Consultation on Street Cafe Licensing Policy
Members’ Comments and Questions Councillor Wanger enquired if the conditions of a licence could be varied for each premises, and what the cost of a licence under the new policy would be.
Every time Stoke-on-Trent's minutes name Councillor Wanger, as the council published it.
Members’ Comments and Questions Councillor Wanger enquired if the conditions of a licence could be varied for each premises, and what the cost of a licence under the new policy would be.
The Lord Mayor invited nominations for the office of Lord Mayor and Chairman for the ensuing municipal year Councillor Wanger nominated Councillor Jean Bowers and this was seconded by Councillor A. Brown.
Councillor Hayward moved the following motion which was seconded by Councillor Wanger:- That the Cabinet defers decision to approve the until 3 December as the original programme of this Committee 1. Members have a comprehensive understanding of what a Management Board is and its modus operandi is properly considered and then added to the constitution of the Council.
Councillor Meredith spoke against the motion and on being put to the vote the motion was lost on the Chairs casting vote In response to a question from Councillor Wanger the Chief Operating Officer explained that with the exception of setting policies the City Council had limited flexibility in the setting of business rates.
Present Councillor Joy Garner (Chair), Councillor Neil Day, Councillor Lee Wanger and Councillor Jackie Barnes (Reserve Member) Officers Sandra Bradbury (Licensing Officer), Jeanette Tsoi (Legal Advisor) and Angela Gardner (Democratic Services Officer) Other Attendees Item 9 PC Graeme Owen (Staffordshire Police), [name removed] (Licensing Officer – Staffordshire Police), [name removed] (Director of Living Room (Stoke) Limited, Premise Licence Holder) and [name removed] (Designated Premise Supervisor)
A Motion moved by Councillor Wazir and seconded by Councillor Wanger “that Councillor Olwen Hamer be appointed the Vice-Chair of the City Renewal Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the remainder of the Municipal Year” was carried.
Councillor Wanger agreed that if lower cost energy could be offered it would attract business to the area. He then queried the amount of fuel required for the ARBOR project.
Councillor Wanger requested a cost /benefit analysis on the biomass project. He asked about a business partner on the project and asked how licencing were involved.
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Wanger suggested that cost of recycling be explored and only recycle the waste that would give financial benefit .
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Wanger requested clarification on the item- Proposal for an Applied Materials Research and Innovation Centre of the Notice of Decisions.
Councillor Wanger asked for an example of where local companies had been successful with the new strategy. The Strategic Manager – Corporate Procurement referred to the recent opportunity for the supply of fresh fruit and vegetables which used to be one supplier covering the whole of the city. The opportunity has now been broken up to 3 local suppliers covering the North, Central and South of the City allowing small companies to bid.
Councillor Wanger questioned if he could receive this data specific to his ward. The Deputy Director of Public Health advised some ward based data is available and he would investigate further.
The Committee was requested to note that Appendix 3 of the report should record that Councillor Wanger and Councillor Wheeldon had both attended a meeting of the Tenancy Sub-Committee in this municipal year.
Councillor Wanger expressed the view that calls to the Customer Access Service would increase again once Universal Credit was introduced and asked if the service would be better prepared to deal with the increasing number of calls.
The Assistant Chief Executive reported that the Council had received some information about Universal Credit and was already having discussions with the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) and therefore he anticipated that the Council would be prepared to deal with the expected increase in calls Councillor Wanger ... view the full minutes text for item 9.
A Motion moved by Councillor Bagh Ali, seconded by Councillor Lee Wanger that “Councillor Peter Hayward be appointed as Vice-Chair of the Corporate Services Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the Municipal Year” was carried.
Councillor Wanger referred to a particular company who had found difficulty attracting funds to develop and it was explained how the City Council signpost to possible sources of funding. Discussion moved on to the High Speed 2 and to the advantages a substation would bring to the City.
In response to clarity sought from Councillor Wanger regarding the temporary borrowing from reserves to partially pay for the redundancy programme, the Assistant Director, Financial Services explained ... view the full minutes text for item 20.
Councillor Wanger referred to the planned ‘Meet the Buyer’ event and commented that such events should be welcomed as there was a need to make it as easy as possible for local firms to do business with the City Council.
Councillor Wanger moved and Councillor Day seconded that the minutes of the Business Services and Chief Executive’s Overview and Scrutiny Committee meetings held on 5 October and 16 November 2011 be noted.
