Election of Chair
Councillor Jo Elgarf motioned that Councillor Richard Clifton be elected Chair, this was seconded by Councillor Alison Long.
Every time Sutton's minutes name Councillor Clifton, as the council published it.
Councillor Jo Elgarf motioned that Councillor Richard Clifton be elected Chair, this was seconded by Councillor Alison Long.
Councillor Richard Clifton (chair) Councillor Jo Elgarf Councillor Alison Long Applicant:
Councillor Richard Clifton motioned that Councillor Trish Fivey be elected Chair, this was seconded by Councillor Wendy Clark.
The amendment was seconded by Councillor Richard Clifton and agreed by the committee.
Councillor Richard Clifton motioned that Councillor Trish Fivey be elected Chair, this was seconded by Councillor Wendy Clark.
Councillor Jayne McCoy moved to the public gallery and Councillor Richard Clifton took the Chair.
Councillor Jake Short moved an amendment which was seconded by Councillor Richard Clifton.
Councillor Lisa Webster motioned that Councillor Richard Clifton be elected as Chair.
Councillor Richard Clifton (Chair) Councillor Lisa Webster Councillor Jillian Green Those making relevant representations:
Councillor Richard Clifton motioned that Trish Fivey be elected Chair, this was seconded by Councillor Wendy Clark.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present.
Recorded Vote Title Type Recorded Vote text Result DM2024/00963 - Proposed Development Land Rear Of 107 And 109 Boundary Road, Wallington SM6 0TE Committee Report A poll vote on the officers’ recommendation was held in accordance with Standing Order 31.4 Rejected DM2024/00963 - Proposed Development Land Rear Of 107 And 109 Boundary Road, Wallington SM6 0TE Motion Councillor Richard Clifton proposed the following motion:
Councillor Richard Clifton motioned that Councillor Louise Phelan be elected Chair, this was seconded by Councillor Wendy Clark.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present and those watching the live stream.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, declared that he was a member of the Mitcham Common Conservaters , the body which manages the junction in consideration for item DM2024/00469 - Junction Of Goat Road, Carshalton Road and London Road, Mitcham. He stated that the Conservaters were neutral on the application and he would approach the issue with an open mind.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present and those watching the live stream.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present and those watching the live stream.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present and those watching the live stream.
In regard to agenda item 6, DM2022/02277 - 2-4 Copse Hill And 52-54 Brighton Road, Sutton SM2 6AD, Councillor Richard Clifton declared that as a ward councillor he was aware of the application, and had played an active part working with residents in relation to a previous application at the site. He explained that he was able to approach this revised application with an open mind and was not predetermined on the application.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton welcomed those present and those watching the live stream.
Councillor Richard Clifton motioned that Councillor Bobby Dean be elected Chair, this was seconded by Councillor Wendy Clark
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, declared that, along with Councillors Jayne McCoy, Luke Taylor, Jake Short, Trish Fivey , Sam Cumber, Tim Foster, and Param Nandha attended a site visit on Friday 24 November to view one of the applicant’s developments that had been partially completed. The visit had been hosted by the applicant and light refreshments were provided. It was noted that the visit had been open to all members of the Committee and was organised for the purposes of information gathering.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present and watching the live stream.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present and watching the live stream.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present and watching the live stream.
On item 6 - DM2021/01562 27 Mayfield Road Sutton SM2 5DU - Councillor Richard Clifton declared that he had previously expressed a view on the application as part of the process of him de-delegating the application. The Chair confirmed that he would not participate in the debate or the vote and would leave the meeting room for the duration of the item.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton left the meeting room at 19:11.
The application had been de-delegated by Councillor Richard Clifton and had received more than ten letters of objection contrary to officers’ recommendation.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton re-joined the meeting at 20:38.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present and watching the live stream.
In regard to agenda item 6, DM2022/01662 - Treetops, Hillcroome Road, Sutton SM2 5EL Councillor Richard Clifton declared that as a ward councillor and local resident he was aware of the application, and had supported residents in relation to a previous application at the site. He explained that he was able to approach this application with an open mind and was not predetermined on the application.
This was proposed by Councillor Richard Clifton and seconded by Councillor Trish Fivey and agreed by all members. The Committee thanked [name removed] for his contributions over the years.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present and watching the live stream.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present and watching the live stream.
Councillor Richard Clifton moved a motion of thanks to the Mayor.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present and watching the live stream.
Councillor Richard Clifton and [name removed]: Other Persons Officers:
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present and watching the live stream.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present and watching the live stream.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present and watching the live stream.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present and watching the live stream.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present and watching the live stream, and announced that he would reorder the agenda to take item 9 - DM2022/01010 - 4 Hindhead Way - as the first application.
The motion was moved by Cllr David Bartolucci and seconded by Councillor Richard Clifton.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present.
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present and watching the live stream.
Councillor Richard Clifton proposed Councillor Trish Fivey , Councillor Marian James seconded the nomination. There being no further nominations, the motion was put to the vote and carried.
The motion was moved by Cllr Steve Cook and seconded by Cllr Richard Clifton.
Councillor Richard Clifton declared that he knew the registered objector, for agenda item 8 [name removed] through council business and this would not affect his decision.
The motion was moved by Councillor Clifton and seconded by Councillor Gordon An amendment was moved by Councillor Drummond and seconded by Councillor Foster.
This was proposed by Councillor Richard Clifton and seconded by Councillor Tony Shields and unanimously agreed by all members.
The motion was moved by Councillor Ruth Dombey and seconded by Councillor Richard Clifton.
DM2020/01653 - 11 BARLOW CLOSE, WALLINGTON SM6 9DR Motion A motion was moved by Councillor Drew Heffernan to defer the planning application so that deficiencies identified in the CLP regarding Dymond House and the rear access point can be clarified to the Committee.This was seconded by Councillor Richard Clifton and a poll vote on the motion was held in accordance with Standing Order 31.4, when there voted:
DM2020/02070 - PURLEY SPORTS CLUB THE RIDGE PURLEY CR8 3PF Motion Councillor Richard Clifton, moved the following motion:
Councillor Richard Clifton welcomed the proposals and congratulated Sutton United Football Club on their promotion to the football league.
