Apologies for absence
In a change from the published agenda Councillor Ross Irving sat on this Licensing Sub-Committee.
Every time Stoke-on-Trent's minutes name Councillor Irving, as the council published it.
In a change from the published agenda Councillor Ross Irving sat on this Licensing Sub-Committee.
On the motion of Councillor Hussain, seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
The Lord Mayor reported that there was no business of an urgent nature to be brought forward but firstly spoke of his honour in presenting a Badge of Office to Councillor Ross Irving to commemorate his role as Honorary Custodian of the Federation of Stoke-on-Trent.
They also extended a warm welcome to Councillor Ross Irving who was a new member of the Committee.
Interest Comments Councillor R Irving 13 Ward Member Councillor Irving confirmed he would be addressing Committee as the eligible Ward Member, and would therefore not take part in the debate or decision for this item.
Councillor R Irving did not take part in the debate or decision for this item, and instead spoke as an eligible Ward Member.
Members received representation from Councillor Ross Irving, speaking as Ward Member.
A motion, moved and seconded, that Councillor Ross Irving be appointed Vice-Chair of the Strategy and Resources Overview and Scrutiny committee for the 2024/25 Municipal Year was carried.
A motion moved by Councillor D Evans, seconded by Councillor R Irving, for Committee to adjourn in order to carry out a site visit, was not carried when put to the vote.
The Licensing and Registration Panel noted that Councillor Ross Irving had replaced Councillor Daniel Jellyman on the Panel as a Local Conservative group nomination.
(Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Development and Growth submitted a report requesting that the Licensing and Registration Panel (the Panel) determine an application for the grant of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
Councillor Irving advised the chamber that Councillor Sheila Pitt and Councillor Paul Shotton, both long-serving councillors, would be standing down in May. He spoke of their commitment to the city and wished them both all the best for the future.
Committee Members noted the Vice-Chair (Councillor Irving) had recently attended the Police, Fire & Crime Panel in Stafford, on behalf of this Committee, and had specifically raised the issue of the difficulty of reporting issues and concerns. Assurances had been given that contact and communication was being looked at in order to improve this area.
A motion, moved by Councillor A James and seconded by Councillor R Irving (Chair), to add to the proposed recommendations as set out within the report submitted, was carried when put to the vote. It was therefore:-
As a result, a procedural motion, moved by Councillor A Platt and seconded by Councillor R Irving, to adjourn consideration of the matter to a future meeting, was supported when put to the vote.
Disclosure Comments Councillor R Irving (Chair) 14 Personal Councillor Irving noted he had a close relative, who was employed by the NHS.
A Motion, moved by Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Ali ‘that Councillor Shaun Bennett be appointed Chair of the Housing, Development and Growth Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the 2022/23 Municipal Year’ was carried.
A Motion, moved by Councillor Bennett, seconded by Councillor Adams ‘that Councillor Ross Irving be appointed Vice-Chair of the Housing, Development and Growth Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the 2022/23 Municipal Year’ was carried.
A Motion, moved by Councillor Maqsoom, seconded by Councillor Bridges, that “Councillor Ross Irving be appointed as Chair of the Planning Committee – Development Management, for the 2022/2023 Municipal Year”, was carried.
Further to the Lord Mayor inviting members to speak to the nominations, Councillor Irving proposed a recorded vote which was supported by more than 18 members present at the meeting .
Further to the Lord Mayor inviting members to speak to the nominations, Councillor Irving proposed a recorded vote which was supported by more than 18 members present at the meeting.
Councillor Irving moved a motion to support the proposals as written, which was seconded by Councillor Blurton.
Councillor Irving referred to some Conservation areas preventing the installation of UPVC window and indicated that he did have sympathy with property owners who were trying to maintain their buildings as the cost difference between UPVC and wood could run into thousands of pounds. He queried whether there were any grants available for property owners. The Cabinet Member for Regeneration, Infrastructure and Heritage confirmed that there were no grants currently available and was one of the reasons why a review needed to take place as the world had changed multiple times indicating that if a house was ... view the full minutes text for item 12.
Councillor Irving queried the possibilities of expanding out the scheme beyond the core of Stoke Town such as to the college to enable residents in that area to also benefit being mindful of having to navigate past the Canal and A500. Andrew Briggs confirmed that at this moment in time, clusters were being created but as the scheme developed further areas could be connected. He confirmed that the network was already in place for the University.
Councillor Irving believed that as the cost of travel increased, people may decide that the city has a lot offer and that the Strategy should be based on attracting people in the near vicinity.
On the motion of Councillor Bennett, seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
BADGES OF OFFICE The Lord Mayor (Councillor Kanneganti) advised that civic badges had been presented to Councillor Ross Irving and Christine Wilson in recognition of their services to the City Council during 2020/21 as Lord Mayor Lady Mayoress.
Councillor Irving noted concerns about democratic input into the proposals, and also the management of resources and inequalities across the area. Simon Whitehouse agreed it needed to be a true partnership effort, and welcomed the continued dialogue and input from Elected Members. Marcus Warnes confirmed in terms of finance, Stoke-on-Trent CCG currently received increased funding due to the deprivation levels, and that moving forwards it was seen as important to ensure funding continued to meet the needs of populations.
Present Councillor Desiree Elliott (Chair), Councillor Chandra Kanneganti (Vice-Chair), Councillor Heather Blurton, Councillor Candi Chetwynd, Councillor Randolph Conteh, Councillor Ross Irving and Councillor Lee Wanger.
Comments and Questions from Committee Members Councillor Irving referred to the under 75 mortality rates and a recent media article that he had read which stated that mortality rates were dependent on an areas deprivation level and could be as much as ten years. The Director of Adult Social Care, Health Integration and Wellbeing agreed that this was a well-known phenomenon. He explained that Public Health regularly measured differences in a number of areas such as education, background, economic wealth and access to health services.
Councillor Irving voiced his concern that the Stay Put Policy was still adopted by the Fire and Rescue Service following the Grenfell Tower disaster. The Assistant Director – Housing Management and Communities explained that high-rise buildings were designed for apartments to be compartmentalised and therefore any fire should be contained. If the Fire and Rescue Service determined to evacuate a building on arrival, they would carry the evacuation out in a safe manner.
Councillor Irving asked if those with underlying health conditions would receive a vaccine earlier, or they needed to wait for their particular age bracket.
A motion moved by Councillor Daniel Jellyman and seconded by Councillor Ross Irving, that Councillor Ann James be appointed Vice-Chair of the Standards Committee for the municipal year, was carried.
A motion moved by Councillor Irving and seconded by Councillor Robinson, that an additional condition be included to ensure the maintenance of the private roads on the site also be dealt with by the management company, and not individual home owners, to ensure private roads are maintained and kept to a high standard, was later withdrawn following debate.
