Named18 Jun 2024Cabinet
Representation on Outside Bodies and Joint Committees
The Leader noted an amendment to the recommendations and it was therefore proposed that Councillor Majid Khan replace Councillor David Williams as a representative on the Community Safety Partnership Board; the Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent Community Safety Forum and the Staffordshire Police, Fire and Crime Panel and that Councillor Sarah Jane Colclough be appointed as the replacement Substitute Member on the Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent Joint Archives Committee.
Named25 Jan 2024City Council
Members' Questions
Question 2: From Councillor Faisal Hussain addressed to the Cabinet Member for Community Safety and Resilience (Councillor David Williams) How many meetings, or phone conversations, has the Cabinet Member had with the Police, Fire & Crime Commissioner since the heightened community tensions as a result of global events?
Named18 Jul 2023Cabinet
Appointments to Outside Bodies
Whilst the Chair, Councillor Ashworth explained that the majority of appointments to Outside Bodies and Partnerships had been made at the previous meeting, she sought approval to appoint Councillor David Williams as a substitute member on the Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent Joint Archives Committee.
Declared2 Mar 2023Strategy and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Disclosure of Interests
Councillor Williams declared a personal interest in Agenda item 6 on the basis that his employer may look at funding opportunities of the UK Shared Prosperity Fund allocation.
Named19 Jan 2023Children and Family Services Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Disclosure of Interests
Name Item Interest Nature Councillor Williams (Vice Chair) Para. 6 – Strategic Measures 2022/23 – Quarter 2 Personal Employer involved in work with the YES Consortium referenced in the report submitted. The Member is not personally involved.
Asked9 Jun 2022Strategy and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Strategic Measures Performance 2021/22 - Quarter 4
Councillor Williams asked if there were any of the key annual targets that caused concern, which would they be.
Named19 May 2022Children and Family Services Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Appointment of Vice-Chair
A Motion, moved by Councillor Maxine Clark, seconded by Councillor Cheryl Gerrard that “Councillor David Williams be appointed as Vice-Chair of the Children and Family Services Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the 2022/2023 Municipal Year” was carried.
Moved19 May 2022Strategy and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Appointment of Vice-Chair
A Motion, moved by Councillor Williams, seconded by Councillor Dodd ‘that Councillor Jane Ashworth be appointed Vice-Chair of the Strategy and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the 2022/2023 Municipal Year’ was carried.
Seconded19 May 2022City Council
To Elect a Lord Mayor and Chairman of the Council for the Ensuing Year
The nomination was seconded by Councillor Williams.
Named7 Apr 2022Strategy and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Strategic Measures Performance 2021/22 - Quarter 3
Councillor Williams referred to the increase in call wait times during the quarter and asked for more details on the resource pressures due to sickness. The City Director confirmed that performance had been affected by the Omicron variant of Covid and that January had been about maintaining services across the council. He confirmed that they were looking to recover the average wait times over the next period.
Asked7 Apr 2022Strategy and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Strategic Measures Performance 2021/22 - Quarter 3
Councillor Williams queried if there was adequate resource at the call centre to be able to reach target if there were any staffing issues in the future. The Assistant Director Strategy, Workforce and Comms, Angela Glithero confirmed that they had real clear plans to improve customer contact with the council including plans to move towards digital solutions which would then free up the phone lines for those needing to contact the council by phone.
Named7 Apr 2022Strategy and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Strategic Measures Performance 2021/22 - Quarter 3
Councillor Williams referred to COU8 – percentage of savings programme delivered and asked how much of the gap had been closed for the unachieved savings from 2020/21 and whether there was confidence in the resilience of the budget setting processes.
Asked7 Apr 2022Strategy and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Strategic Measures Performance 2021/22 - Quarter 3
Councillor Williams asked for more detail on the process for the savings not achieved. The City Director indicated that there were some savings that had been delayed but would be implemented in the next financial year. In a small number of cases, the rationale behind the savings was deemed no longer correct and these would be dealt with by mitigating actions.
Named7 Apr 2022Strategy and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Financial Performance 2021/22 - Quarter 3 (Month 9)
Councillor Williams referred to Education Health and Care Plans (EHCP’s) and the impact in the rising costs. He commented that in February 2022 there was a backlog of 188 EHCP’s and asked if there was a link to staffing levels. He also questioned whether the young people were receiving a good service and was concerned about the impact any delay could have on a young person if their EHCP was not completed in a timely manner.
Asked7 Apr 2022Strategy and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Financial Performance 2021/22 - Quarter 3 (Month 9)
Councillor Williams asked what the typical wait time was currently for an EHCP and whether links were made with other officers in respect of the potential impact. The City Director explained that an EHCP should not be the be all and end all for a young person and if they had identified needs, these should be addressed through schools etc. The EHCP was a way of formalising the arrangements.
