Minutes of Last Meeting (30/09/15)
Cllr J Garner, who had been absent from the meeting held on 30 September 2015, sought clarification on the content of the SPD that had been considered. Officers agreed to respond separately.
Every time Stoke-on-Trent's minutes name Councillor Environment, as the council published it.
Cllr J Garner, who had been absent from the meeting held on 30 September 2015, sought clarification on the content of the SPD that had been considered. Officers agreed to respond separately.
Councillor J Garner noted a typing error on page 23 and felt this should be Marsh Street and not March Street. She also suggested that it was important to engage Ward Councillors at an early stage regarding GTTAA.
Councillor J Garner asked when the Play Pitch Strategy was due.
Councillor J Garner raised concerns about the Wedgewood site and the reported downgrading of some of the builds. She asked if this could set a president.
A motion moved by Councillor Garner and seconded by Councillor Platt that “the application be approved subject to the inclusion of a condition requiring the submission of a waste management plan to ensure adequate waste provision”, was carried.
(Councillor Broughan left the room for the duration of this item) A motion moved by Councillor Shotton and seconded by Councillor Garner “that members are minded to approve the application and request a further report to be brought back to the next committee meeting with conditions”, was lost.
Councillor Garner, Cabinet Member for Housing, Neighbourhoods and Communities introduced this item, the purpose of which was to inform the committee of the production of the Safer City Partnership Plan 2014-2017 and to provide an overview of its purpose. The plan reflected on the successes of our previous business plans, identified current and future challenges and outlined the approach over the next three years.
In moving a motion to approve the policy, Councillor J Garner made further reference to the recommendations put forward by the task and finish group and the resultant consultation that had been carried out on adopting a Cumulative Impact Policy for the city centre which had led to the inclusion at section 10 in the Policy of a cumulative impact policy area for the city centre . She explained that the inclusion of a cumulative impact policy introduced a presumption that within the area identified the council would refuse applications for new premises certificates or variations to existing licences or certificates, whenever it received relevant representations, unless the applicant could demonstrate why the operation of the premises would not add to the cumulative impact already being experienced.
In moving a motion that the report be noted, Councillor J Garner commented on the reference made in the report to the transfer of the 101 system to a single control room and she also highlighted the background to the City Council becoming a recipient of the information, which had historically been submitted only to County Council meetings. Both issues received further comment from members of the council.
Minutes of a reconvened meeting of the Adults and Neighbourhoods Overview and Scrutiny Committee held at the Civic Centre, Glebe Street, Stoke -on-Trent on Monday, 22 September 2014 Present Councillor Bagh Ali (Chair), Councillor Karen Clarke (Vice-Chair), Councillor Kath Banks, Councillor Abi Brown, Councillor Randolph Conteh and Councillor Sheila Pitt Other Attendees Councillor Joy Garner (Cabinet Member for Housing, Neighbourhoods, and Community Safety) and Councillor Gwen Hassall (Cabinet Member for Social Care), Tony Oakman (Executive Director – People), Christine Whitehead (Assistant Director - Adult Social Care), Zafar Iqbal (Interim Head of Public Health), Sharon Taaffe (Head of Health Improvement), Alistair Fisher ( Principal Health Improvement Manager - Long-Term Conditions ), Julie Griffin (Head of Co-operative Working), Pete Stoddart (Finance Team Manager - People), Karl Robinson (Lead Analyst), Mandy Pattinson (Scrutiny Officer) and Ellen Washington (Democratic Services Officer), Helen Jones (Staffordshire and Stoke on Trent Adult Safeguarding Partnership) and Becky Elliott ( Healthwatch ) Apologies for absence Apologies were received from Councillor James and Councillor Muhammad Aumir.
The City Council received details of an amendment to the Terms of Reference of the Staffordshire Police and Crime Panel, which allowed for the appointment of a named substitute member to represent the authority’s core representative, Councillor Joy Garner.
Present Councillor Joy Garner (in-the-Chair), Councillor Terry Crowe and Councillor Lee Wanger Present as Reserve Councillor Alan Dutton Officers Sandra Bradbury (Licensing Officer), Debra Barber (Legal Officer) and Sharon Simpson (Democratic Services Officer) Other Attendees The Applicant and Kevin Sherratt (Staffordshire Police) APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE An apology was received from Councillor Banks DISCLOSURE OF INTERESTS There were no disclosures of interest EXCLUSION OF THE PUBLIC Resolved – That under Section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972, the public be excluded from the meeting for the following item(s) of business on the grounds that it/they involves the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined in the paragraph(s) of Part 1 of Schedule 12(A) of such Act indicated, as now amended by the Local Government (Access to Information) (Variation) Order 2006.
Present Councillor Joy Garner (Chair), Councillor Neil Day, Councillor Lee Wanger and Councillor Jackie Barnes (Reserve Member) Officers Sandra Bradbury (Licensing Officer), Jeanette Tsoi (Legal Advisor) and Angela Gardner (Democratic Services Officer) Other Attendees Item 9 PC Graeme Owen (Staffordshire Police), [name removed] (Licensing Officer – Staffordshire Police), [name removed] (Director of Living Room (Stoke) Limited, Premise Licence Holder) and [name removed] (Designated Premise Supervisor)
Presentation of Long Service Awards to Councillors The Lord Mayor presented Long Service Awards to Councillor Kath Banks, Councillor Joy Garner and Councillor Andy Platt in recognition of them completing twelve years’ service as a Councillor. The Council joined him in congratulating the three members.
The Leader of the Council, Councillor Mohammed Pervez, formally announced appointments to the Cabinet as follows:- Councillor Mohammed Pervez - Leader of the Council Councillor Paul Shotton - Deputy Leader of the Council and Cabinet Member for Economic Development Councillor Ruth Rosenau - Cabinet Member for Regeneration, Planning and Transportation Councillor Gwen Hassall - Cabinet Member for Social Care (Lead Member for Children’s Services) Councillor Terry Crowe - Cabinet Member for Finance, Procurement and Commissioning Councillor Joy Garner - Cabinet Member for Housing, Neighbourhoods and Community Safety Councillor Adrian Knapper - Cabinet Member for Health and Wellbeing Councillor Andy Platt - Cabinet Member Green Enterprises and Clean City Councillor Shaun Pender - Cabinet Member for Education Councillor Olwen Hamer - Cabinet member for Transformation and Resources.