With the consent of the Lord Mayor, Councillor Irving listed those elected members that he believed had taken the decision not to stand for re-election at the forthcoming local elections on 2 May 2019, which included Councillors Brereton, L.
On the motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Jellyman, it was:
Councillor R Irving 4 Non-Pecuniary Councillor Irving confirmed he had spoken to a number of constituents regarding the application, but at no point had expressed an opinion and he remained open minded.
On the motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Dutton, it was:-
Councillor Irving noted that the Panel Chairman, Councillor Frank Chapman, was not seeking re-election to Staffordshire County Council in May 2017 and, given that he had served as a very effective Chair for a considerable period of time, the City Council wished to place on record its thanks and appreciation to Councillor Chapman for the work that he had undertaken with the Police and Crime Panel.
Councillor Irving asked if there were any projections regarding the likely impact to Stoke- on-Trent as a result of the reassessment of Business Rates. The Interim Assistant Director – Finance suggested that this was an issue which should be monitored and agreed to bring back more information to a future meeting of the Committee. He further confirmed that the reassessment was a national re-evaluation process and that there had been a delay in respect of the notification regarding the “multiplier”.
Councillor Irving asked whether the recent by-election had had any impact on the number of calls received and the Strategic Manager – Customer Services confirmed that there had been a slight increase with lines being open from 7am until 10pm instead of 8am-8pm. There had been an increase in calls by about 30-50 and about 100 on the day of the election.
Referring to the request made by the committee at a previous meeting for a briefing note on Parkhall Country Park, which had not yet been received, Councillor Irving requested an update on this item.
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Irving supported the proposal but was concerned about the risks involved and therefore asked if there was a possibility that the company could incur losses.
Councillor Irving agreed that the report lacked the detail necessary for the committee to thoroughly scrutinise this very significant proposal.
A motion moved by Councillor Shotton, seconded by Councillor Irving, “that a special meeting be convened to enable the committee to consider a more detailed report on the ‘Housing Company for the Council’, along with the Business Plan,” was carried.
The Chair and Councillor Irving referred to the proposals for traffic improvements for Tunstall town centre and Councillor Irving noted that the towns with free parking were the most successful as demonstrated by the T u nstall shopping development.
Councillor Irving welcomed the Plan and commended officers for their work and stated that it was important to recognise that this was a joint plan.
The committee felt that the information included in this report was out of date and consequently a Motion moved by Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Shotton, ‘that this item be deferred’, was carried.
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Irving highlighted the importance of obtaining public confidence in the District Heat Network project in terms of for example, addressing any health and safety concerns associated with the quality of the water and what happens to the waste.
Councillor Irving left the meeting at this point.
Councillor Irving requested a list outlining schools which are under local authority control, which are academies and what their governance arrangements were.
Councillor Irving spoke about the law and its requirement for R.E.
Councillor Irving asked what criterion were used to identify this Group and Daniel Marson explained that it covered those customers whom had been identified as being at risk of falling into arrears, those with a history of homelessness, addiction etc. He confirmed that the Council was in discussion with the DWP in relation to these service users and that there had been some flexibility in terms of payment arrangements for this Group. Continuing, Daniel Marson explained that the concept of Universal Credit was to replicate “in work” conditions with the theory that there would be a seamless transition into work.
Councillor Irving queried whether the introduction of Universal Credit could result in a reduction in the availability of private rented accommodation with Landlords becoming more selective and it was confirmed that this was a possibility. Gary Hall referred to a recent information session which had been hold in Hanley which had generated substantial interest from landlords. Daniel Marson added that the advantage to the way that this was being “rolled out” was that landlords would be able to feel their way ... view the full minutes text for item 22.
Councillor Irving asked if response times to the Call Centre had improved and it was confirmed that they had with average waiting times reducing from 7 to 3-4 minutes. It was noted that the Call Centre was now operating at full staff capacity and that the situation had been alleviated by calls in respect of Revenues and Benefits being automatically diverted to that Team and as the calls were complex and generally of 40-45 duration this had again helped to relieve the situation.
Councillor Irving asked if it would be possible to give an indication to callers of what their likely waiting/holding time would be and the Chief Operating Officer confirmed that, following Councillor Irving making a similar suggestion at a previous meeting of the Committee, this possibility had been investigated and confirmed that this was possible but that officers would need to work with Virgin Media to see if this could be developed.
Councillor Irving referred to the City Renewal Overview and Scrutiny meeting on 11 February 2016 at which time the former Victoria Ground had been discussed and the possibility of the Council discussing this site with St Modwen. The Interim Head of Paid Service agreed that this was an issue that could be looked at together with other potential sites.
Hanley- Bentilee Link Road £16.0 million Councillor Irving welcomed this scheme and felt that it offered the best economic benefit and Councillor Platt asked about the capacity and resources to deliver the scheme.
Task and Finish Group Reviews The Scrutiny Officer reported that Councillor Irving had requested to be a member of the Waste: Infrastructure and Collection task and finish group.
Councillor Irving expressed his support for the Ceramic Valley enterprise zone bid which he felt deserved Government support. The committee requested, if possible and at the appropriate time, to carry out pre-decision scrutiny on this item.
On the motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Platt, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Banks, seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
Councillor Irving agreed that these were sensiblesuggestions and commented on the current contact centre telephone system which, in his view, was not fit for purpose. The Chief Operating Officer acknowledged that this had been a concern for both the previous administration and the current portfolio holder. Continuing, the Chief Operating Officer gave details of the number of calls received confirming that the majority of these were residents calling to make payments and that currently, the kiosks in local centres only accepted cash.
Committee Members Comments and Questions Councillor Irving referred to sickness absence rates within the Authority, which although reduced to 97% were still not on a par with the private sector.
Councillor Irving added that it was recognised that some sort of communication vehicle was essential for a local government authority and that discussions would be on-going to decide what this would be. The Chair indicated that he understood that The Sentinel had been considered as a possible provider and the Cabinet Member confirmed that a number of options were being considered but whatever the outcome the focus would be different than where “Our City” ended up.
Councillor Irving expressed concern regarding the recently refurbished public realm in the City Centre which was in the process of being dug up when he had visited the previous day. The Chief Operating Officer agreed to investigate this issue and to advise all members of the Committee of the outcome.
Councillor Irving enquired whether the world expert had reported back yet in relation to the problems and Councillor A Brown confirmed that this report had been received but that it was premature to comment on it at this stage.
On the motion of Councillor Bridges seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Ward, seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Matloob , it was:-
(Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Adult and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report which requested the review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence and Private Hire Vehicle Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
Councillor Irving, Chair, have his thanks on behalf of the Board to all partners for their participation and work towards making the 2008-2011 LAA a success.
