Planning: National Scheme of Delegation
On the motion of Councillor Gordon-McCusker, seconded by Councillor Platt, when put to the vote, the motion received the majority support of the Council and, of those present and voting, it was :
Every time Stoke-on-Trent's minutes name Councillor Platt, as the council published it.
On the motion of Councillor Gordon-McCusker, seconded by Councillor Platt, when put to the vote, the motion received the majority support of the Council and, of those present and voting, it was :
On the motion of Councillor Platt, seconded by Councillor G. Watson, it was resolved that Councillor L. Beardmore be appointed as Chair of the Strategy and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the 2026/27 Municipal Year.
Watkins, it was resolved that Councillor Platt be appointed as Vice-Chair of the Strategy and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the 2026/27 Municipal Year.
On the motion of Councillor Platt, seconded by Councillor Singh Kallar, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Platt, seconded by Councillor Akkurt, it was:-
A Motion, moved by Councillor Platt, seconded by Councillor A.
Committee Member Minute Number Disclosure Comments Councillor A Platt (Chair) 66 Personal Councillor A Platt noted that he had worked for the applicant approximately 30 years prior, for a short time, but confirmed he did not know the attendees present at the meeting, that he sat with an open mind and that he had not predetermined the application.
The Committee then voted and agreed to allow Councillor Andy Platt to speak as an observer.
Councillor Platt requested that the flooding issue be revisited at a future Committee meeting with a full report for the Committee to consider, as he was concerned that a petition in regard to flooding on London Road in 2020 had still not been responded to. The Committee were told that 52 priority locations had been identified by the new flooding officer, however it was agreed that a new, detailed report would be provided to the Committee in July.
In the meantime, officers agreed to provide Councillor Platt with a response to his petition. The Committee also requested that Severn Trent Water be asked to attend the meeting in July, as the Committee also raised concerns about recent sewage leaks on the roads, as well as concerns about how Severn Trent Water would resolve any flooding issues.
The following motion was moved by Councillor Platt and seconded by Councillor Robinson:
Following discussions with the Committee, it was agreed that Councillor Platt would lead on the Governance of Council Owned Companies, Councillor Glen Watson would lead on the Human Resources Review and Councillor Carter would lead on the Use and Implementation of AI in the City Council.
In the absence of further nominations and on the motion of Councillor Colclough, seconded by Councillor Platt, when put to the vote, the motion received the support of the Council and, of those present and voting, it was unanimously :
On the motion of Councillor Platt, seconded by Councillor Evans, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Gordon-McCusker, seconded by Councillor Platt, it was:
The following motion was moved by Councillor Platt and seconded by Councillor Santoro:
Disclosure Comments Councillor A Platt (Vice-Chair, in the Chair) 42 Personal Councillor A Platt confirmed he had been invited to attend the site (and believed all Committee Members had been). He confirmed he had not attended, and there were no indications from other Committee Members to suggest they had either.
Councillor A Platt (Vice-Chair, in the Chair) 42 Personal Councillor A Platt confirmed he had worked on the application site, but that this had been a long time ago, and he did not believe the current applicant would know this or remember him.
Following a detailed debate, Councillor Platt moved a procedural motion, seconded by Councillor Mountford, ‘that the question now be put’. The Monitoring Officer advised that the motion, which was a form of closure motion in relation to the debate, needed ... view the full minutes text for item 63.
The Vice-Chair, Councillor Platt, took the Chair for this item in the absence of the Chair (Councillor Jellyman).
On the motion of Councillor Platt, seconded by Councillor Elliott, it was:
As a result, a procedural motion, moved by Councillor A Platt and seconded by Councillor R Irving, to adjourn consideration of the matter to a future meeting, was supported when put to the vote.
Following a detailed debate, Councillor Pender moved and Councillor Platt seconded that a recorded vote be taken.
A Motion, moved by Councillor Pitt, seconded by Councillor Singh Kallar, that “Councillor Andy Platt be appointed as Vice-Chair of the Planning Committee – Development Management, for the 2022/2023 Municipal Year”, was carried.
Councillor A Platt 44 Personal Councillor Platt noted that attendees may have seen him engaging in a conversation with the applicant’s agent, [name removed]. He advised that the conversation he had engaged in was completely unrelated to the case under consideration.
Councillor Platt 29 Non-Pecuniary Councillor Platt confirmed he had received a generic communication from the applicant, and that he had an open mind regarding the application.
On the motion of Councillor Platt, seconded by Councillor Bridges, it was:-
Councillor Platt proposed that the vote on the nominations was a recorded vote and this was supported by more than 18 members of the Council in accordance with the requirements of Council Procedure Rule 15.05.
The Director acknowledged this point but commented upon the costs involved, the need to be fair to all institutions within the City and the fact that this path was unlikely to be a priority, Councillor Platt asked about the different types of finish that could be used and the Engineering and Commissioning Manager gave details of the different surfaces and associated maintenance costs.
Councillor Platt asked what the operators views were regarding the proposal to close the bus lane on Church Street, Stoke.
Councillor Platt also asked about technological changes, including contactless payment, use of USB charging and wifi and asked if these facilities would become available as in other places and if so when. David Reeves outlined details of the investment they made by D&G to date. First Bus indicated that they could not invest in everything at the same time and that First nationally would invest in areas where there was a good working relationship with the local authority, citing Leeds as an example of this.
Councillor Platt also commented upon multi-user tickets which he did not feel were very well advertised by either First ... view the full minutes text for item 69.
Councillor A Platt 77 Non-Pecuniary Councillor A Platt confirmed he had received an e-mail regarding the application, which he had not read and therefore remained open-minded about the item.
Councillor Evans was not present for the consideration of this item, and therefore the Vice-Chair, Councillor Platt, Chaired this item.
Councillor Platt moved and Councillor Shotton seconded the motion that the Committee set up a Task and Finish Group to look at this issue. This course of action was agreed by the Committee.
Councillor Platt asked for an update in respect of the Hanford Waste Contract as referred to in Appendix A of the report and the Assistant Director – Operational Management gave details of the latest position that included an agreed extension of five years to the existing contract to allow time to put a new facility in place.
Councillor Platt also asked for information regarding CS07_1819 referred to in Appendix B of the report in relation to the removal of illuminated highways signage from the PFI Contract and the Cabinet Member for Regeneration, Transport and Heritage explained that this related to an issue which had also been discussed at the previous meeting of the Committee confirming that this was no longer taking place as it would not realise savings as there were minimum requirements relating to the PFI Contract for street lighting.
Brown moved and Councillor Follows seconded a motion “ That Council approve the Pay Policy Statement for 2019/20 as attached in Appendix 1 of the report submitted .” Councillor Platt moved and Councillor Pender seconded, an amendment which had the effect of adding the following words to paragraph 1 (1.2) on page 1 of the Pay Policy Statement, which was attached as Appendix 1 to the report submitted – “Para.
The following disclosures of interest were made:- Name Item Interest Nature Councillor Platt (Vice-Chair) 63 Non-Pecuniary Holder of a Titanic Brewery loyalty card and knows the Directors at Titanic Brewery and [name removed] (neighbour) Councillor Platt (Vice-Chair) 64 Non-Pecuniary Ward Member for Boothen and Oakhill ward which borders the site and knows many of the neighbours and had received contact from neighbours Councillor Follows 64 Non-Pecuniary Ward Councillor for Hanford and Trentham
Councillor Platt made reference to the meeting of Staffordshire County Council’s Corporate Review Committee on 8 January 2019 which had been attended by this Committee and asked whether these minutes would be received at a future meeting of this Committee. Paul Baddeley, Scrutiny Officer confirmed that he had received the draft minutes of that meeting and that he would include the approved minutes within the Committee’s Work Programme.
