Confirmation of Convener
Cllr Mary Jones was confirmed as Convener of the Panel for 2026-27.
Every time Swansea's minutes name Councillor Jones, as the council published it.
Cllr Mary Jones was confirmed as Convener of the Panel for 2026-27.
The Chair welcomed Councillor Mary Jones, Convenor, Climate Change & Nature who provided the Committee with a progress report on the work / activities of the Climate Change & Nature Scrutiny Performance Panel.
· Streetscene Scrutiny Working Group – REMOVE Councillor Mary Jones.
The Chair welcomed Councillor Mary Jones, Convenor, Climate Change & Nature who provided the Committee with a progress report on the work / activities of the Climate Change & Nature Scrutiny Performance Panel). Resolved that the progress report be noted.
Cllr Mary Jones was appointed as Convener of the Panel.
· Cllr Mary Jones who chaired the original scrutiny inquiry on CAMHS congratulated the HB on all their work. She feels it is a different service now to what it was when it started out, was pleased to hear there are now referrals through Education professionals but felt the one negative issue is access to the actual service which is difficult because of where it is located in the centre of Swansea. Panel agreed it has seen a massive increase in improvement in CAMHS and is hopeful to see it continue. · Panel informed on 9 th February 2024 there will be a children’s mental health event.
Birchgrove Primary School Jade Evans Clydach Primary School Rachel Brimble Craigfelen Primary School Andrew Penalula Gorseinon Primary School Cllr Adam Davies Hendrefoilan Primary School Cllr Mary H Jones Newton Primary School [name removed] Login Fach [name removed] Comprehensive School Emily Davies John Olukoya Babalola
Cllr J Jones and Cllr M Jones both made a declaration of interest regarding Item 7
The Liberal Democrats / Independent Opposition Group amendment was proposed by Councillor C A Holley and seconded by Councillor M H Jones .
1) Councillor Mary H Jones be nominated Lord Mayor Elect 2021-2022.
Councillor Mary H Jones submitted a letter containing the Pre-decision Scrutiny Feedback.
2) Councillor Mary H Jones be nominated as Deputy Lord Mayor Elect 2020-2021.
1) Brynhyfryd Primary School Debbie Whyte 2) Brynhyfryd Primary School Cllr Mike White 3) Newton Primary School George Butterfield 4) Penclawdd Primary School Lynwen Tregembo 5) Penllergaer Primary School Alan Hussey 6) Portmead Primary School Paul Phillips 7) Seaview Primary School Cllr Cyril Anderson 8) Ynystawe Primary School Jenifer James 9) YGG Bryniago Elen Jones 10) YGG Pontybrenin Huw Evans 11) Bishopston Comprehensive School Joanne Meller 12) Cefn Hengoed Comprehensive School Sarah Cole 13) Olchfa Comprehensive School Cllr Mary Jones 14) Penyrheol Comprehensive School Cllr Kelly Roberts 15) YG Bryntawe Parch. Eirian Wyn
Councillor M H Jones, Chair of the Scrutiny Programme Committee (SPC) presented a report which was provided to support the developing relationship between Scrutiny and the Audit Committee and sharing of information.
Councillor Mary Jones – daughter is a mid-wife working for Swansea Bay University Health Board Councillor Jeff Jones – daughter is a mid-wife working for Swansea Bay University Health Board Martyn Waygood – daughter is a nurse working for Swansea Bay University Health Board; trustee for ‘Ospreys in Community’ charity
Councillor M H Jones presented the Pre-decision Scrutiny Feedback.
Councillor M H Jones declared a personal and prejudicial interest in Item 3 – Planning Application 2019/1342/FUL and left prior to discussion.
1) Crwys Primary School Linda Place 2) Hendrefoilan Primary School Cllr Mary H Jones 3) Pen y Fro Primary School Andrea Jones 4) St Helen’s Primary School Cllr Erika T Kirchner 5) Morriston Comprehensive School Paul Relf 6) Penyrheol Comprehensive School Graham Ashman
Councillor M H Jones presented Pre-decision Scrutiny Feedback in relation to the “Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) System Upgrade”.