Councillor Wanger referred to the performance of the Environmental Crime Unit and asked if the unit was close to being self-financing like some other units in the country.
Councillor Wanger questioned how the Technical Services Division would cope with the reduction of ... view the full minutes text for item 36.
Councillor Item Type of Interest Reason for Interest Councillor Wanger 20 Personal Shareholder of debt collection agency based outside of the City.
Councillor Wanger subsequently requested that his name be removed from the schedule as the nomination to serve on the Industrial Communities Alliance and, on that basis, Councillor Pervez then moved “ that the City Renewal Overview and Scrutiny Committee be requested to give further consideration to the vacancy on the Industrial Communities Alliance”.
Councillor Wanger then moved, and Councillor Conway seconded, the following motion (notice of which had previously been given):- Waterworld Holdings UK Ltd and M Chaudry and Stoke-on-Trent City Council “Following the council’s recent press release with regards to the above and given that the Press Statement said ‘it will not make any further statements or comments on this matter’.
Councillor Wanger requested that more information be included in future reports giving a breakdown of both long and short term absences together with any other implications such as the impact on staff and costs of covering the workload.
Councillor Wanger commented on the unique offer of the City and felt that Chatterley Whitfield should also be incorporated into the Accelerated Development Zone as it already had the infrastructure in place.
· Councillor Wanger sought more clarification on the Community and District Heating Systems.
Councillor Wanger commented that in respect of energy, the Local Authority did not receive many applications for wind turbines. He also referred to the Blue Planet development at Chatterley Valley and felt that the building should be used as a benchmark for other new developments because of its green credentials. He went on to ask if the City Council still used Pool bikes.
In response to Councillor Wanger , she confirmed that the City Council had 9 Pool Bikes for use.
· Councillor Wanger asked if Staffordshire Police made any contribution towards the cost of the cameras.
· Councillor Wanger referred to the income pressures associated with Wedgwood Memorial College and queried whether there was land around the college that could be sold.
The Committee noted that Councillor Wanger had replaced Councillor James as a City Independent Group Member of the Committee.
Councillor Wanger queried whether the City Council still had large mainframe computers The Acting Director of Business Services confirmed that the City Council had moved away from mainframe computers to a number of servers.
Question 3: Progress in Respect of Planned Budget Savings ( Submitted by Councillor Lee Wanger) “When ... view the full minutes text for item 26.
Councillor Wanger queried what the timescales would be for develop Etruria Valley.
Councillor Wanger asked if the development of Etruria Valley would be to the detriment of other sites such as Chatterley Valley.
A Motion moved by Councillor Lilley, seconded by Councillor Wanger “that Councillor Lee Wanger be appointed as Vice-Chair of the Business Services and Chief Executive’s Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the Municipal Year” was carried.
Interest Nature Councillors Mick Bell and Shotton 108 Personal Knew the applicant or his relative(s) Councillor Wanger 109 Personal and Prejudicial.
Councillor Bridges moved and Councillor Wanger seconded the following motion which was passed:-
A motion was moved by Councillor Wanger and seconded by Councillor Shotton to add an additional requirement to the recommendation to approve, which was passed:
Councillor Wanger was not present for the consideration of this item.
The Chair invited Councillor Wanger , the committee’s representative on the Special Interest Group of Municipal Authorities (S.I.G.O.M.A), to present an update on the work of the group.
Councillor Wanger reported that the aim of SIGOMA was to try to influence policy direction through a combination of technical expertise and political pressure. He continued to highlight some of the good work carried out in deprived areas.
Councillor Wanger strongly requested that the committee continue to send a representative to SIGOMA meetings. He highlighted the importance of the representative becoming a member of the management committee which could only be achieved by regularly attending the meetings.
Comments from Committee Members The Chair thanked Councillor Wanger for his work with SIGOMA and stressed the importance of the council having a representative on this group.
A motion moved by Councillor Wanger and seconded by Councillor Bridges, “that the application be refused due to the site being located within an area of traditionally designed properties and the proposed development would be out of character with the established use of brick and tile materials. As such the design and scale of the proposed development would be out of place and overbearing in relation to neighbouring properties by reason of appearance and height” was carried.
Interest Nature Councillor Wanger 112 Personal Knows of the Applicant.
Interest Nature Councillor Wanger 98 Personal and Prejudicial and left the room for the duration of the item.