Councillor Platt asked for an update in respect of Stoke Station access to Platform 2 from Glebe Street which could have a positive impact on the usage of Wharf Place Car Park (also known as Stoke Station West) and was also important to the future use of Winton Square. The Director of Place, Growth and Prosperity provided the Committee with an update confirming that Virgin Trains had been approached with regard to access and they had confirmed that they would not look at this issue as part of its current franchise which ended in Autumn 2019. He also commented in relation to a question which had been asked at the previous meeting of the Committee about land/car parking currently not being used at the rear of the stationand explained that the way in which the Network Rail investment process operated meant that the operators couldn’t bid for Network Rail capital within a specified timescale.
Appendix B BS01 and BS3 – Planning Services 2017/18 and 2018/19 Councillor Platt asked why these two proposals were red and amber respectively and the Cabinet Member for Finance and Partnerships explained that this was due to changes in legislation that prevented the implementation of the proposed charges and was also about timing of income being received.
BS56 – Highways and Transportation – Efficiency savings related to investment in more efficient and low maintenance LED 2017/18 Councillor Platt asked why this issue had arisen and the Assistant Director – Operational Management explained that there were two reasons associated with this saving showing as Amber; firstly a previous proposal in relation to traffic signal heads would not have delivered an adequate return on investment and secondly, the scheme had reached its de-accrual limit within the contract and therefore the project had terminated.
BS37- Rental Income from the development of additional industrial units In response to a question from Councillor Platt regarding this proposal showing as Red, the Director of Place, Growth and Prosperity explained that this was due to the phasing of the proposal in terms of its delivery.
2017/18 - £500k 2018/19 - £750k 2019/20 - £1.5m Councillor Platt also asked about progress in relation to improving the WiFi in Stoke Market and commented on difficulties in letting stalls in that market. He further commented with regard to a recent consultation exercise that had been undertaken and expressed disappointment about how this had been conducted in relation to Stoke Market indicating that consultation with regard to other council markets had been conducted better.
Phil Cresswell indicated that he would look into this issue in the light of concerns raised by Councillor Platt and report back thereon to a future meeting. The Chair added that he had also not received any information, even though he was a Ward Councillor for the area, in respect of Tunstall Town Hall refurbishment.
Councillor Platt referred to the actions from the Committee meeting on 14 December 2017 in respect of the Stoke Station Masterplan and the circulation of the presentation to the members of the Committee and commented that the delay in receiving a copy of the slides was as requested previously by the Committee was unacceptable. Phil Cresswell agreed to review the position in respect of this request with the Department for Communities and Local Government.
Councillor Platt added that the City Centre Ring Road defined the City Centre and that the changes to the original proposals significantly changed that. The Chair expressed the view that this was the first that he had been informed of these changes and that this Committee would like to hear about any such changes.
Councillor A Platt 82 & 83 Non-Pecuniary Councillor A Platt confirmed he had received a number of phone calls from Residents living in the North of City regarding the applications.
Councillor Platt indicated that the comparator information, as requested, was useful.
Councillor Platt enquired if there had been a policy decision to change the way that Councillors reporting potholes was dealt with and the Cabinet Member for Regeneration, Transport and Heritage confirmed that there had been to change of policy but that a pre-inspection regime was now being tested and provided details of the trial process accordingly. Following a discussion it was agreed that information be provided in relation to the amount of time that it takes to undertake an inspection following a request to fix a pot hole and the average amount of time that it takes to carry out a repair.
Councillor Platt referred to the variance in relation to security indicating that this had been put forward for a number of years and questioned whether it was legitimate to have had it as a saving for two years and the Assistant Director – Operational Management indicated that the Council had different security needs than two years before and were now at the position of knowing what was needed. Continuing, the Assistant Director acknowledged that there was still a large underspend on the budget but that work was progressing. The Committee requested information in relation to security be provided to a future meeting.
Councillor Platt also referred to Concessionary Fares and the reduction in bus routes.
In response to a question form Councillor Platt, Andrew Briggs also gave an update on the position in relation to the geothermal well commenting upon the significant challenges in the market in recent times confirming that officers were working with relevant parties to produce geothermal at an affordable price.
Councillor Platt also commented on the fact that one of the aspirations was to also have domestic customers and asked what approaches had been made to residents. The Strategic Manager reported that the Council was not looking to do this in Stoke and that it would be years 5-7 when we would be in a position to make a connection to domestic supply.
Councillor Platt also asked officers to consider putting up positive signage on the Scheme.
At the end of the debate Councillor Platt suggested that the City Council should re-consider its intention to consider the matter in open session and move towards excluding the public to enable the exempt Appendix to be considered prior to a decision being taken. The Lord Mayor acknowledged the argument put forward and proposed that the press and public be excluded from the meeting to facilitate the wishes of the member concerned. At this point in the proceedings the proposal was not immediately seconded and the mover of the original motion had already exercised his right of reply in accordance with the Procedure Rules.
A motion moved by Councillor Platt and seconded by Councillor Evans, to include an additional condition that required the acoustic fencing to be coloured, preferably in forest green, and some additional planting to be included along the fencing barrier, was carried when put to the vote.
Councillor Platt asked about the works to Glebe Street Bridge, which had overran and asked how the Programme had been done.
Councillor Platt asked what had happened as it was normal practice to have legal agreements in place with the utilities when this type of work needed to be carried out. The Interim Director of Place, Growth and Prosperity reported that there was an on-going dialogue with the utilities regarding this issue and as such it was not appropriate to discuss it.
Councillor Platt asked for the details regarding this situation to be supplied to him after the meeting.
Councillor Platt asked about the construction of the Road and asked if it would be a dual carriageway with cycle paths as it was crucial to create the right capacity. The Cabinet Member explained that the design would depend on the modelling for the Scheme and that there was not yet this level of detai. Once proposals were available then these would be subject to consultation.
Councillor Platt also welcomed the funding for Spode Start Up Incubator Building No.5.
Councillor Platt indicated that he had found these visits to be useful and queried whether any further actions were required following on from these. The Scrutiny Officer explained that their purpose had been to familiarise members with the Spode Site and with plans for the City Centre and that there were no follow up actions were indicated during the visits. He confirmed that he had made notes from these meetings which he would share with members of the Committee.
Councillor Platt asked whether it may be appropriate to receive a report on how the Asset Management Plan had been produced and the Acting Director agreed to provide a process report to the next meeting to explain what work had been undertaken to date and the current position.
Name Item Interest Nature Councillor A Platt Item 4 Personal Councillor Platt knew Joan Walley, who had previously spoken on this application, and was present at the meeting.
Councillor Platt referred to groups in the area who may be prepared to come forward to run the community centre and [name removed] indicated that if this was the case she would help and support them. She also expressed concern about the equipment that had been bought by groups using the Hall if it were to close without prior notice. [name removed] also referred to the Petition that she had organised with over 1,100 signatures.
Councillor Platt asked for an update on Strategic Measure 31 – Sustainable transport (including bus passenger journeys) and Councillor Jellyman confirmed that this information should be available at the next meeting when this information was submitted.
Councillor Platt referred to Strategic Measure 15 – Gross Value Added (GVA) per head, indicated that the fact that this figure was static was disappointing and enquired what measures had been taken to improve this.
In relation to page 26 Strategic Measure 29 and page 37 – Train Station usage estimates Councillor Platt indicated that this information showed that Stoke Station had overtaken Crewe Station in terms of usage, one of the reasons for which, he suggested, could be attributable to the new platform 2 car park and the reason for supporting the provision of a multi-storey car park. However, he referred to the restrictive access to Platform 2 and asked if consideration had been given to creating an access via Swift House commenting specifically to the Temple Meads Station in Bristol.
Councillor Platt requested that a report be prepared for consideration at a future meeting of the Committee in relation to the possibility of creating an enhanced access to Platform 2.
Councillor Platt also commented on graduate retention rates and Councillor Jellyman indicated that this data was from 2015 and that it would be interesting to see the most up to date data when it became available.
Councillor Platt indicated that he was comfortable with the recommendations, which would hopefully be implemented and also referred to the opportunities that existed in respect of Stoke Market due to the proximity of the University which could attract students and young people to shop there.