Councillor Richard Clifton congratulated Councillor Neil Garratt on his election to the London Assembly for Croydon and Sutton.
Councillor Steve Cook proposed that Councillor Richard Clifton be elected as Chair for the duration of the meeting, this was seconded by Councillor Tom Drummond.
Councillor Richard Clifton (Chair) Councillor Steve Cook Councillor Tom Drummond Applicant:
Councillor Jillian Green proposed that Councillor Jake Short be elected as Chairfor the duration of the meeting, this was seconded by Councillor Richard Clifton .
The motion was moved by Councillor Richard Clifton and seconded by Councillor Annie Moral.
The application had been de-delegated by Councillor Richard Clifton and 10 objections have been received.
Nicola Sharp, Cedar Court Board, an objector, and Councillor Richard Clifton, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 31, and the applicant replied.
The principal issues raised by Councillor Richard Clifton were:- · The application had been opposed by more than ten residents · The frontage is narrow, with the majority of the building being to the rear.
Councillor Richard Clifton proposed Councillor Jake Short be the Chair for the duration of the meeting, this was seconded by Councillor Eric Allen. Resolved that :
It was motioned by Councillor Hicks and seconded by Councillor Clifton that this committee recommend to the Lead Member for Environmental services, to use their delegated powers to implement a 20MPH zone in The Downsway and the Crossways, to complement the 20MPH zone in the roads to the North of those roads.
Councillor Clifton proposed that Councillor Jake Short be elected as Chair for the duration of the meeting.
This was seconded by Councillor Richard Clifton.
Councillor Richard Clifton proposed Councillor Trish Fivey , Councillor Annie Moral seconded the nomination.
Councillor Clifton asked why the tree in Christchurch Park had not been planted and if the motorbike restriction signage in Dorset Road could be enforced. It was confirmed that the Tree Officers had been delayed due to emergency work caused by the recent storms and the new signage could be enforced as it had now changed to a prohibited sign.
Councillor Clifton asked if the 60+ Oyster Card could be used as payment. [name removed] responded that the app would not allow any Oyster card to be used as payment. Andrew Behan, a resident, asked how the trial was able to operate in the area north of Carshalton Road, as this was marked out for no buses.
Councillor Clifton fed back that he was glad the cricket pitch in Overton Park was going ahead. He also asked whether the installation of 2 warning notices in Netley Close to reduce littering could be analysed to measure the impact to understand if they have been effective. Peter Mattey , Belmont and South Cheam Residents Association, asked why a funding bid for street trees was absent in the report.
Councillor Clifton asked if project 18/19.1 regarding replacement of trees had been completed and asked if the completed schemes should be added into the report for completeness. The chair requested that a revised list of the completed schemes please be circulated to all Committee Members.
The Chair Councillor Jill Whitehead welcomed those present, and in particular extended a warm welcome to the new committee members, Councillor Richard Clifton, Vice Chair, and Councillor Sam Weatherlake, and to all guests
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, welcomed those present.
Councillor Richard Clifton moved the motion which was seconded by Councillor Steve Penneck .
Councillor Clifton queried page 35 of the report and advised that the tree on the Ridgeway has not yet been replaced. He also advised that the flashing speed signs on the Farm Road show the speed of travel but that the speed signs in Cedar Road do not display the speed information. Members requested that the signs in Cedar Road be configured to show the speed, as that is thought to be a more effective deterrent for drivers.
Regarding the increase in care for young people, Councillor Clifton noted the rising demand and pressures on the council.
Councillor Richard Clifton formally moved the adoption of the minute, which was put to the vote and carried.
Councillor Richard Clifton welcomed those present to the first meeting of the Audit and Governance Committee.
Following the presentation, Councillor Richard Clifton thanked officers for the thought put into the induction programme of 2018. The Chair then invited newly-elected members in particular to give their views:
Councillor Richard Clifton expressed his belief that this report should refer to the committee as the Audit Committee in the context of 2017/18. He further suggested that photos of the Councillors be removed and that the introduction be written by the Chair of the committee in 2017/18.
The application had been de-delegated by Councillor Clifton and Councillor Shields Members sought clarification on the building the ridge height and also how this compares to the previously refused scheme. In particular clarification was requested on the floor plan specifically the proposed use of the new room. Officers confirmed the existing ridge height is 7m and proposed is 8.4 metres, the officer showed the ridge height compared to the house next door.
Mary Naughton an objector, and Councillor Clifton, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 31, and the applicant replied.
The principal issues raised by the objector Mary Naughton were:- This is an area of special of local character, which is green and spacious people living here wish to protect it Current houses are large with large gardens, when originally built number 2 was smaller and created in a curve The position of the house is near the listed building which is a tennis pavilion and merits protection The proposal would result in harm to neighbouring occupiers, people living here benefit from heritage of the estate inspiring people to protect it The first floor extension would increase size by more than half, and would have 3 times more roof space The principal issues raised by Ward Councillor Clifton were:- He was here as he understood that residents are concerned, and Highfield residents association had submitted letter of objection.
Councillor Shields asked Councillor Clifton if the concern is that this will be another step in the erosion in the area of special local character. He responded that he ... view the full minutes text for item 16.
Councillor Richard Clifton suggested that security in the park be reviewed and more positive activity promoted.
Councillor Richard Clifton suggested that the proposal for a jogging track Overton Park be subsumed into other related works on the park.
The application had been de-delegated by Councillor Richard Clifton.
A restriction of working hours could be put in place in regards to building works George Kiselov and Anne Mitchell, objectors, and Councillor Richard Clifton, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 31.
