Welcome and introductions
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present.
Every time Sutton's minutes name Councillor McCoy, as the council published it.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present.
In relation to items 11 and 12, Councillor Jayne McCoy declared that she lives near the application site, but that she would approach the applications with an open mind.
Councillor Jayne McCoy provided an update on the upcoming Planning Committee reforms.
Councillor Jayne McCoy declared a non-pecuniary interest due to having family buried in the Cemetery.
A motion to appoint Councillor Jayne McCoy as Chair for the 2026/27 municipal year was moved by Councillor Sam Martin and seconded by Councillor Rob Leah. It was then put to a vote and won.
A motion to appoint Councillor Sam Martin as Vice Chair for the 2026/27 municipal year was moved by Councillor Jayne McCoy and seconded by Councillor Rob Leah. It was then put to a vote and won.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present.
Councillor Jayne McCoy declared that for agenda item 10: 6 Woodcote Road, Wallington, Sutton, SM6 0NN she had dedelegated the application, therefore would leave the Committee and act as ward councillor for the application and would also leave the meeting after addressing the meeting in the role of ward councillor
Councillor Jayne McCoy, explained that for agenda item 10, DM2023/01628 6 Woodcote Road, Wallington SM6 0NN she would act as a ward councillor and would not take part in the meeting as a Committee member.
Councillor Jayne McCoy moved to the public gallery and Councillor Richard Clifton took the Chair.
Councillor Jayne McCoy left the Committee and joined the public gallery at 21.47 The Committee considered a report on the above application for the change of use from Sui Generis (drinking establishment) to a flexible Class E use (commercial and business) or Sui Generis use (Drinking establishment).
This application has been referred to the committee because the proposal has been de-delegated by Councillor Jayne McCoy.
Mark Bowman and Jack Barker objectors, and Councillor Jayne McCoy, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 31, and supporter, Akash Luth replied.
The principal issues raised by Mark Bowman and Jack Barker included:- · It was unclear that the site was not viable as a public house · The neighbouring public houses provide a style of establishment that was not a preferred option for everyone (busy and sports bar) · The now closed public house on the site had been busy and popular, providing a variety of offers · The now closed public house had offered a range of community events · There has not been a robust marketing campaign · A viable business could be created at the site The principal issues raised by Councillor Jayne McCoy included:- · There was policy in place to safeguard public houses · Marketing of the property had not been adequate and has not been visible · The price offered was not appropriate for the size and location of the property · There had been interest in the property, which did not appear to have been followed up by the owner · There are not too many public houses in Wallington · The Wallington Arms was a popular community pub which supported events such as the Wallington music festival · It was assumed that the internal structure remained that of a public house, supporting re-establishment as a public house.
Councillor Jayne McCoy left the meeting (the gallery) at 22:15 The principal issues raised by Akash Luth included:- · He was a local resident · There were a number of empty properties in Wallington High Street · Two public houses in the area was sufficient · Another public house would lead to increased anti social behaviour such as noise and rubbish · The site could still be a public house in the future · Public houses are difficult to make profitable at the moment · Empty property in the High Street is a concern In debate members discussed that the property had been empty for five years, the loss was of an empty property rather than ... view the full minutes text for item 59.
In relation to item 7, Councillor Jayne McCoy declared a non-pecuniary interest due to having family buried in the Cemetery.
A motion to appoint Councillor Mark Johnson as Vice Chair for the 2025/26 municipal year was moved by Councillor Jayne McCoy and seconded by Councillor Sam Martin. It was then put to a vote and won.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present.
In relation to item 39, DM2025/00171 - 69 Cornwall Road Councillor Jayne McCoy declared that she was acquainted with the objector, [name removed] , but was not predetermined
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present.
Councillor Jayne McCoy moved the motion which was seconded by Councillor Sam Martin.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present.
Councillor Jayne McCoy, Harshal Kshatri , Martin Bouwers (joined the meeting at 10.45am) Other Persons Officers:
John Sibson, Responsible Authorities Councillor Muhammad Sadiq (representative for Councillor Jayne McCoy), Other Persons Officers:
A motion to appoint Councillor Scott Roche as Chair for the 2025/26 municipal year was moved by Councillor Edward Joyce and seconded by Councillor Jayne McCoy. It was then put to a vote and won.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present.
In regard to agenda item 6, DM2023/01839, 79 - 85 Beddington Lane Beddington Sutton CR0 4TH, Councillor Jayne McCoy declared that she is a trustee of the Wandle Valley Regional Park Trust which is referenced in the report and was not predetermined on the application.
· Councillor Jayne McCoy declared that, in her role as ward councillor, she had submitted objections to previous applications on the site and had spoken with the applicant. She had confirmed that she had not been involved in this application and would approach it with an open mind.
A motion to appoint Councillor Sam Martin as Chair for the 2024/25 municipal year was moved by Councillor Jayne McCoy and seconded by Councillor Edward Joyce. It was then put to a vote and won.
A motion to appoint Councillor Edward Joyce as Vice Chair for the 2024/25 municipal year was moved by Councillor Sam Martin and seconded by Councillor Jayne McCoy. It was then put to a vote and won.
Councillor Jayne McCoy, Other Person Officers:
Councillor Jayne McCoy provided an update on the Elgin Road/Clyde Road/Ross Road area proposed Highway Scheme.
Councillor McCoy answered questions relating to the informal consultation and the purpose of physical measures such as speed humps.
The Vice Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present and those watching the live stream.
Councillor Jayne McCoy moved a vote of thanks to the Leader, which was seconded by Councillor Barry Lewis.
An amendment was moved by Councillor Barry Lewis and seconded by Councillor Jayne McCoy.
The Vice Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy took over the Chairing of the meeting.
In regard to item 7 - DM2022/02131, 219-227 High Street - Councillor Jayne McCoy declared that she had previously visited the site in her previous role as the Chair of the Housing, Economy and Business Committee but was not predetermined on the application.
Councillor Jayne McCoy proposed Councillor Colin Stears , Councillor Ed Joyce seconded the nomination. There being no further nominations, the motion was put to the vote and carried.
This was seconded by Councillor Jayne McCoy.
In regard to item 5, DM2021/02555, Councillor Jayne McCoy declared that she had previously been involved in the pre-application stages of the application in her previous role as the Chair of the Housing, Economy and Business Committee but was not predetermined on the application.
Following discussion, Councillor Jayne McCoy proposed the following amendment to the recommendations:
In relation to item 8, DM2022/00267, Councillor Jayne McCoy declared that she had previously been briefed on some strategic aspects of the application in her previous role as the Chair of the Housing, Economy and Business Committee but was not predetermined on the application.
Prior to the consideration of exempt information detailed in the Sutton Living Business Plan and Budget 2022/23 report, the motion to exclude the public and press for the remainder of the meeting was moved by Councillor Gordon and seconded by Councillor McCoy.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present and watching the live stream.
Councillor Ruth Dombey , moved the closure motion which was seconded by Councillor Jayne McCoy.
Councillor Dombey , moved the closure motion which was seconded by Councillor McCoy.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present.
The motion to exclude the public and press for the remainder of the meeting was moved by Councillor Gordon and seconded by Councillor McCoy.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present and watching the live stream.
Colin Wadeson , an objector, and Councillor Jayne McCoy, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 31, and the applicant Kevin Clarke replied.
