Named29 Mar 2011(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee
The Forward Plan - New Items in Issues 21 and 22
Community CCTV strategy – Forward Plan Reference 254 Depot Review and Rationalisation – Forward Plan Reference 255 Consultation on High Speed Rail (HS2) – Forward Plan Reference 257 Safer City Partnership Plan – Forward Plan Reference 258 Group Supported Living – Forward Plan Reference 259 Councillor Barnes: Indicated that, in addition to the above, he would also like to undertake pre-decision scrutiny of items which had appeared in previous issues of the Forward Plan i.e.
Named29 Mar 2011(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee
The Forward Plan - New Items in Issues 21 and 22
The Vice-Chair (Councillor Barnes) expressed concern over the lack of progress over the last 5 years.
Named29 Mar 2011(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee
The Forward Plan - New Items in Issues 21 and 22
Councillor Matloob responded to Councillor Barnes comments by insisting that we could not keep looking back and now needed to move on with the bus station.
Asked29 Mar 2011(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee
The Forward Plan - New Items in Issues 21 and 22
Councillor Barnes asked for the minutes to record the fact that he accepted that we needed to move on but that the Authority also needed to learn from its past mistakes.
Named29 Mar 2011(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee
Petitions Annual Report 2010/11
Councillor Barnes indicated that Councillors had given great consideration to the issue of petitions and such issues as trigger numbers etc when this matter had been considered by the Constitution Review Working Group and was of the view that this was one of the things that the ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Asked29 Mar 2011(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Annual Report (draft)
Councillor Barnes asked for it to be recorded again that the City Council magazine include a section on the Annual Report and also an article about petitions. John Ross confirmed that he had investigated the previous request made by the Committee in this regard and had been informed that this could cost in the region of £10k, following which it had been decided to retain the current presentation style. The Chair asked what it would cost to have a 4 page insert as a way of promoting the work of Overview and Scrutiny and felt that, as we had an overview and scrutiny budget, this was something that could be considered.
Moved24 Mar 2011City Council
Minutes of a previous meetings of the City Council held on 27/01/11 and 24/02/11
Councillor Barnes moved, and Councillor Salih seconded, that the minutes of the City Council meeting held on 24 February 2011, be amended to record the Lord Mayor’s refusal to a request made by Councillor Barnes for permission to exceed the five minute time limit on speeches when presenting an amendment during the deliberations on the Budget and Council Tax Setting 2011/12.
Moved24 Mar 2011City Council
Minutes of a previous meetings of the City Council held on 27/01/11 and 24/02/11
Councillor Barnes further moved, seconded by Councillor Salih , that the minutes of the meeting held on 24 February 2011 be amended to record how individual Members voted on the motion concerning the scheme for Councillors allowances (Ref: Clause 201),if a recorded vote was requested at the time. His recollection was that the meeting had assumed that the vote was a recorded vote and he wished it to be noted that he had voted in favour of the amendment.
Named24 Mar 2011City Council
To transact business of a non-contentious and/or urgent nature specially brought forward by the Lord Mayor or Chairman
The Lord Mayor presented a long service award to Councillor Michael Barnes in recognition of twelve years service as a City Councillor .
Named24 Mar 2011City Council
To transact business of a non-contentious and/or urgent nature specially brought forward by the Lord Mayor or Chairman
The City Council joined the Lord Mayor in congratulating Councillor Barnes.
Named24 Mar 2011City Council
Members' Questions
The Lord Mayor reported on ten Member questions that had been received under Council Procedure Rule 9.02 from Councillor Barnes, details of the questions and the written answers as circulated at the meeting are set out below:- Question 1 - Housing Revenue Account What is the current spend to date on responsive maintenance for the HRA on housing in this financial year?
Named9 Dec 2010City Council
Members' Questions
The Lord Mayor reported on eight Member questions that had been received under Council Procedure Rule 9.02 from Councillor Barnes:- Question 1: Scaffolding In the last financial year and this year to date, how much in total has been spent on scaffolding to deal with housing repairs (planned and responsive work)? What is the average length of time scaffolding is erected at one of our housing stock properties? What is the average cost of scaffolding per day for a council house roofing repair and a bungalow repair?