Name Item Interest Nature Councillor A Platt Minute Number 73 Personal Councillor Platt had met the applicant Councillor A Platt Minute Number 74 Personal Councillor Platt had been involved at an early stage and knew the applicant Councillor A Platt Minute Number 77 Personal This application was within Councillor Platt’s Ward, he knew the residents and had been involved in discussions about the application Councillor C Robinson Minute Number 79 Personal Councillor Robinson’s wife worked at Ball Green Primary School There were disclosures from:
Councillor Platt asked how this saving had been calculated and the Cabinet Member, Councillor Brereton explained that this had been identified in the response and had been based on the percentage of income from net rental from the sites identified.
Councillor Platt asked what sites were being considered and Councillor Brereton indicated that these could not be disclosed for commercial reasons. The Interim Director of Place, Prosperity and Growth explained that this involved a third party investment with the City Council providing the land.
Councillor Platt asked about the likelihood of achieving this saving and Councillor A Brown, Cabinet Member for Finance and Partnerships explained that the administration were proposing a three year financial strategy and that, as result, whilst proposals detailed were well formed for next year, there would be more detail for future years and that the Council was working with partners to achieve this. Therefore, what was being stated was that there was potential to save money in future years.
Interest Nature Councillor J Garner 64 Personal Was aware of the building issues through Burslem Committees Councillor M Garner 61 Non-prejudicial Had received direct representations from members of the public Councillor A Platt 61 Non-prejudicial Had paid into a small personal works pension when working at Severn Trent Councillor A Platt 62 Non-prejudicial Knows the applicant and agent, and had also sought public views on the matter via social media All Committee Members 61 Non-prejudicial All Committee Members noted they had received e-mails
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Platt asked for details of the strategies that had been withdrawn from the previous Policy Framework and along with the reasons for removal. The Strategic Manager Policy and Performance gave details of the withdrawn strategies as follows: Youth Justice Plan; Community Cohesion Strategy; Sustainability and Environmental Strategy;
Councillor Platt and Councillor Shotton expressed concern at the removal of the Community Cohesion Strategy as a Policy Framework document and Councillor Shotton was also concerned that changes to the Council’s Policy Framework should be approved by City Council not Cabinet.
Councillor Platt commented that it was difficult to identify what was relevant to the committee and requested that the objectives and activities relevant to the committee be disseminated for the committee, including the associated milestones.
Activity 3, Launch expansion of grounds maintenance services to all publicly accessible land in the City Councillor Platt requested further detail about this proposal and the Assistant Director Operational Management explained that it was proposed to commence the maintenance of land that had ceased to be maintained twelve months ago and would include land that was not in the Council’s ownership but had the appearance of being public land, for example, grass verges.
Councillor Platt asked if the Council would charge land owners, where known, for the maintenance work carried out by the ... view the full minutes text for item 55.
Councillor Platt asked for details of the information to be used for the forthcoming Property Asset and Management Plan to be considered at the next committee meeting.
Referring to the use of legal experts Trowers and Hamlins , Councillor Platt asked how much had been spent so far on consultants needed to develop the proposals. He also asked how the Company Board and Investment Panel would be monitored and what the expected outcomes of the project were.
Councillor Platt expressed his view that investment in job creation was more important than investment in property as in his view more housing would be developed as a consequence of more jobs being created and therefore he asked why housing development had been prioritised over job creation.
In addition, Councillor Platt expressed the view that deregulation of local bus services had been detrimental to the city and he felt that the bus service needed to be re-regulated to enable the City Council regain more control over bus routes and prices.
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Platt commented that the focus of the Joint Local Plan should be on job creation and Councillor Shotton expressed serious concern about the change in the language in the new Plan and the fact that it appeared to have abandoned the idea of a City Centre. He felt that it was critical from a forward planning perspective to understand if Stoke-on-Trent had a city centre or six towns as in his view, the city would be held back strategically without a city centre and he also felt that the lack of a designated city centre conflicted with some of the Council’s other policies.
Councillor Platt asked how the scheme had been received by the general public and the Client Manager for Energy reported that active engagement was carried out with local communities and the issues that arose had all been resolved.
Councillor Platt requested that the committee receive, prior to consideration by Cabinet, an options paper outlining the necessary strategic decisions and options available, for example, in respect of whether the income generated is re-invested back into the company or given to the City Council in the form of a dividend.
Outstanding Items Combined Sewers – Following the briefing session for Councillors on combined sewers, Councillor Platt suggested that the requested follow on meeting with Severn Trent Water now be arranged.
Garner seconded, an amendment to the motion which had the effect of removing the first sentence in paragraph 1.2 of the Pay Policy Statement and adding a new sentence to read – “The City Council will also work towards seeking full accreditation as a UK living wage employer as outline by the Living Wage Foundation.” Councillor Platt moved and Councillor Hamer seconded, that a recorded vote be taken on the amendment and this was supported by more than18 members present and voting at the meeting.
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Platt asked about the process followed for the selection and rejection of schemes and asked specifically why the City Centre Ring Road scheme would not be completed and why was there no improvement scheme for Stoke market but there was for Longton market.
Hanley- Bentilee Link Road £16.0 million Councillor Irving welcomed this scheme and felt that it offered the best economic benefit and Councillor Platt asked about the capacity and resources to deliver the scheme.
In addition, Councillor Platt asked what evidence was available to show that 2 Smithfield could be let to commercial organisations.
Councillor Pervez and Councillor Platt requested that copies of the Cheshire East Council and Stoke-on-Trent City Council High Growth Strategy Concordat be forwarded to all Elected Members and is published on the Council’s website.
Councillor Platt asked about the progress made to find an agreed solution with the Environment Agency and Severn Trent in respect of the flood mitigation works on both the Etruria Valley project and the wider-flood zone catchment area. He also asked that the issue of effluent entering the site and then into clean rivers be included in the discussions. Responding, the Executive Director gave details of the proposed solutions.
Councillor Platt commented that commercial and domestic customers were key to the success of the District Heat Network and therefore asked about the level of take up in other places, for example, Germany.
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Platt requested clarification on the statements in the report that a new fly-tipping ‘taskforce’ would be established, whilst at the same time existing teams would be merged.
Councillor Platt asked if officers were aware of any other Local Authorities that had a policy of clearing private land.
Cleaner and Tidier City (Waste Services) – Following a point raised by Councillor Platt, the Scrutiny Officer confirmed this item would include consideration of the future of the incinerator.
By way of a clarification note, the City Council was advised that during the Member Question session at the previous City Council meeting held on 9 July 2015, it was stated that Councillor Andy Platt had attended one Regulation 44 Visit. This statement was inaccurate due to an officer error and appropriate apologies had been made to the Members concerned.
For clarification, Councillor Platt had undertaken one Regulation 44 Visit during the period January to December 2014 and a further two visits during the period January to May 2015.
I n relation to visits that were scheduled but cancelled, there were two further dates that Cllr Platt was available to attend Regulation 44 visits in 2015, but they were unable to go ahead one due to availability of a Regulation 33 officer and the other due to availability at the small group homes – both were rescheduled but unfortunately Cllr Platt was unable to attend the new dates.
A motion moved by Councillor Garner and seconded by Councillor Platt that “the application be approved subject to the inclusion of a condition requiring the submission of a waste management plan to ensure adequate waste provision”, was carried.
Notice of Decisions Councillor Platt reported that Councillor Bridges, Cabinet Member for Education and Economy had indicated that all executive decisions listed in the Notice of Decisions would be presented to the relevant overview and scrutiny committee for pre-decision scrutiny.
Presentation of Gift from Lidice to Stoke-on-Trent Councillor Andy Platt presented a gift to the City Council from children in the village of Lidice in the Czech Republic, which he had received during a recent visit. The gift was a wooden carving of the angel of Lidice, referred to as the ‘Angel for a Better World Children’s Peace Award for Stoke on Trent’.