The principal issues raised by ward councillor, Councillor Jayne McCoy were:- · The application was in an ASLC and adjacent to the greenbelt · The bulk and mass of this application were still high · There would be a significant amount of construction works required at the site · Access to the site would be via a private road · Works could block access to others including those using the route to get to Wallington Girls school · There would be access issues and disturbance to neighbours · Further highways information was needed, with careful review of the construction plan · The site was located in a cul de sac which was a private road, highways conditions relate to the public highway.
The motion to exclude the public and press was moved by Councillor Ruth Dombey and seconded by Councillor Jayne McCoy and duly carried.
The motion was moved by Councillor Jayne McCoy and seconded by Councillor David Bartolucci .
[name removed], an objector; and Councillor Jayne McCoy, a ward councillor; addressed the meeting under Standing Order 31, and [name removed], the applicant, replied.
The principal issues raised by Councillor McCoy were:- · That the development was large and overbearing · The development was in contravention to the borough’s Local Plan and the red lines agreed to protect the Green Belt and open spaces from development creep · That the need for care homes, including dementia care homes, had been adequately considered by the Head of Adult Social Care and that there was sufficient supply to meet local demand · The scale, mass and bulk of the proposal would equate to overdevelopment of the site · The loss of existing greenhouses and plant nurseries · The traffic implications of such a large development on a road that is already busy · The development creep into the Green Belt, setting a precedent for future development The principal issues raised by [name removed] were:- · The proposals would reduce the footprint on the Green Belt by 53%, in contrast to existing ... view the full minutes text for item 27.
The Vice-Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present and those watching the live stream.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present and the watching public to the meeting.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, asked members of the Committee to agree that the report was a correct record of the performance session on the 25 May 2021 involving all councillors on the committee.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, introduced this report and asked the Committee for any questions. The Committee discussed the rough sleepers provision and the HRA budget.
The motion to exclude the public and press was moved by Councillor Ruth Dombey and seconded by Councillor Jayne McCoy and duly carried. RESOLVED : That the public and press be excluded from the meeting for the following items of business on the grounds that they involve the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined in paragraph 3 Schedule 12A of the Local Government Act 1972. The Strategic Director of Resources provided more detailed financial information regarding the proposed acquisition and a letter which had been submitted to the Council by a developer.
The motion to exclude the public and press for the remainder of the meeting was moved by Councillor Dombey and seconded by Councillor McCoy.
Councillor Jayne McCoy moved the draft resolution for adoption.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present and the watching public to the meeting.
Councillor Jayne McCoy moved an amendment to revise wording of recommendation 2 to:
The Vice Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present and advised the committee she would preside over the meeting.
For agenda item 6b · Councillor Eric Allen is a member of the the LGA Safer and Stronger Community Board · Councillor Marlene Heron is a member of the Sutton Housing Partnership (SHP) Board · Councillor Barry Lewis is a member of the Sutton Housing Partnership (SHP) Board · Councillor Jayne McCoy is a representative on the LGA Homes for Londoners Board
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present and the watching public to the meeting.
Following debate, Councillor Jayne McCoy moved a motion to amend the recommendations such that a new recommendation would be inserted:
Councillor David Bartolucci moved the motion, which was seconded by Councillor Jayne McCoy.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed members and the viewing public to the virtual meeting.
Councillor Jayne McCoy moved an amendment that recommendation 2.2 be removed and replaced with:
Councillor Jayne McCoy moved an amendment to the amended recommendation 2.2 to revise the wording to:
The Chair drew attention to the update provided in the agenda pack, and Councillor McCoy kindly assisted with explaining the main points included in the update.
The motion to exclude the public and press was moved by Councillor Gordon and seconded by Councillor McCoy.
Councillor Jayne McCoy explained that the Council as the owner of the site had responsibility for securing a tenant.
Councillor Jayne McCoy motioned that recommendation 2.5 be amended to :£70 from Public Realm Revenue to supply several replacement keys for the notice board outside Wallington Town Hall be approved. This was seconded by Council Muhammad Sadiq .
Councillor Jayne McCoy, a Ward Councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 31, and the applicant replied.
The principal issues raised by Councillor McCoy were:- That Local Plan policies require a mix of retail units in district centres and expressed concern that in Wallington the majority of retail outlets are of a convenient nature like supermarkets and cafes. By adding another coffee shop to the district centre this would not make a diverse retail offer She advised the committee of the number of other retail outlets providing coffee. Her concern is the range of units is not diverse.
The Committee were advised that Councillor McCoy had sought feedback from residents via facebook to see if there was support for another coffee shop. She highlighted that based on responses received, that she believed that residents did not want another coffee shop.
Councillor Ruth Dombey moved the closure motion, which was seconded by Councillor Jayne McCoy.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present.
Following discussion, an amendment to the motion was moved by Councillor McCoy and seconded by Councillor Hicks:
The motion to exclude the public and press was moved by Councillor Gordon and seconded by Councillor McCoy on the grounds that discussion would involve the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined in paragraph 3 Schedule 12A of the Local Government Act 1972. In closed session, members considered the report and its exempt appendices.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present, including representatives of Extinction Rebellion in the public gallery.
Councillor Jayne McCoy declared a non-pecuniary interest in Item 6 as she is a trustee of the Wandle Valley Regional Park Trust.
Councillor McCoy thanked officers and members for their work on the issue and the petitioners for their vigilance in raising their concerns with the committee.
Councillor Jayne McCoy explained at present there were no plans for the buildings but that the Council as owner of the grade 2 listed buildings was working to secure a tenant. The school had expressed they wished to leave this site.
Councillor Jayne McCoy moved an amendment which was seconded by Councillor Jake Short Following debate, and with the consent of his seconder, Councillor Neil Garratt altered the motion to incorporate the amendment.
Councillor Ruth Dombey , moved the closure motion which was seconded by Councillor Jayne McCoy.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present.
Councillor Jayne McCoy attended the Committee to respond to questions in her role as Chair of the Housing, Economy and Business Committee and Councillor David Bartolucci in his role as Lead Member for Revenues and Benefits.
Councillor Jayne McCoy proposed Councillor Sunita Gordon as Chair, this was seconded by Councillor Muhmmad Sadiq .
Councillor Mo Saqib moved the motion which was seconded by Councillor Jayne McCoy. Following debate the motion was put to the vote and carried.
Cllr McCoy reported feedback from chairs and vice chairs of local committees, namely a request that recommendation 1.2 be reviewed after 12 months of operation, with a report back to the committee.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present and a purdah statement regarding the pre-election period was read out.
Councillor Ruth Dombey , moved the closure motion which was seconded by Councillor Jayne McCoy.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present to the meeting.
In response to a question on the BCU from Councillor Jayne McCoy, the Sergeant believed, to his knowledge ,that the commitment to Ward Panels would be continuing. He further explained that the custody suite was ‘paused’ rather than permanently closed and could be re-opened at short notice.
Councillor Jayne McCoy pointed to the highlighted spend on adults with learning disabilities in the report, and the Head of Service gave explanation, referring to the Learning Disability Strategy (which would be developed with the Clinical Commissioning Group). It was also noted that Sutton has a high proportion of people with Learning Disabilities due to the long stay hospital Orchard Hill.
Councillor Jayne McCoy wished to have more detailed information before endorsing any particular option, feeling that option 3 was enforcement-focused and suggesting a meeting be held with the residents living in the park.
Councillor Jayne McCoy moved the draft resolution of the Housing Economy and Business Committee.
