Minutes for Confirmation
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Emma Bushell seconded that the Cabinet resolutions be amended to read:
Every time Swindon's minutes name Councillor Small, as the council published it.
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Emma Bushell seconded that the Cabinet resolutions be amended to read:
During the Committee discussion it was suggested by Councillor Small that he would be happy to support officer`s recommendation on the basis that access to the church and graveyard was guaranteed at all times along with protections against damage to neighbouring areas. The Committee also wished to support the application.
Billy Parkin asked a question at the meeting regarding the David Murray John Tower to which Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance responded at the meeting.
Councillor Jim Robbins moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded:
Councillor Jim Robbins moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded that the Motion be amended to read:
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, referred to the decision taken by the previous administration not to invest in the housing stock and to instead pay off debt at what he believed was a quicker rate than needed and which had contributed to the current issues leaving Swindon below the national home standard.
Councillor Small echoed the thanks to the Cabinet Member and officers for the sensitive way the consultation process had been conducted.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, congratulated the Cabinet Member and officers on the decision to resurface Westcott Place during the school holidays which had minimised disruption in the area, and referred to other areas across the Borough where road improvements have already taken place.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which presented the revenue forecast out-turn position for 2025/2026.
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted the following matters:
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which presented the forecast year end monitoring position for the Council’s capital programme and some proposed changes to the programme.
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Jim Robbins seconded that ( i ) Minute 71 (13), (14) and (15) of the Cabinet (Budget 2026/2027), (ii) Minute 72 (1), (2), (3) and (4) of the Cabinet (Capital Programme 2026/2027), and (iii) Minute 73 of the Cabinet (Treasury Strategy Statement 2026/2027) be confirmed and adopted.
Councillor Kevin Small moved, Councillor Jim Robbins seconded, and the Council agreed:
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which set out how the Council had commissioned the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy to undertake an independent financial resilience review, the purpose of which was to provide an assessment of the Council’s financial sustainability and to provide assurance that the Council was taking all reasonable steps to respond to the challenging financial position. The report further set out how the review was also expected to satisfy the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government’s (MHCLG) requirement for a financial resilience review as part of the Exceptional Financial Support (EFS) process.
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted the following matters:
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which outlined the intentions of spend against the 2026/2027 budget of £233.077m in pursuit of the ambitions outlined within the Swindon Plan. The report also set out the financial challenges facing the council between now and 2028/2029 and proposed a General Fund budget for 2026/2027 that included significant savings proposals and required the capitalisation of revenue costs, pursuant to a Directive permitting Exceptional Financial Support (EFS), to meet the legal requirement to set a balanced budget. The report further set out the indicative budget for the Dedicated Schools Grant and provided an update on the year-end projection for 2025/2026 for the General Fund, Housing Revenue Account and Dedicated Schools Grant.
Councillor Small also made reference to:
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which provided an update to the Capital Strategy and reported new capital investment requirements.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which presented the Treasury Management Strategy for 2026/2027, and included Prudential Indicators up to 2030/2031, the Annual Investment Strategy, and the Minimum Revenue Provision Policy Statement for consideration.
Salzgitter Councillor Kevin Small updated members on the recent visit to Salzgitter that he had attended along with the Mayor, Leader of the Council and the Vice Chair of the Town Twinning Network to celebrate the 50 th anniversary of the twinning agreement between Swindon and Salzgitter.
(1) Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Jim Robbins seconded that Minute 55 (12) of the Cabinet (Budget Management Update) be confirmed and adopted.
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Claire Crilly seconded:
These were answered by the Leader of the Council, Councillor Jim Robbins, Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, the Chief Legal Officer and the Chair of the Committee.
· contrary to the Policy Framework; or · it was contrary/not wholly consistent with the Budget Framework; or · the Committee disagreed with the Monitoring Officer/S151 Officer’s view that the decision was legally and/or financially compliant Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, addressed the Committee and made the following introductory remarks:
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which sought approval to undertake public consultation on the ‘Regulation 18’ draft of the Swindon Borough Local Plan 2043 for a period of 6 weeks in accordance with Regulation 18 of The Town and Country Planning (Local Planning) (England) Regulations 2012 (as amended).
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted the following matters:
Councillor Small endorsed the proposal and discussed the uniqueness of the site and the provision of social housing, and the benefit from a social perspective of the Council replacing the Housing Association and using the Housing Revenue Account to increase housing stock.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which presented the revenue forecast out-turn position for 2025/2026.
Councillor Robbins echoed the comments from Councillor Small regarding the newspaper article on Penhill and stressed the value of the funding coming into the area.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which presented the 2024/2025 capital spend position and how it had been funded, plus some proposed changes to the programme.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report setting out the Treasury Management performance for 2024/2025.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which presented a high-level Interim Business Plan for commercial activities proposed to be undertaken by Swindon Housing Company for the period 2025-2029. The report set out Swindon Housing Company’s vision, broad strategic objectives and values, as well as top-line financial forecasts, methodologies for delivery and programme of development sites.
Resolved – That Councillor Kevin Small be Chair of the Network for the Municipal Year, 2025/26.
Salzgitter Councillor Kevin Small noted that an invitation had been received to attend the 50 th anniversary of the twinning agreement in Salzgitter. Although dates had not yet been confirmed it was likely to be towards the later part of the year.
These were answered by the Leader of the Council, Councillor Jim Robbins, and Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance.
A number of residents were invited to submit their questions in writing subsequent to the meeting, to which Councillor Small undertook to provide written responses. The full details of all submissions under this item and the responses provided can be found in Annex 1.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report seeking a decision on which of the following three options were to be pursued with regards to the future use of the former Highworth Golf Course:
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted the following matters:
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which presented the provisional revenue position for 2024/2025, subject to audit by Grant Thornton, the Council’s external auditors. The report set out how t he effective management of financial resources through robust financial management processes underpins the Council’s ability to achieve its plans and priorities.
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted a number of points from it which included:
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which presented the performance of Council owned companies for the period to 30th March 2025.
Councillor Small introduced the report and explained that it covered the Swindon Common Farm Solar Community Interest PLC, the Swindon Chapel Farm Solar PLC, the Swindon Housing Development Company, and the Wichelstowe Joint Venture Company.
Councillor Small presented an update on each of these in turn.
The Worshipful The Mayor, Councillor Matthew Courtliff, Councillor Kevin Small, Councillor Gayle Cook and Councillor Adam Poole spoke in support of the Motion.
Councillor Jim Robbins moved, Councillor Kevin Small seconded, and the Council agreed, with none opposing, that Councillor Fay Howard be Mayor of the Borough for the ensuing Municipal Year.
Councillor Kevin Small had submitted his apologies prior to the meeting but joined the meeting part way through.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, assisted by the Interim Planning Policy Lead Officer, presented the report and highlighted the following:
Councillor Small, assisted by the Interim Planning Policy Lead Officer, responded to members questions and comments on the following matters:
Gary Llewellyn submitted a written question relating to the Swindon Borough Local Development Scheme March 2025 to which Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, provided a written response prior to the meeting.
[name removed] asked a supplementary question at the meeting regarding the sites allocated in the Local Plan and the areas targeted for growth to which Councillor Small responded at the meeting.
Julie Murphy, Chair of Highworth Town Council, asked two questions regarding (1) the use of Exceptional Financial Support to retain Highworth Golf Course and (2) the circulation of the Ecologists report relating to Highworth Golf Course, to which Councillor Small responded at the meeting.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which sought agreement for the revised Swindon Borough Local Development Scheme (LDS) 2025 (13th Review), which outlined the work programme for the production of Development Plan Documents. The report set out how changes were made to the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) on 12 th December 2024 and, in recognition of these changes and further time and resources required to address these new matters, the Deputy Prime Minister has asked that all local planning authorities produce an updated LDS within 12 weeks of the publication of the NPPF, reflecting the need to incorporate new policy requirements for Plan Making.