Councillor Richard Clifton proposed Councillor Steve Cook, Councillor Stephen Penneck seconded the nomination.
Councillor Clifton mentioned the reference on page 15 of the agenda papers regarding Heritable Bank and was pleased to note that all the investment had been repaid.
Councillor Clifton enquired about recruitment of volunteers for the CAB. Steve Triner informed the Committee that the CAB is a well-known charity and its volunteers are usually students or young professionals seeking experience e.g. law students or retired professionals who have the spare time. The Committee noted the update.
Councillor Jayne McCoy moved an amendment to the motion which was seconded by Councillor Richard Clifton, as attached at Appendix E.
Councillor Richard Clifton apologised that he would need to leave the meeting early, and Councillor Marlene Heron apologised for lateness.
These are 02087212497 - Sutton South 02087283820 - Cheam 020987212829 - Belmont 0208 721 2448 - Sutton West Councillor Pascoe asked that the phone numbers be added to Sutton Neighbourhood team website, and the Officer confirmed this will be done.Councillor Clifton asked if roll out of Smartwater kits can be extended, to all Ward Areas.
Once proposals are developed there will be a stage one presentation to residents and this will come back to local committee.The Highways team are currently drawing up plans for community engagement sessions in late October Councillor Clifton asked what are the agreed consultation areas and also if options such as yellow lines for one hour a day are being considered. Ian Price confirmed that the first stage consultation will give options and second stage will be to seek information on what residents would like to see implemented. He advised that the consultation areas will be shared with the Committee Councillors.
Councillor Clifton raised with the committee a new scheme called the Royal British Legion Silent Soldier Campaign. He asked for committee views on supporting this. He advised that it would cost £100 for each “Silent Soldier statue”.
Councillor Clifton raised a motioned to support this campaign by purchasing 3 Silent Soldier Statues.
Councillor Richard Clifton informed the Committee that as Mayor he was recently invited to an event to celebrate work done by the police. PC Mark Towler was recognised for his work in Sutton South ward and was congratulated by the Committee.
Councillor Richard Clifton asked about cyclepods in Cambourne Road and the Senior Engineer confirmed that consultation would be undertaken.
Councillor Steve Penneck moved a vote of thanks to the Mayor Councillor Richard Clifton which was seconded by Councillor Samantha Bourne.
The Mayor, Councillor Richard Clifton responded to the vote of thanks.
Steve Triner also spoke about outreach work to smaller organisations Councillor Clifton asked if an advocacy service is provided for residents. Steve Triner of Citizens Advice Sutton confirmed the Service can provide services of a legal aid housing solicitor and help people prepare for employment and welfare benefit appeals.
Councillor Clifton highlighted that the Highfields traffic scheme was identified as a reserve scheme, yet it was a scheme in progress.
Councillor Richard Clifton advised that he hoped that funding would be found for the 20mph zones in Grange Road and Worcester Road as listed.
Resolved That Councillor Richard Clifton be duly elected as Mayor of the London Borough of Sutton for the municipal year 2016/17.
The Mayor (Councillor Richard Clifton) in the Chair.
A statement was read out by Vice Chair Councillor Bourne, acting as Chair, on behalf of Councillor Clifton, explaining the reasons for his absence.
Councillor Richard Clifton, Non Pecuniary, as he was a resident of The Ridgway.
To grant (7) Councillors Jason Reynolds, Kevin Burke, Hamish Pollock, Samantha Bourne, Vincent Galligan , Graham Whitham , Hanna Zuchowska Against (2) Councillors Tony Shields, Patrick McManus Abstained (1) Councillor Richard Clifton
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton, announced that Item 5 on the agenda ( application no. D2016/73695/FUL - 23-50 Richmond Green) had been deferred to a future meeting. The Chair also brought items 11 and 9 forward to the beginning of the agenda.
Councillor Richard Clifton raised a motion to grant permission with an extra condition that the bathroom window must be obscure-glazed.
B2015/73049 - KINGSCROFT HOUSE, 27 CEDAR ROAD, SUTTON, SM2 5FL Councillor Richard Clifton, Personal, as he knew the previous owner of the property, a former Member of Sutton Council, and visited the property some years ago.
Against (1) Councillor Kevin Burke Abstained (1) Councillor Richard Clifton
The Chair, Councillor Richard Clifton left the meeting for discussion of this item.
Councillor Richard Clifton noted that when he visited the site he concluded that there were no local residents who would get more than a distant and oblique view of the garden of Chegworth Nursing Home other than a resident at the back, but when he investigated further he found that this house had been demolished. Councillors discussed concerns about landscaping and the unfortunate instance of asbestos being found at the site.
Councillor Richard Clifton, Prejudicial, as ward councillor he had dealt very closely with residents on earlier applications and his views were well known and with that in mind could not consider this application with an open mind. He withdrew from the meeting when this item was discussed..
Councillor Richard Clifton noted his support of the proposal and expressed the view that all relevant ward councillors should be involved.
Reason: To avoid unacceptable impacts on the amenities currently enjoyed by the occupants of nearby premises, local amenity and the highway network.” Councillor Richard Clifton asked why planning permission was needed for buildings within the site, and Officers informed him that each of the buildings had their own planning conditions.
Councillor Richard Clifton attended as substitute.
In response to a question from Councillor Richard Clifton, Kevin Holland advised that each local authority decides whether or not to prosecute those found carrying out fraudulent activity as they must bear the cost of any prosecution. Kevin Holland explained that if a RIPA authorisation is required, a request will be made to the appropriate officer in each authority.
Councillor Richard Clifton asked why the rate of applications is so low, given the public perception of high rates of tenancy fraud. Peter Rollins explained that a lot of actions to uncover fraud can be taken without using RIPA, and much of the work has been delegated to the Department of Work and Pensions and to the South West London Fraud Partnership.