Question 1: Submitted by Councillor Andy Platt addressed to the Leader of the Council (Councillor Conway):- What action is the leader going to take to retain a fixed police station in Stoke Town centre?
There are opportunities for members of the public to ask questions directly of the Police and Crime Commissioner at ordinary meetings of the Staffordshire Police and Crime Panel, the following link provides information on that facility – http://www.staffordshire.gov.uk/yourcouncil/staffordshire-police-and-crime-panel/Question-request/submitaquestiontothepanel.aspx (In a supplementary question, Councillor Platt asked if the Leader of the Council would be instructing the City’s representative on the Police and Crime Panel to ensure that provision was made for a police presence in Stoke Town prior to the closure of the Police Station.
He agreed to circulate the PCC’s written response to all members of the Council.) Question 2: Submitted by Councillor Andy Platt addressed to the Leader of the Council (Councillor Conway):- When did the leader last undertake a S44 visit?
(In a supplementary question, Councillor Platt asked the Leader what he understood to be his responsibility as a corporate parent and why officer advice had not been challenged.
Further to discontent expressed by Councillor Platt over the Leader’s approach to responding to the one supplementary question allowed ... view the full minutes text for item 22.
On the motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Platt, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Pervez, seconded by Councillor Platt, it was:
Councillor Platt nominated Councillor Kath Banks (Deputy Lord Mayor), and this was seconded by Councillor Pitt.
Councillor Pender nominated Councillor Debbie Wheeldon and this was seconded by Councillor Platt.
In response to a question previously raised by Councillor Platt, Mark Stocks confirmed that he had seen no evidence to suggest that the Council was not a ‘Going Concern’.
Following a question form Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City , about access to the site the Development Programme Manager explained that occupiers of the site would eventually have access to the site on a 24/7 basis, but because all but the five first phase buildings would be vacant there would not be public access to the site initially due to security and health and safety issues; however, the public would eventually be able to ... view the full minutes text for item 58.
In moving a motion to accept the recommendations set out in the report submitted, Councillor Platt paid particular tribute to the tremendous amount of work that Andrew Briggs (Energy Client Manager) and Sébastien Danneels (DHN Technical Lead Manager) had put into the scheme and he thanked them for their commitment.
On the motion of Councillor Platt, seconded by Councillor Brown, it was:-
Name Item Interest Nature Councillor Platt 63 – Strategic Risk Register Personal Interest CORE Board Member
· Fraud · Laws and Regulations · Going Concern · Related Parties · Accounting estimates Councillor Platt commented on the Management response in relation to ‘Going Concern’ considerations.
This item, which was introduced by Councillor Platt, Chair of the Alternative Service Delivery Model Project Board, sought endorsement of the principle of establishing and Alternative Service Delivery Model (ASDM) for Leisure and Culture Services, along with approval to proceed with a number of key enabling actions in order to help complete the detailed business case for Leisure and Culture and deliver the financial savings of £600,000 included in the budget proposals 2015/16. He stated that this proposal was about consultation, saving money and learning from others.
Councillor Platt advised that the experience of other authorities had been very positive and evidence had shown that this type of arrangement expanded the provision on offer. He stated that he would be able to provide further information following his visit to Warrington.
Councillor Platt confirmed that the £600,000 would be gained by having charitable status and he reported that one of the changes seen elsewhere in the county was that external stakeholders really did get involved more which was what the authority would like to see happen in the city. He indicated that private companies would be more inclined to make donations to a Community Interest Company (CIC) rather than the Local Authority and he indicated that this was an excellent opportunity to obtain funding from statutory bodies and the private sector.
Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City, introduced this item, the purpose of which was to advise Members that an opportunity existed to improve the energy performance of the City Council’s corporate buildings thereby reducing carbon emissions and achieving substantial cost avoidance. The report also sought approval to access the national RE: FIT framework and to undertake the procurement of a preferred contractor to deliver the project.
Cabinet Members Questions/Comments Councillor Platt expressed his full support for this item and anticipated an early implementation of the programmes of work and looked forward to seeing an improvement in the City.
Cabinet Member Comments/Questions Councillor Platt welcomed these proposals and stated that since the Council purchased this site, there had been a clear vision for the site in terms of protecting the heritage and job creation.
Councillor Platt welcomed this item and stated his view that the Council’s website design had not kept up to date with the development of smart phones and tablets which were used by many people as mini computers and he felt that a modern website was required to remove unnecessary phone calls and emails and to provide a better service and improve engagement with the electorate.
Cabinet Members Comments/Questions Councillor Platt referred to the Section on Environment Waste and Fleet on page 45 of the QBR report commenting specifically on the high refuse collection rates for household waste and that in order to further enhance the service the Council was seeking to procure a system which would enable the driver of the refuse collection vehicle when a household had not put their bin out for collection.
Councillor Platt further emphasised the efforts that staff had made to reduce the number of agency staff used.
Continuing, Councillor Platt also commented on the contamination of recycled goods and the increased costs that local authorities could incur as a result, confirming that he had attended a Waste Conference the previous week which had shared ideas on how to improve upon this position and confirmed that he would report back on this in the future. He also reported that Cabinet would soon be giving consideration to a report which proposed measures that could be introduced in the Council’s buildings in order to reduce energy costs.
Cabinet Members Comments/Questions Councillor Platt felt that there may be some misunderstanding in the media about the Council’s relationship with the Contractor/Developer and asked the Cabinet Member to explain this.
Councillor Platt indicated that, whilst this report was about Budget proposals, the budget reductions which had to be made were as a result of Central Government’s policy and not the City Councils. He pointed out that, in spite of funding cuts the Council had not stopped spending/investing in positive things and commented specifically in relation to waste collection rates and jobs and growth.
It was noted that Councillor Crowe and Councillor Walker had replaced Councillor Watson and Councillor Platt on the Committee.
Name Item Interest Nature Councillor Hamer 50 – Audit Committee Update for Stoke-on-Trent Council Personal Interest Undertakes consultancy work for (INLOGOV) Councillor Platt 52 – Internal Audit Quarterly Monitoring Report 2014/15:Quarter 3 Personal Interest CORE Board Member
Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City, gave a brief introduction to this item, the purpose of which was to continue the formal consultation with the committee in respect of the Budget Development for 2015/16 for the services under the remit of this committee. The report provided an overview of feedback from all the Overview and Scrutiny Committee meetings that took place in December 2014 in respect of the Budget Development for 2015/16 and an update on the Local Government Finance Settlement for 2015/16. The report also contained the additional information requested by the committee at its meeting on 11 December 2014.
On the motion of Councillor Platt, seconded by Councillor J. Garner, it was:-
Councillor Platt declared a personal interest in item 11 ‘Domestic Energy Saving Service’ as a Director of CoRE , which was referred to during the discussion on this item.
On the motion of Councillor Platt, seconded by Councillor Brown, it was:-
Towns Against Tax Dodging (Avoidance & Evasion) It was moved by Councillor Watson and seconded by Councillor Platt, that:- “While many ordinary people face falling household income and rising costs of living, some multinational companies are avoiding billions of pounds of tax from a tax system that fails to make them pay their fair share. Local governments in developing countries and the UK alike would benefit from a fairer tax system, enabling them to provide quality public services.
Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City, highlighted the fact that ... view the full minutes text for item 31.
Councillor Platt commented that the title needed to be more specific and suggested that it referred to planning matters. He referred to the consultation procedures and asked if they would be similar for both authorities at the same time emphasising that the consultation processes should be in harmony with one another.
Councillor Platt moved and Councillor Reynolds seconded the following motion to insert an additional condition, which was not carried, “No development, including site preparation works, shall begin until details of a yellow hatched box junction at the junction of Dividy Road and Trent Street have been submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority. The work shall be completed in accordance with the agreed details prior to the development hereby permitted being brought into use”.
Councillor Watson moved the following motion, which incorporated a further proposal in addition to the recommendations as set out in the report submitted, to replace Cllr Crowe with Councillor Platt on the Human Resources Committee:- (i) “The City Council notes that Councillor Bridges is no longer a Member of the Labour Group and is referred to as a non-aligned Member in this report.