Said7 Apr 2022Strategy and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Financial Performance 2021/22 - Quarter 3 (Month 9)
In response to points raised by Councillor Williams regarding the savings target associated with the Front Door Reforms with Children’s Social Care, Councillor Brown explained that the reform was not about making savings but the right thing to do. She commented that in a perfect world, without the Pandemic, they would have been able to recruit staff within the intended timescales etc. However, with the complexity of life and things beyond the council’s control, the savings would take longer to bring to fruition.
Named7 Apr 2022Strategy and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Work Programme
Councillor Williams believed that it would be useful for the Committee to look at how the Performance Measures were chosen and the benchmarking information used. The Assistant Director Governance and Registration and Monitoring Officer suggested that the topic not be looked at in isolation but alongside other elements such as the Operating Plan etc as the performance measures were only part of the story. The Chair suggested that initially, two members meet with the Monitoring Officer with a view to bring a scope forward to a future meeting.
Named31 Mar 2022Children and Family Services Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Strategic Measures Performance 2021/22 - Quarter 3
Councillor Williams referred to the activity status of young people aged 16-17 % NEETs figure and questioned why the figure was now declining when the City had at one time been ahead of its statistical neighbours. He also referred to the 9.9% of young people where the activity status was not known and asked what work was being done to capture the data, as well as how many young people were persistently not known and how this figure compared with other local authorities.
Asked31 Mar 2022Children and Family Services Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Strategic Measures Performance 2021/22 - Quarter 3
Councillor Williams asked for an explanation as to why the number of apprenticeships at the Council was still low and asked about the target figure and about the impact on finances in respect of not meeting the levy target in 2021/22.
Named31 Mar 2022Children and Family Services Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Strategic Measures Performance 2021/22 - Quarter 3
Councillor Williams and the Chair both asked about Education Health Care Plans (EHCP), where EHCP reviews were in terms of performance, about the backlog situation and if there was any update in terms of SEND data.
Seconded27 Jan 2022City Council
Notice of Motion Submitted by Councillor Ashworth and Councillor Williams
The following motion was moved by Councillor Ashworth and seconded by Councillor Williams:
Asked20 Jan 2022Children and Family Services Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Strategic Measures Performance 2021/22 - Quarter 2
In respect of the current number of Council apprenticeships, Councillor Williams asked if the local authority would need to pay back any of the levy it had received. In response, the Cabinet member for Education and Economy commented that the reduced number of Council Apprenticeships was as a result of the Covid-19 Pandemic and that this had also impacted on the studying element of the apprenticeship scheme. She confirmed that work was ongoing to ensure that the local authority didn’t have to pay back the levy and that apprentices were supported particularly as 20% of an apprenticeship was study work.
Asked20 Jan 2022Children and Family Services Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Strategic Measures Performance 2021/22 - Quarter 2
Councillor Williams also asked about the falling numbers in relation to the numbers of pupils in education, employment or training (EET) and about where the number of Children in Care sat in comparison to the bench mark set within the improvement plan.
Named12 Jan 2022Strategy and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee
10:10 Budget Consultation 2022/23
Councillor Williams was of the opinion that the council was artificially creating less demand for the Local Centres. He believed that by reducing the opening hours, this would provide evidence for future years to close more centres due to forced reduced demand. He felt that any data used as evidence of reduced demand during the Covid-19 pandemic was not a true reflection of usage as residents had been unable to access Local Centres during this time.
Named12 Jan 2022Strategy and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee
10:10 Budget Consultation 2022/23
Councillor Williams also referred to Stoke-on-Line and Google and advised ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Moved20 May 2021(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Corporate Services
Appointment of Vice-Chair
A Motion, moved by Councillor David Williams, seconded by Councillor Lilian Dodd that “Councillor Jane Ashworth be appointed as Vice-Chair of the Corporate Services Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the 2021/2022 Municipal Year” was carried.
Seconded20 May 2021City Council
To Elect a Lord Mayor and Chairman of the Council for the Ensuing Year
The nomination was seconded by Councillor Williams.
Named29 Apr 2021(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Corporate Services
Transformation Programme
Councillor Williams referred to the Stronger Together Strategic Plan and Performance Framework which was brought to the Committee in September 2020. He asked when the annual targets would be available. The Cabinet Member for Corporate Resource, Strategy and Partnerships explained that the transformation programme was aiming to ensure a balanced budget and she advised members to look at the Medium-Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) for the last eighteen months.
Said29 Apr 2021(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Corporate Services
Transformation Programme
Councillor Williams agreed that officers were under a great deal of pressure but thought that as we were now in a new financial year, targets should be available. The Cabinet Member for Corporate Resource, Strategy and Partnerships advised that the MTFS had been presented to Budget Council in February 2021, which set the parameters and the targets.
Said21 Apr 2021(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Children and Young People
Youth Offending
Councillor Williams acknowledged the good work that was being undertaken by the Team. He commented on the make-up of the partnership which he observed was skewed towards the state sector which he appreciated was a statutory requirement but he ... view the full minutes text for item 45.