A motion was raised by Councillor Richard Clifton for a condition to be included that the applications would be reviewed after one year. Andy Webber, Head of Development Management and Strategic Planning, advised that this would be possible for planning application C2015/72574/FUL but not for C2015/72575/FUL as it is not permissible to add a condition to make temporary a proposal to remove a condition, the proposal to remove condition 2 must be either approved or refused.
Councillor Richard Clifton spoke in place of the Chair of the Project Board, Councillor Simon Wales. He highlighted the popularity of the opening of the side entrance and commended all involved in the project for delivering within time and budget.
Councillor Richard Clifton, Non Pecuniary, as the report contained significant reference to former Councillor John Drage who was a colleague of Councillor Clifton on the Council between 2010-2014.
Councillor Clifton informed the meeting that he would approach any information under item 6 with due objectivity.
Cllr Clifton reiterated the statement he had made at the start of the meeting under declarations of interests.
Against (7) Councillors Samantha Bourne, Moira Butt, Margaret Court, Hamish Pollock, Jason Reynolds, Tony Shields and Graham Whitham Abstained (1) Councillor Richard Clifton
Councillor Steve Penneck moved the motion which was seconded by Councillor Richard Clifton.
Councillor Clifton noted his role as Chair of the Planning Committee and that the discussion today should not prejudice the decision of that committee in due course.
Councillor Richard Clifton noted his support for these comments, and suggested the borough adopt a “Twenty’s plenty” approach.
Outside Body Liberal Democrat Appointments Conservative Appointments Local Government Association Councillors Dombey, Wales, vacancy Councillor Tim Crowley Mitcham Common Conservators Councillors Court and vacancy Councillor Neil Garratt Roundshaw Homes (aka Roundshaw Residents' Assurance Committee) Councillor Melican Royal Marsden NHS Trust Council of Governors vacant The Surrey Countryside Partnership Board (formerly Downlands Countryside Management Project Steering Group) Councillors Joyce and Zuchowska Sutton Partnership Board Councillors Dombey, Wales, vacancy Councillor Tony Shields Sutton Safer Neighbourhood Board Councillors Dombey, Gordon, Burke Councillor Moira Butt Wandle Valley Regional Park Trust Cllrs McCoy, Whitehead Substitutes Nick Emmerson , Nighat Piracha Greater London Employment Forum Councillor Richard Clifton
Councillor Richard Clifton noted that the cost of Christmas Lights would account for almost one third of the public realm budget. After some discussion the Committee agreed the indicative cost detailed within the report and looked forward to receiving further detail on exact costs and locations at the July meeting.
Councillor Richard Clifton noted his concern at allocating a further £6000 from the Public Realm budget, but the Committee felt they would be a useful and beneficial addition to the parks.
Councillor Clifton raised several points on the paper:
(a) Motion – Delivering Affordable Housing for Sutton Residents Councillor Jayne McCoy moved the motion which was seconded by Councillor Richard Clifton.
Abstained (1) Councillor Richard Clifton.
Matters Arising The Committee agreed with Councillor Richard Clifton to show gratitude to the four Councillors Peter Geiringer , Heather Honour, Pam Picknett and Jonathan Pritchard, who retired from the Committee at the election on 22 May 2014.
In response to a question from Councillor Richard Clifton, [name removed] stated that there are plans to have the lighting at the station changed. He said that he will ask the project Board if there is Christmas light funding available for Brighton Road. He explained that the new lighting will accommodate power to allow Christmas lights.
Councillor Richard Clifton raised concerns that the proposed introduction of waiting restrictions in Langley Park Road would displace the issue to other roads. In response to a question, Paul Blunt gave his views on whether the measures were necessary. It was explained that the restrictions would improve sightlines, but they were not essential and leaving them out would not cause significant problems.
Councillor Richard Clifton gave his support for the giant poppy proposal, installation of benches at 6 locations in South Sutton and the new trees in Sutton Court Garden.
Cllr Clifton noted that, as a regular user, he had never seen any advance notice of the works. [name removed] noted the measures that had been used to involve the public and users.
Councillor Clifton asked about the Cavendish Road/Cedar Road scheme and wanted to know why work could not commence immediately in the new financial year. A commencement would be sought early in the year, but there would be a requirement to consult and to seek Traffic Regulation Orders.
Councillor Clifton reminded the meeting that Sutton was one of very few Boroughs in London that provided free visitor parking permits, but Councillor Hicks was clear that this was a commitment made by the Council which had been reduced to the detriment of residents.
This being the last meeting of the Committee before the local elections Councillor Richard Clifton thanked both councillors and officers for their service to the Committee. He thought that the decision of the Council to move to a committee form or governance, rather than an executive model, had been a success. He thanked the Chair for the calm and competent way in which she had ensured that business was discharged and all had had their say.
Councillor Clifton was concerned that the institutions were taking the lead and wanted assurance that the partnership was working to get the best for Sutton residents. [name removed] stated that the partnership and the Masterplan would proceed and that it is important that the Council worked with partners to achieve benefit for the Borough and for the community.
Councillor Heather Honour, accompanied by Councillor Richard Clifton, both representing an adjoining ward, [name removed] and [name removed] , objectors, and Councillors Peter Geiringer and David Hicks, ward councillors, addressed the meeting under ... view the full minutes text for item 1202.
Angela Purdue Shanklin Residents Hannah Witkowska Sutton South Neighbourhood Association Peter Mattey Belmont and South Cheam RA Claudia Money CHAPRA Adrian Simpson Highfields RA Jason Hughes Friends of Overton Park Councillor Clifton requested confirmation that the two schemes he proposed, listed in minute 897, are included in the EIP programme. [name removed] (Executive Head of Commissioning) confirmed that all four schemes listed under that item are under consideration in the Environmental Improvement Programme.
Councillor Clifton was assured that the four schemes at Dorset Road, Willis Avenue, The Avenue and Albion Road were still under consideration as part of the Environmental Improvement Programme. Officers confirmed that schemes at Albion Road and Willis Avenue are included in the Programme and the others schemes are awaiting consideration.