The Vice-Chair (Cllr R Irving) thanked Councillor Conteh for his presentation and asked him to also convey the appreciation of the members of the Cabinet to all overview and scrutiny members for their participation in this very difficult process.
(Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Adult and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report which requested the review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
(Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Adult and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting the determination of an application for the grant of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence following the disclosure of matters which required the consideration of the Panel.
Cabinet Members’ Comments / Questions Councillor Irving was fully supportive of the proposals and asked, if possible, for the fountain to be reinstated in Fountain Square.
Councillor Joy Garner (Chair), Councillor David Conway (Vice-Chair), Councillor Melanie Baddeley , Councillor Ross Irving, Councillor Majid Khan, Councillor Roy Naylor and Councillor David Sutton Other Attendees:
On the motion of Councillor Garner, seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Pervez , it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Pervez , seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Smith, seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Matloob , it was:-
On the Motion of Councillor Gratton seconded by Councillor Irving it was:
Cllr Irving referred to the need to be flexible in our approach to the Budget, indicating that the City Council was currently in the process of undertaking public consultation and that a number of strands needed to come together before the Budget could be set, with a deadline of February 2011 for the City Council budget papers to be sent out in time for the City Council meeting on 24 February. The Director of Central Services reported that part of the strategy may be determined by what part of the Budget the Government may cut for e.g. Area Based Grant (ABG) as opposed to mainstream funding which would result in a different strategy.
(Councillor Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report which requested the review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence and Private Hire Vehicle Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
On the motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Garner, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Reynolds, it was:-
Stoke-on-Trent City Council, therefore, asks the Minister responsible for Local Government to consider intervening regarding the above matter in the interests of the electors of Stoke-on-Trent.” Following a full debate on the motion, Councillor Irving moved and Councillor Pervez seconded that a recorded vote be taken and this was supported by more than 25 members present and voting at the meeting.
Councillor Irving complemented the contributors to the report on the depth of the research and cautioned all to look to the next 50 years, Councillor Hill supported this view.
This item was introduced by Councillor Irving, Cabinet member for Community Safety, Partnership and LSP.
On the motion of Councillor Pervez , seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Pervez , it was:-
Councillor Pervez moved, and Councillor Irving seconded, that the minutes be noted.
On the Motion of Councillor Pervez , seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:
Councillor Irving (Cabinet Member for Community Safety, Partnerships and LSP) spoke of the importance of pre-decision scrutiny for Cabinet and urged the committee members to carry out the role where appropriate.
Councillor Irving: Asked what methods were used to publicise the receipt of petitions to afford the opportunity to those with an opposing view to be represented and how Councillors were informed of petition in their local areas.
Councillor Irving (Cabinet Member for Community Safety, Partnerships and LSP): Extended his thanks to those Officers responsible for producing the report which included some complex data and also pointed to the fact that the City Council had been making steady progress in respect of some of the Indicators. He felt that it was particularly pleasing so see that in relation to some indicators where the Authority had previously been criticised for example, in relation to smoking cessation, there had been substantial improvements with the City Council now being in the top quartile.
Councillor Irving also commented upon the very good partnership relations which existed between the City Council and its partner agencies.
Councillor Pervez was now the Leader of the City Council and Councillor Irving, Deputy Leader. He further reported that there would be an ‘all out’ election in May 2011. He indicated that from an Officer point of view, the City Council politically, did feel more stable and organised and that the Cabinet had expressed their determination to make the coalition work.
It was moved by Councillor Follows and seconded by Councillor Irving, ‘ that Councillor D. Tolley be and is hereby elected Lord Mayor of the City of Stoke-on-Trent and Chairman of the Council for the ensuing municipal year’.
It was moved by Councillor Reynolds and seconded by Councillor Irving, ‘ that Councillor Mohammed Matloob be and is hereby appointed Deputy Lord Mayor of the City of Stoke-on-Trent and Vice Chairman of the Council for the ensuing municipal year’ .
It was moved by Councillor Irving and seconded by Councillor Reynolds, ‘ that Councillor Mohammed Pervez be and is hereby elected Leader of Stoke-on-Trent City Council for the ensuing municipal year or until he ceases to be a Councillor or is removed from office by the City Council’ .
Councillor Irving moved and Councillor Pervez seconded that ‘the fifteenth seat on the Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee be allocated to the City Independent Group.’ On being put to the vote, the motion was carried.
On the motion of Councillor Ward, seconded by Councillor Irving, and with the amendments as highlighted now made, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Clarke, seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
(Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting the determination of an application for the grant of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence following the disclosure of matters which required the consideration of the Panel.
( Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting consideration of an application for exemption from displaying private hire licence plates, signage and door signs for the vehicle as outlined in the report and exemption from wearing the driver’s badge when driving the vehicle.
(Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting the determination of an application for the grant of a Private Hire Vehicle Licence under the “Exceptional Condition” criteria as the age of the vehicle meant that it fell outside the age policy introduced by the City Council.
(Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report which requested the review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence and Hackney Carriage Vehicle Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
(Councillor Irving was not present for the consideration of this item).
( Councillor Irving was not present for the consideration of this item).
The Lord Mayor presented an award to the Leader, Councillor Irving,in recognition of the City Council being ranked 68 th in the Sunday Times list of the 75 Best Places to Work in the Public Sector. She explained that more than 200 organisations had competed for a place on the list and the views of 45,000 employees overall had been canvassed.
A motion, moved by Councillor Ibbs and seconded by Councillor Irving, “ that the petition be referred to the relevant Overview and Scrutiny Committee,” was carried when put to the vote.
On the motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Ward, it was:-
The proposals, as set out in the report submitted, were moved by Councillor Clarke and seconded by Councillor Irving.
The following motion was moved by Councillor Clarke and seconded by Councillor Irving - ‘That, in accordance with Part 4 Section 14 of the City Council Financial Regulations and the Treasury Management: Code of Practice, the following be approved:- · The Annual Treasury Management Strategy and the Annual Investment Strategy for 2010/11 (Annex 1 to the report submitted).
On the motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Follows, it was:-
Joynson moved, and Councillor Irving seconded, a motion:
( Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting the determination of an application for the grant of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel. The applicant attended the meeting and confirmed that they had received a copy of the report. The report was read out at the meeting and the applicant was interviewed by the Panel.
( Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting the review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence and Private Hire Vehicle Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
( Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting the determination of an application for the grant of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence and requesting the review of a Private Hire Vehicle Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel. It was reported that the applicant had been invited to attend the meeting but no reason had been given for the non attendance.
( Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting the review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
O n the motion of Councillor Pervez , seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
( Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting the review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence and Private Hire Vehicle Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
Tony Oakman reported that the Tobacco Alliance was being chaired by Councillor Irving, Leader of the Council.
