Questions to the Leader
Councillor Bromwich asked:
Every time Stratford-on-Avon's minutes name Councillor Bromwich, as the council published it.
Councillor Bromwich asked:
Councillor Bromwich asked:
APPLICATION SITE Warwickshire Police Authority, Southam Police Station, High Street, Southam CV47 0HB PROPOSAL Redevelopment of site including demolition of existing building to provide specialised supported housing (SSH) accommodation comprising 21 self-contained one-bedroom apartments (Use Class C3(b)), together with associated parking, open space and landscaping APPLICANT [name removed] – HBV Group SPEAKERS Andrew Crump - On behalf of Southam Town Council – Objecting Michael Gilbert - Agent Cllr Bromwich - District Council Ward Member Updates since the preparation of the Officer’s report were circulated to the Committee as set out on the attached sheet.
Members’ Basic Allowance The following motion was proposed by Councillor Harvey and seconded by Councillor Bromwich.
Councillor Bromwich asked:
Application TPO/085/015 (SDC 753) – Councillor Keighley disclosed that he had received an email from the Ward Member, Councillor Bromwich, requesting a deferral of the application. Following advice from the Planning Manager, it was confirmed that there was no case for a deferral and that the application would be considered by the Committee.
Councillor Bromwich asked:
Amendment 1 For the proposal 10 votes (namely, Councillors Crump, Fleming, Harvey, Littlewood, Mills, Organ, Scorer, Shenton, Stanley and Whalley-Hoggins) Against the proposal 26 votes (namely, Councillors Alcock, J Fradgley, Adam, Coles, Cowcher, Curtis, I Fradgley, Gist, Grocott, Harding, Harmer, Hatch, Hencher-Serafin, Holmes, Johnston, Juned, Keighley, Ostrander, Padgham, Parker, Passingham, Perteghella, Petrovic, Rice, Rolfe and Skinner) Abstentions 1 vote (namely, Councillor Bromwich) Amendment 2.1 For the proposal 10 votes (namely, Councillors Crump, Fleming, Harvey, Littlewood, Mills, Organ, Scorer, Shenton, Stanley and Whalley-Hoggins) Against the proposal 23 votes (namely, Councillors Alcock, J Fradgley, Adam, Coles, Cowcher, Curtis, I Fradgley, Gist, Grocott, Harding, Harmer, Hencher-Serafin, Holmes, Johnston, Juned, Keighley, Ostrander, Padgham, Perteghella, Petrovic, Rice, Rolfe and Skinner) Abstentions 4 votes (namely, Councillors Bromwich, Hatch, Parker and Passingham) Amendment 2.2 For the proposal 10 votes (namely, Councillors Crump, Fleming, Harvey, Littlewood, Mills, Organ, Scorer, Shenton, Stanley and Whalley-Hoggins) Against the proposal 26 votes (namely, Councillors Alcock, J Fradgley, Adam, Coles, Cowcher, Curtis, I Fradgley, Gist, Grocott, Harding, Harmer, Hatch, Hencher-Serafin, Holmes, Johnston, Juned, Keighley, Ostrander, Padgham, Parker, Passin
The Leader hoped that these initiatives would assist Councillor Bromwich to continue to support the residents of his ward.
Could the Leader confirm that the decision to sell the Grange in Southam was not taken by the previous administration, but in fact the administration of 2015-2019, at the meeting of The Cabinet held on 10 September 2018, and request that Councillor Bromwich withdraw his assertion that there was any understanding or undertaken given contrary to the terms of the Minutes of that meeting?
Councillor Bromwich asked:
Councillor Bromwich asked: According to the Constitution of Stratford District Council we elect a Chairman each year. This position is regardless of gender or what sex is written on one’s birth certificate. Over many years there has been both male and female occupants as Chairman of Stratford District Council, this has never been an issue for any of those occupants.
Thank you for your question Councillor Bromwich.
