Appointment of Chair
On the motion of Councillor Santoro, seconded by Councillor Knapper, it was:-
Every time Stoke-on-Trent's minutes name Councillor Knapper, as the council published it.
On the motion of Councillor Santoro, seconded by Councillor Knapper, it was:-
Watson, seconded by Councillor Knapper, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Singh Kallar, seconded by Councillor Knapper, it was resolved that Councillor Davison be appointed as Vice-Chair of the Housing, Regeneration and Operations Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the 2026/27 Municipal Year.
Councillor A Knapper All Personal Councillor Knapper has declared that he is an Estate Agent.
Members received representation from Councillor Adrian Knapper, speaking as Ward Councillor, objecting to the application.
Councillor Knapper was not present for the consideration of this item.
Disclosure Comments Councillor A Knapper All Personal Councillor Knapper confirmed he was an Estate Agent in the City, but that he had not had any involvement in either application.
On the motion of Councillor Alastair Watson, seconded by Councillor Knapper, it was:-
Councillor Knapper made reference to high levels of poverty and underlying associated health issues, commenting on the fact that encouraging growth was an important factor of being able to address these issues.
Garner, seconded by Councillor Knapper, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Garner, seconded by Councillor Knapper, it was:-
This item was introduced by Councillor Knapper, Cabinet Member for Health and Wellbeing, and sought approval to c o m m e n c ea t e nde r i ngp r ocess f or anew Stop S m ok i ng P r o g r a mm e , w hich would i n c l ude beh a v i ou r a l supp o r t and pha r m ac o th e r apyto suppo r t l o c al r es i dents t o q u i t s m okingand t o r educethe p r e v a l enceof s m ok i ngdu ri ngp r e g nanc y , su p po r tedby w o r k t o w a r d s i nc r eased S m oke Fr ee z ones andh o m es.T h i s would bea one y ear c o nt r act w iththe o p tionto e x t e nd f or t w oad d it i onal o ne y earpe ri o ds and the t otal v a l ue would be upto £2 , 666 ,00 0o v er theth r ee y ea r s.
On the motion of Councillor Pervez, seconded by Councillor Knapper, it was:
Councillor Knapper commented that the City Council’s ‘My City, My Say’ consultation had identified mental health as a concern across the City.
The Leader of the Council, Councillor Mohammed Pervez, formally announced appointments to the Cabinet as follows:- Councillor Mohammed Pervez - Leader of the Council Councillor Paul Shotton - Deputy Leader of the Council and Cabinet Member for Economic Development Councillor Ruth Rosenau - Cabinet Member for Regeneration, Planning and Transportation Councillor Gwen Hassall - Cabinet Member for Social Care (Lead Member for Children’s Services) Councillor Terry Crowe - Cabinet Member for Finance, Procurement and Commissioning Councillor Joy Garner - Cabinet Member for Housing, Neighbourhoods and Community Safety Councillor Adrian Knapper - Cabinet Member for Health and Wellbeing Councillor Andy Platt - Cabinet Member Green Enterprises and Clean City Councillor Shaun Pender - Cabinet Member for Education Councillor Olwen Hamer - Cabinet member for Transformation and Resources.
Cabinet Members Comments/Questions Councillor Knapper referred to the number of complaints that he received as a Ward Councillor about dog fouling and associated issues.
Cabinet Members Questions/Comments Councillor Knapper referred to the fact that very often carers didn’t receive the recognition that they deserved and were an asset and Councillor Crowe agreed with this point of view commenting on his own experience and that we needed to recognise what carers are about and the contribution that they make.
Councillor Knapper commented on the fact that the whole purpose of HS2 was to link cities in the North and Councillor Bridges suggested that the City Council’s option was the most economically sound one.
Councillor Knapper explained that the Overview and Scrutiny Committee had been concerned about the sustainability of the BCB as it was a prestigious event. He confirmed that they have had further discussion with the BDB and had now agreed an amount that would continue the work of this organisation. He went on to refer to the proposals in respect of ... view the full minutes text for item 446.
Councillor Knapper commented that if this City was to prosper, it needed to grow and he believed that the Capital Programme was about growth and complemented the Mandate for Change. He highlighted that there was the confidence of investors in the City with examples such as JCB, Bet365, Steelite and Wedgwood.
Councillor Knapper commented on the need to invest in pupils in order to improve education.
Councillor Knapper welcomed the proposals as he felt that it would encourage local firms. He requested that those companies involved, introduce apprenticeships and training schemes.
Councillor Item Type of Interest Reason for Interest Councillor Ali (Chair) 53 Personal Taxi Driver Councillor Aumir 53 Disclosable Pecuniary Interest (DPI) Taxi Marshall - left the room during the consideration of this item Councillor Clarke 53 Personal Relative is a Funeral Director and partner is a local MP who has carried out case work on aspects within the budget Councillor James 53 Personal Trustee of Gingerbread Councillor Knapper (Cabinet Member for Health and Wellbeing) 53 Personal Owns an Estate Agent business in the City and is a member of the Accredited Landlord Scheme in the City
Councillor Knapper encouraged Councillor Platt to speak to Public Health to ensure that support was offered. He commented that a considerable number of people had quit smoking.
Councillor Mohammed Pervez (Chair), Councillor Paul Shotton (Vice-Chair), Councillor Janine Bridges, Councillor Terry Crowe, Councillor Gwen Hassall, Councillor Alan Dutton, Councillor Adrian Knapper, Councillor Shaun Pender, Councillor Andy Platt and Councillor Ruth Rosenau.
Councillor Mohammed Pervez (Chair), Councillor Paul Shotton (Vice-Chair), Councillor Terry Crowe, Councillor Gwen Hassall, Councillor Alan Dutton, Councillor Adrian Knapper, Councillor Shaun Pender, Councillor Andy Platt and Councillor Ruth Rosenau.