On being put to the vote, a motion moved by Councillor A Joynson and seconded by Councillor Irving was unanimously agreed by the City Council and it was:-
The Committee noted that Councillor Joy Garner had replaced Councillor Mohammed Iqbal and that Councillor Ross Irving had replaced Councillor Sheila Matthews as members of the Administration and Appeals Committee.
Councillor Irving suggested that, once the public had been excluded and consideration of the item had begun, no further Elected Members should be permitted to join proceedings.
( Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting the review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence and Private Hire Vehicle Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
On the motion of Councillor Shotton, seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
The Leader, Councillor Irving, referred to the motion passed at the last ordinary council meeting concerning the position of Vice Chair on the Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent Combined Fire Authority, when he had indicated that he would meet with the Leader of Staffordshire County Council to discuss the matter further. He confirmed that the meeting had gone ahead on 17 August 2009, at which point it had been confirmed that a structural review of the fire service would be carried out and the review would incorporate the governance arrangements. He assured members that when the review had been conducted and he was in receipt of draft proposals, he would provide details to Members of the City Council for comment.
In his response, Councillor Irving referred to the balance between a genuine complaint or enquiry and unreasonable persistence. He hoped that [name removed] would respect why the authority had had to make a policy statement and the reasons for it.
Councillor Irving moved and Councillor Kent- Baguley seconded the following motion (notice of which had previously been given):- “That Council notes that in October 2002 the City Council unanimously resolved to support the motion “that the City Council commits its support for and adopts the principles of the Fairtrade Foundation and that the Lord Mayor is a patron of the Stoke-on-Trent Fairtrade Group” and further notes that it is five years since the City of Stoke-on-Trent was recognised by the Fairtrade Foundation as a “ Fairtrade City” and further resolves to continue its commitment and support for the work of the Foundation.” On being put to the vote, it was:-
On the Motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Mitchell, it was:
It was noted that Councillor Megan Ryan had replaced Councillor Irving as a member of the Conservative and Independent Alliance Political Group on this Committee.
Name Item Interest Nature Councillor Ross Irving (Item 48) – Review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence and Hackney Carriage Vehicle Licence ( Paras . 1 & 2) Personal and prejudicial Knew the licence holder and left the meeting whilst this item was under consideration.
( Councillor Ross Irving declared a personal and prejudicial interest and left the meeting whilst this item was being considered) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting the review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence and the review of a Hackney Carriage Vehicle Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
( Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting the review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence and the review of a Private Hire Vehicle Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
( Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting the determination of an application for the grant of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
Members Comments / Questions In response to a question, the Chair, Councillor Irving, explained his reasons for agreeing that the Cabinet consider the item as urgent i.e. in order to avoid any unnecessary delay and to enable the City Council to sign off expressions of interest.
The Council requests the Improving Communities Overview and Scrutiny committee to establish a Task and Finish group to consider the implications of the report and to review options for the structure of neighbourhood management and community engagement and requests the Cabinet not to implement the proposals until the Task and Finish Group have reported their findings” An amendment was moved by Councillor Irving, and seconded by Councillor Daniels, the effects of which would be that the motion would read as follows: “that the City Council notes the report considered by the Improving Communities Overview and Scrutiny Committee and supports the principle of improving customer service but expresses concern about the potential implications for customers. The Council to establishes a cross party working group plus the appropriate Cabinet member to consider the implications of the report and report back to the City Council as a matter of urgency, the aim to report to the City Council meeting scheduled for 1 st October 2009 and requests the Cabinet not to implement the proposals until the Working Group has reported its findings to the City Council.
( Councillor Ross Irving had to leave the meeting and took no part in the decision for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting the determination of an application for the grant of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
( Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting the review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
( Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting the review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence and the review of a Hackney Carriage Vehicle Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
( Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting the review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence and the review of a Private Hire Vehicle Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
The Leader, Councillor Irving, responded by explaining that the money was not available to invest in the type of things being suggested by [name removed], but was invested on a short term day to day basis to maximise potential income.
On the motion of Councillor Pervez , seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
Cabinet Nominations to Partnerships and Outside Bodies 2009/10 Organisation No. of Seats for Cabinet Nomination Cabinet Member(s) Term of Office Dependant on Post-Holder Ceramica Trust Board of Management 1 Councillor Lyth 2 years No Connexions Staffordshire 1 Councillor Mitchell 1 year No Local Government Association Urban Commission 1 Councillor Ward 1 year No LSP - Local Strategic Partnership Board 1 Councillor Irving 1 year Yes LSP - Children and Young People's Trust Board (Strategic Group) 1 Councillor Mitchell 1 year Yes LSP – Healthier Communities and Older People’s Board (Strategic Group) 1 Councillor Brian 1 year Yes LSP – Safer, Stronger, Greener Communities Partnership Group 1 Councillor Garner 1 year Yes LSP - Statutory Authorities Group (Strategic Group) 1 Councillor Follows 1 year Yes LSP - Strategic Policy and Investment Group of the North Staffordshire Regeneration Partnership (Strategic Group) 1 Councillor Lyth 1 year Yes North Staffordshire Regeneration Partnership Development Group 1 Councillor Ward 1 year Yes North Staffordshire Regeneration Partnership Board 3 Leader of the Council (Councillor irving ), Councillor Ward (Leader of the largest Group) and Councillor Lyth 1 year Yes Severn-Trent Regional Flood Defence Committee 1 Councillor Garner 4 years No Stoke-on-Trent Regeneration Limited Board 3 (1 director and 2 observers) Councillor Irving (Director), Councillors Lyth and Ward 1 year No Cabinet Nominations to joint Committees 2009/10 Organisation No.
( Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting the determination of an application for the grant of a private hire vehicle licence under the “Exceptional Condition” criteria.
( Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting the review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence and the review of a Private Hire Vehicle Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
Alan Turley reported on the City Council’s new governance arrangements, which had seen Councillor Ross Irving – Chair of the LSP Board – elected as Leader of the Council. Board Members were circulated a list of Cabinet Members who, together with the Leader, would make up the City Council’s Executive.
Board Members extended their congratulations and best wishes to Councillor Irving, who it was confirmed would remain as Chair of the LSP Board.
A site visit proposed by Councillor Irving and seconded by Councillor P Joynson in order ’to see the impact on the surrounding area’ was carried.
Moved by Councillor Ward, seconded by Councillor Irving, ‘that the best thanks of this Council are due and are hereby extended to Councillor Derek Capey for his invaluable services to this Council and to the City during the past year and to [name removed] for the admirable way in which she has performed the duties of Lady Mayoress ’.
Davis and seconded by Councillor Irving, ‘ that Councillor Denver Tolley be and is hereby appointed Deputy Lord Mayor of the City of Stoke-on-Trent and Vice Chairman of the Council for the ensuing municipal year’ .