Councillor Clarke moved, and Councillor Wanger seconded, ‘that the tax base for 2009/2010 be set at 70,429’.
Councillor Wanger moved and Councillor Clarke seconded that the minutes of the Improving Communities Overview and Scrutiny Committee be noted.
Councillor Wanger commented on the length of time the regeneration of Meir would take.
Councillor Wanger queried the difference in the number of units against the number of businesses.
Councillor Wanger asked what was being done to address the occupancy of the enterprise centres as there were some businesses that were well established and had been there from day one.
Councillor Wanger asked what savings had been identified.
Councillor Wanger queried whether the development of Chatterley Valley would impact upon the run by the City Council.
Councillor Wanger believed that many small businesses could benefit from being a Social Enterprise.
Councillor Wanger referred to the proposed Park and Ride in North Staffordshire and hoped that the number of long stay spaces would be reduced and the number of short stay spaces increased.
Committee Members made the following comments:- Councillor Wanger queried whether the Section 106 officer post was sustainable given the current economic climate.
Councillor Wanger referred to the problems of residents living in conservation areas and gave as an example the on-going maintenance costs associated with the installation of wooden as opposed to upvc window frames.
Councillor Wanger referred to the fact that the Transformation and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee were to receive a report to a future meeting in relation to the City Council’s communication strategy which would include ‘Our City’. He felt that this was a great tool that he would like to see made more use of. Michael Howard responded by explaining that ‘Our City’ carried out good news stories but also in responding to another point, referred to the fact that there would be significant costs in production on a more frequent basis.
Councillor Davis indicated that he would like to see details of the staffing structure within the Communications section and Councillor Wanger indicated that the Transformation and Resources Overview and Scrutiny could consider this as part of their item on the draft Communication Strategy.
Recommendation 1 – Bus/Coach station to be built to a high quality and meets modern day needs of passengers Councillor Wanger agreed that the City did need to put a stamp on the new development and that exceptional materials should be used that other developers would emulate.
Outside Bodies Councillor Wanger commented that he was a member of a number of outside bodies and would bring a detailed report to the next meeting.
Councillor Wanger moved and Councillor B. Ali seconded that the minutes of the Transformation and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee be noted.
Comments from Committee Members The Chair, Councillor Wanger , welcomed Councillor Conway to the meeting and invited him and Councillor Follows to comment as former members of the task and finish group.
The Chair, Councillor Wanger , reported that 2010 would mark 100 years since the 6 towns came together as a federation to form the borough of Stoke-on-Trent, which started the process by which it became a City in 1925.
· Councillor Wanger commented on how impressed he was with the cleanliness of Sheffield City Centre.
Recommendation 3 The Chair, Councillor Wanger , expressed his opinion that it would be useful for members to have information about what Council owned land and buildings were located in their Wards.
Recommendation 6 The Chair, Councillor Wanger , commented that he would not want the prioritisation of solutions to be governed solely by financial concerns and he suggested that a development brief be drawn up before assets were sold to ensure that issues other than finance were considered.
Recommendation 14 The Chair, Councillor Wanger , confirmed that he would still like to see capital receipts from large scale disposals used in the ward where the asset was located.
Special Interest Group of Municipal Authorities (SIGOMA) The Chair, Councillor Wanger , reported that he had attended several meetings in Barnsley and London and ... view the full minutes text for item 10.
Councillor Wanger moved and Councillor M. Davis seconded that the minutes of the Transformation and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting held on 28 March 2008 be noted.
Councillor Wanger felt that some task and finish groups’ work was more complicated than that of others and referred to the Vacant Land and Buildings Task and Finish Group which had been delayed for a number of reasons but which had been a very complicated review to undertake. He suggested that it could be that in those circumstances additional time could be given to receive the Executive response. The Chair agreed with this point but felt that the issue around this matter was one of communication and members and committees being kept informed in relation to when responses were to be received.
Councillor Wanger , as Chair of Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee, referred to the situation in relation to small areas of land which were an eyesore/burden to the City Council and felt that the City Council should seriously consider selling these pieces of land.
Councillor Clarke moved and Councillor Wanger seconded ‘that (as required by the Constitution) the City Council adopts the Council Manager and Chief Executive Officer’s Scheme of Delegation, as appended to the report now submitted’.
Councillor Wanger seconded the motion put forward by Councillor Tappin.