(vi) That Councillor Terry Crowe be replaced on the Human Resources Committee by Councillor Andy Platt” The motion was seconded by Councillor J. Garner, and on being put to the vote it was:-
Councillor Platt enquired where the 8.14 hectares of land for employment purposes had been delivered.
Councillor Platt, cabinet member for Green Enterprises and Clean City, introduced this report which informed members of the development of a District Heating Scheme proposal. The Client Manager Energy and Economic Development Officer proceeded to provide further details of the proposal through a presentation of the key principles and a video showing an existing successful scheme in Pullach , Germany.
In response to Councillor Platt, the External Auditor confirmed that errors were simply misreported, rather than through any malicious intentions.
Councillor Platt moved and Councillor Wazir seconded the revised officer recommendation, which was carried:
Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City, referred to Stoke-on-Trent’s pride in being one of the greenest cities in the Country and he paid tribute to all the staff involved in maintaining the parks and the grounds at Carmountside to such an exceptionally high standard.
Both Councillor Platt and Councillor Meredith suggested that the committee had received sufficient evidence during the last 12 months to confirm that the authority was a going concern . to be amended to:
Both Councillor Platt and Councillor Meredith suggested that the committee had received sufficient evidence during the last 12 months to confirm that the authority was a going concern . The recommendation contained in the report was then put to the vote.
Councillor Platt moved, and Councillor Meredith seconded, the following motion, which was carried:
The Committee also noted that Councillor Platt would no longer be attending meetings of this Committee as the relevant Cabinet Member for Health and Safety as this area of responsibility had transferred to Public Health.
Councillor Platt expressed concerns over the number of long-term vacant units in Stoke town centre, suggesting that urgent action was needed to tackle this as part of the regeneration of the town.
On the motion of Councillor Rosenau, seconded by Councillor Platt, the following resolution was supported by a majority of the whole number of members of the authority, in accordance with the requirements of section 239 of the Local Government Act 1972:-
On the motion of Councillor Platt, seconded by Councillor James, it was:-
and · write to all local MPs outlining the Council’s position.” Councillor Platt moved and Councillor Watson seconded, that a recorded vote be taken and this was supported by more than18 members present and voting at the meeting.
Councillor Platt acknowledged the need for robust procedures, but was mindful that on occasions, such procedures can cause long delays. In response, the Interim Assistant Director confirmed that they were hoping to put in place a number of innovative proposals, whilst also complying with the necessary legislation. In response to the Vice-Chair, the Interim Assistant Director made reference to the agreed surety process designed to provide support, challenge and sign-off for projects wishing to move into delivery.
Both Councillor Platt and Councillor Meredith suggested that the committee had received sufficient evidence during the last 12 months to confirm that the authority was a going concern. The recommendation contained in the report was then put to the vote.
It was moved by Councillor Platt and seconded by Councillor Ali, ‘ that Councillor Majid Khan be and is hereby elected Lord Mayor of the City of Stoke-on-Trent and Chairman of the Council for the ensuing municipal year’.
It was moved by Councillor Platt, seconded by Councillor Banks, ‘that the best thanks of this Council are due and are hereby extended to Sheila Pitt for her invaluable services to this Council and to the City during the past year and to Barry Pitt for the admirable way in which he has performed the duties of Consort’.
Presentation of Long Service Awards to Councillors The Lord Mayor presented Long Service Awards to Councillor Kath Banks, Councillor Joy Garner and Councillor Andy Platt in recognition of them completing twelve years’ service as a Councillor. The Council joined him in congratulating the three members.
The Leader of the Council, Councillor Mohammed Pervez, formally announced appointments to the Cabinet as follows:- Councillor Mohammed Pervez - Leader of the Council Councillor Paul Shotton - Deputy Leader of the Council and Cabinet Member for Economic Development Councillor Ruth Rosenau - Cabinet Member for Regeneration, Planning and Transportation Councillor Gwen Hassall - Cabinet Member for Social Care (Lead Member for Children’s Services) Councillor Terry Crowe - Cabinet Member for Finance, Procurement and Commissioning Councillor Joy Garner - Cabinet Member for Housing, Neighbourhoods and Community Safety Councillor Adrian Knapper - Cabinet Member for Health and Wellbeing Councillor Andy Platt - Cabinet Member Green Enterprises and Clean City Councillor Shaun Pender - Cabinet Member for Education Councillor Olwen Hamer - Cabinet member for Transformation and Resources.
On the motion of Councillor Platt, seconded by Councillor Brown, it was:-
This item was introduced by Councillor Platt the Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City.
Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City introduced this item which provided an update to Cabinet on the progress made to achieving the targets set within the City Councils Carbon Management Plan.
Cabinet Member Questions/Comments Councillor Platt expressed support for this item and commented on the fact that this item demonstrated to the public that the Council was carefully considering the issues at each stage of the process.
Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises introduced this report which sought approval to the Draft Greenspace Strategy which outlined the importance of greenspace and how the Council intended to promote, encourage and maintain its greenspace .
Councillor Platt referred to the fact that the City had the 2 nd largest number of allotments in the Country and further commented on the positive use of our greenspace becoming more important to us. He also reported with regard to the positive comments that visitors to the City made about Stoke-on-Trent.
Councillor Platt thanked his fellow Cabinet Members for their support and also paid tribute to Councillor Bridges, former Cabinet Member for this area, for her work on this.
Continuing, Councillor Platt also commented on the large number of “friends of” groups which operated in the City and the welcome contribution that they made to the area.
Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City presented this item, reporting that the final version of the Strategy would be re-formatted in the Council’s corporate style.
Councillor Platt reported that it would be helpful for Members to be informed of how Public Health had integrated with city council officers and procedures.
Councillor Platt made reference to smaller authorities and rumours around poor Communicating with the Auditor reports. He asked if there was any truth in such rumours and whether any information could be shared with the Committee in relation to lessons learnt. The External Auditor suggested that if district authorities do not address the austerity reductions adequately then there could be issues in the future as some were reliant on ‘reserves’.
Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City, explained what the Breathe Easy initiative entailed and spoke of the importance of ensuring that the health messages continued to get through, particularly to young people. He outlined the significance of the work that had been undertaken which had been recognised through the achievement of the award.
On the motion of Councillor Platt, seconded by Councillor Brown, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Platt, seconded by Councillor Shotton, it was:-
Councillor Platt referred to research by three external organisations which stated that Stoke-on-Trent was out-performing its peers in relation to business start-ups, commenting on the fact that this type of information needed to be conveyed to the public and expressing the hope that this would be picked up by local media.
The Chair thanked Councillor Platt for raising this issue, confirming that one of the key priorities for the Mandate for Change was to create the right conditions for growth and emphasised the need to retain focus and momentum which was required if the City was to be successful.
Councillor Platt also voiced support indicating that one of the most compelling arguments for HS2 was the fact that it would act as a massive catalyst for growth in the area.
Councillor Platt referred to the General Reserves which were there to provide a contingency to reduce the impact of unexpected events or emergencies. He commented that the previous evening, there had been one of the worst storms that the City had experienced with roads having to be closed because of fallen trees and damage to buildings and staff from the Civil Contingencies team had been working overnight. He sought reassurance that the tight budget to which this team worked would be supplemented if necessary as he believed that the reserves were for this exact purpose.
Councillor Crowe agreed with Councillor Platt that the reserves were for this purpose and that monies would be made available if required.
Councillor Platt also supported the proposals. He referred to the Task and Finish Group that had looked into car parking and confirmed that they had listened to the comments made by the Overview and Scrutiny Committee and members of the public. He commented that not all car parks would see a rise in charges and that there were some car parks that would see a reduction in the charges made.
Councillor Platt commented that there were areas in the City with huge deprivation that had not been included such as Bentilee compared with areas within the County Council with affluent villages such as Barlaston and Rocester which had been included. He expressed his disappointment at the proposals.
