Disclosure of Interest
Application 21/00204/FUL – Councillor Cargill disclosed that he had been unable to attend the arranged site visit so had visited the sites of his own accord.
Every time Stratford-on-Avon's minutes name Councillor Cargill, as the council published it.
Application 21/00204/FUL – Councillor Cargill disclosed that he had been unable to attend the arranged site visit so had visited the sites of his own accord.
Having considered the application and the representations made at the meeting, a Motion of GRANT, subject to the conditions/notes detailed below, for the following reasons, was proposed by Councillor Edden and seconded by Councillor Cargill.
Having considered the application and the representations made at the meeting, a Motion of GRANT, in accordance with the recommendation detailed in the report and subject to an additional condition regarding bound surface of the track and an amendment to condition 8 as detailed below , was proposed by Councillor Parry and seconded by Councillor Cargill.
Having considered the application and the representations made at the meeting, a Motion of GRANT, in accordance with the recommendation detailed in the report with an additional condition, was proposed by Councillor Cargill and seconded by Councillor Harvey. By 5 votes in favour to 6 votes against, this proposal fell.
Subsequently, a motion of REFUSE, for the reasons detailed below, was proposed by Councillor Cargill and seconded by Councillor Parry.
Note: Councillor Cargill left the meeting during this item.
Councillor Cargill – Minute 423 - disclosed that he was a Member of the Greig Hall Working Group and a Member of Alcester Town Council.
Subsequently, a motion to GRANT, subject to finalising a phasing strategy, including an overall phasing plan and completion of a legal agreement in accordance with the recommendation detailed in the report , was proposed by Councillor Cargill and seconded by Councillor Parry.
APPLICANT Mr and [name removed] and Mary Holbert SPEAKERS Cllr A Prior – Wellesbourne and Walton Parish Council – Objecting [name removed] – on behalf of the applicant ([name removed] – to answer wuestions only) Cllr Parry - District Council Ward Member Having considered the application and the representations made at the meeting a motion to DEFER, in order to conduct a site visit, for the reasons listed below, was proposed by Councillor Cargill and seconded by Councillor O’Donnell:
Consequently, a motion to DEFER was proposed by Councillor Kendall and seconded by Councillor Cargill.
APPLICANT [name removed] 6 Butchers Close, Bishops Itchington CV47 2PX PROPOSAL Single Storey Side Extension SPEAKERS None Having considered the application and the representations made at the meeting a motion of GRANT, in accordance with the recommendation detailed in the report, was proposed by Councillor Brain and seconded by Councillor Cargill.
Having considered the application and the representations made at the meeting a motion of GRANT was proposed by Councillor Richards and seconded by Councillor Cargill.
Thereafter a motion of GRANT was proposed by Councillor Feilding and seconded by Councillor Cargill.
Minute 477 Councillor Payne, Ward Member Minute 477 Councillor Cargill indicated he had pre-determined this application and would take no part in the consideration of the application.
Note: In accordance with the above, Councillor Cargill had indicated he would vacate the Chair for this item and in the absence of the Vice-Chairman, the Chairman proposed that Councillor Lawton take the Chair for this item only.
in respect of Application 17/01730/LBC a motion of GRANT, was proposed by Councillor Cargill and seconded by Councillor Feilding Thereafter, by unanimous votes, it was
Having considered the application and the representations made at the meeting a motion of GRANT was proposed by Councillor Cargill and seconded by Councillor Feilding.
Councillor Cargill in accordance with Minute 471 above withdrew from the table and took no part in the consideration of the application.
Having considered the application and the representations made at the meeting a motion of GRANT, was proposed by Councillor Cargill and seconded by Councillor Barnes.
Having considered the application and the representations made at the meeting a motion of GRANT, was proposed by Councillor Parry and seconded by Councillor Cargill.
Having considered the application and the representations made at the meeting a motion of GRANT, was proposed by Councillor Brain and seconded by Councillor Cargill.
Having regard to the foregoing, a motion that the application be DEFERRED to enable the correct photographs to be included in the presentation pack, was proposed by Councillor Crump and seconded by Councillor Cargill.
Subsequently, a motion of REFUSE was proposed by Councillor Giles and seconded by Councillor Cargill.
Having considered the application and the representations made at the meeting a motion of GRANT, in accordance with the recommendation detailed in the report and update report and subject to additional amendments to conditions 40 and 42, was proposed by Councillor Gittus and seconded by Councillor Cargill.
Councillor Cargill, as Chairman of Planning Committee West, concurred that the Chairman’s Briefing meetings were designed to tease out any technical issues that may arise during the consideration of the application.
Having considered the application and the representations made at the meeting a motion of DEFER was proposed by Councillor Pemberton and seconded by Councillor Cargill to seek further clarification on the impact on neighbouring property.
Councillor Cargill and Pemberton – Application 15/011897/OUT – Ward Members Councillor Richards disclosed an Interest in Application 15/02164/LBC as the applicant was a close personal friend and indicated he would not take in the consideration of the application.
Having considered the application and the representations made at the meeting a motion of REFUSE was proposed by Councillor Pemberton and seconded by Councillor Cargill.
Councillor Cargill disclosed that he had received a letter from the applicant in respect of application 15/01847/VARY.
Having considered the application and the representations made at the meeting a motion that the application be DEFERRED to enable a Site Visit to be undertaken was proposed by Councillor Cargill and seconded by Councillor Lawton.
Having considered the application a motion that the application be WITHDRAWN from the Agenda and be REFUSED by the officers under delegated powers was proposed by Councillor Cargill and seconded by Councillor Richards.
At the invitation of The Leader, Councillor Cargill addressed the meeting to raise his concerns over the figures used for the evidence base for Alcester and requested that this be investigated this further. In considering the options The Cabinet acknowledged that:
SPEAKERS Councillor Cargill – Alcester Town Council – objecting Cllr Adams (District Councillor Ward Member, representing all three Ward members) Updates since the preparation of the Officer’s report were circulated to the Committee as set out on the attached sheet.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Cargill attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17 Oct 2022 | Council | Proposed Changes to Planning Delegations | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 7 Sep 2016 | Planning Committee (West) | Application No. 16/01505/FUL - Haven Pastures, Liveridge Hill, Henley-in-Arden | Carried | 4 for, 3 against | |
| 12 Aug 2015 | Planning Committee (East) | Application No. 15/00897/OUT - Insight Park , Welsh Road East, Southam, Warwickshire CV47 1NE | 3 for, 3 against, 1 abstained |
Meetings Councillor Cargill was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
No meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Cargill declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7 Dec 2022 | Planning Committee, item 442 | Application 21/00204/FUL – Councillor Cargill disclosed that he had been unable to attend the arranged site visit so had visited the sites of his own accord. | |
| 26 Aug 2015 | Planning Committee (West), item 270 | Councillor Cargill disclosed that he had received a letter from the applicant in respect of application 15/01847/VARY. |
Where Councillor Cargill sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planning Committee (West) | Chairman | Jun 2014 | 29 | |
| Council | Chairman | Sep 2014 | 16 | |
| The Cabinet | Observers | Sep 2014 | 11 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | May 2016 | 11 | |
| Planning Committee (East) | Substitute | Aug 2015 | 7 | |
| Regulatory Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2014 | 6 | |
| Employment and Appointments Committee | Committee Member | May 2018 | 3 | |
| Planning Committee (Cross Boundary) | Committee Member | Nov 2015 | 2 | |
| Planning Committee | Substitute | Oct 2022 | 2 | |
| Licensing Panel | Committee Member | Dec 2015 | 1 | |
| Housing Investment Panel | Committee Member | Dec 2018 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.