To Elect a Lord Mayor and Chairman of the Council for the Ensuing Year
Councillor Conteh moved that a recorded vote be taken on the two proposed nominees and this was supported by more than 18 members present and voting at the meeting.
Every time Stoke-on-Trent's minutes name Councillor Conteh, as the council published it.
Councillor Conteh moved that a recorded vote be taken on the two proposed nominees and this was supported by more than 18 members present and voting at the meeting.
Councillor Conteh nominated Councillor Rita Dale and this was seconded by Councillor Bridges.
On the motion of Councillor Conteh, seconded by Councillor A. Brown it was:-
Present Councillor Randolph Conteh (Chair), Councillor Jackie Barnes, Councillor Karen Clarke and Councillor Alan Dutton (Reserve Member) Officers Debra Barber (Legal Advisor) and Angela Gardner (Democratic Services Officer) Other Attendees Karen Viggars (Housing Officer) The Appellant and their Citizens’ Advice Bureau Representative
Councillor Conteh referred to his discussions with UHNS Estates Officers which had been very satisfactory and he wanted to place on record his thanks to the officers concerned. He was however still aware of parking issues that caused problems for residents of the areas around the hospital.
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Conteh questioned the background reasons surrounding the number of “inappropriate referrals” in respect of the Integrated Family Intervention Service. It was explained that the reason could be that the circumstances within the family had changed.
In relation to an issue raised by Councillor James concerning who had been consulted and Councillor Conteh in respect satisfaction levels in relation to Integrated Working the Director of People stated that data had been validated by the Police and theAssistant Director Adult Social Care explained that a visit was carried out to every household reporting a less than 100% satisfaction level to find out the reasons behind it.
Councillor Conteh asked for an update on the pooled budget and it was stated that the City Council would have a pooled budget during 2015.
Councillor Conteh agreed that this was a priority and supported carrying out a task and finish review.
Councillor Conteh asked if the high mortality rate and the fact that the rest of the country had higher life expectancy rates were due to the legacy of the dangerous industries that were prevalent in the area in the past. Continuing, he commented that behaviour needed to be changed if lives were to be saved in the future and that he would like to see more programmes in schools to prevent young children from smoking and drinking and more campaigns were also needed to encourage people to be scanned as this helps with early diagnosis. He requested that more information on scanning campaigns be forwarded to all Councillors at the appropriate times.
In addition, Councillor Conteh stated that the committee also needed sight of the previous Tenancy Agreement so that they could easily identify what changes were being proposed.
Recommendation 119 – Councillor Conteh asked if there was a single point of contact for Councillors to report the issues they receive from local residents to and suggested that if there was no single point of contact, one was required.
Councillor Conteh referred to the financial implications, outlined in the report, which provided the options available in the event that EnergyCo ... view the full minutes text for item 45.
Present - Councillor Martin Garner (Chair), Councillor Randolph Conteh, Councillor Gwen Hassall, and Councillor Alastair Watson (Reserve).
Members’ Comments and Questions Councillor Conteh asked if councillors were notified of complaints and MP enquiries that affected their ward.
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Conteh expressed concern that an increase in council house rent would add further pressure, particularly on low earners, on top of the pressure that would be caused by the welfare reform and therefore he stated that he could not support the proposed increase.
A Motion moved by Councillor Conteh, seconded by Councillor Conway, “that council house rents and service and facilities charges be frozen”, was lost on the Chair’s casting vote. A vote on the proposal to increase council house rents by 3.86 per cent was lost but there ... view the full minutes text for item 44.
Item 35 - Designation of Polling Places Councillor Conteh requested that his commiserations to Councillor Joy Garner be recorded with regards to the outcome of the recent Police and Crime Commissioner Elections.
Members’ Comments and Questions Councillor Conteh commented that his preferred option would be Option 2 but that he would be happy with Option 3 if implementation of the Customer Relationship Management system was imminent. The Team Manager for Customer Feedback and Information Rights advised that she was unsure of the timescale for this but would know more after a meeting she would be attending on 5 December 2012. She confirmed that she would report back to the Committee following this meeting.
Councillor Conteh moved and Councilllor Conway seconded:- ‘That the petition against the withdrawal of subsidies for Community Halls be referred to the City Renewal Overview and Scrutiny Committee for further consideration.’ Following a debate on the motion, Councillor Conteh moved that a recorded vote be taken and this was supported by more than 18 members present and voting at the meeting.
Councillor Conteh asked Councillor Pervez for his view on the relationship between the City Council and County Council.