Councillor Grocott – Environmental and Neighbourhood Services Portfolio Prior to consideration of this item, it was noted that an email had been received from Councillor Bromwich, which had been circulated to all members of The Cabinet. The Environmental and Neighbourhood Services Portfolio Holder agreed to respond to the email following the meeting.
APPLICATION SITE 5 Hillyard Road, Southam CV47 0LA PROPOSAL Subdivision of existing residential plot and the creation of one additional three-bed detached dwelling with associated parking APPLICANT [name removed] Roland Lloyd-Thomas - Agent *The Chairman read out a statement from Councillor Bromwich, District Council Ward Member, who could not attend the meeting.
Councillor Bromwich asked:
Councillor Bromwich asked:
The Leader thanked Councillor Bromwich for his thoughtful observations and assured him that this Council would do what it could for its residents. The Leader reinforced that the cost of living crisis was, indeed, very serious and would most likely worsen with the Energy Price Cap coming into force in September 2022. With other prices escalating, the Leader forecast that the vast majority of people would be poorer next year than they were this year.
Councillor Bromwich asked:
Councillor Bromwich asked:
Note: At this point Councillor Bromwich disclosed that he was a licensed Dual Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Driver.
An amendment was proposed by Councillor Bromwich which was seconded by Councillor Juned, that the Motion be referred to the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, to review the report from Warwickshire County Council on Food Poverty and to establish a Task and Finish Group to give consideration to what the District Council could put in place to supplement the County Council’s work, that did not duplicate it.
For the proposal (namely, the Chairman, Councillors Fitter, Cargill, Crump, Feilding, Fleming, Forman, Harvey, Jennings, Kettle, Mills, O’Donnell, Parry, Pemberton, Richards, Shenton and Whalley-Hoggins) Against the proposal ( namely , Councillors Adam, Alcock, Cleeve, Curtis, Edden, Fojtik, I Fradgley, J Fradgley, Hencher-Serafin, Juned, Perteghella, Riley, Rock and Rolfe) Abstentions ( namely , Councillor Bromwich) Following which, it was
Councillor Bromwich asked:
For the proposal 20 votes (namely, the Chairman, Councillors Barker, Cargill, Feilding, Fitter, Fleming, Forman, Harris, Harvey, Jefferson, Jennings, Kendall, Kettle, Mills, O’Donnell, Parry, Pemberton, Richards, Shenton and Whalley-Hoggins) Against the proposal 14 votes (namely, Adam, Alcock, Cleeve, Curtis, Edden, Fojtik, I Fradgley, J Fradgley, Hencher-Serafin, Juned, Perteghella, Riley, Rock and Rolfe) Abstentions 1 vote ( namely , Councillor Bromwich) Thereafter, it was
For the proposal 22 votes (namely, the Chairman, Councillors Barker, Cargill, Feilding, Fitter, Fleming, Fojtik, Forman, Harris, Harvey, Jefferson, Jennings, Kendall, Kettle, Mills, O’Donnell, Parry, Pemberton, Richards, Riley, Shenton and Whalley-Hoggins) Against the proposal 12 votes (namely, Councillors Adam, Alcock, Cleeve, Curtis, Edden, I Fradgley, J Fradgley, Hencher-Serafin, Juned, Perteghella, Rock and Rolfe) Abstentions 1 vote (namely, Councillor Bromwich) Accordingly, it was
For the Resolution 32 votes (namely, the Chairman, Councillors Adam, Alcock, Barker, Cargill, Cleeve, Curtis, Edden, Feilding, Fitter, Fleming, Fojtik, Forman, I Fradgley, J Fradgley, Harvey, Hencher-Serafin, Jennings, Juned, Kendall, Kettle, Mills, O’Donnell, Parry, Pemberton, Perteghella, Richards, Riley, Rock, Rolfe, Shenton and Whalley-Hoggins) Abstentions 1 vote ( namely , Councillor Bromwich) Note: Although in attendance at the meeting, due to a loss of internet connection at that point in time, Councillor Harris’ vote was not recorded.
