Seconded30 Jun 2026Governance Committee
Local Government (Access to Information) Act 1985 - Exclusion of Press and Public
It was PROPOSED by Councillor Bullivant and SECONDED by Councillor Clarance and unanimously RESOLVED that, under Section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972, the press and public be excluded from the meeting of the particular item(s) on the grounds that it involve(s) the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined in the relevant paragraphs of Part 1 of Schedule 12A of the Act.
Seconded30 Jun 2026Governance Committee
Review of the Code of Conduct Complaints Process
It was PROPOSED by Councillor Nuttall and SECONDED by Councillor Clarance and unanimously RESOLVED To accept the report.
Seconded30 Jun 2026Governance Committee
Code of Conduct Complaints Update
It was PROPOSED by Councillor Nuttall and SECONDED by Councillor Clarance and unanimously RESOLVED To accept the report and the contents within.
Seconded30 Jun 2026Governance Committee
Annual Review of the Member Development Strategy
It was PROPOSED by Councillor Nuttall and SECONDED by Councillor Clarance and unanimously RESOLVED To add mandatory safeguarding training to the annual programme of training.
Moved30 Jun 2026Governance Committee
Referral from Full Council: Member-Officer Protocol
It was PROPOSED by Councillor Clarance and SECONDED by Councillor Nuttall and unanimously RESOLVED To recognise the revised Member-Officer Protocol agreed by Full Council on 19 th May 2026.
Named3 Mar 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Call-in Executive decision - the Lido Teignmouth
Lastly, that keeping it closed potentially reduces interest to those just wishing to redevelop rather than offer swimming facilities for residents and tourists.” Cllr Clarance also made a request for a call-in.
Said26 Feb 2026Full Council
Chatty Benches
Councillor Clarance spoke on his proposed Notice of Motion as set out in the agenda and which was seconded by Councillor Macgregor.
Seconded10 Feb 2026Appointments & Remuneration Committee
Pay Policy Statement 2026/27
It was proposed by Councillor Bulivant, seconded by Councillor Clarance and unanimously, RECOMMENDED to Council:
Asked8 Jan 2026Governance Committee
Recommendations from the Independent Remuneration Panel (IRP)
Councillor Clarance asked for clarification that only one Special Responsbility Allowance is paid to any one Member, which was confirmed.
Said8 Jan 2026Governance Committee
Councillor DBS Checks
Councillor Clarance spoke of his experience as a Devon County Councillor and welcomed a voluntary DBS scheme. It was clarified that checks should be completed every 3 years to ensure they remain up to date.
Seconded2 Oct 2025Governance Committee
Local Government (Access to Information) Act 1985 - Exclusion of Press and Public
It was proposed by Councillor Nuttall and seconded by Councillor Clarance and RESOLVED that the Press and Public be excluded from meeting of the particular items on the grounds that they involves the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined in the relevant paragraphs of Part 1 of Schedule 12A of the Act.
Moved2 Oct 2025Governance Committee
Determination of Code of Conduct Complaints (FS-Case-636881192)
It was proposed by Councillor Clarance and seconded by Councillor Nuttall and RESOLVED That although the committee recognised the validity of the complaint and that it was decided by the barrister that a breach had occurred, they considered the issue marginal and nuanced, and so no further action would be taken.
Said30 Jul 2024Full Council
Notices of Motion
Cllr Clarance presented and proposed the Motion on Southwest Water discharges.
Named21 May 2024Full Council
Election of Chair of Council
Cllr Macgregor proposed that Cllr Clarance be elected Chair of the Council for the 2024/25 municipal year, this was seconded by Cllr Daws.
Said21 May 2024Full Council
Election of Chair of Council
Cllr Clarance stated that he would decline this kind nomination. He thanked the Liberal Democrats for enabling him to stand as Chair of Council for the past year.