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted: that the plan had been delayed for several reasons which included changes in the government requirements on housing supply, staffing issues, and pressures from making sure it was vision led and deliverable; the work to be done with neighbouring authorities; the emphasis on affordable housing that had been included; how the plan reflects the Swindon plan and Missions on things like affordable housing, local employment, improving the town centre and transport improvements; that this plan would be in place until 2043; how a CIL review and examination of a replacement CIL Charging Schedule would be required soon after the adoption of the new Local Plan, and; the timetable for when the public consultations on Regulation 18 and Regulation 19 and the submission to the Secretary of State were expected to take place.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which set out the 2024/2025 revenue forecast out-turn. The report set out how the effective management of financial resources through robust financial management processes underpins the Council’s ability to achieve its plans and priorities. The report also set out how responsible budget management helps ensure that the Council consistently makes the best use of all available resources as well as providing focus for the Council’s improvement programmes.
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted: that the year-end projection on the General Fund, based on the position at the end of January, was a forecast overspend of £4.5m which was an improvement of £1.3m since the last report; the actions being taken by officers through transitional proposals to further reduce the overspend by the end of the financial year; that in Adult Services there was a forecasted reduction of £838k in the overspend due to a reduction in care costs, additional client contributions and staffing reductions; that in Children's Services there was a forecasted reduction of £608k in the overspend due to improvements to home to school transport costs, placement costs and underspends on staff costs; that in the Inclusive Economy and Sustainability Directorate there was a forecasted increase of £221k in the overspend due to a planning restructure and senior management restructure costs; that in Enabling Services there was a forecasted reduction of £123k in the overspend due to software licenses and staff costs; that the D edicated Schools Grant was forecasting a pressure of £7.93m, £50k lower than last reported, with the cumulative deficit now forecasted at £16.3m, and; that following the previous decision to stop the annual Voluntary Debt Repayment of £5m the forecasted overspend would be removed, resulting in a projected underspend of £3.3m which would be added to the HRA reserve.
Responding to a query from Councillor Ballman, Councillor Small confirmed that any recent reductions in the overspend in Adult Social Services would not be reflected in this report since this was based on the position as at the end of January 2025. Any update on the figures would be provided in the next report.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which presented the year end monitoring position for the Council’s capital programme and some proposed changes to the programme.
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted: that the two budgets for Lydiard House and Park improvements were showing a net overspend of £2k, with the project now ceasing since the works had been completed;
Councillor Small went on to discuss the additions and amendments to the programme that Cabinet were being asked to approve and highlighted: that Swindon had been allocated £552k of revenue funding and £125k of capital funding under the UK Government’s UK Shared Prosperity Fund programme which had to be fully spent in the 2025/2026 financial year; the proposals to allocate the funding, split across a Council internship programme for care-experienced residents, the supported employment programme, the ‘Multiply’ Adult Numeracy Programme, the Integrated Neighbourhood teams programme and a programme to help revitalise vacant and under-used town centre properties for community and cultural use; the £5,385,500 of Local Transport Plan Capital Maintenance Grant for 2025/26, with the potential for a further £375,500 of incentive funding to be confirmed later in the year, as set out in the Local Transport Plan Annual Implementation Plan 2025/2026 report, and; the Honeymans Helm Travel Plan which would create a revenue budget of £86k, funded from s106 contributions, to discharge the travel plan requirements around Shrivenham Road in Highworth .
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Jim Robbins seconded that (i) Minute 80 (11), (12) and (13) of the Cabinet (Budget 2025/2026), (ii) Minute 81 (1), (2) and (3) of the Cabinet (Capital Programme 2025/2026), (iii) Minute 82 of the Cabinet (Treasury Strategy Statement 2025/2026) be confirmed and adopted, and (iv) the receipt of the letter from Jim McMahon OBE MP, the Minister of State for Local Government and English Devolution, confirming that the Deputy Prime Minister was minded to approve a capitalisation direction of a total not exceeding £14.7 million, be noted.
Councillor Kevin Small moved, Councillor Jim Robbins seconded, and the Council agreed:
Councillor Janine Howarth moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded:
Councillor Kevin Small updated members on the Leader of the Council’s previous suggestion that the Civic Offices/Council Chamber be utilised to celebrate a Polish day of importance. Mark confirmed that he would speak with the director of the Saturday school about this.
Councillor Kevin Small suggested that the club may be able to present the kit(s) before or during a Swindon Town FC match in order to promote the friendship link.
Salzgitter Councillor Kevin Small noted that 2025 would see the 50 th anniversary of the twinning agreement between Salzgitter and Swindon being signed being marked.
Councillor Small would contact the Mayor of Salzgitter about the way that the towns would mark the occasion.
Councillor Small updated members about an article in Monday’s Times that mentioned the steel works in Salzgitter and noted the significance of the steel works in Salzgitter’s history.
Councillor Kevin Small, the Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which outlined how the Council intends to spend the 2025/2026 budget of £188.382m in pursuit of the ambitions outlined within the Swindon Plan. The report also: set out the financial challenges facing the Council between now and 2027/2028 and the Council’s response to ensure it can deliver a sustainable budget over the medium term; proposed a General Fund budget for 2025/2026 that included significant savings proposals and required the capitalisation of revenue costs pursuant to a Directive permitting Exceptional Financial Support in order to meet the legal requirement to set a balanced budget; set out the indicative budget for the Dedicated Schools Grant, and; provided an update on the year-end projection for 2024/2025 for General Fund, Housing Revenue Account (HRA) and Dedicated Schools Grant (DSG).
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted the following matters from the 2024/2025 Budget update: the predicted overspend of around £5.8m which had reduced slightly since the writing of the report, and the additional savings made of around £1.8m; the reduction in Adult Services core packages of around £500k due to reduced demand and payment of invoices; the £299k savings in the Economic and Sustainability directorate as a result of management efficiencies and an overspend reduction; the £122k savings in the Enabling Services directorate due to actions put in place to control costs;
Councillor Small then detailed pressures against the budget which included: that around 80% of the overall budget was spent on statutory social care services, meaning there is tremendous pressure on the remaining budget when looking for savings; the predicted overspend of £1.7m on the HRA, with the recent increase being attributed to not having received the utilities rebate and undertaking repairs via outside contractors, and; the decision to not pay the voluntary £5m debt payment which may result in the HRA being in surplus at the end of the financial year.
Councillor Small concluded on the 2024/2025 Budget by referencing the savings delivery which included: the currently predicted rate of 80% savings being achieved, which was down slightly from 82% in the previous year; the contingency factored in when the overall savings targets are not being met, which is part of the prudent management of budgets, and; the £8m overspend on the dedicated schools budget which had doubled since the previous last year and was £500k worse than at the last report, resulting in a deficit of around £16.4m.
Councillor Small then moved on to the Budget proposals for 2025/2026 and highlighted: the additional £5m received from the government which had included £3.3m in grants and £1.7m to offset the increased National Insurance payments, plus an additional £100k for the New Homes bonus and £80k for the Children's Social Care Prevention grant, and;
Councillor Small submitted a report which provided an update to the Capital Strategy and reported on new capital investment requirements. The report set out how the effective management of financial resources through robust financial management processes underpins the Council’s ability to achieve its plans and priorities.