With regard to the Regent Theatre and the Victoria Hall Councillor Conteh asked for an indication of the criteria used to carry out the tendering exercise to ensure that the quality of productions would be maintained and John Holmes provided a response.
Councillor Conteh and the Lord Mayor Para. 51 – Port Vale Football Club Personal Season ticket holder at Stoke City Football Club.
Members’ Comments/Questions Councillor Garner and Councillor Conteh both voiced their surprise that no evidence of displacement activity had been found due to the number of complaints that they had received from residents in their wards.
Councillor Conteh referred to the Stoke Town Retail Study and highlighted that within the conclusions of the report, it stated that a new food store on the Spode site would deliver new sustainable and economic benefits and assist with the regeneration of a prominent site. He stressed the need to send out these positive messages as many people had expressed an opinion that they did not want to see another food store in the Town. He requested that all members of the Committee receive a copy of the Stoke Town Retail Study.
Residential Street Parking – Britannia Stadium Councillor Conteh referred to the recommendation made in respect of shuttle buses as previously issues had been experienced. He confirmed that he had travelled on the shuttle bus himself this season and believed that on the whole the scheme was now successful with very few problems reported. He went on to refer to the recommendation regarding opening up the use of Wharf Place for fans using the shuttle bus and commented that this recommendation had been made in order to try and encourage more people to use the bus rather than blocking up residential streets.
The Lord Mayor conveyed the best wishes of the Council to Councillor Randolph Conteh who was scheduled to undergo surgery on Monday 12 December 2011.
Councillor Conteh referred to the recommendation for a 10% reduction to the existing level of City Council grant to the New Vic Theatre in 2012/13 and asked if the reduction formed part of the City Council’s budget proposals that were currently out for consultation. He believed that if this was the case, the recommendation should be subject to the budget consultation.
Councillor Conteh expressed concern about the number of savings that were showing red for the second quarter and where the savings achieved were showing as zero. He asked that more detail be provided in the next report and questioned why any had been included where it known that zero savings would be achieved.
A motion moved by Councillor Ali and seconded by Councillor Conteh to ‘support option 3’ was carried.
Councillor Conteh moved and Councillor Conway seconded, “that the nominations referred to in the Schedule, as circulated, be confirmed as City Council representatives to serve on the outside bodies indicated”.
Councillor Wilcox moved and Councillor Conteh seconded that the minutes of the City Renewal Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting held on 14 September be noted.
Councillor Conteh referred to the conclusion that in five of the six clinical review cases ‘clinical practice and procedural competence’ was of a ‘reasonable and satisfactory standard and asked for a definition of ‘reasonable and satisfactory’ in this context. The Chief Executive UHNS indicated that further information would be provided in [name removed] final report, but clarified for the committee that the term ‘reasonable and satisfactory’ did not have the same meaning as it would in a performance context where it might be construed to mean could do better.
Councillor Conteh asked what were the lessons learnt by the hospital in terms of the way issues of clinical concern and patient safety would be handled in the future.
In response to a further question from Councillor Conteh about the action plan the Chief Executive UHNS explained that this was ongoing until [name removed] final report had been received.
Councillor Conteh asked why in Stoke, most reported incidents of abuse occurred in care homes when national trends suggested that most abuse takes place in people’s own homes.
Councillor Conteh referred to the ‘outcomes for vulnerable adults’ data and, in noting that 38% of outcomes were not recorded for Staffordshire compared to 0% for Stoke-on-Trent, he asked if lessons were being learned from this.
· Councillor Conteh referred to the information that had been provided by the Director of City Renewal Services in respect of maintenance and queried whether the lead petitioner had been made aware of the measures that had been put into place so far. He expressed a wish that any recommendation made by this Committee today be conveyed to the lead petitioner together with the reasons behind them and indicated that in view of the information received, he felt that no more action should be taken.
· Councillor Conteh indicated that following last year’s budget decision to remove bus subsidies, petitions were still being submitted. Some bus services had continued but that this was ... view the full minutes text for item 16.
Councillor Conteh expressed his support for Local Development Orders but asked if companies automatically received the ‘green light’ to go ahead with their venture or if public opinion was taken into account should there be any opposition to their proposals.
· Councillor Conteh expressed his support for the Strategy but suggested that the word ‘impartial’ be removed from the document. He believed that this Committee should have a representative on the CCTV Strategy Group.
· Councillor Conteh asked if in view of the potential overspends, there would have to be more reductions to staff and what other budget savings might be identified.
