Welcome and introductions
The Chair, Councillor Edward Joyce, welcomed those present.
Every time Sutton's minutes name Councillor Joyce, as the council published it.
The Chair, Councillor Edward Joyce, welcomed those present.
In relation to item 37, DM2025/00470 - Overhill Woodmansterne Lane, Councillor Patrick Magnus declared an interest as the Ward Councillor for South Beddington & Roundshaw and had a working relationship with Councillor Edward Joyce and [name removed] from the audience. He declared that he was not predetermined.
This application had been referred to the committee because the proposal had received over 10 letters of objection contrary to the recommendation to grant planning permission, and the application had been de-delegated by Councillor Edward Joyce on the grounds of the proposal’s bulk and it being an overdevelopment of the area.
The Chair, Councillor Edward Joyce, welcomed those present.
A motion to appoint Councillor Scott Roche as Chair for the 2025/26 municipal year was moved by Councillor Edward Joyce and seconded by Councillor Jayne McCoy. It was then put to a vote and won.
The Chair, Councillor Edward Joyce, welcomed those present.
The Chair, Councillor Edward Joyce welcomed those present.
Councillor Joyce advised that money for the heritage board and three trees has been allocated from the Neighbourhood Fund. It was agreed that timescales would be provided outside of the meeting.
The Chair, Councillor Edward Joyce, welcomed those present.
The Vice Chair, Councillor Edward Joyce, welcomed those present.
A motion to appoint Councillor Sam Martin as Chair for the 2024/25 municipal year was moved by Councillor Jayne McCoy and seconded by Councillor Edward Joyce. It was then put to a vote and won.
A motion to appoint Councillor Edward Joyce as Vice Chair for the 2024/25 municipal year was moved by Councillor Sam Martin and seconded by Councillor Jayne McCoy. It was then put to a vote and won.
The Chair, Councillor Edward Joyce, welcomed those present.
The Chair, Councillor Edward Joyce, welcomed those present..
This was seconded by Councillor Edward Joyce.
The Chair, Councillor Edward Joyce, welcomed those present..
The Chair, Councillor Edward Joyce, welcomed those present.
The Chair, Councillor Edward Joyce, welcomed those present.
Councillor Edward Joyce, ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 31.
There are numerous objections from residents in the local area The Close was built without the additional property as part of the design due to space Access for construction will cause issues for local residents Details on where the utilities would be installed onto the dwelling have not been provided Loss of light In response to questions, Councillor Joyce explained that access to the site for construction could be unsafe ... view the full minutes text for item 50.
The Chair, Councillor Edward Joyce welcomed those present.
The Chair, Councillor Edward Joyce, welcomed those present.
The Chair, Councillor Edward Joyce welcomed those present.
A motion to appoint Councillor Barry Lewis as Chair and Councillor Sam Martin as Vice Chair for the 2022/23 municipal year was moved by Councillor Edward Joyce and seconded by Councillor Scott Roche. It was then put to a vote and won.
Councillor Muhammad Sadiq proposed that Councillor Edward Joyce be elected as Vice Chair of the Beddington and Wallington Local Committee.
RESOLVED : Councillor Edward Joyce be appointed as Vice Chair of the Beddington and Wallington Local Committee.
The motion to exclude the public and press for the remainder of the meeting was moved following item ten by Councillor Whitehead and seconded by Councillor Joyce.
Following this, a motion to appoint Councillor Edward Joyce as Vice Chair for the 2020/21 municipal year was moved by Councillor Muhammad Sadiq and seconded by Councillor Stuart Collins.
· Supply of alcohol - retail (for consumption on the premises) - Everyday 11:00 - 17:30 · Recorded music - Everyday 09:00 - 17:30 The applicant and Cllr Joyce both indicated that the adjournment had been of great benefit and that the site visit and discussions had been useful in setting out the proposed operation and in giving the applicant an opportunity to go some way towards resolving the residents’ concerns with the conditions and reassurances given. Ultimately it was a matter of trust. The Sub-Committee noted the review process available to residents should problems or breaches of the licence occur after grant.