Asked9 Dec 2010City Council
Members' Questions
In a supplementary question, Councillor Barnes questioned what action had been taken to resolve the issue of scaffolding and height restrictions at work.
Named9 Dec 2010City Council
Changes to the Council Constitution
On the motion of Councillor Barnes, seconded by Councillor Coleman, it was:-
Seconded9 Dec 2010City Council
Minutes of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee (4/10/10)
Councillor Naylor moved and Councillor Barnes seconded that the minutes of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee meeting held on 4 October 2010 be noted.
Seconded9 Dec 2010City Council
Minutes of the Economic Development and Enterprise Overview and Scrutiny Committee (08/11/10)
Councillor Knapper moved and Councillor Barnes seconded that the minutes of the Economic Development and Enterprise Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting held on 8 November 2010 be noted.
Named23 Nov 2010Licensing and Registration Panel
Review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver's Licence. (Paras. 1 & 2)
(Councillor Barnes was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report which requested the review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
Named23 Nov 2010Licensing and Registration Panel
Review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver's Licence. Review of a Private Hire Vehicle Licence. (Paras. 1 & 2)
(Councillor Barnes was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report which requested the review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence and Private Hire Vehicle Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
Named23 Nov 2010Licensing and Registration Panel
Update for Members from Previous Panel Hearing Decisions (Paras. 1 & 2)
(Councillor Barnes was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report which updated on the progress of previous cases where the Panel had determined to suspend or revoke the licences of drivers.
Named10 Nov 2010(archived) Licensing and Consumer Protection Committee
Alcohol Restriction Zones
· The data collection period was from January 2008 to September 2010 · For continued monitoring and a consistent approach, the data was based on the neighbourhood area or Police beat area which contained the Alcohol Restriction Zone · Comparison periods for the reductions were July to June 2008/2009 and 2009/2010 · Alcohol-related antisocial behaviour was not separately categorised by the Police on their recording systems · Although crime with a contributory factor of alcohol could be defined, changes in Police recording practices had affected the figures so they had not been used in the analysis to ensure that there was no ambiguity Members Comments/Questions Councillor Barnes voiced his concern that antisocial behaviour and crime had reduced less in the Alcohol Restriction Zones than in the areas of the city without a Zone and questioned their effectiveness, especially due to the resourcing costs. He also asked why some areas were much more successful than others. Inspector Hancock informed the Committee that collectively throughout the city, antisocial behaviour had reduced by 22%.
Named13 Oct 2010(archived) Sports Ground Panel
Membership Change
The Committee noted that Councillor Barnes had replaced Councillor Rigby on the Committee.
Named4 Oct 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee
Government Consultation on Equity and Excellence: Liberating the NHS - Draft Cabinet Response to Chapter on Local Democratic Legitimacy in Health
Cllr Barnes: Referred to the funding streams that came through the Local Strategic Partnership (LSP), for example smoking cessation, suggesting that the City Council needed broader understanding of where funding comes from. In addition, he also made reference to the fact that our Primary Care Trust (PCT) had been moving towards opening health centres where GP’s came together. He also expressed concerns about GP’s managing their own budgets.
Named4 Oct 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee
work programme
Cllr Barnes: Asked the Committee if they considered it appropriate to include an item on its Work Programme in respect of Key Deliverables and it was agreed that this would be appropriate.
Named4 Oct 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee
Summary Sheets
Members Comments/Questions Cllr Barnes: Referred to the situation which had arisen regarding the Telecare /Lifelines Service and indicated that this item had been included in the relevant issue of the City Council’s Forward Plan and that pre-decision scrutiny could have been carried out if requested by the relevant overview and scrutiny committee, Cllr Garner: Referred to the fact that the meeting of the Transformation and Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee held on 23 September 2010 had been in danger of being inquorate and referred to the need for members to ensure that they attended those meetings which they were members of.
Named30 Sep 2010Cabinet
Notification of a Completed Review by the Improving Communities Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Cabinet received questions which had been submitted by Councillor Barnes regarding this item.
Named30 Sep 2010Cabinet
Parking Penalty Processing Policy
Cabinet received questions which had been submitted by Councillor Barnes regarding this item. Responses to these questions were provided by the Head of Regulatory Services.