On the motion of Councillor Reynolds, seconded by Councillor Conteh , it was:
On the motion of Councillor Shotton , seconded by Councillor Conteh , it was:-
Councillor Conteh referred to a briefing meeting which had been arranged for the Committee to meet with the City Council’s Building Regulations Manager, as agreed at the previous meeting held on 7 June 2011 (Item 13). He commented that the briefing had been very worthwhile and informative and that he welcomed the opportunity for members of the Committee to attend the sports grounds throughout the city in an observing capacity at the Building Regulations Manager’s invitation.
· The Best Companies Staff Survey – ‘One to Watch’ (HR and Transformation Division) · The RoSPA Gold Award for Health and Safety (Health and Safety Team) · The Workplace Health Gold Award (Health and Safety Team) · Highly commended in the 2011 Municipal Journal Achievement Awards in the Sustainable Infrastructure category (City Regeneration Division) · Finalists of the 2011 Municipal Journal Achievement Awards in the Excellence in Democratic Services category (Member Services Division) · Commended in the 2011 Municipal Journal Achievement Awards in the Delivering Better Outcomes Achievement of the Year Awards (Integration Services) The Lord Mayor also presented Councillor Randolph Conteh with a runner up award for the Centre for Public Scrutiny Non-executive of the Year.
Councillor Conteh moved, and Councillor Conway seconded, ‘ that the petition concerning the Children’s Centres budget cuts be referred to the relevant Overview and Scrutiny Committee’. On being put to the vote, the motion did not receive the support of the Council.
Councillor Conteh moved, and Councillor Gratton seconded,’ that the petition to give deaf children a fair chance be referred to the relevant Overview and Scrutiny Committee ’. On being put to the vote, the motion received the support of the Council.
In so doing she highlighted the fact that the Police Authority continued to oppose the idea of Police and Crime Commissioners and she commented on the thanks that had been expressed to former City Council representatives on the Authority for their contributions, including Clive Brian, Brian Ward and Councillor Randolph Conteh.
Councillor Conteh moved and Councillor Hassell seconded that the minutes of the former Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee meeting held on 29 March 2011 be noted.
Councillor Conteh queried how the consultation could strengthen the rationale behind the key ... view the full minutes text for item 9.
Councillor Conteh welcomed the report and commented that he did not wish to see sites in the City developed with high value properties that were not going to sell. He expressed a wish to receive a future update on the development of potential sites for executive housing.
Councillor Conteh referred to a previous Task and Finish Review about the parking issues around Stoke City Football Club. He requested that members of any Task and Finish group be sent the relevant background information before the initial meeting.
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Conteh asked if the working group would continue to meet after the election and if it had been confirmed that the Human Resources Committee would consider future appointments of consultants at tiers one and two. He asked if a consultant would be employed to fill the future vacant Director of Business Services post, as in his view this would cost more than using an internal officer to act as an interim. The Director of Business Services reported that regular monitoring reports would be submitted to Overview and Scrutiny, Council, Corporate Directors Board and Cabinet for consideration, but he was unsure whether there was a need for the working group to continue to meet as a group.
b) Petition to save the No. 58/58a bus services from Penkhull to Etruria Locks The Council was advised that the Lead Petitioner for the above petition had changed to Councillor Conteh .
Councillor Conteh then addressed the City Council on behalf of the 195 signatories to the petition.
Councillor Conteh moved and Councillor Garner seconded that the minutes of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee meetings held on 17 January and 7 February 2011 be noted.
The Lead Petitioner, Councillor Randolph Conteh , addressed the City Council on behalf of the 847 signatories to the petition.
Councillor Conteh then moved, and Councillor Salih seconded, that the matter be referred to the next available meeting of the Children and Young People’s Overview and Scrutiny Committee on 17 January 2010.
On the motion of Councillor Brian, seconded by Councillor Conteh , it was then:-
The Democratic Services Officer reported that Councillor Conteh had been appointed to the vacant City Independent Group seat on the committee.
Name Item Type Nature of Interest Councillor Conteh 26 Personal Stoke City Football Club season ticket holder.
Councillor Conteh reported that this had been an in-depth review which was undertaken as a result of complaints from residents living in the vicinity of Stoke City Football Club’s Britannia Stadium. He outlined the problems faced by residents; the methods used to consult and gather evidence and gave details of the visits to Derby City Council and Derby County Football Club. He outlined the recommendations which proposed short, medium and long term solutions to the problems and explained the reasons why they were being proposed.
Councillor Conteh reported that since the start of the review the parking situation had already improved. Stoke City Football Club had increased its parking spaces and changed the method of entrance to the car parks and traffic management had improved, which had all helped to improve the situation for residents.
Councillor Conteh asked that, given the current financial situation and the timeline for implementing the recommendations, would neighbourhood management exist beyond March 2011.