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted some matters from it which included: the additional borrowing of £180k for next year, resulting in annual debt charges of £10k per annum which would be accommodated within existing service revenue budgets; the extra £3.4m High needs Capital allocation from the government, of which £3.3m would be spent on SEND capacity; how this would result in an increase in provision at the specialist unit of around 50 places, the creation of 96 extra places in 4 primary schools at key stage two, and the creation of 60 extra places in secondary schools at key stage three and four; the additional £100k for adaptations in schools to meet high needs provision to enable pupils to remain within mainstream education; the budget of £465,800 for the transformation of OK4U, funded using the remaining approved capital budget of £286k on the Fessey extension capital project, and further borrowing of £179,800; that OK4U would be moving to the currently unused building at the Swindon Family breaks site in Firethorn Close, Gorse Hill which would generate revenue savings of £133k over two years; the ongoing review of the capital programme which ensures effective delivery, the removal of items no longer needed, or a restructuring where necessary to bring cost pressures down, and; that Appendix 1 highlighted how the capital programme strategies were to be fulfilled as required as part of the presentation to Council.
Councillor Kevin Small, the Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which presented the Treasury Management Strategy for 2025/2026, including Prudential Indicators up to 2030/2031, the Annual Investment Strategy, and the Minimum Revenue Provision Policy Statement.
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted the following matters: how the Treasury Strategy looks at how the capital expenditure plan is developed, and also deals with the associated prudential indicators (the amount the Council can borrow against its assets); that it looks at the levels of borrowing needed to support the Council's programme;
Councillor Small responded to questions and comments from Councillor Heenan on the following matters:
Councillor Small welcomed the balanced budget as set out in the report, as well as the cessation of the £5m voluntary repayment of debt. He felt it was important to cease this because of the clearly identified work required on the Council’s housing stock as discussed in the previous item, and questioned if it would have required as much investment now if the voluntary repayment had been stopper sooner and the funds used for maintenance instead.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, made the following introductory remarks:
Before the debate was opened, Councillor Small clarified that any specific questions relating to the planning application for the Oasis, and on matters subject to the planning process, would not be answered in this forum so as not to compromise any future decisions to be made elsewhere.
The presentation by the Director of Finance and Audit, who was joined by Councillor Kevin Small, the Cabinet Member for Finance, covered the following matters:
[name removed], Swindon and Wiltshire Residents Association, asked a question at the meeting regarding anticipated spending cuts and the plans for spending the increased council tax contributions, to which Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, responded at the meeting.
(1) Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Jim Robbins seconded that Minute 63 of the Cabinet (Budget Management Update ) be confirmed and adopted.
Councillor Kevin Small, the Cabinet Member for Finance, responded at the meeting.
Councillor Small echoed the comments made by Councillor Grant, and indicated that he would not have been in favour of this decision had the relationship not improved.
Councillor Small also wished to congratulate Councillor Grant for his initial work on this matter when it was under his portfolio.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which presented the revenue forecast out-turn position for 2024/25 and an update on the outlook for 2025/26. The report also set out how the effective management of financial resources through robust financial management processes underpins the Council’s ability to achieve its plans and priorities.
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted the following matters: the position in July was a predicted overspend of £9.1m, an increase of £3.1m since the last report, which was a concern; that the senior management team were working hard to reduce that overspend; the increasing difficulties in achieving a balanced budget each year; the £1.5m of contingency funds for 2024/2025 which is an ongoing sum, and also the additional £4m of cash flow reserves that can be used to support the budget; that these have not been taken into account as part of the bottom line figures at the present time because they are for emergency use; areas of concern which included a predicted overspend of £4.3m on Children’s Services, £2.5m on Adult Social Care, £2m on Inclusive Economy and Sustainability and £296k on Stronger and Safer Communities;
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which presented the year-end monitoring position for the Council’s capital programme and some proposed changes to the programme.
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted the following matters: the capital approvals listed in Table 1 and the capital programme funding listed in Table 2; the projected budget variances for Wichelstowe Junction 16, the Mead Way junction, No. 7, 9 and 11 Carriage works at Railway Village, and the HRA Refugee Housing Programme; the changes to the Housing Revenue Account capital programme after the re-assessment of required works; the creation of a separate capital void budget, recognising that a substantial level of void repairs now represent significant capital investment to allow these to be monitored outside the main Planned Maintenance programme ; that t hese changes will not affect the long-term capital maintenance programme, the data is now being presented in a more easy to understand format;
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which sought approval to sell the freehold interests of Council owned commercial properties which in turn would generate a capital receipt to support the Council’s financial position.
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted some key points from it which included: the positive benefits this decision would have on both the capital receipts and the revenue budget; how all the properties being proposed for disposal were commercial assets not related to service delivery and freeholds; that the report sought approval to sell the freeholds with the above ground operations continuing to operate;
Councillor Small concluded by thanking officers for achieving a net benefit on the proposed disposals.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which sought approval to authorise a loan to Swindon Housing Company to deliver 17 new dwellings at the site at the former Stratton Education Centre, Clays Close, Swindon. The report set out how this proposal would contribute new housing stock for residents.
Councillor Small responded to Councillor Bushell who had welcomed this proposal which she felt was a project well suited for the Housing Company to deliver.
Councillor Jim Robbins moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded:
These were answered by the Leader of the Council, Councillor Jim Robbins, and Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which presented the revenue forecast out-turn position for 2024/25. The report set out: how the effective management of financial resources through robust financial management processes underpins the Council’s ability to achieve its plans and priorities, and; how responsible budget management helps ensure that the Council consistently makes the best use of all available resources as well as providing focus for the Council’s improvement programmes.
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted some key points from it which included: the predicted £5.9m overspend by the end of the financial year;
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which presented the 2023/2024 capital spend position and how it had been funded, plus set out some proposed changes to the programme.
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted some key points from it which included:
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report which presented the Treasury Management performance for 2023/2024.
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted that there was £17m in new long term borrowing, and that a correction was to be noted with regards to paragraph 3.5 whereby the short term loan wold be maturing in May 2024 and not June as stated.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report relating to the Farming Motion, submitted to Council at its meeting on 18 th January 2024 (Council Minute Item 81b (2023/2024) refers), which had stood deferred to Cabinet in accordance with Standing Order 9(1).
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted some key points from it which included: the formation of small, medium and large Council owned farms as a result of the County Farms Act after WW1; the breakdown of that system as smaller farms were removed for viability reasons and the numbers of permanent tenants increased, and; that some of the farm land had already been sold as part of the Wichelstowe development.
Councillor Small referred to the potential of the remaining farm land given its location. Due to the financial pressures on the Council, he also suggested that it would be improper if it was not included in the upcoming estates and asset review.
Councillor Small therefore proposed that the Motion be rejected, with all pertinent considerations being taken into account as part of the review.
Councillor Small responded to a question from Councillor Steve Weisinger who had sought clarity on whether areas such as Pentylands Park would be included in the review and would therefore be considered for disposal.
Councillor Small confirmed he was unable to respond definitively at this time, but thought it unlikely where service provisions were already in place.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, submitted a report relating to the Highworth Golf Course Motion, submitted to Council at its meeting on 12 th October 2023 (Council Minute Item 51 (2023/2024) refers), which had stood deferred to Cabinet in accordance with Standing Order 9(1).