Councillor Hassall, Cabinet Member Social Care and Councillor Knapper, Cabinet Member Health and Wellbeing arrived at this point.
Councillor Item Type of Interest Reason for Interest Councillor Garner 35, 36 and 37 Personal Rents a Council property Councillor Knapper (Cabinet Member for Health and Wellbeing) 33 and 35 Personal Owns an Estate Agent business in the City and is a member of the Accredited Landlord Scheme in the City
(Councillor Knapper left the room and did not participate nor vote on this item) Paul Moore, Development Management Team Manager, reported that this item had been considered at the previous meeting of the Committee on 20 August 2013, where it had been resolved to defer the item to this meeting. This decision was made having regard to the contentious nature of the application, consultation dates and the fact that a number of responses from consultees had not been received.
Councillor Knapper, Cabinet Member for Health and Wellbeing, presented this report which sought approval for the City Council to commence a procurement process to appoint a provider for a Nicotine Replacement Therapy (NRT) central supply unit and training to accredited stop smoking providers for a one year period with options to extend for two further periods of twelve months.
The decisions related to:- · Ensuring Continuity of NHS Provided Public Health Services Beyond Transition · City Centre Public Realm Improvements Phase 2 · An update on PFI5 Housing for Older People Projects and the submission of the Final Business Case On the motion of Councillor Knapper, seconded by Councillor Pender, it was:-
Councillor Mohammed Pervez - Leader of the Council Councillor Paul Shotton - Deputy Leader of the Council and Cabinet Member for Economic Development Councillor Ruth Rosenau - Cabinet Member for Regeneration, Planning and Transportation Councillor Gwen Hassall - Cabinet Member Social Care and Lead Member for Children’s Services Councillor Terry Crowe - Cabinet Member for Finance, Procurement and Commissioning Councillor Janine Bridges - Cabinet Member for Housing, Neighbourhoods and Community Safety Councillor Adrian Knapper - Cabinet Member for Health and Wellbeing Councillor Andy Platt - Cabinet Member Green Enterprises and Clean City Councillor Shaun Pender - Cabinet Member for Education Councillor Alan Dutton - Cabinet member for Transformation and Resources.
Councillor Knapper commented that, with the transfer of Public Health to the City Council, elected members would need to take a more active role within their communities in the health promotion agenda.
Councillor Knapper, Cabinet Member for Health and Public Health presented this item explaining that the report sought approval to ensure continuity of key public health services currently being provided by Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent Partnerships NHS Trust (SSPT) to the PCT which became local authority responsibility from 1 April 2013, by entering the City Council to enter into contractual arrangements with the Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) as an equal party (principal) to the NHS standard contract with SSPT or, as an alternative for the Council to enter into a contract directly with SSPT.
Cabinet Members Questions/Comment The Chair asked what kind of services were included as part of these contractual arrangements and Councillor Knapper gave details and referred to page 4 of the report accordingly.
Councillor Knapper also welcomed the draft SPD from a Public Health perspective, referring to health issues in Stoke-on-Trent such as heart disease, obesity and diabetes. He indicated that this was particularly relevant given that the City Council had taken on responsibility for the Public Health function with effect from 1 April 2013.
Councillor Knapper enquired if the apartments would have front doors opening out onto an external outside environment.
Councillor Knapper stressed the need for regular positive communication with local residents around the three sites.
Councillor Knapper also welcomed the proposal and commented that from a health perspective the project would provide local people with access to fresh food, which was very important given the City’s current issues in respect of obesity and unhealthy lifetyles . He wished the project every success.
Councillor Knapper , Cabinet Member for Public Health and Health, introduced this item and explained that the purpose of the report was to provide members with details of the new Public Health functions that the Council will be responsible for with effect from 1 April 2013 and to formalise the requirements contained within the Health and Social Care Act 2012 to transfer these functions from that date.
Councillor Knapper explained that the creation of a stronger, improved public health service was required and that it was crucial to ensure that the transferring staff were fully engaged.
On the motion of Councillor Knapper, seconded by Councillor Hassall, it was:-
The motion was seconded by Councillor Knapper and it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Knapper, seconded by Councillor Hamer, it was:-
Councillor Knapper , Cabinet Member for Public Health and Health introduced the (JHWBS) 2013-2016.
In addition, Councillor Knapper also reported that the Strategy, which as a Policy Framework document, if accepted by Cabinet, would be submitted to City Council for approval.
Councillor Knapper , Cabinet Member for Public Health and Health introduced this report which clarified the arrangements for approving and receiving the Public Health transfer scheme that would affect the legal transfer of public health staff and resources to the City Council.
Members Comments/Questions Councillor Knapper agreed with the sentiments expressed by Councillor Shotton whilst suggesting that the proposed Scheme was the best Scheme that the City Council could implement under these difficult circumstances.
(Councillor Knapper was not present for consideration of this item) The City Council considered a report which provided details of the Government’s technical reforms to council tax and recommended changes to council tax exemptions in light of the new powers.
Councillor Knapper suggested that highway improvements would be needed to the south of the site.
Councillor Knapper asked that ward members and local residents be kept informed of all developments and Councillor Meredith responded by confirming that he had received assurances from the Cabinet member that ward councillors had been consulted.
Councillor Knapper , supporting the proposalswas pleased to see an excellent scheme to provide new housing in Stoke on Trent.
Councillor Knapper commented that the role of the Acting Director of Public Health’s team was to raise awareness of a range of health issues and to promote improved lifestyle choices. He stated that the Acting Director recognised, and was eager to promote, the opportunity for Councillors to act as health champions within their communities.
a) Long Service Award The Lord Mayor presented Councillor Adrian Knapper with a Long Service Award to celebrate his 12 years of service as a councillor in Stoke-on-Trent.
All Members and officers present at the meeting joined the Lord Mayor in congratulating Councillor Knapper and acknowledging his commitment to the City.
This item was introduced by Councillor Knapper, Cabinet Member for Public Health and Health.