Named21 May 2024Full Council
Committee Seat Allocations
The following amendments to the circulated lists were advised:- · Cllr Peart would not sit on Planning Committee · Cllr Foden and Cllr Rollason to be replaced by Cllr Swain and Cllr Henderson on Overview & Scrutiny Committee · Cllr Clarance to be a substitute on Planning Committee · Cllr Smith would not be a substitute on Overview & Scrutiny Committee as they did not appoint substitutes Cllr Wrigley proposed the committee seat nominations as circulated and amended; this was seconded by Cllr Keeling.
Named21 May 2024Full Council
Committee Seat Allocations
RESOLVED that membership of Committees as shown in the schedules circulated subject to the following amendments:- · Cllr Peart would not sit on Planning Committee · Cllr Smith would not be a substitute on Overview & Scrutiny Committee as they did not appoint substitutes · Cllr Foden and Cllr Rollason to be replaced by Cllr Swain and Cllr Henderson on Overview & Scrutiny Committee · Cllr Clarance to be a substitute on Planning Committee be approved.
Moved19 Mar 2024Planning Committee
22/00127ENF - Hawthorn House, Newton Abbot
· No appeal against the planning application rejection · The Committee must make a decision on the specific case as set out in the report It was proposed by Cllr Clarance and seconded by Cllr J Taylor that decision be deferred pending a members’ site visit.
Named27 Feb 2024Full Council
Declarations of interest
· Cllr Clarance by virtue of being a patient of Teign Estuary medical practice, Teignmouth.
Said27 Feb 2024Full Council
Notices of Motion
Motion 3 Cllr Clarance presented a Motion on saving Teignmouth hospital from closure.
Moved13 Feb 2024Strata - Joint Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny of Strata Joint Executive Committee decisions 30 January 2024
It was proposed by Councillor Clarance and seconded by Councillor Knott that the decisions made by the Joint Executive Committee are agreed by the Joint Scrutiny Committee.
Moved18 Jul 2023Planning Committee
22/01808/FUL - Broom Park, Shaldon
· There is already outline permission for a dwelling · Footprint largely unchanged as building is being shifted backwards · No greater impact caused by change It was proposed by Cllr Clarance and seconded by Cllr Macgregor that decision be deferred for a Members Site Visit.
Moved27 Jun 2023Strata - Joint Scrutiny Committee
Election of Chair
It was proposed by Councillor Clarance and seconded by Councillor Patrick that Councillor Knott be elected chair of Strata Joint Scrutiny 2023-24.
Named23 May 2023Full Council
Election of Chair of the Council 2023/24
Cllr Wrigley proposed that Cllr Clarance be elected Chair of the Council for the 2023/24 municipal year, this was seconded by Cllr Bullivant.
Named23 May 2023Full Council
Election of Chair of the Council 2023/24
Cllr Clarance and Cllr Radford left the room for the vote.
Named23 May 2023Full Council
Election of Chair of the Council 2023/24
Recorded vote under Procedure Rule 4.13.5 For Cllr Clarance:
Named23 May 2023Full Council
Election of Chair of the Council 2023/24
Cllrs Bradford, Daws, Gearon, Hall, MacGregor, Mullone, P Parker, Ryan, J Taylor Total 9 No Vote: Cllrs Clarance, Radford Total 2 Absent: Buscombe, Hayes, Hook and Rollason Total 4 RESOLVED that Cllr Clarance be elected Chair of the Council for the 2023/2024 municipal year.
Moved12 Jan 2023Full Council
Notice of Motion
The Vice-Chair Cllr Clarance proposed that the matter debated at this meeting, this was seconded by Cllr MacGregor put to the vote and lost as two thirds of the members did not support debate of this matter today. T he item was referred to the next Executive.
Named29 Nov 2022Full Council
Announcements
The Chair thanked the Vice-Chair Cllr Clarance who stood in for him while he was unwell.
Named3 Nov 2022Audit Scrutiny Committee
Future High Street Fund Report
Councillor Clarance abstained from voting.
Declared25 Oct 2022Planning Committee
Declarations of Interest.