Members invited Councillor Joy Garner, Chair of the Licensing Committee, who was not a member of the Overview and Scrutiny committee to speak in respect of this item.
Comments from Committee Members The Interim Director of Public Health welcomed the suggestion from Councillor Joy Garner that Public Health staff liaise with the Council’s Licensing division about how to become more involved in Licensing reviews and to work more collaboratively with the division.
A Motion moved by Councillor Joy Garner, seconded by Councillor Bagh Ali that “Councillor Alison Wedgwood be appointed as Chair of the Corporate Services Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the Municipal Year” was carried.
A motion moved by Councillor Kath Banks and seconded by Councillor Tom Reynolds, that Councillor Joy Garner be appointed Chair of the Licensing and General Purposes Committee for the municipal year, was carried.
A motion moved by Councillor Joy Garner and seconded by Councillor Tom Reynolds, that Councillor Kath Banks be appointed Vice-Chair of the Licensing and General Purposes Committee for the municipal year, was carried.
Item 35 - Designation of Polling Places Councillor Conteh requested that his commiserations to Councillor Joy Garner be recorded with regards to the outcome of the recent Police and Crime Commissioner Elections.
Councillor Garner advised that a full review of the whole process was due to be undertaken by Government.
Item 36 – Gambling Act 2005, Statement of Principles Councillor Garner commented that it would be useful for all members of the Licensing and General Purposes Committee to be invited to attend a meeting of the Licensing Working Group when issues, such as the Gambling Act 2005 were discussed.
Councillor Garner commented that it was important that, in the current economic climate, the City Council prioritised its services. Option 2 would assist elected members by enabling evidence to be collated with regards to ward issues and thereby informing decisions.
Councillor Garner queried whether the information in respect of the audit – Funding of the Demolition of Boothen Methodist Church, had been dealt with. The Assistant Director – Financial Services advised that areas had been identified where procedures could be tightened up, he agreed to issue further information to Members when the review was complete.
Members’ Comments/Questions Councillor Garner and Councillor Conteh both voiced their surprise that no evidence of displacement activity had been found due to the number of complaints that they had received from residents in their wards.
Councillor Garner also asked what system was used to prioritise areas for the introduction of new or extensions to current zones.
Councillor Garner commented that the Committee could have gone into closed session in order to receive the information.
A motion moved by Councillor Kath Banks and seconded by Councillor Ruth Rosenau , that Councillor Joy Garner be appointed Vice-Chair of the Licensing and General Purposes Committee for the municipal year, was carried.
A Motion moved by Councillor Hayward, seconded by Councillor J Garner “that Councillor Andy Lilley be appointed as Chair of the Business Services and Chief Executive’s Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the Municipal Year” was carried.
A Motion moved by Councillor Lilley, seconded by Councillor J Garner “that Councillor Hayward be appointed as Vice-Chair of the Business Services and Chief Executive’s Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the Municipal Year” was carried.
A motion moved by Councillor Garner and seconded by Councillor Platt, that Councillor Hayward be appointed Vice-Chair of the Audit Committee for the municipal year, was carried.
Councillor Garner referred to the number of twitter followers and asked how many of these were businesses that would receive alerts regarding procurement.
Councillor Garner commented that there were a number of outside bodies that were appointed to at Annual Council and commented that not all such as the Burslem School of Art to she was appointed, reported to an Overview and Scrutiny Committee. She further commented that to her knowledge, there had not been a Board meeting since her appointment and asked where such meetings would feed back to.
Present Councillor Joy Garner (Vice-Chair, in-the-Chair), Councillor Neil Day and Councillor Andy Lilley Present as Reserve Councillor Matthew Fry Other Attendees Rachel Collier (Licensing Manager), Zulficar Ali (Solicitor), Sharon Simpson (Democratic Services Officer) , PC G Owen and Sergeant D Wright (Staffordshire Police) The Licensing Sub-Committee considered an application for the transfer of a premises licence in respect of Retro Lounge, 19/21 Broad Street, Hanley, Stoke -on-Trent, ST1 4HS.
Councillor Garner referred to the item scheduled for the next meeting on the Mandate for Change and Transformation Plan and queried whether it was in fact too late for the Committee to look at the item as the Mandate for Change launch event had already been held. She also referred to the Forward Plan item on Community Asset Transfer Policy and indicated her support for the Committee to consider the document.
In response to a question from Councillor Garner regarding the lease of computers and equipment, the Assistant Director of Financial Services explained that historically, the City Council had mainly leased its I.T. equipment. However, moving forward, equipment would be financed by the most advantageous method, whether this was by lease or purchase in order to optimise value for money for the City Council.
Members’ Comments/Questions Councillor Joy Garner referred to a previous meeting of the Licensing and Consumer Protection Committee, held on 10 November 2010 (Item 48), where it had been resolved that “future updates of the smoke-free legislation be included in the Consumer Protection Outcomes report”. She asked why this information had not been provided and asked if outcomes in respect of licensing functions could also be included in the future. The Compliance & Health Protection Manager advised the Committee that the smoke-free legislation update had been scheduled for a future meeting and the Licensing Manager confirmed that licensing updates would also be provided in the future.
Councillor Joy Garner also requested that future reports include updates on the enforcement of stray horses across the City and to explore opportunities for income generation via genealogy.
A Motion moved by Councillor Day, seconded by Councillor J Garner “that Councillor Andy Lilley be appointed as Chair of the Business Services and Chief Executive’s Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the Municipal Year” was carried.