7) Councillor M H Jones The Presiding Member stated that Councillor M H Jones was hopeful to be returning to meetings next week following her surgery and thanked everyone that sent her messages of support and best wishes.
Resolved that: - 1) Councillor Mary Jones be removed from the Anti-Social Behaviour Working Group.
7) Councillor M H Jones The Presiding Member stated that Councillor M H Jones was hopeful to be returning to meetings next week following her surgery and thanked everyone that sent her messages of support and best wishes.
Councillor M H Jones – Personal – Planning Application 2018/0653/FUL (Item 1) – Applicant known to me as a former employee at Olchfa School where I am a governor and Planning Application 2018/0943/FUL (Item 5) – Personal – My doctors surgery is in close proximity to the application site.
Cllr Mary Jones and Cllr Jeff Jones declared a personal interest as their daughter is midwife in Singleton Hospital and there was some discussion around midwives and their involvement in Early Years.
· Cllr Mary Jones discussed the Welsh Audit Office overview report · Swansea is already integrating the ethos behind the Future Generations Act into its Scrutiny functions · Swansea also complete considerable pre-decision scrutiny · There should be feedback due from the conference which will be fed back to the Panel
Councillor M H Jones declared a personal & prejudicial interest in Planning Application No.2018/0191 (Item 9) – My husband has made comments against the proposal and left prior to discussion.
Councillor M H Jones, Convenor of the Scrutiny Performance Panel presented the views of the Panel in relation to the Transfer of Management of Allotments from the City & County of Swansea to Management Associations .
Councillor M H Jones, Chair of the Scrutiny Programme Committee provided a report on the work of scrutiny for the Municipal year 2016-17 and highlighted scrutiny activities planned for 2017/18. The report was provided in order to share information that will help develop the relationship between Scrutiny and the Audit Committee. She praised the work of Dave McKenna, Scrutiny Manager, who left the Authority in July 2017 and the work of the Scrutiny Team.
Councillor M H Jones – Personal – Planning Application 2017/1801(Item 3) – I live near the traffic lights which are proposed for an upgrade through section 106 monies.
Councillor M H Jones presented the Pre-decision Scrutiny Feedback.
Councillor M H Jones - personal - Minute No. 45 – Chair of Governors at Olchfa School – The school playing fields at Olchfa were mentioned as part of the Cabinet Member Question Session.
Cllr Joe Hale and Cllr Mary Jones declared a personal interest for Regional Working Overview.
ii) Education & Skills Policy Development & Delivery Committee Add Councillor M H Jones.
RESOLVED that Councillor M H Jones be elected Chair for the 2017-2018 Municipal Year.
Councillor M H Jones, Chair of the Scrutiny Programme Committee provided the Committee with a verbal update on the work of scrutiny. She highlighted the work of scrutiny and referred to the service being shortlisted for the Municipal Journal Award in London in July. She also praised the work of Dave McKenna, Scrutiny Manager who was leaving the Authority in July 2017.
The Leader of the Council stated that Councillor M H Jones had submitted apologies as she was unable to attend the meeting.
Councillor S E Crouch stated that the Scrutiny Programme Committee had asked her to highlight the concerns of the Committee regarding proposals for Castle Square as set out in the letter from Councillor M H Jones.
Councillor M H Jones asked a question in relation to Minute 96 “Sustainable Swansea - Fit for the Future:
(NOTE: Councillor N J Davies (Vice Chair) presided for the above) Councillor M H Jones also gave an update regarding the establishment of and revised multi agency make-up of the new Public Services Board Scrutiny Performance Panel which had its first meeting in September.