A secret ballot was conducted in the Chamber and the results of each round were as follows:- Round 1: 57 Ballot Papers Issued (1 spoilt) Name of Candidate Number of Votes Councillor Michael Barnes 11 Councillor Ross Irving 16 Councillor Peter Kent- Baguley 6 Councillor Albert Walker 8 Councillor Brian Ward 15 No candidate had an absolute majority of votes. So Counillor Peter Kent-Baguley, who had the fewest votes, was eliminated.
Round 2: 57 Ballot Papers Issued (1 spoilt) Name of Candidate Number of Votes Councillor Michael Barnes 11 Councillor Ross Irving 16 Councillor Albert Walker 8 Councillor Brian Ward 21 No candidate had an absolute majority of votes. So Counillor Albert Walker, who had the fewest votes, was eliminated.
Round 3: 49 Ballot Papers Issued (1 spoilt) Name of Candidate Number of Votes Councillor Michael Barnes 9 Councillor Ross Irving 17 Councillor Brian Ward 22 No candidate had an absolute majority of votes. So Counillor Michael Barnes, who had the fewest votes, was eliminated.
Round 4: 49 Ballot Papers Issued (2 spoilt) Name of Candidate Number of Votes Councillor Ross Irving 26 Councillor Brian Ward 21 At the end of the fourth round, Councillor Ross Irving had an absolute majority and it was therefore:-
On the motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor J. Davis, it was:-
The Leader of the Council, Councillor Ross Irving, formally announced appointments to the Cabinet as follows:
On the motion of Councillor Tolley, seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Mitchell, seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Ward, it was:-
Members Comments/Questions Councillor Irving : Fully supported the comments made by Councillor Bell. He indicated that it would be wrong to offer an advantage to tenants in neighbouring authorities over tenants in Stoke-on-Trent and therefore the Council must ensure that the scheme introduced was right.
Councillor Irving: Welcomed the proposals which he believed would boost the city’s regeneration strategy.
Members Comments/Questions Councillor Irving: Welcomed the proposal as a good deal for the City.
Councillor Irving : Fully supported Councillor Salih’s request for information but commented that the questions asked at the call-in meeting were answered at that meeting and that action would be taken at the appropriate time to deal with issues as they arise.
Members Comments/Questions Councillor Irving : Commented that finances must be ring-fenced to cover the cost of support for all councillors and that it was essential that individual councillors , especially group leaders, received additional support.
On the motion of Councillor Garner, seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
Councillor Barnes moved, and Councillor Irving seconded, “ that the City Council notes the programme of action announced by the Government and the letter from the Electoral Commission.” An amendment was moved by Councillor Kent- Baguley , and seconded by Councillor A. Joynson , that the following words be added to the motion:- “ but expresses concern about the wider remit given to the Governance Transition Board to monitor performance of services, in view of the existing monitoring regime already in place through the Government Inspectorates, the Audit Commission and other regulators and the Council’s own Overview and Scrutiny Committees and Audit Committee; and requests the Minister to consider allowing the scheduled 2010 elections to take place.” On being put to the vote, the amendment was defeated.
Councillor Kent- Baguley moved and Councillor Irving seconded “ that the City Council accept the recommendations of the Independent Remuneration Panel, plus option (a) in respect of the travel and subsistence allowance, and amend the Constitution Part 6 – Member Allowances Scheme accordingly.” Following a debate on the motion, Councillor A.
On the Motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Mitchell, it was:
On the Motion of Councillor Barnes, seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:
This item was introduced by the Portfolio Holder, Councillor Irving and supported by members of the Board.
Councillor Irving : Asked about access on to A500 and David Stubbs indicated that negotiations were underway regarding this issue.
Councillor Irving : Agreed that initial consultation had been based on Trentham/Blurton Academy but his understanding was that the feedback had been positive and that the only argument, in his opinion, was the size of the school. The Director : Confirmed that this issue had been discussed at the Children and Young People’s Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting and confirmed that a public meeting had been held at Blurton High School at which time the community/governing body had been keen to move forward with an academy. The view was that there was not a significant change to the proposals and that those involved with Blurton were excited at the prospect of having a new school.
Councillor Irving asked if the numbers attending feeder schools were taken into account. The Director of Children and Young People’s Services confirmed that as part of the whole process, birth rates and migration in and out of the City were considered. He commented that as part of the Primary Capital Programme there had been the expansion and remodeling of some schools.
Members Comments / Questions Councillor Irving asked if any investment was going to be made in I.T.
Councillor Irving indicated that he fully supported the thesis outlined by the Chair, agreed that there should be no further delay to the process and suggested that the intervention of the Minister had opened up a new opportunity for Trentham High School, which the City Council had not previously been in a position to deliver and indicated that he welcomed the opportunity that this presented to Trentham High School. He expressed the view that it would have been helpful for the Minister to have made this position clearer sooner as he had changed his view substantially. He urged members of the Executive and Members Board to support option 2(b).
Members Comments/Questions Councillor Irving indicated that he welcomed these proposals and was aware that they were also supported by Ward Councillors .
Councillor Garner moved and Councillor Irving seconded, ‘that the persons referred to in the scheduled placed around the Chamber be appointed as the City Council representatives to serve on the Governing Bodies of the schools indicated’.
He moved ‘that the report be noted’, and the motion was subsequently seconded by Councillor Irving.
On the Motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Ibbs , it was:
Ali moved and Councillor Irving seconded that the minutes of the Standards Committee be noted.
Davis moved and Councillor Irving seconded that the minutes of the Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee be noted.
Councillor Irving agreed that it was important to get as wide a coverage as possible and suggested that the grants could be used to bolster the work that they couldn’t afford to do with just ward budgets.
Members Comments/Questions Councillor Irving referred to the complexity of the process and asked whether it would be possible to put something simple together to explain about the transfer of responsibilities as he felt that people needed to have an understanding of what was happening.
Councillor Irving welcomed the proposals and was joined in supportive comments by Councillors Clarke and Garner.
Councillor Irving moved and Councillor Garner seconded an amendment to the motion:
Councillor Irving moved and Councillor Mitchell seconded the following motion, which was carried unanimously:-
Councillor Irving in also welcoming the report felt that this problem could be exacerbated by the current economic climate. He also asked about the funding available and how it would be spent.
Councillor Irving asked if this work would link in with the Connexions service.
Councillor Irving expressed concern that the Children and Young People Overview and Scrutiny Committee had ignored legal advice in making the recommendation and commented that is was not possible to remove 1 school from the programme without delaying the entire scheme.
Councillor Irving commented that the City had always had a good record on the level of rent collection and felt that it was important that it was not allowed to deteriorate.
On the motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Knapper it was:-
The plan had been previously presented in detail to the LSP Board (2007), and the Chairs therefore agreed that the LSP Chair, Councillor Irving, could sign the endorsement on behalf of the Board.
