Apologies for absence
Beardmore, Councillor Clark, Councillor Davison, Councillor Dodd, Councillor Edwards and Councillor Diane Williams.
Every time Stoke-on-Trent's minutes name Councillor Dodd, as the council published it.
Beardmore, Councillor Clark, Councillor Davison, Councillor Dodd, Councillor Edwards and Councillor Diane Williams.
The following motion was moved by Councillor Evans and seconded by Councillor Dodd:
Councillor Dodd reported how much she had enjoyed attending SACRE meetings, and thanked all involved. Mindful of the local elections in May, she confirmed that she could not be sure of her future attendance.
A Motion, moved by Councillor Williams, seconded by Councillor Dodd ‘that Councillor Jane Ashworth be appointed Vice-Chair of the Strategy and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the 2022/2023 Municipal Year’ was carried.
Councillor Dodd referred to the works at Etruscan Square and asked if the new proposed car park was to be council owned and whether there were yet any designs for it.
In response to a question from Councillor Dodd regarding how small local bus operators could compete with the national chains, Phil Cresswell, Director of Housing, Development and Growth explained that when a bus route was agreed, it had to be agreed with the Transport Commissioner. Where patronage fell below a certain number, the operators decided whether or not to continue with the route. The smaller companies had a lower cost base and were therefore able to look at routes that were not viable for the larger companies.
In response to a question from Councillor Dodd regarding improving the current facility, Phil Cresswell explained that there were technologies inside the current facility that were of their limits and age. He commented that the plant would not last forever and required maintenance and would get to a point where it was beyond its economic life. Therefore, the advice at this moment in time was to replace the ... view the full minutes text for item 22.
Councillor Dodd queried if there were any proposals to knock down any of the high-rise flats in the city and Councillor Gerrard asked what the criteria was in terms of height for a high-rise. Adrian Scarrott explained that all options had to be considered and that the standards due to be introduced for high-rise flats were increasing. A high-rise was a building over 18 metres.
In response to a question from Councillor Dodd regarding any complaints received by the council in respect of call wait times, the City Director confirmed that he had personally dealt with one complaint in the last few days.
Councillor Dodd asked for further information on VS10 – 2021 – Charges for Corporate Appointeeship service. The Assistant Director Governance and Registration explained that the reason for the delay in realising the savings for this budget line was the need to carry out consultation with those involved to avoid any legal challenge. The City Director added that the complexity of what needed to be done had been underestimated when the savings proposal had been put forward.
Councillor Dodd sought further information on the future uses of Longton Town Hall and Sutherland Chambers. The Cabinet Member for Regeneration, Infrastructure and Heritage confirmed that the ground floor of Longton Town Hall was still a Local Centre and there was an area at the rear of the building that was used by Parking Services as their southern base. Upstairs had received Government funding and was to be made into high quality office space.
In response to a question from Councillor Dodd regarding how heat mapping worked and how the savings had been defined for the Civic Centre, Andrew Briggs confirmed that they had access to the heat mapping data through Baise which was a high-level map of anonymised data showing what was consumed and provided to different areas. For the Civic Centre, they had a baseline of consumption and had demonstrated a clear reduction in consumption. Heat had been measured against baseline of consumption in 2019 which was pre Covid pandemic.
Councillor Dodd referred to what was being done differently and commented that it may be about refocussing on printed promotional material and approaching the right target audiences.
Councillor Dodd asked if the offers of catch-up and additional training to schools, following the launch of the New Agreed Syllabus, had been taken up.
Councillor Dodd noted due to the pandemic, examinations had not taken place, but asked if grades that students had been awarded, had been published.
Councillor Dodd asked if the New Agreed Syllabus had been fully adopted in the City by all schools.
Councillor Dodd asked if SACRE should be looking to have a pupil voice as part of the group.
Councillor Dodd asked about re-naming of the Gideons, and queried if materials were still being made available to pupils in Stoke-on-Trent schools.
A Motion, moved by Councillor David Williams, seconded by Councillor Lilian Dodd that “Councillor Jane Ashworth be appointed as Vice-Chair of the Corporate Services Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the 2021/2022 Municipal Year” was carried.
Councillor Dodd referred to HB1 (Number of New Business Starts) and HB3 (Inward Investment jobs created and safeguarded) and asked how it was known that these measures were on track when there had been restrictions for businesses with some closing due to the Covid pandemic. The Team Manager Policy and Performance explained that the data was based on the figures received to date and that despite the Covid pandemic, the target was expected to be achieved. The Director of Housing, Development and Growth added that the pandemic had affected businesses regionally, globally and nationally and that the Governments Furlough scheme would be masking some figures.