Question 1 a) Councillor M H Jones asked:
Question 8 Councillor M H Jones asked:
Councillor M H Jones, of the Child and Adolescent Mental Health Scrutiny Inquiry Panel presented a report which outlined the findings, conclusions and recommendations resulting from the Panel’s inquiry into Child and Adolescent Mental Health .
Councillor Mary Jones, Convener presented the final report arising from the Scrutiny Panel’s inquiry into Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services.
Councillor M H Jones – Minute No. 26 - Public Rights of Way – Various Alleged Public Rights of Way between Hendrefoilan Road, Hungtington Way and Waunarlwydd Road – Personal – have walked these footpaths.
i) Councillor M H Jones asked:
RESOLVED that Councillor M H Jones be elected Chair for the 2016-2017 Municipal Year.
Councillor Mary Jones, Convener, provided an update of the work of the Local Service Board Scrutiny Performance Panel.
Councillor M H Jones – Minute No.100 - Planning Application 2015/2527 (Item 1) - Personal and Prejudicial as some of the objectors are close personal friends - made statement under paragraph 14(2) of the Code and left prior to discussion.
2) Illness a) Councillor Mary H Jones The Presiding Member stated that he was pleased to welcome Councillor Mary H Jones back following her recent surgery.
The Chair of the Scrutiny Programme Committee, Councillor M H Jones stated that a Special Scrutiny Programme Committee had met on 14 December 2015 in order to conduct a pre decision scrutiny process in relation to the item.
Councillor M H Jones, Chair of the Scrutiny Programme Committee provided the Committee with a verbal update on the work of scrutiny. She explained the background to scrutiny, particularly the change in working methods in having one committee and a number of working panels and added that all non-executive Councillors should be part of the scrutiny process. She stated that in her opinion, scrutiny did not have sufficient resources, particularly when dealing with challenging topics.
a) Blaenymaes Primary School Councillor Hazel M Morris b) Newton Primary School [name removed] c) Pontarddulais Primary School [name removed] d) Ynystawe Primary School [name removed] e) Olchfa Comprehensive School Councillor Mary H Jones f) Pontarddulais Comprehensive School Councillor Philip Downing g) YGG Y Login Fach [name removed]
The Chair then welcomed Councillor M H Jones, Chair of Scrutiny Programme Committee to the meeting. She responded as follows:
Councillor J W Jones – Minute No.34 – Personal & Prejudicial – Married to applicant Cllr M H Jones – left the meeting prior to the discussion of this item (6.5).
Councillor M H Jones, Chair of the Scrutiny Programme Committee stated that the Scrutiny Programme Committee had met on 18 November 2015 in order to consider a pre-decision scrutiny process in relation to the item.
Councillor M H Jones outlined the finding of the Committee.
Councillor M H Jones – Minute No.71 – Planning Application 2014/1192(Item 5) – Personal as Chair of Governors at Hendrefoilan & Olchfa Schools, and my granddaughter attends Hendrefoilan and proposed traffic light upgrade is close to my home.
c) Hendrefoilan Primary School Councillor Mary H Jones.
Child & Adolescent Mental Health Services Inquiry Panel – Councillor M H Jones be appointed as Convenor; and 2.
Cadle Primary School - [name removed] Primary School - [name removed] (re-appointment) Hendrefoilan Primary School - Councillor M H Jones (re-appointment) Sketty Primary School - Councillor A M Day (re-appointment) St Joseph’s Cathedral Primary School - [name removed] Bryn-Y- Mor - [name removed] Comprehensive School - [name removed] (re-appointment) Pontarddulais Comprehensive School - [name removed] (re-appointment) YGG Bryntawe [name removed] (re-appointment)
Note: Councillor M H Jones asked for further information relating to the categories of reserves referred to in paragraph 2.1 of the report.
Councillor M H Jones, Chair of the Scrutiny Programme Committee stated that Scrutiny would be looking into the issue during this Municipal Year.
9) Swansea Student Liaison Forum Remove Councillor M H Jones.