On behalf of Councillor McCoy, Councillor Sadiq questioned if the update suggested that there should be a need for more parking spaces and that there should be a parking dispensation for Beddington Park cottage residents. The Neighbourhood Manager explained that the need for more parking spaces was not reflected in data received - which showed that 50% of parking spaces were still available - and relating to the dispensation; this would be part of an overall review if the trial is extended.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present to the meeting.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present to the meeting.
The Vice Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, requested that the Managing Director re-circulate the pricing policy among members of the shareholdings board.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy, welcomed those present to the meeting.
In debate, Councillor David Hicks motioned amending the recommendation to include ‘aiming for 65% and taking into account other costs such as service charges’ as seconded by Councillor Jayne McCoy, upon which the committee voted.
Councillor Jayne McCoy moved a motion of thanks for the retiring Mayor Councillor Jean Crossby which was seconded by Councillor David Hicks. The motion was unanimously carried.
Councillor McCoy enquired if the concerns raised by the Sherwood Hill, Headteacher relating to the Sherwood Hill School to include drop kerbs as part of the scheme would be included in the work to be done.
Councillor McCoy requested that considering the number of schemes already underway and looking ahead to the 2018/19 LIP funding, it would be good to have a rigorous timetable for the schemes to ensure schemes are not lost or just drop off the list.
Councillor Jayne McCoy, Chair of the Housing, Economy and Business Committee, then moved the adoption of the minute.
Councillor Jayne McCoy moved an amendment to the motion which was seconded by Councillor Richard Clifton, as attached at Appendix E.
Councillor Jayne McCoy moved the motion which was seconded by Councillor Muhammad Sadiq .
Councillor Nick Emmerson, Non Pecuniary, declared that as he was the Vice-Chair of Housing, Economy and Business Committee, he would be acting in that role to respond to questions during the Q&A with Councillor McCoy.
Councillor Jayne McCoy attended to respond to questions in her role as Chair of Housing, Economy and Business Committee. The questions and answers are set out as an appendix to the minutes.
Councillor McCoy offered her notes to include as part of the attachment, as such the attachment to the minutes contains her notes and any additional discussion that followed each question.
The application had been de-delegated by Councillor Jayne McCoy.
Mark Bowman and Tracy Killick objectors, and Councillor Jayne McCoy, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 31, and the applicant replied.
The principal issues raised by Councillor Jayne McCoy were:- Wider impact on all residents on Ross Road due to increased parking A2dominion building on a site which should have been parking for Julian House Many residents have complained to ward councillors about the parking in the area the level of traffic A2dominion should open up the site for its original function as a parking site Members asked what condition other garages in the area were in and what contact the Ward Councillor had made with A2dominion regarding the garages. The Ward Councillor responded that the other were garages were in a similar condition of disrepair and communication with A2dominion was difficult.
Councillor Jayne McCoy proposed Councillor Jean Crossby , Councillor Margaret Court seconded the nomination.
Councillor Jayne McCoy raised a recent incident of flytipping in Ross Road. Inspector Hicks undertook to look into the issue and feedback through the Head of Local Place and Engagement.
Councillor Jayne McCoy advised that this was proposed by three ward councillors following the issue being raised by residents, and similar collaborative work had been undertaken previously with fencing on housing association land in the ward. This was a one-off offer to match fund with Thames Valley Housing.
[name removed] , a supporter, and Councillor Jayne McCoy, a Ward Councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 31.
Councillor Jayne McCoy responded that there were other modern buildings but not necessarily of the same colour. She added that there was no one dominating style in the road and that residents are comfortable with the design following reassurances.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy opened the meeting and welcomed all present. She read out a short statement reminding the Committee that the meeting was being held during the pre-election period.
Councillor Jayne McCoy noted that, given the collective understanding about the role of SFTRA, it was surprising that they were not mentioned in the management agreement.
Councillor Jayne McCoy proposed amendment no.1 which was seconded by Councillor Amy Haldane.
Councillor Nick Mattey raised concerns about the loading and disabled parking bays in Woodcote Road, which were echoed by Councillor Jayne McCoy.
Councillor Jayne McCoy reported that another new group has been established; Wallington Community Wellbeing Group provide information, advice and activities for the over 50s, and will be launching on 11 March at St Michael’s Centre.
Councillor Jayne McCoy asked how Sutton is performing as a Fair Trade borough, and Judy Walsh suggested that officers and members should look around and observe where there are Fair Trade products available in Council buildings and facilities. Jessica Crowe, the Executive Head of Customers, Commissioning and Governance advised that the new procurement strategy for LB Sutton includes the promotion of Fair Trade and ethically sourced products as a criterion.
Councillor Jayne McCoy suggested that the Jubilee Health Centre, together with CCG representatives could be invited to present to a future meeting of this committee.
Councillor Nick Mattey and Councillor Jayne McCoy noted their thanks to the Town Centre Manager for co-ordinating the lights across the entire borough last year. In response, the Town Centre Manager acknowledged that last year’s installation of lights had been a learning curve for everyone involved, but the lessons learned will lead to a much smoother process in 2016. For example, a contractor is now in place with whom liaison can be made all through the year.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy opened the meeting and welcomed all present.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy welcomed everyone to the meeting, and in particular those speaking to the petition.
Councillor Jayne McCoy, Non Pecuniary, as a trustee of Wandle Valley Regional Park Trust.
Councillor Steve Cook reported that he, the Mayor and Councillor Jayne McCoy had removed graffiti from Wallington Public Hall.
The Chief Executive summarised that: the petition presented by Cllr Ramsey requested that the Council desist from leasing or selling the stable block in Cheam Park and asked that residents are engaged in deciding the future use of the stable block and buildings nearby so would be referred to the Strategy and Resources Committee to consider; the petition presented by Cllr McCoy requested that the Council looks at sites for homes to be used to house ex-servicemen and women so would be referred to the Housing, Economy and Business Committee to consider and the petition presented by Cllr Butt requested that the Council protect the mobile library service in Sutton and so would be referred to the Environment and Neighbourhood Committee.
Councillor Jayne McCoy requested that if the banks were removed signage was placed on site to provide details of alternative provisions and queried whether recycling materials at charity shops and the Vine Project contributed to the Council’s recycling rate.
Councillor Jayne McCoy stated that it was an important aspect of the Local Plan to ensure there was good transport links within Sutton as a balance would need to be struck between providing parking and providing housing. It would be important to seek the views of residents and possibly challenge car usage across the borough.
Councillor Jayne McCoy informed the committee that the Council had a target to deliver 210 new units per year which had been exceeded and had been given a new target by the Mayor of London to deliver 365 units per year.
Councillor Jayne McCoy informed the committee that part of the development of the Local Plan was compiling evidence of where developments could be placed and where infrastructure would be needed. However, it would be necessary to see increased intensification of ... view the full minutes text for item 26.
Councillor Jayne McCoy stated that parking restrictions were being enforced and the highest number of parking tickets within the borough were being issued for the road. Ongoing work was being done to resolve the issue.
Councillor Jayne McCoy opened the meeting and welcomed all present.
Councillor McCoy, Chair of the Housing, Economy and Business Committee, moved the adoption of the recommendation which was put to the vote and carried.
Councillor McCoy suggested a sign should be in place at the site providing details of the locations of recycling centres.
Councillor McCoy further informed the Committee that there was a ‘Report It’ function on the website which residents could use to report bins which needed to be emptied.
Councillor McCoy informed the Committee that the Jubilee Health Centre were required to landscape the gardens under planning conditions and that would not be appropriate to fund the landscaping through the Public Realm budget.