Councillor Dodd referred to the measure on the printing of paper and queried why no previous data was available as she believed that usage of printing was measured on each machine.
The Director of Housing, Development and Growth confirmed that he would take this question away and provide a written response to Councillor Dodd when he had sought further information.
The Chair introduced this item and invited Councillor Dodd to provide an update on the work she had been undertaking on Markets and Councillor Adams on the work she had been undertaking on Allotments.
Councillor Dodd referred to the notes she had circulated to the Committee following her meeting with the Market Traders in Longton. She explained that a lot of queries and questions had come up at that time and suggested that a group of Councillors get together with the Cabinet Member to discuss them and help raise the profile of the markets in the city to make them viable. The Cabinet Member for Housing and Environment indicated that he would be happy to accommodate this.
Comments and Questions from Committee Members Councillor Dodd referred to Appendix A and asked why the savings proposal for the charges for a corporate appointeeship service would not be achieved. The Director – Strategy and Resources (S151 Officer) explained that this savings proposal had been delayed due to the challenges of consulting in the ongoing Covid-19 pandemic; this proposal would be achieved in the future.
Councillor Dodd referred to Appendix C and asked for further information on the use of receipts for transformation. The Director – Strategy and Resources (S151 Officer) confirmed that the primary cost of this was the Transformation Team itself plus additional support.
Councillor Dodd asked why the number of agency staff was currently running higher than that budgeted. The Cabinet Member for Corporate Resource, Strategy and Partnerships advised that the majority of agency staff were employed in Children’s Social Care. The recruitment of Social Workers was a national challenge and therefore locally investigations were being made in to bringing Social Workers in from abroad to help address this issue.
The Committee supported the approach outlined and Councillor Dodd expressed a wish to also be involved in the scoping of the review alongside Councillor Williams.
Councillor Dodd questioned the high percentage of teachers teaching Religious Education who did not have a degree in the subject area, and also asked for assurance that all schools were provided with the information regarding funding support available to them.
Councillor Dodd asked how many students attended the event, and also asked if we would look to hold a similar event again.
CMS02-2122 – Staffing changes to the Markets structure Councillor Dodd questioned if the vacant manager post at Longton market would be lost and commented on the lack of engagement that traders were reporting. She also sought assurances that engagement with the traders would improve in the new structure. The Director of Place, Growth and Prosperity made reference to the Market Trader Programme and what impact it had had.
The Chair asked for it to be recorded that Councillor Dodd was very supportive of the meeting but that due to her personal circumstance (a personal and other pecuniary Interest) she was unable to attend the meeting.
Councillor Adams declared a Personal Interest in item 3 (Clause 42 refers) as she had received phone calls and a visit from residents but had advised them on the process only Councillor Ali declared a Personal Interest in item 3 (Clause 42 refers) as he is a member of the Gillani Noor Masjid Mosque, Chaplin Road, Normacot Councillor Dodd declared a Personal Interest in item 3 (Clause 42 refers) as she had been contacted by residents asking her not to support the call-in Councillor Hussain declared a Personal Interest in item 3 (Clause 42 refers) as he is a member of the Gillani Noor Masjid Mosque, Chaplin Road, Normacot Councillor Watson declared a Personal Interest in item 3 (Clause 42 refers) as he was a Cabinet Member in 2014 when this issue had previously been raised.
Members received representation from Councillor L Dodd, speaking as Ward Member.
A motion moved by Councillor Woolner, seconded by Councillor Dodd “that Councillor Wanger be appointed Chair of the City Renewal Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the municipal year” was carried.
Presentation of Badges of Office The Lord Mayor (Councillor Jackie Barnes) presented civic badges to Councillor Lilian Dodd and Alan Dodd in recognition of their services as Lord Mayor and Consort in 2018/19.
Councillor Dodd declared a personal interest in item 4 – Financial Performance 2017/18 Quarter 3 (Month 9) (Clause 64 refers) as she fundraises and promotes the work of the Foodbank.
Councillor Dodd referred to the new video that had been filmed as part of the CSE Communications campaign and asked if this Committee could have sight of the virtual reality video. The Strategic Manager, Safeguarding, Quality and Assurance confirmed that the CSE Co-ordinator could arrange for a screening of the video at a future meeting of this Committee.