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted some key points which included: the reasons why consideration of this matter had been delayed which included two pre-election periods and the need for liaison with Highworth Town Council; the importance of the dialogue between the Council and Highworth Town Council; all the factors that have to be accounted for by the Cabinet when making a decision on the future of the land (which includes ‘best consideration’ as a principle); the outline of the three proposals set out in paragraph 3.7 that are to be worked up in detail for future consideration by Cabinet and will be informed by professional advice, and; the financial pressures the Council is facing which also have to be taken into consideration.
The Leader of the Council, Councillor Jim Robbins, and Councillor Small responded to questions and statements from Councillor Jim Grant (Cabinet Member for Communities and Partnerships), Councillor Emma Bushell (Deputy Leader of the Council and Cabinet Member for Organisational Oversight), Councillor Marina Strinkovsky (Cabinet Member for Planning and Placemaking), Councillor Steve Weisinger, Councillor Vijay Manro and Councillor Nick Gardiner on the following matters:
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, and the Corporate Director of Inclusive Economy and Sustainability submitted a joint report seeking approval of Wichelstowe LLP’s (the Joint Venture (JV)) 5-year Business Plan, which set out the JV’s proposals for the Wichelstowe development over the next 5 years, and the Phase 2 Business Plan, which set out the detail of the next phase of development. The report also sought approval to amend the JV agreement plan to include Parcel 10 and the car park to serve the district centre which the JV would construct and which currently are not included in the JV agreement, and transfer to the JV the Council owned land included in the Phase 2 business Plan.
Councillor Small introduced the report which he felt showcased an excellent example of a local authority working with the private sector to deliver housing needs.
Councillor Small invited Cabinet to note: that Phase 2 covers 56 acres and 616 units; that the conditions on the transfer listed on page 159 of the report had been met; that the land would be valued by an independent surveyor;
Councillor Small concluded by referring to the business plan contained in the exempt appendix which he advised both himself and officers supported. The Leader opined that this was a sensible approach to see the rest of Wichelstowe built out and the good work continue, and that it seemed sensible to unlock revenue for the Council from it.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, and the Director of Finance and Audit, submitted a joint report presenting the provisional revenue position for 2023/2024 subject to audit by Grant Thornton, the Council’s external auditors. The report set out how t he effective management of financial resources through robust financial management processes underpins the Council’s ability to achieve its plans and priorities.
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted some key points from it which included: the underspend of £159k at the end of the financial year 2023/24 which would be transferred to general reserves; his thanks to the Chief Executive and the Corporate Management Team for their strong leadership and delivery on savings; the increase of £603k in streetsmart costing; the pressures of £800k on homelessness services; the £500k improvement in adult services; the £400k improvement in planning services; the £1.9m surplus from the Council’s business rates collection fund activity; the £3m overspend on the dedicated schools budget last year; the Housing Revenue Account overspend of £2.35m;
Councillor Emma Bushell, Deputy Leader of the Council and Cabinet Member for Organisational Oversight, referred to the recent White Paper issued by the Local Government Association calling on the incoming government to write off all dedicated school budget debts, to which Councillor Small indicated his support. Resolved – (1) T hat the 2023/24 revenue out-turn position for each service area set out in Table 1 and Appendix 1 be noted.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, and the Director of Strategic Development submitted a joint report seeking approval that the ‘Swindon Borough Statement of Community Involvement’ (SCI) be recommended to Council for adoption. The report set out how the SCI is a statutory document required by law (as per the Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act (2004) (as amended)) that outlines how the Planning Service engage with local communities and key stakeholders on both planning applications and the production of planning documents including the Local Plan.
Councillor Small introduced the report and advised that it had previously been brought to Cabinet prior to consultation on the matter. This report and new Statement incorporated the comments received from the public as a result of that consultation process which overall had been positive.
Councillor Small concluded by highlighting the increased use of social media and IT during this consultation as well as the traditional formats.
Councillor Kevin Small moved, Councillor Jim Robbins seconded and the Council, agreed with none opposing, that Councillor Imtiaz Sheikh be Mayor of the Borough for the ensuing Municipal Year.
Councillor Kevin Small, the Cabinet Member for Finance and Councillor Chris Watts, the Cabinet Member for the Environment and Transport, responded to [name removed] questions at the meeting.
The Leader of the Council, Councillor Jim Robbins, and Councillor Small, responded at the meeting.
Adoption of a Masterplan for the Marlowe Avenue Area Councillor Janine Howarth, Cabinet Member for Housing, and Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, responded to questions put by Councillors Gary Sumner, Sean Wilson, and the Chair on the following matters:
[name removed], [name removed] and [name removed] had all submitted written questions prior to the meeting regarding the inclusion of a multi-purpose hall in the Oasis Leisure Centre plans to which the Leader of the Council, Councillor Jim Robbins, and Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, responded at the meeting.
[name removed] asked a number of questions relating to the operational costs of the waste collection services to which Councillor Small and Councillor Chris Watts, Cabinet Member for the Environment and Transport, responded at the meeting.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, stated that engagement with young people is important given that they will be the adults in the future living in the Swindon that this Plan will help shape.
Councillor Small further wished to acknowledge his appreciation to the Leader of the Council and their Cabinet colleagues for their excellent work at the engagement events.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, and Councillor Janine Howarth, Cabinet Member for Housing, along with the Director of Strategic Development and Director of Housing, submitted a joint report which set out the results of a resident consultation on proposals for the regeneration of the Marlowe Avenue area, which had in turn formed the masterplan which Cabinet were being asked to approve.
Councillor Small wished to echo the statements made by Councillor Howarth and note the major regeneration this brought to the Walcot area. He believed these plans formed an integral part of the conversion of Greenbridge Road from industrial to residential use, and would provide benefits for the Rugby Club and the allotment users.
Councillor Small further noted that this land had remained vacant and surplus to requirements for years but was now being used to assist a considerable investment in the Council’s housing stock and improve the quality and conditions for tenants.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, along with the Director of Finance and Audit (S151 Officer), submitted a joint report which explained how responsible budget management helps ensure that the Council consistently makes the best use of all available resources as well as providing focus for the Council’s improvement programmes.
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted some key points from it which included: the year-end projection on the General Fund being a forecast overspend of £261k, an improvement of £353k since the last report; the forecasted improvement in the cost of adult care packages of £352k; the forecasted increase in the overspend of £773k for the Waste and Recycling service; the forecast for savings delivery being at 80% of budgeted savings, in comparison to 79% at the same point last year; the Dedicated Schools Grant forecasting a pressure of £3.5m, an improvement of £0.2m since the last report, with the overall forecast expected to be £8.8m up from £5.3m at the start of the year; the council’s engagement in the Delivering Better Value in SEND programme and the £1m awarded to put in place plans that will reduce future costs; the likelihood of the Government calling in the overspends and the work being done by the Children’s Delivery board to tackle the deficit position on the Dedicated School Grant, and; the changes to the Adult Social Care fees and charges for services linked to the fee the Council pays care providers. The Chair acknowledged the work undertaken over the year to reduce the overspend and thanked officers for their efforts to address this whilst dealing with other challenges.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, along with the Director of Finance and Audit (S151 Officer), submitted a joint report which set out how the effective management of financial resources through robust financial management processes underpins the Council’s ability to achieve its plans and priorities, and also presented the year end monitoring position for the Council’s capital programme and some proposed changes to the programme.
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted some key points from it which included: the £49k saving on the Coroners Service; the overspend of £93k on the Swindon Museum and Art Gallery relocation; the budget improvement of £180k for Rapid Transit at Wichelstowe;
Councillor Small indicated his support for the solution agreed to fund the relocation of the Museum and Art Gallery to the Civic Offices, and noted the protection against future development that the plans for Spring Gardens put in place. Resolved – (1) That the 2023/2024 projected year-end position and funding sources as set out in Tables 1 and 2, and as detailed in Appendix 1 and 2, be noted.