Councillor McCoy stated she would continue to speak with the management of the Health Centre regarding this issue and suggested that residents write to the management also.
Councillor Jayne McCoy invited Colin Wadeson to update the Committee on the Wallington Music Festival which took place on 27 June 2015. [name removed] informed the Committee that the event had been a success with over 20 music groups participating at three venues across Wallington. It was hoped that the event would be become a regular festival.
The Chair, Councillor Jayne McCoy thanked all present for attending, particularly those speaking to the Outer London Fund Project Review Hackbridge item.
Councillor Jayne McCoy suggested that the Wandle Valley Regional Park Trust should be a formal consultee on the Local Plan.
In response to a public query about the next steps the Chair reported that Councillor Jayne McCoy, Tom Brake MP and Baroness Kramer would be taking forward the issue of shared space and officers had been asked to take lessons learned to the Mayor. It was also being raised at high level officer meetings. It was hoped that there would be legislation changes as a result and the public were encouraged to get involved in consultations.
Councillor Jayne McCoy proposed Councillor Muhammad Sadiq, Councillor Joyce Melican seconded the nomination.
Councillor McCoy informed the committee that the Wallington Integrated Transport Package Group needed to be consulted on plans to ensure that the loading bays on Woodcote Road were used for loading only with vehicles parking parallel. Signage would be introduced to ensure drivers were aware of the usage and appropriate parking of the bays. Loading bays were for deliveries rather than parking and it was noted that 30 minutes free parking was provided for shoppers in the Wallington Library car park.
Councillor McCoy stated that festive lighting was important to businesses in the area and that it should continue in the high footfall areas, with possible festoon lighting in Wallington Square. Contributions should be sought from local businesses; however difficulties may arise when some businesses did not participate.
The application had been de-delegated by Councillor Jayne McCoy [name removed], an objector, and Councillor Jayne McCoy a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 31.
The principal issues raised by Councillor Jayne McCoy were:- · The built house is not in keeping with the local area, in overbearing and intrusive.
In response to Member questions Councillor McCoy stated that the canopy increased the bulk of the property making it more overbearing. Furthermore, the canopy contravenes the conditions on the space required between the properties.
Members were informed that Councillor McCoy, Chair of the Housing, Economy and Business Committee, had been sent the letter also and was looking into possible funding which could be provided to assist EcoLocal with their speciality markets.
Councillor Jayne McCoy further stated that ward councillors were progressing concerns raised with officers and were hoped a solution would be implemented which would mean the bays were for goods vehicles only.
Councillor McCoy requested regular updates on progress of this project.
Councillor Jayne McCoy informed the Committee that there had been difficulties with the festive lighting as many of the installations needed to be switched on individually, furthermore previous contractors had removed cabling from the lampposts which had caused some difficulties.
(a) Motion – Delivering Affordable Housing for Sutton Residents Councillor Jayne McCoy moved the motion which was seconded by Councillor Richard Clifton.
(c) Committee Recommendation - The Council Tax Reduction Scheme Housing, Economy and Business Committee held on 9 December 2014 Councillor Jayne McCoy moved the adoption of the recommendation which was put to the vote and carried, Resolved That the recommendations, including those of the member task and finish group, be adopted as follows:- 1. That care leavers become a recognised protected group until their 25 th birthday. If on a qualifying benefit such as job seekers allowance, they would receive a full Council Tax reduction.
Councillor McCoy informed the Committee that the Jubilee Health Centre had two GP practices resident which were responsible for arranging the landscaping and Ward Councillors were in contact with the Health Centre to discuss the delay.
Councillor McCoy suggested residents write to their own GP practice of the Health Centre to raise concerns regarding the landscaping.
Councillor McCoy stated that she would raise the removal of the bollard with officers as she was not aware that this was due to take place.
Councillor McCoy stated that it was important for the council to build a body of evidence for a change to be made to the parking provision and residents could submit photos to a Facebook page with examples of bad parking. Loading bays however would need to be maintained to enable businesses to receive deliveries.
Councillor McCoy informed the Committee that residents of Henfield Court, Beddington Gardens, had requested that a bench was not placed outside the property due to issues with anti-social behaviour. Only one bench would be installed on Beddington Gardens near Runnymede Court and the funds for the second bench would be recycled back into the Public Realm budget.
Councillor Jill Whitehead moved an amendment to the motion which was seconded by Councillor Jayne McCoy.
[name removed] and [name removed] , objectors, and Councillor Jayne McCoy, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 31, and the applicant, [name removed] and a Church steward, replied.
The principal issues raised by Councillor Jayne McCoy were:- · Few remaining historic buildings remained in Wallington.
In response to members’ questions Councillor Jayne McCoy explained that her concerns regarding an additional access point along Shotfield were that this would cause further congestion and difficulties in crossing the road as a pedestrian.
Councillor Jayne McCoy gave a brief update on the Housing Allocations Task and Finish Group. There had been two meeting and a report was to come to the next meeting of this Committee.
Officers reported the receipt of a letter of support for the application from Councillor Jayne McCoy.
Councillor Jayne McCoy requested some amendments to the minutes of 1 October 2013 in advance of the meeting; these have been incorporated in the copy to be signed. The minutes of the meetings held on 25 June 2013 and 1 October 2013 were agreed as a correct record and signed by the Chair.
In accordance with notice given, Councillor Jayne McCoy moved and Councillor Richard Clifton seconded the following Motion “This Council welcomes the news released recently by the ONS that a million more people are in work compared to early 2010 and that in Sutton the rate of JSA claimants has decreased by over 11% in the last year, with a 30% drop in the number of young people claiming JSA over the same period.
“Councillor Jayne McCoy declared an interest as the Trustee of the Wandle Valley Regional Park Trust. The Committee commended the work of Beddington Park Friends and the Parks Service and were wish success in their bid to Heritage Lottery Fund.” Matters Arising Roberta Fusco, Locality Lead Officer, gave an update various matters raised by Springboard Resident Association and Mellows Park Residents Association. Community representative, [name removed] volunteered to assist with the repositioning of flower troughs and Christmas Lights.
Councillor Jayne McCoy offered to put Mellows Park Residents Association in touch with the Social Enterprise Network Group.
As part of the project it was explained that plans are in place to possibly employ a member of staff to recruit volunteers and foster capacity building Councillor Jayne McCoy declared an interest as Trustee of the Wandle Valley Regional Park Trust. The committee commended the work of Beddington Park Friends and the Parks Service and were wished success in their Bid to Heritage Lottery Fund.
[name removed], an objector, and Councillor Jayne McCoy, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 31, and [name removed] replied for the applicant.
The principal issues raised by [name removed] were:- · The illustrations displayed did not show traffic or the three ‘bus stops in Shotfield · Cars and people used Shotfield all day, as well as ‘buses · Shotfield would be congested when the development was completed · Shotfield was already congested by traffic · It was too big – a smaller block would be better The principal issues raised by Councillor McCoy were:- · Traffic made Shotfield very congested · There would be complex traffic movements near the proposed entrance · Impact on transport · The Adult Social Services and Housing directorate reported over-provision of care accommodation in the Borough · The development would not support independent living · The site could be used instead to provide housing for Sutton residents · Over-development and bulk · The five storeys proposed would be outside the approved area for 4-6 storey mid-rise developments · The design would not be in-keeping with the existing library and former town hall · The design would be very imposing and create an ‘urban corridor’ effect · Change in the nature of the street scene In response to questions officers clarified that the proposed development would not be a care home. Residents would purchase properties on a long lease and pay separately for any care they needed as required.