Councillor Platt referred to the last meeting of the City Renewal Overview and Scrutiny Committee where the budget proposals had been discussed including looking at how to re-align senior management within the Directorate as it was very important that there was the right support.
Councillor Platt suggested that the figure of 95% of houses built on brownfield land was very good news, and evidence of the regeneration of the City.
Councillor Platt spoke about the significance of Local Democracy week for young people in the City and referred to the work that the officers had put into making the event a success.
Councillor Platt referred to the Health and Safety update and believed that Health and Safety should be highlighted as a major issue as the more it was highlighted, the more likely it was for incidents to reduce.
The Chair referred to the health indicators and asked Councillor Platt for an update on his pledge to give up smoking.
Councillor Platt reported that the first 5 days of giving up had gone very well. However, he was now having discussions to get help for the next time he tried as he found it difficult to quit smoking without support.
Councillor Knapper encouraged Councillor Platt to speak to Public Health to ensure that support was offered. He commented that a considerable number of people had quit smoking.
Councillor Platt referred to the Capital Investment Programme and commented that the works that had taken place at the entrance of the Spode site in Stoke had vastly improved the look of the Town Centre. Furthermore, a charity shop had closed in the town and a commercial business had set up in its place.
Councillor Platt commented on the growing new media and social media and highlighted that the City Council had over 5000 twitter followers.
Councillor Mohammed Pervez (Chair), Councillor Paul Shotton (Vice-Chair), Councillor Janine Bridges, Councillor Terry Crowe, Councillor Gwen Hassall, Councillor Alan Dutton, Councillor Adrian Knapper, Councillor Shaun Pender, Councillor Andy Platt and Councillor Ruth Rosenau.
Councillor Mohammed Pervez (Chair), Councillor Paul Shotton (Vice-Chair), Councillor Terry Crowe, Councillor Gwen Hassall, Councillor Alan Dutton, Councillor Adrian Knapper, Councillor Shaun Pender, Councillor Andy Platt and Councillor Ruth Rosenau.
Councillor Platt the Cabinet Member Green Enterprise introduced this item which provided the Committee with an overview of progress of the Green Enterprises projects. He gave a short presentation on how Green Enterprise linked in with Mandate for Change and reported that Stoke-on-Trent City Council believed that energy sustainability and security would be a key issue for the future success of residents and businesses. The ability to offer a secure source of energy from indigenous resources from within the city boundaries would provide the City with a unique selling point and could incentivise companies wishing to find a low cost, low risk place to site their business.
Councillor Platt responded to say that he had attended a Renewable Energy Conference where Stoke-on-Trent was recognised for work in this field. The national Planning for Energy Efficient City Committee had planned to visit Stoke-on-Trent to look at projects and share ideas and innovation. He continued to say that Stoke-on-Trent were a finalist under the Creative Council Scheme, National Endowment for Science, Technology and the Arts (NESTA) and had a high reputation with specialists and worked closely with Government on a daily basis.
The Chair congratulated Councillor Platt and officers on their work and acknowledged the fuel poverty within the city and agreed that the Council should focus on renewable energy and queried if schools would be involved.
Councillor Platt responded to say that Staffordshire University were a lead on the ARBOR project and the Council also worked closely with Keele. He also advised that there were School Liaison Officers that worked closely with schools to set up ECO teams which would raise awareness within city schools.
Councillor Platt remarked this was a pilot and a small site was required for the project, but the Council was seeking other sites.
Councillor Platt considered it a good opportunity for a business partner as the Council ... view the full minutes text for item 87.
Councillor Platt the Cabinet Member Green Enterprise gave a presentation which provided the committee with an overview of the progress of the weekly waste collection scheme. He informed the Committee that the Council had bid for funding for the weekly waste collection scheme and was successful in receiving £14 million over a three year period. He explained the current process was limited as many households in the City were unable to accommodate numerous bins for different waste types.
Councillor Platt responded to say that waste commodities change and could become of value. The target for set was 0 to landfill. Some sorting would be manual and would benefit the city through creating jobs.
In response to a question from the Chair querying how long the £14.3 million would last Councillor Platt replied that it was a three year programme which had set funding each year and was a business case stage. The Green Enterprise Project Officer added that the next step would be to purchase new vehicles and agreed to update the Committee in 12 months after draw down and a feasibility study.
Mindful of the above, Councillor Platt made reference to the media and public perception, in relating to increasing debt levels. In response the Finance and Commercial Manager confirmed that the City Council had not taken out any additional borrowing since 2008, with the exception of the HRA (Housing Revenue Account).
In response to a question from Councillor Platt, the Audit Services Manager confirmed that Internal Audit were generally welcomed by service managers and confirmed that feedback suggested that their work helped managers focus in terms of control. Survey results also confirmed that almost 90% of service users believed that Internal Audit provided ‘added value’.
Councillor Platt enquired about the occupancy rate at the Linehouses site.
Councillor Platt enquired if the 40 Gypsy and Traveller households in bricks and mortar accommodation (in 2007) had wanted to be in settled housing.
Councillor Platt enquired if discussions had yet been held with the other local authorities involved in the 2007 assessment, and what the overall timescale for the work would be.
(Councillor Platt was not present for the consideration of this item) Members were informed of amendments to conditions 3, 10, 12, and 14 within the report submitted, and of two additional conditions 18 and 19.
Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City, reported that the draft Wildlife Management Policy had been submitted following a request from the committee made a t a previous meeting. Continuing, the Strategic Manager Environment Waste and Fleet Services explained that the Policy outlined how the Council intended to promote, encourage and control the sustainable co-existence of people and wildlife throughout the Council’s green spaces. She confirmed that the Policy had been consulted on and feedback received and invited committee members to comment on the policy prior to it being forwarded to Cabinet for approval.
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Wedgwood welcomed the policy and asked how it linked with planning policies and in response Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City , explained that this was not a planning document and Councillor Rosenau, Cabinet Member for Regeneration, Planning and Transportation confirmed that at risk species were already included within planning documentation.
In response to a question from Councillor Platt, the External Auditor confirmed that the ‘Amber’ in respect of Strategic Financial Planning was due to risks moving forward and the decisions which would need to be taken in respect of future budgeting. In common with other local authorities, he was mindful that the City Council faced significant financial pressures in the longer term which would require some difficult decisions to be taken.
Cabinet Members Questions/Comments Councillor Platt advised that this school was within his ward and stated that the drawing did not show that this was the whole of the land of the school. He commented that the outside play area for children was very limited and that the site itself was very tight and therefore he requested that this be taken into account, given that this further development would take up even more of the outside land of the school. He stated that there were areas of derelict land nearby which could be utilised for outside play areas with some innovative thinking and co-ordinated working between departments.
He reassured Councillor Platt that this would be looked at and that every opportunity to enable people to access space to exercise would be sought. He agreed that additional capacity for play areas would be required for that part of the city given the plans for future housing development.
Cabinet Members Comments/Questions Councillor Platt welcomed the re-profiling, in particular the confidence highlighted in the report in the future of green enterprise in the city. He reported that the Council had a suite of around 25 projects coming forward but commented that the city was behind in the development of district heating schemes. He explained that district heating was a very efficient and green way of heating buildings and the city had some very innovative potential for district heating and ways of reusing the waste heat from the incinerators and local factories in the city.
Councillor Platt reported on the improvements made to the Arbour conference facilities, which included the replacement of the heating system with a bio-mass boiler, which he indicated would be operational by September/October 2013 and also on the Arbour Woodfuel Hub project.
Cabinet Members Comments/Questions Councillor Platt expressed support for the way officers had responded and were trying to deal with fly tipping in the city, but stated that the Council needed to get the message across that it is the responsibility of individuals not to fly tip in the city.
In response to a question from Councillor Platt, the Audit Services Manager confirmed that work of Internal Audit also looks at areas of duplication and ways to add value.
Councillor Platt enquired how many electric vehicle charging points there were in the City, and what was their level of usage?