Named12 Mar 2021(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Corporate Services
Strategic Measures Performance 2020/21 - Quarter 3
Comments and Questions from Committee Members Councillor Williams referred to the contact centre accessibility and asked if the average queue time included out of hours. The Director – Strategy and Resources (S151 Officer) confirmed that the average queue time of 4 minutes and 36 seconds referred to the standard opening hours of the contact centre.
Named12 Mar 2021(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Corporate Services
Strategic Measures Performance 2020/21 - Quarter 3
He agreed to provide Councillor Williams with the data for the out of hours service following the meeting.
Named12 Mar 2021(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Corporate Services
Financial Performance 2020/21 - Quarter 3 (Month 9)
Councillor Williams referred to the Capital Investment Programme 2020/21 – 2024/25 and asked why the Homelessness and Youth Hubs were still showing when they had previously been discussed and agreed at Budget Council. The Director – Strategy and Resources (S151 Officer) explained that this report had been drafted pre-Budget Council and had been based on the current budget year. The report would be updated moving forward.
Asked12 Mar 2021(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Corporate Services
Financial Performance 2020/21 - Quarter 3 (Month 9)
Councillor Williams asked, if elements of the Capital Investment Programme were removed, could this result in further savings that could be directed elsewhere. The Director – Strategy and Resources (S151 Officer) advised that this had already been taken-into-account as part of the budget setting process.
Said12 Mar 2021(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Corporate Services
Work Programme
Councillor Williams suggested that the Committee undertake a review in relation to the Capital Programme as a point of learning. The review to include one or two completed projects focussing on the original business case to secure inclusion in the Capital Investment Programme, whether the project completed within budget and expected and actual level of return. The Assistant Director – Governance and Registration ( Monitoring Officer) agreed that this would be a rich area for the Committee to undertake Scrutiny and an area where they would be able to constructively contribute.
Named12 Mar 2021(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Corporate Services
Work Programme
The Committee supported the approach outlined and Councillor Dodd expressed a wish to also be involved in the scoping of the review alongside Councillor Williams.
Said4 Mar 2021(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Children and Young People
Strategic Measures 2020/21 - Quarter 3
Councillor Williams commented on the lack of targets set in relation to apprenticeships and stated that he would like to see further information on this with details of local targets being introduced post lockdown in the next update. He also referred to the low number of Educational Health Care Plans (EHCP) completed by the required time and the lack of benchmarking / comparative data.
Moved21 Jan 2021City Council
Notice of Motion Regarding Grit and Grit Bins
The following motion was moved by Councillor Williams and seconded by Councillor Wazir:
Named13 Jan 2021(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Corporate Services
Budget Consultation 2021/22
Councillor Williams referred to Appendix D of the report which included the overview of all efficiencies and additional income savings that did not require public consultation. He voiced his concern that some of the savings had very little detail and asked for clarification on the process for these and who made the decision on which savings did or did not require public consultation. The Assistant Director - Finance (S151 Officer) advised that these proposals, reviewed by the Legal Services team, did not require public consultation as they did not impact on service users and were the managerial and operational aspects of the budget.
Named26 Mar 2020City Council
Minutes of Committees
On the motion of Councillor Williams, seconded by Councillor Ashworth, it was:-
Said24 Jan 2020(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Children and Young People
Strategic Measures 2019/20 Quarter 2
Councillor Williams commented on the reduction in the number of apprenticeships showing from Quarter 2 in 2018/19 to the same period in 2019/20. He referred to the performance being recorded as above average and asked if the percentage was above average. Jen Lomas confirmed that, compared to national figures, the council’s uptake was higher.
Named24 Jan 2020(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Children and Young People
Strategic Measures 2019/20 Quarter 2
Amanda Evans advised that future reports would include additional detail under the current performance figures to provide the clarification that Councillor Williams was seeking.
Said24 Jan 2020(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Children and Young People
Strategic Measures 2019/20 Quarter 2
Councillor Williams commented on the impact that organisational structure changes resulting from the Mid-Year budget update had had in terms of removing some of apprenticeship positions.
Asked24 Jan 2020(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Children and Young People
Stronger Together Vision
Councillor Williams asked how priorities had been reviewed, he referred to the impact of the Mid-Year budget update and associated cuts in services and queried whether the impact had been updated. It was confirmed that updates were being made but the timing of reporting had impacted.
Asked24 Jan 2020(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Children and Young People
Budget Consultation 2020/21
Councillor Williams asked if, where possible, proposals for future budget cuts could include within the narrative an actual percentage of the overall budget.
Seconded23 May 2019(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Children and Young People
Appointment of Vice Chair
A motion, moved by Councillor S Bowers, seconded by Councillor Williams “that Councillor Lillian Dodd be appointed Vice-Chair of the Children and Young People’s Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the Municipal Year” was carried.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.