Councillor Jayne McCoy stated that she hopes that this allocation will also foster working in partnership with businesses to generate a more creative approach to make the funding go as far as possible. Ransford Stewart stated that there is an opportunity to see how similar initiatives will be rolled out in future years to develop bigger and better schemes that are able to deal with more complex and difficult issues.
Councillor Jayne McCoy stated that she was aware of controversial issues around this scheme and asked if the project could ensure that it considers the views of the people fully.
In relation to the Beddington Skate park- Councillor Jayne McCoy asked to ensure that the views of youth are taken into consideration before progressing with the plans. She also encouraged [name removed] to continue contributing to the Bandstand project works.
Councillor Jayne McCoy agreed and stated that Crosspoint provides a space for privacy to discuss confidential issues.
Councillor Colin Hall and Councillor Jayne McCoy were informed by The Jubilee Centre Project Manager that the centre is experiencing water flow and water pressure problems. It is anticipated that these problems will be resolved by the beginning of April.
[name removed] and [name removed] , objectors, and Councillor Jayne McCoy, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 31, and the applicant, [name removed], replied.
The principal issues raised by Councillor McCoy were:- · Concern about the process of the application and granting B8 (storage) use · The applicant had not submitted a new application to provide clarity · Ratification of the B8 (storage) use was a ‘back door’ to obtaining B1 (office) use · The application for a lawful development certificate had only been submitted after significant objections to the planning application · Residents had been powerless to object to the applicant’s desired B1 (office) use · Officers could have required a traffic assessment if planning permission had been required for the B1 (office) use · Evidence for the B8 (storage) use had been scanty and there was none prior to 2006 · Officers should have demanded more robust evidence of the storage use · It was impossible to park ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
[name removed], a supporter, and Councillor Jayne McCoy, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 31.
The principal issues raised by [name removed] were:- · A small staging area for public use was sought · The proposal had been granted public realm funding by the Local Committee · The proposal would make the gardens available to a wider section of the community · There were no similar facilities in the area · A protocol governing potential use of the bandstand had been produced · Contrary to the one letter of objection, the proposed bandstand would be traditional in style and blend in with the design of the listed Wallington Town Hall building · The size of the proposed bandstand was limited because it was not intended to attract large crowds The principal issues raised by Councillor McCoy were:- · The application was supported by the Local Committee · The proposed bandstand arose from a public realm project to use the Wallington Town Hall building terrace and steps for performances · The proposed bandstand was not intended to be used for large scale concerts or functions A poll vote on the officers’ recommendation to grant permission was held in accordance with Standing Order 31.4, when there voted:
In accordance with notice given, in the absence of Councillor Jayne McCoy, Councillor Richard Clifton moved and Councillor Colin Hall seconded the Motion set out as Appendix C to these Minutes.
It was noted that Cllr McCoy had been asking for this for six years.
[name removed] expressed thanks to Cllr McCoy for the work undertaken which had made a good impression in the area, but she was unhappy with work on Plough Lane.
Councillor McCoy would investigate.
The applicant, supported by Councillor Tim Crowley, Councillor Jayne McCoy, a ward councillor, and representatives of the Sutton Centre for Independent Living and Learning (SCILL) were present.
Councillor McCoy had been advised that there were no redundancies, but some had moved to other areas.
Councillor McCoy support the Stafford Road corridor scheme.
Councillor McCoy expressed concern that a lot of the funding seemed to be on Wallington Town Centre not Stafford Road.
Councillor McCoy explained that the CIL gave greater flexibility than Section 106 agreements which were area specific. CIL was a non negotiable set rate to support general infrastructure and development across the borough which gave more certainty.
In accordance with notice given, Councillor Jayne McCoy moved and Councillor Richard Clifton seconded the following Motion This Council notes the findings of the Portas Review and supports the Local Government Association’s response proposing a five point plan for our high streets.
In relation to the Lavender Lights Councillor McCoy requested that Ward Councillors in consultation with residents decide where to place the lights. Keith Knight suggested increasing the number to 13 so that the lights could be on alternate lamppost, Jim Simms suggested the spacing be looked into as the lamppost were not regularly spaced.
Councillor McCoy had every confidence in the headteacher .
Councillor McCoy advised she was not aware of a high accident rate in Stafford Road and asked for it to be swapped with ButterHill .
He was advised that consultation would occur and Councillor McCoy would speak to him.
The Chair welcomed Councillor Jayne McCoy, Executive Member for Planning, Economic Development and Housing and Darren Richards, Executive Head of Planning and Transportation to the meeting. He advised that the report provided a summary on the progress made on implementing the agreed options identified by the Smarter Services Sutton (SSS)
Councillor McCoy advised the planning service was one of the first services to be reviewed and outlined the difference between Strategic Planning and Development Control. She advised that it set a good baseline for other reviews, looked at what other councils were doing, challenged assumptions, was transformative and sought to provide a better service whilst also delivering savings and generating increased income. She acknowledged that it was quite a painful process because it was so challenging and it was the first but was impressed with the range of options that they came up with, particularly the multi-skilling of technical support staff and the pre-application advice paid for service.
Councillor McCoy advised Legal Services could advise on reducing the size of reports.
Councillor McCoy suggested that Members could also promote the service.
Councillor Jayne McCoy moved the reception of the recommendation in Minute 13/12 together with the following alteration.
Councillor McCoy, Executive Member for Planning, Economic Development and Housing and Ward Councillor for Wallington South responded by advising that Wallington residents and shoppers had shaped the plans. Dedicated loading bays were introduced after speaking with shopkeepers. The income downturn referred to when works were taking place and takings were now at the level usual for the time of year.
Councillor McCoy requested if any were found that they be used.
Keith Knight advised that Springboard Residents’ Association had felt the proposals to introduce “no parking at any time” and to not allow single yellow lines directly opposite each other should have been made options, however, on considering the report options, the resident association and Councillor McCoy supported option 1.
Councillor McCoy said the building was of no real architectural value and was owned by the Crown Estate. The old Stanley Park High School site was being considered as a primary school.
Councillor McCoy advised of plans of a Community Centre.
Councillor McCoy asked if signs and/or physical changes were necessary.
The Chair suggested a bench and he and Councillor McCoy thanked Dee Hyatt on behalf of the Committee and residents for her dedication and hard work on the Committee and for the Friends Group.
(x) To note the thanks to Dee Hyatt from the Chair and Councillor McCoy on behalf of the Committee and residents for her dedication and hard work on the Committee and for the Friends Group.
Councillor Jayne McCoy moved and Councillor Colin Stears seconded the following amendment:
Councillor Jayne McCoy moved the reception of Minute 1006/11 on Benhill Leaseholder Charges.
Councillor Jayne McCoy seconded the Motion.
Councillor McCoy, Executive Member gave an overview of the proposals. It was noted that the Sutton Federation of Tenants and Residents Associations (SFTRA) was also looking at the proposals.
Councillor McCoy asked the Committee to prioritise for public realm funding.
The Chair suggested that Councillor McCoy add it to Peter Ashley’s list of yellow line requests.
Councillor Jayne McCoy reported that she had attended an information sharing meeting with other London Boroughs following these events. Many boroughs appeared to have experienced problems with communication between the Police and the local authority. This had not been the case in Sutton where the Safer Sutton Partnership arrangements had worked well.
Councillor McCoy felt people like [name removed] should be recognised.
Councillor McCoy suggested swapping capital funding for revenue.