(Councillor Knapper was not present at the site inspection and was therefore unable to take part in the vote).
This item was introduced by Councillor Knapper , Cabinet Member for Health.
Councillor Knapper spoke in support of the item and highlighted the health benefits associated with the proposals.
Cabinet Members Comments / Questions Councillor Knapper referred to fuel poverty being a big issue, especially for those on low incomes and believed that from a health perspective, it was important that the vulnerable and elderly were helped to have warm homes during the winter and referred to the number of winter deaths in the City. He therefore welcomed the Strategy.
Cabinet Members Comments / Questions Councillor Knapper referred to the importance of this document which would give enormous opportunities to design health back into regeneration. He explained that the City suffered from a wide range of health issues. He welcomed the work that had gone into the document and felt that it would help to re-shape the City.
Cabinet Members Comments / Questions Councillor Knapper welcomed the report commenting on the fact that one in four people will have a mental health or well-being issue at some point in their life. It was therefore important that there was a strategy in place to support them and to help them live independent lives.
(Councillor Knapper was not present for the consideration of the item).
Councillor Knapper welcomed the report and commented that the proposals fitted in with the Mandate for Change. He thanked officers for including public health considerations within the report.
Councillor Knapper endorsed the report and commented that there were a number of vulnerable people in the City that required continued support and stressed that the Mandate for Change not only promoted independent living but also better lives.
Councillor Knapper , Cabinet Member for Planning and Transportation introduced this item.
Cabinet Members Questions/Comments Councillor Knapper expressed support for the project which he felt would give disabled people access to open space and thanked officers for their support with this Project.
Do they agree that local people should be given a say in what types of businesses operate in their area if so will the council be supporting the High Streets First campaign which calls on Eric Pickles to grant communities the power to decide whether they want a bookies or a bookshop on their high street?” Response provided by the Cabinet Member for Planning and Transportation (Councillor Adrian Knapper):
This item was introduced by Councillor Knapper the Cabinet Member for Planning and Transport.
This item was presented by the Cabinet Member for Planning and Transport, Councillor Knapper .
This report was introduced by Councillor Knapper , Cabinet Member for Planning and Transport.
Members Comments/Questions The Chair (Councillor Pervez ) asked what would happen to these vehicles if they were not sold and Councillor Knapper explained that, as they were surplus to requirements there was no current use for them and that, by agreeing to sell them through an open sale would produce a capital receipt.
Councillor Item Nature of interest The Chair (Councillor Pervez ), Councillors Gratton and Rosenau 8 – The Council’s Position on Academies As parents of children attending schools in the City The Chair (Councillor Pervez ) and Councillors Bridges, Gratton , Hassall, Hamer , Hill and Rosenau 8 – The Council’s Position on Academies As Governors of schools in the City Councillor Knapper 9 – Authority to Adopt an Empty Property Enforced Sale Policy to tackle the Blight of Private Sector Empty Properties and to Recover Unpaid Debts Owed to the City Council As a Registered Social Landlor
Councillor Knapper was not present for this item and therefore did not take part in the vote.
Response Provided by the Cabinet Member for Planning and Transportation (Councillor Adrian Knapper):- In summary the Planning Department have no legal powers to secure full occupancy of a building. The powers available to the Planning department, either through use of conditions or a S.106 Agreement, are principally aimed at controlling the phasing of development works (i.e. the order of which the development comes forward) or to restrict occupation of a development until an action or series of actions have been completed; so for example to restrict the occupation of open market housing with a new development until such time as an agreed percentage of affordable housing has ... view the full minutes text for item 132.
(Councillor Knapper was not present for the consideration of this item) Members were notified of an additional objection from Councillor Knapper (Ward Member), relating to residential amenity and drainage.
Councillor Shotton moved and Councillor Knapper seconded the following motion:
Response provided by the Cabinet Member for Planning and Transformation (Councillor Adrian Knapper):- In June this year, the Cabinet considered a report on the government’s consultation on HS2, focused on the section between London and Birmingham. A response was submitted to government which supported the principle of HS2 extending north of Birmingham, subject to a station being provided to serve the local economy. HS2 Limited have been asked to give serious consideration to the need for a station on this section of the proposed route, and we are now liaising with adjacent authorities and LEP areas to develop a joint stance, ahead of the government’s plans to announce a proposed route in the new year.
On the motion of Councillor Bridges, seconded by Councillor Knapper , it was:-
( Councillor Knapper was not present for this item).
On the motion of Councillor Knapper, seconded by Councillor Rossenau, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Knapper , seconded by Councillor Platt, it was:-
Declaration Councillor Knapper 5 Personal – member of the Co-operative Party Personal – attended public consultation event in the capacity of Ward Member
This item was introduced by Councillor Knapper , Cabinet Member for Planning and Transportation.
Cabinet Members’ Comments/ Questions Councillor Gratton : Asked whether it was anticipated that other sites for Executive Housing had been identified and Councillor Knapper referred to the list included within the report.
This item was introduced by Councillor Knapper , Cabinet Member for Planning and Transportation and Councillor Rosenau, Cabinet Member for Regeneration.
Name Item Interest Nature Councillors Bridges , Gratton , Hamer , Knapper , Rosenau and Shotton 11 Personal As Governors of Schools in the City Councillor Knapper 9 Personal As a licensed landlord of properties in the City
Councillor Knapper , who had already declared a personal interest in this item, indicated that he was of the view that we needed to encourage more landlords to become accredited and that we needed to improve the quality of the housing stock in Stoke-on-Trent.
This item was presented by Councillor Knapper , Cabinet Member for Transport and Planning.
This item was also introduced by Councillor Knapper , Cabinet Member for Transport and Planning.
The Chair of that Committee ( Councillor Knapper ) and Councillor Matloob , a member of that Committee, reported that they had found the meeting to be useful and informative and commented on the need to provide the people of the City with a new bus station.