Councillor Clarance declared an interest in application 20/00961/MAJ due to his relationship with the applicant. He did not speak or vote on this application and left the meeting.
Named26 Jul 2022Full Council
Chair of the Meeitng
As the Chair had given his apologises Cllr Clarance the Deputy Chair took the Chair.
Named24 May 2022Full Council
Election of Vice-Chair of the Council 2022/2023
It was proposed by Cllr Bullivant and seconded by the Leader that Cllr Clarance be elected Vice-Chair of the Council for 2022/23 RESOLVED that Cllr Clarance be elected Vice-Chair of the Council for 2022/23.
Seconded17 May 2022Planning Committee
21/02744/FUL Land at 23 Badlake Hill, Dawlish
· Road is steep and narrow · Lack of visibility onto road · No accidents but several near misses · Significant increase in dwellings It was proposed by Councillor J Petherick and seconded by Councillor Clarance that decision be deferred following a members’ site visit.
Moved28 Apr 2022Full Council
Teignmouth, Brunswick Street
Cllr Clarance proposed an amendment that the final decision be deferred until such time as the Council had an answer regarding what alternative options the National Health Service would put forward if the Council chose not to sell the land to them.
Named22 Mar 2022Planning Committee
Election of Vice-Chair
It was proposed by Councillor Jeffery and seconded by Councillor MacGregor that Councillor Clarance be elected Vice-Chair.
Declared22 Feb 2022Full Council
Declarations of interest
Cllr Clarance declared an interest in relation to the member questions (minute no.24) as he lived in one of the lower lying property’s which had been subject to flooding in the past.
Seconded22 Feb 2022Full Council
Future High Street Fund - Newton Abbot Market
This was seconded by Cllr Clarance put to the vote and lost.
Moved21 Dec 2021Planning Committee
21/00533/MAJ Sands Copse, Kingsteignton
It was proposed by Councillor Clarance and seconded by Councillor Kerswell that permission be granted subject to the conditions set out in the report.
Declared15 Nov 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee 1
Declaration of Interest
Councillor Clarance declared an interest in agenda item 9 Climate and Ecologic Emergency Task and Finish Group by virtue of his ownership of a property on low lying land.
Asked15 Nov 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee 1
Councillor Questions
Councillor Clarance asked the following questions of the Executive Member for Environmental Health, Waste and Recycling.
Said15 Nov 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee 1
Councillor Questions
Cllr Clarance advised they were split into two criteria, those being to establish the current actual situation followed by what proposed remedies will/should follow.
Declared17 Aug 2021Planning Committee
Declarations of Interest.
Councillor Clarance declared an interest in application 21/00829/FUL. He left the room for this item, and did not vote on it.
Named12 Jul 2021Strata - Joint Scrutiny Committee
Election of Chair 2021/2022
In accordance with the existing annual rotation for the position of Chair, Councillor Nuttall proposed that Councillor Clarance representing Teignbridge District Council be elected Chair for the 2021/22 Municipal Year.
Named12 Jul 2021Strata - Joint Scrutiny Committee
Election of Chair 2021/2022
This was seconded by Councillor Twiss and RESOLVED Councillor Clarance be elected Chair for the 2021/22 Municipal Year.
Seconded15 Jun 2021Planning Committee
21/00706/HOU 71 Coombe Vale Road, Teignmouth
It was proposed by Councillor J Hook and seconded by Councillor Clarance that permission be granted as set out in the report.
Asked11 Jan 2021Strata - Joint Scrutiny Committee
Question from Members of the Councils under Procedure Rules
Councillor Clarance asked a question which was circulated to the Committee with the answer. The question and answer which is appended was noted.
Named11 Jan 2021Strata - Joint Scrutiny Committee
Question from Members of the Councils under Procedure Rules
The Chair concluded that the question submitted by Councillor Clarance had provided a worthwhile scrutiny exercise into Strata’s value for money efficiency and effectiveness.
Moved21 Oct 2020Audit Committee
Election of Chair
It was proposed by Councillor Clarance and seconded by Councillor Rollason that Councillor Morgan is elected Chair.