Councillor McCoy supported [name removed] on addressing this issue.
The applicant was related to Councillor Jayne McCoy.
Wallington Square Councillor McCoy advised that the offices at the front of The Square were being turned into flats and that the Council was in discussion with the developers to improve the whole area. She mentioned that the back of The Square would be developed and there would also be improvements to shop fronts. A resident suggested the need for a change in tax legislation relating to empty properties to encourage owners to lease their shops.
In answer to a suggestion from a resident that the paving in The Square be levelled off, Councillor McCoy advised she would consult with the developers on linking the paving from the high street to The Square.
In answer to a question from a resident, Councillor McCoy advised that a condition had been put in the planning permission for the flats which stated that there must be adequate parking for residents. Part of Sainsburys car park had been set aside for this.
Councillor McCoy advised that there was no Section 106 monies that could be used in this area. The Chair said Public Realm monies may be able to be used for double yellow lines and that the Committee supported the residents in trying to get double yellow lines.
In relation to Project 2, Councillor McCoy was uncertain whether a 20 mph zone limit in Sandy Lane North would make any difference and therefore supported option (ii) contribution to Mellows Park Cycle Way (approved through the LIP scheme 20110/12).
Councillor McCoy asked that the project still be progressed as it was waiting on the planning officers.
Councillor Jayne McCoy indicated that tenants had been consulted on these proposals.
Councillor McCoy requested that £9,000 funding be allocated to replace the wooden fencing at Russell Court, Ross Road with metal railings. The current fencing encouraged anti social behaviour. The Police and Housing Association had agreed to match fund the project each providing £9,000.
Councillor McCoy replied that the Council did not want the same problems to happen again in Wallington. There was a different approach to Wallington which included a better working relationship between officers, Councillors, the deliverers and JMP. There had been discussions with residents, SCOLA, and Wallington Library which had introduced many changes to proposals.
Cllr McCoy commented that she had been very impressed with Martin Furtauer -Hayes’ practical, hands-on and ‘can do’ attitude.
Councillor McCoy suggested that residents come to a majority decision as this would gain more credence with TfL.
Councillor McCoy and Councillor Melican requested that Sandy Lane South/ Waterer Rise/ Wordsworth Road junction be pushed to the top of the list.
Councillor McCoy requested that the £5,000 recommended for the mosaics at Wallington Library Car Park be reduced to £3,000 and that further information was needed before monies could be released.
Councillor Jayne McCoy, Executive Councillor for Planning, apprised Members of the planning issues relevant to this project.
Cllr McCoy referred to the lack of guidance available and said that the timescales did not allow enough time for people to get together and discuss proposals properly. The structure in London would depend on the LGA and LDA transition. London Councils would be discussing with the Mayor what the new structure should be.
Cllr McCoy said that it was important to spread the message about Sutton’s opportunities and benefits. The borough needed investment and needed to look at innovative ways of attracting it. More also needed to be made of Sutton’s good transport links, including its direct link with Eurostar, and its ideal position between Gatwick and Heathrow.
An address submitted by Councillor Jayne McCoy, a ward councillor, was read on her behalf.
The principal issues raised by Councillor McCoy were:- The change of use would detract from the vitality and viability of Wallington Noise, litter and additional traffic would adversely affect the amenity of nearby residents People feltl unsafe using the town centre in the evenings The existing takeaways encouraged anti-social behaviour Additional takeaway premises would increase the likelihood of anti-social behaviour, noise and litter Delivery vans and customers wouldl create additional parking problems [name removed] addressed the meeting under Standing Order 33, on behalf of the applicant.
Councillor McCoy requested play equipment for disabled children. It was noted that the Friends of Mellows Park had also requested BBQs, bins and seating. A member of public suggested the café be updated.
Councillor McCoy advised the Safer Neighbourhood Team had informed her that it was for smokers.
Abstained (1) Councillor Jayne McCoy.
Councillor Jayne McCoy commended Stephen Waring on his work since he took the position of Director. Stephen Waring appreciated the problems over the years with frequent changes to personnel and noted that he was now the longest standing Director of Programme so far. He had tried to improve ways of ensuring that information was passed on when personnel do change.
The application had been de-delegated by Councillor Jayne McCoy.
[name removed] , an objector, and Councillor Jayne McCoy, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 33, and [name removed] replied on behalf of the applicant. The Chair also permitted [name removed], a local businessman, to speak in support of the application.
The principal issues raised by Councillor McCoy were:- Wallington Square needed a facelift to attract customers and businesses The provision of flats was a sensible approach that would meet housing needs The provision of flats would reduce the pressure to build flats elsewhere in Wallington No objection had been raised to the similar increase in the height of Mint House The proposal would provide more attractive shop units The proposal would create a favourable impact in the centre of Wallington In response to questions Councillor McCoy explained that, like Mint House, Wallington Square ... view the full minutes text for item 66.
Councillor Jayne McCoy reported that at a recent meeting of the Tier 4 Joint Health Scrutiny Committee it had been agreed that the consultation on the proposed closure of the Henderson hospital had been carried out successfully and could be a model for other NHS consultations. .However recommendations from 62 PCT’s on their recommendations for Tier 4 services were still awaited. These would be considered at a meeting of the PCT on 11 November 2009. The proposals would be circulated electronically to members of the Scrutiny Committee whose views would be submitted to the PCT in time for their meeting.
Councillor McCoy abstained for neutrality.
Councillor Jayne McCoy congratulated the Sutton LINk for being very well organised as they seemed to be ahead of other LINks and for the work done so far.
[name removed] concurred with Councillor McCoy and explained that the Sutton LINk were further ahead of other boroughs and believed that this was due to the joint working, at various levels, with Sutton Council.
Councillor Jayne McCoy asked if there was likely to be a loss of borough focus due to their being such a large commissioning group. [name removed] responded that the main change, so far, had been the establishment of a sub- regional acute commissioning PCT partnership. It was very early days yet and it was not clear how this might impact, from a social care perspective, in the longer term but any changes were being monitored.
Councillor Jayne McCoy asked if there was any work taking place on a cost benefit analysis of integrating systems to which [name removed] responded that this was implicit in section 6 of the agenda report. If this was to be developed there would need to be a business case which showed clear benefits to any investment made.
Abstained (1) Councillor Jayne McCoy.
· Councillor Jayne McCoy declared a personal interest as a member of Sutton, Epsom & District Branch of The National Childbirth Trust.
The Chair Councillor Jayne McCoy sent apologies and Vice Chair Councillor Richard Bailey took the Chair on her behalf.
Councillor Jayne McCoy welcomed everyone to the meeting and introductions were made.
Councillor Jayne McCoy referred to the indicator “Adults in contact with secondary mental health services in settled accommodation” and asked what were the secondary mental health services and what was the problem in obtaining the data. Matthew Wallbridge explained that relationships had been established with colleagues in PCT and Mental Health Trust. The Mental Health Trust were retrospectively adding data into systems to enable the end of year outturn to be provided, and then for 2009/10 onwards to monitor on regular basis.
b) Tier 4 Joint Scrutiny Committee Councillor McCoy stated that there was no update on this committee.
In accordance with notice given, Councillor Ruth Dombey moved and Councillor Jayne McCoy seconded the following Motion:
Further to Minute 713(b)/08, Councillor Ruth Dombey moved and Councillor Jayne McCoy seconded the following Motion:
(ii) To appoint Councillor Jayne McCoy to serve on the Joint Health Scrutiny Committee for the 2008/09 municipal year.