Cllr Joyce suggested three further areas for potential conditions and in response the applicant offered two additional conditions as follows and clarified that no amplified music will be played at the premises:
Councillor Edward Joyce explained the property is rented to a tenant at present, and that the Bandon Hill Cemetery Committee were looking to tidy up that area, although at present there were no long term plans for the property. Concerns about the current state of the property will be passed to the Council’s Asset Management team.
Councillor Edward Joyce welcomed attendees.
Councillor Edward Joyce proposed Councillor Stuart Collins be elected as Chair this was seconded by Councillor Barry Lewis.
An amendment to the recommendation 2.2 in the report was motioned by Councillor Edward Joyce and seconded by Councillor Stuart Collins that “ The possibility of obtaining funding through a suitable Landfill Tax Credits Scheme be explored to help fund the replacement of the wooden fence to the front boundary, using oak to improve the appearance and security of the cemetery and to continue to repair the fences on the other boundaries be funded” The Contract Officer explained that the Council’s tree Officer will be completing an audit of the trees within the cemetery in August as it had been suggested that some trees on the Queenswood Avenue boundary may have to be removed due to damage and disease. Residents in Queenswood Avenue would be informed before any trees on that boundary are removed. Members asked for information about the mesh bins which are no longer in place.
The Chair, Councillor Edward Joyce welcomed attendees.
Councillor Edward Joyce gave apologies for lateness.
Councillor Edward Joyce joined the meeting at 7.12.
Councillor Edward Joyce asked about a previous debt investment in a technology company which was subsequently lost. He raised concern regarding further investment in this sector, and if a high level of security could be provided to mitigate risk. David Walker advised that the previous investment was a different type of investment where there were no covenants in place.
Councillor Allen, Councillor Whitehead and Councillor Joyce declared that they are Sutton pensioners.
Councillor Edward Joyce disclosed that previously he was a teacher at 3 of the schools mentioned in the report.
Councillor Joyce asked if they can be inspected in the next cycle or to look at them in the summer once they are in leaf. Head of Neighbourhood Services will investigate the date of the last inspection and provide an update at the next committee meeting.
Councillor Joyce asked a question regarding working with local communities to “police with consent” as the riots in 2011 saw some of the worst offences on the border of the borough, and how to maintain the high levels of safety in Sutton. Chief Supt Robyn Williams responded that Sutton has an engaged community, and that she would focus on those in protected characteristic areas in order to understand the communities and ensure that nobody feels isolated or disenfranchised. She added that she would want to hear from charities and voluntary groups in Sutton, was looking to refresh the Independent Advisory Group and work more closely with young people.There was a practice exercise planned early next year to see how services would respond to work together to keep community safe for a major/critical incident.
Councillor Joyce introduced the report, and invited questions from the Committee following discussion on each of the four aims. The first aim was to explore the preparations made for the introduction of the new service.
Councillor Edward Joyce arrived at 18:26 and the meeting was quorate after the Member Training item.
Councillor Joyce raised concern that the responses to question 17 indicated that responders had not been given the opportunity to feedback or raise concerns about the care they were receiving. Peter Flavell replied that he was aware ESTH were procuring an improved system to obtain feedback from service users, so the answer to that question may improve.
The move to service line management - they used to organise their management in terms of boroughs (each of the 5 boroughs covered by the trust) and were now organised in clinical lines headed by a Clinical Director (Acute and Urgent Care, Cognition and Mental Health in Ageing, Community, Forensic, Specialist and National, Child and Adolescent Mental Health) Councillor Joyce asked what impact the new allocation of beds by need rather than by borough would have on Sutton residents. [name removed] responded that although there were no longer designated borough wards, they aim to admit patients into the most convenient location for them and try not to move them around unless necessary, and that the advantages of this change outweighed the disadvantages. David Bradley added that anyone that needed admission would be admitted, and that following an increase in demand for beds some people elsewhere in the UK had been sent away from their local areas to be admitted to hospitals, which would not happen in South West London.