Seconded21 Oct 2020Audit Committee
Election of Deputy Chair
It was proposed by Councillor Morgan and seconded by Councillor Clarance that Councillor Rollason is elected Vice-Chair.
Named22 Sep 2020Overview and Scrutiny Committee 1 (until May 2024)
Election of Deputy Chair
It was also proposed and seconded that Councillor Clarance be elected Vice Chair for the 2020/21 Municipal year.
Named22 Sep 2020Overview and Scrutiny Committee 1 (until May 2024)
Election of Deputy Chair
For Councillor Clarance: Councillors Clarance, Gribble, Hocking and Thorne Total 4 For Councillor Jenks: Councillors D Cox, H Cox, Eden, Foden, Jenks, Nutley and Rollason.
Seconded7 Jul 2020Planning Committee
NEWTON ABBOT - 16/02693/MAJ - Land At Berry Knowles, Bovey Road - Outline application for residential development (up to 135 dwellings), access from Old Exeter Road, public open space, landscaping and associated works and infrastructure (approval sought for access).
It was proposed by Councillor Bullivant and seconded by Councillor Clarance that planning permission be granted subject to conditions outlined in the agenda report and update sheet and with ward member consultation.
Named24 Feb 2020Full Council
Councillor Question
In response to the supplementary question the Leader he confirmed he would let Councillor Clarance know of any decisions as soon as they were made.
Named24 Feb 2020Full Council
Final Budget Proposals 2020/21
Councillor Clarance as budget spokesperson for the opposition commented that the unpalatable cuts that were being proposed could be avoided if less funds were transferred from the revenue account to the capital account and the reduction in funding from the capital account be made up by increasing borrowing.
Named19 Nov 2019Full Council
Councillor questions under Council Procedure Rule 4.5(k)
In response to Councillor Clarance supplementary question, the Leader clarified that the Portfolio Holder for Business, Economy & Tourism, Portfolio Holder for Sport, Recreation & Culture and Portfolio Holder for Communities & IT all had experience a t the highest levels of Government.
Moved22 Jan 2019Planning Committee
TEIGNMOUTH - 18/02166/FUL - Unit 14-15, Estuary Court - Change of use from Use Class B1 (General Industrial) to D2 (Assembly and Leisure)
It was proposed by Councillor Clarance, seconded by Councillor Bullivant and Resolved Permission be granted subject to the following conditions:
Named30 Jul 2018Full Council
Referral from Audit Scrutiny - 2017/18 STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTS INCLUDING THE ANNUAL GOVERNANCE STATEMENT AND TREASURY MANAGEMENT RESULTS
Councillor Clarance, Chairman of the Audit Scrutiny Committee referred to the report circulated with the agenda. The Council’s accounts had received an ‘excellent rating’ from external audit.
Moved30 Jul 2018Full Council
Referral from Audit Scrutiny - 2017/18 STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTS INCLUDING THE ANNUAL GOVERNANCE STATEMENT AND TREASURY MANAGEMENT RESULTS
Councillor Clarance proposed the approval of the recommendations as set out in the report circulated with the agenda.
Named21 Jun 2018Audit Committee
Appointment of Chairman
It was proposed by Cllr Hockin and seconded by Cllr Peart that Cllr Clarance be appointed Chairman for the 2018/19 municipal year.
Named21 Jun 2018Audit Committee
Appointment of Chairman
Resolved Cllr Clarance be appointed Chairman of Audit Scrutiny.
Seconded5 Jun 2018Planning Committee
CHUDLEIGH – 17/02330/MAJ - Land At Station Hill - Variation of condition 4 (amended plans for highway arrangements) on planning permission 13/01062/MAJ
It was proposed by Councillor Bullivant, seconded by Councillor Clarance and Resolved Subject to:
Moved5 Jun 2018Planning Committee
Supplementary Planning Document for Solar Photovoltaic (PV) Developments in the Landscape
It was proposed by Councillor Clarance, seconded by Councillor Jones and Resolved 1. The Committee accepts that the public consultation has been carried out appropriately and in accordance with recommended procedures, that issues raised during the public consultation have been satisfactorily addressed, and no changes are required.