Councillor Platt disclosed a potential interest in item 8 of the agenda “Housing Retrofit Framework Agreement” as the owner of an old property.
Cabinet Members Comments/Questions Councillor Platt referred to the importance of this Agreement and also to the City Council working alongside CoRE in relation to projects such as this.
Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City presented this report and responded to questions which had been asked Councillor J Garner and Councillors Hamer and Gratton who were also in attendance at the meeting.
Councillor Platt (Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City), commented on the fact that this was the fourth consecutive year that the Health and Safety Team had received an Award and extended his congratulations to the staff for their achievement.
Name Item Interest Nature The Lord Mayor and Councillors Pervez, Clarke, Rosenau, Gratton, Watson, Ali, Wazir, Wedgwood, Hamer, Khan, Hussain and Singh-Kallar, Para. 26 Personal Member of a Trade Union Councillor Clarke Para. 26 Personal Member of Unite Trade Union and Partner of Robert Flello MP Councillor Walker Para. 26 Personal Member of a Trade Union and actively involved in the campaign Councillor Platt, Shotton and Dutton Para. 26 Personal Member of a Trade Union and Signatory to the Petition.
Garner, seconded by Councillor Platt, it was:-
This Council will take every legitimate step necessary to ensure that the City Council never knowingly engages or contracts with a company that operates a blacklist or has been found to operate a blacklist.” Following a full and detailed debate on the motion, it was moved by Councillor Platt and seconded by Councillor M. Garner that a recorded vote be taken and this was supported by more than 18 members present and voting at the meeting.
Councillor Item Type of Interest Reason for Interest Councillor Platt 68 Personal Lives in Stoke.
Councillor Platt advised that this will become clearer when the final strategy comes to action plan. Some of the recommendations had already been implemented such as the Diamond Woods.
Councillor Platt thanked Councillor Wedgewood for the useful feedback.
Councillor Platt declared personal interests, as a resident of Stoke in respect of items 9 and 10 “Establishing an Energy Trading Company” and “Regional Growth Fund – Round 4 Bids” as both of these reports could have potential implications for the Town.
Cabinet Members Comments/Questions Councillor Platt was of the view that, even if there was no funding currently available, he wanted officers to be in the position of being able to react as quickly as possible to opportunities to keep up with other local authorities.
This item was introduced by Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City who outlined the purpose of the report which was to seek approval to commence a procurement process for eight split bodied waste recycling collection vehicles and for delegated authority for the Director of City Renewal, in consultation with the Section 151 Officer and himself, as Cabinet member, to award the contract.
Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City who outlined the purpose of the report and confirmed in his introduction that Stoke-on-Trent City Council had reached the last 6 of the NESTA Creative Councils competition. Continuing, he explained that the purpose of this report was to agree to the creation of a Holding Company (Holdco) which would allow the Council to facilitate investment in and derive a return for particular energy projects.
Councillor Platt also explained that the model would be similar to the one adopted by Woking, Surrey which had been very successful. However, he also pointed out that there could be no guarantee of creating a profit but that there were lessons to be learnt from the Woking model. He hoped that the creation of the Holdco would act as a stimulus to bring new jobs into the area.
Cabinet Members Comments/Questions Councillor Platt expressed support for the report and commented on the fact that energy was a key driver within the City Deal and showed that the City Council was serious about using energy as one of our major selling points.
Councillor Platt agreed that there were major variations, even within smaller wards.
Councillor Platt moved and Councillor Singh-Kallar seconded the following motion to amend condition 17 of the report, which was carried:
Cabinet Members Comments/Questions Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City advised that all the recommendations of the Task and Finish Group had been agreed. He reported that it was anticipated that a Greenspace Strategy and Action Plan would be presented to Cabinet at its meeting on 24 October 2013.
Cabinet Members Questions/Comments Councillor Platt requested that Cabinet receive a quarterly inspection report.
A motion moved by Councillor Wazir and seconded by Councillor Platt, that Councillor Reynolds be appointed Chair of the Development Management Committee for the municipal year, was carried.
A motion moved by Councillor Platt and seconded by Councillor Rosenau, that Councillor Hamer be appointed Chair of the Audit Committee for the municipal year, was carried.
Moved by Councillor Shotton, seconded by Councillor Platt, ‘that the best thanks of this Council are due and are hereby extended to Terry Crowe for his invaluable services to this Council and to the City during the past year and to [name removed] for the admirable way in which she has performed the duties of Lady Mayoress ’.
It was moved by Councillor Ali and seconded by Councillor Platt, ‘ that Councillor Majiid Khan be and is hereby appointed Deputy Lord Mayor of the City of Stoke-on-Trent and Vice Chairman of the Council for the ensuing municipal year’ .
Councillor Mohammed Pervez - Leader of the Council Councillor Paul Shotton - Deputy Leader of the Council and Cabinet Member for Economic Development Councillor Ruth Rosenau - Cabinet Member for Regeneration, Planning and Transportation Councillor Gwen Hassall - Cabinet Member Social Care and Lead Member for Children’s Services Councillor Terry Crowe - Cabinet Member for Finance, Procurement and Commissioning Councillor Janine Bridges - Cabinet Member for Housing, Neighbourhoods and Community Safety Councillor Adrian Knapper - Cabinet Member for Health and Wellbeing Councillor Andy Platt - Cabinet Member Green Enterprises and Clean City Councillor Shaun Pender - Cabinet Member for Education Councillor Alan Dutton - Cabinet member for Transformation and Resources.
On the motion of Councillor Platt, seconded by Councillor Brown, it was:-
Councillor Item Type of Interest Reason for Interest Councillor Platt 60 Personal Lives in Stoke.
Our previous energy Offer Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member Green Enterprise and Clean City referred to the front cover of Gas and Electricity Service Booklet provided by the City Council for the provision of gas and electricity which was provided by the City Council until 1948 when it was nationalised. He added that this service would have come full circle under the current proposal of the City Council producing and supplying energy, with an appropriate partner.
Cabinet Members Questions/Comments Councillor Platt asked if the Centre had been marketed internally for Team Meetings/Away Days etc ?
Councillor Dutton confirmed that the Centre was being extensively marketed but that its facilities were probably not suitable for conferences and the type of event to which Councillor Platt referred.
It was also recognised that there were opportunities to use the Centre as Councillor Platt suggested but these would need to be complimentary to and not detract from the educational value of the Centre. There needed to be a blend but primarily the Centre’s use was educational.
Cabinet Members Comments/Questions Councillor Platt welcomed the draft SPD and indicated that a lot of work had gone into this important document which he emphasised was only for public consultation at this stage and was not yet City Council policy with its aim being to gain views on it.
Councillor Platt moved and Councillor Bridges seconded the following motion, which was carried:
Councillor Platt provided a summary in respect of the Economic Development, Culture and Sport and Leisure portfolio, in Councillor Meredith’s absence.
This item was introduced by Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City, who explained that approval was sought to adopt a revised Allotment self-management framework which would enable delegated decisions to grant allotment self-management status and associated leases under the revised framework. He reported that, if approved, it was expected that the introduction of a framework for existing self-managed sites would be approved and completed by April 2014.
On the motion of Councillor Platt, seconded by Councillor Brown, it was:-
To call on the government to scrap this unworkable and ill-conceived policy, that attacks the most vulnerable residents of Stoke-on-Trent.” Councillor Platt moved and Councillor Ali seconded, that a recorded vote be taken and this was supported by more than 18 members present and voting at the meeting.
Councillor Platt enquired about the progress of a Supplementary Planning Document for shop fronts.
Cabinet Members Questions/Comments Councillor Platt drew attention to Paragraph 16.2 within the report and confirmed that the Accelerating Renewable energies through valorisation Biogenetic Organic Raw materials (ARBOR) was progressing on schedule and was a very exciting scheme.
Cabinet Members Questions/Comments Councillor Platt referred to City Services measures within the report and commented upon frustration that was often expressed regarding the car parking situation around schools and that the City Council had responded to this problem as outlined within the Measures Summary in this section.