Councillor Jayne McCoy expressed concern that this committee would not be scrutinising direct payments and asked that this committee request that the SOC invite disabled people, that receive direct payments, to give witness for the investigation.
Councillor Jayne McCoy referred to a report that had gone to the Strategic Housing Group, but which had not gone out with the agenda and therefore members had not had time to review the information.
Councillor Jayne McCoy suggested that it would be useful information as the committee needed to make a decision tonight on what it wanted to scrutinise. Simon Latham suggested giving this committee a quarterly report. Andrew Taylor explained the various processes of scrutiny that the Sutton Housing Partnership already go through.
“That the Standing Committees, Joint Committees with other local authorities, Advisory Committees and Joint Committees with Staff, as set out on the agenda, as altered below, be appointed until the annual meeting of the Council in May 2009.” Health and Well Being Scrutiny Committee DELETE: Vice Chair – Councillor Joan Hartfield INSERT: Vice Chair – Councillor Jayne McCoy Scrutiny Overview Committee DELETE: Councillor Joan Hartfield (LD) INSERT: Councillor Jayne McCoy (LD) Audit Committee DELETE: Councillor Jayne McCoy (LD) INSERT: Councillor Roger Thistle (LD) CHANGE: Better Health Care Closer to Home Joint Health Scrutiny Committee to read Joint Health Scrutiny Committee DELETE: All reference to the Epsom & St. Helier Recovery Plan Joint Health Scrutiny Committee Sutton Joint Health and Safety Committee DELETE: Councillors Margaret Ali (LD), and Brendan Hudson (LD) INSERT: Councillors Colin Hall (LD) and Colin Stears (LD)
Councillor McCoy criticised the continuing care consultation document was rather wordy and full of jargon and not suited to relatives. There was also praise that the public events were excellent and got the message across very well.
Councillor Jayne McCoy explained that the task group set up to look at the Henderson Hospital issue had come to the conclusion that it was a substantial variation of service.
The Chair explained that In relation to the Malvern Ward a question was asked at the full Council meeting and Councillor Jayne McCoy and he, at the request of the mental health trust visited the site. Both found the visit very useful and informative and thanked the trust for the invitation. The Malvern Ward issue was included with the wider consultation on mental health services.
[name removed], an objector, and Councillor Jayne McCoy, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 33, and the applicant, [name removed], replied.
The principal issues raised by Councillor McCoy were:- The proposal was a sympathetic conversion There were fewer houses in the road in multiple occupation than elsewhere Car parking would not have a significant impact The property would remain in residential use The principal issues raised by [name removed] were:- Local residents had been consulted regarding the proposal The building would continue to have the appearance of a large detached house Refuse would not be stored outside In response to questions [name removed] said that one ground floor room could be used by clients with mobility problems and that the building would be accessible by disabled people.
[name removed], a supporter of the application, and Councillor Jayne McCoy, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 33.
The principal issues raised by [name removed] were:- On the basis that something would be built on the site the proposal was acceptable The proposed design would be in keeping with the area Most of the trees on the site would be retained The proposed building would not be near any boundary There would be minimal overlooking The principal issues raised by Councillor McCoy were:- The erosion of green land The site was of ecological value because its size would maintain a greater diversity of wildlife 30% of the site would be hard surface There would be pollution of the trees and lichen The proposal was effectively for three storeys and would appear bulky The proposal was not of a good design There would be additional traffic movements on the access road Members noted that there were few objections; the site and its access had existed for many years; the siting, scale and design of the proposed dwelling would not materially harm the character or appearance of the area of special local character; nor lead to the loss of any trees of a high amenity value; would not have a significant impact on adjoining neighbours, would not adversely affect parking or highway safety; and the quality of materials could be controlled by condition.
[name removed], a supporter, Councillor Jayne McCoy, a ward councillor, Dr Ling, one of the applicants, and [name removed], from the Sutton and Merton Primary Care Trust, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 33.
The principal issues raised by [name removed] were:- The enormous benefit the proposal would bring to people in Wallington There were some unspecified reservations The principal issues raised by Councillor Jayne McCoy (who declared a personal interest as a patient of the medical practice that was the applicant) were:- The proposal would improve health facilities and the street scene Despite some reservations the proposal represented an improvement The inclusion of a lift for disabled people and sustainable improvements were welcomed The principal issues raised by [name removed] and [name removed] were:- The existing Shotfield Clinic was no longer fit for purpose The proposal was for a temporary use Other options to provide a medical practice whilst Shotfeld Clinic was refurbished were not viable The proposal would also lead to the improvement of Shotfield Gardens In response to questions officers explained that refurbishment of the outside of Mint House could not be required because it was not part of the application, although it was noted that the applicant was prepared to consider such refurbishment in the future.
Councillor Jayne McCoy was elected Vice Chair.
Councillor McCoy stated that it was very difficult to follow the presentation as two different print versions, of the material, had been supplied with the agenda and requested that a copy of the final presentation be supplied to members with graphs and charts clearly labelled.
Paragraphs 4.24 and 4.31 of the report do not convey the full picture in that the Access Group have been working with the new Robin Hood Centre and have kept users informed at all stages regarding accessibility. ii) Councillor McCoy asked if the assessment took into account the increasing use of larger sized wheelchairs?
Councillor Jayne McCoy, the Chair outlined the role of the new local committee and how it would operate. She advised that although Special Advisors were drawn from local Residents Associations, Tenants Associations and Friends of Parks, she hoped everyone would still take part and have a say and particularly welcomed the Friends of Wallington Library and Gardens. The Chair advised that if Special Advisors felt they had an item of particular interest on the agenda, they should contact the Area Co-ordinator who would make a place available for them at the Committee table.
Councillor Jayne McCoy declared a personal interest as the Vice Chair of Sutton, Epsom & District Branch of The National Childbirth Trust.
The application had been de-delegated by Councillor Jayne McCoy.
[name removed], an objector, and Councillor Jayne McCoy, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 33.
The principal issues raised by [name removed] were:- The design was similar to the previous design that had been considered unacceptable by the planning inspectorate The proposed building lacked symmetry, it was bigger and deeper than the previous design, and the roof height had been increased The applicant had not submitted a site plan, which would have shown that the proposed building would fill the plot If the application was approved there would be three driveways converging at the same point on the private roadway, which would not be permitted if it were a public highway The proposed building would be out of character with other properties in the area and only four metres from the front boundary The principal issues raised by Councillor McCoy were:- The proposal constituted ‘back garden’ development in an Area of Special Local Character The ecological value of the site was as part of a larger site The design of the proposed property was abysmal The proposal would erode the character of the area The proposed building would be bland, characterless and not in keeping with others in the area The garden of the donor property would no longer be a large one Any proposed building should be of the same quality as others in the area In response to questions Councillor McCoy explained that the area was characterised by a number of large properties of which the donor property was typical.
Dan Billin, an objector, and Councillor Jayne McCoy, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 33, and Andrew Grimes and Norman Smith replied for the applicant.
In response to questions Councillor Jayne McCoy acknowledged that there were differing views about the proposed building; that on the whole residents welcomed the improved provision and increased ‘footfall’ it would bring to Wallington; but that it was larger than the existing clinic and would lead to some loss of green space. It was noted that there had not been any written objections to the application.
Councillor Roger Thistle substituted for Councillor Jayne McCoy.