In response to a query from Councillor Small regarding how the replacement of traffic signals is programmed, Councillor Watts observed the considerable costs associated with their maintenance and replacement, and advised of the funding obtained to replace the units along Thamesdown Avenue which would provide a revenue saving on repairs.
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Jim Robbins seconded that Minute 60(13 and 14) of the Cabinet ( Budget 2024 – 2025 ) , Minute 61(1)(2)(3)(4)(5) of the Cabinet ( Capital Programme 2024/25 ) and Minute 62 of the Cabinet ( Treasury Strategy Statement 2024-2025 ) be confirmed and adopted.
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Jim Robbins seconded and the Council agreed:
Councillor Janine Howarth moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded:
· Establishes a cross-party task group to provide all elected members an opportunity to contribute to the future of the Oasis Leisure Centre.” Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Jim Robbins seconded that the Motion be amended to read:
Councillor Jim Grant, Cabinet Member for Communities and Joint Working, and Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, responded at the meeting.
[name removed] asked a supplemental question regarding the obstacles to decision-making on the former Highworth Golf Course, to which Councillor Small responded at the meeting.
[name removed] asked questions at the meeting concerning the amount of the Local Government Settlement figure being received by the Council and what it would be spent on, to which Councillor Small responded at the meeting.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, along with the Directorof Finance and Audit, submitted a joint report which set out the financial challenges facing the council between now and 2026/2027 and highlighted the key areas of focus to ensure the council could deliver a sustainable budget over the medium term. The report also set out the budget proposals for 2024/25 which included significant savings proposals and a targeted use of reserves in order to meet the legal requirement to set a balanced budget. Also set out in the report was an update on the year end projection for 2023/2024 which demonstrated the impact that management actions have had in order to manage the in-year financial challenges.
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted some key points from it which included: the predicted overspend of £600k on the 2023/2024 budget which had reduced from £5.9m as predicted in December 2023; the £3.7m business rate changes; the £1m saving in Adults Services; the £500k saving from no longer progressing a planning appeal in the Eastern Villages; that 75% of the 2023/24 savings plan had been delivered against a forecast of around 80%;
Councillor Small also referred to missed funding opportunities for Local Authorities that in his opinion had not been taken by the Government in autumn 2023, and the reductions in the current funding opportunities from Council Tax collection which in his opinion had been caused by the Government decision in the 2010s to instruct Local Authorities to not raise Council Tax. The Chair expressed his thanks to Officers for ... view the full minutes text for item 60.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, along with the Directorof Finance and Audit, submitted a joint report which provided an update to the Capital Strategy and reported new capital investment requirements. It set out how the effective management of financial resources through robust financial management processes underpins the Council’s ability to achieve its plans and priorities, and how responsible budget management underpins the Council’s strategic objective of consistently making the best use of all available resources as well as providing focus for its change programmes.
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted some key points from it which included: the additional anticipated £1.42m for Adopted Homes Grants and £4.85m for Local Transport Grants; the High Needs SEN provision allocation of £9.23m funded via an SEN grant and S106 funding which will include 3 major schemes at Eldene Primary School, Badbury Park and Nylands; the £13.2m of borrowing for complex needs accommodation; the £2.5m required for a new Children’s Services IT system; £500k for improved schools building grant, and; the £15m which will be required for the Children’s Services Sufficiency Strategy if the Council has to provide local provision.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, along with the Directorof Finance and Audit , submitted a joint report which presented the Treasury Management Strategy for 2024/25, including Prudential Indicators up to 2029/30, the Annual Investment Strategy, and the Minimum Revenue Provision Policy Statement.
Councillor Small introduced the report which he explained dealt with the Council’s management of money, how it borrows, its investment plan, and how it deals with cash surpluses and cash flow. The Statement also looks at how the Council deals with its investments and its policy over debts.
Councillor Small advised that the Audit Committee had considered the Statement at its most recent meeting and it also regularly reviewed the Statement as part of its Work Programme.
In response to a question from the Chair, Councillor Small confirmed that the Council does not currently invest in any areas with questionable human rights records.
Councillor Small welcomed the work undertaken to reduce the waiting time on voids, which has a subsequent effect on homeless numbers which is funded via the General Fund. He also referred to the programme to replace UPVC Windows and Doors, most of which had been originally supplied and fitted by the Local Authorities in-house provider.
Councillor Small referred to the £1m quoted in the Motion from the Cabinet Member decision to support the sale of the Corn Exchange, including the Planks carparks, and advised that this figure was overestimated. He also noted that any monies received from the sale would have to be offset against the revenue losses from the car parks, projected to be around £50k annually. The Chair reflected on the impossibility of being able to finalise the ownership of the Mechanics Institute within the 90 day deadline required for Motions agreed by Council to be enacted, and felt it appropriate that it had stood deferred to Cabinet without debate given its financial implications.
Following the introductory presentation, the Leader, supported by the Director of Finance and Audit and Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, responded to questions and comments raised by the attendees at the meeting on the following points:
(1) Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Jim Robbins seconded that Minute 54 of Cabinet (Swindon Borough Council - Biodiversity Net Gain: A Framework for Developer Contribution) be adopted.
The Chair along with Councillors Hopkins, Lodge and Weisinger, the Chief Legal Officer and at the invitation of the Chair, Councillor Kevin Small, asked a range of questions or made comments in relation to the issues set out below:
The Leader on behalf of Councillor Kevin Small responded at the meeting noting this formed part of the Local Plan process.
The Leader of behalf of Councillor Kevin Small responded that it provided good value to add clarity for staff and the public on the Council’s priorities.
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Jim Robbins seconded:
Councillor Jim Robins moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded that 3.13 be amended to read;
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, indicated his support for the report as he felt it important for Cabinet to help set the new emphasis for the Council, under its new administration and with its new direction and priorities. He believed the election results had been a clear endorsement of the Missions from the public and it was therefore proper to incorporate them into policy making. The reports to Full Council on 13 th July 2023 he felt reflected the move towards incorporating the Missions in the decision-making process and should be endorsed.
The Leader concurred with Councillor Small on the importance of Cabinet having considered this matter as the first item at its first meeting and also encouraging member and officer buy-in to the Missions. He referred to the proposed changes to the Committee structure that Full Council would be asked to adopt at its meeting on 13 th July 2023 which also reflected the new Missions.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, along with the Corporate Director of Finance and Assets, submitted a joint report that presented the provisional revenue position for 2022/23, subject to audit by Grant Thornton, the Council’s external auditors.
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted some key points from it which included: the final end of year figures on the Children Services budget compared to the mid-year projections; the cumulative deficit on the Dedicated Schools Grant; the final position on the Housing Revenue Account and its current general reserve amount; the hard work undertaken by officers and members of the Audit Committee on the Annual Auditor’s Report for 2021/22, and; the revenue contributions to the capital programme of £1.2m as set out in Appendix 2.
In response to a question from the Leader regarding whether there were any concerns for Cabinet that required further focus, Councillor Small confirmed that a steering group had been created to monitor the issues that had arisen from the payroll contract transfer, and that appropriate measures had been taken to mitigate future risk.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, along with the Corporate Director of Finance and Assets, submitted a joint report that presented the year end monitoring position for the Council’s capital programme and some proposed changes to the programme.