Councillor Joyce asked how the Trust was meeting targets to reduce MRSA and E.Coli . Charlotte Hall responded that last year they had 6 cases of MRSA and that this year they had 1. She attributed this to staff being conscious about washing hands and changing aprons and isolating anybody who develops it, and referred to new guidance about E.Coli meaning they would work closely with community providers, as the infection is often brought in with people using a catheter at home.
Following nomination and vote, Councillor Edward Joyce (Sutton) was elected as Chair and Councillor Timothy Godfrey (Croydon) as Vice Chair.
Councillor Edward Joyce asked for confirmation that the pension deficit would be cleared in full. The Assistant Director confirmed this and it was welcomed by Members.
Councillor Joyce moved a resolution that when a draft of the lease is ready this should be reviewed by Councillors at a meeting of this committee before it is signed. If the wording is ready before the next meeting is due Members would like an additional meeting to take place.
Councillor Joyce asked if it would be possible to trial opening on Mothering Sunday next year. The Head of Neighbourhood Services advised it should be possible to use idverde or Mite to open and lock the cemetery he advised the cost is likely to be approximately £150.
Councillor Joyce moved a resolution that £150 be allocated to open the cemetery on Mother's day in March 2018 as a trial, this was seconded by Councillor Nick Mattey.
Councillor Edward Joyce sought further clarification on liabilities, to which the Head of Financial Strategy and Planning commented that these were not examined on a quarter basis, rather annually around December.
Councillor Edward Joyce referred to the returns mentioned, enquiring how these kinds of assets respond to difficult situations, for example, financial crisis. The representatives elaborated on the inherent nature of infrastructure investment, referring to leverage and diversification. Members further discussed leverage among different types of assets, diversification and the future of the market.
The motion was seconded by Councillor Edward Joyce and was put forward as an amendment to the recommendations.
Councillor Joyce asked whether “Brexit” had caused an increase in racial hate crime.
(Councillor Joyce) A: Councillor Dombey gave a history of the decision to move to a Committee system in Sutton and referred the committee to the remit of Strategy and Resources in the Council’s Constitution, in particular to set the overall strategic direction of the council and to ensure that the budget is available to carry it out. She also highlighted that Strategy and Resources does not sit above the other decision making committees.
Councillor Edward Joyce enquired as to the impact of the recent referendum result on the value of the holdings outlined on Page 9 of the Public Report Pack. It was responded that the quarter had been volatile but that the FTSE had bounced by its end and an impact on property values had not yet been witnessed. David Walker added that the strong performance of the equity market had continued but that currency had seen an impact and yields had been pushed even lower.
Councillor Edward Joyce then questioned the current state of liabilities and it was answered that this would be discussed in further detail at the December meeting of the Pension Committee as only interim valuations were currently available.
Councillor Edward Joyce mentioned that this had been discussed a lot in the news recently and asked whether it was possible to sell on any share. It was answered that the news related to retail not institutional investors, and that in this instance funds are reviewed quarterly and contain a redemption mechanism.
Following nomination and vote, Councillor Timothy Godfrey (Croydon) was elected as Chair and Councillor Edward Joyce (Sutton) as Vice Chair.
Councillor Edward Joyce, Non Pecuniary, in that he is a teacher at Wallington Grammar School for Boys.
Councillor Edward Joyce asked that as mentioned in the report why there were issues with staff morale. The Executive Head of Education and Early Intervention responded that there were a number of issues currently affecting staff, including the potential fundamental changes to the ways that they work. He assured the Committee that staff would be supported through the process.
Councillor Edward Joyce asked why there was a decline in the number of Meals on Wheels delivered. The Executive Head of Adult Social Care read a note from the Manager of the Meals on Wheels service confirming that there is presently no one on the waiting list following a change in processes, a lower number of users and a move to the Inclusion Centre which has increased capacity.
Councillor Edward Joyce informed the committee that he had visited the site that day and had found flytipping present, including a sofa.
Councillor Edward Joyce stated that there were a number of issues being experienced around Mollison Drive which needed to be addressed. The Head of Highways and Transport stated that if savings were made through the implementation of schemes and scheme could be proposed to address concerns around Forresters and Mollison Drive.