Councillor Irving was of the view that the introduction of neighbourhood management had been a very positive development, welcoming the initiative to include partners in the call centre, and applauding the service’s recent performance improvements.
( Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Head of Citywide and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting the review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
( Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Head of Citywide and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting the review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence and Private Hire Vehicle Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
( Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Head of Citywide and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting consideration of an application for the Grant of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
On the motion of Councillor Pervez, seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
Councillor Irving, Portfolio Holder for Partnerships and Transformation, asked if there was any danger that the town hall building could form part of the asset for claw back if Ceramica folded.
Following a recruitment process during the summer, a total of two candidates were interviewed by a panel comprising the Monitoring Officer (Paul Hackney), the Vice Chair (Joan Carr) and Councillor Irving.
A motion moved by Councillor Irving and seconded by Councillor Tolley “that the item be deferred pending the outcome of a site inspection to better enable the Committee to visualize the site layout and to view the road proposals and environmental works”, was carried.
Councillor Irving commented that the football clubs should provide facilities to the Panel as they were carrying out a statutory duty.
A motion moved by Councillor Ross Irving and seconded by Councillor Joy Garner that “a further report be submitted to the next meeting of the Licensing and Consumer Protection Committee outlining the remit of the Sports Grounds Certification Panel”, was carried.
Councillor Irving voiced his concern on the significant number of people seen smoking whilst in commercial vehicles and suggested that a message be sent out to all members of staff reminding them of their responsibilities whilst using council vehicles.
( Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Community Services submitted a report requesting the determination of an application to continue to licence a private hire vehicle under the “Exceptional Condition” criteria.
( Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Community Services submitted a report requesting the review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence and Private Hire Vehicle Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
( Councillor Ross Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Community Services submitted a report requesting the review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
Councillor Irving moved and Councillor J. Bell seconded ‘that:- (i) City Council appoints one Councillor from the Longton North Ward and one Councillor from the Longton South Ward to serve on the (shadow) Longton Regeneration Company for the term of four municipal years.
On the motion of Councillor Barnes, seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
Davis and Councillor Irving seconded that the minutes of the Licensing Consumer Protection meeting be noted.
Councillor Irving moved and Councillor M. Davis seconded that the minutes of the Standards Committee meeting be noted.
A motion was moved by Councillor Irving and seconded by Councillor Brian to approve the application subject to a Section 106 agreement to include that investigation/consideration be given to the adoption of the 2-metre strip to the rear of the plots adjoining the footpath alongside the River Trent.
A Motion, moved by Councillor Irving and seconded by Councillor Brian, to refuse the application for the following reason was carried:
A motion, moved by Councillor Irving, and seconded by Councillor Ward, that consideration of the application be deferred pending a site visit to enable Members to envisage the proximity of the proposed wind turbine to surrounding properties’, was carried.
Councillor Irving welcomed that the strategy was being looked at on a conurbation wide basis and felt that partnership arrangements with the neighbouring authorities was vital.
Councillor Irving welcomed the report but sought assurances on the timescales of clearance and future development.
Members’ Questions/Comments Councillor Irving referred to the need to dispose of the properties as soon as possible.
Members’ Comments/Questions In response to a question from Councillor Irving with regard to the after-use of the site, Steve Wilds confirmed that the site would be disposed of and that the Planning Section had already looked at the site and would see to get the best value for the site which would be re-invested in Council property.
This item was introduced by Councillor Irving, Portfolio Holder for Partnership and Transformation.
Councillor Irving indicated that he did not recognise these comments as Board meetings were open to the public to attend.
Councillor Barnes explained that he was referring to the pillar groups and Councillor Irving expressed surprise at Councillor Barnes’ experience, indicating that minutes be made available and that Councillor Barnes could submit questions on his behalf in which he could get answers on.
The Chair extended his congratulations and thanks to Councillor Irving for taking on the role of Chair of the LSP and agreed that things had moved on in terms of member accountability. He also indicated that the City Council was not recognised as the lead partner in the LSP.
Councillor Irving moved and Councillor Garner seconded “that the persons referred to in the schedule now placed around the Chamber be appointed as the City Council representatives to serve on the outside bodies listed, for the terms of office specified in that schedule (unless they should cease to be a councillor)”.
Councillor Irving also referred to consultation with the Planning Department and suggested that officers from Regulatory Services convey the committees concerns to Government and request that Regulatory Services become a statutory consultee with regard to air quality control when processing planning applications. All members of the committee agreed with this recommendation.
A Motion, moved by Councillor Kent- Baguley and seconded by Councillor Irving, to approve the officer’s recommendation, as outlined in the report now submitted and subject to amendments to conditions as outlined at the meeting, with the exception of Condition 10, which should remain as Condition 10 as outlined within the report, and subject to the inclusion of the word ‘brick’ after ‘boundary’, was carried.
Felstead , the applicant’s agent.) A Motion, moved by Councillor Ward and seconded by Councillor Irving, that the application be deferred for a site visit as Members were unable to visualise the impact on surrounding properties, was carried.
A Motion, moved by Councillor Irving and seconded by Councillor Brian, that the application be deferred for a site visit to enable closer inspection of the details of window design and material quality within the application, was carried.
Moved by Councillor Ward seconded by Councillor Irving, ‘that Councillor D. Capey be and is hereby elected Lord Mayor of the City of Stoke-on-Trent and Chairman of the Council for the ensuing municipal year’.
( Councillor Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Community Services submitted a report requesting the determination of an application for the variation of the terms and conditions of a Sex Establishment Licence .
( Councillor Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Community Services submitted a report requesting consideration of the revocation of a Hackney Carriage/Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
A motion, moved by Councillor Irving and seconded by Councillor Sandland , ‘that it was not expedient to take enforcement action’, was carried.
Councillor Irving suggested that separate reports should be adopted for regulatory and all other meetings.
Councillor Irving moved and Councillor Garner seconded “that the persons referred to in the schedule now placed around the Chamber be appointed as City Council representatives to serve on the outside bodies listed for the remainder of the municipal year.” On being put to the vote, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Barnes, it was:
Councillor Irving referred to the City Council having to hire buses, etc., in order to enable site inspections, etc., to take place and asked if consideration had been given to investigating whether it would be more cost effective to purchase a vehicle(s) for this purpose.
Councillor Irving welcomed the report, pointing out that this was an example of us working in partnership with Staffordshire County Council. He suggested that it may be useful to organise a meeting between the City and County Councils so that members could be provided with more detail regarding the partnership and what it does. He hoped that such an invitation would be sent to all City Councillors.
Councillor Irving agreed with these comments and felt that their impact had been substantial, particularly as the reductions in road traffic accidents had been achieved during a period when the number of vehicles on our roads had increased. He referred to the good road traffic accident record of our country compared to other European countries.