Councillor Knapper reported on the positive impact that greener energy could have for social housing tenants with lower cost heating and also commented on the need for local authorities and social housing landlords to have higher housing standards than private landlords and Councillor Garner confirmed that the aim was to raise housing standards across the board.
Councillor Knapper moved and Councillor Daniels seconded that the minutes of the Economic Development and Enterprise Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting held on 17 th and 26 th January 2011 be noted.
Councillor Knapper moved and Councillor Rosenau seconded that the minutes of the Economic Development and Enterprise Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting held on 6 December 2010 be noted.
Councillor Item Type of Interest Reason for Interest Councillor Adrian Knapper 50 Personal Credit Union Board Member
However, the rise in cost should not be above breakeven point 1-REG19 Asset Rationalisation – Review of Property Support 1-REG25 Charging for pre-application planning advice (for major applications only) Support 2-REG01 Cease provision of Christmas Illuminations Support (on the proviso that alternative are sought) 2-REG03 Providing companion element to concessionary buss pass for severely disabled (391 as at 01/08/10) Support 3-REG03 Dial-a-ride Support 3-REG09 Planning and Highways – Salary Savings Support 4-REG01 Subsidised bus services – cut all subsidies Support 4-REG05 Property Services – Salary Savings Support 5-REG01 Concessionary fares – introduction of morning peak period full fare Support (on the proviso that there is a consistent approach with Staffordshire County Council) Specific Grants Worklessness Support Enterprise Development Support Carbon Footprint Support Detrunking Support Road Safety Support Surface Water Management / Env Damage Support School Travel Advisor Support Sustainable Travel to School Officer Support Credit Union Support (Councillor Knapper abstained from voting on this item).
Cllr Knapper : Indicated that one of the issues regarding the settlement was that there had not been long enough to plan for the savings that were required and that it had not therefore been possible to have a long term strategy in place. ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Cllr Knapper was of the opinion that the coalition government was moving too fast and felt that under such circumstances funding and partnership working ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Councillor Item Type of Interest Reason for Interest Councillor Adrian Knapper 43 Personal Employed by an Estate Agent
Councillor Knapper moved that the matter be referred to the Economic Development and Enterprise Overview and Scrutiny Committee.
Councillor Knapper moved and Councillor Barnes seconded that the minutes of the Economic Development and Enterprise Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting held on 8 November 2010 be noted.
Councillor Knapper expressed concern regarding life expectancy especially in relation to obesity and smoking. He believed that there was a need for a message to be sent out that people should start to live a healthier lifestyle and that there should be activities to encourage people to take up exercise.
Ali, Councillor Baddeley , Councillor Barber, Councillor Barnes, Councillor Bowers, Councillor Bridges, Councillor Brown, Councillor Conteh , Councillor Conway, Councillor M Davis, Councillor T Fradley , Councillor Hamer , Councillor Hassall, Councillor Joynson , Councillor Knapper , Councillor Marfleet , Councillor Naylor, Councillor Pervez , Councillor Rosenau , Councillor Ryan
Julie Brough , Democratic Services Officer reported that Councillor Knapper had replaced Councillor Hamer as a Member of this Committee.
The Chair reported that Councillor Hamer had replaced Councillor Knapper and Councillor Brian had replaced Councillor Wright as Members of the Committee.
Councillor Knapper moved and Councillor B. Ali seconded that the minutes of the Economic Development and Enterprise Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting held on 20 September 2010 be noted.
Members Comments/Questions Cllr Knapper : Referred to the high levels of deprivation in Stoke-on-Trent and pockets of health inequalities which already existed and indicated that one of his main concerns was about what budget would be passed on when the changes were made. He felt that it would be appropriate to establish a working group over the next 6/7 months to ensure that the City was receiving the appropriate level of funding. Director of Adult Social Care, Health and Communities: Agreed with these comments, commenting that we needed to ensure that any changes to health services were adequately supported and resourced and that the resources currently held under the public health umbrella came over.
Davis, Councillor Knapper and Councillor Kent- Baguley regarding this item.
A motion was moved by Councillor Knapper , and seconded by Councillor J. Davis, ‘that, the following persons be appointed as the City Council’s Representatives to serve on the Management Committee’s of the Community Halls now indicated, and that the City Council nominations to serve on the Harold Clowes and Packmoor Community Halls be deferred until a subsequent meeting of the City Council, following discussion with Group Leaders.
Councillor Knapper moved and Councillor Sutton seconded that the minutes of the Economic Development and Enterprise Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting held on 12/7/10 be noted.
Councillor Knapper requested that the Directorate arrange visits to the relevant establishments so that Members could explore the services delivered.
Councillor Knapper welcomed support for carers and asked if there were any qualifications attached to the training that would assist them in future years.
The Chair (Councillor Knapper ) expressed a wish for the Committee to explore Business Tax Initiative areas.
The Chair (Councillor Knapper ) indicated that he had received a request from Councillor Barnes for the Committee to look at the Local Strategic Partnership (LSP) funding cuts to the Area Based Grant. The Scrutiny Officer confirmed that he would obtain more information on this and the other suggestions before discussing further with the Chair.
Councillor Knapper : Referred to the substantial funding cuts being made by Central Government and expressed concern that these would exacerbate the problems which already existed within the City such as low skill base, poor housing, access to employment, health issues etc suggesting that the City Council faced a major challenge to continue to tackle these issues in the funding and economic climate which existed.
Councillor Knapper requested that the Committee receive a presentation from the new Interim Manager at a future meeting to provide their vision and plans for the theatre and suggested that a further site visit be arranged once the new Committee was appointed. The Project Manager agreed that these could be arranged.
Councillor Knapper also suggested that local businesses be approached to obtain their interest in appointing members to the Trust. The Chair emphasised the importance of the Trust and asked that the positions be advertised again. The Project Manager confirmed that the positions could be re-advertised.