Councillor Conteh was disappointed that the recommendation to reinstate community ward events had only been partially agreed by Cabinet. He felt that funding should be found elsewhere if ward budgets ceased.
In response to a question from Councillor Conteh who asked if Vanguard were working towards saving money for the council during this or the next financial year, the Head of Neighbourhood Services responded that the primary objective of the housing systems thinking intervention was to improve services for customers, not to save money. She indicated that savings might be made as the intervention is rolled out, but this was not the primary objective. The Chair raised concerns that the perception of the general public was that the council would complete all works that needed doing.
Councillor Conteh welcomed the Cabinet’s response to the recommendations. He circulated a presentation explaining how to carry out effective consultation, which he regarded as an example of best practice. He thanked all members and officers involved for their contribution to this comprehensive review.
Petitions Councillor Conteh gave an update on the petition opposing the proposed residents parking schemes in several streets in Harpfields and Penkhull , as discussed at the previous meeting. He explained that the 21 day consultation period had ended. He reported that 84% of residents were in favour of the residents’ parking schemes but there had been some objections.
Outside Bodies Safer, Stronger, Greener Communities Partnership Group Councillor Conteh reported that he had attended a meeting of this group where he received a presentation on the ‘Alcohol Branding Strategy’. He requested that a copy of this presentation be forwarded to all members of the committee.
Councillor Conteh enquired how staff morale, which would inevitably be very low in this economic climate, was being factored in as a risk.
The Cabinet received notification of a completed review by the Improving Communities Overview and Scrutiny Committee entitled “Learning from Richmond Street Park Improvements” which was presented by Councillor Conteh , the Chair of the Task and Finish Group.
Councillor Conteh outlined details of the main findings of the review together with the recommendations which had been put forward by the Task and Finish Group. He hoped that lessons had been learnt and took the opportunity to thank Cabinet for their response to the recommendations. He highlighted the official opening of Richmond Street Park which was to take place on Saturday 7 August 2010.
Councillor Irving fully supported all of the recommendations of the review and commented that he had sympathy with Councillor Conteh and residents as he had experience of similar issues in Hanford where improvements had taken a number of years to come to fruition.
Comments from Committee Members Task and Finish Group Reviews Councillor Conteh confirmed that the Richmond Street Park review would be considered by Cabinet on 29 July 2010.
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Conteh asked where the £3.018m underspend had not been spent.
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Conteh asked if funding for alley gating had been affected by the cuts in the area based grant.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Conteh attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 18 Jul 2008 | City Council | Stoke-on-Trent Governance Commission | Carried | 33 for, 22 against | |
| 18 Jul 2008 | City Council | Report of the Independent Remuneration Panel | Lost | 26 for, 31 against |
Meetings Councillor Conteh was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
No meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Conteh declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Conteh in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Conteh sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Licensing and Registration Panel | Committee Member | Jun 2012 | 37 | |
| City Council | Committee Member | Mar 2007 | 36 | |
| (archived) Human Resources Committee | Committee Member | May 2010 | 27 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities | Committee Member | May 2007 | 24 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Adult and Neighbourhoods | Committee Member | May 2011 | 20 | |
| Licensing and Appeals Committee | Committee Member | May 2011 | 16 | |
| (archived) Human Resources Sub-Committee (Appointments) | Committee Member | Sep 2010 | 14 | |
| Licensing Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Aug 2011 | 14 | |
| (archived) Sports Ground Panel | Committee Member | Jul 2007 | 13 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Health | Vice-Chair | May 2007 | 12 | |
| (archived) Tenancy Sub-Committee | Chair | Jan 2013 | 10 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - City Renewal | Committee Member | May 2011 | 8 | |
| Local Strategic Partnership Board | Committee Member | Jan 2008 | 6 | |
| (archived) Human Resources Sub-Committee (Employment Appeals) | Committee Member | Sep 2010 | 5 | |
| (archived) Councillors Forum | Committee Member | Dec 2008 | 4 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Commission - City-Wide Services | Committee Member | Apr 2007 | 3 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Transformation and Resources | Committee Member | Nov 2010 | 3 | |
| (archived) Audit Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2010 | 2 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Commission - Health | Vice-Chair | May 2007 | 1 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Commission - Neighbourhood Management | Observer | May 2007 | 1 | |
| (archived) Licensing and Consumer Protection Committee | Guest | Nov 2008 | 1 | |
| Cabinet | Committee Member | Jul 2010 | 1 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee | Chair | Mar 2011 | 1 | |
| (archived) Standards Committee | Committee Member | May 2013 | 1 | |
| Way Panel | Committee Member | Nov 2013 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.