The Deputy Lord Mayor, Councillor Dodd, expressed a personal tribute, describing Mike as a great champion for Longton South. She spoke about the significant work that he had done in support of the Queens Park partnership and she confirmed that he would be deeply missed by the community in Dresden and Florence.
Councillor Dodd queried how young people sat exams if they were home educated. The Lead for Elective Home Education explained that it was a parents’ responsibility to provide the education and so they did not have to follow a curriculum but they did have to follow a system of numeracy and literacy. She confirmed that her team worked closely with the local colleges who did take home educated learners.
Councillor Dodd asked for information to be provided to a future meeting of the Committee regarding start up grants and how these are promoted, including information on the number of applicants, take up and success rates.
Councillor Dodd asked whether the City Council was still planning to establish a security company and Councillor Jellyman confirmed that this was the case and that it should take two to three months for officers to take the necessary steps to incorporate this Company.
Councillor Dodd commented on the fact that this was the fourth Task and Finish Group to look at the Council’s markets and also referred to the lack of signage in respect of Longton Market.
The Vice-Chair (Councillor L Dodd) referred to the information that had previously been requested with regard to the management restructure and the Chair confirmed that he had received this information. The Interim Assistant Director – Finance confirmed that he had information ready to send to the Committee which just required the removal of some lower level posts in the first instance.
Councillor Dodd queried how the team was monitoring feedback it received from schools. The Community Cohesion Manager confirmed that schools were keen to invite his team back to hold further sessions. Furthermore there was a Headteachers Prevent Group and so they would be co-ordinating with them to go into schools in a more cohesive way.
In response to a question from Councillor Dodd regarding particular issues in the city that members should be aware of, the Community Cohesion Manager confirmed that Social Media was the main issue as things could take on a life of their own. His team therefore worked closely with Staffordshire Police.
Councillor Dodd asked for more information on the increased focus on teacher recruitment to attract and retain quality teachers in Stoke. The Strategic Manager, Pupil Achievement commented that one example was the Maths project within the secondary sector. He explained that there was also a sub-group to look at the broad strategy of attracting and retaining teaching staff in the city and it was about the whole offer including housing, leisure and retail.
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Dodd asked if the proposals were fixed or could projects be added, removed or amended if required. She also asked for an update on the Stoke town centre improvement proposals.
Councillor Dodd moved, and Councillor A. Brown seconded, a motion to approve the Pay Policy Statement for 2016/17, as submitted.
Following comments made by the Chair and Councillor Dodd, it was agreed to clarify/amend the report prior to consideration at Cabinet and City Council:- · paragraph 6.27 - An additional sentence to be added – ‘ Any investment in such organisations would be the subject of a separate report to City Council prior to agreement’ . · paragraph 6.9 – An additional sentence to be added – ‘ The interest rate is agreed at the time the borrowing is taken out’.
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Dodd asked if the furniture had been ordered, and if so had it been ordered for 1 and 2 Smithfield.
The Vice-Chair (Councillor Dodd) suggested that it ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Dodd attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Dodd's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Dodd was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 4 of 12 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Dodd declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 Mar 2020 | (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - City Renewal, item 41 | Councillor Adams declared a Personal Interest in item 3 (Clause 42 refers) as she had received phone calls and a visit from residents but had advised them on the process only Councillor Ali declared a Personal Interest in item 3 (Clause 42 refers) as he is a member of the Gillani Noor Masjid Mosque, Chaplin Road, Normacot Councillor Dodd declared a Personal Interest in item 3 (Clause 42 refers) as she had been contacted by residents asking her not to support the call-in Councillor Hussain declared a Personal Interest in item 3 (Clause 42 refers) as he is a member of the Gillani Noor Masjid Mosque, Chaplin Road, Normacot Councillor Watson declared a Personal Interest in item 3 (Clause 42 refers) as he was a Cabinet Member in 2014 when this issue had previously been raised. | |
| 3 May 2018 | (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Children and Young People, item 63 | Councillor Dodd declared a personal interest in item 4 – Financial Performance 2017/18 Quarter 3 (Month 9) (Clause 64 refers) as she fundraises and promotes the work of the Foodbank. |
Where Councillor Dodd sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| City Council | Committee Member | May 2015 | 6 | 17 Dec 2026 |
| Licensing and Appeals Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2026 | 3 | |
| Housing, Regeneration & Operations Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2026 | 3 | 7 Dec 2026 |
| Licensing Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Aug 2026 | 1 | 23 Nov 2026 |
| (archived) Audit Committee | Committee Member | Aug 2015 | 1 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - City Renewal | Committee Member | Oct 2015 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.