Councillor Small introduced the report and highlighted some key points from it which included: the proposals to fund the satellite provision for Crowdy’s Hill School at Swindon New College; the grant funds for Westlea School SEN unit; the Devolved Formula Capital grant from government; the funding allocated to improve the vehicle fleet at Waterside; the re-costing of the Ventnor and Ashley Close proposals due to inflationary pressures on market costs; the toilets being funded by the Changing Places Facilities budget; the additional s106 funding for recreational improvements at Coate Water Country Park, and: the funds being transferred to Parish Councils.
Councillor Small then explained in further detail what the capital budget of £2m was needed for in relation to the works at the Councils leisure centres, how the projects would take place, and the improved leisure offer as a result.
Councillor Small responded at the meeting to the following questions and comments from Councillor Jim Grant, Cabinet Member for Communities and Joint Working, Councillor Marina Strinkovsky, Cabinet Member for Culture, Art and Heritage, and Councillor Chris Watts, Cabinet Member for the Environment and Transport:
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, along with the Corporate Director of Finance and Assets, submitted a joint report setting out the Treasury Management Performance for 2022/23.
Councillor Small introduced the report which he noted reviewed the Council’s borrowing and investment position, the prudential indicator, and also the capital financing requirements, and highlighted the list of investments made during the last 12 months.
Councillor Small then expressed disappointment at the recent legislation affecting investment decisions.
Councillor Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, and Councillor Chris Watts, Cabinet Member for the Environment and Transport, both indicated their support for the renewal of the agreement given its excellence as a facility and the services it provides.
Councillor Kevin Small, Cabinet Member for Finance, along with the Director of Strategic Development and Growth, submitted a joint report which sought the adoption of an Interim Recreation Mitigation Strategy for North Meadow and Clattinger Farm Special Area of Conservation (SAC) for the period 2023-2028. The report set out how the purpose of the mitigation strategy is to ensure that recreational impacts arising from development proposals (planning applications) within an identified catchment of the SAC do not lead to a negative impact on the ecological integrity of the SAC. The report noted that although North Meadow and Clattinger Farm Special Area of Conservation is not in Swindon Borough, part of its catchment is.
Councillor Small introduced the report and drew attention to the international importance of the SAC due to its biodiversity. As new developments in the Borough have the potential to impact on the site, Natural England have advised that recreational pressures require future mitigation to protect that biodiversity.
Councillor Small confirmed that, if adopted, the Strategy would affect all planning applications and be in place for 2023-2028. The Strategy had been drawn up between Cotswold District Council, Wiltshire County Council and Swindon Borough Council as the authorities within the SACs catchment area.
Councillor Small concluded by highlighting the pricing structures within the zones as set out in detail in the report and noting that, without a strategy in place, either Natural England or the government could impose a planning freeze on development in the catchment area.
Resolved – That Councillor Kevin Small be Chair the Network for the Municipal Year 2023/24.
(Councillor Small took the Chair.)
Councillor Emma Bushell moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded:
The External Auditors responded to questions from the Chair and Councillor Kevin Small in respect of:
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Jim Robbins seconded that the Motion be amended as follows:
Requests that the Leader writes to the Secretary of State for Education to ask them to consider Early Years settings who deliver Government underfunded hours of Early Education in the same way as state funded schools when it comes to giving out defibrillators.” Councillor Jim Robbins moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded:
Councillor Jim Robbins moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded that “Councillor Matt Lodge replace Councillor Will Stone on the Planning Committee.” The resolution was put to the vote and declared carried.
Ian Burbidge responded to comments of the Chair and Councillor Kevin Small in respect of how the update on Council investment would be provided to the Committee .
CouncillorJim Robbins moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded:
Councillor Cathy Martyn moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded:
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Jim Grant seconded:
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Steve Weisinger seconded that the Annual Report of the Scrutiny Committee be noted.
Resolved – That Councillor Kevin Small be Chair of the Forum for the Municipal Year 2022/23.
(Councillor Small took the Chair.)
Councillor Kevin Small updated the Forum on the recent visit by himself and the former Mayor, Garry Perkins, to Slazgitter which included:
Councillor Small asked a number of questions to which Nick Hobbs and Ian Burbidge, Head of Finance – Technical, responded at the meeting.
The Chair proposed and Councillor Small seconded that Officers bring a report back to the Committee in twelve months’ time so that the matter could be kept under consideration.
Councillor Small asked about the overspending on the Moonrakers Roundabout work and the lessons learned. The Chair and the Head of Internal Audit confirmed that this would be part of a specific report for the Committee’s next meeting.
Councillor Kevin Small made a non-prejudicial declaration of interest in respect of Agenda Item No. 10 (Allocation of Seats and Appointments to Committee, Other Bodies and Outside Bodies) in his capacity as a member of the Wiltshire Pension Fund.
(Councillor Kevin Small made a non-prejudicial declaration of interest in respect of this Agenda Item (Appointments to Outside Bodies) in his capacity as a member of the Wiltshire Pension Fund.)
Councillor Small asked a question relating to joint venture partnership, to which Councillor Sumner responded at the meeting. The Corporate Director of Finance and Assets confirmed that while the companies made their own arrangements for audit, the Council was treated as a ‘group’ for external audit purposes and, as such, the costs could not be disaggregated.
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Jim Grant seconded that the recommendations of the Independent Remuneration Panel be supported.
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Jim Robbins seconded that Cabinet Minute 56 be amended as set out in Item 8(d) of the Notice of Meeting and set out in an annexe to these minutes.
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Jim Grant seconded that Cabinet Minute 57 be amended as set out in Item 8(e) of the Notice of Meeting and set out in an annexe to these minutes.
Councillor Kevin Small questioned why this item was not being taken as the final part of the agenda as was the usual custom and practice. The Chair responded that it was in response to a specific request.
Councillor Small asked about a borrowing requirement for one company; however, the Corporate Director of Finance and Assets advised that this was for a separate issue not covered at the Shareholder Panel.
The Corporate Director of Finance and Assets along with the External Auditors responded to the following questions from the Chair, Councillor Clare Crilly and Councillor Kevin Small a) That the scheduling of future audits by Grant Thornton would be scheduled better to account for when Swindon Borough Council was providing the information on time.
Councillor Small requested more information on the reasons for the percentage variations in the Comprehensive Income and Expenditure Statement (CIES) (page 208 of ... view the full minutes text for item 31.
Member-had reviewed the Richmond Report, and Councillor Small commented that as residents’ elected and accountable representatives, there would be no additional benefit through having an independent member of the Committee, as suggested by the Report. The Chair and the meeting concurred with this view.
Councillor Grant proposed and Councillor Small proposed an amendment that Cllr Heenan not be appointed Chair of the Licensing Committee. The amendment was defeated (Councillors Grant and Small requested that their votes for the amendment be recorded).
The Head of Internal Audit highlighted key issues within the report and along with the Chief Operating Officer, responded to the following questions and comments from the Chair and Councillor Small.
[name removed] and the Head of Internal Audit responded to the following comments and questions from the Chair and Councillor Kevin Small:
The Head of Internal Audit presented the report highlighting the minor changes set out within the report and responded to a question from Councillor Small to confirm that the powers had not been used in the last year.
The Chief Legal Officer responded to the following comments and questions from the Chair and Councillor Kevin Small:
Councillor Kevin Small asked why this matter could not be deferred to Council. Phil Smith, Service Manager – Planning Policy, stated that it was to meet a statutory deadline.
They responded at the meeting to questions from Councillor Small:
Councillor Small asked if information could be provided about the effect the pandemic and lockdown has had on the audit team and its planned work. The Head of Internal Audit responded that this would be covered elsewhere on the agenda.