Councillor Tony Bromwich asked:
The Chief Executive read out a supplementary question on behalf of Councillor Bromwich.
In response, Councillor Shenton acknowledged the concerns raised by Councillor Bromwich noting that the operational and contractual details of the policy would be addressed further along in the process.
Councillor Tony Bromwich asked:
An amendment to accept the proposal, subject to a review in six months, to incorporate consultation between Officers and Members to examine the performance and efficiency of the Committee, was proposed by Councillor Bromwich and seconded by Councillor Riley. This proposal was not supported.
APPLICATION SITE Acorn Stores, 75 - 76 Coventry Street, Southam CV47 0EA PROPOSAL Fascia signs and projector APPLICANT Heart of England Co-Operative SPEAKERS Tony Asbury - Applicant Statement from Cllr Bromwich - District Council Ward Member Having considered the application and the representations made at the meeting, a motion of GRANT, in accordance with the recommendation detailed in the report, was proposed by Councillor Harvey and seconded by Councillor Kettle.
APPLICANT Sandeep Singh & Hayley Connolly SPEAKERS Cllr Mike Brooks – Southam Town Council - Objecting Cllr Bromwich - District Council Ward Member Updates since the preparation of the Officer’s report were circulated to the Committee, as set out on the attached sheet and the case officer confirmed that a Members’ site visit had taken place on the afternoon of the meeting.
APPLICATION SITE Lilley Meadow, Solus Gardens, Southam PROPOSAL Erection of 10 dwellings (Use class C3) and associated parking, landscaping, public open space and ancillary infrastructure APPLICANT Owl Homes Ltd SPEAKERS Michael Boswell - Resident - Objecting John Williams - Agent Cllr Bromwich - District Council Ward Member Updates since the preparation of the Officer’s report were circulated to the Committee as set out on the attached sheet.
Councillor Bromwich disclosed that he was a dual Hackney Carriage and Private Hire licence holder.
APPLICANT Heart Of England Co-operative Group SPEAKERS Jonathan Bush – (on behalf of residents) Objecting Tony Aspbury – Agent Cllr Bromwich - District Council Ward Member Updates since the preparation of the Officer’s report were circulated to the Committee as set out on the attached sheet.
Councillor Bromwich asked:
Councillor Bromwich raised a question on Member training hours.
That he would discuss the matter with Councillor Bromwich outside of the meeting.
APPLICANT Avenue Properties (Warwickshire) SPEAKERS Cllr Bromwich - District Council Ward Member A site visit was held on 20 January 2020 which was attended by the Ward Member.
Councillor Bromwich asked:
Councillor Bromwich disclosed a personal interest at this juncture as a licensed taxi driver .
APPLICATION SITE The Grange, Coventry Road, Southam CV47 1QB PROPOSAL Engineering works to widen two access points onto the public highway and to widen small sections of the internal driveway through the site to Grange Hall APPLICANT Stratford-on-Avon District Council SPEAKERS Cllr Andrew Walster – Southam Town Council – Objecting Tony Perks (on behalf of the Applicant) Cllr Bromwich - District Council Ward Member (statement read out by the Chairman) Updates since the preparation of the Officer’s report were circulated to the Committee as set out on the attached sheet.
Finally, it was proposed and agreed that Councillor Bromwich be appointed as an outside body representative to The Grange Hall, Southam .
Councillor Bromwich asked:
APPLICATION SITE 14 Heather Close, Southam , CV47 1ER PROPOSAL Proposed side and rear extensions APPLICANT [name removed] Bromwich* - District Council Ward Member *The Chairman read out a statement on behalf of Councillor Bromwich Updates since the preparation of the Officer’s report were circulated to the Committee as set out on the attached sheet.
Councillor Bromwich asked:
It was not known at this time, therefore Councillor Jefferson agreed to check and respond directly to Councillor Bromwich.