A motion moved by Councillor Joy Garner and seconded by Councillor Gwen Hassall, that Councillor Abi Brown be appointed Chair of the Licensing and General Purposes Committee for the municipal year, was carried.
A motion moved by Councillor Abi Brown and seconded by Councillor Kath Banks, that Councillor Joy Garner, be appointed Vice-Chair of the Licensing and General Purposes Committee for the municipal year, was carried.
Members Comments/Questions Councillor Garner: Suggested that it would be appropriate to undertake pre-decision scrutiny on 5 of the 6 new items contained within Issue 22 of the Forward Plan. These included:
This item was introduced by Councillor Garner, the Chair of the “Sustainability and Climate Change – How the planning process can help” Task and Finish Review.
Councillor Garner then proceeded to go through each of the recommendations giving an explanation and answering questions as appropriate.
Councillor Knapper reported on the positive impact that greener energy could have for social housing tenants with lower cost heating and also commented on the need for local authorities and social housing landlords to have higher housing standards than private landlords and Councillor Garner confirmed that the aim was to raise housing standards across the board.
In respect of Recommendation 4, Councillor Garner referred to a very interesting debate which had occurred at a Forum which had been attended by the private sector and where the opinion was given that there was a lower standard/quality of provision in Stoke-on-Trent.
The Chair referred to Officer training as included in Recommendation 5 of the report and Councillor Matloob also asked about the “self scoring mechanism (Recommendation 3 refers) and Councillor Garner and Edward Sidley explained how this mechanism worked. In addition, Edward Sidley also commented that Council’s had their own policies, plus ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Members Comments/Questions Councillor Garner was please to see that we were continuing with Task and Finish and Spotlight Reviews in the proposed new committee’s work programmes in the new municipal year.
John Ross referred to the availability of a DVD on national select committees and Councillor Garner indicated that she would like to see our own Overview and Scrutiny Committees working in the manner of a select committee. She also indicated that she hoped the work on carbon reduction would be rolled forward into the relevant Work Programme for the following year.
In Councillor Edwards’ absence, Councillor Joy Garner accepted the gift of an Aynsley Vase and bouquet of flowers on her behalf and Councillors Pervez , Salih , Irving, Ward and Bowers each paid tribute to the significant contributions made by Councillor Edwards during her time in office.
On the motion of Councillor Garner, seconded by Councillor Clarke, it was:-
Councillor Conteh moved and Councillor Garner seconded that the minutes of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee meetings held on 17 January and 7 February 2011 be noted.
Councillor Hassell moved and Councillor Garner seconded that the minutes of the Improving Communities Overview and Scrutiny Committee meetings held on 25 th January and 15 th February 2011 be noted.
Councillor Garner moved and Councillor J. Davis seconded that the minutes of the Transformation and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee meetings held on 25 th January and 15 th February 2011 be noted.
Type of Interest Nature of Interest Chair (Councillor Conway) 46, 47, 48 Personal Council house tenant Councillor Garner 46, 47, 48 Personal Council house tenant
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Garner acknowledged that the Section 30 Dispersal Orders worked well, but felt that the exit strategies did not work so well.
Councillor Garner, Chair of the task and finish group, thanked everyone involved in the task and finish review for their contribution. She explained that the review was undertaken following concerns raised by the Improving Communities Overview and Scrutiny Committee that the Local Area Agreement (LAA) performance indicator NI15 Most Serious Violence was continually failing to reach its target and was performing unfavourably when compared to other authorities positioned in the same family group. She gave a brief outline of some of the key issues looked at as part of the review.
Councillor Garner asked why there was not more emphasis on reducing the level of rent paid to social landlords.
Councillor Garner requested the figures for the number of garages in use and the income received from the rental of these garages.
Councillor Garner 74 Personal and Prejudicial (left the room after speaking on the item) Spoke at the meeting against the proposal.
Members received representations from Councillor Garner objecting to the application and from [name removed] , the Agent, speaking in support of the application.
A motion moved by Councillor Garner and seconded by Councillor Follows “that prior to occupation, details of a crossing facility across Westport Road is to be agreed in writing by the Local Planning Authority and implemented prior to occupation of the new Academy”, was carried.
In seconding the referral, Councillor Garner suggested that the Overview and Scrutiny Committee needed to look at a policy for celebrating the many prominent singers that originate from the City.
On the motion of Councillor Garner, seconded by Councillor Clarke, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Garner, seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
On the Motion of Councillor Shotton , seconded by Councillor Garner, it was:
Councillor Khan moved and Councillor Garner seconded that the minutes of the Licensing and Consumer Protection Committee meetings held on 11 October and 10 November 2010 be noted.
Councillor Garner moved and Councillor Hamer seconded that the minutes of the Transformation and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting held on 9 November 2010 be noted.
Members Comments/Questions Cllr Garner: Forward Plan Reference 221 – Greenspace Strategy – Suggested that it may be appropriate to carry out pre-decision scrutiny on this issue.
Cllr Garner expressed concern regarding this item but Cllr Conway gave assurances that this matter would be discussed by the Committee at its meeting on 7 Decembe 2010.
Cllr Garner raised the issue of the need for the City Council to ensure that, were services were being reduced or ceased altogether as part of the budget cuts, that work was done in order to anticipate and mitigate for the impact of these cuts. Peter Bates agreed with this comment and indicated that one of the criteria for assessment and ... view the full minutes text for item 31.
Cllr Garner: Key Deliverable 10 11 19 – We will support and prepare people into work by offering 100 work experience placements in Environmental Services - What do these figures mean? Improvement and Performance Manager explained that this meant that the target had been exceeded.
Cllr Garner: Asked whether those offered work experience were being kept on and if so how many. The Improvement and Performance Manager indicated that she would need to look into this issue and would forward the details to the Councillor.
Cllr Garner: Key Deliverable 10 11 23 and 26 – Referred to the fact that when a new store/supermarket first opened it generally appointed more staff to begin with than were needed and that they usually reduced staff numbers by approximately one quarter after the initial opening and asked if this was a positive in this instance.