In accordance with notice given, Councillor Jayne McCoy moved and Councillor Richard Clifton seconded the following Motion “This Council welcomes the news released recently by the ONS that a million more people are in work compared to early 2010 and that in Sutton the rate of JSA claimants has decreased by over 11% in the last year, with a 30% drop in the number of young people claiming JSA over the same period.
[name removed] , an objector, and Councillor Richard Clifton, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 31.
The principal issues raised by Councillor Clifton were:- · Retrospective planning applications for the office block and dining room had both resulted in altered buildings · The fire escape was the remaining element of past works · The fire escape was to have had a glass roof but it never happened · Officers had acknowledged that the fire escape was not of the highest design quality · Members had to judge whether or not the design bad enough to justify refusal In response to a question Councillor Clifton explained that the fire escape was to serve additional bedrooms and join two buildings.
The Committee took a break at 8.30pm for 15 minutes and Cllr Clifton left the meeting at this point.
Councillor Clifton asked about the consultation. He was informed that it would run for three months and would be open to all. A wide range of publicity would be used to bring opportunities to be informed and comment before people.
Councillor Clifton also asked about Accident and Emergency (A+E) services. If these were overloaded was it not the policy to discourage their use? The process should abide by the outcome of the consultation.
Cllr Clifton stated that Jack Hamilton’s suggestion, during the Community session of using living streets and home zones as a way of finding play space for children, was an interesting idea and suggested that officers give this further thought. Paul Blunt indicated that these are quite expensive would be particularly difficult to fund in a climate of reduced funding.
Councillor Clifton referred to the Ward Panel meeting for Sutton South at which priorities were set and at which priority streets for speeding were identified. He noted the need to prioritise Cedar Road and Cavendish Road.
Councillor Clifton welcomed the proposals and hoped that the junction of Brighton Road and Cedar Road could be realigned. [name removed] recognised this as a possibility.
Councillor Clifton also sought ‘countdown’ lights across Brighton Road; this was already proposed. He also hoped for improvements to the Public Realm outside Sutherland House.
Councillor Clifton thanked Amy for her help with this and other schemes.
Councillor Clifton had submitted two schemes for inclusion in the list in Appendix A, for Willis Avenue and Albion Road.
Councillor Clifton raised concerns that there had not been sufficient or appropriate consultation on the proposals.
[name removed], an objector, and Councillor Richard Clifton, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 31, and the applicant, [name removed], replied.
The principal issues raised by Councillor Clifton were:- · The application site had been subject to three different designs · The applicant had apologised and claimed the changes were unimportant · The development should have been built according to the permission granted · Officers had advised that the changes were acceptable · The roof was higher, the windows were different and the bays were wider · Refusal would mean either demolition of the building or an appeal to the Planning Inspectorate The principal issues raised by [name removed] were:- · The development was on the approved building line · Construction had commenced before expiry of the planning consent · The windows were not significantly bigger · The building was not significantly different from the permitted scheme · The Council’s officers had not been consulted, for ... view the full minutes text for item 713.
Councillor Richard Clifton presented a précis of the report and highlighted the fact that the Committee had been able to compare two different policies over two different periods of time, which had helped the Committee form its view that the procedures set out in Appendix 1 to the report were the procedures most likely to minimise homelessness, while being fair to landlords and fully discharging the Council's statutory duties.
Cllr Richard Clifton addressed the committee as Ward Councillor for Sutton South. He explained some of the benefits the new development would bring to the area. He favoured incentives to encourage existing users of Brighton Road car park to move to Gibson Road and Times Square.
Councillor Clifton added his support for the Cavendish Road/Cedar Road scheme and was disappointed to note that no earlier funding has been identified as hoped.
This minute was subsequently changed to read: Cllr Clifton stated that Jack Hamilton’s suggestion, during the Community session of using living streets and home zones as a way of finding play space for children, was an interesting idea and suggested that officers give this further thought. Paul Blunt indicated that these are quite expensive would be particularly difficult to fund in a climate of reduced funding.
Resolved i ) To make a Neighbourhood Grant of £500 to Cheam Traders association Councillor Clifton reported that an application was being prepared by the Guide Group.
The principal issues raised by Councillor Clifton were:- · Because of the planning history of the application site any further planning application should be submitted to the Committee for consideration · The proposed work was the third example of work that had been started without planning permission · Other extensions at the application site still failed to comply with planning permissions · The applicant had given an undertaking in 2010 that there would be no further building work at the site · The applicant’s history of failure to comply with planning legislation should be noted Members noted the history of retrospective planning applications for the application site and expressed considerable frustration at the applicant’s repeated flouting of planning legislation and procedures, and in particular that some work to secure compliance with existing planning permissions had still to be carried out. However they noted that it was not an offence to start building work pending planning permission and that the Authority could not instigate enforcement action until it had refused planning permission. The application was considered in the context of what was proposed and the structures on the application site as a whole, and the officers’ view that it would not cause harm to the amenity of neighbouring properties.
At the start of the debate, [name removed] and Councillor Richard Clifton addressed the committee. [name removed] expressed the following concerns - noise and dirt from the demolition of the existing car park, where were the construction workers going to park, loss of privacy to local residents and what was the financial gain to the Council.
Councillor Clifton indicated he was in favour of the proposal but expressed a number of concerns that he felt must be addressed. These included a financial incentive for drivers to use Gibson Road car park when they were displaced from Brighton Road, resident’s only parking schemes must be introduced for local estates, the outcome of the development must be monitored and action taken to alleviate any problems that arose and that efforts should be made to extend the existing car park at Sutton Railway Station.
In response, it was stated that most of the concerns expressed by [name removed] and Councillor Clifton would be dealt with as part of the planning process. Discussions with Southern Rail to see if they would be prepared to increase the size of their car park would also be started.