Councillor Crump indicated that he would withdraw from the table whilst the item was determined, informing the Committee that he would read out a statement on behalf of Councillor Bromwich, Ward Member, who was unable to attend the meeting.
SPEAKERS [name removed] – Applicant’s Agent Cllr Crump – on behalf of Cllr Bromwich - District Council Ward Member The case officer informed the Committee that a site visit had been undertaken that afternoon to allow Members the opportunity to view the site and its surroundings. Councillors Bromwich and Feilding were in attendance.
The Head of Paid Service informed the meeting that he had been advised by the Leader that Councillor Bromwich was no longer a member of the Conservative Group. A revised Political Balance Calculation was then circulated and is appended to these Minutes.
b) In addition, Councillor Bromwich was incorrectly advised by a council officer that as he had a non-pecuniary interest he would have to withdraw from the debate, when in fact he should have been advised that he could partake of the debate but not the vote.
In addition, the Chair of the meeting incorrectly instructed Councillor Bromwich to withdraw from the room, when in fact Councillor Bromwich had the right to decide to remain. Thus the Ward member was wrongly prevented from representing the views of the Ward residents.
APPLICANT [name removed] Outbuilding rear of 1 High Street, Southam PROPOSAL Change of use/ conversion of outbuilding to a two bedroom dwelling SPEAKERS Cllr Bromwich - District Council Ward Member Having considered the application and the representations made at the meeting a motion of GRANT, in accordance with the recommendation detailed in the report, was proposed by Councillor Brain and seconded by Councillor Barnes.
APPLICANT [name removed] 1 High Street, Southam PROPOSAL Alteration/ relocation of existing pedestrian access to flat and proposed general refurbishment SPEAKERS Cllr Mike Brooks – Southam Town Council - Objecting Cllr Bromwich - District Council Ward Member Councillor Crump, at this juncture, disclosed that he was a Member of Southam Town Council but had not commented on this or the previous application (16/02683/FUL) and would therefore remain at the table.
Councillor Bromwich drew the Council’s attention to the fact that the Grange Hall building owned by the District Council was currently empty and had been for ... view the full minutes text for item 405.
It was proposed by Councillor Crump and seconded by Councillor Bromwich that the Motion be amended to read as follows:
The Chairman enquired as to whether Councillor Bromwich, as the adjacent Ward Member, should remain at the table whilst the application was discussed in light of his objection contained within the agenda report and advised caution on this decision.
Councillor Bromwich stated that due to the new material considerations that had been submitted following his original objection, he was able to determine the application with an open mind.
Councillor Bromwich was not in attendance at this point and did not take part in the determination of this application.
Accordingly, a motion to DEFER to a future date for consideration was proposed by Councillor Kendal and seconded by Councillor Bromwich.
Having considered the application and the representations made at the meeting a motion of REFUSE was proposed by Councillor Bromwich and seconded by Councillor Brain.
Minute 818 - Application No 15/02047/OUT – Land off Manders Croft, Southam Councillor Bromwich declared an interest as his brother lived on the estate and he was the Ward Councillor for the application site. He therefore stated that he would withdraw from the table for the item.
However, prior to considering the item Councillor Bromwich indicated he had sought advice during the meeting and was now happy that as Ward Member he could participate in the application as he had come to meeting with an open mind.
He advised that he would not vote on the item but stated that he did not think Southam had been best served by the decision not to allow himself or Councillor Bromwich to speak when the item was originally debated.
APPLICANT [name removed] SITE Rowendene , 6 Walton Way, Wellesbourne PROPOSAL Single storey extension to the rear SPEAKERS Cllr Christine Michael – Wellesbourne and Walton PC - objecting [name removed] - applicant Cllr Kendall - District Council Ward Member Having considered the application and the representations made at the meeting a motion of GRANT was proposed by Councillor Kettle and seconded by Councillor Bromwich.