Moved14 May 2018Annual Council (Annual Council can be found in Full Council Meetings)
Committee Appointments and Political Balance - Local Government and Housing Act 1989.
Vice Chairman of Overview and Scrutiny Committee 2018-19 It was proposed by Councillor Clarance and seconded by Councillor Winsor that Councillor Ford be elected.
Moved14 May 2018Annual Council (Annual Council can be found in Full Council Meetings)
Committee Appointments and Political Balance - Local Government and Housing Act 1989.
Chairman of the Planning Committee 2018-19 It was proposed by Councillor Clarance and seconded by Councillor Prowse that Councillor Smith be elected.
Named14 May 2018Annual Council (Annual Council can be found in Full Council Meetings)
Committee Appointments and Political Balance - Local Government and Housing Act 1989.
Vice Chairman of the Planning Committee 2018-19 It was proposed by Councillor Smith and seconded by Councillor Fusco that Councillor Clarance be elected.
Named14 May 2018Annual Council (Annual Council can be found in Full Council Meetings)
Committee Appointments and Political Balance - Local Government and Housing Act 1989.
Resolved That Councillor Clarance be elected Vice Chairman of the Planning Committee for the 2018-19 Municipal Year.
Seconded20 Mar 2018Planning Committee
TEIGNMOUTH - 18/00250/FUL - Beachcomber, Promenade - Replacement windows, aluminium panels to roof and alterations to fenestration
It was proposed by Councillor Prowse, seconded by Councillor Clarance and Resolved Permission be granted subject to the following conditions:
Said20 Feb 2018Planning Committee
EXMINSTER/SHILLINGORD ST GEORGE -17/03039/MAJ, West Exe Park, Alphington - Outline - employment development (Use Classes B1, B2 and B8) up to 47,112 square metres (gross floor area) together with associated infrastructure including new vehi
Councillor Clarance advised that he had a predetermined view on the application and left the meeting while the application was determined.
Moved15 Jan 2018Full Council
Financial Instructions
It was proposed by Councillor Clarance, seconded by Councillor Hockin and Resolved That the proposed amendments to the Financial Instructions recommended by the Audit Committee at its meeting on 14 December, 2017 be approved.
Seconded19 Dec 2017Planning Committee
NEWTON ABBOT - 17/02166/MAJ - Land At NGR 283353 2691, Howton Road - Outline application for up to 20 custom build dwellings (approval sought for means of access)
It was proposed by Councillor Hook (was Brodie), seconded by Councillor Clarance and Resolved Permission be granted subject to the following conditions:
Moved19 Dec 2017Planning Committee
NEWTON ABBOT - 17/00618/MAJ - Western House, 10 Howton Road- Outline - erection of 32 dwellingfs including incidental open space, landscaping and an area of strategic green,
An amendment was proposed by Councillor Clarance, seconded by Councillor Prowse and Resolved Consideration deferred for investigation into highway improvements which could be achieved to accommodate 32 ... view the full minutes text for item 259f
Moved21 Nov 2017Planning Committee
SHALDON - 17/02014/FUL - Shaldon Storage & Distribution Centre, Long Lane - Change of use of yard from storage (Use Class B8) to General Industrial (Use Class B2) and extend working hours of building to 8.30am to 1pm on Saturdays
It was proposed by Councillor Clarance, seconded by Councillor Fusco and Resolved Consideration of the application deferred pending a Member site inspection to assess the site in relation to neighbouring properties, particularly with regards to noise. (18 votes for, 0 against and 1 not voted).
Moved24 Oct 2017Planning Committee
SHALDON - 17/01385/VAR - Highfield, Torquay Road
It was proposed by Councillor Clarance, seconded by Councillor Dewhirst and Resolved Consideration deferred pending a Member site inspection.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.