He responded at the meeting to questions from Councillor Kevin Small, stating out how Grant Thornton had been able to complete its 2019/20 audit as well as outlining when the firm would commence the 2020/21 audit.
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Jim Robbins seconded:
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Jim Grant seconded:
Councillor Kevin Small, referring to Table 6 in Appendix One, asked if the Capital Financing Requirements contained only those schemes that had already been approved or if it also contained those schemes that were yet to be adopted by Council at its Budget meeting? The Head of Finance stated that it includes all the existing commitments and he undertook to provide a response, before 19.00 on Thursday 18th February 2021 if possible to confirm whether it included proposed schemes yet to be approved.
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Jim Grant seconded:
In response to a request from Councillor Kevin Small about why Agenda item 11 (Minute 22) should be taken without the press and public present, the Chief Legal Officer responded that the report and discussion might refer to posts in a way that would allow individuals to be identified, along with commercial information about the service area.
Councillor Kevin Small asked a question in general about how all audit companies were maintaining standards and ensuring the quality of audits, given issues at some councils and other sectors. With the consent of the Chair and the questioner, Barrie Morris (external auditor) undertook to address this under the agenda item on the Statement of Accounts.
Councillor Kevin Small asked a number of questions about the committee structure chart, in particular that Special Committee should have a direct link to Council, for which it is authorised to act and that the overview and scrutiny committees should be shown as subordinate to the Scrutiny Committee.
The Chair agreed to follow up this issue with Councillor Small and relevant officers outside the meeting.
The Chair along with Councillor Kevin Small asked a range of questions to which the External Auditors responded at the meeting, covering:
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Russell Holland seconded:
Councillor Steve Allsopp moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded:
· Officers write a Briefing Note outlining the road safety priorities for the Borough and for this report to consider the measures required for the Borough including Hay Lane.” Councillor Steph Exell moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded that the Motion be amended to read:
Councillor Jim Robbins moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded:
(Councillor Kevin Small made a prejudicial declaration of interest in respect of the Cabinet Member Decision Note – Assignment and Deed of Variation to this item as he was Member of the Wiltshire Pension Fund and left the room during the discussion of the item).
Councillor Jim Grant will move and Councillor Kevin Small will second:
Resolved – That Councillor Kevin Small be Chair of the Network for the Municipal Year 2019/20.
(Councillor Small took the Chair.)
These letters had been signed by Councillor Junab Ali as Mayor of the Borough of Swindon and Councillor Kevin Small as Chair of the Network and were tabled for Members’ information.
Councillor Russell Holland moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded:
Councillor Kevin Small moved and ... view the full minutes text for item 85.
Councillor Keith Williams moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded:
It was noted that The Worshipful the Mayor and Councillor Kevin Small had travelled to Salzgitter in September where Councillor Kevin Small had been awarded the “City of Salzgitter Gold Medal of Honour” in recognition of his work on town twinning on 23rd September 2108 at special awards evening.
(2) That the Network’s congratulations to Councillor Kevin Small on the receipt of the City of Salzgitter Gold Medal of Honour be recorded.
Resolved – That Councillor Kevin Small be appointed Chair of the Town Twinning Network for the Municipal Year 2018/19.
(Councillor Small hereupon took the Chair)
Councillor David Renard moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded:
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Jim Grant seconded:
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Steph Exell seconded:
Councillor Jim Grant moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded:
(d) The comments of Councillor Small in respect application numbered S/17/283 (e) (f) The comments of Councillor Perkins in respect application numbered S/OUT/17/968 The comments of Councillor Dixon in respect application numbered S/17/526 (g) The comments of the following interested persons:-
(c) That there was no amendment to restore funding for crossing patrols when Council debated the Budget on 23 rd February 2017.” Councillor James Robbins moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded that the Motion be amended to read:
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Jim Grant seconded that the Motion be amended to read:
Resolved – That Councillor Kevin Small be Chair of the Town Twinning Network for the Municipal Year 2016/17 (Councillor Small hereupon took the Chair)
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Robert Wright seconded:
“That subject to the detailed budget proposals set out in Appendix 4 and summarised in Table 3 of the published report as amended by the proposals under paragraph 1.4 in the tabled update paper and that the £826,000 2016-17 Transition Grant is used to smooth the implementation of planned services changes, including for Libraries, as targeted pump-priming funding to ensure that the transition to new service models is managed as effectively as possible; and to fund any shortfall in the budgeted level of savings achieved through the transfer of services to parish councils be agreed the Motions contained in Minute 59 of the Cabinet (Budget 2016/17 and Beyond) and Minute 60 of the Cabinet (Capital Programme 2016/17) be confirmed and adopted .” Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Jim Grant seconded that:
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Chris Watts seconded:
Councillor Kevin Small commented that he believed that there was merit in the Council’s Chief Executive also being its Returning Officer.
Councillor Jim Robbins moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded:
Councillor Kevin Small explained that the traffic on Rodbourne Road has greatly improved. The temporary lights are reducing the traffic.
Councillor Kevin Small will find out why this happened.
Councillor Kevin Small feels that different groups need different spaces, each reflecting needs.
The Mayor updated Council on the recent successful visit to the Borough of the Salzgitter Mayor and expressed his gratitude to Councillor Kevin Small for the work undertaken by him in respect of the visit.
Councillor Kevin Small reminded all Councillors that they should declare any known interests in any matter to be considered.
Councillor Small asked why it had been delayed, and states that residential would be beneficial.
Councillor Kevin Small asked what would the time scale be, Councillor Small is concerned that opening the bus lane will increase traffic into Rodbourne .
Councillor Small made residents aware that ward members met with the Highways Department regarding the congestion in Rodbourne , Councillors suggested temporary lighting – Highways are looking at what can be done.
Councillor Kevin Small responds, many meetings have taken place around traffic management, he agrees that it just needs to be sorted now.
Councillor Kevin Small sent apologies.
Councillor Kevin Small: Not form an SBC point of view, we would need to look at the voluntary sector.
Councillor Joe Tray moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded and the Council agreed that Councillor Teresa Page be thanked for her year of service as Mayor of the Borough.
Councillor Jim Grant moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded that:
“That Minute 53(7) of the Cabinet (Motion at Council – Cars Parking on Grass Verges) be noted.” Councillor Mark Dempsey moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded that the Motion be amended to read:
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Cpouncillor Jim Grant seconded that the Motion be amended to read:
Councillor Kevin Small, Chair of the Town twinning Network, explained the background to the Network’s recommendation to the Cabinet and the reasons why it believed it would be desirable for the Council to promote actively the 40 th Anniversary of the Swindon / Salzgitter Twinning. He believed it could assist with attracting new and younger people to become involved and re-invigorate the concept of town twinning.
In response to a question seeking clarification regarding Minute 15 of the Licensing Committee from Councillor Kevin Small, the Chair of the Licensing Committee confirmed that the revised Street Trading Policy would permit the playing of music at Christmas Markets, and where appropriate, at other organised markets.
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Joe Tray seconded and the Council unanimously agreed that Councillor Teresa Page be Mayor of the Borough for the ensuing Municipal Year.
(Councillor Kevin Small and Joe Tray and Councillors David Renard, Jim Grant and Stan Pajak offered their support and congratulations to the Mayor, on behalf of their political groups.) Councillor Teresa Page made and signed the Declaration of Acceptance of Office formally becoming The Worshipful The Mayor.