Cllr Garner also referred to JETS/Connexions, indicating that the future of both was uncertain. The Performance Improvement Manager indicated that the figures were looking positive and referred to the fact that there was a wider strategy behind these Key Deliverables. She indicated that she would seek to ascertain the latest position regarding these Key Deliverables and emphasised the fact that there was a lot of detail that sat behind this.
Cllr Garner pointed out that Looked after Children needed to be taken into consideration during the work into this review and the Chair confirmed that this issue had already been taken into consideration.
A motion moved by Councillor Garner and seconded by Councillor Bridges “for a site visit to consider the scope and size of the development and how it would affect the wider community, particularly in terms of highway considerations,” was carried.
Members Comments/Questions Councillor Garner referred to the disposal of animals and asked if they could be sold to animal welfare charities for a nominal amount. The Principal Trading Standards Officer confirmed that the governing legislation stated that animals had to be sold at public auction and generally charities would not deal with sale animals.
Councillor Garner suggested that future reports also include projects undertaken on a regional level.
Forward Plan References 192, 193, 194 and 200 – European Social Fund 2011-13, JET Service – ERDF Bid, The Work Programme and ESF community Grants - Cllr Garner asked that more detail be provided to members of the Committee in respect of all of these items, which were all linked and it was agreed that details with respect to each would be forwarded to all committee members accordingly.
Cllr Garner indicated that she would like the relevant Overview and Scrutiny Committee to undertake pre-decision scrutiny on this item.
Cllr Garner: Suggested that we needed to encourage a balance between small and large GP surgeries and expressed concern that the overarching PCT and strategic placing of GP’s surgeries may be lost in all of these changes but that we should ensure that there were not pockets in the City where the local population did not have access to a GP because GP’s didn’t want to establish a surgery in a particular area. The Director of Adult Social Care, Health and Communities suggested that it would be appropriate to include a ... view the full minutes text for item 23.
Members Comments/Questions Cllr Garner: Referred to the Executive Response Schedule and to the fact that a number of Lead Officers named in the report had either left or may be leaving. John Ross agreed to ensure that this information was updated as appropriate.
Cllr Garner: One of the recommendations contained within the report was that Carbon reduction targets should be included within Director’s Performance Development Reviews (PDR’s) and that this should also form part or other member’s of staff PDR’s (Recommendation 1 (e).
In addition, Cllr Garner indicated that the target of 40% carbon reduction by 2020 on Council operations should be achievable.
Cllr Garner also suggested that the responses to 4 (b), (C), and (d) also required clarifying. In respect of recommendation 5, it was noted that the Local Development Framework (LDF) would be launched later that week at the Development Management Committee.
Thanked Cllr Garner for her hard work and thoroughness as Chair of the Review indicating that the response to most of the recommendations contained within the Executive Response Schedule was “yes” and that where the response was “partial” this was generally attributable to a lack of or reduction in funding. He also referred to the installation of solar panels into new build council houses with this Authority being one of the first to do so.
Cllr Garner: Reported that she was awaiting information from officers regarding serious violent crime.
Members Comments/Questions Cllr Barnes: Referred to the situation which had arisen regarding the Telecare /Lifelines Service and indicated that this item had been included in the relevant issue of the City Council’s Forward Plan and that pre-decision scrutiny could have been carried out if requested by the relevant overview and scrutiny committee, Cllr Garner: Referred to the fact that the meeting of the Transformation and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee held on 23 September 2010 had been in danger of being inquorate and referred to the need for members to ensure that they attended those meetings which they were members of.
Members Comments/Questions Cllr Garner: Asked if the Government had announced that any other areas other than the NHS Budget would be ring fenced? The Director of Central Services responded by indicating that at the time when the Emergency Budget was made in June 2010, the Chancellor had announced that spending on International Development, Health and to a certain extent, education, would be protected. He indicated that if the Government chose to go down the route of cutting the ABG then the implications could be more difficult for the City Council as there were some programmes that were funded by ABG that were highly contentious.
Finally, John Ross reported on details of member training which was to take place, together with feedback from the Chair (Cllr Naylor) and Cllr Garner who had attended the Centre for Public Scrutiny Annual Conference on 30 June – 1 July 2010.
On the motion of Councillor Garner, seconded by Councillor Dale, it was:-
Councillor Garner moved, and Councillor Brian seconded, “that the appointment of City Council representatives to serve on the Management Committees of Harold Clowes and Packmoor Community Halls be determined by ballot.” When put to the vote, the procedural motion was supported by more than 25 members present and voting at the meeting and a ballot was conducted in the Chamber. Following the counting of the votes by officers from the Members Services Division, the Head of Legal Services announced the results, and it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Garner, it was:-
On the Motion of Councillor Shotton , seconded by Councillor Garner, it was:-
Davis moved and Councillor Garner seconded that the minutes of the Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting held on 17/9/10 be noted.
Councillor Garner moved and Councillor Najmi seconded that the minutes of the Transformation and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting held on 21/7/10 be noted.
A motion moved by Councillor Fradley and seconded by Councillor Garner “that the application be approved subject to the two additional conditions, outlined below, to prevent dust and noise pollution in the interests of residential amenity”, was carried.
On the motion of Councillor Garner, seconded by Councillor Clarke, it was:-
Councillor Powell-Beckett moved and Councillor Garner seconded that the minutes of the Licensing and Consumer Protection Committee meeting held on 2/7/10 be noted.
Councillor Conway moved and Councillor Garner seconded that the minutes of the Improving Communities Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting held on13/7/10 be noted.
Councillor Garner moved and Councillor Hamer seconded that the minutes of the Transformation and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee held on 7/6/10 be noted.
The Cabinet received notification of a completed review by the Transformation and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee entitled “Communications and New Media ” which was presented by Councillor Garner, Chair of the Committee, in the absence of the Task and Finish Group Members.
Councillor Garner outlined details of the main findings of the review together with the recommendations which had been put forward by the Task and Finish Group. She took the opportunity to thank all of the local media organisations and individuals who had taken part in the review .