- PFI Scheme - Role of Governing Bodies The Chair: Also referred to items which had been raised with him by Councillor Knapper for possible inclusion in the Work Programme which were as follows:
The Lead Petitioner, Councillor Adrian Knapper , addressed the City Council on behalf of the 432 signatories to the petition.
The following amendment was then moved by Councillor Pervez , and seconded by Councillor Knapper :- ‘At the end of 2.1 add the following words and the following amendments, which do not affect the total general fund revenue budget, are made to the detailed budgets set out in the report:
Councillor Knapper commented that there appeared to be several different brands such as for the British Ceramics Bienniel , UniQ and Federation of the 6 Towns. He believed there should be just one brand.
Outside Bodies Councillor Knapper confirmed that he was on the Ceramica Trust and not Groundwork as stated in the report.
Interest Nature Councillor Knapper 5 Personal Campaigned against similar use of nearby sites for car storage as part of election campaign Councillor Bell 6 Personal Knows parties involved
(Councillor Knapper was not present for the consideration of this item) Members were informed that, since the report was published, discussions had continued between the applicant and the Environment Agency (EA), and that two further written responses had been received from the EA outlining their concerns. In response to these concerns, the applicant had made a number of additional comments.
Councillor Knapper commented that there were a lot of skills in the City but a low education base and the key was removing barriers. He expressed a wish to see social enterprise promoted and a dedicated officer.
Councillor Knapper expressed his wish to be appointed as the Committee’s representative on Ceramica Trust Board of Management.
Following a requisition signed by twenty two members of the City Council, in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 3.01, the City Council debated the following motion, moved by Councillor Salih and seconded by Councillor Kent- Baguley :- ‘That this City Council deplores the fact that press statements were issued on redundancies at the City Council before elected members were informed and further deplores the failure of the Executive to supply the financial information required by the Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee when it was briefed on the City Council’s financial crisis on 14 September 2009, thus preventing effective scrutiny of the Executive’s proposal to make more than 400 staffing positions redundant.’ An amendment to the motion was moved by Councillor Pevez and seconded by Councillor Knapper , which read:- ‘Insert paragraph 1 below before the words “This City Council deplores… 1. That this Council recognises the seriousness of the financial situation it faces. Like under all local authorities under the current economic climate we will have less income and increased pressure on expenditure.
Name Minute No Interest Nature Councillor A Knapper 59 Personal and Prejudicial Raised concerns over the proposals through a letter sent by the Local Neighbourhood Manager on behalf of ward members.
Councillor Knapper believed that an Action Plan should be produced to explain what was being done to address the recommendations of the Audit Commission report. He also expressed a wish to see the Business Plan revised to include firm timescales for development.
Councillor Knapper requested that in the event that the RBS Bank split up its banking headquarters M.P’s be lobbied to try and attract RBS to relocate to the Business District.
Councillor Knapper 45 Personal and Prejudicial Has had previous discussions regarding the application with the applicant Councillor Follows 47 Personal and Prejudicial Is a friend of the applicant
He went on to move the following motion, which was seconded by Councillor Knapper:- “that Stoke-on-Trent City Council has no confidence in the Chair and Vice Chair of the Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent Combined Fire Authority.” Following a debate on the appropriateness of the motion, Councillor Barnes explained that he was happy to withdraw it and allow the Leader of the Council to take the matter forward in the way he had outlined.
Councillor Knapper, as the seconder, consented to the withdrawal of the motion but the majority of Members present and voting in the Chamber did not consent to its withdrawal.
Councillor Knapper then moved that the petition be referred to the relevant Overview and Scrutiny Committee.
Councillor Knapper moved, and Councillor Barnes seconded that the petition referred to at (b) above be referred to the relevant Overview and Scrutiny Committee, but on being put to the vote the motion was lost and it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Knapper , seconded by Councillor Ward, it was:-
On the Motion of Councillor Knapper , seconded by Councillor P. Joynson , it was:
On the motion of Councillor Barnes, seconded by Councillor Knapper, it was:-
Councillor Knapper – Question read out in his absence. Written response to be provided.
Councillor Knapper believed that it was important that in the current economic care was taken that Section 106 obligations did not stop developments from taking place.
Councillor Knapper suggested that as not all Members of the Committee were present, a letter be sent to Group Leaders asking them for nominations to the outside bodies.
On the Motion of Councillor Knapper , seconded by Councillor Follows, it was:
Councillor Knapper moved and Councillor Shotton seconded, ‘that Councillor B. Ali (Labour) be appointed the fifteenth seat on the Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee’. This motion was supported when put to the vote.
Members Comments/Questions Councillor Knapper: Agreed that it was important to raise the creative image of the city and asked if the government would be providing direct funding for the scheme.
This item was introduced by Councillor Knapper , Portfolio Holder.
Members Comments/Questions Councillor Knapper : Referred to the Street Games initiative and expressed disappointment that not all wards had, for various reasons, decided to participate in this. A discussion also took place with regard to ward budgets.
This item was introduced by Councillor Knapper , Portfolio Holder for Economic Development.
Councillor Knapper indicated that he was unable to support either option 2(a) or 2(b) as his view was that if there were to be a 14 th school then it should be in the centre of the City i.e. in the Bucknall area and that neither of the options presented satisfied the needs of the community which he represented.
She congratulated the Trentham community for their persistence and sympathised with Councillor Knapper and suggested that he continue to take this matter up with the minister. She expressed her support for option 2(b).
This item was introduced by Councillor Knapper , Portfolio Holder for Economic Development.
The Panel noted that Councillor Adrian Knapper had replaced Councillor Michael Barnes and that Councillor Hazel Lyth had replaced Councillor Joanne Powell-Beckett as members of the Licensing and Registration Panel.