Councillor Joyce queried the figures for Harding Loevner and Schroders under paragraph 4.12 as they were exactly the same. It was confirmed that these were correct.
Councillor Edward Joyce informed the Committee that the Roundshaw Festival was being organised to take place on 29 August at the Phoenix Centre.
In response to a question raised by Councillor Edward Joyce, Sergeant Le Shirley advised that the digging up of soil bunds if seen to cause criminal damage is an offence.
PUBLIC REALM REPORT In relation to the water tanks at Bute Road Allotments, Councillor Joyce advised 4 would be preferable.
Councillor Joyce advised other stakeholders in the area should be contacted.
Councillor Joyce was in favour of the proposal but requested officer comments on the proposal’s implications.
Councillor Joyce requested on behalf of Councillor Melican, 2 more BBQs in Beddington Park. Dee Hyatt requested more bins, especially near the BBQs.
Councillor Joyce requested a grit bin in Apeldoorn Estate due to the steep incline, one exit/entrance.
Councillor Edward Joyce advised that Meals on Wheels had had difficulty in delivering to the Apeldoorn Estate during the bad bout of snow and residents could not get out. He suggested a gritting vehicle visit the roads or a delivery of grit be sent to the area. [name removed] advised the gritting vehicles had a list of priority routes.
Councillor Edward Joyce submitted a petition on behalf of residents in Link Lane, Wallington. The prayer to the petition states:
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Joyce attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 21 May 2018 | Council | Vote of Thanks for the retiring Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 May 2016 | Council | Motion: Vote of thanks to the Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 9 Jun 2015 | Adult Social Services and Health Committee | Alternative Delivery Models update | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 May 2015 | Council | Motion: Vote of thanks to the Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 May 2015 | Council | Election of Mayor for Municipal Year 2015/16 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 May 2015 | Council | South London Partnership Joint Committee | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 3 Nov 2014 | Council | Motion - Sutton's Future | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 Jul 2014 | Council | Motion - Making Sutton a Dementia Friendly Borough | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Joyce was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 11 of 15 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Joyce declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 26 Sep 2018 | Pension Committee, item 14 | Councillor Allen, Councillor Whitehead and Councillor Joyce declared that they are Sutton pensioners. | |
| 18 Dec 2017 | Pension Committee, item 42 | Councillor Edward Joyce disclosed that previously he was a teacher at 3 of the schools mentioned in the report. |
Where Councillor Joyce sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | May 2010 | 98 | 23 Nov 2026 |
| Beddington and Wallington Local Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2010 | 67 | 8 Dec 2026 |
| Scrutiny Committee | Vice-Chair | Jun 2012 | 55 | |
| Planning Committee | Substitute | Sep 2014 | 16 | 2 Dec 2026 |
| Audit and Governance Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2025 | 3 | 16 Dec 2026 |
| Licensing Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2026 | 1 | |
| Pension Committee | Vice-Chair | Jun 2014 | 31 | |
| Bandon Hill Cemetery Joint Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2014 | 23 | |
| Development Control Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2010 | 21 | |
| Children, Family and Education Committee | Substitute | Jun 2012 | 12 | |
| South West London and Surrey County Council Joint Health Scrutiny Committee | Vice-Chair | Jun 2018 | 11 | |
| Sustainable Communities Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2010 | 8 | |
| Adult Social Services and Health Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2015 | 8 | |
| People Committee | Vice-Chair | Oct 2020 | 7 | |
| Health and Well Being Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2011 | 5 | |
| Health and Wellbeing Board | Committee Member | Jan 2021 | 5 | |
| Senior Officer Appointment Committee | Committee Member | May 2021 | 4 | |
| Strategy and Resources Committee | Substitute | Jul 2021 | 3 | |
| Pension Fund Annual Meeting | Committee Member | Jul 2015 | 2 | |
| Licensing Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2022 | 2 | |
| The Executive | Committee Member | May 2010 | 1 | |
| Joint Surrey and SWL Health Overview and Scrutiny Sub Committee | Committee Member | Nov 2023 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.