Appointment of Chairman
Councillor MacDonald proposed and Councillor Yalden seconded the motion that Councillor C Dowden be appointed as Chairman for the duration of the meeting.
Every time Test Valley's minutes name Councillor Dowden, as the council published it.
Councillor MacDonald proposed and Councillor Yalden seconded the motion that Councillor C Dowden be appointed as Chairman for the duration of the meeting.
Councillor C Dowden seconded the motion.
Councillor Celia Dowden asked a question in relation to the minutes of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee held on 6 March 2024, minute number 485 – Cost of Living.
Councillor Celia Dowden noted that the minutes referred to the lessons learnt by the Council and its partners however did not set out what those lessons learnt were.
Councillor Celia Dowden asked for confirmation of what the lessons learnt from the work undertaken to support residents with the increased cost of living were.
Councillor Celia Dowden asked a question in relation to the minutes of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting held of 30 August 2023, minute number 158 – Tourism Presentation.
Councillor Celia Dowden asked whether the draft report from the consultants would presented to the Overview and Scrutiny round table, enquired as to the cost of the current review of tourism, and asked which actions from the previous review, undertaken in 2020, had been implemented?
Councillor Celia Dowden asked a question in relation to the minutes from the Cabinet meeting held on 12 April 2023, minute number 557 – Public Spaces Protection Order.
Councillor Celia Dowden referred to an incident at Knightwood where a dog had been allegedly attacked and killed by another dog and enquired as to the number of times the Public Spaces Protection Orders (PSPOs) had been enforced.
Councillor Phil North was disappointed to hear of the incident Councillor Celia Dowden referred to and confirmed that the PSPOs had been used in the past.
Further information on the use of the PSPOs would be circulated to Councillor Celia Dowden outside of the meeting.
Councillor Celia Dowden asked a question in relation to the minutes from the Annual Council meeting held on 24 May 2023, minute number 7 – Appointments to Committees and Outside Bodies and dates and times of meetings of the Council.
Councillor Celia Dowden asked what support was in place for Councillors who were appointed to outside bodies and what mechanisms were in place for Councillors to report back on the work they undertake in relation to the outside bodies.
The new Mayor and new Mayoress Councillor Linda Lashbrook, together with Councillor Alan Dowden and his Mayoress Councillor Celia Dowden, retired to enable the new Mayor to be robed. Upon returning to the chamber, the Mayor and Mayoress were invested with their insignia of office.
“That the thanks of the Council be extended to Councillor Alan Dowden and Councillor Celia Dowden for the excellent manner in which they have carried out their duties as Mayor and Mayoress of the Borough during the past year, and that they be accorded the privilege at their discretion of wearing the Past Mayor’s badge and the Past Mayoress’s badge respectively”.
Councillor C Dowden declared an interest in respect of Item 18 Property Matters and left the room during consideration of the item.
Councillor Celia Dowden asked a question in relation to report of the Capital Strategy Update 2022/23 – 2027/28.
Councillor Celia Dowden asked for clarification on the use of the term near future in reference to market value of land and buildings.
A special meeting of the Test Valley Partnership was convened and co hosted by Councillor North and Councillor C Dowden on 10 August which sought to identify what support is already provided in Test Valley and what gaps in provision there are and what the partnership can do to help. The partnership agreed that a cost of living grant scheme be introduced that could be quickly implemented for local organisations supporting people with cost of living related challenges. The funding available in the scheme is £50,000 which was the underspend from the Covid fund.
The new Mayor and Councillor Cooper, together with the new Mayoress Councillor Celia Dowden, and Councillor Cooper’s Mayoress [name removed], retired to enable the new Mayor to be robed. Upon returning to the chamber, the Mayor and Mayoress were invested with their insignia of office.
Councillor Celia Dowden seconded the motion.
Councillor Celia Dowden asked the Planning Portfolio Holder the following question:
Councillor Bundy thanked Councillor Celia Dowden for her question and was pleased to say that a link to the planning application can be provided in the delegated report itself which will allow easy access for Councillors when notified to drawings and associated planning application documents. The Head of Planning and Building would implement this change immediately.
Councillor Celia Dowden did not ask a supplementary question but thanked officers for their work developing a solution.
Councillor C Dowden wished it to be noted that she knew the applicant on application 22/00121/FULLS but that it did not constitute an interest.