Councillor Pyatt Para. 201 Report on Petitions Received Personal Involved with a stall on Stoke Market Councillor Billington Para 208 Motion moved by Councillor Webb Personal Holder of a licence affected by the Market Franchise Policy Councillor Conteh Para. 207 Periodic report of the Chair of Staffordshire Police Authority Personal Member of Staffordshire Police Authority Councillor Knapper and Garner Para 204 – Discussion on the NSRP Personal NSRP Board Members Councillors Garner, Dale and Hall Para. 196 – Housing Revenue Account Personal Council House Tenant Councillor Barnes Para. 223 – Improving Communities O&S Committee - reference to Kier Stoke Personal Offered hospitality by Kier (Declaration made in Register)
Members Comments/Questions Councillor Knapper suggested that a message be sent out to all members explaining how this funding could be accessed.
Councillor Pervez introduced the report and Councillor Knapper , Portfolio Holder for Economic Development, presented the decisions.
Members Comments/Questions Councillor Knapper referred to the shortage of bungalows in the City and Alan Slater confirmed that this was an issue that was being brought forward and the aspiration was that the City Council would continue to develop this type of housing through traditional funding and also via PFI.
Members Comments/Questions Councillor Knapper welcomed the report, indicating that it helped the most vulnerable who sometimes found it difficult to maintain their homes.
Councillor Knapper referred to the protests that had taken place when the original decision had been made by this Board, specifically from the parents and pupils at Heathfield School. He indicated that the recommendation made at the Children and Young People’s Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting regarding the call-in had been in respect of Trentham High School. He therefore sought clarification that the proposals for the Special Schools had also been considered by the Scrutiny Committee.
Councillor Knapper commented on the levels of rent being collected and questioned whether it had been cost effective for doorstep collections.
On the motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Knapper it was:-
Councillor Knapper also declared an interest in the same item as a member of the Co-operative Society.
· Confirmed that this was the case Councillor Knapper:
This item was introduced by Councillor Knapper. Phil Brundrett confirmed that ward members had been very supportive of these proposals.
This item was introduced by Councillor Knapper (Portfolio Holder for Regeneration).
Councillor Knapper , as Ward Councillor addressed the meeting on behalf of local residents objecting to the application. The Committee also received representations from the applicant, Steve Lowndes .
Outside Bodies North Staffordshire Warm Zone – John Ross confirmed that this vacancy had now been filled by Councillor Knapper.
The Committee received representations from Steve Lowndes, the applicant, and Councillor Adrian Knapper, third party, objecting to the application.
Councillor Knapper felt it was important that the strategy be endorsed and commented that people were fearful of going into fuel poverty. He believed that there only had to be one harsh winter to cause many people to go into debt.
Members’ Comments/Questions This item was introduced by Councillor Knapper , Portfolio Holder for Economic Development.
In addition, Councillor Knapper , Portfolio Holder, indicated that he would ensure that he visited the service to see the issues first hand.
(iv) Councillor Knapper be appointed as the City Council representative to serve on the North Staffordshire Warm Zone Steering Group.
(v) Councillor Knapper be replaced by Councillor Joan Bell as the City Council’s representative on Empowering People Inspiring Communities (E.P.I.C) Ltd (vi) All councillor appointments to outside bodies and partner organisations are dependant on them being a serving member of the City Council, and should cease if their membership of the City Council ends ..
On the Motion of Councillor Garner seconded by Councillor Knapper , it was:
Councillor Knapper , Portfolio Holder for Children and Young People’s Services, introduced this item. [name removed], Director of Children and Young People’s Services, circulated amendments to the report and went through those amendmendments .
This item was introduced by Councillor Knapper , Portfolio Holder for Children and Young People’s Serevices .
Councillor Knapper welcomed the report and felt that this would make the area a safer place for residents to live in.
Councillor Tolley moved and Councillor Knapper seconded ‘that the persons referred to in the schedule placed around the Chamber be appointed as the City Council’s representatives to serve on the governing bodies of the schools indicated’.
Councillor Knapper agreed with the comments made by Councillor Smith, particularly regarding the fact that this project was introduced for safety reasons and not to increase revenue.
Councillor Knapper expressed the hope that the City Council would now start to invest in all parks in the City.
Councillor Knapper indicated that he had high rise flats in his ward and welcomed anything that improved the quality of cleaning in them. He referred to the fact that there was an issue with regard to bins and that we needed to keep a close eye on this.
Councillor Knapper referred to reports about emergency services not being able to get to calls because of inconsiderate parking and emphasised the need to treat the highways with respect.
Councillor Knapper indicated that, as a ward councillor, he would like to make a point about the letter which had gone out to all residents last Thursday and indicated that residents had expressed concern to him that the letters were addressed to the ‘Occupier’. He indicated that the phone line referred to within that letter had been engaged all day and that, after he had contacted officers, the phone line had been manned but he felt that we needed to sort out how we communicated and dealt with situations such as these. He indicated that the City Council needed to support residents and that Members and residents had been told that we would be using local workmen but that did not seem to be the case.
He indicated that Members were crucial in delivering the messages and Councillor Smith agreed that Councillor Knapper had raised a number of crucial issues but that it was necessary to preface this statement by saying that this was one of the most difficult facets of urban regeneration and that there was going to be some degree of pain. A sensitive approach was paramount and RENEW were moving towards a more responsible approach of looking at the needs of the community and a more flexible approach and suggested that this was progressed but that there were still more lessons which needed to be learned.
Councillor Knapper indicated that when the Council considered selling land it needed to be linked in with other Council policies and it was not just about bringing in money but also the need to decide what the population in the City wanted.
Councillor Knapper expressed concerns about the way that small businesses were often disadvantaged as a result of the Compulsory Purchase Order process.
Georgina Patel took on the point made by Councillor Knapper with regard to the effect on small businesses and indicated that it was known that a gap existed with regard to this section of people and that they were working with RENEW and had also appointed a Business Relocation Officer to assist small businesses. A discussion then took place with regard to what financial packages had been made available to residents in the Slater Street area and Steve Robinson indicated that there was a lot of consideration with regard to relocation grants and that it had become clear as the Housing Market Renewal Prospectus was being developed that the Government had concerns about some of the approaches that were being taken. In the end, support through the relocation loans had been deemed by the Government to be the most appropriate way forward.