The questions included the following subjects:- Councillor Jayne McCoy asked who are the vulnerable people? Adi Cooper, Strategic Director ASSH, explained that the Fair Access Framework is used as a measure of people’s vulnerability and that people are judged according to need i.e. alcohol, mental health needs etc.
Showing the latest 300 of 314.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor McCoy attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 21 May 2018 | Council | Vote of Thanks for the retiring Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 May 2016 | Council | Motion: Vote of thanks to the Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 May 2015 | Council | Motion: Vote of thanks to the Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 May 2015 | Council | Election of Mayor for Municipal Year 2015/16 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 May 2015 | Council | South London Partnership Joint Committee | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 3 Nov 2014 | Council | Motion - Sutton's Future | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 Jul 2014 | Council | Motion - Making Sutton a Dementia Friendly Borough | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Dec 2013 | Strategy and Resources Committee | Possible Closure of Crown Post Offices in Sutton | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 7 Dec 2009 | Council | Site Development Policies DPD - Proposed Submission | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Nov 2007 | Council | Committee Recommendations | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor McCoy was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 15 of 22 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor McCoy declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 Aug 2026 | Planning Committee, item 20 | In relation to items 11 and 12, Councillor Jayne McCoy declared that she lives near the application site, but that she would approach the applications with an open mind. | |
| 6 Jul 2026 | Bandon Hill Cemetery Joint Committee, item 3 | Councillor Jayne McCoy declared a non-pecuniary interest due to having family buried in the Cemetery. | |
| 3 Dec 2025 | Planning Committee, item 52 | Councillor Jayne McCoy declared that for agenda item 10: 6 Woodcote Road, Wallington, Sutton, SM6 0NN she had dedelegated the application, therefore would leave the Committee and act as ward councillor for the application and would also leave the meeting after addressing the meeting in the role of ward councillor | |
| 10 Nov 2025 | Bandon Hill Cemetery Joint Committee, item 12 | In relation to item 7, Councillor Jayne McCoy declared a non-pecuniary interest due to having family buried in the Cemetery. | |
| 1 Oct 2025 | Planning Committee, item 34 | In relation to item 39, DM2025/00171 - 69 Cornwall Road Councillor Jayne McCoy declared that she was acquainted with the objector, [name removed] , but was not predetermined | |
| 2 Apr 2025 | Planning Committee, item 63 | In regard to agenda item 6, DM2023/01839, 79 - 85 Beddington Lane Beddington Sutton CR0 4TH, Councillor Jayne McCoy declared that she is a trustee of the Wandle Valley Regional Park Trust which is referenced in the report and was not predetermined on the application. | |
| 4 Dec 2024 | Planning Committee, item 38 | · Councillor Jayne McCoy declared that, in her role as ward councillor, she had submitted objections to previous applications on the site and had spoken with the applicant. She had confirmed that she had not been involved in this application and would approach it with an open mind. | |
| 7 Jun 2023 | Planning Committee, item 4 | In regard to item 7 - DM2022/02131, 219-227 High Street - Councillor Jayne McCoy declared that she had previously visited the site in her previous role as the Chair of the Housing, Economy and Business Committee but was not predetermined on the application. | |
| 1 Feb 2023 | Planning Committee, item 55 | In regard to item 5, DM2021/02555, Councillor Jayne McCoy declared that she had previously been involved in the pre-application stages of the application in her previous role as the Chair of the Housing, Economy and Business Committee but was not predetermined on the application. | |
| 6 Jul 2022 | Planning Committee, item 18 | In relation to item 8, DM2022/00267, Councillor Jayne McCoy declared that she had previously been briefed on some strategic aspects of the application in her previous role as the Chair of the Housing, Economy and Business Committee but was not predetermined on the application. | |
| 8 Oct 2019 | Housing, Economy and Business Committee, item 14 | Councillor Jayne McCoy declared a non-pecuniary interest in Item 6 as she is a trustee of the Wandle Valley Regional Park Trust. | |
| 1 Oct 2013 | Beddington and Wallington Local Committee, item 916 | “Councillor Jayne McCoy declared an interest as the Trustee of the Wandle Valley Regional Park Trust. The Committee commended the work of Beddington Park Friends and the Parks Service and were wish success in their bid to Heritage Lottery Fund.” Matters Arising Roberta Fusco, Locality Lead Officer, gave an update various matters raised by Springboard Resident Association and Mellows Park Residents Association. Community representative, [name removed] volunteered to assist with the repositioning of flower troughs and Christmas Lights. | |
| 25 Jun 2013 | Beddington and Wallington Local Committee, item 639 | As part of the project it was explained that plans are in place to possibly employ a member of staff to recruit volunteers and foster capacity building Councillor Jayne McCoy declared an interest as Trustee of the Wandle Valley Regional Park Trust. The committee commended the work of Beddington Park Friends and the Parks Service and were wished success in their Bid to Heritage Lottery Fund. | |
| 16 Apr 2009 | Merton, Sutton and Surrey Joint Health Scrutiny Committee, item 2 | · Councillor Jayne McCoy declared a personal interest as a member of Sutton, Epsom & District Branch of The National Childbirth Trust. | |
| 8 Oct 2007 | Better Healthcare Closer to Home Joint Health Scrutiny, item 2 | Councillor Jayne McCoy declared a personal interest as the Vice Chair of Sutton, Epsom & District Branch of The National Childbirth Trust. |
Where Councillor McCoy sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | May 2006 | 128 | 23 Nov 2026 |
| Beddington and Wallington Local Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2007 | 82 | 8 Dec 2026 |
| Planning Committee | Chair | May 2022 | 46 | 2 Dec 2026 |
| Audit and Governance Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2022 | 19 | 16 Dec 2026 |
| Bandon Hill Cemetery Joint Committee | Chair | Nov 2024 | 5 | |
| Strategy and Resources Committee | Substitute | May 2012 | 69 | |
| Housing, Economy and Business Committee | Chair | Jun 2012 | 45 | |
| The Executive | Executive Councillor | May 2010 | 25 | |
| Sutton Shareholdings Board | Vice-Chair | Aug 2015 | 24 | |
| Planning Advisory Group | Chair | Jun 2010 | 20 | |
| Senior Officer Appointment Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2015 | 16 | |
| Appeals Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2006 | 15 | |
| Health and Well Being Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2007 | 15 | |
| Scrutiny Overview Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2008 | 14 | |
| Development Control Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2009 | 14 | |
| Housing Advisory Group | Chair | Jan 2011 | 12 | |
| Senior Officer Appointment (Ad Hoc) Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Nov 2010 | 11 | |
| Beddington and Wallington Area Committee | Chair | Jan 2006 | 9 | |
| Merton, Sutton and Surrey Joint Health Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2008 | 9 | |
| Economic Development Advisory Group | Chair | Jun 2010 | 8 | |
| Health Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2006 | 7 | |
| Asset Management Advisory Group | Committee Member | Jul 2010 | 7 | |
| Wallington Forum | Committee Member | Jul 2006 | 6 | |
| Better Healthcare Closer to Home Joint Health Scrutiny | Committee Member | Nov 2006 | 6 | |
| Licensing Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2006 | 5 | |
| Audit Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2007 | 4 | |
| Licensing (Miscellaneous Functions) Committee | Committee Member | May 2006 | 3 | |
| Licensing Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Dec 2006 | 2 | |
| Urgency Committee | Chair | May 2021 | 2 | |
| Transport and Traffic Strategy Committee Advisory Group | Substitute | Jul 2006 | 1 | |
| Joint Tier 4 Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2009 | 1 | |
| Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Jun 2023 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.