Members Questions/Comments Councillor Irving referred to the amount of work put in by the Sub-Group of the Schools Forum which had been established to look at this issue and confirmed that it had been an arduous task for all involved and that he would like to personally thank all those involved.
Councillor Irving felt that the proposals were very wide ranging and referred to Appendix A of the report and suggested that, if we were now going to be taking action as suggested within the report that the City Council should ensure that it was properly publicised to the public so that people were aware in advance of what would be happening.
Regarding the reorganisation of secondary schools, Councillor Irving was of the view that the issue needed to be tackled city-wide.
([name removed] , the applicant’s agent and [name removed], the agent on behalf of Mr and [name removed], addressed the meeting.) A Motion, moved by Councillor Brian and seconded by Councillor Irving,” that the application be approved, subject to appropriate conditions, as it is considered that the property as built does not have a sufficiently adverse impact on the amenity of the adjoining bungalow, No. 632, to be contrary to Policy HP3 of the City Plan”, was carried on the Chairs casting vote.
Councillor Irving referred to the visit to Liverpool made by the task and finish group to see how they had dealt with this issue. He indicated that there were issues with regard to staffing levels/resources and how we dealt with the issues around the disposal of land.
(The applicant addressed the Committee.) A Motion, moved by Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Owen, ‘that to improve the visual amenity and, due to the problem nature of the site and its sustainable position in transport and amenity terms, Members are mindful to approve the development of a single dwelling, subject to conditions to be reported back to Committee’, was carried.
A Motion, moved by Councillor Brian, seconded by Councillor Irving, ‘to approve the application, subject to conditions to be reported back to the Committee on the grounds that they do not regard the application to be so out of character as to justify refusal’, was lost.
A motion moved by Councillor Irving and seconded by Councillor Brian that “ the application be approved, subject to the following conditions”, was agreed.
On the motion of Councillor Garner, seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:
With reference to the minutes of the meeting of the General Purposes Committee held on 28 November 2007, Councillor Irving moved and Councillor Tappin seconded the proposals for the transfer of ownership of Swann House, Boothen Road, Stoke, from Stoke Civic Properties Ltd to the City Council, as set out in the minutes.
Councillor Irving, as a member of the Task and Finish Group, explained that the review had been a lengthy one which had lasted over 12 months and as the review progressed, the task increased.
Councillor Irving added that, in his opinion, the City Council did not have enough staff to provide the services required for disposing of land and therefore the present problems would not be solved over night. He thanked his fellow members of the Task and Finish Group along with the City Council officers. Comments from Committee Members:
Representations were made to the Committee by [name removed] , the applicant.) It was proposed by Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Ward, that the application be deferred for a site visit as the plans do not effectively indicate the relationship of the applicant’s property to its neighbours. On being put to the vote, the proposed to defer was carried.
Councillor Irving suggested that we were half way down this journey, that massive progress had been made but that we had not received the recognition that we would have hoped for. The Chair felt that the thanks of the Executive and Members Board should be conveyed to all the staff involved in this for their hard work and service.
Councillor Irving agreed that it was a very positive report but the recommendation showed that there were still some problem areas which needed to be addressed. He extended his congratulations to the ‘Aiming Higher’ project which had increased the take-up of higher education in the City. However, he did refer to poor behaviour still affecting standards in some secondary schools, which was an area of concern.
Councillor Irving indicated that he understood that public consultation had taken place but that he was concerned with regard to press reports about the fact that some businesses in the area would be affected by these proposals. Stuart Davies explained that, first of all, the emphasis in relation to this report was about restricted access rather than closure.
In response to a question asked by Councillor Irving, he confirmed that no additional weighting had been given to the responses made to businesses but explained that it was a predominantly residential area. He acknowledged that there would be a downside for businesses in the area in the sense that there would be less through traffic. However, he felt that this was one situation where it would not be possible to satisfy everyone but felt that, nevertheless, what was being put forward was appropriate.
( Councillor Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Community Services submitted a report requesting consideration of the revocation of a Hackney Carriage/Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
( Councillor Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Community Services submitted a report requesting consideration of the revocation of a Hackney Carriage/Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence and the revocation of a Private Hire Vehicle Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
A Motion, moved by Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Pervez , “that the relevant Portfolio Holder (as identified as Councillor Lyth ) be appointed as the City Council representative to serve on the Joint Venture Company Board of Directors”.
In response to a question from Councillor Irving, Portfolio Holder for Community Partnerships, [name removed] confirmed that once the CPS had made a decision not to prosecute that would be final; the CPS was the final arbiter. However the right to institute a private prosecution would remain.
Councillor Irving, Portfolio Holder for Community Partnerships, stated that the under-funding of the Drug and Alcohol Action Team had been an issue for some years.
Members, however, had concerns that the applicant would be unable to comform with the requirements of the Section 106 Agreement and a motion moved by Councillor Irving and seconded by Councillor Owen that the application be deferred to allow for further discussions was agreed.
A motion was proposed by Councillor Irving and seconded by Councillor Owen that the application was deferred for a site inspection was agreed.
At the invitation of the Chair, Councillor Irving, Portfolio Holder for Partnerships, enquired if anyone had consulted with Renew for funding.
A further motion, moved by Councillor Irving and seconded by Councillor Knapper , ‘that Sid Bourne of 65 Woodhead Road, Abbey Hulton, Stoke-on-Trent, be appointed as the City Council’s representative to serve on the Joiners Square Community Hall Management Committee for the remainder of the municipal year’, was carried.
On the motion of Councillor Shotton , seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
Councillor James moved and Councillor Irving seconded that the minutes of the Improving Communities Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting held on 26 July be noted.
(The Applicants’ Agent, [name removed], addressed the Committee in respect of this item.) A Motion, moved by Councillor Irving, seconded by the Vice-Chair (Councillor Joynson ) “that the application be approved” was lost.
A Motion, moved by Councillor Mitchell, seconded by Councillor Irving “that the application be deferred to allow further discussion with the applicant” was carried.
( Councillor Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Community Services submitted a report requesting the consideration of the revocation of a Hackney Carriage/Private Hire Vehicle Drivers Licence , which had disclosed matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
( Councillor Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Community Services submitted a report requesting the determination of an application for the grant of a Hackney Carriage/Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence , which had disclosed matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
A motion moved by Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Bate “that the application be deferred pending a site inspection to enable members to better visualise the visual amenity issues” was carried.
A motion moved by Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Ward “that the application be deferred pending a site inspection in order to enable members to understand the visual amenity issues”.
(Councillor Irving was not in attendance for this item) The Director of Community Services submitted a report requesting consideration of the revocation of a Hackney Carriage/Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel.