Interest Nature Councillor Wright 28 Personal Had corresponded with the objector Councillor Garner 30 Personal and prejudicial (left the room after speaking on the item – did not vote) Addressed the Committee as a speaker on behalf of the Smallthorne Village Residents Association Councillor Clarke 30 Personal and prejudicial (left the room for the duration of the item) Knew the previous owner of the premises
Councillor Garner moved and Councillor Ryan seconded the following motion, which was passed:-
Members received representations from Councillor Garner, on behalf of the Smallthorne Village Residents Association, confirming withdrawal of their objection to the application.
Type of Interest Nature of Interest Chair ( Councillor Conway) and Councillor Garner 12 Personal Council house tenants
Outstanding Actions Councillor Garner noted that the report ‘Planned Housing Investment Programme –Kitchens and Bathrooms’ deferred from the previous meeting, would no longer be considered by the committee and consequently expressed her concerns about heath and safety issues with regard to the unsafe siting of appliances, which had been raised with her by tenants.
The Head of Housing Services agreed to look into the kitchen and bathroom programme to identify any health and safety issues and to report back directly to the Chair, Councillor Garner and the Cabinet Member for Housing, Planning and Transportation, Councillor Ward, in the first instance.
Members Comments/Questions Councillor Garner : Referred to the substantial number of petitions received by the City Council regarding planning and licensing issues and asked if these should be included within this report, whilst accepting that the processes for dealing with them was different.
Councillor Garner: Reported on her attendance at the Centre For Public Scrutiny ( CfPS ) Conference together with Councillor Naylor and Paul Baddeley and gave details of the Conference.
A motion moved by the Chair, Councillor Joanne Powell-Beckett and seconded by Councillor Joy Garner that “a letter be sent to the Chief Constable of Staffordshire Police expressing the concerns of the Committee with regards to the non-attendance of Staffordshire Police Licensing Officers at Licensing Sub-Committee meetings”, was carried.
On the motion of Councillor Garner, seconded by Councillor Clarke, it was:-
Councillor Powell-Becket moved and Councillor Garner seconded that the minutes of the Licensing and Consumer Protection Committee meeting held on 8/6/10 be noted.
Davis moved and Councillor Garner seconded that the minutes of the Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting held on 23/4/10 be noted.
Councillor Conteh moved and Councillor Garner seconded that the minutes of the Improving Communities Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting held on 22/4/10 be noted.
Davis moved and Councillor Garner seconded that the minutes of the Transformation and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee meetings held on 16/4/10 and 29/4/10 be noted.
It was noted that Councillor Garner had replaced Councillor Bagh Ali as the Labour Group representative on this Committee.
Councillor Garner referred to Proxy Buying and asked what was being done to educate the public on the penalties. Sergeant Wright advised that plans were being developed for the Respect weeks when adults, children and shop owners would be approached and given information on the penalties of proxy buying. The local media would also be utilised to highlight this area.
Councillor Garner asked for the in-depth figures for this indicator.
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Garner raised her concern that there was still no proper signage for the City Farm and that Dimensions was omitted from the list of attractions whilst Waterworld was listed.
Councillor Garner also suggested that the Civic Centre be renamed the Civic Offices. The Engineer explained that the appropriate application has to be filed in order to obtain a brown tourism sign and no such application had been received in respect of the City Farm or Dimensions. He highlighted the uncertainty surrounding the future of the City Farm.
Councillor Reynolds moved and Councillor Garner seconded that a recorded vote be taken on the nominations for Parkhall Primary School and this was supported by more than 25 members present and voting at the meeting.
On the motion of Councillor Garner, seconded by Councillor Lyth , it was:-
On the Motion of Councillor Garner, seconded by Councillor M. Davis, it was:
Councillor Garner moved and Councillor Z. Ali seconded that the minutes of the Adult and Older People’s Wellbeing Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting be noted.
Councillor Garner moved and Councillor M. Davis seconded that the minutes of the Improving Communities Overview and Scrutiny Committee be noted.
Councillor Garner referred to the minutes of the Sports Grounds Certification Panel held on 27 September 2008 and asked for confirmation that Councillors Jean Edwards and Adrian Knapper had not been in attendance at this meeting of the Panel. The Democratic Services Officer confirmed that they had not.
Councillor Garner also enquired if the issues that had been highlighted in the minutes of the above meeting had now been resolved. Officers advised the committee of the actions taken.
On the motion of Councillor Garner, seconded by Ibbs , it was:-
Councillor Garner referred to the Sports Grounds Certification Panel and queried why members of the Panel were no longer provided with seating when attending match day visits at the Britannia Stadium and Vale Park.
A motion moved by Councillor Ross Irving and seconded by Councillor Joy Garner that “a further report be submitted to the next meeting of the Licensing and Consumer Protection Committee outlining the remit of the Sports Grounds Certification Panel”, was carried.
Councillor Garner enquired if Councillor Tolley had as yet sat the training to enable him to sit as a member on the Licensing Sub-Committees. The Democratic Services Officer confirmed that he had not and agreed to follow this up.
Councillor Garner referred to internal signage in licensed vehicles and relayed the positive comments that she had received from members of the public with regards to the driver’s licence being displayed on the dashboard. She requested that praise be fed back to the Licensing Service.
On the motion of Councillor Lyth , seconded by Councillor Garner, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Ibbs , seconded by Councillor Garner, it was:-
On the motion of the Elected Mayor, Mark Meredith, seconded by Councillor Garner, it was:-
Davis moved and Councillor Garner seconded that the minutes of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee be noted.
Councillor Garner moved and Councillor M. Davis seconded that the minutes of the Improving Communities Overview and Scrutiny Committee be noted.
Councillor Garner introduced the draft final report of the Task and Finish Group that had been set up to look at Interpretation and Translation Services. She indicated that the Task and Finish Group had found that the City Council was not translating as much information as was first thought. She confirmed that the review had also looked at translation for the blind, deaflinks and disabled people.