Cabinet Members Questions/Comments Councillor Platt was of the opinion that the Strategy linked into other City Council strategies, welcomed the item and expressed his thanks to the Cabinet Member and the Interim Director of Public Health for their work in bringing forward the Strategy.
Councillor Platt made reference to the expansion of retail and other activities at the Trentham Gardens estate, suggesting that the impact on the City of any further expansion on its borders would need to be carefully considered.
Councillor Platt stressed the need for the response, preferably a joint response with Newcastle-under-Lyme Borough Council, to concentrate on the issues of safeguarding the regeneration of North Staffordshire and protecting the green belt.
This item was introduced by Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City, who explained that the report provided an overview of the projects which make up the suite of Green Enterprise projects. These projects look at a number of pioneering projects including generating energy from our organic waste, capturing waste industrial heat to feed District Heating schemes, alongside Green deal housing retrofit and extracting heat from warm mine water beneath our feet. Cabinet Members Comments/Questions Councillors Bridges fully endorsed these projects which she felt were very innovative.
Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City , also thanked Councillor Bridges for her work, carried out as the previous Cabinet Member, in this complex area. He stated that these projects will make Stoke-on-Trent special and encourage growth and industry in the city.
In response to a question from Councillor Platt who sought confirmation that six community halls would remain open under these proposals, the Chair confirmed that six community halls would remain open and the committees would have greater control of their community halls.
This item was introduced by Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City, who reported that the report sought Cabinet approval to pursue the Central District Energy project earmarked to provide district heating to the central business district, existing council buildings, other proposed regeneration and new development commencing in the city centre and subsequently beyond in the adjacent and surrounding areas.
On the motion of Councillor Shotton, seconded by Councillor Platt, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Platt, seconded by Councillor Brown, it was :_
Councillor Platt commented on the speed with which the development on the former Lomax site in Stoke Town was progressing, he saw this as a positive change in mentality for the development of Stoke town centre.
Cabinet Members Comments/Questions Councillor Platt commented on the additional pressure that this change had created for Officers and asked the Cabinet Member what he thought that the Government’s motivation was when they decided to introduce these changes?
Councillor Platt suggested that the level of cuts being imposed upon the City Council needed to be emphasised as the Authority had no choice but to make budget savings as a result of Government reductions, which in his view, were more severe for some of the most deprived areas in the Country.
This item was introduced by Councillor Platt, cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City.
Councillor Platt referred to the comment made by the Government that “cities are the engine for change” and commented on the need to ensure that this was indeed the basis of any City Deal for Stoke-on-Trent and Staffordshire, which if successful, would help to accelerate economic growth and prosperity in the area.
Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City welcomed the Review’s findings.
Councillor Platt felt that this was a positive initiative as there was a vast number of heritage buildings in the City, some of which had been well preserved, others not as well preserved. He commented that there were residents who had a love of old buildings but not necessarily the money to spend on them and asked if such residents would be invited to participate.
Question 2: Submitted by Ian Norris of Tunstall, Stoke-on-Trent, addressed to the Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City (Councillor Platt):- On 10th February 2010 Cabinet Members agreed to award of a Contract to Vital Earth Derby Ltd from 1st April 2010 to 31 March 2020 with a 3 year break clause. It was the Cabinets aim to provide an In-Vessel composting facility within the City following the feasibility report by Ancer Spa published March 2010, in time to meet the break clause.
Response provided by the Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City (Councillor Platt):- The City Council has established a task and finish group to review Options for Energy from Waste which includes but is not limited to the treatment of the ... view the full minutes text for item 83.
Councillor Platt enquired if the CIL could be used to further Council policy objectives, such as the regeneration of the city centre.
Councillor Platt enquired if the CIL could be used to fund infrastructure projects such as sewerage or broadband, which came under the remit of other agencies.
Councillor Platt questioned the rationale behind changing the boundary of the Newcastle town centre retail, suggesting that land outside the current boundary could instead be allocated to housing.
Cabinet Members Comments/Questions Councillor Platt asked why, bearing in mind the present Councillors had only come to power in May 2011, the debts had not been written off earlier?
This item was introduced by Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Clean City.
Councillor Platt confirmed that the draft strategy would come back to Cabinet and referred to the timeline contained in the report.
This item was introduced by Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprise and Clean City.
Councillor Platt welcomed the proposals which were designed to introduce energy saving measure to reduce the risk of cold homes, particularly in the more difficult to treat homes and reduce associated risks of poor health.
Councillor Platt made reference to the reduction in the number of non-teaching staff from 2010/11 to 2011/12, which had gone down from 206 to 177, reflecting the delayering.
On the motion of Councillor Rosenau , seconded by Councillor Platt, it was:-
Whilst there was general support to the figures suggesting for the number of takeaways in certain areas, Councillor Platt presented a counter argument to keep takeaways in close proximity.
Cabinet Members Comments / Questions Councillor Platt referred to the key changes in respect of council tax exemptions and discounts for second homes and empty properties. He was surprised that people with second properties could currently qualify for a discount and asked if there was expected to be any objections from those in receipt of a discount if this was removed.
Councillor Platt asked when people could start to apply to buy the houses.
Councillor Platt expressed his support for this document and anticipated that it would run alongside the relevant Overview and Scrutiny Task and Finish Group currently taking place.
A motion moved by Councillor Platt and seconded by Councillor Bridges “that the application be approved subject to the conditions outlined below” was carried. The reason for the motion was that members during the site visit had had an opportunity to consider the impact in terms of the visual amenity of the proposed extension.
Councillor Platt reported that his apologies had been submitted to the last meeting, and requested that this be noted in the minutes.
Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprise and Clean City expressed a wish for the Task and Finish Review in respect of waste to present their report and recommendations as soon as possible.
This item was introduced by Councillor Platt, Cabinet Member for Green Enterprises and Green City.
Councillor Platt confirmed that the HLF bid could not be used to fund stage one of the process. However, the cost of submitting the bid was approximately £30k which would be funded using in-house resources. He further confirmed that, subject to being successful at stage one, there was a programme of funding up until 2022.
Councillor Platt highlighted that there were approximately 80 friends of groups for parks in the City and confirmed that, in respect of the proposals for Hanley Park, the Council will work in partnership with the Friends of Hanley Park Group. He indicated that a key part of the bid for Hanley Park was to bring the buildings back into use and then look to see how they can generate an income.
Showing the latest 300 of 349.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Platt attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Platt's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Platt was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 9 of 15 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Platt declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 22 Jan 2015 | Cabinet, item 17 | Councillor Platt declared a personal interest in item 11 ‘Domestic Energy Saving Service’ as a Director of CoRE , which was referred to during the discussion on this item. | |
| 25 Jul 2013 | Cabinet, item 372 | Councillor Platt disclosed a potential interest in item 8 of the agenda “Housing Retrofit Framework Agreement” as the owner of an old property. | |
| 27 Jun 2013 | Cabinet, item 355 | Councillor Platt declared personal interests, as a resident of Stoke in respect of items 9 and 10 “Establishing an Energy Trading Company” and “Regional Growth Fund – Round 4 Bids” as both of these reports could have potential implications for the Town. |
Where Councillor Platt sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planning Committee - Development Management | Chair | Jun 2011 | 31 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| City Council | Committee Member | May 2011 | 19 | 17 Dec 2026 |
| Audit and Standards Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2026 | 3 | |
| Strategy and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Vice-Chair | Jul 2026 | 3 | 13 Jan 2027 |
| Planning Committee - Policy Group | Committee Member | Oct 2011 | 20 | |
| (archived) Audit Committee | Committee Member | Nov 2011 | 13 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - City Renewal | Committee Member | May 2011 | 12 | |
| Cabinet | Cabinet Member | Nov 2011 | 4 | |
| Licensing and Appeals Committee | Cabinet Member | Nov 2013 | 1 | |
| (archived) Human Resources Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2014 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.