Seconded24 Mar 2011City Council
Minutes of a previous meetings of the City Council held on 27/01/11 and 24/02/11
Councillor Barnes moved, and Councillor Salih seconded, that the minutes of the City Council meeting held on 24 February 2011, be amended to record the Lord Mayor’s refusal to a request made by Councillor Barnes for permission to exceed the five minute time limit on speeches when presenting an amendment during the deliberations on the Budget and Council Tax Setting 2011/12.
Seconded24 Mar 2011City Council
Minutes of a previous meetings of the City Council held on 27/01/11 and 24/02/11
Councillor Barnes further moved, seconded by Councillor Salih , that the minutes of the meeting held on 24 February 2011 be amended to record how individual Members voted on the motion concerning the scheme for Councillors allowances (Ref: Clause 201),if a recorded vote was requested at the time. His recollection was that the meeting had assumed that the vote was a recorded vote and he wished it to be noted that he had voted in favour of the amendment.
Named24 Mar 2011City Council
Changes to the Council Constitution
On the motion of Councillor Salih, seconded by Councillor Brian, it was:-
Seconded24 Mar 2011City Council
Minutes of the Cabinet (3/2/11 and 10/2/11)
During a debate on a review of the subsidy for bus services, which had been undertaken by an Overview and Scrutiny Committee and was referred to in the minutes, Councillor Kent- Baguley moved and Councillor Salih seconded, an amendment which had the effect of adding the following words to the motion:- ‘Building on the “Subsidy for bus services” Spotlight Review as presented to Cabinet 3 rd February 2011, Council agrees the immediate establishment of a Member/Officer Working Group to undertake urgent monitoring of the service use of all City Council subsidised bus routes as a basis for immediate negotiations with the bus operators to restructure bus services affected by the cut in the bus subsidies.’ On being put to the vote, the amendment was not approved by the City Council and, following further debate on the motion, it was subsequently:-
Seconded9 Dec 2010City Council
Report of Petitions Received
Councillor Conteh then moved, and Councillor Salih seconded, that the matter be referred to the next available meeting of the Children and Young People’s Overview and Scrutiny Committee on 17 January 2010.
Named9 Dec 2010City Council
Stoke-on-Trent Electoral Review - Local Government Boundary Commission for England Final Proposals
On the motion of Councillor Salih , seconded by Councillor Ryan, it was:-
Moved9 Dec 2010City Council
Minutes of the Administration and Appeals Committee (18/11/2010)
Councillor Salih moved and Councillor Ryan seconded that the minutes of the Administration and Appeals Committee held on 18 November 2010 be noted.
Moved9 Dec 2010City Council
Minutes of the Improving Communities Overview and Scrutiny Committee (9/11/10)
Councillor Salih moved and Councillor Brown seconded that the minutes of the Improving Communities Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting held on 9 November 2010 be noted.
Asked7 Dec 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities
Performance and Customer Feedback Report
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Salih asked if all the Local Area Agreement (LAA) targets had been deleted by the government as he felt that having officers working on targets which were to be deleted was a waste of resources. He also expressed concern that a significant amount of evidence had been gathered in order to obtain grants; but if the Local Area Agreement targets were axed the council would no longer be able to access the grants.
Named7 Dec 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities
Performance and Customer Feedback Report
Following a question from Councillor Salih , who asked if complaints received by councillors were monitored, the Customer Feedback Manager confirmed that these were not monitored and highlighted the importance of councillors referring any complaints received to the complaints team.
Asked7 Dec 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities
Performance and Customer Feedback Report
Councillor Salih asked why the council did not have a system which allowed complaints to be resolved, in the first instance, by individual departments. The Head of Member Services indicated that there ... view the full minutes text for item 36.
Said7 Dec 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities
Preparing for budget setting - The role of Overview and Scrutiny
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Salih expressed his view that the committee was not able to comment effectively on the bigger picture until the outcome of the financial settlement was known on 13 December 2010.
Named7 Dec 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities
Budget Development 2011/12 - 2014/15
Option Reference Number Description Support/Reject/Further information required 1-HEN01 Executive restructure Support – Copy of the revised structure requested by Councillor Salih 1-HEN02 Restructure of ground maintenance management. The new structure goes from 30 posts to 28 posts. A net reduction of 2 posts. 16 staff will be placed potentially putting at risk 13 staff with 1 vacant post.
Said7 Dec 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities
Housing Revenue Account - Rent Arrears
Councillor Salih expressed his view that this situation had been self inflicted as a consequence of the council centralising rent collection and ceasing the practice of having neighbourhood officers collecting rent. He suggested that rent collection be decentralised and returned to the local centres.
Asked21 Sep 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities
Performance and Customer Feedback Report
Councillor Salih asked what the impact of the cut in the Homes and Communities grant had been and what the target would be after 2011 as a result of the cut to this grant.
Named21 Sep 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities
Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services Financial Review 2010/11 to the end of July 2010 (Period 4)
Councillor Salih was also unhappy that grass cuttings were not being collected despite residents of council homes paying an extra £2.48 on top of their rent for this service.
Asked21 Sep 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities
Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services Financial Review 2010/11 to the end of July 2010 (Period 4)
Councillor Salih asked for clarification of the legacy issues from previous years of £0.632m which had not been identified until after the budget had been set.
Asked21 Sep 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities
Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services Financial Review 2010/11 to the end of July 2010 (Period 4)
Councillor Salih asked if the £400k net financial risk which the council was currently assessing related to recycling.
Named21 Sep 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities
Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services Financial Review 2010/11 to the end of July 2010 (Period 4)
Councillor Salih referred to the list of income streams and asked if other service provision and possible new sources of income had been examined. The Financial Services Manager (HENS) stated that other sources of income had been explored and in addition, all fees and ... view the full minutes text for item 19.