Councillor Garner explained that there was now a database that held the customers requirements meaning that they did not have to keep contacting the City Council everytime information was sent to them as it should automatically be sent out in the required format. The only time the customer needed to contact the City Council was if their requirements changed.
Councillor Ellie Walker queried whether there was any funding for staff training Councillor Garner highlighted that one of the recommendations was for the Executive to support training and indicated that some people did do the courses out of work.
Councillor Garner explained that to be a recognised translator, the person would have to have a degree in the language and also there were translators with specialisms which was costly to be trained at that level. She indicated that in some cases, translators had to be brought in from out of the area and therefore there was the cost of travel to consider. However, she confirmed that the fees charged internally could be looked at.
However, there had also got to be a balance against the cost of translation Councillor Garner commented that some Local Authorities were translating too much which was costly. She believed that the emphasis should be for people to learn English.
She indicated that this had an effect on learning for other pupils and had suggested that separate classes be held for those pupils who could not currently speak English Councillor Garner commented that pupils learnt English at a faster pace if they were integrated with English speaking pupils
Councillor Ibbs moved and Councillor Garner seconded, ‘that:
Councillor Garner moved and Councillor Ibbs seconded ‘that the City Council accepts the recommendations of the report and amends Part 6 of the Constitution accordingly, save as regards:
On the Motion of the Elected Mayor Mark Meredith, seconded by Councillor Garner, it was:
On the Motion of Councillor Garner seconded by Councillor Knapper , it was:
Councillor James moved and Councillor Garner seconded that the minutes of the General Purposes Committee meetings held on 2 June and 2 July 2008 be noted.
Councillor Coleman moved and Councillor Garner seconded that the minutes of the Standards Committee meeting held on 4 June 2008 be noted.
Councillor Garner moved and Councillor Edwards seconded that the minutes of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee meeting held on 30 May 2008 be noted.
Councillor Garner moved and Councillor Tolley seconded that the minutes of the Improving Communities Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting held on 18 June 2008 be noted.
Councillor Irving moved and Councillor Garner seconded “that the persons referred to in the schedule now placed around the Chamber be appointed as the City Council representatives to serve on the outside bodies listed, for the terms of office specified in that schedule (unless they should cease to be a councillor)”.
(Three members to be nominated by the Executive and Members Board and three members to be nominated by the Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee.) Councillor Ibbs moved, and Councillor Garner seconded, ‘that the City Council:
Councillor Garner moved and Councillor Tolley seconded that the minutes of the Licensing and Consumer Protection Committee meetings held on 20 February, 2 April and 21 May 2008 be noted.
Councillor Garner moved and Councillor Tolley seconded that the minutes of the Improving Communities Overview and Scrutiny Committee meetings held on 3 April and 15 May 2008 be noted.
On the Motion of Councillor Garner, seconded by Councillor Ibbs, it was:
Councillor Garner moved, and Councillor Ibbs seconded, ‘that Councillors Conteh and Brian remain as the two City Council’s representatives on Staffordshire Police Authority.’ Councillor A.
Councillor Joy Garner declared a personal and prejudicial interest in items 8 & 9 as a member of the Burslem Regeneration Company and also because she had declared previously her opposition to the proposed scheme, took no part in discussion and left the room prior to consideration.
On the motion of Councillor Rigby, seconded by Councillor Garner, it was:
On the motion of Councillor Garner, seconded by Councillor Miller, it was:
On the motion of Councillor Garner, seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:
Councillor Garner reported on a meeting of the Licensing and Consumer Protection Committee on 21 November 2007. In presenting the report, she drew the Council’s attention to action that had been taken by the Licensing Sub-Committee to suspend the premises licence for Furnace Stores, Normacot for a period of one month which, she explained, had received positive press coverage. Elected Members present at the meeting agreed that by taking action to suspend the licence it had assisted in demonstrating that under-age sales of alcohol in the City would not be tolerated.
On the motion of Councillor Garner, seconded by Councillor Capey, it was:
Councillor Garner moved and Councillor Pitt seconded that the minutes of the Audit Committee held on 30 October 2007 be noted.
Councillor Garner moved and Councillor Pitt seconded that the minutes of the Improving Communities Overview and Scrutiny Committee meetings held on 18 and 29 October 2007 be noted.
Minutes of a meeting of the Licensing and Registration Panel held at the Civic Centre, Stoke-on-Trent on Friday, 21 September 2007 RECORD OF ATTENDANCE City Councillors Councillor Joy Garner (Chair) , Councillors D Hall, D Capey , D Conway, R Irving, P Sandland and G Webb Apologies submitted Councillor Reginald Booth (Vice-Chair), Councillor Sybil Halfpenny and Councillor Alan Joynson Absent (if any) Other Attendees Ian Tamburello (Principal Licensing Officer), Mike Keighley (Licensing Support Officer) and Trevor Vernon (Solicitor) , Angela Gardner (Democratic Services Officer) (Secretary) Apologies Apologies were noted.
Declarations of Interest (if any) Member Clause Type of Interest Nature of Interest Councillor Garner (Chair) Clause 10 – Consideration of the Revocation or Suspension of Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Drivers Licence ( Paras . 1 & 2) Personal and prejudicial interest and left the meeting whilst this item was under consideration Submitted complaint against the licence-holder Exclusion of the Public Resolved - That under Section 100(A )( 4) of the Local Government Act, 1972, the public be excluded from the meeting for the following item(s) of business on the grounds that it/they involves the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined in the paragraph(s) of Part 1 of Schedule 12(A) of such Act indicated, as now amended by the Local Government (Access to Information) (Variation) Order 2006 Request to display Door Signs on Private Hire Vehicles (Paras. 1 & 2) The Director of Community Services submitted a report requesting the consideration of a request from a Private Hire Operator for approval of a door sign to display on licensed private hire vehicles.