Councillor Wanger moved and Councillor Gratton seconded that the minutes of the Transformation and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting held on 16 November 2007 be noted.
Councillor Wanger welcomed the review.
Councillor Wanger , Chair of Transformation and Resources, indicated that he had concerns with the report, regarding the knock-on effect that it may have, especially in Tunstall where he was a Ward Councillor and Peter Devaney confirmed that he was happy to look at this situation and to go back to Councillor Wanger once he had investigated it further.
Councillor Wanger asked if the officers had carried out external consultation on the draft and Paul Atkins confirmed that the detail had been discussed with various external groups through existing City Council networking arrangements. With regard to schools, he confirmed that he had been to Bursar meetings to talk about procurement and, in some cases, offer services where it would be economically advantageous or beneficial.
Councillor Wanger asked how the Head of Procurement intended achieving a customer focus and ensuring an open approach. Peter Stone explained how it was his intention to make processes more straightforward and Paul Atkins added that there would be clear guidance produced explaining why the Council did business in the way it did.
Councillor Wanger commented that parts of the strategy seemed aspirational and did not provide the detail of how the intended outcomes would be delivered. Paul Atkins explained that the strategy was intended to set out the road of travel and he advised that more detailed actions would be produced to underpin its implementation and delivery.
Councillor Wanger also asked about how the actions and outcomes would be measured and Paul Atkins explained that there were a number of performance indicators that were being looked at as part of the strategy but there was also a whole performance measures agenda that sat beneath it. He confirmed that he would be happy to bring back the underlying performance framework to a future meeting of the Committee.
The Chair, Councillor Wanger, then went on to report on a SIGOMA (the Special Interest Group of Municipal Authorities within the LGA) meeting that he had attended in Barnsley on 4 October 2007. He explained that the group was a lobbying group that was currently concentrating on two main issues: NRF (Neighbourhood Renewal Fund) and the funding for social care and children. He reported on a visit that he had planned to London on 10 October to lobby Parliament and he proceeded to read out a briefing note that he would be submitting to MPs.
Councillor Wanger indicated that he too had attended the relevant meeting for his committee and found them to be an informative and useful tool in the budget-setting process.
Councillor Wanger reported that the Council’s Equality and Diversity Strategy would be reported to the Transformation and Resources Committee at its meeting on the 16 November. The Chair asked for any views on the suggestions which had been made.
Councillor Wanger moved and Councillor Matthews seconded that the minutes of the Transformation and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting held on 24 August 2007 be noted.
Councillor Wanger commented on the wider effects of worklessness on health and economic growth etc, and the fact that the City had third generation unemployed. He wanted to see strategies that linked jobs into the City, provided people with opportunities and raised school children’s expectations.
Councillor Wanger commented on the limited opportunities for progression for fork lift truck drivers and the need to train more individuals to work in the construction industry.
Councillor Wanger commented on the detail shown in Appendix B of the report submitted which showed the income from ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Questions from the committee Councillor Wanger could not see the appeal of the Homeswap Assistance Scheme.
Councillor Wanger pointed out that it was not the individual’s fault that the value of their homes had reduced. In many cases, if they were given another home the same they would move. The Chair asked if the individuals could go into council properties.
Councillor Wanger felt that one of the problems with the AITs ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
· The Chair, Councillor Wanger, hoped that the service areas where the actions had been assessed as being ‘on track’ would still continue to try and improve. · The Committee discussed in depth the layout of the report and it was agreed that greater clarity was needed on the description of the indicator, key milestones, its overall progress and that there be regular reports to members in the event of any slippage of performance.
· Councillor Wanger sought clarification on what came under the costs for information services.
· The Chair, Councillor Wanger , once more questioned why these items were coming to the Committee and asked that any specific questions be sent to officers to respond.
Councillor Wanger then asked questions of [name removed].
On the motion of Councillor Wanger , seconded by Councillor Bayley , it was:-
Councillor Wanger moved, and Councillor Gratton seconded, that the minutes of the meeting of the Transformation and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Commission held on 8 June 2007 and 13 July 2007 be noted.
Councillor Wanger – asked whether this was a procurement issue.
Adult and Older People`s Wellbeing 15 June 2007 Children and Young People`s 18 June 2007 Economic Development and Enterprise 6 June and 5 July 2007 Health 29 June 2007 Improving Communities 21 June 2007 Transformation and Resources 8 June and 13 July 2007 Nomination to Outside Bodies – Economic Development and Enterprise Councillor Wanger informed that he was intended to step down from Coalfield Communities Campaign so that Councillor Booth could retain his seat.