Consideration was given to a report of the Panel Lead Member, Councillor C Dowden which brought together the final conclusions of the panel to review the arrangements in place for Councillors’ representation on outside bodies. The report followed the initial findings report that was presented to the committee in April 2021.
The Chairman distributed the list of Portfolio Coordinators for each of the Cabinet portfolios and thanked Councillor C Dowden for agreeing to take on the Coordinator role for the Housing and Environmental Health (including Diversity and Inclusion) Portfolio.
Councillor Gwynne proposed and Councillor C Dowden seconded the following motion:
Councillor C Dowden wished an additional sentence to be added to the minutes at minute 358 third paragraph penultimate sentence to read;
Process for selection of Chairman and Vice-Chairman of the Committee – Councillor C Dowden requested that the process for the selection of the Chairman and Vice-Chairman of the Committee is added to the Overview and Scrutiny Handbook. The Chairman acknowledged that this will be included.
Consideration was given to a report of the Chairman of the Panel, Councillor C Dowden which brought together the final conclusions of the panel that has reviewed the informal process for selecting the candidate for Chairman of Overview and Scrutiny Committee following the piloting of a new approach in 2021.
Councillor C Dowden reported that following feedback from members it would be helpful if the presentations could be videoed so that anyone that was unable to attend the presentations may view them in their own time. Feedback also showed that the majority of responses were supportive of the proposal which allowed them to get a better understanding of the person applying for the role. This will then allow members to appoint the best person for the role at Annual Council.
Review of Outside Bodies – The Member Community and Community Group had made some suggestions and Councillor C Dowden will meet with the Democratic Services Manager to take this forward.
Review of Outside Bodies – Councillor C Dowden reported that she was still waiting for the Member Community Development Group to meet.
The Mayor ask Councillor C Dowden to convey the Council’s good wishes and hope for a speedy recovery.
Council considered the following motion moved by Councillor Gwynne and seconded by Councillor C Dowden.
Review of Outside Bodies – This is ongoing and Councillor C Dowden will report back in due course.
Process for the selection of Chairman and Vice-Chairman of the Committee – Councillor C Dowden is in the process of collating comments and feedback.
Review of Outside Bodies – Councillor C Dowden that there was nothing to report until the Member and Community Group has reported back.
Process for the selection of Chairman – Councillor C Dowden will come back to inform the Committee whether the process agreed will be the process that will go forward once she has received comments back.
Councillor Celia Dowden proposed that Council Procedure Rule 17.3, the requirement to vote by a show of hands so that a paper ballot may be carried out, be suspended.
Review of Outside Bodies – Councillor C Dowden reported that the panel were waiting for input from the Member and Development Group and hoped to report back to the committee at its meeting on 14 July.
Informal process for selection of Chairman of Overview and Scrutiny Committee – Councillor C Dowden reported that she had met with the Group Leaders to discuss how this would proceed. A timetable for the process has been drafted.
Consideration was given to a report by Councillor C Dowden, Lead Member of the panel tasked with reviewing the informal process for selecting the Overview and Scrutiny Committee Chair. The purpose of the review has been to identify if there are opportunities to refine the current informal process to select the proposed candidate for Chair of Overview and Scrutiny Committee for consideration at Annual Council. The review has focused on how the informal process can enable members to learn more about prospective candidates and how they will meet the qualities of the role description and what they will bring to the role of Chair if selected.
The panel was chaired by Cllr Matthews and also included Cllr Borg-Neal, Cllr Burley, Cllr Donnelly, Cllr C Dowden, Cllr Hamilton and Cllr Warnes. As a result of the review, the panel have developed an evidence base to support future development of the Armed Forces Covenant in Test Valley. This evidence base has led the panel to three key recommendations with an onward work plan highlighting a number of detailed ambitions.
Councillor C Dowden gave an update on her two panels. The review of the process for selecting the Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee and the review of Outside Bodies panels have met in the last 5 days to set a scope.
Councillor C Dowden reported that she had circulated a briefing note on the current situation and focus on representations on outside bodies. She asked if anyone was interested in taking part in that panel to let her know. This would need to be carried out in January in order for this to take effect following Annual Council in May.
Councillor C Dowden also reported that she would like to review the process for the selection of the Overview and Scrutiny Chairman. She asked if anyone was interested in taking part in that panel to let her know. This would also need to be carried out in January in order for this to take effect following Annual Council in May.