Councillor Garner asked if the case had already been to court and [name removed] replied that the first matter had been to court, the outcome of which was that [name removed] had received a conviction and that [name removed] had been given a formal warning.
Councillor Garner enquired as to what would happen if [name removed] was to fail the CRB check and [name removed] confirmed that the premises would not be allowed to operate without a Designated Premises Supervisor.
The Chair of the committee, Councillor Garner, suggested that the Chair of the Public Rights of Way Panel request a scrutiny review with the support of the Licensing and Consumer Protection Committee.
Minutes of a meeting of the Licensing and Registration Panel held at the Civic Centre, Stoke-on-Trent on Wednesday, 15 August 2007 RECORD OF ATTENDANCE City Councillors Councillor Joy Garner (Chair) , Councillors R Booth (Vice-Chair), D Capey , D Conway, S Halfpenny, R Irving and P Sandland Apologies submitted Councillor Derek Hall, Councillor Alan Joynson and Councillor Gavin Webb Absent (if any) Other Attendees Rachel Collier (Principal Licensing Officer), Sarah Henson (Senior Business Support Officer), Geraldine Johnson (Licensing Officer), Debra Barber (Solicitor), Angela Gardner (Democratic Services Officer) (Secretary) 13 Apologies Apologies were noted.
With regard to BV14 – ‘Percentage of Early Retirements’, Councillor Garner suggested that officers were confusing redundancy with retirement.
Councillor Garner questioned whether the same people had been surveyed in 2006 as those previously surveyed in 2003.
Councillor Garner indicated that, whilst welcoming extra Council involvement, she still had concerns about this report as she felt that we were jumping ahead too fast and that it could be better to defer this item until the White Paper had gone through.
Councillor Garner indicated that she had spoken to Councillor Pervez and understood why the price increases were so low and Councillor Capey indicated that he had slight concerns about the small number of self-managed allotments within the City.
Councillor Garner indicated that she had several questions in relation to the appendix to the report, the first of which was whether or not B&G had resolved its problems to which Paul Feehily confirmed that this was the case.
In addition, Councillor Garner asked why the 521 service was not let and Paul Feehily explained that this was a value-for-money issue and that what needed to be considered were the benefits and the subsidies that would be required. In view of the number of passengers that this service would attract, he was recommending that we did not pursue this service.
Councillor Garner felt that the service were linked to Hanley then it would be viable and also questioned what the reference to the north of the City meant and whether or not we should be looking at this. In addition, she was of the opinion that one or two buses could cover the whole of the City on a Friday/Saturday night and that this service was easier to run than a Monday/Thursday service.
Member Clause Type of Interest Nature of Interest Councillor Garner (Chair) Clause 10 – Consideration of the Revocation or Suspension of Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Drivers Licence ( Paras . 1 & 2) Personal and prejudicial interest and left the meeting whilst this item was under consideration Submitted complaint against the licence-holder
Councillor Garner introduced a report on the business conducted by the Licensing and Consumer Protection Committee at a meeting held on 31 August 2007.
Councillor Garner moved and Councillor Shotton seconded that the report be noted.
However, he believed that there should be acceptance that there were certain constraints on the budget such as the Single Status, inflation and also that the spending review was still outstanding. · Councillor Garner felt that more thought should be given before selling off potential income generators such as car parks.
A Motion, moved by Councillor Brian seconded by Councillor Garner, that ‘the persons referred to in the schedule placed around the Chamber be appointed as the City Council’s representatives to serve on the Governing Bodies of the Schools indicated’, was carried.
On the motion of Councillor Garner, seconded by Councillor Ibbs, it was:-
Councillor Garner moved, and Councillor Davis seconded that the report of the Chair of the Licensing and Consumer Protection Committee in respect of meetings held on 6 June and 16 July 2007 be noted.
Councillor Garner moved, and Councillor Tolley seconded, that the minutes of the meeting of the Improving Communities Overview and Scrutiny Commission held on 21 June 2007 be noted.
Minutes of a meeting of the Licensing and Registration Panel held at the Civic Centre, Stoke-on-Trent on Monday, 21 May 2007 RECORD OF ATTENDANCE City Councillors Councillor Joy Garner (Chair) , Councillors D Hall (Vice-Chair), D Conway, S Halfpenny, R Irving and P Sandland Apologies submitted Councillor Reginald Booth and Councillor Alan Joynson Absent (if any) Other Attendees Debra Barber (Solicitor) and Ian Tamburello (Principal Licensing Officer) , Angela Gardner (Democratic Services Officer) (Secretary) Apologies Resolved – That the above apologies be noted.
Committee Members made the following comments:- The Chair, Councillor Garner, commented that a further training session had been arranged for Monday, 23 July 2007, for the five new members to the Committee who have not yet sat the appropriate training as stated in the Licensing Code of Conduct. She requested that these members attend if at all possible as their absence was putting further pressure on the remaining members to attend.
Members’ Comments/Questions:- With the Committee’s endorsement, the Chair allowed Councillor Garner, as an observer to the meeting, to ask questions of the officers.
Councillor Garner commented that if the scheme was doing what it intended to do then even with the overspend it was worth doing. She then referred specifically to the junction on Stanfields Road where visibility was now difficult. David Stubbs confirmed that the issue would be addressed.
Councillor Garner also referred to a survey that the residents were promised after six months that had not been seen. Dave Stubbs explained that information had been issued to ward Councillors in March explaining proposals to replace the survey. He provided details of a questionnaire poster that would be going into the local primary schools.
Councillor Garner expressed the hope that the plan would be in clear language when circulated for wider consultation and Councillor Smith agreed with her comment.
Councillor Garner referred to other areas in the country which were kitted out with computers in their mobile library vans and asked whether it would be possible to access funding to enable us to provide such facilities. A discussion also took place with regard to the location of Longton library.
Councillor Garner commented that in one of the original presentations by Internal Audit, there had been a question on staffing and she was surprised at reference made in the report to extra staff. It was explained that the shortfall in resources had been reported to the former General Purposes and Audit Committee in January 2007, and vacancies had been mapped so that the Audit Plan 2007/08 was based on the resources that were available. The Head of Finance added that a recruitment exercise was underway to help address the shortfall.
