the PDGs and their subsequent escalation. This work was also supported by the Engagement PDG. The system would propose a monitoring process (providing consistency between all PDGs) for tracking ideas and recommendations to ensure they reached the appropriate person.
Councillor Morgan declared a personal interest in application KJC1, as she formerly lived in the property subject to the application.
Councillor Morgan advised the meeting that the matter of voting issues which had been the subject of some discussion at the last meeting of the committee, in relation to the inability of members who had not heard all the debate on a matter to vote, had been referred to solicitors for advice, and she would report in due course.
Councillor Morgan was substituting for Councillor Shorrock for this meeting only.
Action Note That a work flow programme be devised by Councillor Morgan to be trialled by the Engagement PDG.
Councillor Morgan declared a personal interest in topics for discussion under updates from the previous meeting, as she used to work for British Telecom with responsibility for delivering broadband provision for businesses, and she had served as a member of the Grantham Community Heritage Association.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Morgan attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Morgan's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Morgan was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 0 of 4 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Morgan declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9 Jul 2026 | Planning Committee, item 13 | Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared an interest as a member of Lincolnshire Wildlife Trust for application S26/0237. She would remain open minded on this application. | |
| 9 Jul 2026 | Planning Committee, item 18 | (Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared she was a Member of Grantham Town Council, however, she remained open minded). | Stayed and took part |
| 16 Apr 2026 | Planning Committee, item 120 | Prior to the consideration of application S26/0363, Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared that she was a member of the Grantham Civic Society, however, approached the application with an open mind. | |
| 19 Feb 2026 | Planning Committee, item 90 | Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared an interest on S25/2345 and S25/1653, S25/1526 as a member of Grantham Town Council. She came to the Committee with an open mind. | |
| 3 Jul 2025 | Planning Committee, item 11 | Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared that the applicant to application S25/0553 was a relative of a Councillor . All Members had been trained to retain their independence and were not pre-determined of the application. | |
| 3 Jul 2025 | Planning Committee, item 11 | Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared the following on behalf of the Committee: | |
| 15 May 2025 | Culture and Leisure Overview and Scrutiny Committee, item 70 | Councillor Morgan declared an interest that her daughter had been involved in the Grantham Dramatic Society. | |
| 6 Feb 2025 | Planning Committee, item 109 | Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared an interest on application S24/1040 as she was a Member of the National Trust. She did not have a pecuniary interest and would be open minded on the application. | |
| 6 Feb 2025 | Planning Committee, item 112 | · Comments received from Anglian Water · No comments received from Cadent Gas · Comments received from Grantham Civic Society · Comments received from Grantham Town Council · Comments received from Heritage Lincolnshire · No comments received from Historic England · No comments received from Lincolnshire County Council (Education) · Comments received from Lincolnshire County Council (Highways & SuDS) · No comments received from Lincolnshire Fire & Rescue · No comments received from Lincolnshire Police Crime Prevention Officer · No comments received from Lincolnshire Wildlife Trust · Comments received from LNER · Comments received from NHS Lincolnshire Integrated Care Board · Comments received from SKDC Conservation Officer · No comments received from SKDC Environmental Protection · No comments received from SKDC Planning Policy Officer – Affordable Housing · Comments received from SKDC Urban Design Officer · Comments received from Network Rail (Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared this application was within her District Ward) During questions to Public Speakers, Members commented on: | |
| 9 Jan 2025 | Planning Committee, item 91 | Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared that she was familiar with a few of the public speakers for application S24/1414. She declared that there was no pecuniary interest and would remain impartial when debating and voting on the application. | |
| 19 Sep 2024 | Housing Overview and Scrutiny Committee, item 21 | None, however, Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared an interest in respect of the agenda item on Build and Acquisition update as she was the Chairman of Planning and took no part in the discussion. | Took no part |
| 19 Sep 2024 | Housing Overview and Scrutiny Committee, item 31 | (Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared an interest in this item as Chairman of the Planning Committee and took no part in the discussion) The scheme of 20 units at Swinegate, Grantham was progressing and was on target for completion by July 2025. | Took no part |
| 30 May 2024 | Planning Committee, item 2 | Councillor Charmaine Morgan disclosed that she was a member of the Woodland Trust and Lincolnshire Wildlife Trust, but this did not preclude her from taking part in or voting on item S23/1177. | |
| 14 Dec 2023 | Rural and Communities Overview and Scrutiny Committee, item 34 | Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared that she was the District’s representative on the Health Scrutiny Committee at Lincolnshire County Council and would be willing to pass on any concerns. | |
| 18 Sep 2023 | Community Governance Review Working Group, item 3 | Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared that she was the deputy Mayor of Grantham. | |
| 25 Jul 2023 | the Finance & Economic & Environment Overview and Scrutiny Committee, item 5 | Councillor Charmaine Morgan declared that she was Vice-Chairman of the Planning Committee. | |
| 12 Jul 2012 | Council, item 21 | Councillor Morgan disclosed an interest in agenda item 10 (Notices of Motion given under Council Procedure Rule 12 – first notice of motion) as the new fundraiser for Grantham Foodbank. | |
| 3 Apr 2012 | Planning Committee, item 83 | Councillor Morgan declared an interest in agenda item 6, as a member of Grantham Conservation Group, to avoid the impression of pre-determination or bias. | |
| 8 Mar 2012 | Communities Policy Development Group, item 44 | During the meeting Councillor Morgan declared a personal interest in the item of urgent business on street processions as a member of the group responsible for organising Grantham carnival. | |
| 7 Feb 2012 | Planning Committee, item 70 | Councillor Morgan declared a personal and prejudicial interest in application PWM1 as she had extensively lobbied against approval of the application, and in KJC1, to avoid the impression of bias. | |
| 5 Jan 2012 | Communities Policy Development Group, item 35 | Councillor Morgan declared a personal interest in agenda item 6 (Updates from previous meeting – Rural Broadband), as a former employee of a broadband provider. | |
| 15 Nov 2011 | Planning Committee, item 47 | Councillor Morgan declared a personal and prejudicial interest in application PJM1, as she had predetermined the application by circulating to members a lengthy email objecting to the proposals. | |
| 18 Oct 2011 | Planning Committee, item 40 | Councillor Morgan declared a personal and prejudicial interest in application PWM1, as she had extensively lobbied against approval of the application. | |
| 20 Sep 2011 | Planning Committee, item 33 | Councillor Morgan declared a personal interest in applications JJ2 and JJ3, as a member of the Labour and Cooperative party, and the applicants were the Cooperative Society. | |
| 1 Sep 2011 | Communities Policy Development Group, item 17 | Councillor Morgan declared a personal interest in agenda item 9 (Rural Broadband Update), as a former employee of British Telecom. | |
| 26 Jul 2011 | Planning Committee, item 18 | Councillor Morgan declared a personal interest in application KJC1, as she formerly lived in the property subject to the application. | |
| 7 Jun 2011 | Communities Policy Development Group, item 2 | Councillor Morgan declared a personal interest in topics for discussion under updates from the previous meeting, as she used to work for British Telecom with responsibility for delivering broadband provision for businesses, and she had served as a member of the Grantham Community Heritage Association. |
Where Councillor Morgan sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Sep 2026 | 3 | |
| Environment Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2026 | 1 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | Dec 2017 | 1 | |
| Finance, Economic Development and Corporate Services Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Dec 2021 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.