On the motion of Councillor Brian, seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Joynson, seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
Councillor Irving enquired if the police community support officers were free-standing or working with police neighbourhood officers. In response, Adrian Bloor confirmed that although a police constable and a police community support officer may be working on the same problem the police community support officers are isolated out and the statistics are specific to them.
Councillor Irving commented that the City Council had tried in the past to achieve savings and had not been very successful and that the Star Chamber was part of the process introduced to attempt to do this more successfully in the future.
Julie Seddon added that members identifying areas such as this would provide good member feedback into budget consultation Councillor Irving commented that the decisions as to where and why cameras are sited needs to be investigated further. He added that there was no chance of his ward, Hanford, receiving a CCTV camera and that residents did not regard it beneficial to have a CCTV camera sited outside Trentham Gardens, as this was for national registration recognition purposes and not for crime detection.
43/04 RH - Enson Works Longton Councillor Brian referred to his previous concerns over the start-up facilities for new businesses and added that he was pleased that John Gething now had this matter in hand. 58/06 RH – Infrastructure Improvements – Hanford Incinerator – Household Waste Site Councillor Irving enquired what the cost implications were. In response, the Chair confirmed that the improvements were linked to access of the site and transportation issues.
Councillor Irving welcomed the scheme and indicated that this was an excellent example of a Section 106 Agreement benefiting residents and the local community.
Councillor Irving confirmed that this report had been submitted to and approved by the Schools’ Forum.
Gibson on behalf of the City Council, addressed the Committee in respect of this item.) A Motion, moved by Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Ward “that the application be approved subject to an additional condition requiring a scheme to be submitted showing the tactile crossing point on Union Street to be retained as existing and an amendment to condition 4 to make specific reference to the memorial tree on the grounds of road safety and vehicle visibility issue” was carried
Councillor Ibbs then moved, and Councillor Irving seconded, that the Performance Plan 2007/08 be approved.
On the motion of Councillor Ibbs , seconded by Councillor Irving, it was:-
Councillor Irving submitted a report on three meetings of the Development Control Committee which were held on 20 April and 2 and 23 May 2007. He confirmed that during those meetings, 13 planning applications had been approved, two telecommunications applications had been granted, site visits had been agreed for three applications and enforcement action had been agreed in respect of land to the rear of 89 Austin Street, Hanley, and land opposite Drawbridge Cottage, Canalside , Norton.
On the motion of Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Ibbs , it was:-
Councillor Tolley moved, and Councillor Irving seconded, that the report of the Chair of the Licensing and Consumer Protection Committee in respect of a meeting held on 16 May 2007 be noted.
Type of Interest Nature of Interest Councillor Bate 4 Personal Acquaintance of the Applicant Councillor Irving 4 Personal Acquaintance of the Applicant
A Motion, moved by Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Brian “that the application be approved subject to additional conditions for ( i ) landscaping and maintenance, (ii) removal of balconies at rear (third floor level) and (iii) revised internal layout (third floor) on the grounds that the new proposals will remove concerns of residents regarding privacy and overlooking of neighbouring properties” was carried.
A Motion, moved by Councillor Irving, seconded by Councillor Mitchell “that the application be refused on the grounds of loss of amenity for the immediate neighbouring property and serious potential noise problems to the neighbouring bedroom area and inadequate parking arrangements” was carried.
Councillor Irving commented that the reviews appeared to be conducted in a piecemeal road by road approach. The Chief Executive confirmed that the reviews were not piecemeal and were part of a bigger picture.
Councillor Irving expressed concern that the City Council was to fund the £250,000 required to alleviate the future risk of flooding. Brian Davies indicated that this amount was probably the sum set aside for future maintenance. Mayor Meredith confirmed that further details would be brought to a future meeting.
Councillor Irving welcomed the work done by the Group but commented that the problem was the design of the City itself. He added that one solution to the problem would be to introduce the Park and Ride system into the suburbs and to ensure that there was adequate parking at the base which was cheap or free and that regular buses were scheduled.
Councillor Irving welcomed the report and added that this concept was very imaginative and was the way forward. He hoped that this model would be progressed in other parts of the City.
Councillor Irving welcomed this decision as a step in the right direction towards modernising the service for the public.
Councillor Irving echoed Councillor Capey’s sentiments and added that the ultimate responsibility is still with the parents. He welcomed the proposals to monitor on a daily basis. Mayor Meredith commented that although it was important to give powers to the Police, there were other intervention measures such as behaviour contracts and the involvement of the Youth Service.
As this was the last meeting of the Licensing and Registration Panel for this municipal year, Councillor Irving expressed his thanks to the Chair, Councillor Joy Garner, for her commitment and professionalism at the meetings over the previous 12 months.
Showing the latest 300 of 319.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Irving attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Irving's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Irving was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 9 of 15 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Irving declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 18 Aug 2009 | Licensing and Registration Panel, item 48 | ( Councillor Ross Irving declared a personal and prejudicial interest and left the meeting whilst this item was being considered) The Director of Housing, Environmental and Neighbourhood Services submitted a report requesting the review of a Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Driver’s Licence and the review of a Hackney Carriage Vehicle Licence following the disclosure of matters requiring the consideration of the Panel. | Left the room |
Where Councillor Irving sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| City Council | Committee Member | Mar 2007 | 26 | 17 Dec 2026 |
| Licensing Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2008 | 7 | 23 Nov 2026 |
| Planning Committee - Development Management | Committee Member | Jun 2015 | 6 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| Audit and Standards Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2026 | 3 | |
| Licensing and Appeals Committee | Committee Member | May 2026 | 2 | |
| Licensing and Registration Panel | Committee Member | Mar 2007 | 55 | |
| (archived) Development Control Committee | Vice-Chair | Apr 2007 | 32 | |
| (archived) Executive and Members Board | Cabinet Member | Apr 2007 | 29 | |
| Cabinet | Cabinet Member | Apr 2010 | 11 | |
| (archived) Councillors Forum | Committee Member | Sep 2007 | 8 | |
| Local Strategic Partnership Board | Chair | Jan 2008 | 7 | |
| (archived) Standards Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2008 | 4 | |
| (archived) Licensing and Consumer Protection Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2008 | 4 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee | Cabinet Member | Feb 2007 | 3 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Transformation and Resources | Cabinet Member | Dec 2007 | 3 | |
| (archived) Standards Committee - Referrals Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Aug 2008 | 3 | |
| (archived) Human Resources Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2010 | 3 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Health | Cabinet Member | Jun 2007 | 2 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Improving Communities | Cabinet Member | Oct 2007 | 2 | |
| (archived) Standards Committee - Review Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Dec 2008 | 2 | |
| (archived) Administration and Appeals Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2010 | 2 | |
| (archived) General Purposes Committee | Observer | Oct 2007 | 1 | |
| (archived) Standards Committee - Hearings Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Nov 2008 | 1 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - City Renewal | Committee Member | Oct 2015 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.