( i ) Question 3 - Councillor M H Jones asked:- Do the 467 casual/relief employees on zero hour contracts receiving the Living Wage?
(ii) Question 5 – Councillor M H Jones asked:-
7) Joint Consultative Committee Remove Councillor M H Jones.
RESOLVED that Councillor M H Jones be elected Chair for the 2015-2016 Municipal Year.
RESOLVED on the motion of Councillor C A Holley, seconded by Councillor M H Jones that Councillor John Newbury be elected to the office of Lord Mayor of the City and County of Swansea for the Municipal Year 2015-2016.
Those supplementary questions requiring a written response are listed below:- ( i ) Question 4 - Councillor M H Jones asked:- I n relation to revised figures verbal provided by the Cabinet Member do these include the staff who were on temporary contracts of under a year and had already been given notice?(Councillor M H Jones indicated that she would provide notes regarding this matter in the new term) The Cabinet Member for Education indicated that she would provide a written response.
(ii) Question 4 – Councillor M H Jones further asked:- As a result of the emphasis on Numeracy and Literacy in recent years, can the Cabinet Member indicate how schools were going to manage to help all children to be able to read at their chronological reading age when the staff schools are mainly losing Teaching Assistants that work with these children? How do you expect them to access the Curriculum when they get to Secondary School. The Cabinet Member for Education indicated that she would provide a written response.
Councillor M H Jones asked:
The Convenor of the Service Improvement and Finance Scrutiny Panel, Councillor Mary Jones, provided a further update to the committee on the work of the Panel and its effectiveness. She referred to the key activities and achievements/impact.
The Leader invited Councillor M H Jones, Convenor of the Service Improvement and Finance Performance Panel to present their views on the budget proposals.
Councillor M H Jones indicated that she had welcomed the Engagement with Scrutiny. She expressed the Panels concerns regarding the Schools Budget Forum, timing of reviews together with the Resource Gap and the proposal to cease production of the Swansea Leader. She referred to the public questions that had been received in respect of Libraries, main priorities of the Budget and Equality Impact Assessment.
The Leader thanked Councillor M H Jones for the Panels contribution on the Budget proposals and indicated that the Budget Equality Impact Assessments had been circulated to Cabinet Members.
The Head of Democratic Services stated that Councillor M H Jones had resigned as Chair of the Democratic Services Committee on 8 December 2014.
The Presiding Member thanked Councillor M H Jones for her service as Chair of the Committee.
RESOLVED that Councillor M H Jones be elected as Chair for the remainder of the 2014/2015.
Councillor M H Jones (Chair) presided.
Councillor J W Jones – personal and prejudicial - Minute No. 124 – Election of Chair for the Remainder of the Municipal Year – married to Councillor M H Jones who may be nominated.
Councillor M H Jones asked a question in relation to Minute No136 – The Introduction of the Education ( Penalty Notice) ( Wales) Regulations 2013 and the use of Fixed Penalty Notices for non school attendance. The Cabinet Member for Education responded accordingly.
Councillor M H Jones attended the Committee in order to provide the views of the Panel.
6) Councillor M H Jones - Council Procedure Rule 17 “Rules of Debate” The Deputy Presiding Member stated that as Councillor M H Jones had an illness causing pain when rising to a standing position.
As a result of this, she was suspending Council Procedure Rule 17.2 “Rules of Debate - Standing When Speaking” for Councillor M H Jones until further notice.
This was in order to allow Councillor M H Jones to take part in debate without having to stand.
Councillor M H Jones, Convenor, Service Improvement & Finance Scrutiny Performance Panel, provided a progress update on the work of the Panel.
The Chair also stated that he had arranged to meet with the Chair of the Audit Committee and Cllr Mary Jones in order to develop the relationship between scrutiny and the Audit Committee and ensure coordination of work programmes.
b) Councillor M H Jones referred to a Welsh Government initiative whereby each Primary School child is provided with toothpaste and a toothbrush and encouraged to clean their teeth. She queried why this was not referred to in the report.