This Council requests that: The Cabinet Member for Finance and the Cabinet Member for Public Protection, Housing and StreetSmart (Delivery) to bring a report to the Cabinet as soon as practicable suggesting ways that a weekly green waste recycling service, free at the point of use, could be re-introduced for Eastcott ward and the Town Centre.” Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Bob Wright seconded that the Motion be amended to read:
Councillor Kevin Small, Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, referred to the procurement process for the Council’s banking arrangements.
Councillor Kevin Small, Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, advised that the national J oint Negotiating Committee (JNC) for Youth and Community had confirmed a 1% pay increase for effected local government staff earlier in the week.
The Chair thanked Councillor Small for this information, which would be taken into account in the preparation of the final Statement.
Councillor Kevin Small, Chair of Scrutiny Committee, and Councillor Des Moffatt, Chair of the Task Group, presented the recommendations of the Scrutiny Committee and the findings of the final report of the Digital City (UK) Ltd Task Group.
Councillor Small and Councillor Moffatt advised that in their view, the Task Group had completed its investigation and there was no merit in any further action to re-interview those who had provided evidence to it. Resolved – (1) That, further to Minute 40(1) of the Corporate Governance Review Working Group, the contents of the report of the Director of Law and Democratic Services and the views of the Working Group as set out in Minute 40(2) to (10) be noted and endorsed.
· Clarification on the cost of the service for those individuals on the green bag scheme in comparison to those on the green bin scheme was given and it was noted that bins provided a significantly greater capacity in a year than that provided by 100 bags but the charge remained the same for both types of service user (Councillor Small);
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Des Mofatt seconded:
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Michael Dickinson seconded:
Cllr Small indicated that the Ombudsman would only review process and not the decision itself.
Cllr Small indicated that this is how democracy works. Councillors have to take into account the weight of the argument and make a decision accordingly. The ballot box is there for residents to say if Councillors have done a good job or not.
Councillor Joe Tray moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded and the Council agreed that Councillor Teresa Page be Deputy Mayor of the Borough for the ensuing Municipal Year.
(2) That the Director of Law and Democratic Services be authorised, in consultation with the members of the Corporate Governance Review Working Party where appropriate, to vary the wording and layout of the Constitution and its associated documentation to reflect legislative and procedural changes should this prove necessary for the efficient discharge of Council business during the course of the Municipal Year.” Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Bob Wright seconded that the Motion be amended to read:
Cllr Small indicated that GWH had challenges but had clear policies to deal with coping for the parking at the hospital site now and in the future with options for land adjacent to the building. The reduction in buses related more to running out of funding for particular bus routes rather than provision at GWH.
Resolved – That in the absence of the Locality Chair (Councillor Small), Councillor Des Moffatt be appointed as Chair for the meeting.
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Des Moffatt seconded:
Councillor Kevin Small moved and Councillor Garry Perkins seconded:
Resolved – That Councillor Kevin Small be Chair of the Town Twinning Network until December 2013.
(Councillor Small took the Chair.)
Councillor Kevin Small, Mannington and Western Ward Councillor, referred to the proposed Purton to Ifley Road link and asked whether this remained in the Local Plan. He advised that whilst the exact route might need to change to reflect the current development of the area, it remained a key project that local residents would wish to see achieved. He also welcomed the green corridor proposals and policy and the continued designation and protection of Martins Farm within the draft document.
Councillor Kevin Small, a member of the Town Twinning Network, welcomed the report and highlighted the views of the Network on the merits of Town Twinning. He believed more could be done to link Town Twining with the Council’s economic development goals and, in particular, to secure access to European Union grant funding through utilising Twinning and Twinning links. He believed that more effort should be put into encouraging young people to become involved in Twinning activities.
Councillor Kevin Small, Chair of the Scrutiny Committee, presented the report and highlighted some of the aspects of the Scrutiny Committee’s and other Overview and Scrutiny Committees’ work programmes for the coming Municipal Year. He commented on the involvement of Cabinet Members in the process and highlighted the need for Cabinet Members to indicate as soon as possible if they were unable to attend a meeting to which they had been invited or believed that an item appearing on a work programme was inappropriately timed.
“That Councillor Andrew Bennett replace Councillor Roderick Bluh as a member serving of the Joint Wiltshire and Swindon Police and Crime Panel for remainder of the Municipal Year, 2012/13.” Councillor Jim Grant moved and Councillor Kevin Small seconded that the Motion be amended to read:
The Chair advised that he had received comments on the proposal for Even Swindon Primary School from Councillor Kevin Small who was unable to attend the meeting.
Showing the latest 300 of 472.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Small attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 14 Jul 2026 | Planning Committee | S-23-0288 Land at Home Farm | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 Feb 2021 | Audit Committee | External Audit - progress report | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Nov 2016 | Council | Motion - Heathrow Airport Expansion | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Nov 2016 | Council | Motion - Heathrow Airport Expansion | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 6 Nov 2014 | Council | Motion - Regent Circus Crossing | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 Sep 2014 | Council | Motion - Averies Waste Site | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 Jul 2014 | Council | Motion - Motor Neurone Disease Charter | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Dec 2012 | Council | Motion - Heathrow Airport | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 8 Nov 2012 | Council | Minute for Confirmation | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 8 Nov 2012 | Council | Motion - Future Cities | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 May 2012 | Council | To elect a qualified person to be Mayor of the Borough for the Municipal Year 2012/13 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 May 2011 | Council | To Elect a Qualified Person to be Mayor of the Borough for the Municipal Year 2011/12 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Sep 2008 | Council | Motion - Former Councillor Percy Jefferies | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Apr 2007 | Council | Admission of Mr. Rudolf Ruckert to be an Honorary Freeman of the Borough | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Apr 2007 | Council | To Transfer the Freedom of the Borough Rights to the Rifles Regiment | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Jul 2006 | Council | Appointment of Chief Executive and Head of Paid Service | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Apr 2006 | Council | Admission of Councillor Mike Bawden to be an Honorary Freeman of the Borough | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 Nov 2004 | Council | Admission of Sir Maurice Johnston to be an Honorary Freeman of the Borough | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Small was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 5 of 28 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Small declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Small in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Small sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Member | Jul 2004 | 75 | |
| Town Twinning Network | Chair | Jun 2008 | 28 | 19 Nov 2026 |
| Dorset and Wiltshire Fire and Rescue Authority | Member | Jul 2021 | 10 | |
| Education Transport Appeals Sub-Committee | Member | Jun 2026 | 8 | |
| Planning Committee | Member | Aug 2005 | 6 | 8 Dec 2026 |
| Corporate Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Member | Jun 2026 | 3 | 14 Dec 2026 |
| Finance Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Member | Sep 2026 | 1 | |
| Member | Nov 2026 | 1 | ||
| Scrutiny Committee | Chair | Jul 2005 | 87 | |
| Special Committee | Deputy | Sep 2005 | 20 | |
| Locality - North Central | Chair | May 2012 | 14 | |
| Audit Committee | Member | Sep 2016 | 12 | |
| Locality - West | Member | May 2012 | 11 | |
| Cabinet | Cabinet Member attendee | Oct 2005 | 7 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Management Board | Member | Aug 2004 | 3 | |
| Education and Young People Commission | Chair | Nov 2004 | 3 | |
| Appointments Committee | Member | Jun 2005 | 3 | |
| Standards Committee | Member | Jul 2011 | 3 | |
| Scrutiny Review Board | Member | Jun 2005 | 1 | |
| Resources Overview Committee | Member | Apr 2006 | 1 | |
| Appeals Committee | Member | Feb 2007 | 1 | |
| Licensing Committee | Member | Aug 2007 | 1 | |
| Licensing Panel | Member | Aug 2007 | 1 | |
| Resources and Corporate Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Member | Nov 2022 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.