Councillor Wanger would raise this at City Council on 2 nd August.
Task and Finish–Improving Sickness Absence–Transformation and Resources Councillor Wanger , as Chair of the Committee, sought guidance as there were mixed views on the appropriateness of both the Audit Committee and the Transformation and Resources Committee receiving quarterly monitoring information on sickness absence.
Councillor Wanger enquired if the City had any maintenance obligations should it register the area of land in question as a town or village green.
Councillor Wanger enquired if the application was uncontested.
Councillor Wanger hoped that there could be an area of open space in the City Centre where large public events could be held.
Councillor Wanger made reference to the suggested structures and hoped that there would be long-term plans for their use.
Councillor Wanger hoped that the City Centre would attract retailers that could provide a different offer to other cities.
Councillor Wanger referred to the previous options for Madison Street, Tunstall . In response, Andrew Milroy confirmed that the other options were no longer valid hence the proposed decision to dispose of the property.
· Councillor Wanger sought further clarification to the response to question 5 John Gething explained that they did not want to see a ‘top down’ approach to delivering some of the actions and that there should be a two way process with businesses and Partners working together.
Members’ Comments/Questions:- The Chair, Councillor Wanger, referred to the anticipated reduction in cashable savings for the 2007/08 financial year and asked if this was expected to be a continuing trend. He also asked if there were performance indicators for procurement and whether these would form part of the strategy.
Councillor Wanger moved, and Councillor Tappin seconded, that the minutes of the meeting of the Resources Overview and Scrutiny Commission held on 27 April 2007 be noted.
Councillor Wanger wanted action to bring derelict buildings back into use.
He requested action to reduce the number of businesses that re-locate outside of the City Councillor Wanger commented that there was no speculative developments in the City David Mather explained that speculative development would be taking place at Trentham Lakes and furthermore, there were proposals for Phase 3 development at Etruria Valley along with development opportunities at Chatterley Valley. He acknowledged that there was a lot of Brownfield land in the City but referred to issues in securing ownership of the sites or encouraging owners to re-develop the land.
Councillor Wanger commented that a number of well-established businesses were occupying space in enterprise centres and they should be encouraged to move to their own premises.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Wanger attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 18 Jul 2008 | City Council | Stoke-on-Trent Governance Commission | Carried | 33 for, 22 against | |
| 18 Jul 2008 | City Council | Report of the Independent Remuneration Panel | Lost | 26 for, 31 against |
Meetings Councillor Wanger was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
No meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Wanger declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Wanger in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Wanger sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| City Council | Committee Member | Mar 2007 | 30 | |
| Licensing Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Apr 2010 | 22 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2007 | 16 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Transformation and Resources | Committee Member | Jun 2007 | 16 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Economic Development and Enterprise | Committee Member | May 2007 | 14 | |
| (archived) Tenancy Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Aug 2012 | 14 | |
| (archived) General Purposes Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2007 | 13 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - City Renewal | Chair | May 2011 | 13 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Corporate Services | Committee Member | May 2011 | 13 | |
| Licensing and Appeals Committee | Committee Member | May 2012 | 11 | |
| (archived) Executive and Members Board | Committee Member | May 2007 | 7 | |
| (archived) Appeals Committee - Tenancy | Committee Member | Mar 2007 | 5 | |
| (archived) Councillors Forum | Committee Member | Nov 2007 | 5 | |
| Planning Committee - Development Management | Committee Member | Apr 2010 | 4 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Commission - City-Wide Services | Committee Member | Apr 2007 | 3 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Commission - Regeneration | Vice-Chair | Apr 2007 | 2 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Commission - Community Safety | Committee Member | Apr 2007 | 2 | |
| Licensing and Registration Panel | Committee Member | Apr 2010 | 2 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Commission - Neighbourhood Management | Committee Member | May 2007 | 1 | |
| Town and Village Greens Panel | Committee Member | Jul 2007 | 1 | |
| (archived) Audit Committee | Observer | Sep 2007 | 1 | |
| (archived) Licensing and Consumer Protection Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2010 | 1 | |
| Way Panel | Committee Member | Nov 2013 | 1 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Adult and Neighbourhoods | Committee Member | May 2014 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.