Councillor M H Jones (Deputy Leader of the Liberal Democrat Political Group) paid tribute to the hard work and dedication of Councillor C A Holley.
RESOLVED on the motion of Councillor C A Holley, seconded by Councillor M H Jones that Councillor John Newbury be elected to the office of Deputy Lord Mayor of the City and County of Swansea for the Municipal Year 2014-2015.
14) Councillor M H Jones be elected as Chair of the Democratic Services Committee;
b) Councillor M H Jones asked what the Board of the Wales National Pool Swansea had done and were doing in order to offset the difficult challenges it faced following the removal of its International Training Camps (ITC) status?
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Jones attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Jones's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Jones was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 30 of 48 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Jones declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 Dec 2019 | Planning Committee, item 39 | Councillor M H Jones declared a personal and prejudicial interest in Item 3 – Planning Application 2019/1342/FUL and left prior to discussion. | |
| 6 Mar 2018 | Planning Committee, item 61 | Councillor M H Jones declared a personal & prejudicial interest in Planning Application No.2018/0191 (Item 9) – My husband has made comments against the proposal and left prior to discussion. | |
| 2 Oct 2017 | Scrutiny Inquiry Panel – Regional Working, item 1 | Cllr Joe Hale and Cllr Mary Jones declared a personal interest for Regional Working Overview. |
Where Councillor Jones sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Jul 2012 | 122 | 3 Dec 2026 |
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2015 | 101 | 1 Dec 2026 |
| Scrutiny Programme Committee | Councillor Co-optee | Dec 2014 | 72 | 15 Dec 2026 |
| Scrutiny Performance Panel - Service Improvement, Regeneration and Finance | Committee Member | Jan 2024 | 20 | 8 Dec 2026 |
| Scrutiny Performance Panel - Climate Change and Nature | Chair | Mar 2021 | 18 | |
| Scrutiny Working Group - Taxi Services | Committee Member | Jul 2026 | 1 | |
| Scrutiny Working Group - Business Support | Committee Member | Oct 2026 | 1 | |
| Scrutiny Performance Panel – Service Improvement & Finance | Committee Member | Aug 2017 | 26 | |
| Scrutiny Performance Panel – Development & Regeneration | Committee Member | Sep 2017 | 16 | |
| Area 2 Development Control Committee | Committee Member | Apr 2014 | 9 | |
| Scrutiny Performance Panel – Public Services Board | Chair | Aug 2017 | 8 | |
| Development Management and Control Committee | Committee Member | May 2014 | 7 | |
| Scrutiny Inquiry Panel – Regional Working | Committee Member | Oct 2017 | 7 | |
| Scrutiny Inquiry Panel - Anti-Social Behaviour | Committee Member | Jan 2023 | 7 | |
| Democratic Services Committee | Chair | Apr 2014 | 4 | |
| Education & Skills Policy Development Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2017 | 2 | |
| Scrutiny Working Group - Workforce | Committee Member | Mar 2021 | 2 | |
| Scrutiny Performance Panel – Child & Family Services | Committee Member | Aug 2017 | 1 | |
| Scrutiny Working Group – Emergency Planning & Resilience | Chair | Oct 2017 | 1 | |
| Scrutiny Inquiry Panel – Child & Adolescent Mental Health Services | Chair | Nov 2017 | 1 | |
| Scrutiny Working Group - Roads and Footway Maintenance | Committee Member | Jan 2018 | 1 | |
| Scrutiny Working Group - Renewable Energy | Committee Member | Mar 2018 | 1 | |
| Scrutiny Working Group - Environmental Enforcement | Committee Member | Feb 2019 | 1 | |
| Scrutiny Working Group - Coproduction | Committee Member | Mar 2023 | 1 | |
| Scrutiny Working Group - Agile Working | Committee Member | Jan 2025 | 1 | |
| Scrutiny Working Group - Tree Services | Committee Member | May 2025 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.