Councillor Knapper felt that the report should have included some reference to climate change and asked for such comments to be included in future reports. Brian Davis explained that the City Council was also obliged to produce statements in relation to climate change and that it was necessary to avoid any undue duplication but accepted that it could have been possible to have included some comments about climate change within this report.
Councillor Knapper made reference to the risks identified, mindful that the Authority had to make a number of payments in respect of redundancy costs and Single Status. James Cook reported that if the Audit Commission had any concern regarding the level of reserves a comment would have been made to reflect their concerns. He accepted that the Authority were keen to settle any outstanding claims but, added that there was a need to be mindful of the future impact on Council Tax levels.
A further motion, moved by Councillor Irving and seconded by Councillor Knapper , ‘that Sid Bourne of 65 Woodhead Road, Abbey Hulton, Stoke-on-Trent, be appointed as the City Council’s representative to serve on the Joiners Square Community Hall Management Committee for the remainder of the municipal year’, was carried.
Councillor Knapper referred to the importance of this service and Councillor Ibbs acknowledged that it was an important service and that this represented another example of joint working with the PCT.
Councillor Knapper felt that this was a positive use of technology and would help the more vulnerable in society. He also indicated that he would like to see this initiative promoted as widely as possible.
Councillor Knapper welcomed the proposals and stated that the fair Trade Café was an excellent idea. He enquired if there would be a role for the voluntary sector.
Councillor Knapper commented that this was a moderate increase and that more pupils should be encouraged to have school dinners to ensure that they get at least one hot, well-balanced, healthy meal a day.
Councillor Knapper , the Chair of the Review, indicated that there were opportunities for people to engage and to use social enterprise. The Chair (Mayor Meredith) agreed that the task and finish group had produced excellent work over the year and that we now needed to ensure that the North Staffs Regeneration Partnership Board discussed their recommendations and took them on board as far as possible.
Councillor Knapper referred to the fact that it was important to encourage people to take up allotments as it was necessary to ensure that they were fully utilised.
Councillor Knapper referred to residents’ car parking and felt that there needed to be a charge for car parking, particularly as most of the people who parked in the centre of Hanley were workers and not shoppers. He suggested that it may be appropriate to look at the establishment of a workers’ car park where charges were reasonable.
Councillor Knapper felt that it was important to ensure that the population of Stoke-on-Trent understood what this item was about and the Chair indicated that he hoped that officers/members would be able to work with the public so that they could ensure that they were aware of the options available.
Councillor Knapper felt that it was necessary to ensure that the support was there for re-housing for residents having to move from these areas and also referred to the importance of ensuring that support was in place for businesses affected.
Councillor Knapper referred to the need to also ensure that residents’ parking was looked at in the whole of the area and suggested that RENEW needed to take up this issue.
Councillor Knapper expressed similar concerns and also referred to the need to provide a simple process for the elderly to provide feedback in respect of the services they were receiving.
Councillor Knapper commended the report recommendations to the Commission and felt that it was important to submit these to the Executive as soon as possible. He paid tribute to Colin Hunton who had supported the Task and Finish Group and was in the process of up a Credit Union in North Staffordshire. Colin Hunton explained that the main conclusions of the group were that there were many types of Social Enterprises but all were set up as a business for social reasons.
Type of Interest Nature of Interest Councillor Knapper 5(e) Personal and Prejudicial Interest and left the room whilst this item was under consideration Member of the Landlord Accreditation Panel
Councillor Knapper expressed his support for this order to be made.
Councillor James expressed concern about how people would be able to afford the new housing provision and Councillor Knapper commented on his concerns about the size and standard of new provision. Councillors Ibbs, A. Joynson and S.
Members’ Questions/Comments Councillor Knapper supported the document presented and suggested that when it was adopted, Members of the Development Control Committee should received full training.
Councillor Knapper moved that the minutes of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee meeting held on 26 March 2007 be noted.
Councillor Knapper moved that the minutes of the Resources Overview and Scrutiny Commission meeting held on 16 March 2007 be noted.
· Councillor Knapper commented that in order for the City to be successful, it needed better infrastructure in place and suggested following Norwich’s example of introducing wireless technology throughout the City. · Councillor Owen commented that the City needed creative vision in order to break out of the rut of creating part-time low-paid jobs.
· Councillor Knapper suggested that the City organised its own conference around medical technology and IT etc in order to provide the opportunity to show companies what the City had to offer.
· Councillor Knapper stressed the need for action to be taken so that the City could continue to run markets.
· Councillor Knapper requested that any profit from markets be ring-fenced and reinvested in the markets.
· Councillor Knapper requested that site be found for the City’s Sunday market before the closure of Clough Street car park.
Councillor Knapper believed that local knowledge was important and that some drivers did need to be educated to drive more sensibly. He believed that it was important for the Partnership to work at a local level. Steve Robinson agreed that this initiative should be taken to the local area teams.
Councillor Knapper expressed a wish for the City Council to review the budget for flooding as there were problems in many of the City’s Wards.
Councillor Knapper requested that the City Council’s procedure on valuations be reviewed.
John Gething confirmed that a meeting had been scheduled with the Chief Executive and appropriate officers and the developers on the 14 May 2007. · Councillor Knapper requested that the Commission receive an update on the East/West Precinct after 14 May 2007.
· Councillor Knapper referred to the park-and-ride project. In his opinion a park and ride facility was unnecessary and concentration should be on ensuring that there was a regular, reliable bus service serving all residential areas.
· Councillor Knapper referred to the conversion of the Weatherby Pottery site off Town Road in the City Centre and felt that there were too many apartment developments in the City. He believed that the building would be put to better use if converted to ... view the full minutes text for item 3.