Named21 Sep 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities
Housing Repairs and the Trial Scheme
The Director of Operations, Kier Stoke agreed to respond directly to Councillor Salih who asked if the agency staff employed on the pilot had undergone Criminal Records Bureau (CRB) checks.
Said21 Sep 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities
Housing Repairs and the Trial Scheme
Councillor Salih raised concerns that the onus of diagnosis was being placed back onto individual workmen and individual workmen operate in different ways; which would lead to inconsistent service provision. He also expressed concerns about health and safety issues and hoped that these would be addressed so that only appropriately qualified operatives could complete particular types of work such as electrics, gas and plumbing work.
Named21 Sep 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities
Work Programme: Planning and Progress
Following a question from Councillor Salih about the progress of the Vangaurd work, particularly in relation to allocations, the Head of Housing Services updated the committee on the progress made so far by officers involved with the Vanguard systems thinking project. She indicated that the information would be mapped out without a formal written report and that members would be invited to have a look at what had been done.
Named21 Sep 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities
Work Programme: Planning and Progress
Councillor Salih was concerned that members would not be able to see what benefits the outside consultancy group Vanguard had brought to the council if not evidenced in a written report and he felt strongly that any suggestions for changes to the allocations policy should first be submitted to the committee for consideration. He requested that the current allocations policy be forwarded to the committee and that a future item on allocations be considered at Councillors ’ Forum.
Moved9 Sep 2010City Council
Minutes of the Appeals and Administration Committee (12/8/10)
Councillor Salih moved and Councillor Reynolds seconded that the minutes of Administration and Appeals Committee meeting held on 12/8/10 be noted.
Seconded5 Aug 2010City Council
Report of Petitions Received
Councillor Barnes moved, and Councillor Salih seconded, that the matter be referred to the Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee with a request that the relevant Overview and Scrutiny committee undertake a review.
Seconded5 Aug 2010City Council
Report of Petitions Received
On the motion of Councillor Barnes seconded by Councillor Salih it was :-
Seconded5 Aug 2010City Council
Appointment of City Council Representatives to Community Hall Management Committees
An amendment was moved by Councillor Barnes, and seconded by Councillor Salih , the effect of which would be to add the following words to the motion:- ‘The Council is concerned that volunteers may be deterred from volunteering in the light of recent events at Goldenhill Community Centre and requests that a report is presented to the Audit Committee detailing the reasons for the recent referral of volunteer(s) to the Police’.
Seconded5 Aug 2010City Council
District Auditor's Report
On the motion of Councillor Coleman, seconded by Councillor Salih , it was:-
Named13 Jul 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities
Work Programme: Planning and progress
Following a request from Councillor Salih that the Serious Violent Crime (LAA15) review begin as soon as possible, the Scrutiny Officer confirmed that he could start the review immediately with the Chair and current membership, whilst awaiting further volunteers.
Said13 Jul 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities
Quarter 4 Performance and Customer Feedback Report
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Salih noted that some of the indicators were funded through the Area Based Grant (ABG) and asked how the proposed cuts by the Local Strategic Partnership (LSP) to the grants for reducing re-offending and drug and alcohol services would affect the projects aimed at tackling these issues. He further asked if the Local Area Agreement targets would be realigned to reflect the cuts and if any representations had been made to central government.
Said13 Jul 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities
Quarter 4 Performance and Customer Feedback Report
Councillor Salih expressed serious concern about the proposed cuts to the two services previously highlighted and was also concerned that members were due to commence a review into serious violent crime (NI 15) and yet they were not in receipt of all the facts, given that they unaware of the proposed cuts or who had authorised the cuts. The Director of Resources NSRP explained that the new coalition government had introduced a 10 % in year cut to area based grant funding budgets as part of its emergency budget in June 2010. He indicated that these cuts were unexpected and therefore necessitated the need for officers to make cuts quickly.
Asked13 Jul 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities
Quarter 4 Performance and Customer Feedback Report
Councillor Salih asked why a report had not been appended to the report being considered by the committee today to inform members of the reduction in the area based grant and to highlight that targets could be affected.
Asked13 Jul 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities
Housing Revenue Account - Rent Arrears Review 2009/10
Councillor Salih asked how many introductory tenants already had rent arrears. He recognised the effect the current economic climate had had on some tenants’ ability to pay but he did not accept defaulters who leave council premises for the private sector owing rent, and are then subsequently re-housed by the council having accrued debt in the private sector. He strongly suggested that the whole rent arrears and allocations situation needed to be thoroughly looked into.
Named14 Jun 2010(archived) Audit Committee
Minutes of Previous Meetings (29/3/2010 and 27/5/2010)
Councillor Salih made reference to Item 60 – Sale of City Council Shares in the Stoke-on-Trent Community Stadium Development Company, questioning when the report would be available.
Asked14 Jun 2010(archived) Audit Committee
Minutes of Previous Meetings (29/3/2010 and 27/5/2010)
Councillor Salih sought assurances that the report would not be subject to further delays, suggesting that this would be totally unacceptable. He also suggested that, in view of the £180,000 cost to the authority in terms of lost interest payments, that the matter should be heard by the widest possible audience in terms of elected members and taxpayers of the City.
Said7 Jun 2010(archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Transformation and Resources
call-in: Transformational Change Programme
Councillor Salih outlined the reasons why he and Councillors Kent- Baguley and Joynson had called in the decision, which were as follows:- The call-in was about the procurement process and not about services. He felt that the procurement process was being short circuited and given that the decision involved a lot of money it should be dealt with through the proper procurement process. The link between Lean Systems Thinking and DECATS had not been explained fully.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.