Councillor Bromwich declared a non-pecuniary interest for Application 15/02499/VARY as he was a Member of Southam Town Council and had abstained from the previous determination of this application and would therefore leave the table whilst the item was determined.
Councillor Bromwich in accordance with Minute number 753 above left the table.
At this point Councillor Bromwich disclosed that he was known to both speakers and would therefore withdraw from table.
Subsequently Councillor Bromwich left the meeting.
Councillor Bromwich disclosed a non-pecuniary interest in application 15/02047/OUT in that a close relation lived adjacent to the proposed site and would therefore leave the meeting whilst the item was determined.
In accordance with Minute 640 above, Councillor Bromwich withdrew from the table for this item.
2) The resignation of Councillor Dalla Mura from Planning Committee East, and that Councillor Bromwich would be his replacement.
Councillor Bromwich disclosed a non-pecuniary interest in application 15/00897/OUT in that he resided on the road of the application site and would therefore withdraw from the meeting whilst the application was determined.
In accordance with Minute 253 above, Councillor Bromwich left the meeting whilst the application was determined.
Having considered the application and the representations made at the meeting a motion of GRANT was proposed by Councillor Brain and seconded by Councillor Bromwich.
Southam Ward By-Election – 19 June 2014 The Returning Officer reported that Councillor Tony Bromwich had been elected District Councillor for the Southam Ward at the By-Election held on 19 June 2014.
The Chairman welcomed Councillor Bromwich to the meeting.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Bromwich attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17 Oct 2022 | Council | Proposed Changes to Planning Delegations | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 12 Aug 2015 | Planning Committee (East) | Application No. 15/00897/OUT - Insight Park , Welsh Road East, Southam, Warwickshire CV47 1NE | 3 for, 3 against, 1 abstained |
Meetings Councillor Bromwich was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 0 of 3 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Bromwich declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 13 Dec 2021 | Council, item 458 | Note: At this point Councillor Bromwich disclosed that he was a licensed Dual Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Driver. | |
| 26 Jun 2020 | Regulatory Committee, item 21 | Councillor Bromwich disclosed that he was a dual Hackney Carriage and Private Hire licence holder. | |
| 16 Dec 2019 | Council, item 478 | Councillor Bromwich disclosed a personal interest at this juncture as a licensed taxi driver . | |
| 25 Feb 2016 | Planning Committee (East), item 802 | Minute 818 - Application No 15/02047/OUT – Land off Manders Croft, Southam Councillor Bromwich declared an interest as his brother lived on the estate and he was the Ward Councillor for the application site. He therefore stated that he would withdraw from the table for the item. | |
| 10 Feb 2016 | Planning Committee (East), item 753 | Councillor Bromwich declared a non-pecuniary interest for Application 15/02499/VARY as he was a Member of Southam Town Council and had abstained from the previous determination of this application and would therefore leave the table whilst the item was determined. | Took no part |
| 10 Feb 2016 | Planning Committee (East), item 759 | At this point Councillor Bromwich disclosed that he was known to both speakers and would therefore withdraw from table. | |
| 16 Dec 2015 | Planning Committee (East), item 640 | Councillor Bromwich disclosed a non-pecuniary interest in application 15/02047/OUT in that a close relation lived adjacent to the proposed site and would therefore leave the meeting whilst the item was determined. | |
| 12 Aug 2015 | Planning Committee (East), item 253 | Councillor Bromwich disclosed a non-pecuniary interest in application 15/00897/OUT in that he resided on the road of the application site and would therefore withdraw from the meeting whilst the application was determined. |
Where Councillor Bromwich sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Sep 2014 | 21 | 14 Dec 2026 |
| Climate Change Panel | Observers | Nov 2025 | 2 | 5 Jan 2027 |
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | May 2015 | 13 | |
| Regulatory Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2020 | 4 | |
| Planning Committee (East) | Committee Member | Aug 2015 | 3 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.