The principal issues raised by [name removed] were:- · Loss of amenity · There would be a 12 metre wall within about ten feet of his kitchen · The flank boundary was believed to be 1.5 metres from the proposed extension · The depth of the extension was designed to be just within government guidelines · The distance had been measured from an existing extension · The proposed extension would be twice the size of an extension at the nursing home in Mayfield Road · The proposed extension would be out of proportion to the existing house · Guidelines set expectations and were not necessarily intended to permit the scale proposed The principal issues raised by Councillor Clifton were:- · The previous de-delegation had been withdrawn following the withdrawal of an objection and in the knowledge that the application was to be referred to the Committee anyway · Initial concerns had mostly been dealt with · [name removed] believed that the proposed extension would harm the amenity of his property · Impact on the street scene In response to a question officers explained that there was presently a vehicle crossover, and a car port and parking space within the cartilage of the site; and that there would still be room for at least one parking space after construction of the proposed extension.
Councillor Clifton suggested bins could be rationalised, but commended the speed with which they were replenished and the strategy used by council workers to avoid any empty grit bins.
Councillor Clifton queried the crime figures, quoting from the Office of National Statistics figures published on the day of the meeting. He was concerned about how harassment was defined and why there had been such an increase. Inspector Rowe noted that offences around social media were new and contributing to the increase; however a new code of conduct was expected on the definition.
Councillor Clifton commended the SNT on data that was presented to the safer neighbourhood panel the previous week stating that crime was down 13% from last year in South Sutton.
Councillor Clifton asked whether there would be any concerns from the Police about a children’s play area at Brighton Road and was advised that this would not be a problem.
“This council believes that fairness is at the heart of it's activities and does not seek to be bullying in its’ administration.” Councillor Ruth Dombey moved and Councillor Richard Clifton seconded the following amendment “ This council confirms believes that fairness has always been is at the heart of it’s its activities and condemns does not seek to be bullying in all its forms. its ’ administration .” Following debate, the amendment was adopted on a show of hands. The Motion, as amended, was adopted.
In accordance with notice given, in the absence of Councillor Jayne McCoy, Councillor Richard Clifton moved and Councillor Colin Hall seconded the Motion set out as Appendix C to these Minutes.
Councillor Clifton had presented the petition to Full Council on 15 July and paid tribute to [name removed] for compiling the petition. The majority of signatories were elderly and scared of speeding traffic. He noted the average speed on the road was still above the 20 mph limit.
Councillor Clifton spoke about the proposed change to train services which would mean that services on the Sutton/Wimbledon link would terminate at Blackfriars rather than go on to St Pancras and Bedford.
Councillor Clifton expressed concern at proposals from the Department of Transport that could lead to the removal of the Sutton to Bedford rail service. It was noted that consultation was underway around the franchise for this service. The Council were strongly opposed to withdrawal of the service and a public meeting was to be held on 19 July, 7.00 pm, at SCOLA.
Councillor Clifton noted that there was to be a review of parking operations and felt that the concerns raised in the petition should be included within that review.
Councillor Clifton asked for a table of projects and progress to be made available at future meetings, this was agreed.
Councillor Clifton also requested Double Yellow Lines to be introduced at Grange Court; this would be investigated and brought to a future meeting.
A request for Double Yellow Lines at Lorraine Court, Camborne Road, was re-iterated by Councillor Clifton. A sum of £1500 was agreed.
Councillor Richard Clifton was present in his place.
In accordance with notice given, Councillor Jayne McCoy moved and Councillor Richard Clifton seconded the following Motion This Council notes the findings of the Portas Review and supports the Local Government Association’s response proposing a five point plan for our high streets.
Councillor Clifton mentioned the recent refusal by the Licensing Committee to grant a licence for a club at the old Academy public house, as evidence of pressure on Police resource. Inspector Rowe gave reassurance that the Town Centre team are ring-fenced and additional support is available when needed.
Cllr Clifton raised a concern that the proposals run the possibility of displacing cars into neighbouring roads in Sutton South ward and welcomed Peter Ashley’s commitment that any changes made as part of this process will be reviewed in 18-24 months’ time. He will monitor to see ifsuch a displacement occurs.
The Minutes of the meeting held on 29 June 2011 were approved as a correct record, subject to noting that Councillor Richard Clifton had given apologies for his absence, and signed by the Chair.
Councillor Richard Clifton left the meeting at 11.12am so was not in attendance for items 6, 7a and 7b as listed on the agenda.
Councillor Clifton requested an item on the next agenda for PAG regarding Article 4 Directions under the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order 1995 with regards to how such Directions could be used to restrict developments such as take- aways .
Cllr Clifton explained that while parking on one side of the road may be more palatable to the fire service, residents were generally not in favour of any sort of restrictions.
Cllr Clifton praised Devonshire Primary School on a favourable OFSTED inspection recently.
Councillor Colin Hall moved and Councillor Richard Clifton seconded the following amendment:
Councillor Clifton asked how ‘Pupil Premium’ will affect pupils of the school. [name removed] explained what ‘Pupil Premium’ meant and how it assisted children from under privileged backgrounds and said it was an exciting avenue for the school. He said it will aid closing the gap between disadvantaged and advantaged children.
Councillor Clifton also wanted to be involved.
Councillor Clifton informed Committee that letters regarding amendments to parking restrictions in Eastleigh Close had been delivered to residents. He still needed to analyse results.
Councillor Clifton asked why the scheme regarding Belmont Controlled Parking Zone was not on the update. Ian Kershaw confirmed that this matter was having its own item on the next meeting.
Resolved : ( i ) Councillor Clifton would advise officers of Eastleigh Close responses.
It was noted that Councillor Clifton would provide [name removed] with details of a particular issue.
[name removed], an objector, and Councillor Richard Clifton, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 33, and [name removed] replied for the applicant.