Councillor Garner asked what happened in circumstances where individuals had since retired and she also asked whether any of the issues had been referred to Overview and Scrutiny. In response, it was explained that if individuals had retired, the work would be picked up elsewhere and with regard to referrals to Overview and Scrutiny, Steve Robinson explained that it was the role of the Audit Committee itself to pick up issues and if necessary call Directorates to account. He emphasised the need for the Committee to be satisfied that systems and processes were in place.
With regard to the Annual Opinion 2006/07 of “adequate”, Councillor Garner asked what was required to take the internal control opinion up a level. In response, Sue Woodall explained that the systems that internal audit would focus on were the key financial systems and to achieve the highest opinion it would be necessary for all those to show adequate.
The Chair, Councillor Garner, requested confirmation that all other conditions requested by Staffordshire Police had been accepted.
A motion, moved by Councillor Garner, seconded by Councillor Tolley, that ‘the persons referred to in the schedule placed around the chamber be appointed as the City Council’s representatives to serve on the governing bodies of the schools indicated’, was carried.
Councillor Garner commented on some of the anomalies contained within the recommendations and the Chief Executive explained that it was important to get rid of any ambiguity that existed within the scheme and what the City Council was being asked to do was to endorse the principles, further to which detailed guidance and a session with all members would be arranged.
Councillor Garner referred to the different passes available and indicated that there should be only one type of pass in order to prevent discrimination.
Councillor Garner commented that on a recent journey, it had taken her one hour to travel from Tunstall to Stoke whereas it would have taken her 15 minutes to travel the same distance by car.
Councillor Garner welcomed this as a fantastic scheme and enquired about the future of the current Stoke Library building given the problems with the building failing to comply with the Disability Discrimination Act.
Councillor Garner enquired why the winning company had been chosen. In response, Mayor Meredith explained that the City needed an iconic structure that symbolised the City’s past but used modern materials. He added that the team that was chosen was a renowned design company that had a strong focus on public consultation.
As this was the last meeting of the Licensing and Registration Panel for this municipal year, Councillor Irving expressed his thanks to the Chair, Councillor Joy Garner, for her commitment and professionalism at the meetings over the previous 12 months.
Minutes of a meeting of the Licensing and Registration Panel held at the Civic Centre, Stoke-on-Trent on Friday, 23 March 2007 RECORD OF ATTENDANCE City Councillors Councillor Joy Garner (Chair) , Councillors R Booth, D Conway, S Halfpenny, R Irving, A Joynson , M Lewis and C Sutton Apologies submitted Councillor Derek Hall (Vice-Chair) and Councillor Phillip Sandland Absent (if any) Other Attendees Geraldine Johnson (Licensing Officer), Ian Tamburello (Principal Licensing Officer) and Trevor Vernon (Solicitor) , Angela Gardner (Democratic Services Officer) (Secretary) Apologies Apologies were noted.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Environment attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 18 Jul 2008 | City Council | Stoke-on-Trent Governance Commission | Carried | 33 for, 22 against | |
| 18 Jul 2008 | City Council | Report of the Independent Remuneration Panel | Lost | 26 for, 31 against |
Meetings Councillor Environment was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
No meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Environment declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7 May 2008 | (archived) Development Control Committee, item 2 | Councillor Joy Garner declared a personal and prejudicial interest in items 8 & 9 as a member of the Burslem Regeneration Company and also because she had declared previously her opposition to the proposed scheme, took no part in discussion and left the room prior to consideration. | Left the room |
Where Councillor Environment sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Licensing Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2007 | 65 | |
| Licensing and Registration Panel | Committee Member | Mar 2007 | 59 | |
| City Council | Committee Member | Mar 2007 | 37 | |
| Planning Committee - Development Management | Committee Member | Jun 2010 | 20 | |
| (archived) Executive and Members Board | Cabinet Member | May 2007 | 18 | |
| (archived) Licensing and Consumer Protection Committee | Committee Member | May 2007 | 16 | |
| (archived) Audit Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2007 | 16 | |
| Licensing and Appeals Committee | Chair | May 2011 | 16 | |
| (archived) Tenancy Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2011 | 16 | |
| (archived) Councillors Forum | Committee Member | Aug 2007 | 15 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Transformation and Resources | Chair | Jul 2007 | 12 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Corporate Services | Committee Member | May 2011 | 12 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities | Committee Member | Dec 2008 | 9 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee | Committee Member | May 2010 | 6 | |
| Standing Advisory Council | Committee D Member | Jul 2010 | 5 | |
| Cabinet | Cabinet Member | Jul 2010 | 5 | |
| Way Panel | Chair | Aug 2010 | 5 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Adult and Neighbourhoods | Cabinet Representative | Oct 2013 | 5 | |
| (archived) Sports Ground Panel | Committee Member | Aug 2010 | 4 | |
| (archived) Development Control Committee | Committee Member | Apr 2008 | 3 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Commission - Community Safety | Committee Member | Apr 2007 | 2 | |
| (archived) General Purposes Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2007 | 2 | |
| (archived) Human Resources Committee | Observer | Sep 2014 | 2 | |
| (archived) General Purposes and Audit Committee | Committee Member | Apr 2007 | 1 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Commission - Health | Committee Member | May 2007 | 1 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Commission - Neighbourhood Management | Committee Member | May 2007 | 1 | |
| Town and Village Greens Panel | Chair | Jul 2007 | 1 | |
| (archived) Appointments Committee | Chair | Aug 2008 | 1 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Adults and Older People's Wellbeing | Guest | Sep 2008 | 1 | |
| (archived) Administration and Appeals Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2010 | 1 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Health | Committee Member | Nov 2010 | 1 | |
| (archived) Standards Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2015 | 1 | |
| Planning Committee - Policy Group | Committee Member | Oct 2015 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.