Named30 Sep 2010Cabinet
Contracts for Remaining 2010-11 Primary Capital Programme Works
Cabinet received a question which had been submitted by Councillor Barnes regarding this item. A response to this question was provided by the Head of Legal Services.
Asked20 Sep 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Economic Development and Enterprise
North Staffordshire Regeneration Partnership (NSRP) and Regeneration Directorate Financial Review to the end of July 2010
Councillor Al- Khatib and Councillor Barnes sought further clarification regarding the Town Centre Programme, in particular, the re-phasing of investment and investment in relation to Spode.
Said20 Sep 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Economic Development and Enterprise
North Staffordshire Regeneration Partnership (NSRP) and Regeneration Directorate Financial Review to the end of July 2010
Councillor Barnes commented that budget increases were ... view the full minutes text for item 17.
Named20 Sep 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Economic Development and Enterprise
Quarter 1 2010-11 LAA Performance Report
NSRP NI 152 – Working age people on out of work benefits (red) Councillor Barnes referred to the pledges that had been published by Cabinet and queried if the target relating to the JET scheme was more challenging that the LAA target. He indicated that he felt that this Committee should receive the details of the pledges made by Cabinet that were relevant to this Committee.
Asked20 Sep 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Economic Development and Enterprise
Quarter 1 2010-11 LAA Performance Report
Councillor Barnes queried if there was a target for the number of people who remained in employment as some of the jobs through the JET Programme were temporary contracts Alison Knight, Director of Employment and Skills explained that there were different schemes for different jobs. She indicated that 91% of those people entering permanent employment were still employed and more and more were employed by the Private Sector. She commented that the temporary jobs were funded by the Future Jobs Fund.
Asked20 Sep 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Economic Development and Enterprise
Quarter 1 2010-11 LAA Performance Report
Councillor Barnes asked what the target was in total over the three years The Performance and Programme Manager explained that the target for the three years was 570 in total. She commented that it was anticipated that there would be 44 anticipated units would be delivered in this quarter.
Said20 Sep 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Economic Development and Enterprise
Employment & Skills Strategy (pre-decision scrutiny)
Councillor Barnes expressed his support to the priorities within the Plan and highlighted that it was the Constitution Review Working Group and not Cabinet who had the authority to amend the Policy Framework as stated within the report.
Named9 Sep 2010City Council
Members' Questions
They have also been meeting heads and heads designate of our new academies, where these are in place, in order to ensure that they also buy back music service provision from the Council.” Question 2 from Councillor Barnes: Position of Leader “Could the Leader of the City Council highlight the Business and meetings he has conducted on behalf of the City Council since the last full council meeting?” R esponse provided by Concillor Pervez (Leader of the Council):
Moved9 Sep 2010City Council
Motion on Notice - Request to the Minister responsible for Local Government
Councillor Barnes moved, and Councillor Ward seconded, the following motion (notice of which had previously been given):- “That Stoke-on-Trent City Council welcomes the Government’s interest in local governance and will consider with interests its proposals in the forthcoming Bills that affect local democracy, some of them radical and far reaching.
Named5 Aug 2010City Council
Members' Questions
The Lord Mayor advised that six questions had been received from Councillor Barnes under Council procedure rule 11.2.
Moved5 Aug 2010City Council
Report of Petitions Received
Councillor Barnes moved, and Councillor Salih seconded, that the matter be referred to the Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee with a request that the relevant Overview and Scrutiny committee undertake a review.
Seconded5 Aug 2010City Council
Report of Petitions Received
On the motion of Councillor Barnes seconded by Councillor Salih it was :-
Moved5 Aug 2010City Council
Appointment of City Council Representatives to Community Hall Management Committees
An amendment was moved by Councillor Barnes, and seconded by Councillor Salih , the effect of which would be to add the following words to the motion:- ‘The Council is concerned that volunteers may be deterred from volunteering in the light of recent events at Goldenhill Community Centre and requests that a report is presented to the Audit Committee detailing the reasons for the recent referral of volunteer(s) to the Police’.
Named5 Aug 2010City Council
Changes to the Council Constitution
On the motion of Councillor Barnes, seconded by Councillor Clarke, it was:-
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.