· Councillor Knapper referred to property sales, suggesting that in addition to Best Value, Officers need to ensure that best use of the land/property was made in order to avoid the City being left with derelict buildings etc. He suggested that the Commission receive an update report in respect of land sold and end result.
· Councillor Knapper commented on the Bentilee Neighbourhood Centre, expressing some concern in relation to the unoccupied areas.
Commission Members made the following comments:- · Councillor Knapper suggested that consideration be given to the use of local contractors, mindful that they had been affected by RENEW works.
Commission Members made the following comments:- · Councillor Knapper enquired as to whether any improvements could be made to suggest that the building was still in use. Officers commented on the restrictions associated with listed buildings in Conservation Areas.
· Councillor Knapper stressed that Stoke-on-Trent was the major city between Manchester and Birmingham and that the City should be given a fair deal.
· Councillor Billington queried the Members’ role on the Regional Assembly and requested that a covering letter accompany our response to explain the reasons behind it. · Councillor Matloob felt that thought should be given to provision for future generations and facilities provided for those people living outside of the City. · Councillor Knapper believed that the ambition of the City should be looked at including ... view the full minutes text for item 3.
· With regard to the Executive’s intentions to agree standard lease terms, Councillor Knapper asked what break clauses would be put in for circumstances where the running of the hall went wrong or the management committee got into difficulties.
· Councillor Knapper pressed for more regular scheduled meetings.
· Councillor Knapper pointed out the need to create a pleasant greenspace within the City.
· Councillor Knapper added that there would be an inevitable impact on services. He also commented that, if slippage occurred during the year, other savings would have to be found. He therefore stressed the need for careful monitoring and control.
Commission Members made the following comments:- · Councillor Knapper questioned in more detail the reasons for the variance between the tender total figure and final cost.
· Councillor Knapper highlighted the importance to the local economy of the local authority procuring goods services through locally based companies, where possible.
He articulated his desire to promote a functional relationship and urged Councillor Knapper to take that message back to the Committee.
Councillor Knapper commented that, although he disagreed with the system, he fully supported efforts made by Elected Members to make it work.
Councillor Knapper commented that where development sites were situated near to housing, there should be consultation with residents and a buffer zone created through planting.
Commission Members made the following comments:- Councillor Knapper felt that there was an issue in respect of the quality of new housing developments Councillor Wanger made reference to affordable housing and believed that the houses would not be sold on at low cost in the future.
Councillor Knapper referred to neighbourhood management and asked what work could be done with the communities to enable them to access funds Aktar Choudhury confirmed that a project had recently been commissioned and £50k allocated to each Area Implementation Team. He indicated that a project could only be funded if it originated from the residents.
She further asked what the legal position was in respect of the members undertaking the inspections. · Councillor Knapper – supported the idea of the Panel and ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
The following Members declared interests as detailed, in accordance with the provisions of the City Council’s Constitution:- Member Item Type of Interest Nature of Interest Chair (Councillor Knapper) Clause 10 – Overview and Scrutiny Commissions – Summary Decision/Action Sheets - Health Personal Non-Executive Board Director - Stoke North PCT.
Councillor Knapper stated that this was about trying to find a solution and asked if democratic services could also block some slots in the corporate diary to keep them free for task and finish activity.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Knapper attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 18 Jul 2008 | City Council | Stoke-on-Trent Governance Commission | Carried | 33 for, 22 against | |
| 18 Jul 2008 | City Council | Report of the Independent Remuneration Panel | Lost | 26 for, 31 against |
Meetings Councillor Knapper was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 6 of 12 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Knapper declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 21 Jan 2009 | (archived) Executive and Members Board, item 120 | Councillor Knapper also declared an interest in the same item as a member of the Co-operative Society. |
Where Councillor Knapper sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| City Council | Committee Member | Mar 2007 | 38 | 17 Dec 2026 |
| Housing, Regeneration & Operations Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2026 | 3 | 7 Dec 2026 |
| Adult Social Care, Health Integration and Wellbeing Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Aug 2026 | 3 | 3 Dec 2026 |
| Licensing and Appeals Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2026 | 1 | |
| Planning Committee - Development Management | Committee Member | Apr 2010 | 30 | |
| (archived) Executive and Members Board | Cabinet Member | May 2007 | 28 | |
| Planning Committee - Policy Group | Committee Member | Oct 2011 | 20 | |
| (archived) Sports Ground Panel | Committee Member | Jul 2007 | 13 | |
| (archived) Mitchell Memorial Youth Centre Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2007 | 10 | |
| Cabinet | Cabinet Member | Jun 2011 | 9 | |
| (archived) Audit Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2007 | 8 | |
| (archived) Councillors Forum | Committee Member | Aug 2007 | 8 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2007 | 7 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Adults and Older People's Wellbeing | Committee Member | May 2010 | 7 | |
| Health and Wellbeing Board | Vice-Chair | May 2012 | 7 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Economic Development and Enterprise | Chair | Apr 2010 | 6 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Adult and Neighbourhoods | Cabinet Representative | May 2012 | 6 | |
| (archived) General Purposes Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2008 | 5 | |
| (archived) Development Control Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2007 | 4 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Commission - Resources | Committee Member | Nov 2006 | 2 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Commission - Regeneration | Committee Member | Apr 2007 | 2 | |
| Way Panel | Committee Member | Nov 2008 | 2 | |
| Local Strategic Partnership - Strategic Policy and Investment Group (Strategic Group) | Committee Member | Jun 2010 | 2 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - City Renewal | Cabinet Representative | Jul 2011 | 2 | |
| (archived) Standards Committee | Committee Member | May 2013 | 2 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Commission - Health | Observer | May 2007 | 1 | |
| Community Hall Association - Joiners Square | Committee Member | Aug 2007 | 1 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Children and Young People | Committee Member | Jun 2008 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.