The principal issues raised by Councillor Clifton were:- The trend in the area was to demolish older large houses and replace them with small flats – there were few family houses The proposal would be an over-development of the site It would be perverse to come to a different view from that of the officers The principal issues raised by [name removed] were:- Permission had been granted previously for residential development The applicant had sought to overcome all technical issues The proposal was ... view the full minutes text for item 552.
Councillor Richard Clifton, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 33, and [name removed] replied for the applicant.
The principal issues raised by Councillor Clifton were:- Local residents continued to raise concerns about the state of the building The site added to the general impression of dilapidation in the area It was expected that the additional condition would facilitate only minor changes to the application, as suggested in the report It was hoped that the Council could take steps to improve the condition of the site The principal issues raised by [name removed] were:- The scheme submitted was exactly as approved previously The additional condition would facilitate only applications for minor changes, which would be approved, or not, by the Council The ‘section 106’ agreement had been signed and the applicant wished to proceed with the development In response to questions [name removed] explained that the additional condition was sought to comply with the Government’s latest recommended practice and would simplify the process for approving minor amendments. It would be for officers to decide what constituted a minor amendment.
The Chair welcomed Councillor Richard Clifton to his first meeting of the Planning Advisory Group and introductions were made.
Councillor Clifton observed that the consultation was likely to affect adjacent areas of Carshalton and Clockhouse (which could include where he lived so he highlighted a possible personal interest) and that concerns had been raised about displacement to parts of Sutton South ward Therefore he felt that ward councillors and local associations should be involved. Highfields Residents Association had already written to the Council saying that they should have been consulted and Adrian Simpson added some comments. Furthermore a collective discussion of all ward councillors should be arranged.
Councillor Roger Thistle substituted for Councillor Clifton.
Councillor Richard Clifton reported receipt of a petition relating to insufficiency of parking of visitors to Fiske Court, a sheltered housing block in Cavendish Road. Peter Ashley, Traffic Engineer and Sutton South ward councillors agreed that the problem could be dealt with by changing the designation of bays in front of Fiske Court. This could be progressed in conjunction with work on another scheme nearby, i.e. the costs would come from the budget/ Section 106 monies for that other scheme.
These included the appointment of Councillor Richard Clifton referred to above.
[name removed], an objector, and Councillor Richard Clifton, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 33.
The principal issues raised by Councillor Clifton were:- There were four objections to the application from premises in the ward One objection was from the Licensed Taxi Drivers’ Association There was already a taxi rank at the nearby railway station Mini-cabs were largely a telephone service and so most drivers were unlikely to visit the premises There were concerns that the drivers would remain in the area and cause parking problems Members noted that only three of the objections were from nearby premises and that, regardless of the recommended condition referred to above, drivers would need to visit the office to complete financial transactions. They were concerned that the drivers would use the parking bays outside the proposed office and that the proposed use would increase traffic generation in the area and increase parking problems. They were also concerned that the recommended condition precluding drivers from visiting the proposed office would be unenforceable and noted that planning permission had been refused recently for a hot food takeaway nearby, partly on parking grounds.
The Minutes of the meeting held on 30 September were agreed as a correct record, and signed by the Chair with the inclusion of locations for street tree planting suggested by Councillor Clifton under Minute 713/10 (outside 6 and 24 Copse Hill and 41 Effingham Close).
The Chair invited Councillor Richard Clifton to report on a fund-raising dinner held on 28 August at St. John’s Church Hall. The dinner had been in aid of the Pakistan Flood Relief Appeal and organised by Humza Imam and his family.
Councillor Clifton said that the evening had featured photographs of the aftermath of the disaster and relief effort. All those present showed their appreciation of the work that Humza and his family had put into the organisation of this successful event.
Councillor Clifton responded, acknowledging that the issues were at European Union not local level. However he did not agree that the consultation was fatuous. It was agreed that a written reply would be sent to [name removed] concerning the funding of the project detailed in the committee report.
Councillor Richard Clifton said that on 8 September the South Sutton police consultative committee meeting had agreed unanimously to seek an extension of the controlled area (no drinking zone) further into Sutton South ward.
Keith Percy, resident, thanked Councillor Clifton for his help and hoped that the problem would not be displaced.
Councillor Clifton made some general comments on the public realm programme and suggested that there be evaluation or feedback given that the Committee was in effect a grant giving body. Secondly there could be a further table in the report listing suggestions for projects by local community groups. Ideas seemed to arise ad-hoc and there could be a more targeted approach to projects with regard to characteristics and needs of the Committee’s area.
Following brief input from Councillor Clifton concerning inclusion of Eaton Road in the review, the Chair said that he had already raised the Eaton Road scheme and getting best value for money with the author of the report. It had just emerged that some other section 106 money might be available for parking bay re-alignment and he felt that Sutton South ward councillors needed to have a meeting with officers to ensure that the Council got excellent best value for money, which might avoid the need to call on public realm monies (Minute 463/10 refers).
[name removed], an objector, and Councillor Richard Clifton, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 33.
The principal issues raised by Councillor Clifton were:- The proposed expansion was supported, and would be an advantage to the School and improve its layout It was acknowledged that there was a parking problem at the School It was disappointing that the only offer to relieve the parking problem was a travel plan The parking problems at the School were different from those at Barrow Hedges Primary School, considered earlier in the meeting Members noted, with concern, as they had in respect of the application for Barrow Hedges Primary School considered earlier, the reliance on a travel plan to resolve existing parking difficulties at the School. It was suggested that travel plans did not help the situation and that individual schools would need to do more to resolve the problem of parking.
[name removed], an objector, and Councillor Richard Clifton, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 33, and [name removed] replied for the applicant.