Council considered the following motion moved by Councillor C Dowden and seconded by Councillor P North:
Councillor C Dowden reported that the Local Government Association was putting on a webinar on a draft model of the Code of Conduct on 17 September from 6pm to 7pm The Chairman reported that the second Awayday will be held on Monday 5 October at King Somborne Village Hall (time to be confirmed). The Chief Executive explained that the results of the member survey will be circulated early next week. At the Away Day members will look at the top 8 topics and carry out a prioritization exercise.
It was also noted that Councillor Celia Dowden had submitted a question under Rule 11.2 which referred to exempt information and therefore this would be taken at the end of the agenda following an exclusion of the public.
Councillor Celia Dowden asked her question submitted under Rule 11.2 and received a response from the Leader.
Councillor Celia Dowden submitted a question asking “The council will have suffered loss of income ... view the full minutes text for item 58.
Councillor C Dowden suggested that the panel request a briefing from health professionals on how they have coped with the Coronavirus emergency over the last few months.
Councillor Phil North proposed and Councillor Celia Dowden seconded, that due to the current circumstances resulting from the Coronavirus pandemic, Councillor Hatley be appointed as Mayor of the Borough for the ensuing year and until the appointment of his successor and that Councillor Cooper be appointed as Deputy Mayor of the Borough for the ensuing year and until the appointment of his successor, in order to allow both the incumbent and future Mayor to each have a full and effective Mayoral term.
Councillor C Dowden declared a personal interest in relation to item 8.2.3.3 - 2019/20 Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL) Spending Protocol – Allocation of Funds as she had been involved in the submission of the Valley Park Community Centre project..
Councillor North moved the motion and Councillor Celia Dowden seconded the motion.
Council considered the following motion moved by Councillor North and Seconded by Councillor Celia Dowden:
Councillor Celia Dowden submitted a question asking the Leader ‘Would the leader inform the council of the progress made “to create a detached youth worker project to properly support young people and discourage anti social behaviour” as stated in Conservative literature delivered throughout areas of Test Valley during the May 2019 election’.
Council considered the following motion moved by Councillor Celia Dowden and seconded by Councillor Adams-King.
Councillor C Dowden asked that additional wording be added to the Planning Panel’s paragraph to reflect the Planning Advisory Service’s alternative recommendations to those of the Panel. A minor amendment to the ‘Armed Forces Covenant and Test Valley Housing Services’ was also suggested.
Councillor C Dowden wished to ask questions on Item 11 – Review of Area Planning Committees which the Mayor took under that item.
Councillor C Dowden proposed an amendment to the motion - ‘To refer this matter to the Overview & Scrutiny Committee for them to consider the Planning Advisory Service Review Report and to make their comments and recommendations to the Cabinet or directly back to this Council’.
Councillor C Dowden had submitted a question asking whether Test Valley Borough Council would cover the application fee for those employees wishing to submit applicants under the EU settlement scheme but was pleased that since submission of her question the requirement for an application fee had been withdrawn.
Councillor C Dowden asked the Leader what liaison had TVBC carried out with large and small employers in the borough over the risks and impact of Brexit?
Councillor C Dowden also asked a further question of the Leader. Following the set up of a Management Brexit Working Group, would the Leader inform the Council of the Key Risks identified and what contingency plans are to be put in place?
Question 1 Councillor P Hurst asked a question of the Housing and Community Services Portfolio Holder on behalf of Councillor C Dowden which asked if the Council would take advantage of the lifting of the borrowing cap for Local Authorities, and explore opportunities to work with partners to build much needed social housing throughout Test Valley.
Question 2 Councillor C Dowden then asked a question of the Leader whether he would provide a draft on the take-up of online services and for residents who have access to use services digitally, were the Council making it easy, efficient and as effective as possible.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Dowden attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Dowden's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Dowden was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 0 of 5 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Dowden declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 23 Feb 2023 | Council, item 480 | Councillor C Dowden declared an interest in respect of Item 18 Property Matters and left the room during consideration of the item. | Left the room |
| 20 Nov 2019 | Council, item 220 | Councillor C Dowden declared a personal interest in relation to item 8.2.3.3 - 2019/20 Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL) Spending Protocol – Allocation of Funds as she had been involved in the submission of the Valley Park Community Centre project.. |
Where Councillor Dowden sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2021 | 2 | 23 Dec 2026 |
| Southern Area Planning Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2026 | 2 | 24 Nov 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | Oct 2026 | 1 | 9 Dec 2026 |
| General Purposes Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2026 | 1 | 30 Nov 2026 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.