The principal issues raised by [name removed] were:- Refuse bins from premises at the rear were brought outside his bedroom window for collection Refuse left at the rear of the premises harboured flies and rats One refuse bin was shown on the application plan but the applicant’s other premises in the area had four Waste from the nearby Tesco store was left at the front of their premises Residents at the rear of the premises would suffer from increased noise It was hoped that delivery mopeds would not park at the rear of the premises There was no parking available in the area at all in the evening The application did not represent a suitable use of the premises The principal issues raised by Councillor Clifton were:- There were a significant number of objections to the application The delivery mopeds would create noise and disturbance A similar previous application had been refused because of the lack of parking Delivery mopeds would end up parked on the footway There was no room for more refuse to be stored at the rear of the premises A lot of refuse from existing premises was placed in domestic bins The principal issues raised by [name removed] were:- There had been long discussions to meet planning, environmental health and highways requirements The main activity would be between 6.30 pm and 10.30 pm, which did not coincide with heavy traffic There would be sufficient space for additional refuse bins if necessary The proposed use would not create a lot of waste Deliveries would be lim
Councillor Richard Clifton asked for a map of the grit bins in the Committee’s area and on advice he would forward suggested locations for new bins to Annette Madden. He also had suggestions for replanting of street trees in Sutton South ward and noted that the South Sutton Neighbourhood Association had match-funded the public realm allocation for tree/shrub planting in 2009/10. Peter Mattey said he was aware that 2010/11 was the year for the Belmont tree survey and any further public realm funding would be welcome.
Councillor Richard Clifton, a ward councillor, addressed the meeting under Standing Order 33, and [name removed] replied for the applicant.
The principal issues raised by Councillor Clifton were:- An objection by the Mayfield Residents’ Association had not been included in the officers’ report The proposal involved only the partial demolition of a building for which permission had been refused If permission were granted a substantial structure would remain It was doubtful that the proposal complied with planning policies The proposed building would be visually intrusive and of more substantial height The earlier building on the site had been only a shed The proposed building would be less than one metre from the northern flank boundary Local residents believed that the proposal would not be acceptable in a residential property.
In response to a question Councillor Clifton explained that the adjoining owner on the northern flank boundary had not objected to the application because it was thought that the Residents’ Association would do so, but had said that there was a lot of ‘coming and going’ to the office at night.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Clifton attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 25 Nov 2021 | Sutton South, Cheam and Belmont Local Committee | Appointment of local community representative | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 May 2018 | Council | Vote of Thanks for the retiring Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 May 2016 | Council | Motion: Vote of thanks to the Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 30 Mar 2016 | Planning Committee | APPLICATION NO. A2015/73366/FUL - 19-21 Central Road, Worcester Park, KT4 8EH | Lost | 4 for, 5 against | |
| 18 May 2015 | Council | Motion: Vote of thanks to the Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 May 2015 | Council | Election of Mayor for Municipal Year 2015/16 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 May 2015 | Council | South London Partnership Joint Committee | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 3 Nov 2014 | Council | Motion - Sutton's Future | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 Jul 2014 | Council | Motion - Making Sutton a Dementia Friendly Borough | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Dec 2013 | Strategy and Resources Committee | Possible Closure of Crown Post Offices in Sutton | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 30 Sep 2010 | Sutton South, Cheam and Belmont Local Committee | Update from the safer sutton partnership service | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Clifton was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 17 of 25 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Clifton declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6 Mar 2024 | Planning Committee, item 65 | In regard to agenda item 6, DM2022/02277 - 2-4 Copse Hill And 52-54 Brighton Road, Sutton SM2 6AD, Councillor Richard Clifton declared that as a ward councillor he was aware of the application, and had played an active part working with residents in relation to a previous application at the site. He explained that he was able to approach this revised application with an open mind and was not predetermined on the application. | |
| 6 Sep 2023 | Planning Committee, item 21 | On item 6 - DM2021/01562 27 Mayfield Road Sutton SM2 5DU - Councillor Richard Clifton declared that he had previously expressed a view on the application as part of the process of him de-delegating the application. The Chair confirmed that he would not participate in the debate or the vote and would leave the meeting room for the duration of the item. | |
| 2 Aug 2023 | Planning Committee, item 12 | In regard to agenda item 6, DM2022/01662 - Treetops, Hillcroome Road, Sutton SM2 5EL Councillor Richard Clifton declared that as a ward councillor and local resident he was aware of the application, and had supported residents in relation to a previous application at the site. He explained that he was able to approach this application with an open mind and was not predetermined on the application. | |
| 2 Feb 2022 | Planning Committee, item 69 | Councillor Richard Clifton declared that he knew the registered objector, for agenda item 8 [name removed] through council business and this would not affect his decision. |
Where Councillor Clifton sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | May 2010 | 98 | 23 Nov 2026 |
| Planning Committee | Vice-Chair | Jun 2014 | 94 | 2 Dec 2026 |
| Sutton South, Cheam and Belmont Local Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2010 | 65 | 26 Nov 2026 |
| Strategy and Resources Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2012 | 28 | |
| Licensing Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2018 | 15 | |
| Housing, Economy and Business Committee | Substitute | Jun 2012 | 25 | |
| Audit and Governance Committee | Substitute | Jul 2018 | 15 | |
| Development Control Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2012 | 13 | |
| Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Jun 2012 | 12 | |
| Pension Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2019 | 12 | |
| Standards Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2011 | 11 | |
| Licensing Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2017 | 11 | |
| Audit Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2010 | 10 | |
| Planning Advisory Group | Committee Member | Jun 2011 | 9 | |
| Health and Well Being Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2010 | 5 | |
| Economic Development Advisory Group | Committee Member | Jun 2011 | 4 | |
| Senior Officer Appointment Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2021 | 4 | |
| Sustainable Communities Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2011 | 2 | |
| Pension Board | Committee Member | Aug 2021 | 2 | |
| The Executive | Committee Member | May 2010 | 1 | |
| HWB Bulletin | Committee Member | Jul 2010 | 1 | |
| Standards (Assessment) Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2011 | 1 | |
| Standards (Hearing) Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2011 | 1 | |
| Environment and Neighbourhood Committee | Substitute | Feb 2018 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.